Staying alert for patients with narcolepsy

Almost half of Americans report feeling daytime sleepiness on at least 3 days per week. For most patients, this sleepiness results from insufficient nighttime sleep. But a minority of these patients have narcolepsy, a chronic neurologic disorder that impairs the brain’s control of sleep-wake cycles. This disorder often goes undiagnosed, but neurologists can make a significant difference by learning how to recognize and treat it.

What is narcolepsy?

Narcolepsy is characterized by excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) and sudden attacks of sleep. Patients have difficulty staying awake for long periods of time, and the disorder can make performing daily tasks difficult. Problems with concentration and alertness are common.

Narcolepsy is considered to have two subtypes. Patients with narcolepsy type 1 also have cataplexy, a sudden loss of muscle tone. Attacks of cataplexy are triggered by strong, usually positive, emotions. These attacks have manifestations ranging from slurred speech to complete weakness of most muscles. Patients with narcolepsy type 2, however, do not have cataplexy.

Dysregulation of rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, which is when most dreaming occurs, is another symptom of narcolepsy. The transition to REM sleep is quicker in patients with narcolepsy and usually occurs within 15 minutes of sleep onset. A related symptom is sleep paralysis, an inability to move while falling asleep or waking up. This symptom resembles a state that normally occurs during REM sleep.

Hallucinations also are common in patients with narcolepsy and can be especially vivid. Hypnagogic hallucinations occur during the transition to sleep, and hypnopompic hallucinations arise while the patient is waking up. Patients may think they see a stranger in their bedroom, and children sometimes report seeing animals.

Although it is easy for patients with narcolepsy to fall asleep at night, they often have disrupted sleep. Patients have frequent, brief arousals throughout the night that may become disturbing. Dream content often is affected in narcolepsy, too. Patients have described lucid dreams of flying or out-of-body experiences. After such intense dreams, patients often feel that their sleep has not been restful.

Criteria and diagnosis

To receive a diagnosis of narcolepsy type 1, a patient must have EDS that persists for at least 3 months and at least one of the following two features: cataplexy and objective evidence of quick sleep onset and early start of REM sleep or low cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) levels (that is, less than 110 pg/mL) of hypocretin. Hypocretin, also known as orexin, is a neuropeptide that regulates wakefulness and arousal.

Patients must meet five criteria to receive a diagnosis of narcolepsy type 2. They must have EDS that persists for at least 3 months. They must have test results that show quick sleep onset and early start of REM sleep. They must have no cataplexy. Their CSF levels of hypocretin must be normal or unknown. Finally, they must have no other conditions that provide a better explanation for their symptoms and test results.

“The diagnosis of narcolepsy is made primarily by history on the clinical features of the disorder,” said Michael J. Thorpy, MB, ChB, professor of neurology at Albert Einstein College of Medicine and director of the Sleep–Wake Disorders Center at Montefiore Medical Center in New York. When narcolepsy is suspected, testing is required to confirm the diagnosis. The patient should undergo all-night polysomnographic (PSG) testing, followed by a daytime multiple sleep latency test (MSLT). Measurement of CSF hypocretin can be diagnostic but is performed mainly in the research setting and is not common in the clinical setting, said Dr. Thorpy.

Patients with narcolepsy typically fall asleep in an average of less than 8 minutes during the nap opportunities of the MSLT. They also have at least two sleep-onset REM periods. “A new change in the diagnostic classification is that a sleep-onset REM period on the preceding night’s PSG can count as one of the two sleep-onset REM periods required for diagnosis,” said Dr. Thorpy.

“In the case of type 1 narcolepsy, the history is usually pretty clear, and the MSLT is usually positive, in the sense that it is consistent with a narcolepsy pattern,” said Thomas E. Scammell, MD, professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston. “The PSG is also important, because other factors that disrupt the patient’s nighttime sleep (such as obstructive sleep apnea and periodic limb movements) must be ruled out, especially in type 2 narcolepsy,” said Dr. Scammell.

 

Early sleep onset, late diagnosis

Diagnostic delay is a common problem for patients with narcolepsy. Although the median age of onset is 16 years, a patient typically does not receive the appropriate diagnosis until adulthood. “It takes, on average, somewhere between 8 and 12 years for a patient to get a diagnosis of narcolepsy,” said Dr. Thorpy. Growing awareness and an increase in the number of sleep disorder centers have reduced but not eliminated the diagnostic delay.

Children with narcolepsy are often misdiagnosed. “One of the most common misdiagnoses in childhood is ADHD, because sleepiness in children differs from that in adults,” said Dr. Thorpy. Sleepy children often become hyperactive and display increased impulsivity, he explained. Stimulants prescribed for ADHD tend to mask the symptoms of narcolepsy and delay the correct diagnosis. Mood disorders, behavioral disorders, and psychogenic disorders are other common misdiagnoses for children with narcolepsy.

But when it comes to adults, sometimes patients themselves contribute to the diagnostic delay. EDS is “such a pervasive feeling that I think a lot of people just don’t make much of it,” said Dr. Scammell. The symptom is easily ascribed to insufficient sleep or a difficult work schedule. “It may take them months to get to see a doctor,” said Dr. Scammell.

Behavioral treatments

Nonpharmacologic treatments are one component of care for patients with narcolepsy. Patients must maintain a regular sleep-wake schedule and ensure that they are in bed for no less than 8 hours per night, said Dr. Thorpy. Taking no more than two daytime naps of less than 20 minutes each can help relieve some of the sleepiness, he added.

In addition to ensuring an adequate amount of sleep, it is important to promote good quality sleep, said Dr. Scammell. To do this, clinicians should address any conditions such as sleep apnea that disrupt patients’ sleep, he added.

Patients also tend to avoid situations that are likely to entail the emotional stimuli that could precipitate cataplexy. Some avoid laughter or try to suppress their emotions. “That’s not good,” said Kiran Maski, MD, MPH, assistant professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School and neurologist and sleep physician at Boston Children’s Hospital. “We worry that that might be a risk factor for depression or social isolation.” Cognitive-behavioral therapy can help patients with narcolepsy gradually increase their comfort with and exposure to social situations.

Although behavioral treatments are helpful, they are not sufficient to control all the symptoms of narcolepsy. Most patients require pharmacologic treatments, which are the most effective treatments for narcolepsy, said Dr. Thorpy.

