User login
Our role in colorectal cancer prevention education
Each year in the month of March, advocates, physicians, and health care educators come together to promote the importance of colorectal cancer screening during Colorectal Cancer Awareness Month. As independent GI physicians, we work within our communities to promote colorectal screening year-round.
We also understand that our education efforts do not end with the people in our community who need to be screened. Independent GI practices also engage with primary care physicians who often initiate conversations about available screening tests and when people should be screened.
Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the second leading cause of cancer death in the United States.1 It is expected to kill more than 50,000 Americans this year alone.2 This is why screening for colorectal cancer is so important. The American Cancer Society recommends screening for all average-risk patients aged 45-75 years.3
The good news? If caught early, the survival rate is very high. In fact, when caught early, the five-year survival rate is 90 percent. Unfortunately, one in three Americans who are eligible for screenings do not get screened. For certain groups, there are larger numbers of people who are not getting screened. And there are groups for whom the death rates from colorectal cancer are much higher.
Disparities in colorectal cancer screenings
According to the American Cancer Society, Blacks and Hispanics are less likely to receive prompt follow up after an abnormal CRC screening result and are more likely to be diagnosed with late-stage cancer.4 African Americans have the highest death rate when compared with all other racial groups in the United States. American Indians and Alaska Natives are the only groups for which CRC death rates are not declining.
There are many factors that drive disparities, but the main factors seem to be socioeconomic status and differences in access to early detection and treatment. While some of these issues are complex and difficult to change, increasing awareness and providing education can be easier than you might think.
Working with your community as a private GI practitioner
To address economic factors, Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates has a program that provides resources on a sliding fee scale to people in our community who do not have insurance and are concerned about having to pay for CRC screening out of pocket. This includes the costs for anesthesia, colonoscopy, and pathology services.
We also have a Direct Access Program, which allows people to self-schedule a screening and fill out a survey that assesses their candidacy for screening colonoscopy. This allows our patients to bypass an initial prescreening office visit and associated copays. Patients are provided instructions for colonoscopy prep and show up for the colonoscopy on the day of their procedure. When the colonoscopy is completed, we give them a patient education card on CRC screening to share with friends and family members who need to be screened.
Atlanta is a very diverse city, and representation is important. But, fortunately, the size of Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates allows us to have representation within many communities. We attend a significant number of health fairs and community events, many of which are sourced internally. Our physicians and staff are members of churches and social groups that we work with to provide screening materials and conduct informational events.
Word of mouth is the best advertising, and it works the same way with health education. There are a lot of myths that we must debunk. And in many of our communities, people are worrying about paying the bills to keep the lights on – they are not thinking about getting screened. But, if they hear from a friend or family member that their screening colonoscopy was a good experience and that resources were provided to help pay for the procedure, it really does make a difference.
You do not need to join a large practice to have an impact. All over the country, there are community groups working to increase screening rates, and engaging with those groups is a good start. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we are all using social media and other platforms to connect. You do not need a lot of resources to set up a Zoom meeting with people in your community to discuss CRC screening.
Engaging with referring physicians
As a private practice practitioner, part of growing your practice is engaging with the primary care physicians in your area to ensure that they are up to date on the latest research in CRC screening and that they are discussing available screening options with their patients.
Preventing cancer should always be our first goal. Most CRCs begin as a polyp. Finding, quantifying, localizing, and removing polyps through screening colonoscopy is the most effective strategy for preventing this cancer. That is why colonoscopy remains the preferred method for colon cancer screening.
The Multi-Society Task Force on Colorectal Cancer recommends that, in sequential approaches, physicians should offer colonoscopy first.5 For patients who decline to have a colonoscopy, the FIT test should be offered next, followed by second-tier tests such as Cologuard and CT colonography for patients who decline both first-tier options.
Beyond the science of colorectal screening, we want to make sure that our primary care partners are aware of the disparities that exist – and which patients are at higher risk – so that they can engage with their patients to encourage screening.
For example, in our practice, we work with local Asian American community groups to help make sure that the “model minority” myth – that Asian Americans are healthier, wealthier, and better educated than the average American – does not become a barrier to screening. While Asian Americans may have lower overall rates of some types of cancer, there are some cancers that disproportionately affect certain Asian American groups. Rates of CRC in Japanese men, for instance, are 23% higher than in non-Hispanic Whites.
Additionally, we work with our primary care colleagues to help them understand that patients may have insurance considerations when choosing a test. While insurance typically covers 100% of a preventive screening test, a follow-up colonoscopy for a positive stool test is considered a diagnostic or therapeutic service and may not be fully covered. Medicare patients may face a coinsurance bill after their follow-up colonoscopy for a positive stool test. Legislation was passed last year to remove this barrier, but Medicare beneficiaries may have some out-of-pocket costs until it is completely removed in 2030.
Are you joining a practice that supports CRC education? Just ask!
We all want to work for an organization that aligns with our core values, and for GI physicians like us, CRC screening is a core component of our everyday work.
If you are considering joining a private practice, ask how the practice is doing with their CRC awareness programs and if it leads to increases in screenings. Inquire about the groups that are being engaged with and why. Is the practice focused on communities that have disparities in screening and treatment, and is it able to complete the entire screening process for individuals in communities that are more adversely affected by colorectal cancer?
We have found that candidates who have the most success in our practice are people who want to work at Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates but are also active in their communities and have a sense of how they want to be of service in their community. It is a sign of leadership in people – the idea that they are really going to get out and network and build a practice that serves everyone in their community. These actions make a difference in getting more people screened and in decreasing the disparities that exist.
Dr. Aja McCutchen is the chair of the quality committee at Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates and serves as chair of the Digestive Health Physicians Association’s Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Committee. She reports having nothing to disclose.
References
1. Siegel RL et al. CA Cancer J Clin. 2018 Jan;68(1):7-30.
2. Key Statistics for Colorectal Cancer. Cancer.org.
3. Wolf AMD et al. CA Cancer J Clin. 2018 Jul;68(4):250-281.
4. American Cancer Society. Colorectal Cancer Facts & Figures 2020-2022.
5. Rex DK et al. Am J Gastroenterol. 2017;112(7):1016-30.
Each year in the month of March, advocates, physicians, and health care educators come together to promote the importance of colorectal cancer screening during Colorectal Cancer Awareness Month. As independent GI physicians, we work within our communities to promote colorectal screening year-round.
We also understand that our education efforts do not end with the people in our community who need to be screened. Independent GI practices also engage with primary care physicians who often initiate conversations about available screening tests and when people should be screened.
Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the second leading cause of cancer death in the United States.1 It is expected to kill more than 50,000 Americans this year alone.2 This is why screening for colorectal cancer is so important. The American Cancer Society recommends screening for all average-risk patients aged 45-75 years.3
The good news? If caught early, the survival rate is very high. In fact, when caught early, the five-year survival rate is 90 percent. Unfortunately, one in three Americans who are eligible for screenings do not get screened. For certain groups, there are larger numbers of people who are not getting screened. And there are groups for whom the death rates from colorectal cancer are much higher.
Disparities in colorectal cancer screenings
According to the American Cancer Society, Blacks and Hispanics are less likely to receive prompt follow up after an abnormal CRC screening result and are more likely to be diagnosed with late-stage cancer.4 African Americans have the highest death rate when compared with all other racial groups in the United States. American Indians and Alaska Natives are the only groups for which CRC death rates are not declining.
There are many factors that drive disparities, but the main factors seem to be socioeconomic status and differences in access to early detection and treatment. While some of these issues are complex and difficult to change, increasing awareness and providing education can be easier than you might think.
Working with your community as a private GI practitioner
To address economic factors, Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates has a program that provides resources on a sliding fee scale to people in our community who do not have insurance and are concerned about having to pay for CRC screening out of pocket. This includes the costs for anesthesia, colonoscopy, and pathology services.
We also have a Direct Access Program, which allows people to self-schedule a screening and fill out a survey that assesses their candidacy for screening colonoscopy. This allows our patients to bypass an initial prescreening office visit and associated copays. Patients are provided instructions for colonoscopy prep and show up for the colonoscopy on the day of their procedure. When the colonoscopy is completed, we give them a patient education card on CRC screening to share with friends and family members who need to be screened.
Atlanta is a very diverse city, and representation is important. But, fortunately, the size of Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates allows us to have representation within many communities. We attend a significant number of health fairs and community events, many of which are sourced internally. Our physicians and staff are members of churches and social groups that we work with to provide screening materials and conduct informational events.
Word of mouth is the best advertising, and it works the same way with health education. There are a lot of myths that we must debunk. And in many of our communities, people are worrying about paying the bills to keep the lights on – they are not thinking about getting screened. But, if they hear from a friend or family member that their screening colonoscopy was a good experience and that resources were provided to help pay for the procedure, it really does make a difference.
You do not need to join a large practice to have an impact. All over the country, there are community groups working to increase screening rates, and engaging with those groups is a good start. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we are all using social media and other platforms to connect. You do not need a lot of resources to set up a Zoom meeting with people in your community to discuss CRC screening.
Engaging with referring physicians
As a private practice practitioner, part of growing your practice is engaging with the primary care physicians in your area to ensure that they are up to date on the latest research in CRC screening and that they are discussing available screening options with their patients.
Preventing cancer should always be our first goal. Most CRCs begin as a polyp. Finding, quantifying, localizing, and removing polyps through screening colonoscopy is the most effective strategy for preventing this cancer. That is why colonoscopy remains the preferred method for colon cancer screening.
The Multi-Society Task Force on Colorectal Cancer recommends that, in sequential approaches, physicians should offer colonoscopy first.5 For patients who decline to have a colonoscopy, the FIT test should be offered next, followed by second-tier tests such as Cologuard and CT colonography for patients who decline both first-tier options.
Beyond the science of colorectal screening, we want to make sure that our primary care partners are aware of the disparities that exist – and which patients are at higher risk – so that they can engage with their patients to encourage screening.
For example, in our practice, we work with local Asian American community groups to help make sure that the “model minority” myth – that Asian Americans are healthier, wealthier, and better educated than the average American – does not become a barrier to screening. While Asian Americans may have lower overall rates of some types of cancer, there are some cancers that disproportionately affect certain Asian American groups. Rates of CRC in Japanese men, for instance, are 23% higher than in non-Hispanic Whites.
Additionally, we work with our primary care colleagues to help them understand that patients may have insurance considerations when choosing a test. While insurance typically covers 100% of a preventive screening test, a follow-up colonoscopy for a positive stool test is considered a diagnostic or therapeutic service and may not be fully covered. Medicare patients may face a coinsurance bill after their follow-up colonoscopy for a positive stool test. Legislation was passed last year to remove this barrier, but Medicare beneficiaries may have some out-of-pocket costs until it is completely removed in 2030.
Are you joining a practice that supports CRC education? Just ask!
We all want to work for an organization that aligns with our core values, and for GI physicians like us, CRC screening is a core component of our everyday work.
If you are considering joining a private practice, ask how the practice is doing with their CRC awareness programs and if it leads to increases in screenings. Inquire about the groups that are being engaged with and why. Is the practice focused on communities that have disparities in screening and treatment, and is it able to complete the entire screening process for individuals in communities that are more adversely affected by colorectal cancer?
We have found that candidates who have the most success in our practice are people who want to work at Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates but are also active in their communities and have a sense of how they want to be of service in their community. It is a sign of leadership in people – the idea that they are really going to get out and network and build a practice that serves everyone in their community. These actions make a difference in getting more people screened and in decreasing the disparities that exist.
Dr. Aja McCutchen is the chair of the quality committee at Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates and serves as chair of the Digestive Health Physicians Association’s Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Committee. She reports having nothing to disclose.
References
1. Siegel RL et al. CA Cancer J Clin. 2018 Jan;68(1):7-30.
2. Key Statistics for Colorectal Cancer. Cancer.org.
3. Wolf AMD et al. CA Cancer J Clin. 2018 Jul;68(4):250-281.
4. American Cancer Society. Colorectal Cancer Facts & Figures 2020-2022.
5. Rex DK et al. Am J Gastroenterol. 2017;112(7):1016-30.
Each year in the month of March, advocates, physicians, and health care educators come together to promote the importance of colorectal cancer screening during Colorectal Cancer Awareness Month. As independent GI physicians, we work within our communities to promote colorectal screening year-round.
We also understand that our education efforts do not end with the people in our community who need to be screened. Independent GI practices also engage with primary care physicians who often initiate conversations about available screening tests and when people should be screened.
Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the second leading cause of cancer death in the United States.1 It is expected to kill more than 50,000 Americans this year alone.2 This is why screening for colorectal cancer is so important. The American Cancer Society recommends screening for all average-risk patients aged 45-75 years.3
The good news? If caught early, the survival rate is very high. In fact, when caught early, the five-year survival rate is 90 percent. Unfortunately, one in three Americans who are eligible for screenings do not get screened. For certain groups, there are larger numbers of people who are not getting screened. And there are groups for whom the death rates from colorectal cancer are much higher.
Disparities in colorectal cancer screenings
According to the American Cancer Society, Blacks and Hispanics are less likely to receive prompt follow up after an abnormal CRC screening result and are more likely to be diagnosed with late-stage cancer.4 African Americans have the highest death rate when compared with all other racial groups in the United States. American Indians and Alaska Natives are the only groups for which CRC death rates are not declining.
There are many factors that drive disparities, but the main factors seem to be socioeconomic status and differences in access to early detection and treatment. While some of these issues are complex and difficult to change, increasing awareness and providing education can be easier than you might think.
Working with your community as a private GI practitioner
To address economic factors, Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates has a program that provides resources on a sliding fee scale to people in our community who do not have insurance and are concerned about having to pay for CRC screening out of pocket. This includes the costs for anesthesia, colonoscopy, and pathology services.
We also have a Direct Access Program, which allows people to self-schedule a screening and fill out a survey that assesses their candidacy for screening colonoscopy. This allows our patients to bypass an initial prescreening office visit and associated copays. Patients are provided instructions for colonoscopy prep and show up for the colonoscopy on the day of their procedure. When the colonoscopy is completed, we give them a patient education card on CRC screening to share with friends and family members who need to be screened.
Atlanta is a very diverse city, and representation is important. But, fortunately, the size of Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates allows us to have representation within many communities. We attend a significant number of health fairs and community events, many of which are sourced internally. Our physicians and staff are members of churches and social groups that we work with to provide screening materials and conduct informational events.
Word of mouth is the best advertising, and it works the same way with health education. There are a lot of myths that we must debunk. And in many of our communities, people are worrying about paying the bills to keep the lights on – they are not thinking about getting screened. But, if they hear from a friend or family member that their screening colonoscopy was a good experience and that resources were provided to help pay for the procedure, it really does make a difference.
You do not need to join a large practice to have an impact. All over the country, there are community groups working to increase screening rates, and engaging with those groups is a good start. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we are all using social media and other platforms to connect. You do not need a lot of resources to set up a Zoom meeting with people in your community to discuss CRC screening.
Engaging with referring physicians
As a private practice practitioner, part of growing your practice is engaging with the primary care physicians in your area to ensure that they are up to date on the latest research in CRC screening and that they are discussing available screening options with their patients.
Preventing cancer should always be our first goal. Most CRCs begin as a polyp. Finding, quantifying, localizing, and removing polyps through screening colonoscopy is the most effective strategy for preventing this cancer. That is why colonoscopy remains the preferred method for colon cancer screening.
The Multi-Society Task Force on Colorectal Cancer recommends that, in sequential approaches, physicians should offer colonoscopy first.5 For patients who decline to have a colonoscopy, the FIT test should be offered next, followed by second-tier tests such as Cologuard and CT colonography for patients who decline both first-tier options.
Beyond the science of colorectal screening, we want to make sure that our primary care partners are aware of the disparities that exist – and which patients are at higher risk – so that they can engage with their patients to encourage screening.
For example, in our practice, we work with local Asian American community groups to help make sure that the “model minority” myth – that Asian Americans are healthier, wealthier, and better educated than the average American – does not become a barrier to screening. While Asian Americans may have lower overall rates of some types of cancer, there are some cancers that disproportionately affect certain Asian American groups. Rates of CRC in Japanese men, for instance, are 23% higher than in non-Hispanic Whites.
Additionally, we work with our primary care colleagues to help them understand that patients may have insurance considerations when choosing a test. While insurance typically covers 100% of a preventive screening test, a follow-up colonoscopy for a positive stool test is considered a diagnostic or therapeutic service and may not be fully covered. Medicare patients may face a coinsurance bill after their follow-up colonoscopy for a positive stool test. Legislation was passed last year to remove this barrier, but Medicare beneficiaries may have some out-of-pocket costs until it is completely removed in 2030.
Are you joining a practice that supports CRC education? Just ask!
We all want to work for an organization that aligns with our core values, and for GI physicians like us, CRC screening is a core component of our everyday work.
If you are considering joining a private practice, ask how the practice is doing with their CRC awareness programs and if it leads to increases in screenings. Inquire about the groups that are being engaged with and why. Is the practice focused on communities that have disparities in screening and treatment, and is it able to complete the entire screening process for individuals in communities that are more adversely affected by colorectal cancer?
We have found that candidates who have the most success in our practice are people who want to work at Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates but are also active in their communities and have a sense of how they want to be of service in their community. It is a sign of leadership in people – the idea that they are really going to get out and network and build a practice that serves everyone in their community. These actions make a difference in getting more people screened and in decreasing the disparities that exist.
Dr. Aja McCutchen is the chair of the quality committee at Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates and serves as chair of the Digestive Health Physicians Association’s Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Committee. She reports having nothing to disclose.
