Safety of Skin-Sparing Mastectomy Confirmed Short-Term

SAN ANTONIO – Total skin-sparing mastectomy with complete preservation of the breast skin envelope was associated with favorable oncologic and ischemic outcomes in a large, high-risk cohort of women who underwent the procedure over a 10-year period in San Francisco, a study has shown.

The findings suggest that the surgery, which produces superior cosmesis and is associated with a high rate of patient satisfaction, is a reasonable option for many women facing therapeutic or prophylactic mastectomy, Dr. Anne G. Warren Peled said at the San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium.

The total skin-sparing mastectomy (TSSM) allows preservation of the nipple-areola dermal layer when ductal tissue is removed during mastectomy. "The procedure is increasingly offered to women for both therapeutic and prophylactic indications, and when combined with immediate breast reconstruction, can produce excellent aesthetic results," explained Dr. Warren Peled, a surgical resident at the University of California, San Francisco.

Because the oncologic safety of the procedure and the potential for higher rates of postoperative complications continue to be debated, Dr. Warren Peled and her colleagues sought to evaluate both outcomes using data collected in a prospectively maintained database. The investigators analyzed patient and tumor characteristics, treatment details, and the development of any postoperative complications, as well as local or distant recurrences, for 428 patients (mean age, 46.9 years) who underwent 657 TSSMs and immediate breast reconstruction at the UCSF Medical Center in 2001-2010.

"The mastectomy incisions included radial, lateral, periareolar, and inframammary incisions, and the areolar and nipple complex tissue was separated from the dermal layer of skin by sharp dissection with inversion of the nipple skin to ensure the removal of all of the nipple duct tissue," Dr. Warren Peled said during a poster discussion. Of the 657 mastectomies, 412 were therapeutic procedures, and 245 (58 bilateral and 187 contralateral) were prophylactic, she said.

Most of the tumors were stage 0 (111) or stage I (135), although stage II (95), III (48), and IV (7) tumors were also observed, Dr. Warren Peled reported. Some 14 mastectomies were for recurrent cancer, she noted. In addition, 210 patients underwent neoadjuvant chemotherapy, 144 had postmastectomy radiation therapy, and 78 had adjuvant chemotherapy, she said.

With respect to nipple involvement on pathological analysis, 11 specimens had evidence of in situ cancer and 9 had evidence of invasive cancer, leading to re-excision in 7 cases, removal of the nipple-areolar complex (NAC) in 9 cases, and NAC radiation in 4 cases, said Dr. Warren Peled.

The conventional, two-stage, expander-implant method – in which a tissue expander placed under the chest muscle is implanted and gradually inflated to expand the tissue in preparation for the synthetic implant 3-6 months later – was used in 80% of the postmastectomy reconstructions, Dr. Warren Peled said. The remaining 20% of the reconstructions included either the placement of a permanent silicon implant at the time of mastectomy (4.7%) or autologous reconstruction (15.3%), she said.

A review of the oncologic outcomes in the 412 patients who underwent therapeutic mastectomies showed that, at a median follow-up of 28 months, four patients (1%) experienced local recurrence only, eight (1.9%) experienced distant recurrence only, and four experienced both local and distant recurrence (1%), Dr. Warren Peled reported. Among the local recurrences, two each were invasive (0.7%) and in situ cancer (1.8%), and among the distant recurrences, all eight (2.7) were invasive cancers. Among those with both local and distant recurrences, three (1%) and one (0.9%) were invasive and in situ, respectively, she said,

Of the 126 patients who had a minimum 36 months’ follow-up (median, 45 months), 2 patients (1.6%) had local recurrence only, one of which was invasive; 1 patient (0.8%) had distant recurrence only; and 1 (0.8%) had both, Dr. Peled said, noting that the recurrences in the latter two patients were invasive.

An assessment of ischemic complications showed 13 cases (1.9%) of partial nipple loss; 10 cases (1.5%) of complete nipple loss, and 78 cases (11.8%) of skin flap necrosis, Dr. Peled said, noting that the group’s current nipple loss rate is lower than 1%, thanks to serial improvements in surgical technique.

The findings indicate that TSSM "can be performed with low rates of nipple involvement and locoregional recurrence," Dr. Warren Peled stated. Although the short-term findings are encouraging, the study cannot speak to the long-term oncologic safety of the procedure. "Longer term follow-up is needed to confirm the oncologic safety over time," she said.