Pharmacologic treatments

Previously, neurologists relied on the stimulants methylphenidate and amphetamine, which primarily treated patients’ EDS. But the field is moving away from these drugs because of their tendency to induce side effects and their potential for abuse, said Dr. Thorpy. In this context, modafinil and armodafinil became the mainstay for promoting alertness in patients with narcolepsy.

In recent years, newer medications have emerged that have slightly greater efficacy and better safety profiles than modafinil and armodafinil. Solriamfetol (Sunosi, Jazz Pharmaceuticals), for example, is effective for EDS but does not affect cataplexy. Pitolisant (Wakix, Harmony Biosciences), on the other hand, effectively treats EDS and cataplexy.

Sodium oxybate (Xyrem, Jazz Pharmaceuticals) is the only medication that treats all the symptoms of narcolepsy, said Dr. Thorpy. “That treats the sleepiness, the cataplexy, and the disturbed nocturnal sleep,” he added. Sodium oxybate also appears to reduce sleep paralysis, hallucinations, and disturbed dreams.

A potential concern about sodium oxybate, which has been used since approximately 2000, is its high sodium load. A new formulation called low-sodium oxybate (Xywav, Jazz Pharmaceuticals) “has a slightly better safety profile, particularly in people who have cardiovascular or renal disease,” said Dr. Thorpy. “This is tending to take over the role of regular sodium oxybate.”

Many clinicians who treat patients with narcolepsy develop their own approaches, but the choice of treatment generally depends on the patient’s symptoms, said Dr. Scammell. Modafinil is a good first choice for patients with mild to moderate sleepiness, he added. Pitolisant is another good choice for these patients but is more expensive. Both drugs are well tolerated.

Clinicians can consider solriamfetol and amphetamine for patients with moderate to severe sleepiness. “I generally consider the oxybates to be a second line,” said Dr. Scammell. Although these drugs may be the most effective, and they do help patients a great deal, they have a higher prevalence of side effects and are more expensive, he added. “If we can get good results with something gentle and simple like modafinil, that would be great.”

“There are differences of opinion as to what the first-line treatments are,” said Dr. Thorpy. Some patients prefer to use the traditional stimulants as first-line treatments, but others prefer to avoid them because of their adverse effects. They favor the newer, and unfortunately more expensive, medications instead. But there is no consensus among clinicians about which of the newer medications to use. “There’s no standard treatment, and it’s very hard to develop an algorithm that is acceptable to most physicians treating patients with narcolepsy,” said Dr. Thorpy. Treatment response varies, as well. Some patients respond extremely well to treatment, but clinical trials indicate that even optimal therapy helps patients achieve about 70% of the normal level of alertness. “If they’re sedentary, sitting in a boring meeting or at the computer, they can still fall asleep, even with our current medications,” said Dr. Scammell.

“The hardest symptom of all to treat is the EDS,” agreed Dr. Thorpy. Most patients cannot be treated with one medication alone, and polypharmacy tends to be necessary, he added. Typically, this means the addition of another medication to the regimen to maximize alertness. For other patients, cataplexy is difficult to control, and adding an anticataplectic medication is appropriate. Still, most patients can control their cataplexy with one drug, either oxybate or pitolisant, said Dr. Thorpy.

 

Investigational treatments

Researchers are trying to develop new medicines with greater potency, and several medications are under investigation. Early studies have shown that reboxetine, an antidepressant medication that affects dopamine and norepinephrine activity, is an effective treatment for EDS and cataplexy. Ongoing phase 3 studies are examining reboxetine for EDS. Another drug known as FT-218 is a once-nightly formulation of sodium oxybate, unlike the twice-nightly formulations of the drug that currently are available. In a phase 3 trial, the drug was associated with significant improvements in wakefulness and reductions in attacks of cataplexy. Avadel, which is developing the drug, submitted it to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for approval in 2021, but the agency has not yet made a decision about it.

Researchers and patients alike have high hopes for medications that activate the orexin receptors. Orexin stimulates the wake-promoting neurons in the brain. Narcolepsy, and particularly narcolepsy type 1, is characterized by a loss of hypocretin cells in the central nervous system. The loss of these cells promotes sleepiness and disturbed REM sleep. To counteract this loss of cells, several companies are investigating new orexin agonists.

One such medication is TAK-994, which was developed by Takeda. The drug showed great promise for treating EDS and cataplexy, said Dr. Thorpy. But when phase 3 studies suggested that TAK-994 was associated with hepatotoxicity, the company terminated the studies. Nevertheless, other orexin agonists, including Takeda’s TAK-861, are under investigation.

“If we can restore orexin signaling, it could be like giving insulin to type 1 diabetics,” said Dr. Scammell. This class of medications could provide substantial improvements in sleepiness and other symptoms, he added. “I think when orexin agonists become available, it’s going to be quite transformative.” But these drugs are still in early development and will not be available in clinical practice for several years.

Common psychological comorbidities

Certain comorbidities are prevalent among patients with narcolepsy, and psychiatric disorders tend to be the most common. These comorbidities may complicate the management of narcolepsy. Nevertheless, they often are significant enough to require management in their own right, said Dr. Thorpy.

Depression is likely twice as common among patients with narcolepsy than among the general population, said Dr. Scammell. “Whether this is an actual neurobiologic feature of the disease, or whether it is just a reaction to having a challenging disorder isn’t entirely clear,” he added. “But it doesn’t get the attention or treatment that it deserves.”

Partnering with a psychologist or psychiatrist is important because many treatments can exacerbate mood disorders, said Dr. Maski. In general, stimulants, for example, can worsen depression and anxiety and are associated with increased suicide risk. “We oftentimes are using high-dose stimulants in patients, so mood has to be really carefully monitored and managed,” Dr. Maski added.

Cases of depression and suicidal ideation were reported in clinical trials of sodium oxybate. Although these serious adverse events were rare, patients must be monitored very closely even on treatments specifically approved for narcolepsy, said Dr. Maski. Mood disturbances are reported less frequently with modafinil and pitolisant than with stimulants, she noted.

