HIV not a risk factor for postappendectomy complications

Article Type
Changed
Fri, 01/18/2019 - 15:43
Display Headline
HIV not a risk factor for postappendectomy complications

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Patients who have HIV are at no greater risk of complications from appendectomy than are non-HIV patients according to an analysis of cases in a national surgical database presented at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Dr. Michael C. Smith of the State University of New York, Brooklyn, explained why he and his colleagues felt it was time to update the literature on HIV and surgery. “Much of the literature on appendectomy in the setting of HIV is either from the early 1990s or elsewhere in the world, and it shows greatly increased complication rates in these patients,” he said.

Dr. Michael C. Smith

The analysis queried the Nationwide Inpatient Sample (NIS) database for all patients who had acute appendicitis and appendectomy during 2005-2012. The analysis included patients who had both open and laparoscopic appendectomy, and compared the HIV group that did not have AIDS with the non-HIV group, Dr. Smith said. The population with AIDS, along with patients who had interval appendectomies after appendicitis, were excluded.

The study looked at 821 patients with HIV and 338,425 patients without HIV as controls.

“The only significant difference we found between the two groups was hospital length of stay, which differed by about three-quarters of a day,” Dr. Smith said. Patients with HIV spent on average 3.8 days in the hospital after appendectomy vs. 3 days for non-HIV patients. “Other complication rates were nonsignificant by our study,” he said.

The average total charge for HIV patients was also higher, $33,350 vs. $30,714, the analysis showed.

Dr. Smith acknowledged some limitations in using the NIS database, most notably that the data were from index hospitalizations only. “So we probably did not capture people who returned to the hospital on postoperative day 3, 4, and 5 after they were discharged home,” he said. “Therefore, prospective studies are needed to validate these results.”

He also said that the study did not differentiate between operations for perforated and nonperforated appendix, and he and his coresearchers could not determine why the HIV population had longer hospital stays.

Dr. Smith and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Sections
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Patients who have HIV are at no greater risk of complications from appendectomy than are non-HIV patients according to an analysis of cases in a national surgical database presented at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Dr. Michael C. Smith of the State University of New York, Brooklyn, explained why he and his colleagues felt it was time to update the literature on HIV and surgery. “Much of the literature on appendectomy in the setting of HIV is either from the early 1990s or elsewhere in the world, and it shows greatly increased complication rates in these patients,” he said.

Dr. Michael C. Smith

The analysis queried the Nationwide Inpatient Sample (NIS) database for all patients who had acute appendicitis and appendectomy during 2005-2012. The analysis included patients who had both open and laparoscopic appendectomy, and compared the HIV group that did not have AIDS with the non-HIV group, Dr. Smith said. The population with AIDS, along with patients who had interval appendectomies after appendicitis, were excluded.

The study looked at 821 patients with HIV and 338,425 patients without HIV as controls.

“The only significant difference we found between the two groups was hospital length of stay, which differed by about three-quarters of a day,” Dr. Smith said. Patients with HIV spent on average 3.8 days in the hospital after appendectomy vs. 3 days for non-HIV patients. “Other complication rates were nonsignificant by our study,” he said.

The average total charge for HIV patients was also higher, $33,350 vs. $30,714, the analysis showed.

Dr. Smith acknowledged some limitations in using the NIS database, most notably that the data were from index hospitalizations only. “So we probably did not capture people who returned to the hospital on postoperative day 3, 4, and 5 after they were discharged home,” he said. “Therefore, prospective studies are needed to validate these results.”

He also said that the study did not differentiate between operations for perforated and nonperforated appendix, and he and his coresearchers could not determine why the HIV population had longer hospital stays.

Dr. Smith and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Patients who have HIV are at no greater risk of complications from appendectomy than are non-HIV patients according to an analysis of cases in a national surgical database presented at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Dr. Michael C. Smith of the State University of New York, Brooklyn, explained why he and his colleagues felt it was time to update the literature on HIV and surgery. “Much of the literature on appendectomy in the setting of HIV is either from the early 1990s or elsewhere in the world, and it shows greatly increased complication rates in these patients,” he said.

Dr. Michael C. Smith

The analysis queried the Nationwide Inpatient Sample (NIS) database for all patients who had acute appendicitis and appendectomy during 2005-2012. The analysis included patients who had both open and laparoscopic appendectomy, and compared the HIV group that did not have AIDS with the non-HIV group, Dr. Smith said. The population with AIDS, along with patients who had interval appendectomies after appendicitis, were excluded.