References
1. Siegel RL et al. CA Cancer J Clin. 2018 Jan;68(1):7-30.
2. Key Statistics for Colorectal Cancer. Cancer.org.
3. Wolf AMD et al. CA Cancer J Clin. 2018 Jul;68(4):250-281.
4. American Cancer Society. Colorectal Cancer Facts & Figures 2020-2022.
5. Rex DK et al. Am J Gastroenterol. 2017;112(7):1016-30.
How productivity influences compensation in private practice
When starting a career in gastroenterology, physicians tend to work in the hospital, where there is usually high demand for services and productivity goals are easy to meet. This is a little different in private GI groups, where it takes some time to build up your patient base. This might be a significant concern for young physicians considering private practice. But understanding the role that productivity plays in compensation packages can help in choosing the right group to join.
While compensation models may differ from practice to practice, there is usually a base salary provided with a productivity bonus. Some practices may use productivity along with other measures to determine when a physician is eligible to become a partner in the practice. Partnership is often accompanied with the benefits of ancillary services ownership such as ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) and anesthesia, pathology, and infusion services.
How is productivity measured?
Most practices utilize relative value units (RVUs), a standard used by Medicare to determine the amount to pay physicians according to their productivity. Most public and private payers are utilizing the RVU system first developed for Medicare as a useful, time-saving way to handle physician payments. The RVU defines the volume of work doctors perform for all procedures and services covered under the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule.
The Medicare Physician Payment System has three components:
• The geographic practice cost indices (GPCIs)
• Relative value units (RVUs)
• A conversion factor
It is important to understand the types of RVUs that exist to understand how to calculate them properly – these include the following categories:
• Physician work, which accounts for the time and effort to perform a procedure.
• Practice expense, which is for the costs of nonphysician labor such as rent and supplies.
• Global fees, which includes fees for initial visits, follow-ups, and practice expense, and applies during a predetermined length of time known as the “global periods,” primarily for major surgeries.
• Malpractice expense, such as costs for professional liability insurance.
There is no specific dollar amount attached to an RVU because RVUs are part of a resource-based relative value scale (RBRVS) which uses RVUs to relate medical procedures to each other. Payment for physician work is based on whether the procedure is performed in an ASC or hospital outpatient department or in an office. A separate facility fee payment is made to the ASC or hospital outpatient department for procedures performed there. Other elements include skills and the amount of time needed to perform a procedure. Calculating the reimbursement from an RVU involves several components and a significant amount of complex math.
Meeting goals while building a practice
For many young physicians working in the hospital where patients are plentiful, it might seem daunting to build your practice with productivity goals. Practices should, and many do, design their initial productivity plans to minimum or mean RVUs for young physicians rather than someone 10 years into practice. Younger physicians have fellowship and training, but it takes years to become highly efficient with time and productivity. It’s important for everyone involved to set attainable benchmarks.
The practice should also do its best to support your efforts to grow your patient base. While you should be expected to develop relationships with referring physicians, you’ll benefit from the practice’s marketing efforts. When new patients come in, they usually go to newly hired physicians because more senior physicians are booked weeks or months in advance.
Practice administrators also work hard to time new hires to overlap with expected retirements. Senior partners will always have follow-up colonoscopies and associates will need to take on these cases as their colleagues retire. In some practices, younger physicians are expected to take the hospital on call schedules or respond to emergency department calls, so it shouldn’t be difficult to meet productivity goals.
And once you become a partner and are further along on in your career, your productivity plan will change. Some groups have productivity-based compensation, which allows more senior partners to work when they want to – as long as they are meeting the productivity rates that will cover their portion of the practice expenses.
If a physician is consistently not meeting productivity measures, a practice may exercise the right to terminate the relationship, but this is rare. More often, physicians meet their productivity levels and receive certain bonuses for exceeding their goals. In most practices, the partners you work with will know if you aren’t meeting your goals. In most cases, they will take on a mentorship role to help you succeed.
Ask questions, be engaged
Another thing to be aware of is that all practices worth joining make sure productivity plans do not violate the Stark Law, anti-kickback statutes, or other regulations. A huge red flag to look out for is a productivity plan that is based on the number of procedures – it should never be tied to volume.
It’s also best to consider how often the productivity plan is measured. It might be a red flag if it is measured weekly or monthly or if there are heavy consequences for not meeting RVU goals. Most groups look at productivity on a quarterly basis and integrate those discussions into a standard review process.
The successful early-career GIs we interview in our practices are those who are interested in understanding the ins and outs of our practices and what they can achieve through practicing independently. The practices worth joining will likewise be interested in discussing your level of entrepreneurship, the opportunities for you to grow in your career, and what it takes to be on the track to partner.
Dr. Baig is a practicing gastroenterologist at Allied Digestive Care in New Jersey and is the chair of communications for the Digestive Health Physicians Association (DHPA); Mr. Harlen is the president of PE Practice Solutions and immediate past chief operating officer of Capital Digestive Care in Maryland. He is the executive director of DHPA.
When starting a career in gastroenterology, physicians tend to work in the hospital, where there is usually high demand for services and productivity goals are easy to meet. This is a little different in private GI groups, where it takes some time to build up your patient base. This might be a significant concern for young physicians considering private practice. But understanding the role that productivity plays in compensation packages can help in choosing the right group to join.
While compensation models may differ from practice to practice, there is usually a base salary provided with a productivity bonus. Some practices may use productivity along with other measures to determine when a physician is eligible to become a partner in the practice. Partnership is often accompanied with the benefits of ancillary services ownership such as ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) and anesthesia, pathology, and infusion services.
How is productivity measured?
Most practices utilize relative value units (RVUs), a standard used by Medicare to determine the amount to pay physicians according to their productivity. Most public and private payers are utilizing the RVU system first developed for Medicare as a useful, time-saving way to handle physician payments. The RVU defines the volume of work doctors perform for all procedures and services covered under the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule.
The Medicare Physician Payment System has three components:
• The geographic practice cost indices (GPCIs)
• Relative value units (RVUs)
• A conversion factor
It is important to understand the types of RVUs that exist to understand how to calculate them properly – these include the following categories:
• Physician work, which accounts for the time and effort to perform a procedure.
• Practice expense, which is for the costs of nonphysician labor such as rent and supplies.
• Global fees, which includes fees for initial visits, follow-ups, and practice expense, and applies during a predetermined length of time known as the “global periods,” primarily for major surgeries.
• Malpractice expense, such as costs for professional liability insurance.
There is no specific dollar amount attached to an RVU because RVUs are part of a resource-based relative value scale (RBRVS) which uses RVUs to relate medical procedures to each other. Payment for physician work is based on whether the procedure is performed in an ASC or hospital outpatient department or in an office. A separate facility fee payment is made to the ASC or hospital outpatient department for procedures performed there. Other elements include skills and the amount of time needed to perform a procedure. Calculating the reimbursement from an RVU involves several components and a significant amount of complex math.
Meeting goals while building a practice
For many young physicians working in the hospital where patients are plentiful, it might seem daunting to build your practice with productivity goals. Practices should, and many do, design their initial productivity plans to minimum or mean RVUs for young physicians rather than someone 10 years into practice. Younger physicians have fellowship and training, but it takes years to become highly efficient with time and productivity. It’s important for everyone involved to set attainable benchmarks.
The practice should also do its best to support your efforts to grow your patient base. While you should be expected to develop relationships with referring physicians, you’ll benefit from the practice’s marketing efforts. When new patients come in, they usually go to newly hired physicians because more senior physicians are booked weeks or months in advance.
Practice administrators also work hard to time new hires to overlap with expected retirements. Senior partners will always have follow-up colonoscopies and associates will need to take on these cases as their colleagues retire. In some practices, younger physicians are expected to take the hospital on call schedules or respond to emergency department calls, so it shouldn’t be difficult to meet productivity goals.
And once you become a partner and are further along on in your career, your productivity plan will change. Some groups have productivity-based compensation, which allows more senior partners to work when they want to – as long as they are meeting the productivity rates that will cover their portion of the practice expenses.
If a physician is consistently not meeting productivity measures, a practice may exercise the right to terminate the relationship, but this is rare. More often, physicians meet their productivity levels and receive certain bonuses for exceeding their goals. In most practices, the partners you work with will know if you aren’t meeting your goals. In most cases, they will take on a mentorship role to help you succeed.
Ask questions, be engaged
Another thing to be aware of is that all practices worth joining make sure productivity plans do not violate the Stark Law, anti-kickback statutes, or other regulations. A huge red flag to look out for is a productivity plan that is based on the number of procedures – it should never be tied to volume.
It’s also best to consider how often the productivity plan is measured. It might be a red flag if it is measured weekly or monthly or if there are heavy consequences for not meeting RVU goals. Most groups look at productivity on a quarterly basis and integrate those discussions into a standard review process.
The successful early-career GIs we interview in our practices are those who are interested in understanding the ins and outs of our practices and what they can achieve through practicing independently. The practices worth joining will likewise be interested in discussing your level of entrepreneurship, the opportunities for you to grow in your career, and what it takes to be on the track to partner.
Dr. Baig is a practicing gastroenterologist at Allied Digestive Care in New Jersey and is the chair of communications for the Digestive Health Physicians Association (DHPA); Mr. Harlen is the president of PE Practice Solutions and immediate past chief operating officer of Capital Digestive Care in Maryland. He is the executive director of DHPA.
When starting a career in gastroenterology, physicians tend to work in the hospital, where there is usually high demand for services and productivity goals are easy to meet. This is a little different in private GI groups, where it takes some time to build up your patient base. This might be a significant concern for young physicians considering private practice. But understanding the role that productivity plays in compensation packages can help in choosing the right group to join.
While compensation models may differ from practice to practice, there is usually a base salary provided with a productivity bonus. Some practices may use productivity along with other measures to determine when a physician is eligible to become a partner in the practice. Partnership is often accompanied with the benefits of ancillary services ownership such as ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) and anesthesia, pathology, and infusion services.
How is productivity measured?
Most practices utilize relative value units (RVUs), a standard used by Medicare to determine the amount to pay physicians according to their productivity. Most public and private payers are utilizing the RVU system first developed for Medicare as a useful, time-saving way to handle physician payments. The RVU defines the volume of work doctors perform for all procedures and services covered under the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule.
The Medicare Physician Payment System has three components:
• The geographic practice cost indices (GPCIs)
• Relative value units (RVUs)
• A conversion factor
It is important to understand the types of RVUs that exist to understand how to calculate them properly – these include the following categories:
• Physician work, which accounts for the time and effort to perform a procedure.
• Practice expense, which is for the costs of nonphysician labor such as rent and supplies.
• Global fees, which includes fees for initial visits, follow-ups, and practice expense, and applies during a predetermined length of time known as the “global periods,” primarily for major surgeries.
• Malpractice expense, such as costs for professional liability insurance.
There is no specific dollar amount attached to an RVU because RVUs are part of a resource-based relative value scale (RBRVS) which uses RVUs to relate medical procedures to each other. Payment for physician work is based on whether the procedure is performed in an ASC or hospital outpatient department or in an office. A separate facility fee payment is made to the ASC or hospital outpatient department for procedures performed there. Other elements include skills and the amount of time needed to perform a procedure. Calculating the reimbursement from an RVU involves several components and a significant amount of complex math.
Meeting goals while building a practice
For many young physicians working in the hospital where patients are plentiful, it might seem daunting to build your practice with productivity goals. Practices should, and many do, design their initial productivity plans to minimum or mean RVUs for young physicians rather than someone 10 years into practice. Younger physicians have fellowship and training, but it takes years to become highly efficient with time and productivity. It’s important for everyone involved to set attainable benchmarks.
The practice should also do its best to support your efforts to grow your patient base. While you should be expected to develop relationships with referring physicians, you’ll benefit from the practice’s marketing efforts. When new patients come in, they usually go to newly hired physicians because more senior physicians are booked weeks or months in advance.
Practice administrators also work hard to time new hires to overlap with expected retirements. Senior partners will always have follow-up colonoscopies and associates will need to take on these cases as their colleagues retire. In some practices, younger physicians are expected to take the hospital on call schedules or respond to emergency department calls, so it shouldn’t be difficult to meet productivity goals.
And once you become a partner and are further along on in your career, your productivity plan will change. Some groups have productivity-based compensation, which allows more senior partners to work when they want to – as long as they are meeting the productivity rates that will cover their portion of the practice expenses.
If a physician is consistently not meeting productivity measures, a practice may exercise the right to terminate the relationship, but this is rare. More often, physicians meet their productivity levels and receive certain bonuses for exceeding their goals. In most practices, the partners you work with will know if you aren’t meeting your goals. In most cases, they will take on a mentorship role to help you succeed.
Ask questions, be engaged
Another thing to be aware of is that all practices worth joining make sure productivity plans do not violate the Stark Law, anti-kickback statutes, or other regulations. A huge red flag to look out for is a productivity plan that is based on the number of procedures – it should never be tied to volume.
It’s also best to consider how often the productivity plan is measured. It might be a red flag if it is measured weekly or monthly or if there are heavy consequences for not meeting RVU goals. Most groups look at productivity on a quarterly basis and integrate those discussions into a standard review process.
The successful early-career GIs we interview in our practices are those who are interested in understanding the ins and outs of our practices and what they can achieve through practicing independently. The practices worth joining will likewise be interested in discussing your level of entrepreneurship, the opportunities for you to grow in your career, and what it takes to be on the track to partner.
Dr. Baig is a practicing gastroenterologist at Allied Digestive Care in New Jersey and is the chair of communications for the Digestive Health Physicians Association (DHPA); Mr. Harlen is the president of PE Practice Solutions and immediate past chief operating officer of Capital Digestive Care in Maryland. He is the executive director of DHPA.
Quality measures and initiatives in private practices
It has been almost 15 years since the American College of Gastroenterology and American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy established the Task Force on Quality Endoscopy and published the first set of quality indicators for GI endoscopic procedures.
This work was motivated by two seminal reports on patient safety that fostered a demand by the public, policy makers, and payers to accurately define and measure the quality of health care services.
While the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services initially designated and required reporting on several basic outcome measures, leaders within the field of gastroenterology recognized the importance of developing evidence-based quality measures for our field, and specifically for endoscopic procedures.
Integrating safety measures into our daily operations has always been important, and over the years, policies have been implemented to incentivize health care providers to meet standards in everything from patient safety to patient satisfaction.
Defining quality and how to measure it
The goals of implementing quality measures within private practices include effective patient care and safety, but they also include issues like access and affordability, as well as the professionalism of your physicians and advanced practice providers.
As a larger practice, we have the resources to support a quality coordinator who spends half their time focused on quality measures. Every provider is required to complete annual education on quality parameters.
We have two committees that propose and track quality initiatives in our practice. We have one on the practice side and one for our ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs). The committees are made of physicians who have a particular interest in quality measures. On the ASC side, our ASC center director from our management partner AmSurg is also a member of the committee.
The road to improving quality within a private practice starts by defining the aspects of care that affect the quality of the patient experience.
Tracking quality in the office and in the surgery center
In our practices we have about 60 physicians. Start times and coding accuracy are good examples of what we have tracked in the past as areas of quality improvement. For instance, if only one or two providers get started late, it can cause a domino effect. Schedules get cramped, which can increase stress and possibly cause our team members to rush. Even things that seem like patient satisfaction issues can affect patient care, so it is important to make sure they are being measured.
On the ASC side, we track adenoma detection rates, colonoscopy intervals, complication rates, and many other additional criteria. As an example, when a pathology report is issued, we require our physicians to provide results to our patients within 72 hours.
Data on all providers are tabulated quarterly and then distributed to the providers in the form of a scorecard. The scorecard is then used for constructive feedback on improvements that can be made. A cumulative annual report is given to the providers, which is also incorporated into reviews. Not paying attention to quality measures can potentially have financial ramifications for providers in our group.
Find the right fit from a quality standpoint
In terms of what we are tracking, we are probably not that different from most groups of our size. Standardization will continue to increase, and it is important as an early career physician to familiarize yourself with quality measures in gastroenterology.
I often interview early career physicians who would like to join Regional GI, and the most impressive are the young men and women who ask about our processes for tracking quality measures and implementing programs geared toward improvement. If you are thinking of joining a practice, bring it up. You will be glad you did.
The interest in quality shows that you are invested in providing the best evidence-based patient care. As an independent group, this is critical because so much of what we do depends on having a track record of measurement. For instance, an ASC might not be credentialed if the quality metrics do not meet a certain threshold.
We are looking for potential partners who are seriously interested in joining us on our mission to provide the highest-quality care to our patients. After all, that is why became gastroenterologists in the first place.
Dr. Lalani serves as treasurer on the executive committee of the Digestive Health Physicians Association and is a practicing gastroenterologist at U.S. Digestive Health.
It has been almost 15 years since the American College of Gastroenterology and American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy established the Task Force on Quality Endoscopy and published the first set of quality indicators for GI endoscopic procedures.
This work was motivated by two seminal reports on patient safety that fostered a demand by the public, policy makers, and payers to accurately define and measure the quality of health care services.
While the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services initially designated and required reporting on several basic outcome measures, leaders within the field of gastroenterology recognized the importance of developing evidence-based quality measures for our field, and specifically for endoscopic procedures.
Integrating safety measures into our daily operations has always been important, and over the years, policies have been implemented to incentivize health care providers to meet standards in everything from patient safety to patient satisfaction.
Defining quality and how to measure it
The goals of implementing quality measures within private practices include effective patient care and safety, but they also include issues like access and affordability, as well as the professionalism of your physicians and advanced practice providers.
As a larger practice, we have the resources to support a quality coordinator who spends half their time focused on quality measures. Every provider is required to complete annual education on quality parameters.
We have two committees that propose and track quality initiatives in our practice. We have one on the practice side and one for our ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs). The committees are made of physicians who have a particular interest in quality measures. On the ASC side, our ASC center director from our management partner AmSurg is also a member of the committee.
The road to improving quality within a private practice starts by defining the aspects of care that affect the quality of the patient experience.
