User login
LAKE BUENA VISTA, FLA. – When making diagnostic and treatment decisions about thyroid nodules, many endocrinologists are not following current clinical practice guidelines, according to a recent survey. Further, according to a recent international survey of endocrinologists, there is wide regional variation in the use of molecular testing and calcitonin levels.
Dr. Nicole Vietor of the department of endocrinology at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, Bethesda, Md., and her collaborators contacted members of the American Thyroid Association (ATA), the Endocrine Society (TES), and the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists (AACE). Members of these societies were contacted directly by investigators and asked to complete a web-based survey regarding their practices for diagnosing and managing thyroid nodules.
The survey consisted of 36 questions, with an index case with variations presented to respondents, who then answered questions about diagnostic and management decisionmaking practices. The hypothetical index patient was a 52 year old woman with an incidental finding of a 1.5 cm right thyroid nodule. The patient was healthy and without risk factors; the patient’s nodule was not palpable on physical exam and she had no cervical lymphadenopathy.
Almost all respondents (99.4%) would order a thyroid-stimulating hormone for initial lab testing. Other commonly ordered exams included free T4 levels and thyroid peroxidase antibody requested by 41.5% and 24.3% of respondents, respectively. Fewer than 15% of respondents would have ordered any further lab exams.
All but 1.5% of respondents would order an anatomic or functional test for this index patient, with 57.2% ordering a thyroid ultrasound to be performed in radiology and 52.1% ordering an ultrasound in clinic (multiple responses were permitted). Cervical lymph nodes were included in the initial ultrasound assessment by 68.5% of respondents. Overall, more than half (56.6%) of thyroid ultrasounds were performed by endocrinologists, and about a third (31.9%) done by radiologists.
Practice variation from guidelines became apparent when respondents were asked how various nodule characteristics affected the decision to perform a fine needle aspiration (FNA). For a 1.5-cm solid hypoechoic nodule, 93.8% of respondents would perform FNA, while two thirds (67.0%) would perform an FNA for a 0.7-cm hypoechoic nodule with microcalcifications.
When performing FNAs, 83.3% of respondents use ultrasound to guide the biopsy, with most operators performing two (19.2%), three (28.5%), or four (23.0%) passes per nodule.
Of the 897 respondents, 80.5% were TES members, 56.5% were AACE members, and 44.5% were ATA members; most respondents belonged to more than one society. Almost two thirds of respondents (63.0%) were from North America, while 12.2% were from Europe, 10.8% were from Latin America, 6.5% were from Asia, 5.6% were from the Middle East or Africa, and just 1.9% were from Oceania. More men (60.2%) than women responded.
The AACE issued clinical practice guidelines for the management of thyroid nodules in 2010, as did the ATA in 2009 and 2015.
“In summary, management of a thyroid nodule is highly variable and differs from societal guidelines in multiple areas,” wrote Dr. Vietor and her colleagues in the presentation abstract.
On Twitter @karioakes
LAKE BUENA VISTA, FLA. – When making diagnostic and treatment decisions about thyroid nodules, many endocrinologists are not following current clinical practice guidelines, according to a recent survey. Further, according to a recent international survey of endocrinologists, there is wide regional variation in the use of molecular testing and calcitonin levels.
Dr. Nicole Vietor of the department of endocrinology at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, Bethesda, Md., and her collaborators contacted members of the American Thyroid Association (ATA), the Endocrine Society (TES), and the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists (AACE). Members of these societies were contacted directly by investigators and asked to complete a web-based survey regarding their practices for diagnosing and managing thyroid nodules.
The survey consisted of 36 questions, with an index case with variations presented to respondents, who then answered questions about diagnostic and management decisionmaking practices. The hypothetical index patient was a 52 year old woman with an incidental finding of a 1.5 cm right thyroid nodule. The patient was healthy and without risk factors; the patient’s nodule was not palpable on physical exam and she had no cervical lymphadenopathy.
Almost all respondents (99.4%) would order a thyroid-stimulating hormone for initial lab testing. Other commonly ordered exams included free T4 levels and thyroid peroxidase antibody requested by 41.5% and 24.3% of respondents, respectively. Fewer than 15% of respondents would have ordered any further lab exams.
All but 1.5% of respondents would order an anatomic or functional test for this index patient, with 57.2% ordering a thyroid ultrasound to be performed in radiology and 52.1% ordering an ultrasound in clinic (multiple responses were permitted). Cervical lymph nodes were included in the initial ultrasound assessment by 68.5% of respondents. Overall, more than half (56.6%) of thyroid ultrasounds were performed by endocrinologists, and about a third (31.9%) done by radiologists.
