User login
PHILADELPHIA – , according to a review of published studies presented at the annual meeting of the Menopause Society (formerly The North American Menopause Society).
“Gaps in treatment can be used to inform health care providers about menopausal HT prescribing disparities, with the goal of improving equitable and advanced patient care among disadvantaged populations,” wrote Danette Conklin, PhD, an assistant professor of psychiatry and reproductive biology at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, and a psychologist at University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center; Sally MacPhedran, MD, an associate professor of reproductive biology at Case Western Reserve University and an ob.gyn at MetroHealth Medical Center, also in Cleveland; and their colleagues.
The researchers combed through PubMed, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, Web of Science and PsychInfo databases to identify all studies conducted in the United States since 1940 that contained data on patient demographics and prescribing patterns for hormone therapy to treat menopausal symptoms. In addition to excluding men, children, teens, trans men, and women who had contraindications for HT, the investigators excluded randomized clinical trials so that prescribing patterns would not be based on protocols or RCT participatory criteria.
The researchers identified 20 studies, ranging from 1973 through 2015, including 9 national studies and the others across different U.S. regions. They then analyzed differences in HT prescribing according to age, race/ethnicity, education, income, insurance type, body mass index, and mental health, including alcohol or substance use.
Seven of the studies assessed HT use based on patient surveys, seven used medical or medication records showing an HT prescription, two studies used insurance claims to show an HT prescription, and one study surveyed patients about whether they received an HT prescription. Another four studies used surveys that asked patients whether they received HT counseling but did not indicate if the patients received a prescription.
Half of the studies showed racial disparities in HT prescribing. In all of them, Black women used or were prescribed or counseled on using HT less than white, Hispanic, or Asian women. White women had greater use, prescribing, or counseling than all other races/ethnicities except one study in which Hispanic women were prescribed vaginal estrogen more often than white women.
Six of the studies showed education disparities in which menopausal women with lower education levels used less HT or were prescribed or counseled on HT less than women with higher education.
Complex reasons
Monica Christmas, MD, an associate professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Chicago and director of the Menopause Program and the Center for Women’s Integrated Health, said the study’s findings were not surprising, but the reasons for the racial disparities are likely complex.
Implicit bias in providers is likely one contributing factor, with some providers not thinking of offering HT to certain patients or not expecting the patients to be interested in it. Providers may also hesitate to prescribe HT to patients with more comorbidities because of concerns about HT risks, so if Black patients have more comorbidities, that could play a role in how many are offered or counseled on HT, she said.
“Probably the biggest take home is that it is important to be asking all of our patients about their symptoms and being proactive about talking about it,” Dr. Christmas said in an interview.
At the same time, in her anecdotal experience at a previous institution, Dr. Christmas noticed that her Black patients were less receptive to using hormone therapy than her White patients even though her Black patients tended to exhibit or report greater or more severe symptoms. But there’s been a “paradigm shift” more recently, Dr. Christmas said. With awareness about menopause growing in the media and particularly on social media, and with greater awareness about racial disparities in menopausal symptoms and care – including that shown in Dr. Christmas’s work in the SWAN Study – Dr. Christmas has had more Black patients asking about HT and other treatments for their menopausal symptoms more recently.
“Just 10 years ago, I was trying to talk to people about hormones, and I’ve been giving them to people that need them for a long time, and I couldn’t,” Dr. Christmas said. “Now people are coming in, saying ‘no one’s ever talked to me about it’ or ‘I deserve this.’ It shows you the persuasion that social media and the Internet have on our thinking too, and I think that’s going to be interesting to look at, to see how that impacts people’s perception about wanting treatment.”
Dr. Conklin agreed that reasons for the disparities likely involve a combination of factors, including providers’ assumptions about different racial groups’ knowledge and receptiveness toward different treatments. One of the studies in their review also reported provider barriers to prescribing HT, which included lack of time, lack of adequate knowledge, and concern about risks to patients’ health.
“Medical providers tend to have less time with their patients compared to PhDs, and that time factor really makes a big difference in terms of what the focus is going to be in that [short] appointment,” Dr. Conklin said in an interview. “Perhaps from a provider point of view, they are prioritizing what they think is more important to their patient and not really listening deeply to what their patient is saying.”