Many times, patients need to take an antidepressant medication, but these drugs could affect the medicines administered for narcolepsy, said Dr. Thorpy. Pitolisant, in particular, may be adversely affected by current antidepressant medications. The only remedies are to change from pitolisant to another narcolepsy medication or to use an antidepressant that does not have histamine 1 receptor antagonism or affect the QTc interval.

Anxiety also is prevalent among patients with narcolepsy, and it can be worsened by traditional stimulants. These drugs also can increase the likelihood of irritability or obsessive-compulsive tendencies. “Traditional stimulants would be best avoided in these patients who have significant anxiety,” said Dr. Thorpy.

 

The social burden of narcolepsy

The burden of narcolepsy extends beyond psychiatric comorbidities into the social sphere. “Patients with narcolepsy do have greater difficulties in terms of social and interpersonal relationships,” said Dr. Thorpy. The disorder reduces patients’ quality of life, and educational difficulties and job loss are common in this population. “It’s a lifelong, incurable disorder, and these patients suffer an immense burden throughout their life because of the sleepiness that … affects their cognitive abilities,” said Dr. Thorpy.

“There’s an increased reporting of what probably amounts to social isolation,” said Dr. Maski. Patients often report that they must prioritize activities or events because they do not have the energy or alertness to participate in all of them. For instance, adolescents with narcolepsy frequently say that they must forgo after-school extracurricular activities because they need to prioritize studying and getting enough sleep. “Those priorities take away from their normal social life and events that they would like to participate in,” said Dr. Maski.

Another problem is that patients have the impression that others do not understand their condition. They are afraid that they will be perceived as lazy, uninterested, or unmotivated if they fall asleep. “Sometimes they withdraw from social events because they don’t want to be perceived in such a way,” said Dr. Maski. She and her colleagues encourage patients to participate in selected after-school events and to engage in social activities they find meaningful to maintain social networks.

An unpublished study of more than 300 patients with narcolepsy examined the effect of the disorder on patients’ social lives. At the end of the day, many patients “crash and burn,” said Dr. Scammell. Consequently, they do not have as much energy for social activities.

This lack of energy affects patients’ social relationships. The study suggests that patients with narcolepsy do not have as many friends as the general population does. Nevertheless, the frequency of close relationships and marriage was similar between patients with narcolepsy and the general population. “What people are doing is putting their energy into these close relationships, rather than having lots of friends and socializing a lot,” said Dr. Scammell. “I found that heartening, that people were doing their best and developed those close relationships,” which are vitally important for many reasons, he added.

The study, which has been submitted for publication, also asked patients about their sex lives. Many patients reported having had cataplexy during sex, and others reported that their medications caused problems with their sex lives. “Their doctors never ask about these things, and many patients actually would like their doctor to ask about them more,” said Dr. Scammell.

In addition, narcolepsy significantly affects a patient’s ability to drive. Patients with narcolepsy have a three- to fourfold increased risk of car accidents, said Dr. Scammell. This increased risk likely results from patients’ EDS.

But as important as this issue is for patients’ lives, there is no consensus on how to counsel patients about driving, said Dr. Maski. “For instance, it is not really clear if there is value in doing a maintenance of wakefulness test before allowing patients with narcolepsy to drive,” she said. The test is not validated in children or adolescents, which raises questions about how to advise beginning drivers with narcolepsy. “It’s not really clear that passing your maintenance of wakefulness test increases your safety behind the wheel,” said Dr. Maski.

“It’s the rare person with narcolepsy who can easily and safely do a 2-hour drive by themselves,” said Dr. Scammell. Patients must determine what their own limits are, and it is important for clinicians to discuss reasonable limits honestly with their patients. “I almost never would push to have somebody’s license taken away,” said Dr. Scammell. “But there are patients who only can drive around town for short errands, and if it’s anything more than half an hour, they start getting drowsy.”

There is a need for a public awareness campaign about narcolepsy, Dr. Scammell added. Such a campaign was carried out in Italy several years ago, and it included cartoons and TV segments. “It got a lot of people’s attention, and there was a real spike in new and correct diagnoses of narcolepsy,” said Dr. Scammell. But such a broad campaign is expensive, while narcolepsy is rare, and it might not be feasible to reach out to the general population. “But I certainly think it’s worth targeting doctors who are likely to see patients with sleepiness: neurologists, psychiatrists and psychologists, and primary care doctors,” said Dr. Scammell.

Almost half of Americans report feeling daytime sleepiness on at least 3 days per week. For most patients, this sleepiness results from insufficient nighttime sleep. But a minority of these patients have narcolepsy, a chronic neurologic disorder that impairs the brain’s control of sleep-wake cycles. This disorder often goes undiagnosed, but neurologists can make a significant difference by learning how to recognize and treat it.

What is narcolepsy?

Narcolepsy is characterized by excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) and sudden attacks of sleep. Patients have difficulty staying awake for long periods of time, and the disorder can make performing daily tasks difficult. Problems with concentration and alertness are common.

Narcolepsy is considered to have two subtypes. Patients with narcolepsy type 1 also have cataplexy, a sudden loss of muscle tone. Attacks of cataplexy are triggered by strong, usually positive, emotions. These attacks have manifestations ranging from slurred speech to complete weakness of most muscles. Patients with narcolepsy type 2, however, do not have cataplexy.

Dysregulation of rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, which is when most dreaming occurs, is another symptom of narcolepsy. The transition to REM sleep is quicker in patients with narcolepsy and usually occurs within 15 minutes of sleep onset. A related symptom is sleep paralysis, an inability to move while falling asleep or waking up. This symptom resembles a state that normally occurs during REM sleep.

Hallucinations also are common in patients with narcolepsy and can be especially vivid. Hypnagogic hallucinations occur during the transition to sleep, and hypnopompic hallucinations arise while the patient is waking up. Patients may think they see a stranger in their bedroom, and children sometimes report seeing animals.

Although it is easy for patients with narcolepsy to fall asleep at night, they often have disrupted sleep. Patients have frequent, brief arousals throughout the night that may become disturbing. Dream content often is affected in narcolepsy, too. Patients have described lucid dreams of flying or out-of-body experiences. After such intense dreams, patients often feel that their sleep has not been restful.

Criteria and diagnosis

To receive a diagnosis of narcolepsy type 1, a patient must have EDS that persists for at least 3 months and at least one of the following two features: cataplexy and objective evidence of quick sleep onset and early start of REM sleep or low cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) levels (that is, less than 110 pg/mL) of hypocretin. Hypocretin, also known as orexin, is a neuropeptide that regulates wakefulness and arousal.