Tracking quality in the office and in the surgery center
In our practices we have about 60 physicians. Start times and coding accuracy are good examples of what we have tracked in the past as areas of quality improvement. For instance, if only one or two providers get started late, it can cause a domino effect. Schedules get cramped, which can increase stress and possibly cause our team members to rush. Even things that seem like patient satisfaction issues can affect patient care, so it is important to make sure they are being measured.
On the ASC side, we track adenoma detection rates, colonoscopy intervals, complication rates, and many other additional criteria. As an example, when a pathology report is issued, we require our physicians to provide results to our patients within 72 hours.
Data on all providers are tabulated quarterly and then distributed to the providers in the form of a scorecard. The scorecard is then used for constructive feedback on improvements that can be made. A cumulative annual report is given to the providers, which is also incorporated into reviews. Not paying attention to quality measures can potentially have financial ramifications for providers in our group.
Find the right fit from a quality standpoint
In terms of what we are tracking, we are probably not that different from most groups of our size. Standardization will continue to increase, and it is important as an early career physician to familiarize yourself with quality measures in gastroenterology.
I often interview early career physicians who would like to join Regional GI, and the most impressive are the young men and women who ask about our processes for tracking quality measures and implementing programs geared toward improvement. If you are thinking of joining a practice, bring it up. You will be glad you did.
The interest in quality shows that you are invested in providing the best evidence-based patient care. As an independent group, this is critical because so much of what we do depends on having a track record of measurement. For instance, an ASC might not be credentialed if the quality metrics do not meet a certain threshold.
We are looking for potential partners who are seriously interested in joining us on our mission to provide the highest-quality care to our patients. After all, that is why became gastroenterologists in the first place.
Dr. Lalani serves as treasurer on the executive committee of the Digestive Health Physicians Association and is a practicing gastroenterologist at U.S. Digestive Health.
It has been almost 15 years since the American College of Gastroenterology and American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy established the Task Force on Quality Endoscopy and published the first set of quality indicators for GI endoscopic procedures.
This work was motivated by two seminal reports on patient safety that fostered a demand by the public, policy makers, and payers to accurately define and measure the quality of health care services.
While the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services initially designated and required reporting on several basic outcome measures, leaders within the field of gastroenterology recognized the importance of developing evidence-based quality measures for our field, and specifically for endoscopic procedures.
Integrating safety measures into our daily operations has always been important, and over the years, policies have been implemented to incentivize health care providers to meet standards in everything from patient safety to patient satisfaction.
Defining quality and how to measure it
The goals of implementing quality measures within private practices include effective patient care and safety, but they also include issues like access and affordability, as well as the professionalism of your physicians and advanced practice providers.
As a larger practice, we have the resources to support a quality coordinator who spends half their time focused on quality measures. Every provider is required to complete annual education on quality parameters.
We have two committees that propose and track quality initiatives in our practice. We have one on the practice side and one for our ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs). The committees are made of physicians who have a particular interest in quality measures. On the ASC side, our ASC center director from our management partner AmSurg is also a member of the committee.
The road to improving quality within a private practice starts by defining the aspects of care that affect the quality of the patient experience.
Tracking quality in the office and in the surgery center
In our practices we have about 60 physicians. Start times and coding accuracy are good examples of what we have tracked in the past as areas of quality improvement. For instance, if only one or two providers get started late, it can cause a domino effect. Schedules get cramped, which can increase stress and possibly cause our team members to rush. Even things that seem like patient satisfaction issues can affect patient care, so it is important to make sure they are being measured.
On the ASC side, we track adenoma detection rates, colonoscopy intervals, complication rates, and many other additional criteria. As an example, when a pathology report is issued, we require our physicians to provide results to our patients within 72 hours.
Data on all providers are tabulated quarterly and then distributed to the providers in the form of a scorecard. The scorecard is then used for constructive feedback on improvements that can be made. A cumulative annual report is given to the providers, which is also incorporated into reviews. Not paying attention to quality measures can potentially have financial ramifications for providers in our group.
Find the right fit from a quality standpoint
In terms of what we are tracking, we are probably not that different from most groups of our size. Standardization will continue to increase, and it is important as an early career physician to familiarize yourself with quality measures in gastroenterology.
I often interview early career physicians who would like to join Regional GI, and the most impressive are the young men and women who ask about our processes for tracking quality measures and implementing programs geared toward improvement. If you are thinking of joining a practice, bring it up. You will be glad you did.
The interest in quality shows that you are invested in providing the best evidence-based patient care. As an independent group, this is critical because so much of what we do depends on having a track record of measurement. For instance, an ASC might not be credentialed if the quality metrics do not meet a certain threshold.
We are looking for potential partners who are seriously interested in joining us on our mission to provide the highest-quality care to our patients. After all, that is why became gastroenterologists in the first place.
Dr. Lalani serves as treasurer on the executive committee of the Digestive Health Physicians Association and is a practicing gastroenterologist at U.S. Digestive Health.
Navigating a pandemic: The importance of preparedness in independent GI practices
It was early March, and our second day of advocacy on Capitol Hill with the Digestive Health Physicians Association (DHPA) was cut short when congressional offices were shuttered because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Sitting with several of my GI physician colleagues from across the country, we knew that our practices, our patients, and our communities would be impacted by the coronavirus. None of us could have known the extent.
We also didn’t know in that moment that our advocacy work through DHPA would be one of the most important factors in ensuring that our practices were prepared to weather the pandemic. Our membership, legal counsel, and legislative lobbyists helped us remain informed about new legislation and regulations and ensured that we had much-needed access to government resources.
Just a few months into what is now the COVID-19 pandemic, independent GI practice leaders have learned a lot about how to strengthen our practices to respond to future crises – and what early-career GIs should look for in the practices they are considering.
First and foremost, practice leadership is key. One thing most successful GI practices have in common is that they hire really smart executives and administrative teams who excel at taking care of the business side of things so that physicians like me can do what we do best: treat patients.
Stay informed about state and federal policies
As a member of DHPA, Capital Digestive Care was well positioned to keep up to date on the government response to the coronavirus and the support it provided to small businesses and to health care providers.
Over the past 5 years, DHPA physician leaders have established strong relationships with our elected federal leaders. During our Capitol Hill visits in early March, we discussed the coronavirus in addition to our policy priorities.
The relationships we’ve built with policymakers have helped us educate them about how private practices were being affected and make the case that it was crucial to include private practices in health care stimulus packages.
Without this federal financial support, many medical groups may have had to close their doors – leaving a large gap in care once the pandemic subsides.
In addition to the federal government’s financial support, our policy advocacy efforts kept us informed about federal health agencies’ decisions on telehealth coverage. We were able to educate our physicians and staff about state and federal adjustments to telehealth rules for the pandemic, on the guidelines for elective procedures, on employee furlough and leave rules, as well as other congressional and state actions that would impact our practice.
You can’t be an independent physician without being open to learning about the business of health care and understanding how health policies affect your ability to practice medicine and care for people in your community. Every early-career physician who is looking to join a practice should ask how its leadership remains informed about health policy at the state and federal levels.
Make plans, be flexible
Implementing telehealth was critical in responding to the coronavirus pandemic. We were able to get up and running quickly on telemedicine because we had already invested in telehealth and had conducted a pilot of the platform with a smaller group of providers well before the pandemic hit.
In March, we were able to expand the telehealth platform to accommodate virtual visits by all of our providers. We also had to figure out how to shift our employees to telework, develop remote desktop and VPN solutions, and make sure that our scheduling and revenue cycle team members were fully operational.
The overriding goal was the safety of patients, staff, and our providers while continuing to provide medical care. Our inflammatory bowel disease patients needing visits to receive medication infusions took over an entire office so that there could be appropriate spacing and limited contacts with staff and other patients.
Our administrators knew early on that we needed a back-up plan and worked with physicians and providers doing telehealth visits to provide the flexibility to switch to Centers for Medicare & Medicaid–approved platforms (including Facetime) for those instances in which patients were uncomfortable using our main platform or when it was strained by bandwidth issues – a common challenge with any platform. Virtual check-in and check-out procedures were developed utilizing our usual office staff from remote locations.
For patients who had indications for gastroenterology procedures, we established a prioritization system, based on state guidelines, for those that were needed urgently or routinely as our endoscopy centers began to reopen. Safety measures were put into place including screening questionnaires, preprocedure COVID rt-PCT testing, personal protective equipment, and workflow changes to achieve social distancing.
As an early-career GI physician who is considering private practice, you’ll likely have several conversations with administrative leaders when deciding what practice to join. Ask about how the practice responded to COVID-19, and what processes it has in place to prepare for future emergencies.
During the early weeks of the pandemic, the CDC Board of Managers met two to three times per week. Task forces to discuss office operations and planning for ambulatory surgery center opening were established with participation by nearly every provider and manager. Communication between all providers and managers was important to decrease the obvious anxiety everyone was experiencing.
Old financial models may no longer work
Most practices develop budgets based on historical data. We quickly figured out that budgets from historical forecasts no longer worked and that we needed to understand the impact to budgets almost in real time.
We immediately looked to conserve cash and reduce expenses, requesting that our large vendors extend payment terms or provide a period of forbearance. We looked at everything from our EMR costs to lab supplies and everything in between.
Changing how we modeled our budgets and reducing costs made some of our hard decisions less difficult. While we had to furlough staff, our models for reducing physician compensation and lowering our costs allowed us to create a model for the return to work that included the use of paid time off and paid health care for our furloughed employees.
Our operations team also set up systems to gather information that was needed to apply for and report on federal loans and grants. They also set up ways to track revenue per visit and appeals for denied telehealth and other services in an effort to create new models and budgets as COVID-19 progressed. The revenue cycle team focused on unpaid older accounts receivable.
Focused on the future
It’s an understatement to say that COVID-19 has forever changed the practice of medicine. The health care industry will need to transform.
For some time now, GI practices have discussed the consequence of disruptive innovation affecting utilization of endoscopic procedures. We were looking at technology that might eventually replace office personnel. No one was thinking about a pandemic that would cause nearly overnight closure of endoscopy suites and curtail the entire in-office administrative workforce. The coronavirus pandemic is likely to be the catalyst that brings many innovations into the mainstream.
We’ll most likely see a transition to the virtual medical office for those visits that don’t require a patient to see a physician in person. This will make online scheduling and registration, on-demand messaging, and remote patient monitoring and chronic care management necessities.
We may also see more rapid adoption of technologies that allow information from health trackers and wearables to be integrated into EMRs that easily follow the patient from physician to physician. Administrative support and patient assistance from remote locations will become the norm.
Inquiring about how practices plan for emergencies and how their leadership thinks about the future of gastroenterology is a great way to show that you’re thinking holistically about health care delivery and how medicine is practiced now and in the future.
So much has changed in the decades I’ve been practicing medicine and so much is yet to change. As early-career GI physicians who are familiar with new technologies, you are in a great position to lead the practices you join into the future of gastroenterology.
Dr. Weinstein is president and CEO of Capital Digestive Care and the immediate past president of the Digestive Health Physicians Association.
It was early March, and our second day of advocacy on Capitol Hill with the Digestive Health Physicians Association (DHPA) was cut short when congressional offices were shuttered because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Sitting with several of my GI physician colleagues from across the country, we knew that our practices, our patients, and our communities would be impacted by the coronavirus. None of us could have known the extent.
We also didn’t know in that moment that our advocacy work through DHPA would be one of the most important factors in ensuring that our practices were prepared to weather the pandemic. Our membership, legal counsel, and legislative lobbyists helped us remain informed about new legislation and regulations and ensured that we had much-needed access to government resources.
Just a few months into what is now the COVID-19 pandemic, independent GI practice leaders have learned a lot about how to strengthen our practices to respond to future crises – and what early-career GIs should look for in the practices they are considering.
First and foremost, practice leadership is key. One thing most successful GI practices have in common is that they hire really smart executives and administrative teams who excel at taking care of the business side of things so that physicians like me can do what we do best: treat patients.
Stay informed about state and federal policies
As a member of DHPA, Capital Digestive Care was well positioned to keep up to date on the government response to the coronavirus and the support it provided to small businesses and to health care providers.
Over the past 5 years, DHPA physician leaders have established strong relationships with our elected federal leaders. During our Capitol Hill visits in early March, we discussed the coronavirus in addition to our policy priorities.
The relationships we’ve built with policymakers have helped us educate them about how private practices were being affected and make the case that it was crucial to include private practices in health care stimulus packages.
Without this federal financial support, many medical groups may have had to close their doors – leaving a large gap in care once the pandemic subsides.
In addition to the federal government’s financial support, our policy advocacy efforts kept us informed about federal health agencies’ decisions on telehealth coverage. We were able to educate our physicians and staff about state and federal adjustments to telehealth rules for the pandemic, on the guidelines for elective procedures, on employee furlough and leave rules, as well as other congressional and state actions that would impact our practice.
You can’t be an independent physician without being open to learning about the business of health care and understanding how health policies affect your ability to practice medicine and care for people in your community. Every early-career physician who is looking to join a practice should ask how its leadership remains informed about health policy at the state and federal levels.
Make plans, be flexible
Implementing telehealth was critical in responding to the coronavirus pandemic. We were able to get up and running quickly on telemedicine because we had already invested in telehealth and had conducted a pilot of the platform with a smaller group of providers well before the pandemic hit.
In March, we were able to expand the telehealth platform to accommodate virtual visits by all of our providers. We also had to figure out how to shift our employees to telework, develop remote desktop and VPN solutions, and make sure that our scheduling and revenue cycle team members were fully operational.
The overriding goal was the safety of patients, staff, and our providers while continuing to provide medical care. Our inflammatory bowel disease patients needing visits to receive medication infusions took over an entire office so that there could be appropriate spacing and limited contacts with staff and other patients.
Our administrators knew early on that we needed a back-up plan and worked with physicians and providers doing telehealth visits to provide the flexibility to switch to Centers for Medicare & Medicaid–approved platforms (including Facetime) for those instances in which patients were uncomfortable using our main platform or when it was strained by bandwidth issues – a common challenge with any platform. Virtual check-in and check-out procedures were developed utilizing our usual office staff from remote locations.
For patients who had indications for gastroenterology procedures, we established a prioritization system, based on state guidelines, for those that were needed urgently or routinely as our endoscopy centers began to reopen. Safety measures were put into place including screening questionnaires, preprocedure COVID rt-PCT testing, personal protective equipment, and workflow changes to achieve social distancing.
As an early-career GI physician who is considering private practice, you’ll likely have several conversations with administrative leaders when deciding what practice to join. Ask about how the practice responded to COVID-19, and what processes it has in place to prepare for future emergencies.
During the early weeks of the pandemic, the CDC Board of Managers met two to three times per week. Task forces to discuss office operations and planning for ambulatory surgery center opening were established with participation by nearly every provider and manager. Communication between all providers and managers was important to decrease the obvious anxiety everyone was experiencing.
Old financial models may no longer work
Most practices develop budgets based on historical data. We quickly figured out that budgets from historical forecasts no longer worked and that we needed to understand the impact to budgets almost in real time.
We immediately looked to conserve cash and reduce expenses, requesting that our large vendors extend payment terms or provide a period of forbearance. We looked at everything from our EMR costs to lab supplies and everything in between.
Changing how we modeled our budgets and reducing costs made some of our hard decisions less difficult. While we had to furlough staff, our models for reducing physician compensation and lowering our costs allowed us to create a model for the return to work that included the use of paid time off and paid health care for our furloughed employees.
Our operations team also set up systems to gather information that was needed to apply for and report on federal loans and grants. They also set up ways to track revenue per visit and appeals for denied telehealth and other services in an effort to create new models and budgets as COVID-19 progressed. The revenue cycle team focused on unpaid older accounts receivable.
Focused on the future
It’s an understatement to say that COVID-19 has forever changed the practice of medicine. The health care industry will need to transform.
For some time now, GI practices have discussed the consequence of disruptive innovation affecting utilization of endoscopic procedures. We were looking at technology that might eventually replace office personnel. No one was thinking about a pandemic that would cause nearly overnight closure of endoscopy suites and curtail the entire in-office administrative workforce. The coronavirus pandemic is likely to be the catalyst that brings many innovations into the mainstream.
We’ll most likely see a transition to the virtual medical office for those visits that don’t require a patient to see a physician in person. This will make online scheduling and registration, on-demand messaging, and remote patient monitoring and chronic care management necessities.
We may also see more rapid adoption of technologies that allow information from health trackers and wearables to be integrated into EMRs that easily follow the patient from physician to physician. Administrative support and patient assistance from remote locations will become the norm.
Inquiring about how practices plan for emergencies and how their leadership thinks about the future of gastroenterology is a great way to show that you’re thinking holistically about health care delivery and how medicine is practiced now and in the future.
So much has changed in the decades I’ve been practicing medicine and so much is yet to change. As early-career GI physicians who are familiar with new technologies, you are in a great position to lead the practices you join into the future of gastroenterology.
Dr. Weinstein is president and CEO of Capital Digestive Care and the immediate past president of the Digestive Health Physicians Association.
It was early March, and our second day of advocacy on Capitol Hill with the Digestive Health Physicians Association (DHPA) was cut short when congressional offices were shuttered because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Sitting with several of my GI physician colleagues from across the country, we knew that our practices, our patients, and our communities would be impacted by the coronavirus. None of us could have known the extent.
We also didn’t know in that moment that our advocacy work through DHPA would be one of the most important factors in ensuring that our practices were prepared to weather the pandemic. Our membership, legal counsel, and legislative lobbyists helped us remain informed about new legislation and regulations and ensured that we had much-needed access to government resources.
Just a few months into what is now the COVID-19 pandemic, independent GI practice leaders have learned a lot about how to strengthen our practices to respond to future crises – and what early-career GIs should look for in the practices they are considering.