Educating clinicians
Potentially supporting that possibility, Dr. Conklin and Dr. MacPhedran also had a poster at the conference that looked at prescribing of HT in both Black and White women with a diagnosis of depression, anxiety, or bipolar disorder.
“In a population with a high percentage of Black patients known to have more menopause symptoms, the data demonstrated a surprisingly low rate of documented menopause symptoms (11%) compared to prior reports of up to 80%,” the researchers reported. “This low rate may be related to patient reporting, physician inquiry, or physician documentation of menopause symptoms.” They further found that White women with menopause symptoms and one of those psychiatric diagnosis were 40% more likely to receive an HT prescription for menopausal symptoms than Black women with the same diagnoses and symptoms.
Dr. Conklin emphasized the importance of providers not overlooking women who have mental health disorders when it comes to treating menopausal symptoms, particularly since mental health conditions and menopausal symptoms can exacerbate each other.
“Their depression could worsen irritability, and anxiety can worsen during the transition, and it could be overlooked or thought of as another [psychiatric] episode,” Dr. Conklin said. Providers may need to “dig a little deeper,” especially if patients are reporting having hot flashes or brain fog.
A key way to help overcome the racial disparities – whether they result from systemic issues, implicit bias or assumptions, or patients’ own reticence – is education, Dr. Conklin said. She recommended that providers have educational material about menopause and treatments for menopausal symptoms in the waiting room and then ask patients about their symptoms and invite patients to ask questions.
Dr. MacPhedran added that education for clinicians is key as well.
“Now is a great time – menopause is hot, menopause is interesting, and it’s getting a little bit of a push in terms of research dollars,” Dr. MacPhedran said. “That will trickle down to more emphasis in medical education, whether that’s nurse practitioners, physicians, PAs, or midwives. Everybody needs more education on menopause so they can be more comfortable asking and answering these questions.”
Dr. Conklin said she would like to see expanded education on menopause for medical residents and in health psychology curricula as well.
Among the 13 studies that found disparities in prescribing patterns by age, seven studies showed that older women used or were prescribed or counseled on HT more often than younger women. Four studies found the opposite, with older women less likely to use or be prescribed or counseled about HT. One study had mixed results, and one study had expected prescribing patterns.
Five studies found income disparities and five studies found disparities by medical conditions in terms of HT use, prescribing, or counseling. Other disparities identified in smaller numbers of studies (four or fewer) included natural versus surgical menopause, insurance coverage, body mass index, geographic region, smoking and alcohol use.
The two biggest limitations of the research were its heterogeneity and the small number of studies included, which points to how scarce research on racial disparities in HT use really are, Dr. Conklin said.
The research did not use any external funding. The authors had no industry disclosures. Dr. Christmas has done an educational video for FertilityIQ.
PHILADELPHIA – , according to a review of published studies presented at the annual meeting of the Menopause Society (formerly The North American Menopause Society).
“Gaps in treatment can be used to inform health care providers about menopausal HT prescribing disparities, with the goal of improving equitable and advanced patient care among disadvantaged populations,” wrote Danette Conklin, PhD, an assistant professor of psychiatry and reproductive biology at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, and a psychologist at University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center; Sally MacPhedran, MD, an associate professor of reproductive biology at Case Western Reserve University and an ob.gyn at MetroHealth Medical Center, also in Cleveland; and their colleagues.
The researchers combed through PubMed, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, Web of Science and PsychInfo databases to identify all studies conducted in the United States since 1940 that contained data on patient demographics and prescribing patterns for hormone therapy to treat menopausal symptoms. In addition to excluding men, children, teens, trans men, and women who had contraindications for HT, the investigators excluded randomized clinical trials so that prescribing patterns would not be based on protocols or RCT participatory criteria.
The researchers identified 20 studies, ranging from 1973 through 2015, including 9 national studies and the others across different U.S. regions. They then analyzed differences in HT prescribing according to age, race/ethnicity, education, income, insurance type, body mass index, and mental health, including alcohol or substance use.
Seven of the studies assessed HT use based on patient surveys, seven used medical or medication records showing an HT prescription, two studies used insurance claims to show an HT prescription, and one study surveyed patients about whether they received an HT prescription. Another four studies used surveys that asked patients whether they received HT counseling but did not indicate if the patients received a prescription.