Patients must meet five criteria to receive a diagnosis of narcolepsy type 2. They must have EDS that persists for at least 3 months. They must have test results that show quick sleep onset and early start of REM sleep. They must have no cataplexy. Their CSF levels of hypocretin must be normal or unknown. Finally, they must have no other conditions that provide a better explanation for their symptoms and test results.

“The diagnosis of narcolepsy is made primarily by history on the clinical features of the disorder,” said Michael J. Thorpy, MB, ChB, professor of neurology at Albert Einstein College of Medicine and director of the Sleep–Wake Disorders Center at Montefiore Medical Center in New York. When narcolepsy is suspected, testing is required to confirm the diagnosis. The patient should undergo all-night polysomnographic (PSG) testing, followed by a daytime multiple sleep latency test (MSLT). Measurement of CSF hypocretin can be diagnostic but is performed mainly in the research setting and is not common in the clinical setting, said Dr. Thorpy.

Patients with narcolepsy typically fall asleep in an average of less than 8 minutes during the nap opportunities of the MSLT. They also have at least two sleep-onset REM periods. “A new change in the diagnostic classification is that a sleep-onset REM period on the preceding night’s PSG can count as one of the two sleep-onset REM periods required for diagnosis,” said Dr. Thorpy.

“In the case of type 1 narcolepsy, the history is usually pretty clear, and the MSLT is usually positive, in the sense that it is consistent with a narcolepsy pattern,” said Thomas E. Scammell, MD, professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston. “The PSG is also important, because other factors that disrupt the patient’s nighttime sleep (such as obstructive sleep apnea and periodic limb movements) must be ruled out, especially in type 2 narcolepsy,” said Dr. Scammell.

 

Early sleep onset, late diagnosis

Diagnostic delay is a common problem for patients with narcolepsy. Although the median age of onset is 16 years, a patient typically does not receive the appropriate diagnosis until adulthood. “It takes, on average, somewhere between 8 and 12 years for a patient to get a diagnosis of narcolepsy,” said Dr. Thorpy. Growing awareness and an increase in the number of sleep disorder centers have reduced but not eliminated the diagnostic delay.

Children with narcolepsy are often misdiagnosed. “One of the most common misdiagnoses in childhood is ADHD, because sleepiness in children differs from that in adults,” said Dr. Thorpy. Sleepy children often become hyperactive and display increased impulsivity, he explained. Stimulants prescribed for ADHD tend to mask the symptoms of narcolepsy and delay the correct diagnosis. Mood disorders, behavioral disorders, and psychogenic disorders are other common misdiagnoses for children with narcolepsy.

But when it comes to adults, sometimes patients themselves contribute to the diagnostic delay. EDS is “such a pervasive feeling that I think a lot of people just don’t make much of it,” said Dr. Scammell. The symptom is easily ascribed to insufficient sleep or a difficult work schedule. “It may take them months to get to see a doctor,” said Dr. Scammell.

Behavioral treatments

Nonpharmacologic treatments are one component of care for patients with narcolepsy. Patients must maintain a regular sleep-wake schedule and ensure that they are in bed for no less than 8 hours per night, said Dr. Thorpy. Taking no more than two daytime naps of less than 20 minutes each can help relieve some of the sleepiness, he added.

In addition to ensuring an adequate amount of sleep, it is important to promote good quality sleep, said Dr. Scammell. To do this, clinicians should address any conditions such as sleep apnea that disrupt patients’ sleep, he added.

Patients also tend to avoid situations that are likely to entail the emotional stimuli that could precipitate cataplexy. Some avoid laughter or try to suppress their emotions. “That’s not good,” said Kiran Maski, MD, MPH, assistant professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School and neurologist and sleep physician at Boston Children’s Hospital. “We worry that that might be a risk factor for depression or social isolation.” Cognitive-behavioral therapy can help patients with narcolepsy gradually increase their comfort with and exposure to social situations.

Although behavioral treatments are helpful, they are not sufficient to control all the symptoms of narcolepsy. Most patients require pharmacologic treatments, which are the most effective treatments for narcolepsy, said Dr. Thorpy.

Pharmacologic treatments

Previously, neurologists relied on the stimulants methylphenidate and amphetamine, which primarily treated patients’ EDS. But the field is moving away from these drugs because of their tendency to induce side effects and their potential for abuse, said Dr. Thorpy. In this context, modafinil and armodafinil became the mainstay for promoting alertness in patients with narcolepsy.

In recent years, newer medications have emerged that have slightly greater efficacy and better safety profiles than modafinil and armodafinil. Solriamfetol (Sunosi, Jazz Pharmaceuticals), for example, is effective for EDS but does not affect cataplexy. Pitolisant (Wakix, Harmony Biosciences), on the other hand, effectively treats EDS and cataplexy.

Sodium oxybate (Xyrem, Jazz Pharmaceuticals) is the only medication that treats all the symptoms of narcolepsy, said Dr. Thorpy. “That treats the sleepiness, the cataplexy, and the disturbed nocturnal sleep,” he added. Sodium oxybate also appears to reduce sleep paralysis, hallucinations, and disturbed dreams.

A potential concern about sodium oxybate, which has been used since approximately 2000, is its high sodium load. A new formulation called low-sodium oxybate (Xywav, Jazz Pharmaceuticals) “has a slightly better safety profile, particularly in people who have cardiovascular or renal disease,” said Dr. Thorpy. “This is tending to take over the role of regular sodium oxybate.”

Many clinicians who treat patients with narcolepsy develop their own approaches, but the choice of treatment generally depends on the patient’s symptoms, said Dr. Scammell. Modafinil is a good first choice for patients with mild to moderate sleepiness, he added. Pitolisant is another good choice for these patients but is more expensive. Both drugs are well tolerated.

Clinicians can consider solriamfetol and amphetamine for patients with moderate to severe sleepiness. “I generally consider the oxybates to be a second line,” said Dr. Scammell. Although these drugs may be the most effective, and they do help patients a great deal, they have a higher prevalence of side effects and are more expensive, he added. “If we can get good results with something gentle and simple like modafinil, that would be great.”