Dr. Warren Peled had no relevant financial conflicts to disclose.

SAN ANTONIO – Total skin-sparing mastectomy with complete preservation of the breast skin envelope was associated with favorable oncologic and ischemic outcomes in a large, high-risk cohort of women who underwent the procedure over a 10-year period in San Francisco, a study has shown.

The findings suggest that the surgery, which produces superior cosmesis and is associated with a high rate of patient satisfaction, is a reasonable option for many women facing therapeutic or prophylactic mastectomy, Dr. Anne G. Warren Peled said at the San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium.

The total skin-sparing mastectomy (TSSM) allows preservation of the nipple-areola dermal layer when ductal tissue is removed during mastectomy. "The procedure is increasingly offered to women for both therapeutic and prophylactic indications, and when combined with immediate breast reconstruction, can produce excellent aesthetic results," explained Dr. Warren Peled, a surgical resident at the University of California, San Francisco.

Because the oncologic safety of the procedure and the potential for higher rates of postoperative complications continue to be debated, Dr. Warren Peled and her colleagues sought to evaluate both outcomes using data collected in a prospectively maintained database. The investigators analyzed patient and tumor characteristics, treatment details, and the development of any postoperative complications, as well as local or distant recurrences, for 428 patients (mean age, 46.9 years) who underwent 657 TSSMs and immediate breast reconstruction at the UCSF Medical Center in 2001-2010.

"The mastectomy incisions included radial, lateral, periareolar, and inframammary incisions, and the areolar and nipple complex tissue was separated from the dermal layer of skin by sharp dissection with inversion of the nipple skin to ensure the removal of all of the nipple duct tissue," Dr. Warren Peled said during a poster discussion. Of the 657 mastectomies, 412 were therapeutic procedures, and 245 (58 bilateral and 187 contralateral) were prophylactic, she said.

Most of the tumors were stage 0 (111) or stage I (135), although stage II (95), III (48), and IV (7) tumors were also observed, Dr. Warren Peled reported. Some 14 mastectomies were for recurrent cancer, she noted. In addition, 210 patients underwent neoadjuvant chemotherapy, 144 had postmastectomy radiation therapy, and 78 had adjuvant chemotherapy, she said.

With respect to nipple involvement on pathological analysis, 11 specimens had evidence of in situ cancer and 9 had evidence of invasive cancer, leading to re-excision in 7 cases, removal of the nipple-areolar complex (NAC) in 9 cases, and NAC radiation in 4 cases, said Dr. Warren Peled.

The conventional, two-stage, expander-implant method – in which a tissue expander placed under the chest muscle is implanted and gradually inflated to expand the tissue in preparation for the synthetic implant 3-6 months later – was used in 80% of the postmastectomy reconstructions, Dr. Warren Peled said. The remaining 20% of the reconstructions included either the placement of a permanent silicon implant at the time of mastectomy (4.7%) or autologous reconstruction (15.3%), she said.

A review of the oncologic outcomes in the 412 patients who underwent therapeutic mastectomies showed that, at a median follow-up of 28 months, four patients (1%) experienced local recurrence only, eight (1.9%) experienced distant recurrence only, and four experienced both local and distant recurrence (1%), Dr. Warren Peled reported. Among the local recurrences, two each were invasive (0.7%) and in situ cancer (1.8%), and among the distant recurrences, all eight (2.7) were invasive cancers. Among those with both local and distant recurrences, three (1%) and one (0.9%) were invasive and in situ, respectively, she said,

Of the 126 patients who had a minimum 36 months’ follow-up (median, 45 months), 2 patients (1.6%) had local recurrence only, one of which was invasive; 1 patient (0.8%) had distant recurrence only; and 1 (0.8%) had both, Dr. Peled said, noting that the recurrences in the latter two patients were invasive.

An assessment of ischemic complications showed 13 cases (1.9%) of partial nipple loss; 10 cases (1.5%) of complete nipple loss, and 78 cases (11.8%) of skin flap necrosis, Dr. Peled said, noting that the group’s current nipple loss rate is lower than 1%, thanks to serial improvements in surgical technique.

The findings indicate that TSSM "can be performed with low rates of nipple involvement and locoregional recurrence," Dr. Warren Peled stated. Although the short-term findings are encouraging, the study cannot speak to the long-term oncologic safety of the procedure. "Longer term follow-up is needed to confirm the oncologic safety over time," she said.

Dr. Warren Peled had no relevant financial conflicts to disclose.

