Article Type
Changed
Fri, 02/28/2020 - 15:46
Updating the list of “rainbow” herbicides helps clarify some distinctions for veteran benefits and comes as a response to the recent GAO report.

The VA has released an updated list of locations outside of Vietnam where tactical herbicides have been used, tested, or stored by the US military. The list, which includes the “rainbow” herbicides (Agents Orange, Pink, Green, Purple, Blue, and White), comes from the DoD, after a “thorough review” of research, reports, and government publications in response to a November 2018 US Government Accountability Office (GAO) report.

The GAO made 6 recommendations, including that the DoD develop a process for updating the list, and that the DoD and the VA develop a process for coordinating the communication of the information. The DoD concurred with 4 recommendations.

The VA, responding to the GAO report, said it was “concerned that the report conflates the terms commercial herbicides with tactical herbicides, which are distinct from one another.” Certain testing and storage locations (eg, Kelly Air Force Base), it noted, are added to the list based on the presence of commercial herbicides or “mere components” of Agent Orange or other rainbow agents.

The distinction is important for veterans applying for disability benefits. The impetus for creating the list of testing and storage sites, the VA says, was to carry out the administration of providing disability benefits in accordance with the applicable Agent Orange statute and regulations. Exposure to tactical herbicides (herbicides intended for military operations in Vietnam) is required for the VA to grant benefits on a presumptive basis for Agent Orange conditions outside of Vietnam. Thus, the VA concludes in its response, unless the commercial herbicides were the “same composition, forms, and mixtures” as the estimated 20 million gallons of rainbow agents specifically produced for operations in Vietnam, the “discussion is misleading.”

The VA also did not concur with the recommendation that it take the lead on developing “clear and transparent criteria” for what constitutes a location to be included on the list.

The DoD and VA did agree with the recommendation that the DoD should be the lead agency for producing and updating the list, while the VA will be the lead agency in providing information to veterans. The list will be updated as verifiable information becomes available, said Defense Secretary Mark Esper.

The full list of locations is available at https://www.publichealth.va.gov/docs/agentorange/dod_herbicides_outside_vietnam.pdf.
The GAO report is available at https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-19-24.pdf.

Publications
Topics
Sections
Updating the list of “rainbow” herbicides helps clarify some distinctions for veteran benefits and comes as a response to the recent GAO report.
Updating the list of “rainbow” herbicides helps clarify some distinctions for veteran benefits and comes as a response to the recent GAO report.

The VA has released an updated list of locations outside of Vietnam where tactical herbicides have been used, tested, or stored by the US military. The list, which includes the “rainbow” herbicides (Agents Orange, Pink, Green, Purple, Blue, and White), comes from the DoD, after a “thorough review” of research, reports, and government publications in response to a November 2018 US Government Accountability Office (GAO) report.

The GAO made 6 recommendations, including that the DoD develop a process for updating the list, and that the DoD and the VA develop a process for coordinating the communication of the information. The DoD concurred with 4 recommendations.

The VA, responding to the GAO report, said it was “concerned that the report conflates the terms commercial herbicides with tactical herbicides, which are distinct from one another.” Certain testing and storage locations (eg, Kelly Air Force Base), it noted, are added to the list based on the presence of commercial herbicides or “mere components” of Agent Orange or other rainbow agents.

The distinction is important for veterans applying for disability benefits. The impetus for creating the list of testing and storage sites, the VA says, was to carry out the administration of providing disability benefits in accordance with the applicable Agent Orange statute and regulations. Exposure to tactical herbicides (herbicides intended for military operations in Vietnam) is required for the VA to grant benefits on a presumptive basis for Agent Orange conditions outside of Vietnam. Thus, the VA concludes in its response, unless the commercial herbicides were the “same composition, forms, and mixtures” as the estimated 20 million gallons of rainbow agents specifically produced for operations in Vietnam, the “discussion is misleading.”

The VA also did not concur with the recommendation that it take the lead on developing “clear and transparent criteria” for what constitutes a location to be included on the list.

The DoD and VA did agree with the recommendation that the DoD should be the lead agency for producing and updating the list, while the VA will be the lead agency in providing information to veterans. The list will be updated as verifiable information becomes available, said Defense Secretary Mark Esper.

The full list of locations is available at https://www.publichealth.va.gov/docs/agentorange/dod_herbicides_outside_vietnam.pdf.
The GAO report is available at https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-19-24.pdf.

The VA has released an updated list of locations outside of Vietnam where tactical herbicides have been used, tested, or stored by the US military. The list, which includes the “rainbow” herbicides (Agents Orange, Pink, Green, Purple, Blue, and White), comes from the DoD, after a “thorough review” of research, reports, and government publications in response to a November 2018 US Government Accountability Office (GAO) report.

The GAO made 6 recommendations, including that the DoD develop a process for updating the list, and that the DoD and the VA develop a process for coordinating the communication of the information. The DoD concurred with 4 recommendations.

The VA, responding to the GAO report, said it was “concerned that the report conflates the terms commercial herbicides with tactical herbicides, which are distinct from one another.” Certain testing and storage locations (eg, Kelly Air Force Base), it noted, are added to the list based on the presence of commercial herbicides or “mere components” of Agent Orange or other rainbow agents.

The distinction is important for veterans applying for disability benefits. The impetus for creating the list of testing and storage sites, the VA says, was to carry out the administration of providing disability benefits in accordance with the applicable Agent Orange statute and regulations. Exposure to tactical herbicides (herbicides intended for military operations in Vietnam) is required for the VA to grant benefits on a presumptive basis for Agent Orange conditions outside of Vietnam. Thus, the VA concludes in its response, unless the commercial herbicides were the “same composition, forms, and mixtures” as the estimated 20 million gallons of rainbow agents specifically produced for operations in Vietnam, the “discussion is misleading.”

The VA also did not concur with the recommendation that it take the lead on developing “clear and transparent criteria” for what constitutes a location to be included on the list.

The DoD and VA did agree with the recommendation that the DoD should be the lead agency for producing and updating the list, while the VA will be the lead agency in providing information to veterans. The list will be updated as verifiable information becomes available, said Defense Secretary Mark Esper.

The full list of locations is available at https://www.publichealth.va.gov/docs/agentorange/dod_herbicides_outside_vietnam.pdf.
The GAO report is available at https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-19-24.pdf.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Gate On Date
Fri, 02/28/2020 - 15:45
Un-Gate On Date
Fri, 02/28/2020 - 15:45
Use ProPublica
CFC Schedule Remove Status
Fri, 02/28/2020 - 15:45
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.