“There are differences of opinion as to what the first-line treatments are,” said Dr. Thorpy. Some patients prefer to use the traditional stimulants as first-line treatments, but others prefer to avoid them because of their adverse effects. They favor the newer, and unfortunately more expensive, medications instead. But there is no consensus among clinicians about which of the newer medications to use. “There’s no standard treatment, and it’s very hard to develop an algorithm that is acceptable to most physicians treating patients with narcolepsy,” said Dr. Thorpy. Treatment response varies, as well. Some patients respond extremely well to treatment, but clinical trials indicate that even optimal therapy helps patients achieve about 70% of the normal level of alertness. “If they’re sedentary, sitting in a boring meeting or at the computer, they can still fall asleep, even with our current medications,” said Dr. Scammell.

“The hardest symptom of all to treat is the EDS,” agreed Dr. Thorpy. Most patients cannot be treated with one medication alone, and polypharmacy tends to be necessary, he added. Typically, this means the addition of another medication to the regimen to maximize alertness. For other patients, cataplexy is difficult to control, and adding an anticataplectic medication is appropriate. Still, most patients can control their cataplexy with one drug, either oxybate or pitolisant, said Dr. Thorpy.

 

Investigational treatments

Researchers are trying to develop new medicines with greater potency, and several medications are under investigation. Early studies have shown that reboxetine, an antidepressant medication that affects dopamine and norepinephrine activity, is an effective treatment for EDS and cataplexy. Ongoing phase 3 studies are examining reboxetine for EDS. Another drug known as FT-218 is a once-nightly formulation of sodium oxybate, unlike the twice-nightly formulations of the drug that currently are available. In a phase 3 trial, the drug was associated with significant improvements in wakefulness and reductions in attacks of cataplexy. Avadel, which is developing the drug, submitted it to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for approval in 2021, but the agency has not yet made a decision about it.

Researchers and patients alike have high hopes for medications that activate the orexin receptors. Orexin stimulates the wake-promoting neurons in the brain. Narcolepsy, and particularly narcolepsy type 1, is characterized by a loss of hypocretin cells in the central nervous system. The loss of these cells promotes sleepiness and disturbed REM sleep. To counteract this loss of cells, several companies are investigating new orexin agonists.

One such medication is TAK-994, which was developed by Takeda. The drug showed great promise for treating EDS and cataplexy, said Dr. Thorpy. But when phase 3 studies suggested that TAK-994 was associated with hepatotoxicity, the company terminated the studies. Nevertheless, other orexin agonists, including Takeda’s TAK-861, are under investigation.

“If we can restore orexin signaling, it could be like giving insulin to type 1 diabetics,” said Dr. Scammell. This class of medications could provide substantial improvements in sleepiness and other symptoms, he added. “I think when orexin agonists become available, it’s going to be quite transformative.” But these drugs are still in early development and will not be available in clinical practice for several years.

Common psychological comorbidities

Certain comorbidities are prevalent among patients with narcolepsy, and psychiatric disorders tend to be the most common. These comorbidities may complicate the management of narcolepsy. Nevertheless, they often are significant enough to require management in their own right, said Dr. Thorpy.

Depression is likely twice as common among patients with narcolepsy than among the general population, said Dr. Scammell. “Whether this is an actual neurobiologic feature of the disease, or whether it is just a reaction to having a challenging disorder isn’t entirely clear,” he added. “But it doesn’t get the attention or treatment that it deserves.”

Partnering with a psychologist or psychiatrist is important because many treatments can exacerbate mood disorders, said Dr. Maski. In general, stimulants, for example, can worsen depression and anxiety and are associated with increased suicide risk. “We oftentimes are using high-dose stimulants in patients, so mood has to be really carefully monitored and managed,” Dr. Maski added.

Cases of depression and suicidal ideation were reported in clinical trials of sodium oxybate. Although these serious adverse events were rare, patients must be monitored very closely even on treatments specifically approved for narcolepsy, said Dr. Maski. Mood disturbances are reported less frequently with modafinil and pitolisant than with stimulants, she noted.

Many times, patients need to take an antidepressant medication, but these drugs could affect the medicines administered for narcolepsy, said Dr. Thorpy. Pitolisant, in particular, may be adversely affected by current antidepressant medications. The only remedies are to change from pitolisant to another narcolepsy medication or to use an antidepressant that does not have histamine 1 receptor antagonism or affect the QTc interval.

Anxiety also is prevalent among patients with narcolepsy, and it can be worsened by traditional stimulants. These drugs also can increase the likelihood of irritability or obsessive-compulsive tendencies. “Traditional stimulants would be best avoided in these patients who have significant anxiety,” said Dr. Thorpy.

 

The social burden of narcolepsy

The burden of narcolepsy extends beyond psychiatric comorbidities into the social sphere. “Patients with narcolepsy do have greater difficulties in terms of social and interpersonal relationships,” said Dr. Thorpy. The disorder reduces patients’ quality of life, and educational difficulties and job loss are common in this population. “It’s a lifelong, incurable disorder, and these patients suffer an immense burden throughout their life because of the sleepiness that … affects their cognitive abilities,” said Dr. Thorpy.

“There’s an increased reporting of what probably amounts to social isolation,” said Dr. Maski. Patients often report that they must prioritize activities or events because they do not have the energy or alertness to participate in all of them. For instance, adolescents with narcolepsy frequently say that they must forgo after-school extracurricular activities because they need to prioritize studying and getting enough sleep. “Those priorities take away from their normal social life and events that they would like to participate in,” said Dr. Maski.

Another problem is that patients have the impression that others do not understand their condition. They are afraid that they will be perceived as lazy, uninterested, or unmotivated if they fall asleep. “Sometimes they withdraw from social events because they don’t want to be perceived in such a way,” said Dr. Maski. She and her colleagues encourage patients to participate in selected after-school events and to engage in social activities they find meaningful to maintain social networks.

An unpublished study of more than 300 patients with narcolepsy examined the effect of the disorder on patients’ social lives. At the end of the day, many patients “crash and burn,” said Dr. Scammell. Consequently, they do not have as much energy for social activities.