The study looked at 821 patients with HIV and 338,425 patients without HIV as controls.

“The only significant difference we found between the two groups was hospital length of stay, which differed by about three-quarters of a day,” Dr. Smith said. Patients with HIV spent on average 3.8 days in the hospital after appendectomy vs. 3 days for non-HIV patients. “Other complication rates were nonsignificant by our study,” he said.

The average total charge for HIV patients was also higher, $33,350 vs. $30,714, the analysis showed.

Dr. Smith acknowledged some limitations in using the NIS database, most notably that the data were from index hospitalizations only. “So we probably did not capture people who returned to the hospital on postoperative day 3, 4, and 5 after they were discharged home,” he said. “Therefore, prospective studies are needed to validate these results.”

He also said that the study did not differentiate between operations for perforated and nonperforated appendix, and he and his coresearchers could not determine why the HIV population had longer hospital stays.

Dr. Smith and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
HIV not a risk factor for postappendectomy complications
Display Headline
HIV not a risk factor for postappendectomy complications
Sections
Article Source

AT THE ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Key clinical point: Patients who have HIV are at no greater risk of complications from appendectomy than are non-HIV patients.

Major finding: Risk of death and complications were similar across both groups, although hospital stays were about 26% longer and cost about 10% more for patients with HIV.

Data source: Query of Nationwide Inpatient Sample (NIS) database during 2005-2012 of 812 HIV and 338,425 non-HIV patients who had appendectomy for acute appendicitis.

Disclosures: The study authors reported having no financial disclosures.

Damage to nearby structure common cause of hernia malpractice claim

Article Type
Changed
Thu, 03/28/2019 - 15:12
Display Headline
Damage to nearby structure common cause of hernia malpractice claim

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – General surgeons are among the most sued physicians, and hernia repair is one of the most common operations they perform, so a study was conducted to drill down into the legal data on hernia repair to determine what about the operation is most likely to get surgeons in trouble.

They found that a failure to diagnose a complication caused by damage to a nearby structure during the operation was the most common cause for a malpractice suit for hernia repair, Dr. Nadeem Haddad of the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., reported at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

“Hernia repair with more than 1 million cases annually is one of the most common surgical procedures,” Dr. Haddad said. “The most common type of operation for malpractice was inguinal hernia repair. The majority of cases were elective cases where the informed consent was not breached.”

The researchers sampled data on 250 malpractice cases arising from hernia surgery filed with the Westlaw Next legal database between 1985 and 2015, Dr. Haddad said. He added that the sample is not inclusive of all malpractice cases related to hernia repair in that time. “Our objective was to analyze reasons for litigation related to hernia repairs,” he said.

Among the hernia cases from the database, physicians (defendants) won 59%, patients (plaintiffs) won around 27%, and the remainder went to settlement before a verdict. Award payments ranged from $10,000 for a case where a Penrose drain was left in the patient to $16 million in the case of death of an infant due to perioperative hyperkalemia.

Eighty-four percent of the cases in the study involved inguinal or ventral hernia repair, Dr. Haddad said, but the Westlaw Next database did not differentiate between the two types of procedures. Nor did it separate out pediatric or adult repairs. Westlaw Next provides the alleged reason for litigation and gives details about lawsuits. The researchers classified the alleged reasons for the lawsuits based on the time period in which they happened: preoperatively, intraoperatively, and postoperatively.

“The single most common reason for malpractice in hernia repair was failure to diagnose a complication following damage to a surrounding structure,” Dr. Haddad said.

The state of New York had the highest number of medical malpractice cases (46), followed closely by California (42). In 15% of cases (38) the patients claimed a breach of informed consent by the surgeon

“While understanding the reasons why surgeons go to trial, the risk of future lawsuits may lessen if measures are enacted to prevent such outcomes,” Dr. Haddad said. “Following protocols in diagnosis and management, attention to good surgical technique, and keeping a checklist of possible complications are some of the ways to improve patients safety and decrease chances of litigation.”

Dr. Haddad and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Sections
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – General surgeons are among the most sued physicians, and hernia repair is one of the most common operations they perform, so a study was conducted to drill down into the legal data on hernia repair to determine what about the operation is most likely to get surgeons in trouble.