Practice variation from guidelines became apparent when respondents were asked how various nodule characteristics affected the decision to perform a fine needle aspiration (FNA). For a 1.5-cm solid hypoechoic nodule, 93.8% of respondents would perform FNA, while two thirds (67.0%) would perform an FNA for a 0.7-cm hypoechoic nodule with microcalcifications.
When performing FNAs, 83.3% of respondents use ultrasound to guide the biopsy, with most operators performing two (19.2%), three (28.5%), or four (23.0%) passes per nodule.
Of the 897 respondents, 80.5% were TES members, 56.5% were AACE members, and 44.5% were ATA members; most respondents belonged to more than one society. Almost two thirds of respondents (63.0%) were from North America, while 12.2% were from Europe, 10.8% were from Latin America, 6.5% were from Asia, 5.6% were from the Middle East or Africa, and just 1.9% were from Oceania. More men (60.2%) than women responded.
The AACE issued clinical practice guidelines for the management of thyroid nodules in 2010, as did the ATA in 2009 and 2015.
“In summary, management of a thyroid nodule is highly variable and differs from societal guidelines in multiple areas,” wrote Dr. Vietor and her colleagues in the presentation abstract.
On Twitter @karioakes
LAKE BUENA VISTA, FLA. – When making diagnostic and treatment decisions about thyroid nodules, many endocrinologists are not following current clinical practice guidelines, according to a recent survey. Further, according to a recent international survey of endocrinologists, there is wide regional variation in the use of molecular testing and calcitonin levels.
Dr. Nicole Vietor of the department of endocrinology at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, Bethesda, Md., and her collaborators contacted members of the American Thyroid Association (ATA), the Endocrine Society (TES), and the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists (AACE). Members of these societies were contacted directly by investigators and asked to complete a web-based survey regarding their practices for diagnosing and managing thyroid nodules.
The survey consisted of 36 questions, with an index case with variations presented to respondents, who then answered questions about diagnostic and management decisionmaking practices. The hypothetical index patient was a 52 year old woman with an incidental finding of a 1.5 cm right thyroid nodule. The patient was healthy and without risk factors; the patient’s nodule was not palpable on physical exam and she had no cervical lymphadenopathy.
Almost all respondents (99.4%) would order a thyroid-stimulating hormone for initial lab testing. Other commonly ordered exams included free T4 levels and thyroid peroxidase antibody requested by 41.5% and 24.3% of respondents, respectively. Fewer than 15% of respondents would have ordered any further lab exams.
All but 1.5% of respondents would order an anatomic or functional test for this index patient, with 57.2% ordering a thyroid ultrasound to be performed in radiology and 52.1% ordering an ultrasound in clinic (multiple responses were permitted). Cervical lymph nodes were included in the initial ultrasound assessment by 68.5% of respondents. Overall, more than half (56.6%) of thyroid ultrasounds were performed by endocrinologists, and about a third (31.9%) done by radiologists.
Practice variation from guidelines became apparent when respondents were asked how various nodule characteristics affected the decision to perform a fine needle aspiration (FNA). For a 1.5-cm solid hypoechoic nodule, 93.8% of respondents would perform FNA, while two thirds (67.0%) would perform an FNA for a 0.7-cm hypoechoic nodule with microcalcifications.
When performing FNAs, 83.3% of respondents use ultrasound to guide the biopsy, with most operators performing two (19.2%), three (28.5%), or four (23.0%) passes per nodule.
Of the 897 respondents, 80.5% were TES members, 56.5% were AACE members, and 44.5% were ATA members; most respondents belonged to more than one society. Almost two thirds of respondents (63.0%) were from North America, while 12.2% were from Europe, 10.8% were from Latin America, 6.5% were from Asia, 5.6% were from the Middle East or Africa, and just 1.9% were from Oceania. More men (60.2%) than women responded.
The AACE issued clinical practice guidelines for the management of thyroid nodules in 2010, as did the ATA in 2009 and 2015.
“In summary, management of a thyroid nodule is highly variable and differs from societal guidelines in multiple areas,” wrote Dr. Vietor and her colleagues in the presentation abstract.
On Twitter @karioakes
AT THE 15TH INTERNATIONAL THYROID CONGRESS
Key clinical point: A first-ever international survey of endocrinologists showed wide variation in clinical management of thyroid nodules.
Major finding: Respondents reported performing more fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies of thyroid nodules than recommended by practice guidelines.
Data source: Web-based survey of 897 members of three different professional organizations.
Disclosures: No disclosures were identified.