First and foremost, practice leadership is key. One thing most successful GI practices have in common is that they hire really smart executives and administrative teams who excel at taking care of the business side of things so that physicians like me can do what we do best: treat patients.
Stay informed about state and federal policies
As a member of DHPA, Capital Digestive Care was well positioned to keep up to date on the government response to the coronavirus and the support it provided to small businesses and to health care providers.
Over the past 5 years, DHPA physician leaders have established strong relationships with our elected federal leaders. During our Capitol Hill visits in early March, we discussed the coronavirus in addition to our policy priorities.
The relationships we’ve built with policymakers have helped us educate them about how private practices were being affected and make the case that it was crucial to include private practices in health care stimulus packages.
Without this federal financial support, many medical groups may have had to close their doors – leaving a large gap in care once the pandemic subsides.
In addition to the federal government’s financial support, our policy advocacy efforts kept us informed about federal health agencies’ decisions on telehealth coverage. We were able to educate our physicians and staff about state and federal adjustments to telehealth rules for the pandemic, on the guidelines for elective procedures, on employee furlough and leave rules, as well as other congressional and state actions that would impact our practice.
You can’t be an independent physician without being open to learning about the business of health care and understanding how health policies affect your ability to practice medicine and care for people in your community. Every early-career physician who is looking to join a practice should ask how its leadership remains informed about health policy at the state and federal levels.
Make plans, be flexible
Implementing telehealth was critical in responding to the coronavirus pandemic. We were able to get up and running quickly on telemedicine because we had already invested in telehealth and had conducted a pilot of the platform with a smaller group of providers well before the pandemic hit.
In March, we were able to expand the telehealth platform to accommodate virtual visits by all of our providers. We also had to figure out how to shift our employees to telework, develop remote desktop and VPN solutions, and make sure that our scheduling and revenue cycle team members were fully operational.
The overriding goal was the safety of patients, staff, and our providers while continuing to provide medical care. Our inflammatory bowel disease patients needing visits to receive medication infusions took over an entire office so that there could be appropriate spacing and limited contacts with staff and other patients.
Our administrators knew early on that we needed a back-up plan and worked with physicians and providers doing telehealth visits to provide the flexibility to switch to Centers for Medicare & Medicaid–approved platforms (including Facetime) for those instances in which patients were uncomfortable using our main platform or when it was strained by bandwidth issues – a common challenge with any platform. Virtual check-in and check-out procedures were developed utilizing our usual office staff from remote locations.
For patients who had indications for gastroenterology procedures, we established a prioritization system, based on state guidelines, for those that were needed urgently or routinely as our endoscopy centers began to reopen. Safety measures were put into place including screening questionnaires, preprocedure COVID rt-PCT testing, personal protective equipment, and workflow changes to achieve social distancing.
As an early-career GI physician who is considering private practice, you’ll likely have several conversations with administrative leaders when deciding what practice to join. Ask about how the practice responded to COVID-19, and what processes it has in place to prepare for future emergencies.
During the early weeks of the pandemic, the CDC Board of Managers met two to three times per week. Task forces to discuss office operations and planning for ambulatory surgery center opening were established with participation by nearly every provider and manager. Communication between all providers and managers was important to decrease the obvious anxiety everyone was experiencing.
Old financial models may no longer work
Most practices develop budgets based on historical data. We quickly figured out that budgets from historical forecasts no longer worked and that we needed to understand the impact to budgets almost in real time.
We immediately looked to conserve cash and reduce expenses, requesting that our large vendors extend payment terms or provide a period of forbearance. We looked at everything from our EMR costs to lab supplies and everything in between.
Changing how we modeled our budgets and reducing costs made some of our hard decisions less difficult. While we had to furlough staff, our models for reducing physician compensation and lowering our costs allowed us to create a model for the return to work that included the use of paid time off and paid health care for our furloughed employees.
Our operations team also set up systems to gather information that was needed to apply for and report on federal loans and grants. They also set up ways to track revenue per visit and appeals for denied telehealth and other services in an effort to create new models and budgets as COVID-19 progressed. The revenue cycle team focused on unpaid older accounts receivable.
Focused on the future
It’s an understatement to say that COVID-19 has forever changed the practice of medicine. The health care industry will need to transform.
For some time now, GI practices have discussed the consequence of disruptive innovation affecting utilization of endoscopic procedures. We were looking at technology that might eventually replace office personnel. No one was thinking about a pandemic that would cause nearly overnight closure of endoscopy suites and curtail the entire in-office administrative workforce. The coronavirus pandemic is likely to be the catalyst that brings many innovations into the mainstream.
We’ll most likely see a transition to the virtual medical office for those visits that don’t require a patient to see a physician in person. This will make online scheduling and registration, on-demand messaging, and remote patient monitoring and chronic care management necessities.
We may also see more rapid adoption of technologies that allow information from health trackers and wearables to be integrated into EMRs that easily follow the patient from physician to physician. Administrative support and patient assistance from remote locations will become the norm.
Inquiring about how practices plan for emergencies and how their leadership thinks about the future of gastroenterology is a great way to show that you’re thinking holistically about health care delivery and how medicine is practiced now and in the future.
So much has changed in the decades I’ve been practicing medicine and so much is yet to change. As early-career GI physicians who are familiar with new technologies, you are in a great position to lead the practices you join into the future of gastroenterology.
Dr. Weinstein is president and CEO of Capital Digestive Care and the immediate past president of the Digestive Health Physicians Association.
The pros and cons of pathology lab ownership: What early career GI doctors need to know
From colonoscopies to endoscopic ultrasound, gastroenterology is fundamentally a procedure-based specialty. Given that reality, making a decision to have as much control as possible over the entire process just makes sense for many GI practices.
Back in 2008, I was in charge of the process to develop a pathology lab at Arizona Digestive Health, a physician group with 26 locations throughout the state, as part of our decision to form a supergroup with eight ambulatory surgery centers. For us, having ambulatory surgery centers had been a game changer. We learned we could double our efficiency with procedures when we controlled the process from start to finish. We began to consider other processes – in this case pathology – that we could improve.
Prior to running our own pathology lab, doctors who read our slides were general pathologists who did not always understand the language of gastroenterology. We had results that came back by fax that were often cumbersome to read and did not always give us the information we needed in the way we needed it. Consistency was a problem. We knew we needed a change.
I cannot lie – setting up and running your own pathology lab is not always easy. But with the right factors in place, here are some benefits to consider when you are making a decision about joining a practice.
Quality, efficiency can lead to opportunity
Our lab has three GI fellowship–trained pathologists reading our slides. That means they are highly specialized and know exactly what we are looking for in a pathology report. We have a 24-hour turnaround for results. A courier service delivers biopsy specimens from our endoscopy centers to our path lab every day, and each morning our gastropathologists have a stack of pathology slides waiting for them. It’s added predictability and stability to the process, and we get the level of quality, specificity, and uniformity we need in a report.
The efficiencies are beneficial and it has given us more leverage in our negotiations with payers. We know what our costs are and have great quality metrics as well as read rates that we can provide. This signals to health plans that quality is a top priority for us.
We have also gained a reputational benefit with patients. Although much of the work is happening behind the scenes for our patients, they get results faster and a consistency with costs. It also allows us to easily access the slides of patients we have been seeing for years, giving us a richer data set and more confidence in our diagnosis.
Now that we have our own lab, we can look at our pathology data and conduct studies that will benefit all patients. For example, a few of our GI fellows were able to work with our pathologists to conduct a study on adenoma detection rates, exhausting a tissue block when no adenoma was found on initial review. We found a significant increase in adenoma detection using this method; we plan to publish results soon. The ability to conduct this kind of research is worth considering when early career gastroenterologists are selecting a practice to join.
And last but not least, having our own pathology lab acts as a unifying force for our group, which is spread out across 26 offices. When diagnoses are available and we get a call from our pathologist, we know to pick up the phone immediately.
What to consider before jumping in
Setting up our own pathology lab from the ground up was a learning process. We had enough patient volume for the move to make sense, so it is possible that smaller practices might not be able to make the investment if they have lower patient volume or cannot control their specimen flow. One option is to set up a technical lab and contract out for the slide reading. We felt it was important for our pathologists to also be our practice partners, and time has proven this to be a good decision for us.
We designed a lab with our work flow in mind, and it helped to have a pathologist on board from the beginning who knows gastroenterology. We even created our own lab information system with the help of a software engineer. It took a little bit over a year from conception to a functioning comprehensive lab.
Of course, there are regulatory factors to consider – the federal physician self-referral (Stark) law and the federal Anti-Markup Rule – come to mind. But we made sure to get a legal opinion that allows us to comply with the law. That’s something anyone who wants to make a move in this direction should do.
Looking back over the experience, I would not do anything differently. Yes, there are startup costs and a learning curve. But the quality we get from having our own pathology lab dedicated to GI and the efficiencies we have gained are well worth it.
Dr. Berggreen is the president of Arizona Digestive Health and chief strategy officer of the GI Alliance. He is also a board member of the Digestive Health Physicians Association. He received his doctorate at Louisiana State University, New Orleans. He is the former site director of the Good Samaritan GI Fellowship Program and named one of Phoenix Magazine’s “Top Docs.”
From colonoscopies to endoscopic ultrasound, gastroenterology is fundamentally a procedure-based specialty. Given that reality, making a decision to have as much control as possible over the entire process just makes sense for many GI practices.
Back in 2008, I was in charge of the process to develop a pathology lab at Arizona Digestive Health, a physician group with 26 locations throughout the state, as part of our decision to form a supergroup with eight ambulatory surgery centers. For us, having ambulatory surgery centers had been a game changer. We learned we could double our efficiency with procedures when we controlled the process from start to finish. We began to consider other processes – in this case pathology – that we could improve.
Prior to running our own pathology lab, doctors who read our slides were general pathologists who did not always understand the language of gastroenterology. We had results that came back by fax that were often cumbersome to read and did not always give us the information we needed in the way we needed it. Consistency was a problem. We knew we needed a change.
I cannot lie – setting up and running your own pathology lab is not always easy. But with the right factors in place, here are some benefits to consider when you are making a decision about joining a practice.
Quality, efficiency can lead to opportunity
Our lab has three GI fellowship–trained pathologists reading our slides. That means they are highly specialized and know exactly what we are looking for in a pathology report. We have a 24-hour turnaround for results. A courier service delivers biopsy specimens from our endoscopy centers to our path lab every day, and each morning our gastropathologists have a stack of pathology slides waiting for them. It’s added predictability and stability to the process, and we get the level of quality, specificity, and uniformity we need in a report.
The efficiencies are beneficial and it has given us more leverage in our negotiations with payers. We know what our costs are and have great quality metrics as well as read rates that we can provide. This signals to health plans that quality is a top priority for us.
We have also gained a reputational benefit with patients. Although much of the work is happening behind the scenes for our patients, they get results faster and a consistency with costs. It also allows us to easily access the slides of patients we have been seeing for years, giving us a richer data set and more confidence in our diagnosis.
Now that we have our own lab, we can look at our pathology data and conduct studies that will benefit all patients. For example, a few of our GI fellows were able to work with our pathologists to conduct a study on adenoma detection rates, exhausting a tissue block when no adenoma was found on initial review. We found a significant increase in adenoma detection using this method; we plan to publish results soon. The ability to conduct this kind of research is worth considering when early career gastroenterologists are selecting a practice to join.
And last but not least, having our own pathology lab acts as a unifying force for our group, which is spread out across 26 offices. When diagnoses are available and we get a call from our pathologist, we know to pick up the phone immediately.
What to consider before jumping in
Setting up our own pathology lab from the ground up was a learning process. We had enough patient volume for the move to make sense, so it is possible that smaller practices might not be able to make the investment if they have lower patient volume or cannot control their specimen flow. One option is to set up a technical lab and contract out for the slide reading. We felt it was important for our pathologists to also be our practice partners, and time has proven this to be a good decision for us.
We designed a lab with our work flow in mind, and it helped to have a pathologist on board from the beginning who knows gastroenterology. We even created our own lab information system with the help of a software engineer. It took a little bit over a year from conception to a functioning comprehensive lab.
Of course, there are regulatory factors to consider – the federal physician self-referral (Stark) law and the federal Anti-Markup Rule – come to mind. But we made sure to get a legal opinion that allows us to comply with the law. That’s something anyone who wants to make a move in this direction should do.
Looking back over the experience, I would not do anything differently. Yes, there are startup costs and a learning curve. But the quality we get from having our own pathology lab dedicated to GI and the efficiencies we have gained are well worth it.
Dr. Berggreen is the president of Arizona Digestive Health and chief strategy officer of the GI Alliance. He is also a board member of the Digestive Health Physicians Association. He received his doctorate at Louisiana State University, New Orleans. He is the former site director of the Good Samaritan GI Fellowship Program and named one of Phoenix Magazine’s “Top Docs.”
From colonoscopies to endoscopic ultrasound, gastroenterology is fundamentally a procedure-based specialty. Given that reality, making a decision to have as much control as possible over the entire process just makes sense for many GI practices.
Back in 2008, I was in charge of the process to develop a pathology lab at Arizona Digestive Health, a physician group with 26 locations throughout the state, as part of our decision to form a supergroup with eight ambulatory surgery centers. For us, having ambulatory surgery centers had been a game changer. We learned we could double our efficiency with procedures when we controlled the process from start to finish. We began to consider other processes – in this case pathology – that we could improve.
Prior to running our own pathology lab, doctors who read our slides were general pathologists who did not always understand the language of gastroenterology. We had results that came back by fax that were often cumbersome to read and did not always give us the information we needed in the way we needed it. Consistency was a problem. We knew we needed a change.
I cannot lie – setting up and running your own pathology lab is not always easy. But with the right factors in place, here are some benefits to consider when you are making a decision about joining a practice.
Quality, efficiency can lead to opportunity
Our lab has three GI fellowship–trained pathologists reading our slides. That means they are highly specialized and know exactly what we are looking for in a pathology report. We have a 24-hour turnaround for results. A courier service delivers biopsy specimens from our endoscopy centers to our path lab every day, and each morning our gastropathologists have a stack of pathology slides waiting for them. It’s added predictability and stability to the process, and we get the level of quality, specificity, and uniformity we need in a report.
The efficiencies are beneficial and it has given us more leverage in our negotiations with payers. We know what our costs are and have great quality metrics as well as read rates that we can provide. This signals to health plans that quality is a top priority for us.
We have also gained a reputational benefit with patients. Although much of the work is happening behind the scenes for our patients, they get results faster and a consistency with costs. It also allows us to easily access the slides of patients we have been seeing for years, giving us a richer data set and more confidence in our diagnosis.
Now that we have our own lab, we can look at our pathology data and conduct studies that will benefit all patients. For example, a few of our GI fellows were able to work with our pathologists to conduct a study on adenoma detection rates, exhausting a tissue block when no adenoma was found on initial review. We found a significant increase in adenoma detection using this method; we plan to publish results soon. The ability to conduct this kind of research is worth considering when early career gastroenterologists are selecting a practice to join.
And last but not least, having our own pathology lab acts as a unifying force for our group, which is spread out across 26 offices. When diagnoses are available and we get a call from our pathologist, we know to pick up the phone immediately.
What to consider before jumping in
Setting up our own pathology lab from the ground up was a learning process. We had enough patient volume for the move to make sense, so it is possible that smaller practices might not be able to make the investment if they have lower patient volume or cannot control their specimen flow. One option is to set up a technical lab and contract out for the slide reading. We felt it was important for our pathologists to also be our practice partners, and time has proven this to be a good decision for us.
We designed a lab with our work flow in mind, and it helped to have a pathologist on board from the beginning who knows gastroenterology. We even created our own lab information system with the help of a software engineer. It took a little bit over a year from conception to a functioning comprehensive lab.
Of course, there are regulatory factors to consider – the federal physician self-referral (Stark) law and the federal Anti-Markup Rule – come to mind. But we made sure to get a legal opinion that allows us to comply with the law. That’s something anyone who wants to make a move in this direction should do.
Looking back over the experience, I would not do anything differently. Yes, there are startup costs and a learning curve. But the quality we get from having our own pathology lab dedicated to GI and the efficiencies we have gained are well worth it.
Dr. Berggreen is the president of Arizona Digestive Health and chief strategy officer of the GI Alliance. He is also a board member of the Digestive Health Physicians Association. He received his doctorate at Louisiana State University, New Orleans. He is the former site director of the Good Samaritan GI Fellowship Program and named one of Phoenix Magazine’s “Top Docs.”
Ambulatory surgery centers 101: What new GIs need to know
Almost 20 years ago, I joined Digestive Disease Specialists in Oklahoma, where I am an owner in two ambulatory endoscopy centers (AECs). Through this experience, I’ve learned a thing or two about the advantages of these centers and what to consider when joining a practice that has ownership in an endoscopy center or an ambulatory surgery center (ASC).
ASCs – or in my case AECs – are highly specialized, modern health care facilities in which physicians provide safe, high-quality procedures to millions of Americans each year, including diagnostic and preventive procedures. ASCs and AECs allow us to provide a more convenient and cost-effective alternative to performing GI procedures in a hospital. As you can imagine, these facilities are a vital part of being an independent gastroenterologist.
Quality care at a lower cost
When looking into practices with ownership in surgery centers, quality of care is one of the most critical considerations. Each center must enter into an agreement with Medicare and meet its certification requirements, which are similar to those required for hospital outpatient departments. We also undergo accreditation by the Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Healthcare. And while not everyone participates in quality registries such as GIquic – which helps us define and refine our endoscopic outcomes – our AEC does because we put patient care first.
