Weight loss failures drive bariatric surgery regrets

Not all weight loss surgery patients “live happily ever after,” according to Daniel B. Jones, MD, of Harvard Medical School, Boston.

A 2014 study of 22 women who underwent weight loss surgery reported lower energy, worse quality of life, and persistent eating disorders, Dr. Jones said in a presentation at the virtual Annual Minimally Invasive Surgery Symposium by Global Academy for Medical Education.

However, postprocedure problems don’t always equal regrets, he said. “Although many women [in the 2014 study] reported negative thoughts and health issues after weight loss surgery, none of them said they regret undergoing the procedure,” he noted.

To further examine decision regret in patients who underwent gastric bypass and gastric banding, Dr. Jones participated in a study of patients’ attitudes 4 years after gastric bypass and gastric banding (Obes Surg. 2019;29:1624-31).

“Weight loss surgery is neither risk free nor universally effective, yet few studies have examined what proportion of patients regret having undergone weight loss surgery,” he noted.

Dr. Jones and colleagues interviewed patients at two weight loss surgery centers and used specific metrics and a multivariate analysis to examine associations among weight loss, quality of life, and decision regret.

A total of 205 Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB) patients responded at 1 year after surgery: 181, 156, and 134 patients responded at 2, 3, and 4 years, respectively.

At 1 year, 2% reported regret and that they would not choose the surgery again, and by 4 years, 5% reported regret, based on overall regret scores greater than 50. In addition, 13% of patients at 1 year and 4 years reported that weight loss surgery caused “some” or “a lot” of negative effects.

The researchers also interviewed gastric band patients: 170, 157, 146, and 123 responded at years 1,2,3, and 4.

Overall, 8% of these patients expressed regret at 1 year, and 20% expressed regret at 4 years, said Dr. Jones.

“Almost 20% did not think they made the right decision,” he said.

Weight loss was a key driver in regret among gastric banding patients, Dr. Jones noted. An average weight loss of 7.4% of excess body weight was associated with regret scores greater than 50, while an average weight loss of 21.1% was associated with regret scores less than 50, he said.

In addition, poor sexual function, but not weight loss or other quality-of-life factors was significantly associated with regret among RYGB patients.

Many surgeons are performing sleeve gastrectomies, which appear to yield greater weight loss than gastric banding and fewer complications than gastric bypass, said Dr. Jones. His study did not include sleeve gastrectomies, but “I expect a sleeve gastrectomy to do pretty well in this analysis,” and to be associated with less patient regret, he said.

Overall, better patient education is key to improving patients’ experiences and reducing feelings of regret, said Dr. Jones.

“The better patients understand the difference between band, bypass, and sleeve preoperatively, the better we can set expectations,” he said. Dr. Jones’ institution has developed an app for laparoscopic sleeve that guides patients through the process from preop through postoperative stay, he noted.

Given the association between amount of weight lost and regret, “setting expectations is very important,” and could include not only written consent but also webinars, information sessions, and apps for patients in advance to help mitigate regrets after the procedure, Dr. Jones concluded.

Global Academy for Medical Education and this news organization are owned by the same parent company.

Dr. Jones disclosed serving on the medical advisory board for Allurion.

Not all weight loss surgery patients “live happily ever after,” according to Daniel B. Jones, MD, of Harvard Medical School, Boston.

A 2014 study of 22 women who underwent weight loss surgery reported lower energy, worse quality of life, and persistent eating disorders, Dr. Jones said in a presentation at the virtual Annual Minimally Invasive Surgery Symposium by Global Academy for Medical Education.

However, postprocedure problems don’t always equal regrets, he said. “Although many women [in the 2014 study] reported negative thoughts and health issues after weight loss surgery, none of them said they regret undergoing the procedure,” he noted.

To further examine decision regret in patients who underwent gastric bypass and gastric banding, Dr. Jones participated in a study of patients’ attitudes 4 years after gastric bypass and gastric banding (Obes Surg. 2019;29:1624-31).

“Weight loss surgery is neither risk free nor universally effective, yet few studies have examined what proportion of patients regret having undergone weight loss surgery,” he noted.

Dr. Jones and colleagues interviewed patients at two weight loss surgery centers and used specific metrics and a multivariate analysis to examine associations among weight loss, quality of life, and decision regret.

A total of 205 Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB) patients responded at 1 year after surgery: 181, 156, and 134 patients responded at 2, 3, and 4 years, respectively.

At 1 year, 2% reported regret and that they would not choose the surgery again, and by 4 years, 5% reported regret, based on overall regret scores greater than 50. In addition, 13% of patients at 1 year and 4 years reported that weight loss surgery caused “some” or “a lot” of negative effects.