They found that a failure to diagnose a complication caused by damage to a nearby structure during the operation was the most common cause for a malpractice suit for hernia repair, Dr. Nadeem Haddad of the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., reported at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

“Hernia repair with more than 1 million cases annually is one of the most common surgical procedures,” Dr. Haddad said. “The most common type of operation for malpractice was inguinal hernia repair. The majority of cases were elective cases where the informed consent was not breached.”

The researchers sampled data on 250 malpractice cases arising from hernia surgery filed with the Westlaw Next legal database between 1985 and 2015, Dr. Haddad said. He added that the sample is not inclusive of all malpractice cases related to hernia repair in that time. “Our objective was to analyze reasons for litigation related to hernia repairs,” he said.

Among the hernia cases from the database, physicians (defendants) won 59%, patients (plaintiffs) won around 27%, and the remainder went to settlement before a verdict. Award payments ranged from $10,000 for a case where a Penrose drain was left in the patient to $16 million in the case of death of an infant due to perioperative hyperkalemia.

Eighty-four percent of the cases in the study involved inguinal or ventral hernia repair, Dr. Haddad said, but the Westlaw Next database did not differentiate between the two types of procedures. Nor did it separate out pediatric or adult repairs. Westlaw Next provides the alleged reason for litigation and gives details about lawsuits. The researchers classified the alleged reasons for the lawsuits based on the time period in which they happened: preoperatively, intraoperatively, and postoperatively.

“The single most common reason for malpractice in hernia repair was failure to diagnose a complication following damage to a surrounding structure,” Dr. Haddad said.

The state of New York had the highest number of medical malpractice cases (46), followed closely by California (42). In 15% of cases (38) the patients claimed a breach of informed consent by the surgeon

“While understanding the reasons why surgeons go to trial, the risk of future lawsuits may lessen if measures are enacted to prevent such outcomes,” Dr. Haddad said. “Following protocols in diagnosis and management, attention to good surgical technique, and keeping a checklist of possible complications are some of the ways to improve patients safety and decrease chances of litigation.”

Dr. Haddad and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – General surgeons are among the most sued physicians, and hernia repair is one of the most common operations they perform, so a study was conducted to drill down into the legal data on hernia repair to determine what about the operation is most likely to get surgeons in trouble.

They found that a failure to diagnose a complication caused by damage to a nearby structure during the operation was the most common cause for a malpractice suit for hernia repair, Dr. Nadeem Haddad of the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., reported at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

“Hernia repair with more than 1 million cases annually is one of the most common surgical procedures,” Dr. Haddad said. “The most common type of operation for malpractice was inguinal hernia repair. The majority of cases were elective cases where the informed consent was not breached.”

The researchers sampled data on 250 malpractice cases arising from hernia surgery filed with the Westlaw Next legal database between 1985 and 2015, Dr. Haddad said. He added that the sample is not inclusive of all malpractice cases related to hernia repair in that time. “Our objective was to analyze reasons for litigation related to hernia repairs,” he said.

Among the hernia cases from the database, physicians (defendants) won 59%, patients (plaintiffs) won around 27%, and the remainder went to settlement before a verdict. Award payments ranged from $10,000 for a case where a Penrose drain was left in the patient to $16 million in the case of death of an infant due to perioperative hyperkalemia.

Eighty-four percent of the cases in the study involved inguinal or ventral hernia repair, Dr. Haddad said, but the Westlaw Next database did not differentiate between the two types of procedures. Nor did it separate out pediatric or adult repairs. Westlaw Next provides the alleged reason for litigation and gives details about lawsuits. The researchers classified the alleged reasons for the lawsuits based on the time period in which they happened: preoperatively, intraoperatively, and postoperatively.

“The single most common reason for malpractice in hernia repair was failure to diagnose a complication following damage to a surrounding structure,” Dr. Haddad said.

The state of New York had the highest number of medical malpractice cases (46), followed closely by California (42). In 15% of cases (38) the patients claimed a breach of informed consent by the surgeon

“While understanding the reasons why surgeons go to trial, the risk of future lawsuits may lessen if measures are enacted to prevent such outcomes,” Dr. Haddad said. “Following protocols in diagnosis and management, attention to good surgical technique, and keeping a checklist of possible complications are some of the ways to improve patients safety and decrease chances of litigation.”