This focus on quality leads to better care. A 2016 study of Medicare claims in the Journal of Health Economics shows that ASCs and AECs, on average, provide higher-quality care for outpatient procedures than hospitals.1
We get into medicine because we care about patients and want to provide them with the best and most convenient care possible. Because we don’t have to operate in the context of a large hospital, we can be nimbler when it comes to patient needs. As is true in other areas, the more you specialize, the more effective and efficient you can become performing certain procedures. For instance, our practice is highly specialized in endoscopy. As a result, we can be highly efficient in the turnaround time in between patient procedures. This helps people get back to their daily lives as soon as possible, whereas patients may spend a lot more time waiting to have their procedure in the hospital setting.
Performing procedures in an ASC or AEC also helps us keep costs down, and we spend a lot of time educating policymakers about the role independent physicians play in lowering health care costs. According to a recent study in Health Affairs, hospital-based outpatient care prices grew at four times the rate of physician prices from 2007 to 2014.2 And the National Institute for Health Care Reform found that the average Medicare facility payment for a basic colonoscopy was more than twice as much in a hospital setting.3
The challenges and benefits of running an ASC or AEC
With consolidation of hospitals and insurance companies, operating an independent ASC or AEC has become more challenging. The players are bigger, providing more competition. Where we practice in Oklahoma, we are the only independent gastroenterologists. The way we have kept up is by diversifying the ancillary services we offer. This includes infusion center services, pathology, anesthesia, and research alongside our standard endoscopic and office/hospital-based practice.
As doctors, we are not typically trained on the business side of medicine, but when you own an ASC, you need to learn to be your own boss. You will need to understand the details of how the business operates, from relevant state and federal regulations to the supportive services that make the center run smoothly.
Gastroenterologists who are new to the field can and should ask questions of any practice they are considering joining about the buy-in process for ASCs and the path to becoming a partner. One of the things to consider is what kind of planning has gone into determining how many investors there are in the ASC. It is possible to have too many physician partners, but having too few could also present challenges. If there are too many physician owners, ownership interests could be diluted. On the flip side, if there aren’t many physician owners, it will be more expensive to buy in and there will be greater risk.
Another question to ask is if the practice partners with a hospital for its ASC or AEC. About one in four surgery centers have a hospital partner. This can be helpful with managed care contracting and concerns physicians may have about being excluded from having hospital privileges. Partnering with a hospital is not an indication of a successful center given there are still many surgery centers with hospital partners that are not run well or underperform.
While I have outlined some of the challenges of owning an ASC or AEC, physician ownership can be very attractive under the right circumstances. There are many benefits including having more control over your life. You get to set your own schedules and determine your patient load.
When physicians own the surgery center, we can control the schedule and the environment in the operating room. In a hospital, there is not much we can do if the operating room is not running efficiently. If our cases are bumped, the care of our patients is undermined. In our own surgery center, we can ensure that these things do not happen. We are able to provide our patients the best care possible.
When I look back over my time in our AEC, I wouldn’t change anything. Even though there may be challenges in running an AEC, I would advise young gastroenterologists to consider this path. Nothing worthwhile is easy, but the ability to provide the best care to our patients is its own reward.
References
1. Munnich E et al. J Health Economics, January 2018;57:147-67. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhealeco.2017.11.004.
2. Cooper Z et al. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2018.05424. Health Affairs 2019;38(2).
3. Reschovsky J et al. NIHCR Research Brief No. 16. http://nihcr.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Research_Brief_No._16.pdf. National Institute for Health Care Reform; June 2014.
Dr. Stokesberry is a practicing gastroenterologist at Digestive Disease Specialists in Oklahoma City and serves as an executive committee member of the Digestive Health Physicians Association.
Almost 20 years ago, I joined Digestive Disease Specialists in Oklahoma, where I am an owner in two ambulatory endoscopy centers (AECs). Through this experience, I’ve learned a thing or two about the advantages of these centers and what to consider when joining a practice that has ownership in an endoscopy center or an ambulatory surgery center (ASC).
ASCs – or in my case AECs – are highly specialized, modern health care facilities in which physicians provide safe, high-quality procedures to millions of Americans each year, including diagnostic and preventive procedures. ASCs and AECs allow us to provide a more convenient and cost-effective alternative to performing GI procedures in a hospital. As you can imagine, these facilities are a vital part of being an independent gastroenterologist.
Quality care at a lower cost
When looking into practices with ownership in surgery centers, quality of care is one of the most critical considerations. Each center must enter into an agreement with Medicare and meet its certification requirements, which are similar to those required for hospital outpatient departments. We also undergo accreditation by the Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Healthcare. And while not everyone participates in quality registries such as GIquic – which helps us define and refine our endoscopic outcomes – our AEC does because we put patient care first.
This focus on quality leads to better care. A 2016 study of Medicare claims in the Journal of Health Economics shows that ASCs and AECs, on average, provide higher-quality care for outpatient procedures than hospitals.1
We get into medicine because we care about patients and want to provide them with the best and most convenient care possible. Because we don’t have to operate in the context of a large hospital, we can be nimbler when it comes to patient needs. As is true in other areas, the more you specialize, the more effective and efficient you can become performing certain procedures. For instance, our practice is highly specialized in endoscopy. As a result, we can be highly efficient in the turnaround time in between patient procedures. This helps people get back to their daily lives as soon as possible, whereas patients may spend a lot more time waiting to have their procedure in the hospital setting.
Performing procedures in an ASC or AEC also helps us keep costs down, and we spend a lot of time educating policymakers about the role independent physicians play in lowering health care costs. According to a recent study in Health Affairs, hospital-based outpatient care prices grew at four times the rate of physician prices from 2007 to 2014.2 And the National Institute for Health Care Reform found that the average Medicare facility payment for a basic colonoscopy was more than twice as much in a hospital setting.3
The challenges and benefits of running an ASC or AEC
With consolidation of hospitals and insurance companies, operating an independent ASC or AEC has become more challenging. The players are bigger, providing more competition. Where we practice in Oklahoma, we are the only independent gastroenterologists. The way we have kept up is by diversifying the ancillary services we offer. This includes infusion center services, pathology, anesthesia, and research alongside our standard endoscopic and office/hospital-based practice.
As doctors, we are not typically trained on the business side of medicine, but when you own an ASC, you need to learn to be your own boss. You will need to understand the details of how the business operates, from relevant state and federal regulations to the supportive services that make the center run smoothly.
Gastroenterologists who are new to the field can and should ask questions of any practice they are considering joining about the buy-in process for ASCs and the path to becoming a partner. One of the things to consider is what kind of planning has gone into determining how many investors there are in the ASC. It is possible to have too many physician partners, but having too few could also present challenges. If there are too many physician owners, ownership interests could be diluted. On the flip side, if there aren’t many physician owners, it will be more expensive to buy in and there will be greater risk.
Another question to ask is if the practice partners with a hospital for its ASC or AEC. About one in four surgery centers have a hospital partner. This can be helpful with managed care contracting and concerns physicians may have about being excluded from having hospital privileges. Partnering with a hospital is not an indication of a successful center given there are still many surgery centers with hospital partners that are not run well or underperform.
While I have outlined some of the challenges of owning an ASC or AEC, physician ownership can be very attractive under the right circumstances. There are many benefits including having more control over your life. You get to set your own schedules and determine your patient load.
When physicians own the surgery center, we can control the schedule and the environment in the operating room. In a hospital, there is not much we can do if the operating room is not running efficiently. If our cases are bumped, the care of our patients is undermined. In our own surgery center, we can ensure that these things do not happen. We are able to provide our patients the best care possible.
When I look back over my time in our AEC, I wouldn’t change anything. Even though there may be challenges in running an AEC, I would advise young gastroenterologists to consider this path. Nothing worthwhile is easy, but the ability to provide the best care to our patients is its own reward.
References
1. Munnich E et al. J Health Economics, January 2018;57:147-67. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhealeco.2017.11.004.
2. Cooper Z et al. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2018.05424. Health Affairs 2019;38(2).
3. Reschovsky J et al. NIHCR Research Brief No. 16. http://nihcr.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Research_Brief_No._16.pdf. National Institute for Health Care Reform; June 2014.
Dr. Stokesberry is a practicing gastroenterologist at Digestive Disease Specialists in Oklahoma City and serves as an executive committee member of the Digestive Health Physicians Association.
Almost 20 years ago, I joined Digestive Disease Specialists in Oklahoma, where I am an owner in two ambulatory endoscopy centers (AECs). Through this experience, I’ve learned a thing or two about the advantages of these centers and what to consider when joining a practice that has ownership in an endoscopy center or an ambulatory surgery center (ASC).
ASCs – or in my case AECs – are highly specialized, modern health care facilities in which physicians provide safe, high-quality procedures to millions of Americans each year, including diagnostic and preventive procedures. ASCs and AECs allow us to provide a more convenient and cost-effective alternative to performing GI procedures in a hospital. As you can imagine, these facilities are a vital part of being an independent gastroenterologist.
Quality care at a lower cost
When looking into practices with ownership in surgery centers, quality of care is one of the most critical considerations. Each center must enter into an agreement with Medicare and meet its certification requirements, which are similar to those required for hospital outpatient departments. We also undergo accreditation by the Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Healthcare. And while not everyone participates in quality registries such as GIquic – which helps us define and refine our endoscopic outcomes – our AEC does because we put patient care first.
This focus on quality leads to better care. A 2016 study of Medicare claims in the Journal of Health Economics shows that ASCs and AECs, on average, provide higher-quality care for outpatient procedures than hospitals.1
We get into medicine because we care about patients and want to provide them with the best and most convenient care possible. Because we don’t have to operate in the context of a large hospital, we can be nimbler when it comes to patient needs. As is true in other areas, the more you specialize, the more effective and efficient you can become performing certain procedures. For instance, our practice is highly specialized in endoscopy. As a result, we can be highly efficient in the turnaround time in between patient procedures. This helps people get back to their daily lives as soon as possible, whereas patients may spend a lot more time waiting to have their procedure in the hospital setting.
Performing procedures in an ASC or AEC also helps us keep costs down, and we spend a lot of time educating policymakers about the role independent physicians play in lowering health care costs. According to a recent study in Health Affairs, hospital-based outpatient care prices grew at four times the rate of physician prices from 2007 to 2014.2 And the National Institute for Health Care Reform found that the average Medicare facility payment for a basic colonoscopy was more than twice as much in a hospital setting.3
The challenges and benefits of running an ASC or AEC
With consolidation of hospitals and insurance companies, operating an independent ASC or AEC has become more challenging. The players are bigger, providing more competition. Where we practice in Oklahoma, we are the only independent gastroenterologists. The way we have kept up is by diversifying the ancillary services we offer. This includes infusion center services, pathology, anesthesia, and research alongside our standard endoscopic and office/hospital-based practice.
As doctors, we are not typically trained on the business side of medicine, but when you own an ASC, you need to learn to be your own boss. You will need to understand the details of how the business operates, from relevant state and federal regulations to the supportive services that make the center run smoothly.
Gastroenterologists who are new to the field can and should ask questions of any practice they are considering joining about the buy-in process for ASCs and the path to becoming a partner. One of the things to consider is what kind of planning has gone into determining how many investors there are in the ASC. It is possible to have too many physician partners, but having too few could also present challenges. If there are too many physician owners, ownership interests could be diluted. On the flip side, if there aren’t many physician owners, it will be more expensive to buy in and there will be greater risk.
Another question to ask is if the practice partners with a hospital for its ASC or AEC. About one in four surgery centers have a hospital partner. This can be helpful with managed care contracting and concerns physicians may have about being excluded from having hospital privileges. Partnering with a hospital is not an indication of a successful center given there are still many surgery centers with hospital partners that are not run well or underperform.
While I have outlined some of the challenges of owning an ASC or AEC, physician ownership can be very attractive under the right circumstances. There are many benefits including having more control over your life. You get to set your own schedules and determine your patient load.
When physicians own the surgery center, we can control the schedule and the environment in the operating room. In a hospital, there is not much we can do if the operating room is not running efficiently. If our cases are bumped, the care of our patients is undermined. In our own surgery center, we can ensure that these things do not happen. We are able to provide our patients the best care possible.
When I look back over my time in our AEC, I wouldn’t change anything. Even though there may be challenges in running an AEC, I would advise young gastroenterologists to consider this path. Nothing worthwhile is easy, but the ability to provide the best care to our patients is its own reward.
References
1. Munnich E et al. J Health Economics, January 2018;57:147-67. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhealeco.2017.11.004.
2. Cooper Z et al. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2018.05424. Health Affairs 2019;38(2).
3. Reschovsky J et al. NIHCR Research Brief No. 16. http://nihcr.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Research_Brief_No._16.pdf. National Institute for Health Care Reform; June 2014.
Dr. Stokesberry is a practicing gastroenterologist at Digestive Disease Specialists in Oklahoma City and serves as an executive committee member of the Digestive Health Physicians Association.
Clinical research in private practice? It can be done, and here’s how
Not every physician coming out of medical school wants to go down the path of conducting clinical research. But for those who do, the decision is a rewarding one that can make a real difference in patients’ lives.
I took a nontraditional route to get to my current role as the director of clinical research and education at the largest gastroenterology practice in the United States. I had a business degree coming out of college and worked for years in the business world prior to going to medical school. After graduation, I got an offer to join the pharmaceutical industry in medical affairs. There, I focused on inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), where my role was to share high-level scientific data and liaise with IBD disease state experts. Part of the role was working internally with clinical operations and externally with sites conducting research throughout the United States. In the next 6 years, I had the opportunity to observe how research was run in both the academic and community practice settings, noting those characteristics that allowed some to succeed and far more to stagnate or fail.
In 2014, I joined Texas Digestive Disease Consultants with the goal to ramp up the practice’s clinical research arm and create a department expressly for that purpose. To date, the department has become incredibly successful and ultimately sustainable. If you’re considering joining a practice based on its clinical research program or starting one in your current practice, here is what I’ve learned along the way:
Know the benefit to patients
You have to decide to conduct clinical research because of its benefit to the patient, not because you see it as an alternative revenue stream. It will never be sustainable if viewed as a profit center. Clinical research offers therapeutic advancements that will not be available to most for the next 5-10 years. Additionally, patients do not need insurance in order to participate in a study. The sponsor covers all study visits, procedures, and therapeutics.
Know the value to the practice
Having a clinical trials program brings both direct and indirect enterprise value to the practice. It may come in the form of referrals from other practices that don’t have the same capabilities. Patients may view your practice differently, knowing that it has the added value of research. There is a halo effect from having clinical trials capabilities in how you are viewed by patients and other physicians in the community.
Get the right people in place
First, you will need an enthusiastic primary investigator who can take a bit of time from practice to conduct clinical trials. But just as importantly, you need a knowledgeable clinical research coordinator. Without an effective coordinator, the program is doomed. A good coordinator should be well rounded in all aspects of research (e.g., regulatory, patient recruitment, quality assurance, contracts, budgets, running labs, conducting patient visits) and able to deal with the day-to-day intricacies of running clinical trials, which will allow a doctor to take care of the existing practice. They should also be versed in the requisite equipment (e.g., locking refrigerator, freezer, and ambient cabinet, temperature monitoring devices, EKG machine, and centrifuge) necessary to run a clinical study.
Know how to recruit patients
The database at Texas Digestive Disease Consultants/GI Alliance (TDDC/GIA) is vast, which makes identification of patients who may qualify for a trial an easier task. Many practices will have an electronic medical record that will aid in identification, but if that is not the case at your practice, there are a number of ways you can go about this. First, talk to physicians in your practice and in other practices – internists, family physicians, and other gastroenterologists come to mind – about what you can offer. Send a letter or an email out to physicians in the community with the inclusion/exclusion criteria for your study, and always direct them to https://clinicaltrials.gov/ for additional information. Patient advocacy organizations are another good source of referrals for clinical trials. And of course, pharmaceutical companies have recruitment services that they use and can help steer patients your way.
Understand the ethics
There are numerous ethical and legal considerations when it comes to running clinical trials. The principles of Good Clinical Practice (GCP) and Human Subject Protection (HSP) guide the conduct of clinical trials in the United States. Understanding the concepts and regulations around caring for patients in trials is not only “good practice,” it’s a necessity. There are free Good Clinical Practice training courses available, which are required every few years for everyone conducting clinical research. These courses are quite lengthy (3-6 hours), but provide a great overview of the Food and Drug Administration regulations, ethical considerations, and other advice on successfully operating a clinical trials program. Again, a capable clinical research coordinator will help guide you here.
Adopt standard operating procedures
Every clinical trials sponsor will require standard operating procedures for such facets of research as informed consent, reporting requirements, and safety monitoring. Here again, a seasoned clinical trials coordinator can put you on the right path. You may choose to purchase standardized templates or work with another group that already has them and would be willing to share.
Be smart about spending
While this may depend on the scale you want to grow your research, at TDDC/GIA we knew we wanted to build a sustainable program. We invested a lot of time and money into our infrastructure, as well as adopting a robust Clinical Trials Management System (CTMS). A CTMS system will provide the ability to measure productivity, finances, schedule patient visits, and pay patient stipends. Some systems even automate the regulatory process (E-Regulatory) or source process (E-source), which can cut down on the paper burden on a site.
Seek mentors
Look for someone to emulate who is already established in operating a clinical research program in private practice. Reach out to the practices or physicians that are already doing this work and doing it well. For physicians who are just starting out or still in training, look for opportunities to publish or be involved with the clinical trials program at your institution.
Contacts in the pharmaceutical industry are very important to getting a new program off the ground. Ask the pharma sales representatives who visit your clinic to put you in touch with their medical science liaison (MSL). The MSL can get you information about the clinical trials their company is currently running and those they have in the pipeline.
Dr. Chris Fourment, director of clinical research and education, Texas Digestive Disease Consultants/GI Alliance.
Not every physician coming out of medical school wants to go down the path of conducting clinical research. But for those who do, the decision is a rewarding one that can make a real difference in patients’ lives.