Half of the studies showed racial disparities in HT prescribing. In all of them, Black women used or were prescribed or counseled on using HT less than white, Hispanic, or Asian women. White women had greater use, prescribing, or counseling than all other races/ethnicities except one study in which Hispanic women were prescribed vaginal estrogen more often than white women.
Six of the studies showed education disparities in which menopausal women with lower education levels used less HT or were prescribed or counseled on HT less than women with higher education.
Complex reasons
Monica Christmas, MD, an associate professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Chicago and director of the Menopause Program and the Center for Women’s Integrated Health, said the study’s findings were not surprising, but the reasons for the racial disparities are likely complex.
Implicit bias in providers is likely one contributing factor, with some providers not thinking of offering HT to certain patients or not expecting the patients to be interested in it. Providers may also hesitate to prescribe HT to patients with more comorbidities because of concerns about HT risks, so if Black patients have more comorbidities, that could play a role in how many are offered or counseled on HT, she said.
“Probably the biggest take home is that it is important to be asking all of our patients about their symptoms and being proactive about talking about it,” Dr. Christmas said in an interview.
At the same time, in her anecdotal experience at a previous institution, Dr. Christmas noticed that her Black patients were less receptive to using hormone therapy than her White patients even though her Black patients tended to exhibit or report greater or more severe symptoms. But there’s been a “paradigm shift” more recently, Dr. Christmas said. With awareness about menopause growing in the media and particularly on social media, and with greater awareness about racial disparities in menopausal symptoms and care – including that shown in Dr. Christmas’s work in the SWAN Study – Dr. Christmas has had more Black patients asking about HT and other treatments for their menopausal symptoms more recently.
“Just 10 years ago, I was trying to talk to people about hormones, and I’ve been giving them to people that need them for a long time, and I couldn’t,” Dr. Christmas said. “Now people are coming in, saying ‘no one’s ever talked to me about it’ or ‘I deserve this.’ It shows you the persuasion that social media and the Internet have on our thinking too, and I think that’s going to be interesting to look at, to see how that impacts people’s perception about wanting treatment.”
Dr. Conklin agreed that reasons for the disparities likely involve a combination of factors, including providers’ assumptions about different racial groups’ knowledge and receptiveness toward different treatments. One of the studies in their review also reported provider barriers to prescribing HT, which included lack of time, lack of adequate knowledge, and concern about risks to patients’ health.
“Medical providers tend to have less time with their patients compared to PhDs, and that time factor really makes a big difference in terms of what the focus is going to be in that [short] appointment,” Dr. Conklin said in an interview. “Perhaps from a provider point of view, they are prioritizing what they think is more important to their patient and not really listening deeply to what their patient is saying.”
Educating clinicians
Potentially supporting that possibility, Dr. Conklin and Dr. MacPhedran also had a poster at the conference that looked at prescribing of HT in both Black and White women with a diagnosis of depression, anxiety, or bipolar disorder.
“In a population with a high percentage of Black patients known to have more menopause symptoms, the data demonstrated a surprisingly low rate of documented menopause symptoms (11%) compared to prior reports of up to 80%,” the researchers reported. “This low rate may be related to patient reporting, physician inquiry, or physician documentation of menopause symptoms.” They further found that White women with menopause symptoms and one of those psychiatric diagnosis were 40% more likely to receive an HT prescription for menopausal symptoms than Black women with the same diagnoses and symptoms.
Dr. Conklin emphasized the importance of providers not overlooking women who have mental health disorders when it comes to treating menopausal symptoms, particularly since mental health conditions and menopausal symptoms can exacerbate each other.
“Their depression could worsen irritability, and anxiety can worsen during the transition, and it could be overlooked or thought of as another [psychiatric] episode,” Dr. Conklin said. Providers may need to “dig a little deeper,” especially if patients are reporting having hot flashes or brain fog.
A key way to help overcome the racial disparities – whether they result from systemic issues, implicit bias or assumptions, or patients’ own reticence – is education, Dr. Conklin said. She recommended that providers have educational material about menopause and treatments for menopausal symptoms in the waiting room and then ask patients about their symptoms and invite patients to ask questions.
