User login
In discussions between health care providers and patients, the words “regularity” and “irregularity” come up primarily in reference to either constipation or menstrual cycles. However, the participants in a recent panel convened by the National Sleep Foundation think we should also be discussing irregularity when we are discussing sleep with our patients.
The sleep experts on the panel began by considering 40,000 papers that directly or tangentially dealt with the topic of irregular sleep patterns. The reviewers uncovered numerous references to an association between sleep irregularity and a wide variety of adverse health outcomes, including obesity and metabolic disorders, hypertension and other cardiovascular disorders, and elevations in several inflammatory markers. Not surprisingly, the investigators also found an abundance of references supporting an association between irregular sleep and a suite of mental health problems, including depression, mood disorders, lower self esteem, poor academic performance, and deficits in attention. For example, several of the studies the panel reviewed found that in college students, GPA was lower when their sleep pattern was irregular. There were some papers that found no significant association between irregular sleep and other adverse health outcomes, but none of the studies demonstrated an association with better or improved health outcomes.
There is currently no universally accepted definition of an irregular sleep pattern. The experts pointed to some papers that used a standard deviation of 1 hour from the patient’s usual bed time determined by averaging over an interval measured in weeks. You and I shouldn’t be surprised that irregular sleep is unhealthy, but the breadth of the panel’s findings is impressive.
Although it has been long in coming, sleep is finally beginning to get some attention by the media. The focus is usually on the optimal number of hours we need each night. This panel’s findings suggest that total sleep time is only part of the story, and may even be less important than the regularity of our sleep patterns.
For those of us in pediatrics, the place where irregularity raises its ugly head is with teenagers and weekends. Although the numbers are far from clear, the question remains of how effective is catch-up sleep after a week of too-early mornings and too-late bedtimes for the chronically under-slept adolescent.
In some studies in which patients had the demonstrable effects of sleep deprivation (e.g., metabolic and cardiovascular) there was some improvement when weekend sleep was extended by 1 or 2 hours, but none beyond 2 hours.
The panel’s findings, while certainly significant, merely add weight and nuance to the existing evidence of importance of sleep and the damage done by sleep deprivation. As one of the panel members has said, “Sleep is the third pillar of health, equally important as diet and exercise, if not more.” However, this message is not getting out, or at least it is not being heeded. Like obesity, our efforts as advisers to our patients isn’t working. Unfortunately, this is because our advice is often whispered and given halfheartedly.
There was some evidence of improvement as a result of the pandemic, when those fortunate enough to be able to work from home were taking advantage of the flexibility in their schedules and getting more sleep. But health care providers certainly can’t take responsibility for what was an accident of nature.
Those of you who have been reading Letters from Maine for the last 3 decades may tire of my beating the tired horse of sleep deprivation. But I will not be deterred. I see very little evidence among health care professionals in taking the importance of sleep seriously. Sure, they may include it buried in the list of potential contributors to their patient’s complaint, but I see very little effort to move it higher on their list of priorities and almost no movement toward making substantive recommendations and then reinforcing them with follow-up.
Like obesity, sleep deprivation is a societal problem. We can lay some of the blame on Thomas Edison, but Until that time you will continue to read columns like this one when I encounter significant studies on the importance of sleep.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Other than a Littman stethoscope he accepted as a first-year medical student in 1966, Dr. Wilkoff reports having nothing to disclose. Email him at [email protected].
In discussions between health care providers and patients, the words “regularity” and “irregularity” come up primarily in reference to either constipation or menstrual cycles. However, the participants in a recent panel convened by the National Sleep Foundation think we should also be discussing irregularity when we are discussing sleep with our patients.
The sleep experts on the panel began by considering 40,000 papers that directly or tangentially dealt with the topic of irregular sleep patterns. The reviewers uncovered numerous references to an association between sleep irregularity and a wide variety of adverse health outcomes, including obesity and metabolic disorders, hypertension and other cardiovascular disorders, and elevations in several inflammatory markers. Not surprisingly, the investigators also found an abundance of references supporting an association between irregular sleep and a suite of mental health problems, including depression, mood disorders, lower self esteem, poor academic performance, and deficits in attention. For example, several of the studies the panel reviewed found that in college students, GPA was lower when their sleep pattern was irregular. There were some papers that found no significant association between irregular sleep and other adverse health outcomes, but none of the studies demonstrated an association with better or improved health outcomes.
There is currently no universally accepted definition of an irregular sleep pattern. The experts pointed to some papers that used a standard deviation of 1 hour from the patient’s usual bed time determined by averaging over an interval measured in weeks. You and I shouldn’t be surprised that irregular sleep is unhealthy, but the breadth of the panel’s findings is impressive.
Although it has been long in coming, sleep is finally beginning to get some attention by the media. The focus is usually on the optimal number of hours we need each night. This panel’s findings suggest that total sleep time is only part of the story, and may even be less important than the regularity of our sleep patterns.
For those of us in pediatrics, the place where irregularity raises its ugly head is with teenagers and weekends. Although the numbers are far from clear, the question remains of how effective is catch-up sleep after a week of too-early mornings and too-late bedtimes for the chronically under-slept adolescent.