I took a nontraditional route to get to my current role as the director of clinical research and education at the largest gastroenterology practice in the United States. I had a business degree coming out of college and worked for years in the business world prior to going to medical school. After graduation, I got an offer to join the pharmaceutical industry in medical affairs. There, I focused on inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), where my role was to share high-level scientific data and liaise with IBD disease state experts. Part of the role was working internally with clinical operations and externally with sites conducting research throughout the United States. In the next 6 years, I had the opportunity to observe how research was run in both the academic and community practice settings, noting those characteristics that allowed some to succeed and far more to stagnate or fail.
In 2014, I joined Texas Digestive Disease Consultants with the goal to ramp up the practice’s clinical research arm and create a department expressly for that purpose. To date, the department has become incredibly successful and ultimately sustainable. If you’re considering joining a practice based on its clinical research program or starting one in your current practice, here is what I’ve learned along the way:
Know the benefit to patients
You have to decide to conduct clinical research because of its benefit to the patient, not because you see it as an alternative revenue stream. It will never be sustainable if viewed as a profit center. Clinical research offers therapeutic advancements that will not be available to most for the next 5-10 years. Additionally, patients do not need insurance in order to participate in a study. The sponsor covers all study visits, procedures, and therapeutics.
Know the value to the practice
Having a clinical trials program brings both direct and indirect enterprise value to the practice. It may come in the form of referrals from other practices that don’t have the same capabilities. Patients may view your practice differently, knowing that it has the added value of research. There is a halo effect from having clinical trials capabilities in how you are viewed by patients and other physicians in the community.
Get the right people in place
First, you will need an enthusiastic primary investigator who can take a bit of time from practice to conduct clinical trials. But just as importantly, you need a knowledgeable clinical research coordinator. Without an effective coordinator, the program is doomed. A good coordinator should be well rounded in all aspects of research (e.g., regulatory, patient recruitment, quality assurance, contracts, budgets, running labs, conducting patient visits) and able to deal with the day-to-day intricacies of running clinical trials, which will allow a doctor to take care of the existing practice. They should also be versed in the requisite equipment (e.g., locking refrigerator, freezer, and ambient cabinet, temperature monitoring devices, EKG machine, and centrifuge) necessary to run a clinical study.
Know how to recruit patients
The database at Texas Digestive Disease Consultants/GI Alliance (TDDC/GIA) is vast, which makes identification of patients who may qualify for a trial an easier task. Many practices will have an electronic medical record that will aid in identification, but if that is not the case at your practice, there are a number of ways you can go about this. First, talk to physicians in your practice and in other practices – internists, family physicians, and other gastroenterologists come to mind – about what you can offer. Send a letter or an email out to physicians in the community with the inclusion/exclusion criteria for your study, and always direct them to https://clinicaltrials.gov/ for additional information. Patient advocacy organizations are another good source of referrals for clinical trials. And of course, pharmaceutical companies have recruitment services that they use and can help steer patients your way.
Understand the ethics
There are numerous ethical and legal considerations when it comes to running clinical trials. The principles of Good Clinical Practice (GCP) and Human Subject Protection (HSP) guide the conduct of clinical trials in the United States. Understanding the concepts and regulations around caring for patients in trials is not only “good practice,” it’s a necessity. There are free Good Clinical Practice training courses available, which are required every few years for everyone conducting clinical research. These courses are quite lengthy (3-6 hours), but provide a great overview of the Food and Drug Administration regulations, ethical considerations, and other advice on successfully operating a clinical trials program. Again, a capable clinical research coordinator will help guide you here.
Adopt standard operating procedures
Every clinical trials sponsor will require standard operating procedures for such facets of research as informed consent, reporting requirements, and safety monitoring. Here again, a seasoned clinical trials coordinator can put you on the right path. You may choose to purchase standardized templates or work with another group that already has them and would be willing to share.
Be smart about spending
While this may depend on the scale you want to grow your research, at TDDC/GIA we knew we wanted to build a sustainable program. We invested a lot of time and money into our infrastructure, as well as adopting a robust Clinical Trials Management System (CTMS). A CTMS system will provide the ability to measure productivity, finances, schedule patient visits, and pay patient stipends. Some systems even automate the regulatory process (E-Regulatory) or source process (E-source), which can cut down on the paper burden on a site.
Seek mentors
Look for someone to emulate who is already established in operating a clinical research program in private practice. Reach out to the practices or physicians that are already doing this work and doing it well. For physicians who are just starting out or still in training, look for opportunities to publish or be involved with the clinical trials program at your institution.
Contacts in the pharmaceutical industry are very important to getting a new program off the ground. Ask the pharma sales representatives who visit your clinic to put you in touch with their medical science liaison (MSL). The MSL can get you information about the clinical trials their company is currently running and those they have in the pipeline.
Dr. Chris Fourment, director of clinical research and education, Texas Digestive Disease Consultants/GI Alliance.
Not every physician coming out of medical school wants to go down the path of conducting clinical research. But for those who do, the decision is a rewarding one that can make a real difference in patients’ lives.
I took a nontraditional route to get to my current role as the director of clinical research and education at the largest gastroenterology practice in the United States. I had a business degree coming out of college and worked for years in the business world prior to going to medical school. After graduation, I got an offer to join the pharmaceutical industry in medical affairs. There, I focused on inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), where my role was to share high-level scientific data and liaise with IBD disease state experts. Part of the role was working internally with clinical operations and externally with sites conducting research throughout the United States. In the next 6 years, I had the opportunity to observe how research was run in both the academic and community practice settings, noting those characteristics that allowed some to succeed and far more to stagnate or fail.
In 2014, I joined Texas Digestive Disease Consultants with the goal to ramp up the practice’s clinical research arm and create a department expressly for that purpose. To date, the department has become incredibly successful and ultimately sustainable. If you’re considering joining a practice based on its clinical research program or starting one in your current practice, here is what I’ve learned along the way:
Know the benefit to patients
You have to decide to conduct clinical research because of its benefit to the patient, not because you see it as an alternative revenue stream. It will never be sustainable if viewed as a profit center. Clinical research offers therapeutic advancements that will not be available to most for the next 5-10 years. Additionally, patients do not need insurance in order to participate in a study. The sponsor covers all study visits, procedures, and therapeutics.
Know the value to the practice
Having a clinical trials program brings both direct and indirect enterprise value to the practice. It may come in the form of referrals from other practices that don’t have the same capabilities. Patients may view your practice differently, knowing that it has the added value of research. There is a halo effect from having clinical trials capabilities in how you are viewed by patients and other physicians in the community.
Get the right people in place
First, you will need an enthusiastic primary investigator who can take a bit of time from practice to conduct clinical trials. But just as importantly, you need a knowledgeable clinical research coordinator. Without an effective coordinator, the program is doomed. A good coordinator should be well rounded in all aspects of research (e.g., regulatory, patient recruitment, quality assurance, contracts, budgets, running labs, conducting patient visits) and able to deal with the day-to-day intricacies of running clinical trials, which will allow a doctor to take care of the existing practice. They should also be versed in the requisite equipment (e.g., locking refrigerator, freezer, and ambient cabinet, temperature monitoring devices, EKG machine, and centrifuge) necessary to run a clinical study.
Know how to recruit patients
The database at Texas Digestive Disease Consultants/GI Alliance (TDDC/GIA) is vast, which makes identification of patients who may qualify for a trial an easier task. Many practices will have an electronic medical record that will aid in identification, but if that is not the case at your practice, there are a number of ways you can go about this. First, talk to physicians in your practice and in other practices – internists, family physicians, and other gastroenterologists come to mind – about what you can offer. Send a letter or an email out to physicians in the community with the inclusion/exclusion criteria for your study, and always direct them to https://clinicaltrials.gov/ for additional information. Patient advocacy organizations are another good source of referrals for clinical trials. And of course, pharmaceutical companies have recruitment services that they use and can help steer patients your way.
Understand the ethics
There are numerous ethical and legal considerations when it comes to running clinical trials. The principles of Good Clinical Practice (GCP) and Human Subject Protection (HSP) guide the conduct of clinical trials in the United States. Understanding the concepts and regulations around caring for patients in trials is not only “good practice,” it’s a necessity. There are free Good Clinical Practice training courses available, which are required every few years for everyone conducting clinical research. These courses are quite lengthy (3-6 hours), but provide a great overview of the Food and Drug Administration regulations, ethical considerations, and other advice on successfully operating a clinical trials program. Again, a capable clinical research coordinator will help guide you here.
Adopt standard operating procedures
Every clinical trials sponsor will require standard operating procedures for such facets of research as informed consent, reporting requirements, and safety monitoring. Here again, a seasoned clinical trials coordinator can put you on the right path. You may choose to purchase standardized templates or work with another group that already has them and would be willing to share.
Be smart about spending
While this may depend on the scale you want to grow your research, at TDDC/GIA we knew we wanted to build a sustainable program. We invested a lot of time and money into our infrastructure, as well as adopting a robust Clinical Trials Management System (CTMS). A CTMS system will provide the ability to measure productivity, finances, schedule patient visits, and pay patient stipends. Some systems even automate the regulatory process (E-Regulatory) or source process (E-source), which can cut down on the paper burden on a site.
Seek mentors
Look for someone to emulate who is already established in operating a clinical research program in private practice. Reach out to the practices or physicians that are already doing this work and doing it well. For physicians who are just starting out or still in training, look for opportunities to publish or be involved with the clinical trials program at your institution.
Contacts in the pharmaceutical industry are very important to getting a new program off the ground. Ask the pharma sales representatives who visit your clinic to put you in touch with their medical science liaison (MSL). The MSL can get you information about the clinical trials their company is currently running and those they have in the pipeline.
Dr. Chris Fourment, director of clinical research and education, Texas Digestive Disease Consultants/GI Alliance.
Building an effective community gastroenterology practice
During my medical training and fellowship, I often heard that my education was not preparing me for the real world. After 3 years of internal medicine training with limited exposure to the outpatient arena and 3-4 years of specialty gastroenterology, hepatology, and advanced procedure training, you’ve probably heard the same thing.
Most gastroenterologists who enter private practice have felt this way early on, and our experiences can help you navigate some of the major factors that influence clinical practice to build a thriving career in gastroenterology.Conduct research on referrals
Once you’ve decided to join a practice, do some research about local dynamics between large hospital systems and private practice. Community clinical practice is unique and varies by region, location, and how the practice is set up. GIs working in rural, low-access areas face different challenges than those working in urban areas near major health care systems. In rural, low-access areas, some physicians have long wait lists for office appointments and procedures.
In urban settings, there may be a larger population of patients but more competition from hospital systems and other practices. In this case, you’ll have to figure out where most of the referrals come from and why – is it the group’s overall reputation or are there physicians in the practice with a highly needed specialty?
Determine if your specialty training can be a differentiator in your market. If you are multilingual and there is a large patient population that speaks the language(s) in which you are fluent, this can be a great way to bring new patients into a practice. This is especially true if there aren’t many (or any) physicians in the practice who are multilingual.
Meet with local physicians in health care systems. Make a connection with hospitalists, referring physicians, ED physicians, advanced practitioners, and surgeons while covering inpatient service. Volunteer for teaching activities – including for nursing staff, who are a great referral source.
Figure out what opportunities exist to have direct interactions with patients, such as health fairs. If possible, it might be smart to invest in marketing directly to patients in your community as well. Leverage opportunities provided by awareness months – such as providing patients with information about cancer screening – to establish a referral basis.
Medical practice is complex and at times can be confusing until you’ve practiced in a given location for some time. Look internally to learn about the community. It’s always a good idea to learn from those who have been practicing in the community for a long time. Don’t hesitate to ask questions and make suggestions, even if they seem naive. Develop relationships with staff members and gain their trust. Establishing a clear understanding of your specialty with your colleagues and staff also can be a good way to find referrals.
Learn the internal process
Schedules during early months are usually filled with urgent patients. Make yourself available for overflow referrals to other established physicians within the practice and for hospital discharge follow-ups. Reading through the charts of these patients can help you understand the various styles of other doctors and can help you familiarize yourself with referring physicians.
This also will help to clarify the process of how a patient moves through the system – from the time patients call the office to when they check out. This includes navigating through procedures, results reporting, and the recall system. While it will be hard to master all aspects of a practice right away, processes within practices are well established, and it is important for you to have a good understanding of how they function.
Focus on patient care and satisfaction
Learning internal processes also can be useful in increasing patient satisfaction, an important quality outcome indicator. As you’re starting out, keep the following things in mind that can help put your patients at ease and increase satisfaction.
- Understand how to communicate what a patient should expect when being seen. Being at ease with the process helps garner trust and confidence.
- Call patients the next day to check on their symptoms.
- Relay results personally. Make connections with family member(s).
- Remember that cultural competency is important. Do everything you can to ensure you’re meeting the social, cultural, and linguistic needs of patients in your community.
- Above all – continue to provide personalized and thorough care. Word of mouth is the best form of referral and is time tested.
Continue to grow
As you begin to understand the dynamics of local practice, it’s important to establish where you fit into the practice and start differentiating your expertise. Here are some ideas and suggestions for how you can continue to expand your patient base.
- Differentiate and establish a subspecialty within your practice: Motility, inflammatory bowel disease, Clostridium difficile/fecal microbiota transplantation, liver diseases, Celiac disease, and medical weight-loss programs are just a few.
- Establish connections with local medical societies as well as hospital and state committees. This is a great way to connect with other physicians of various specialties. If you have a specialty unique to the area, it may help establish a clear referral line.
- Establish a consistent conversation with referring physicians – get to know them and keep direct lines of communication, such as having their cell phone numbers.
- Look for public speaking engagements that reach patients directly. These are organized mostly through patient-based organization and foundations.
- Increase your reach through the local media and through social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter.
At this point, you should have plenty of patients to keep you busy, which could lead to other challenges in managing your various responsibilities and obligations. A key factor at this stage to help reduce stress is to lean on the effective and efficient support system your practice should have in place. Educating medical assistants or nurses on the most common GI diseases and conditions can help reduce the time involved in communicating results. Practice management software and patient portals can help create efficiencies to handle the increasing number of patient visits.
Remember, creating a referral process and patient base as a new gastroenterologist doesn’t have to be daunting. If you follow these tips, you’ll be on your way to establishing yourself within the community. No doubt you will have the same success as many physicians in my group and in the groups of my colleagues in the Digestive Health Physicians Association. And once you’re established, it will be your turn to help the next generation of physicians who want to enter private practice and thrive – so that independent community GI care remains strong well into the future.
Dr. Alaparthi is the director of committee operations at the Gastroenterology Center of Connecticut and serves as chair of the communications committee for the Digestive Health Physicians Association.
During my medical training and fellowship, I often heard that my education was not preparing me for the real world. After 3 years of internal medicine training with limited exposure to the outpatient arena and 3-4 years of specialty gastroenterology, hepatology, and advanced procedure training, you’ve probably heard the same thing.
Most gastroenterologists who enter private practice have felt this way early on, and our experiences can help you navigate some of the major factors that influence clinical practice to build a thriving career in gastroenterology.Conduct research on referrals
Once you’ve decided to join a practice, do some research about local dynamics between large hospital systems and private practice. Community clinical practice is unique and varies by region, location, and how the practice is set up. GIs working in rural, low-access areas face different challenges than those working in urban areas near major health care systems. In rural, low-access areas, some physicians have long wait lists for office appointments and procedures.
In urban settings, there may be a larger population of patients but more competition from hospital systems and other practices. In this case, you’ll have to figure out where most of the referrals come from and why – is it the group’s overall reputation or are there physicians in the practice with a highly needed specialty?
Determine if your specialty training can be a differentiator in your market. If you are multilingual and there is a large patient population that speaks the language(s) in which you are fluent, this can be a great way to bring new patients into a practice. This is especially true if there aren’t many (or any) physicians in the practice who are multilingual.
Meet with local physicians in health care systems. Make a connection with hospitalists, referring physicians, ED physicians, advanced practitioners, and surgeons while covering inpatient service. Volunteer for teaching activities – including for nursing staff, who are a great referral source.
Figure out what opportunities exist to have direct interactions with patients, such as health fairs. If possible, it might be smart to invest in marketing directly to patients in your community as well. Leverage opportunities provided by awareness months – such as providing patients with information about cancer screening – to establish a referral basis.
Medical practice is complex and at times can be confusing until you’ve practiced in a given location for some time. Look internally to learn about the community. It’s always a good idea to learn from those who have been practicing in the community for a long time. Don’t hesitate to ask questions and make suggestions, even if they seem naive. Develop relationships with staff members and gain their trust. Establishing a clear understanding of your specialty with your colleagues and staff also can be a good way to find referrals.
Learn the internal process
Schedules during early months are usually filled with urgent patients. Make yourself available for overflow referrals to other established physicians within the practice and for hospital discharge follow-ups. Reading through the charts of these patients can help you understand the various styles of other doctors and can help you familiarize yourself with referring physicians.
This also will help to clarify the process of how a patient moves through the system – from the time patients call the office to when they check out. This includes navigating through procedures, results reporting, and the recall system. While it will be hard to master all aspects of a practice right away, processes within practices are well established, and it is important for you to have a good understanding of how they function.
Focus on patient care and satisfaction
Learning internal processes also can be useful in increasing patient satisfaction, an important quality outcome indicator. As you’re starting out, keep the following things in mind that can help put your patients at ease and increase satisfaction.
- Understand how to communicate what a patient should expect when being seen. Being at ease with the process helps garner trust and confidence.
- Call patients the next day to check on their symptoms.
- Relay results personally. Make connections with family member(s).
- Remember that cultural competency is important. Do everything you can to ensure you’re meeting the social, cultural, and linguistic needs of patients in your community.
- Above all – continue to provide personalized and thorough care. Word of mouth is the best form of referral and is time tested.