This lack of energy affects patients’ social relationships. The study suggests that patients with narcolepsy do not have as many friends as the general population does. Nevertheless, the frequency of close relationships and marriage was similar between patients with narcolepsy and the general population. “What people are doing is putting their energy into these close relationships, rather than having lots of friends and socializing a lot,” said Dr. Scammell. “I found that heartening, that people were doing their best and developed those close relationships,” which are vitally important for many reasons, he added.

The study, which has been submitted for publication, also asked patients about their sex lives. Many patients reported having had cataplexy during sex, and others reported that their medications caused problems with their sex lives. “Their doctors never ask about these things, and many patients actually would like their doctor to ask about them more,” said Dr. Scammell.

In addition, narcolepsy significantly affects a patient’s ability to drive. Patients with narcolepsy have a three- to fourfold increased risk of car accidents, said Dr. Scammell. This increased risk likely results from patients’ EDS.

But as important as this issue is for patients’ lives, there is no consensus on how to counsel patients about driving, said Dr. Maski. “For instance, it is not really clear if there is value in doing a maintenance of wakefulness test before allowing patients with narcolepsy to drive,” she said. The test is not validated in children or adolescents, which raises questions about how to advise beginning drivers with narcolepsy. “It’s not really clear that passing your maintenance of wakefulness test increases your safety behind the wheel,” said Dr. Maski.

“It’s the rare person with narcolepsy who can easily and safely do a 2-hour drive by themselves,” said Dr. Scammell. Patients must determine what their own limits are, and it is important for clinicians to discuss reasonable limits honestly with their patients. “I almost never would push to have somebody’s license taken away,” said Dr. Scammell. “But there are patients who only can drive around town for short errands, and if it’s anything more than half an hour, they start getting drowsy.”

There is a need for a public awareness campaign about narcolepsy, Dr. Scammell added. Such a campaign was carried out in Italy several years ago, and it included cartoons and TV segments. “It got a lot of people’s attention, and there was a real spike in new and correct diagnoses of narcolepsy,” said Dr. Scammell. But such a broad campaign is expensive, while narcolepsy is rare, and it might not be feasible to reach out to the general population. “But I certainly think it’s worth targeting doctors who are likely to see patients with sleepiness: neurologists, psychiatrists and psychologists, and primary care doctors,” said Dr. Scammell.

Almost half of Americans report feeling daytime sleepiness on at least 3 days per week. For most patients, this sleepiness results from insufficient nighttime sleep. But a minority of these patients have narcolepsy, a chronic neurologic disorder that impairs the brain’s control of sleep-wake cycles. This disorder often goes undiagnosed, but neurologists can make a significant difference by learning how to recognize and treat it.

What is narcolepsy?

Narcolepsy is characterized by excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) and sudden attacks of sleep. Patients have difficulty staying awake for long periods of time, and the disorder can make performing daily tasks difficult. Problems with concentration and alertness are common.

Narcolepsy is considered to have two subtypes. Patients with narcolepsy type 1 also have cataplexy, a sudden loss of muscle tone. Attacks of cataplexy are triggered by strong, usually positive, emotions. These attacks have manifestations ranging from slurred speech to complete weakness of most muscles. Patients with narcolepsy type 2, however, do not have cataplexy.

Dysregulation of rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, which is when most dreaming occurs, is another symptom of narcolepsy. The transition to REM sleep is quicker in patients with narcolepsy and usually occurs within 15 minutes of sleep onset. A related symptom is sleep paralysis, an inability to move while falling asleep or waking up. This symptom resembles a state that normally occurs during REM sleep.

Hallucinations also are common in patients with narcolepsy and can be especially vivid. Hypnagogic hallucinations occur during the transition to sleep, and hypnopompic hallucinations arise while the patient is waking up. Patients may think they see a stranger in their bedroom, and children sometimes report seeing animals.

Although it is easy for patients with narcolepsy to fall asleep at night, they often have disrupted sleep. Patients have frequent, brief arousals throughout the night that may become disturbing. Dream content often is affected in narcolepsy, too. Patients have described lucid dreams of flying or out-of-body experiences. After such intense dreams, patients often feel that their sleep has not been restful.

Criteria and diagnosis

To receive a diagnosis of narcolepsy type 1, a patient must have EDS that persists for at least 3 months and at least one of the following two features: cataplexy and objective evidence of quick sleep onset and early start of REM sleep or low cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) levels (that is, less than 110 pg/mL) of hypocretin. Hypocretin, also known as orexin, is a neuropeptide that regulates wakefulness and arousal.

Patients must meet five criteria to receive a diagnosis of narcolepsy type 2. They must have EDS that persists for at least 3 months. They must have test results that show quick sleep onset and early start of REM sleep. They must have no cataplexy. Their CSF levels of hypocretin must be normal or unknown. Finally, they must have no other conditions that provide a better explanation for their symptoms and test results.

“The diagnosis of narcolepsy is made primarily by history on the clinical features of the disorder,” said Michael J. Thorpy, MB, ChB, professor of neurology at Albert Einstein College of Medicine and director of the Sleep–Wake Disorders Center at Montefiore Medical Center in New York. When narcolepsy is suspected, testing is required to confirm the diagnosis. The patient should undergo all-night polysomnographic (PSG) testing, followed by a daytime multiple sleep latency test (MSLT). Measurement of CSF hypocretin can be diagnostic but is performed mainly in the research setting and is not common in the clinical setting, said Dr. Thorpy.

Patients with narcolepsy typically fall asleep in an average of less than 8 minutes during the nap opportunities of the MSLT. They also have at least two sleep-onset REM periods. “A new change in the diagnostic classification is that a sleep-onset REM period on the preceding night’s PSG can count as one of the two sleep-onset REM periods required for diagnosis,” said Dr. Thorpy.

“In the case of type 1 narcolepsy, the history is usually pretty clear, and the MSLT is usually positive, in the sense that it is consistent with a narcolepsy pattern,” said Thomas E. Scammell, MD, professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston. “The PSG is also important, because other factors that disrupt the patient’s nighttime sleep (such as obstructive sleep apnea and periodic limb movements) must be ruled out, especially in type 2 narcolepsy,” said Dr. Scammell.

 

Early sleep onset, late diagnosis

Diagnostic delay is a common problem for patients with narcolepsy. Although the median age of onset is 16 years, a patient typically does not receive the appropriate diagnosis until adulthood. “It takes, on average, somewhere between 8 and 12 years for a patient to get a diagnosis of narcolepsy,” said Dr. Thorpy. Growing awareness and an increase in the number of sleep disorder centers have reduced but not eliminated the diagnostic delay.