In some studies in which patients had the demonstrable effects of sleep deprivation (e.g., metabolic and cardiovascular) there was some improvement when weekend sleep was extended by 1 or 2 hours, but none beyond 2 hours.
The panel’s findings, while certainly significant, merely add weight and nuance to the existing evidence of importance of sleep and the damage done by sleep deprivation. As one of the panel members has said, “Sleep is the third pillar of health, equally important as diet and exercise, if not more.” However, this message is not getting out, or at least it is not being heeded. Like obesity, our efforts as advisers to our patients isn’t working. Unfortunately, this is because our advice is often whispered and given halfheartedly.
There was some evidence of improvement as a result of the pandemic, when those fortunate enough to be able to work from home were taking advantage of the flexibility in their schedules and getting more sleep. But health care providers certainly can’t take responsibility for what was an accident of nature.
Those of you who have been reading Letters from Maine for the last 3 decades may tire of my beating the tired horse of sleep deprivation. But I will not be deterred. I see very little evidence among health care professionals in taking the importance of sleep seriously. Sure, they may include it buried in the list of potential contributors to their patient’s complaint, but I see very little effort to move it higher on their list of priorities and almost no movement toward making substantive recommendations and then reinforcing them with follow-up.
Like obesity, sleep deprivation is a societal problem. We can lay some of the blame on Thomas Edison, but Until that time you will continue to read columns like this one when I encounter significant studies on the importance of sleep.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Other than a Littman stethoscope he accepted as a first-year medical student in 1966, Dr. Wilkoff reports having nothing to disclose. Email him at [email protected].
In discussions between health care providers and patients, the words “regularity” and “irregularity” come up primarily in reference to either constipation or menstrual cycles. However, the participants in a recent panel convened by the National Sleep Foundation think we should also be discussing irregularity when we are discussing sleep with our patients.
The sleep experts on the panel began by considering 40,000 papers that directly or tangentially dealt with the topic of irregular sleep patterns. The reviewers uncovered numerous references to an association between sleep irregularity and a wide variety of adverse health outcomes, including obesity and metabolic disorders, hypertension and other cardiovascular disorders, and elevations in several inflammatory markers. Not surprisingly, the investigators also found an abundance of references supporting an association between irregular sleep and a suite of mental health problems, including depression, mood disorders, lower self esteem, poor academic performance, and deficits in attention. For example, several of the studies the panel reviewed found that in college students, GPA was lower when their sleep pattern was irregular. There were some papers that found no significant association between irregular sleep and other adverse health outcomes, but none of the studies demonstrated an association with better or improved health outcomes.
There is currently no universally accepted definition of an irregular sleep pattern. The experts pointed to some papers that used a standard deviation of 1 hour from the patient’s usual bed time determined by averaging over an interval measured in weeks. You and I shouldn’t be surprised that irregular sleep is unhealthy, but the breadth of the panel’s findings is impressive.
Although it has been long in coming, sleep is finally beginning to get some attention by the media. The focus is usually on the optimal number of hours we need each night. This panel’s findings suggest that total sleep time is only part of the story, and may even be less important than the regularity of our sleep patterns.
For those of us in pediatrics, the place where irregularity raises its ugly head is with teenagers and weekends. Although the numbers are far from clear, the question remains of how effective is catch-up sleep after a week of too-early mornings and too-late bedtimes for the chronically under-slept adolescent.
In some studies in which patients had the demonstrable effects of sleep deprivation (e.g., metabolic and cardiovascular) there was some improvement when weekend sleep was extended by 1 or 2 hours, but none beyond 2 hours.
The panel’s findings, while certainly significant, merely add weight and nuance to the existing evidence of importance of sleep and the damage done by sleep deprivation. As one of the panel members has said, “Sleep is the third pillar of health, equally important as diet and exercise, if not more.” However, this message is not getting out, or at least it is not being heeded. Like obesity, our efforts as advisers to our patients isn’t working. Unfortunately, this is because our advice is often whispered and given halfheartedly.
There was some evidence of improvement as a result of the pandemic, when those fortunate enough to be able to work from home were taking advantage of the flexibility in their schedules and getting more sleep. But health care providers certainly can’t take responsibility for what was an accident of nature.
Those of you who have been reading Letters from Maine for the last 3 decades may tire of my beating the tired horse of sleep deprivation. But I will not be deterred. I see very little evidence among health care professionals in taking the importance of sleep seriously. Sure, they may include it buried in the list of potential contributors to their patient’s complaint, but I see very little effort to move it higher on their list of priorities and almost no movement toward making substantive recommendations and then reinforcing them with follow-up.
Like obesity, sleep deprivation is a societal problem. We can lay some of the blame on Thomas Edison, but Until that time you will continue to read columns like this one when I encounter significant studies on the importance of sleep.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Other than a Littman stethoscope he accepted as a first-year medical student in 1966, Dr. Wilkoff reports having nothing to disclose. Email him at [email protected].