Dr. MacPhedran added that education for clinicians is key as well.
“Now is a great time – menopause is hot, menopause is interesting, and it’s getting a little bit of a push in terms of research dollars,” Dr. MacPhedran said. “That will trickle down to more emphasis in medical education, whether that’s nurse practitioners, physicians, PAs, or midwives. Everybody needs more education on menopause so they can be more comfortable asking and answering these questions.”
Dr. Conklin said she would like to see expanded education on menopause for medical residents and in health psychology curricula as well.
Among the 13 studies that found disparities in prescribing patterns by age, seven studies showed that older women used or were prescribed or counseled on HT more often than younger women. Four studies found the opposite, with older women less likely to use or be prescribed or counseled about HT. One study had mixed results, and one study had expected prescribing patterns.
Five studies found income disparities and five studies found disparities by medical conditions in terms of HT use, prescribing, or counseling. Other disparities identified in smaller numbers of studies (four or fewer) included natural versus surgical menopause, insurance coverage, body mass index, geographic region, smoking and alcohol use.
The two biggest limitations of the research were its heterogeneity and the small number of studies included, which points to how scarce research on racial disparities in HT use really are, Dr. Conklin said.
The research did not use any external funding. The authors had no industry disclosures. Dr. Christmas has done an educational video for FertilityIQ.
PHILADELPHIA – , according to a review of published studies presented at the annual meeting of the Menopause Society (formerly The North American Menopause Society).
“Gaps in treatment can be used to inform health care providers about menopausal HT prescribing disparities, with the goal of improving equitable and advanced patient care among disadvantaged populations,” wrote Danette Conklin, PhD, an assistant professor of psychiatry and reproductive biology at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, and a psychologist at University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center; Sally MacPhedran, MD, an associate professor of reproductive biology at Case Western Reserve University and an ob.gyn at MetroHealth Medical Center, also in Cleveland; and their colleagues.
The researchers combed through PubMed, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, Web of Science and PsychInfo databases to identify all studies conducted in the United States since 1940 that contained data on patient demographics and prescribing patterns for hormone therapy to treat menopausal symptoms. In addition to excluding men, children, teens, trans men, and women who had contraindications for HT, the investigators excluded randomized clinical trials so that prescribing patterns would not be based on protocols or RCT participatory criteria.
The researchers identified 20 studies, ranging from 1973 through 2015, including 9 national studies and the others across different U.S. regions. They then analyzed differences in HT prescribing according to age, race/ethnicity, education, income, insurance type, body mass index, and mental health, including alcohol or substance use.
Seven of the studies assessed HT use based on patient surveys, seven used medical or medication records showing an HT prescription, two studies used insurance claims to show an HT prescription, and one study surveyed patients about whether they received an HT prescription. Another four studies used surveys that asked patients whether they received HT counseling but did not indicate if the patients received a prescription.
Half of the studies showed racial disparities in HT prescribing. In all of them, Black women used or were prescribed or counseled on using HT less than white, Hispanic, or Asian women. White women had greater use, prescribing, or counseling than all other races/ethnicities except one study in which Hispanic women were prescribed vaginal estrogen more often than white women.
Six of the studies showed education disparities in which menopausal women with lower education levels used less HT or were prescribed or counseled on HT less than women with higher education.
Complex reasons
Monica Christmas, MD, an associate professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Chicago and director of the Menopause Program and the Center for Women’s Integrated Health, said the study’s findings were not surprising, but the reasons for the racial disparities are likely complex.
Implicit bias in providers is likely one contributing factor, with some providers not thinking of offering HT to certain patients or not expecting the patients to be interested in it. Providers may also hesitate to prescribe HT to patients with more comorbidities because of concerns about HT risks, so if Black patients have more comorbidities, that could play a role in how many are offered or counseled on HT, she said.
“Probably the biggest take home is that it is important to be asking all of our patients about their symptoms and being proactive about talking about it,” Dr. Christmas said in an interview.