SAN ANTONIO – Total skin-sparing mastectomy with complete preservation of the breast skin envelope was associated with favorable oncologic and ischemic outcomes in a large, high-risk cohort of women who underwent the procedure over a 10-year period in San Francisco, a study has shown.

The findings suggest that the surgery, which produces superior cosmesis and is associated with a high rate of patient satisfaction, is a reasonable option for many women facing therapeutic or prophylactic mastectomy, Dr. Anne G. Warren Peled said at the San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium.

The total skin-sparing mastectomy (TSSM) allows preservation of the nipple-areola dermal layer when ductal tissue is removed during mastectomy. "The procedure is increasingly offered to women for both therapeutic and prophylactic indications, and when combined with immediate breast reconstruction, can produce excellent aesthetic results," explained Dr. Warren Peled, a surgical resident at the University of California, San Francisco.

Because the oncologic safety of the procedure and the potential for higher rates of postoperative complications continue to be debated, Dr. Warren Peled and her colleagues sought to evaluate both outcomes using data collected in a prospectively maintained database. The investigators analyzed patient and tumor characteristics, treatment details, and the development of any postoperative complications, as well as local or distant recurrences, for 428 patients (mean age, 46.9 years) who underwent 657 TSSMs and immediate breast reconstruction at the UCSF Medical Center in 2001-2010.

"The mastectomy incisions included radial, lateral, periareolar, and inframammary incisions, and the areolar and nipple complex tissue was separated from the dermal layer of skin by sharp dissection with inversion of the nipple skin to ensure the removal of all of the nipple duct tissue," Dr. Warren Peled said during a poster discussion. Of the 657 mastectomies, 412 were therapeutic procedures, and 245 (58 bilateral and 187 contralateral) were prophylactic, she said.

Most of the tumors were stage 0 (111) or stage I (135), although stage II (95), III (48), and IV (7) tumors were also observed, Dr. Warren Peled reported. Some 14 mastectomies were for recurrent cancer, she noted. In addition, 210 patients underwent neoadjuvant chemotherapy, 144 had postmastectomy radiation therapy, and 78 had adjuvant chemotherapy, she said.

With respect to nipple involvement on pathological analysis, 11 specimens had evidence of in situ cancer and 9 had evidence of invasive cancer, leading to re-excision in 7 cases, removal of the nipple-areolar complex (NAC) in 9 cases, and NAC radiation in 4 cases, said Dr. Warren Peled.

The conventional, two-stage, expander-implant method – in which a tissue expander placed under the chest muscle is implanted and gradually inflated to expand the tissue in preparation for the synthetic implant 3-6 months later – was used in 80% of the postmastectomy reconstructions, Dr. Warren Peled said. The remaining 20% of the reconstructions included either the placement of a permanent silicon implant at the time of mastectomy (4.7%) or autologous reconstruction (15.3%), she said.

A review of the oncologic outcomes in the 412 patients who underwent therapeutic mastectomies showed that, at a median follow-up of 28 months, four patients (1%) experienced local recurrence only, eight (1.9%) experienced distant recurrence only, and four experienced both local and distant recurrence (1%), Dr. Warren Peled reported. Among the local recurrences, two each were invasive (0.7%) and in situ cancer (1.8%), and among the distant recurrences, all eight (2.7) were invasive cancers. Among those with both local and distant recurrences, three (1%) and one (0.9%) were invasive and in situ, respectively, she said,

Of the 126 patients who had a minimum 36 months’ follow-up (median, 45 months), 2 patients (1.6%) had local recurrence only, one of which was invasive; 1 patient (0.8%) had distant recurrence only; and 1 (0.8%) had both, Dr. Peled said, noting that the recurrences in the latter two patients were invasive.

An assessment of ischemic complications showed 13 cases (1.9%) of partial nipple loss; 10 cases (1.5%) of complete nipple loss, and 78 cases (11.8%) of skin flap necrosis, Dr. Peled said, noting that the group’s current nipple loss rate is lower than 1%, thanks to serial improvements in surgical technique.

The findings indicate that TSSM "can be performed with low rates of nipple involvement and locoregional recurrence," Dr. Warren Peled stated. Although the short-term findings are encouraging, the study cannot speak to the long-term oncologic safety of the procedure. "Longer term follow-up is needed to confirm the oncologic safety over time," she said.

Dr. Warren Peled had no relevant financial conflicts to disclose.