Children with narcolepsy are often misdiagnosed. “One of the most common misdiagnoses in childhood is ADHD, because sleepiness in children differs from that in adults,” said Dr. Thorpy. Sleepy children often become hyperactive and display increased impulsivity, he explained. Stimulants prescribed for ADHD tend to mask the symptoms of narcolepsy and delay the correct diagnosis. Mood disorders, behavioral disorders, and psychogenic disorders are other common misdiagnoses for children with narcolepsy.

But when it comes to adults, sometimes patients themselves contribute to the diagnostic delay. EDS is “such a pervasive feeling that I think a lot of people just don’t make much of it,” said Dr. Scammell. The symptom is easily ascribed to insufficient sleep or a difficult work schedule. “It may take them months to get to see a doctor,” said Dr. Scammell.

Behavioral treatments

Nonpharmacologic treatments are one component of care for patients with narcolepsy. Patients must maintain a regular sleep-wake schedule and ensure that they are in bed for no less than 8 hours per night, said Dr. Thorpy. Taking no more than two daytime naps of less than 20 minutes each can help relieve some of the sleepiness, he added.

In addition to ensuring an adequate amount of sleep, it is important to promote good quality sleep, said Dr. Scammell. To do this, clinicians should address any conditions such as sleep apnea that disrupt patients’ sleep, he added.

Patients also tend to avoid situations that are likely to entail the emotional stimuli that could precipitate cataplexy. Some avoid laughter or try to suppress their emotions. “That’s not good,” said Kiran Maski, MD, MPH, assistant professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School and neurologist and sleep physician at Boston Children’s Hospital. “We worry that that might be a risk factor for depression or social isolation.” Cognitive-behavioral therapy can help patients with narcolepsy gradually increase their comfort with and exposure to social situations.

Although behavioral treatments are helpful, they are not sufficient to control all the symptoms of narcolepsy. Most patients require pharmacologic treatments, which are the most effective treatments for narcolepsy, said Dr. Thorpy.

Pharmacologic treatments

Previously, neurologists relied on the stimulants methylphenidate and amphetamine, which primarily treated patients’ EDS. But the field is moving away from these drugs because of their tendency to induce side effects and their potential for abuse, said Dr. Thorpy. In this context, modafinil and armodafinil became the mainstay for promoting alertness in patients with narcolepsy.

In recent years, newer medications have emerged that have slightly greater efficacy and better safety profiles than modafinil and armodafinil. Solriamfetol (Sunosi, Jazz Pharmaceuticals), for example, is effective for EDS but does not affect cataplexy. Pitolisant (Wakix, Harmony Biosciences), on the other hand, effectively treats EDS and cataplexy.

Sodium oxybate (Xyrem, Jazz Pharmaceuticals) is the only medication that treats all the symptoms of narcolepsy, said Dr. Thorpy. “That treats the sleepiness, the cataplexy, and the disturbed nocturnal sleep,” he added. Sodium oxybate also appears to reduce sleep paralysis, hallucinations, and disturbed dreams.

A potential concern about sodium oxybate, which has been used since approximately 2000, is its high sodium load. A new formulation called low-sodium oxybate (Xywav, Jazz Pharmaceuticals) “has a slightly better safety profile, particularly in people who have cardiovascular or renal disease,” said Dr. Thorpy. “This is tending to take over the role of regular sodium oxybate.”

Many clinicians who treat patients with narcolepsy develop their own approaches, but the choice of treatment generally depends on the patient’s symptoms, said Dr. Scammell. Modafinil is a good first choice for patients with mild to moderate sleepiness, he added. Pitolisant is another good choice for these patients but is more expensive. Both drugs are well tolerated.

Clinicians can consider solriamfetol and amphetamine for patients with moderate to severe sleepiness. “I generally consider the oxybates to be a second line,” said Dr. Scammell. Although these drugs may be the most effective, and they do help patients a great deal, they have a higher prevalence of side effects and are more expensive, he added. “If we can get good results with something gentle and simple like modafinil, that would be great.”

“There are differences of opinion as to what the first-line treatments are,” said Dr. Thorpy. Some patients prefer to use the traditional stimulants as first-line treatments, but others prefer to avoid them because of their adverse effects. They favor the newer, and unfortunately more expensive, medications instead. But there is no consensus among clinicians about which of the newer medications to use. “There’s no standard treatment, and it’s very hard to develop an algorithm that is acceptable to most physicians treating patients with narcolepsy,” said Dr. Thorpy. Treatment response varies, as well. Some patients respond extremely well to treatment, but clinical trials indicate that even optimal therapy helps patients achieve about 70% of the normal level of alertness. “If they’re sedentary, sitting in a boring meeting or at the computer, they can still fall asleep, even with our current medications,” said Dr. Scammell.

“The hardest symptom of all to treat is the EDS,” agreed Dr. Thorpy. Most patients cannot be treated with one medication alone, and polypharmacy tends to be necessary, he added. Typically, this means the addition of another medication to the regimen to maximize alertness. For other patients, cataplexy is difficult to control, and adding an anticataplectic medication is appropriate. Still, most patients can control their cataplexy with one drug, either oxybate or pitolisant, said Dr. Thorpy.

 

Investigational treatments

Researchers are trying to develop new medicines with greater potency, and several medications are under investigation. Early studies have shown that reboxetine, an antidepressant medication that affects dopamine and norepinephrine activity, is an effective treatment for EDS and cataplexy. Ongoing phase 3 studies are examining reboxetine for EDS. Another drug known as FT-218 is a once-nightly formulation of sodium oxybate, unlike the twice-nightly formulations of the drug that currently are available. In a phase 3 trial, the drug was associated with significant improvements in wakefulness and reductions in attacks of cataplexy. Avadel, which is developing the drug, submitted it to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for approval in 2021, but the agency has not yet made a decision about it.

Researchers and patients alike have high hopes for medications that activate the orexin receptors. Orexin stimulates the wake-promoting neurons in the brain. Narcolepsy, and particularly narcolepsy type 1, is characterized by a loss of hypocretin cells in the central nervous system. The loss of these cells promotes sleepiness and disturbed REM sleep. To counteract this loss of cells, several companies are investigating new orexin agonists.