The researchers also interviewed gastric band patients: 170, 157, 146, and 123 responded at years 1,2,3, and 4.

Overall, 8% of these patients expressed regret at 1 year, and 20% expressed regret at 4 years, said Dr. Jones.

“Almost 20% did not think they made the right decision,” he said.

Weight loss was a key driver in regret among gastric banding patients, Dr. Jones noted. An average weight loss of 7.4% of excess body weight was associated with regret scores greater than 50, while an average weight loss of 21.1% was associated with regret scores less than 50, he said.

In addition, poor sexual function, but not weight loss or other quality-of-life factors was significantly associated with regret among RYGB patients.

Many surgeons are performing sleeve gastrectomies, which appear to yield greater weight loss than gastric banding and fewer complications than gastric bypass, said Dr. Jones. His study did not include sleeve gastrectomies, but “I expect a sleeve gastrectomy to do pretty well in this analysis,” and to be associated with less patient regret, he said.

Overall, better patient education is key to improving patients’ experiences and reducing feelings of regret, said Dr. Jones.

“The better patients understand the difference between band, bypass, and sleeve preoperatively, the better we can set expectations,” he said. Dr. Jones’ institution has developed an app for laparoscopic sleeve that guides patients through the process from preop through postoperative stay, he noted.

Given the association between amount of weight lost and regret, “setting expectations is very important,” and could include not only written consent but also webinars, information sessions, and apps for patients in advance to help mitigate regrets after the procedure, Dr. Jones concluded.

Global Academy for Medical Education and this news organization are owned by the same parent company.

Dr. Jones disclosed serving on the medical advisory board for Allurion.

Not all weight loss surgery patients “live happily ever after,” according to Daniel B. Jones, MD, of Harvard Medical School, Boston.

A 2014 study of 22 women who underwent weight loss surgery reported lower energy, worse quality of life, and persistent eating disorders, Dr. Jones said in a presentation at the virtual Annual Minimally Invasive Surgery Symposium by Global Academy for Medical Education.

However, postprocedure problems don’t always equal regrets, he said. “Although many women [in the 2014 study] reported negative thoughts and health issues after weight loss surgery, none of them said they regret undergoing the procedure,” he noted.

To further examine decision regret in patients who underwent gastric bypass and gastric banding, Dr. Jones participated in a study of patients’ attitudes 4 years after gastric bypass and gastric banding (Obes Surg. 2019;29:1624-31).

“Weight loss surgery is neither risk free nor universally effective, yet few studies have examined what proportion of patients regret having undergone weight loss surgery,” he noted.

Dr. Jones and colleagues interviewed patients at two weight loss surgery centers and used specific metrics and a multivariate analysis to examine associations among weight loss, quality of life, and decision regret.

A total of 205 Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB) patients responded at 1 year after surgery: 181, 156, and 134 patients responded at 2, 3, and 4 years, respectively.

At 1 year, 2% reported regret and that they would not choose the surgery again, and by 4 years, 5% reported regret, based on overall regret scores greater than 50. In addition, 13% of patients at 1 year and 4 years reported that weight loss surgery caused “some” or “a lot” of negative effects.

The researchers also interviewed gastric band patients: 170, 157, 146, and 123 responded at years 1,2,3, and 4.

Overall, 8% of these patients expressed regret at 1 year, and 20% expressed regret at 4 years, said Dr. Jones.

“Almost 20% did not think they made the right decision,” he said.

Weight loss was a key driver in regret among gastric banding patients, Dr. Jones noted. An average weight loss of 7.4% of excess body weight was associated with regret scores greater than 50, while an average weight loss of 21.1% was associated with regret scores less than 50, he said.

In addition, poor sexual function, but not weight loss or other quality-of-life factors was significantly associated with regret among RYGB patients.

Many surgeons are performing sleeve gastrectomies, which appear to yield greater weight loss than gastric banding and fewer complications than gastric bypass, said Dr. Jones. His study did not include sleeve gastrectomies, but “I expect a sleeve gastrectomy to do pretty well in this analysis,” and to be associated with less patient regret, he said.

Overall, better patient education is key to improving patients’ experiences and reducing feelings of regret, said Dr. Jones.

“The better patients understand the difference between band, bypass, and sleeve preoperatively, the better we can set expectations,” he said. Dr. Jones’ institution has developed an app for laparoscopic sleeve that guides patients through the process from preop through postoperative stay, he noted.

Given the association between amount of weight lost and regret, “setting expectations is very important,” and could include not only written consent but also webinars, information sessions, and apps for patients in advance to help mitigate regrets after the procedure, Dr. Jones concluded.

Global Academy for Medical Education and this news organization are owned by the same parent company.

Dr. Jones disclosed serving on the medical advisory board for Allurion.