Continue to grow
As you begin to understand the dynamics of local practice, it’s important to establish where you fit into the practice and start differentiating your expertise. Here are some ideas and suggestions for how you can continue to expand your patient base.
- Differentiate and establish a subspecialty within your practice: Motility, inflammatory bowel disease, Clostridium difficile/fecal microbiota transplantation, liver diseases, Celiac disease, and medical weight-loss programs are just a few.
- Establish connections with local medical societies as well as hospital and state committees. This is a great way to connect with other physicians of various specialties. If you have a specialty unique to the area, it may help establish a clear referral line.
- Establish a consistent conversation with referring physicians – get to know them and keep direct lines of communication, such as having their cell phone numbers.
- Look for public speaking engagements that reach patients directly. These are organized mostly through patient-based organization and foundations.
- Increase your reach through the local media and through social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter.
At this point, you should have plenty of patients to keep you busy, which could lead to other challenges in managing your various responsibilities and obligations. A key factor at this stage to help reduce stress is to lean on the effective and efficient support system your practice should have in place. Educating medical assistants or nurses on the most common GI diseases and conditions can help reduce the time involved in communicating results. Practice management software and patient portals can help create efficiencies to handle the increasing number of patient visits.
Remember, creating a referral process and patient base as a new gastroenterologist doesn’t have to be daunting. If you follow these tips, you’ll be on your way to establishing yourself within the community. No doubt you will have the same success as many physicians in my group and in the groups of my colleagues in the Digestive Health Physicians Association. And once you’re established, it will be your turn to help the next generation of physicians who want to enter private practice and thrive – so that independent community GI care remains strong well into the future.
Dr. Alaparthi is the director of committee operations at the Gastroenterology Center of Connecticut and serves as chair of the communications committee for the Digestive Health Physicians Association.
During my medical training and fellowship, I often heard that my education was not preparing me for the real world. After 3 years of internal medicine training with limited exposure to the outpatient arena and 3-4 years of specialty gastroenterology, hepatology, and advanced procedure training, you’ve probably heard the same thing.
Most gastroenterologists who enter private practice have felt this way early on, and our experiences can help you navigate some of the major factors that influence clinical practice to build a thriving career in gastroenterology.Conduct research on referrals
Once you’ve decided to join a practice, do some research about local dynamics between large hospital systems and private practice. Community clinical practice is unique and varies by region, location, and how the practice is set up. GIs working in rural, low-access areas face different challenges than those working in urban areas near major health care systems. In rural, low-access areas, some physicians have long wait lists for office appointments and procedures.
In urban settings, there may be a larger population of patients but more competition from hospital systems and other practices. In this case, you’ll have to figure out where most of the referrals come from and why – is it the group’s overall reputation or are there physicians in the practice with a highly needed specialty?
Determine if your specialty training can be a differentiator in your market. If you are multilingual and there is a large patient population that speaks the language(s) in which you are fluent, this can be a great way to bring new patients into a practice. This is especially true if there aren’t many (or any) physicians in the practice who are multilingual.
Meet with local physicians in health care systems. Make a connection with hospitalists, referring physicians, ED physicians, advanced practitioners, and surgeons while covering inpatient service. Volunteer for teaching activities – including for nursing staff, who are a great referral source.
Figure out what opportunities exist to have direct interactions with patients, such as health fairs. If possible, it might be smart to invest in marketing directly to patients in your community as well. Leverage opportunities provided by awareness months – such as providing patients with information about cancer screening – to establish a referral basis.
Medical practice is complex and at times can be confusing until you’ve practiced in a given location for some time. Look internally to learn about the community. It’s always a good idea to learn from those who have been practicing in the community for a long time. Don’t hesitate to ask questions and make suggestions, even if they seem naive. Develop relationships with staff members and gain their trust. Establishing a clear understanding of your specialty with your colleagues and staff also can be a good way to find referrals.
Learn the internal process
Schedules during early months are usually filled with urgent patients. Make yourself available for overflow referrals to other established physicians within the practice and for hospital discharge follow-ups. Reading through the charts of these patients can help you understand the various styles of other doctors and can help you familiarize yourself with referring physicians.
This also will help to clarify the process of how a patient moves through the system – from the time patients call the office to when they check out. This includes navigating through procedures, results reporting, and the recall system. While it will be hard to master all aspects of a practice right away, processes within practices are well established, and it is important for you to have a good understanding of how they function.
Focus on patient care and satisfaction
Learning internal processes also can be useful in increasing patient satisfaction, an important quality outcome indicator. As you’re starting out, keep the following things in mind that can help put your patients at ease and increase satisfaction.
- Understand how to communicate what a patient should expect when being seen. Being at ease with the process helps garner trust and confidence.
- Call patients the next day to check on their symptoms.
- Relay results personally. Make connections with family member(s).
- Remember that cultural competency is important. Do everything you can to ensure you’re meeting the social, cultural, and linguistic needs of patients in your community.
- Above all – continue to provide personalized and thorough care. Word of mouth is the best form of referral and is time tested.
Continue to grow
As you begin to understand the dynamics of local practice, it’s important to establish where you fit into the practice and start differentiating your expertise. Here are some ideas and suggestions for how you can continue to expand your patient base.
- Differentiate and establish a subspecialty within your practice: Motility, inflammatory bowel disease, Clostridium difficile/fecal microbiota transplantation, liver diseases, Celiac disease, and medical weight-loss programs are just a few.
- Establish connections with local medical societies as well as hospital and state committees. This is a great way to connect with other physicians of various specialties. If you have a specialty unique to the area, it may help establish a clear referral line.
- Establish a consistent conversation with referring physicians – get to know them and keep direct lines of communication, such as having their cell phone numbers.
- Look for public speaking engagements that reach patients directly. These are organized mostly through patient-based organization and foundations.
- Increase your reach through the local media and through social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter.
At this point, you should have plenty of patients to keep you busy, which could lead to other challenges in managing your various responsibilities and obligations. A key factor at this stage to help reduce stress is to lean on the effective and efficient support system your practice should have in place. Educating medical assistants or nurses on the most common GI diseases and conditions can help reduce the time involved in communicating results. Practice management software and patient portals can help create efficiencies to handle the increasing number of patient visits.
Remember, creating a referral process and patient base as a new gastroenterologist doesn’t have to be daunting. If you follow these tips, you’ll be on your way to establishing yourself within the community. No doubt you will have the same success as many physicians in my group and in the groups of my colleagues in the Digestive Health Physicians Association. And once you’re established, it will be your turn to help the next generation of physicians who want to enter private practice and thrive – so that independent community GI care remains strong well into the future.
Dr. Alaparthi is the director of committee operations at the Gastroenterology Center of Connecticut and serves as chair of the communications committee for the Digestive Health Physicians Association.
How to create your specialized niche in a private practice
Let’s imagine you landed your first job in a private gastroenterology practice or are trying to find the perfect job that allows you to put your energy toward your passions. And, like many GI doctors, you spent additional time in your fellowship training focusing on a specific interest – whether inflammatory bowel disease, advanced endoscopy, motility, hepatology, or maybe the lesser-traveled paths of weight management, geriatrics, or public policy.
Perhaps you haven’t taken an extra year of training, but you have a desire to specialize. What steps should you take to create your own niche in a private practice? How do you go about growing a practice that allows you to utilize your training?
Why specialize? Know your market!
Without a focus, unless you plan to work in an underserved area or to take over a retiring physician’s practice, a generalist position can be challenging because the demand for your skills may not be met with the supply of patients. Much like in any business, the more focused you are, the more you have a differentiator that separates you from your colleagues, increasing your chances of success.
With specialization, however, comes the importance of understanding your patient catchment area. If your focus is highly specialized and serves a less-diagnosed entity, you’ll need a larger catchment area or you won’t have the volume of patients. Also, be mindful about an oversupply of subspecialists in your given area. If you are the third or fourth subspecialist in your group, the only way you will get patients is if you are far superior in talent or personality (sorry – not typical!) or your more senior colleagues are looking to turn over work to you.
Economic considerations for subspecialties
Compensation for subspecializing is often a major factor. Understanding the economics of your specialty are important, as providers can become disappointed and disenchanted when they realize that their desire for income, especially when compared to other colleagues, differs from what their subspecialty can provide.
For instance, in GI, a physician pursuing a procedurally focused subspecialty like advanced endoscopy is likely to be compensated more highly than one who focuses on a more office-based, evaluation and management (E/M) billing-driven specialty, like motility, geriatric gastroenterology, or even hepatology. These office-based specialties are no less important, but the reality is that they create less revenue for a private practice.
Negotiating a fair contract at the beginning is critical, as you may need your income to be supplemented by your higher revenue-producing colleagues and partners for long-term success. Academic centers are often able to provide the supplement through endowments, grants, or better payer reimbursement for E/M codes, compared with a private practice.
Remember, everyone’s in sales
From my vantage point as a partner at Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates, there are several ways new GI physicians can set about a path toward specialization.
One of the first things that you should ask yourself during training is whether you want to spend another year beyond the typical 3 years. Best-case scenario would be figuring out a way to get the necessary training during the 3 years, possibly spending the third year dedicated to the specialty. Another possibility is to simply get on-the-job training during your first few years in practice without the extra year.
Whichever path you choose, building up a specialized niche within a private practice won’t come overnight. You have to create a plan and navigate a course. Here are a few ways to do that:
Take the case, especially the hard ones!
Have the mentality: “I will take care of it.” One of the best ways to specialize is to offer to help with all cases, but especially the most challenging ones. Be open to helping take on any patient. In the beginning, if you develop a reputation that you enjoy caring for all patients, even when the case requires more time and effort, this will translate into future referrals. Naturally, it may be slower in the beginning, as there may not be enough patients to treat within your specialty. Being willing to do everything will expedite the growth of your practice. No consult should be rebuffed, even when it appears unnecessary (i.e., heme-positive stool in an elderly, septic ICU patient – we all have gotten them); think of it as your opportunity to show off your skills and share your interests.
Market yourself.
This is perhaps one of the most important steps you can take. Get out in the community! This includes:
- Attend your hospital grand rounds and offer to be a presenter. There is no better way to show your enthusiasm and knowledge on a topic than to teach it. Many state GI societies have meetings, which provide opportunities to introduce yourself to physicians in other practices that can act as a good referral source if you are a local expert.
- Remember, as a subspecialist, always communicate back with the primary gastroenterologist. In doing so, feel out whether the referring doctor wants you to take over the patient’s management or send the patient back.
- Reach out to foundations, pharmaceutical companies, and advocacy groups in the area. Understand each specialty has an ecosystem beyond just a doctor-patient relationship. Participating in events that support the patient outside of the office will provide goodwill. Further, many patients rely on foundations for referrals.
- Consider research studies. Many pharmaceutical companies have the opportunity for you to register patients in investigational drug studies. By being a part of these studies, you will be included in publications, which will build your brand.
- Many disease processes need a multidisciplinary approach to treating them. Attending multidisciplinary conferences will allow you to lend your expertise. Also, presenting interesting cases and asking for help from more experienced physicians will show humility and leads to more referrals; it won’t be viewed as a weakness.
- Be creative. Develop relationships with providers who are not often considered to be a primary referral source. Motility experts may want to work closely with the local speech pathologists. An IBD specialist should develop a network of specialists for patients with extraintestinal manifestations. Advanced endoscopists and oncologists work closely together.
- Get involved in social media. Engage with other specialists and become part of the online community. Follow the subspecialty organizations or key thought leaders in your space on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn. You should share relevant articles or interesting cases.
There are so many aspects of gastroenterology that present great opportunities to specialize. Following your passions will lead to long-term happiness and prevent burnout. Remember that, even once you’ve built your practice, you must continue to stay involved and nurture what you’ve built. Go to the conferences. Make connections. Continue your education. Your career will thank you.
Dr. Sonenshine joined Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates in 2012. An Atlanta native, he graduated magna cum laude from the University of Georgia in Athens where he received a bachelor’s degree in microbiology and was selected to the Phi Beta Kappa Academic Honor Society. He received his medical degree from the Medical College of Georgia in Augusta, where he was named to the Alpha Omega Alpha Medical Honor Society. He completed both his internship and residency through the Osler Housestaff Training Program at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore. Following his residency, Dr. Sonenshine completed a fellowship in digestive diseases at Emory University in Atlanta while earning a master of business administration degree from the Terry College of Business at the University of Georgia. He is a partner in United Digestive and the chairman of medicine at Northside Hospital.
Let’s imagine you landed your first job in a private gastroenterology practice or are trying to find the perfect job that allows you to put your energy toward your passions. And, like many GI doctors, you spent additional time in your fellowship training focusing on a specific interest – whether inflammatory bowel disease, advanced endoscopy, motility, hepatology, or maybe the lesser-traveled paths of weight management, geriatrics, or public policy.
Perhaps you haven’t taken an extra year of training, but you have a desire to specialize. What steps should you take to create your own niche in a private practice? How do you go about growing a practice that allows you to utilize your training?
Why specialize? Know your market!
Without a focus, unless you plan to work in an underserved area or to take over a retiring physician’s practice, a generalist position can be challenging because the demand for your skills may not be met with the supply of patients. Much like in any business, the more focused you are, the more you have a differentiator that separates you from your colleagues, increasing your chances of success.
With specialization, however, comes the importance of understanding your patient catchment area. If your focus is highly specialized and serves a less-diagnosed entity, you’ll need a larger catchment area or you won’t have the volume of patients. Also, be mindful about an oversupply of subspecialists in your given area. If you are the third or fourth subspecialist in your group, the only way you will get patients is if you are far superior in talent or personality (sorry – not typical!) or your more senior colleagues are looking to turn over work to you.
Economic considerations for subspecialties
Compensation for subspecializing is often a major factor. Understanding the economics of your specialty are important, as providers can become disappointed and disenchanted when they realize that their desire for income, especially when compared to other colleagues, differs from what their subspecialty can provide.
For instance, in GI, a physician pursuing a procedurally focused subspecialty like advanced endoscopy is likely to be compensated more highly than one who focuses on a more office-based, evaluation and management (E/M) billing-driven specialty, like motility, geriatric gastroenterology, or even hepatology. These office-based specialties are no less important, but the reality is that they create less revenue for a private practice.
Negotiating a fair contract at the beginning is critical, as you may need your income to be supplemented by your higher revenue-producing colleagues and partners for long-term success. Academic centers are often able to provide the supplement through endowments, grants, or better payer reimbursement for E/M codes, compared with a private practice.
Remember, everyone’s in sales
From my vantage point as a partner at Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates, there are several ways new GI physicians can set about a path toward specialization.
One of the first things that you should ask yourself during training is whether you want to spend another year beyond the typical 3 years. Best-case scenario would be figuring out a way to get the necessary training during the 3 years, possibly spending the third year dedicated to the specialty. Another possibility is to simply get on-the-job training during your first few years in practice without the extra year.
Whichever path you choose, building up a specialized niche within a private practice won’t come overnight. You have to create a plan and navigate a course. Here are a few ways to do that:
Take the case, especially the hard ones!
Have the mentality: “I will take care of it.” One of the best ways to specialize is to offer to help with all cases, but especially the most challenging ones. Be open to helping take on any patient. In the beginning, if you develop a reputation that you enjoy caring for all patients, even when the case requires more time and effort, this will translate into future referrals. Naturally, it may be slower in the beginning, as there may not be enough patients to treat within your specialty. Being willing to do everything will expedite the growth of your practice. No consult should be rebuffed, even when it appears unnecessary (i.e., heme-positive stool in an elderly, septic ICU patient – we all have gotten them); think of it as your opportunity to show off your skills and share your interests.
Market yourself.
This is perhaps one of the most important steps you can take. Get out in the community! This includes:
- Attend your hospital grand rounds and offer to be a presenter. There is no better way to show your enthusiasm and knowledge on a topic than to teach it. Many state GI societies have meetings, which provide opportunities to introduce yourself to physicians in other practices that can act as a good referral source if you are a local expert.
- Remember, as a subspecialist, always communicate back with the primary gastroenterologist. In doing so, feel out whether the referring doctor wants you to take over the patient’s management or send the patient back.
- Reach out to foundations, pharmaceutical companies, and advocacy groups in the area. Understand each specialty has an ecosystem beyond just a doctor-patient relationship. Participating in events that support the patient outside of the office will provide goodwill. Further, many patients rely on foundations for referrals.
- Consider research studies. Many pharmaceutical companies have the opportunity for you to register patients in investigational drug studies. By being a part of these studies, you will be included in publications, which will build your brand.
- Many disease processes need a multidisciplinary approach to treating them. Attending multidisciplinary conferences will allow you to lend your expertise. Also, presenting interesting cases and asking for help from more experienced physicians will show humility and leads to more referrals; it won’t be viewed as a weakness.
- Be creative. Develop relationships with providers who are not often considered to be a primary referral source. Motility experts may want to work closely with the local speech pathologists. An IBD specialist should develop a network of specialists for patients with extraintestinal manifestations. Advanced endoscopists and oncologists work closely together.
- Get involved in social media. Engage with other specialists and become part of the online community. Follow the subspecialty organizations or key thought leaders in your space on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn. You should share relevant articles or interesting cases.
There are so many aspects of gastroenterology that present great opportunities to specialize. Following your passions will lead to long-term happiness and prevent burnout. Remember that, even once you’ve built your practice, you must continue to stay involved and nurture what you’ve built. Go to the conferences. Make connections. Continue your education. Your career will thank you.
Dr. Sonenshine joined Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates in 2012. An Atlanta native, he graduated magna cum laude from the University of Georgia in Athens where he received a bachelor’s degree in microbiology and was selected to the Phi Beta Kappa Academic Honor Society. He received his medical degree from the Medical College of Georgia in Augusta, where he was named to the Alpha Omega Alpha Medical Honor Society. He completed both his internship and residency through the Osler Housestaff Training Program at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore. Following his residency, Dr. Sonenshine completed a fellowship in digestive diseases at Emory University in Atlanta while earning a master of business administration degree from the Terry College of Business at the University of Georgia. He is a partner in United Digestive and the chairman of medicine at Northside Hospital.