One such medication is TAK-994, which was developed by Takeda. The drug showed great promise for treating EDS and cataplexy, said Dr. Thorpy. But when phase 3 studies suggested that TAK-994 was associated with hepatotoxicity, the company terminated the studies. Nevertheless, other orexin agonists, including Takeda’s TAK-861, are under investigation.

“If we can restore orexin signaling, it could be like giving insulin to type 1 diabetics,” said Dr. Scammell. This class of medications could provide substantial improvements in sleepiness and other symptoms, he added. “I think when orexin agonists become available, it’s going to be quite transformative.” But these drugs are still in early development and will not be available in clinical practice for several years.

Common psychological comorbidities

Certain comorbidities are prevalent among patients with narcolepsy, and psychiatric disorders tend to be the most common. These comorbidities may complicate the management of narcolepsy. Nevertheless, they often are significant enough to require management in their own right, said Dr. Thorpy.

Depression is likely twice as common among patients with narcolepsy than among the general population, said Dr. Scammell. “Whether this is an actual neurobiologic feature of the disease, or whether it is just a reaction to having a challenging disorder isn’t entirely clear,” he added. “But it doesn’t get the attention or treatment that it deserves.”

Partnering with a psychologist or psychiatrist is important because many treatments can exacerbate mood disorders, said Dr. Maski. In general, stimulants, for example, can worsen depression and anxiety and are associated with increased suicide risk. “We oftentimes are using high-dose stimulants in patients, so mood has to be really carefully monitored and managed,” Dr. Maski added.

Cases of depression and suicidal ideation were reported in clinical trials of sodium oxybate. Although these serious adverse events were rare, patients must be monitored very closely even on treatments specifically approved for narcolepsy, said Dr. Maski. Mood disturbances are reported less frequently with modafinil and pitolisant than with stimulants, she noted.

Many times, patients need to take an antidepressant medication, but these drugs could affect the medicines administered for narcolepsy, said Dr. Thorpy. Pitolisant, in particular, may be adversely affected by current antidepressant medications. The only remedies are to change from pitolisant to another narcolepsy medication or to use an antidepressant that does not have histamine 1 receptor antagonism or affect the QTc interval.

Anxiety also is prevalent among patients with narcolepsy, and it can be worsened by traditional stimulants. These drugs also can increase the likelihood of irritability or obsessive-compulsive tendencies. “Traditional stimulants would be best avoided in these patients who have significant anxiety,” said Dr. Thorpy.

 

The social burden of narcolepsy

The burden of narcolepsy extends beyond psychiatric comorbidities into the social sphere. “Patients with narcolepsy do have greater difficulties in terms of social and interpersonal relationships,” said Dr. Thorpy. The disorder reduces patients’ quality of life, and educational difficulties and job loss are common in this population. “It’s a lifelong, incurable disorder, and these patients suffer an immense burden throughout their life because of the sleepiness that … affects their cognitive abilities,” said Dr. Thorpy.

“There’s an increased reporting of what probably amounts to social isolation,” said Dr. Maski. Patients often report that they must prioritize activities or events because they do not have the energy or alertness to participate in all of them. For instance, adolescents with narcolepsy frequently say that they must forgo after-school extracurricular activities because they need to prioritize studying and getting enough sleep. “Those priorities take away from their normal social life and events that they would like to participate in,” said Dr. Maski.

Another problem is that patients have the impression that others do not understand their condition. They are afraid that they will be perceived as lazy, uninterested, or unmotivated if they fall asleep. “Sometimes they withdraw from social events because they don’t want to be perceived in such a way,” said Dr. Maski. She and her colleagues encourage patients to participate in selected after-school events and to engage in social activities they find meaningful to maintain social networks.

An unpublished study of more than 300 patients with narcolepsy examined the effect of the disorder on patients’ social lives. At the end of the day, many patients “crash and burn,” said Dr. Scammell. Consequently, they do not have as much energy for social activities.

This lack of energy affects patients’ social relationships. The study suggests that patients with narcolepsy do not have as many friends as the general population does. Nevertheless, the frequency of close relationships and marriage was similar between patients with narcolepsy and the general population. “What people are doing is putting their energy into these close relationships, rather than having lots of friends and socializing a lot,” said Dr. Scammell. “I found that heartening, that people were doing their best and developed those close relationships,” which are vitally important for many reasons, he added.

The study, which has been submitted for publication, also asked patients about their sex lives. Many patients reported having had cataplexy during sex, and others reported that their medications caused problems with their sex lives. “Their doctors never ask about these things, and many patients actually would like their doctor to ask about them more,” said Dr. Scammell.

In addition, narcolepsy significantly affects a patient’s ability to drive. Patients with narcolepsy have a three- to fourfold increased risk of car accidents, said Dr. Scammell. This increased risk likely results from patients’ EDS.

But as important as this issue is for patients’ lives, there is no consensus on how to counsel patients about driving, said Dr. Maski. “For instance, it is not really clear if there is value in doing a maintenance of wakefulness test before allowing patients with narcolepsy to drive,” she said. The test is not validated in children or adolescents, which raises questions about how to advise beginning drivers with narcolepsy. “It’s not really clear that passing your maintenance of wakefulness test increases your safety behind the wheel,” said Dr. Maski.

“It’s the rare person with narcolepsy who can easily and safely do a 2-hour drive by themselves,” said Dr. Scammell. Patients must determine what their own limits are, and it is important for clinicians to discuss reasonable limits honestly with their patients. “I almost never would push to have somebody’s license taken away,” said Dr. Scammell. “But there are patients who only can drive around town for short errands, and if it’s anything more than half an hour, they start getting drowsy.”

There is a need for a public awareness campaign about narcolepsy, Dr. Scammell added. Such a campaign was carried out in Italy several years ago, and it included cartoons and TV segments. “It got a lot of people’s attention, and there was a real spike in new and correct diagnoses of narcolepsy,” said Dr. Scammell. But such a broad campaign is expensive, while narcolepsy is rare, and it might not be feasible to reach out to the general population. “But I certainly think it’s worth targeting doctors who are likely to see patients with sleepiness: neurologists, psychiatrists and psychologists, and primary care doctors,” said Dr. Scammell.