At the same time, in her anecdotal experience at a previous institution, Dr. Christmas noticed that her Black patients were less receptive to using hormone therapy than her White patients even though her Black patients tended to exhibit or report greater or more severe symptoms. But there’s been a “paradigm shift” more recently, Dr. Christmas said. With awareness about menopause growing in the media and particularly on social media, and with greater awareness about racial disparities in menopausal symptoms and care – including that shown in Dr. Christmas’s work in the SWAN Study – Dr. Christmas has had more Black patients asking about HT and other treatments for their menopausal symptoms more recently.
“Just 10 years ago, I was trying to talk to people about hormones, and I’ve been giving them to people that need them for a long time, and I couldn’t,” Dr. Christmas said. “Now people are coming in, saying ‘no one’s ever talked to me about it’ or ‘I deserve this.’ It shows you the persuasion that social media and the Internet have on our thinking too, and I think that’s going to be interesting to look at, to see how that impacts people’s perception about wanting treatment.”
Dr. Conklin agreed that reasons for the disparities likely involve a combination of factors, including providers’ assumptions about different racial groups’ knowledge and receptiveness toward different treatments. One of the studies in their review also reported provider barriers to prescribing HT, which included lack of time, lack of adequate knowledge, and concern about risks to patients’ health.
“Medical providers tend to have less time with their patients compared to PhDs, and that time factor really makes a big difference in terms of what the focus is going to be in that [short] appointment,” Dr. Conklin said in an interview. “Perhaps from a provider point of view, they are prioritizing what they think is more important to their patient and not really listening deeply to what their patient is saying.”
Educating clinicians
Potentially supporting that possibility, Dr. Conklin and Dr. MacPhedran also had a poster at the conference that looked at prescribing of HT in both Black and White women with a diagnosis of depression, anxiety, or bipolar disorder.
“In a population with a high percentage of Black patients known to have more menopause symptoms, the data demonstrated a surprisingly low rate of documented menopause symptoms (11%) compared to prior reports of up to 80%,” the researchers reported. “This low rate may be related to patient reporting, physician inquiry, or physician documentation of menopause symptoms.” They further found that White women with menopause symptoms and one of those psychiatric diagnosis were 40% more likely to receive an HT prescription for menopausal symptoms than Black women with the same diagnoses and symptoms.
Dr. Conklin emphasized the importance of providers not overlooking women who have mental health disorders when it comes to treating menopausal symptoms, particularly since mental health conditions and menopausal symptoms can exacerbate each other.
“Their depression could worsen irritability, and anxiety can worsen during the transition, and it could be overlooked or thought of as another [psychiatric] episode,” Dr. Conklin said. Providers may need to “dig a little deeper,” especially if patients are reporting having hot flashes or brain fog.
A key way to help overcome the racial disparities – whether they result from systemic issues, implicit bias or assumptions, or patients’ own reticence – is education, Dr. Conklin said. She recommended that providers have educational material about menopause and treatments for menopausal symptoms in the waiting room and then ask patients about their symptoms and invite patients to ask questions.
Dr. MacPhedran added that education for clinicians is key as well.
“Now is a great time – menopause is hot, menopause is interesting, and it’s getting a little bit of a push in terms of research dollars,” Dr. MacPhedran said. “That will trickle down to more emphasis in medical education, whether that’s nurse practitioners, physicians, PAs, or midwives. Everybody needs more education on menopause so they can be more comfortable asking and answering these questions.”
Dr. Conklin said she would like to see expanded education on menopause for medical residents and in health psychology curricula as well.
Among the 13 studies that found disparities in prescribing patterns by age, seven studies showed that older women used or were prescribed or counseled on HT more often than younger women. Four studies found the opposite, with older women less likely to use or be prescribed or counseled about HT. One study had mixed results, and one study had expected prescribing patterns.
Five studies found income disparities and five studies found disparities by medical conditions in terms of HT use, prescribing, or counseling. Other disparities identified in smaller numbers of studies (four or fewer) included natural versus surgical menopause, insurance coverage, body mass index, geographic region, smoking and alcohol use.
The two biggest limitations of the research were its heterogeneity and the small number of studies included, which points to how scarce research on racial disparities in HT use really are, Dr. Conklin said.
The research did not use any external funding. The authors had no industry disclosures. Dr. Christmas has done an educational video for FertilityIQ.
AT NAMS 2023