Let’s imagine you landed your first job in a private gastroenterology practice or are trying to find the perfect job that allows you to put your energy toward your passions. And, like many GI doctors, you spent additional time in your fellowship training focusing on a specific interest – whether inflammatory bowel disease, advanced endoscopy, motility, hepatology, or maybe the lesser-traveled paths of weight management, geriatrics, or public policy.
Perhaps you haven’t taken an extra year of training, but you have a desire to specialize. What steps should you take to create your own niche in a private practice? How do you go about growing a practice that allows you to utilize your training?
Why specialize? Know your market!
Without a focus, unless you plan to work in an underserved area or to take over a retiring physician’s practice, a generalist position can be challenging because the demand for your skills may not be met with the supply of patients. Much like in any business, the more focused you are, the more you have a differentiator that separates you from your colleagues, increasing your chances of success.
With specialization, however, comes the importance of understanding your patient catchment area. If your focus is highly specialized and serves a less-diagnosed entity, you’ll need a larger catchment area or you won’t have the volume of patients. Also, be mindful about an oversupply of subspecialists in your given area. If you are the third or fourth subspecialist in your group, the only way you will get patients is if you are far superior in talent or personality (sorry – not typical!) or your more senior colleagues are looking to turn over work to you.
Economic considerations for subspecialties
Compensation for subspecializing is often a major factor. Understanding the economics of your specialty are important, as providers can become disappointed and disenchanted when they realize that their desire for income, especially when compared to other colleagues, differs from what their subspecialty can provide.
For instance, in GI, a physician pursuing a procedurally focused subspecialty like advanced endoscopy is likely to be compensated more highly than one who focuses on a more office-based, evaluation and management (E/M) billing-driven specialty, like motility, geriatric gastroenterology, or even hepatology. These office-based specialties are no less important, but the reality is that they create less revenue for a private practice.
Negotiating a fair contract at the beginning is critical, as you may need your income to be supplemented by your higher revenue-producing colleagues and partners for long-term success. Academic centers are often able to provide the supplement through endowments, grants, or better payer reimbursement for E/M codes, compared with a private practice.
Remember, everyone’s in sales
From my vantage point as a partner at Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates, there are several ways new GI physicians can set about a path toward specialization.
One of the first things that you should ask yourself during training is whether you want to spend another year beyond the typical 3 years. Best-case scenario would be figuring out a way to get the necessary training during the 3 years, possibly spending the third year dedicated to the specialty. Another possibility is to simply get on-the-job training during your first few years in practice without the extra year.
Whichever path you choose, building up a specialized niche within a private practice won’t come overnight. You have to create a plan and navigate a course. Here are a few ways to do that:
Take the case, especially the hard ones!
Have the mentality: “I will take care of it.” One of the best ways to specialize is to offer to help with all cases, but especially the most challenging ones. Be open to helping take on any patient. In the beginning, if you develop a reputation that you enjoy caring for all patients, even when the case requires more time and effort, this will translate into future referrals. Naturally, it may be slower in the beginning, as there may not be enough patients to treat within your specialty. Being willing to do everything will expedite the growth of your practice. No consult should be rebuffed, even when it appears unnecessary (i.e., heme-positive stool in an elderly, septic ICU patient – we all have gotten them); think of it as your opportunity to show off your skills and share your interests.
Market yourself.
This is perhaps one of the most important steps you can take. Get out in the community! This includes:
- Attend your hospital grand rounds and offer to be a presenter. There is no better way to show your enthusiasm and knowledge on a topic than to teach it. Many state GI societies have meetings, which provide opportunities to introduce yourself to physicians in other practices that can act as a good referral source if you are a local expert.
- Remember, as a subspecialist, always communicate back with the primary gastroenterologist. In doing so, feel out whether the referring doctor wants you to take over the patient’s management or send the patient back.
- Reach out to foundations, pharmaceutical companies, and advocacy groups in the area. Understand each specialty has an ecosystem beyond just a doctor-patient relationship. Participating in events that support the patient outside of the office will provide goodwill. Further, many patients rely on foundations for referrals.
- Consider research studies. Many pharmaceutical companies have the opportunity for you to register patients in investigational drug studies. By being a part of these studies, you will be included in publications, which will build your brand.
- Many disease processes need a multidisciplinary approach to treating them. Attending multidisciplinary conferences will allow you to lend your expertise. Also, presenting interesting cases and asking for help from more experienced physicians will show humility and leads to more referrals; it won’t be viewed as a weakness.
- Be creative. Develop relationships with providers who are not often considered to be a primary referral source. Motility experts may want to work closely with the local speech pathologists. An IBD specialist should develop a network of specialists for patients with extraintestinal manifestations. Advanced endoscopists and oncologists work closely together.
- Get involved in social media. Engage with other specialists and become part of the online community. Follow the subspecialty organizations or key thought leaders in your space on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn. You should share relevant articles or interesting cases.
There are so many aspects of gastroenterology that present great opportunities to specialize. Following your passions will lead to long-term happiness and prevent burnout. Remember that, even once you’ve built your practice, you must continue to stay involved and nurture what you’ve built. Go to the conferences. Make connections. Continue your education. Your career will thank you.
Dr. Sonenshine joined Atlanta Gastroenterology Associates in 2012. An Atlanta native, he graduated magna cum laude from the University of Georgia in Athens where he received a bachelor’s degree in microbiology and was selected to the Phi Beta Kappa Academic Honor Society. He received his medical degree from the Medical College of Georgia in Augusta, where he was named to the Alpha Omega Alpha Medical Honor Society. He completed both his internship and residency through the Osler Housestaff Training Program at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore. Following his residency, Dr. Sonenshine completed a fellowship in digestive diseases at Emory University in Atlanta while earning a master of business administration degree from the Terry College of Business at the University of Georgia. He is a partner in United Digestive and the chairman of medicine at Northside Hospital.
Finding your first job: Tips for picking the right practice
Editor’s Note: This is the second installment of the Private Practice Perspectives column, which is a collaboration between the AGA’s The New Gastroenterologist and the Digestive Health Physicians Association (DHPA). In this issue’s column, David Ramsay (Winston Salem, N.C.) provides valuable advice on the very important topic of picking the right practice.
Bryson W. Katona, MD, PhD
Editor in Chief, The New Gastroenterologist
Just 7 years ago, I faced the same difficult decisions many new gastroenterologists have. Like many physicians coming out of a residency and fellowship program, I had loans to repay and family to consider when evaluating the choices about where I would practice.
Looking back, there were several essential questions that helped guide my decision-making process. If you are early in your career as a GI, here are some questions to ask yourself and tips that I’ve learned along the way that may help make the decision about which practice is right for you.
What do you want to do with your training and skills? This may sound obvious, but it’s important to align your interests with the right practice. Did you receive extra training in endoscopic procedures, such as endoscopic ultrasonography and endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography? Do you want to specialize in inflammatory bowel disease? Have a passion for hepatology? Look for a practice that has those specific opportunities available to match your interests.
In addition, some GI docs want to pursue their interest in research. Keep in mind that many independent practices have research arms and offer physicians the opportunity to continue on this path.
Lastly, consider whether you want to be involved in the business of medicine or take on a leadership role. Many practices offer (and even encourage) those opportunities, and you can winnow down your list of practices based on whether they allow you to take on those roles.
Where do you want to live? My wife and I completed our residencies and fellowships in Washington, but when it came time to find a place to practice medicine, we knew we wanted to be near family. We narrowed our search to Tennessee, Florida, and North Carolina, where we eventually ended up.
Of course, wherever you decide to go is a personal choice. Some people prefer living on the coasts or want to reside in a major city. This might come as a surprise to some, but very often you will command a higher salary in rural areas or smaller cities, which are traditionally underserved by our profession. That starts to matter when you think about paying off your student loan debt.
What is the long-term potential of each position? This is perhaps the most important question to ask. Does your new practice offer ownership potential? Are there opportunities to share in the various (ancillary) revenue streams, such as an ambulatory surgery center, anesthesia, or pathology? How soon might you have the opportunity to buy in and what is the buy in structure and cost? What are the practice rules around offering partnerships?
These are all questions that you should ask up front. Remember that the lifestyle you start out with may change over the course of your career. Find a practice that offers opportunities for growth because your long-term income potential is much more important than your starting salary or size of any sign-on bonus.
Once you’ve decided the answers to some of these questions, here are a few tips to help you land a job at the right medical practice.
Talk to your mentors and tap into your connections: Most GI physicians completing a fellowship will have mentors who have connections to practices. Speak with them about where to look. In addition, most medical societies and state-specific GI societies post classified job listings. Use these professional memberships.
Don’t be afraid of the cold call: If you know where you might want to live, you should consider cold calls to practices in the area to see what opportunities are available. That’s how I found my job. I started calling practices in North Carolina. Those that didn’t have openings knew of, and shared names of, practices in the state that did.
Call the local hospitals and ask to speak to the charge nurse in endoscopy: This is one the best tips I got to help narrow the field. These nurses are a great source of information with honest feedback about the reputation of the local GI practices.
Look for collegiality: This can be harder to spot, but it’s a good sign when the CEOs or practice administrators are engaging and take the time to answer questions.
Look for groups that don’t have a lot of turnover: This is another important sign. We call it the churn and burn: We all know of fellows who have joined a practice where they work long hours but never have the opportunity to make partner. You might ask the question directly: How many physicians have come here and left within the first 5 years of employment? A high turnover rate is a red flag. No matter what type of practice you choose, the key is to look at your long-term prospects, not just at short-term rewards. After all, that’s what will give you the greatest opportunities – and likely make you happiest in your career.
David Ramsay, MD, is treasurer of the Digestive Health Physicians Association. He is President of Digestive Health Specialists in Winston Salem, N.C., which he joined in 2012 after working in the Washington area.
Editor’s Note: This is the second installment of the Private Practice Perspectives column, which is a collaboration between the AGA’s The New Gastroenterologist and the Digestive Health Physicians Association (DHPA). In this issue’s column, David Ramsay (Winston Salem, N.C.) provides valuable advice on the very important topic of picking the right practice.
Bryson W. Katona, MD, PhD
Editor in Chief, The New Gastroenterologist
Just 7 years ago, I faced the same difficult decisions many new gastroenterologists have. Like many physicians coming out of a residency and fellowship program, I had loans to repay and family to consider when evaluating the choices about where I would practice.
Looking back, there were several essential questions that helped guide my decision-making process. If you are early in your career as a GI, here are some questions to ask yourself and tips that I’ve learned along the way that may help make the decision about which practice is right for you.
What do you want to do with your training and skills? This may sound obvious, but it’s important to align your interests with the right practice. Did you receive extra training in endoscopic procedures, such as endoscopic ultrasonography and endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography? Do you want to specialize in inflammatory bowel disease? Have a passion for hepatology? Look for a practice that has those specific opportunities available to match your interests.
In addition, some GI docs want to pursue their interest in research. Keep in mind that many independent practices have research arms and offer physicians the opportunity to continue on this path.
Lastly, consider whether you want to be involved in the business of medicine or take on a leadership role. Many practices offer (and even encourage) those opportunities, and you can winnow down your list of practices based on whether they allow you to take on those roles.
Where do you want to live? My wife and I completed our residencies and fellowships in Washington, but when it came time to find a place to practice medicine, we knew we wanted to be near family. We narrowed our search to Tennessee, Florida, and North Carolina, where we eventually ended up.
Of course, wherever you decide to go is a personal choice. Some people prefer living on the coasts or want to reside in a major city. This might come as a surprise to some, but very often you will command a higher salary in rural areas or smaller cities, which are traditionally underserved by our profession. That starts to matter when you think about paying off your student loan debt.
What is the long-term potential of each position? This is perhaps the most important question to ask. Does your new practice offer ownership potential? Are there opportunities to share in the various (ancillary) revenue streams, such as an ambulatory surgery center, anesthesia, or pathology? How soon might you have the opportunity to buy in and what is the buy in structure and cost? What are the practice rules around offering partnerships?
These are all questions that you should ask up front. Remember that the lifestyle you start out with may change over the course of your career. Find a practice that offers opportunities for growth because your long-term income potential is much more important than your starting salary or size of any sign-on bonus.
Once you’ve decided the answers to some of these questions, here are a few tips to help you land a job at the right medical practice.
Talk to your mentors and tap into your connections: Most GI physicians completing a fellowship will have mentors who have connections to practices. Speak with them about where to look. In addition, most medical societies and state-specific GI societies post classified job listings. Use these professional memberships.
Don’t be afraid of the cold call: If you know where you might want to live, you should consider cold calls to practices in the area to see what opportunities are available. That’s how I found my job. I started calling practices in North Carolina. Those that didn’t have openings knew of, and shared names of, practices in the state that did.
Call the local hospitals and ask to speak to the charge nurse in endoscopy: This is one the best tips I got to help narrow the field. These nurses are a great source of information with honest feedback about the reputation of the local GI practices.
Look for collegiality: This can be harder to spot, but it’s a good sign when the CEOs or practice administrators are engaging and take the time to answer questions.
Look for groups that don’t have a lot of turnover: This is another important sign. We call it the churn and burn: We all know of fellows who have joined a practice where they work long hours but never have the opportunity to make partner. You might ask the question directly: How many physicians have come here and left within the first 5 years of employment? A high turnover rate is a red flag. No matter what type of practice you choose, the key is to look at your long-term prospects, not just at short-term rewards. After all, that’s what will give you the greatest opportunities – and likely make you happiest in your career.
David Ramsay, MD, is treasurer of the Digestive Health Physicians Association. He is President of Digestive Health Specialists in Winston Salem, N.C., which he joined in 2012 after working in the Washington area.
Editor’s Note: This is the second installment of the Private Practice Perspectives column, which is a collaboration between the AGA’s The New Gastroenterologist and the Digestive Health Physicians Association (DHPA). In this issue’s column, David Ramsay (Winston Salem, N.C.) provides valuable advice on the very important topic of picking the right practice.
Bryson W. Katona, MD, PhD
Editor in Chief, The New Gastroenterologist
Just 7 years ago, I faced the same difficult decisions many new gastroenterologists have. Like many physicians coming out of a residency and fellowship program, I had loans to repay and family to consider when evaluating the choices about where I would practice.
Looking back, there were several essential questions that helped guide my decision-making process. If you are early in your career as a GI, here are some questions to ask yourself and tips that I’ve learned along the way that may help make the decision about which practice is right for you.
What do you want to do with your training and skills? This may sound obvious, but it’s important to align your interests with the right practice. Did you receive extra training in endoscopic procedures, such as endoscopic ultrasonography and endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography? Do you want to specialize in inflammatory bowel disease? Have a passion for hepatology? Look for a practice that has those specific opportunities available to match your interests.
In addition, some GI docs want to pursue their interest in research. Keep in mind that many independent practices have research arms and offer physicians the opportunity to continue on this path.
Lastly, consider whether you want to be involved in the business of medicine or take on a leadership role. Many practices offer (and even encourage) those opportunities, and you can winnow down your list of practices based on whether they allow you to take on those roles.
Where do you want to live? My wife and I completed our residencies and fellowships in Washington, but when it came time to find a place to practice medicine, we knew we wanted to be near family. We narrowed our search to Tennessee, Florida, and North Carolina, where we eventually ended up.
Of course, wherever you decide to go is a personal choice. Some people prefer living on the coasts or want to reside in a major city. This might come as a surprise to some, but very often you will command a higher salary in rural areas or smaller cities, which are traditionally underserved by our profession. That starts to matter when you think about paying off your student loan debt.
What is the long-term potential of each position? This is perhaps the most important question to ask. Does your new practice offer ownership potential? Are there opportunities to share in the various (ancillary) revenue streams, such as an ambulatory surgery center, anesthesia, or pathology? How soon might you have the opportunity to buy in and what is the buy in structure and cost? What are the practice rules around offering partnerships?
These are all questions that you should ask up front. Remember that the lifestyle you start out with may change over the course of your career. Find a practice that offers opportunities for growth because your long-term income potential is much more important than your starting salary or size of any sign-on bonus.
Once you’ve decided the answers to some of these questions, here are a few tips to help you land a job at the right medical practice.
Talk to your mentors and tap into your connections: Most GI physicians completing a fellowship will have mentors who have connections to practices. Speak with them about where to look. In addition, most medical societies and state-specific GI societies post classified job listings. Use these professional memberships.
Don’t be afraid of the cold call: If you know where you might want to live, you should consider cold calls to practices in the area to see what opportunities are available. That’s how I found my job. I started calling practices in North Carolina. Those that didn’t have openings knew of, and shared names of, practices in the state that did.
Call the local hospitals and ask to speak to the charge nurse in endoscopy: This is one the best tips I got to help narrow the field. These nurses are a great source of information with honest feedback about the reputation of the local GI practices.
Look for collegiality: This can be harder to spot, but it’s a good sign when the CEOs or practice administrators are engaging and take the time to answer questions.
Look for groups that don’t have a lot of turnover: This is another important sign. We call it the churn and burn: We all know of fellows who have joined a practice where they work long hours but never have the opportunity to make partner. You might ask the question directly: How many physicians have come here and left within the first 5 years of employment? A high turnover rate is a red flag. No matter what type of practice you choose, the key is to look at your long-term prospects, not just at short-term rewards. After all, that’s what will give you the greatest opportunities – and likely make you happiest in your career.
David Ramsay, MD, is treasurer of the Digestive Health Physicians Association. He is President of Digestive Health Specialists in Winston Salem, N.C., which he joined in 2012 after working in the Washington area.