Dr. Haddad and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
Damage to nearby structure common cause of hernia malpractice claim
Display Headline
Damage to nearby structure common cause of hernia malpractice claim
Sections
Article Source

AT THE ANNUAL ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Key clinical point: Failure to diagnose a complication caused by damage to a nearby structure during hernia repair surgery is the most common cause for a malpractice claim for hernia repair.

Major finding: In malpractice cases involving hernia surgery that go to trial, 59% of the rulings are for the plaintiff physicians and about 14% go to settlement before a judge or jury decision.

Data source: Sample of 250 hernia surgical malpractice cases from 1985 to 2015 in the Westlaw Next legal database.

Disclosures: The study authors reported having no financial disclosures.

TAMIS for rectal cancer holds its own vs. TEM

Article Type
Changed
Wed, 05/26/2021 - 13:55
Display Headline
TAMIS for rectal cancer holds its own vs. TEM

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Over the past 30 years, transanal endoscopic microsurgery (TEM) has emerged as a technique for localized rectal cancer, but the need for expensive specialized equipment put it beyond the reach of most hospitals.

Now, early results with transanal minimally invasive surgery (TAMIS) may open the door to an option that achieves the benefits of TEM while using commonly available and less expensive equipment, according to a study presented at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Dr. John Costello, general surgery resident at Georgetown University, Washington, presented a poster summarizing the findings of a systematic literature review of TEM and TAMIS studies. The experience with TAMIS is more limited since Dr. Sam Atallah of Sebring, Fla., first introduced it in 2010. The review included the only head-to-head study of the technical aspects of TAMIS and TEM to date.

“Overall the results are very similar between the two approaches,” Dr. Costello said. “In many ways there are, at least anecdotally, some benefits potentially toward the TAMIS technique aside from cost: The perioperative morbidity may be a little lower and, particularly, there seemed to be fewer early problems with continence after surgery.”

The review found similar outcomes between the two approaches: low recurrence rates for small tumors (up to 3 cm) of 4% for TAMIS and 5% for TEM, although the study found that the recurrence rate for TEM increased with larger tumors. Surgery-related deaths with TAMIS ranged from 7.4% to19% and TEM from 6% to 31% across the studies reviewed.

The challenge with the systematic review was that the population of patients who had TAMIS was fewer than 500.

Dr. Costello elucidated the reasons that rectal cancer surgery has proved so challenging to surgeons over the years. The choice of operation was either limited to transabdominal or transanal excision, but the transanal approach had limitations anatomically and was found to be oncologically inferior for early stage cancer. Even with the evolution of the TEM approach, its adoption has been slow.

Either TEM or TAMIS would be a good option for patients too frail for the radical resection that low anterior resection or abdominal perineal resection demand, and would offer an option for palliation for advanced disease, Dr. Costello said. “You could locally resect patients in a way that they go home the same day or at most stay one day in the hospital,” he said.

“The challenge with TEM is that, although the oncologic outcomes are quite good with early-stage disease, the adoption has been very poor over 3 decades mainly because it requires specialized equipment with a very large upfront cost that is limited to use in the rectum,” Dr. Costello said. He estimated the initial capital investment cost for TEM equipment at up to $60,000 on average.

The TAMIS approach, on the other hand, carries a per-procedure equipment cost of about $500 over traditional laparoscopic surgery, he said. It can utilize the single-incision laparoscopic port (SILS) for the transanal approach. TAMIS sacrifices the three-dimensional view of TEM for two-dimensional, but it does provide 360-degree visualization. The surgeon must also be facile with the laparoscopic technique. “In the past that was a big challenge, but now all trainees are very familiar with laparoscopic surgery,” Dr. Costello said.

While the paucity of data on the TAMIS approach makes it difficult to make a strong case for the procedure, the path forward is clear, Dr. Costello said.

“We feel, as do a number of authors of the most papers, that the time truly is now for an actual prospective randomized trial to compare these techniques head-to-head, because colorectal surgeons now have the skill set to be facile at both,” Dr. Costello said.

The investigators had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

Click for Credit Link
Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Sections
Click for Credit Link
Click for Credit Link
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Over the past 30 years, transanal endoscopic microsurgery (TEM) has emerged as a technique for localized rectal cancer, but the need for expensive specialized equipment put it beyond the reach of most hospitals.

Now, early results with transanal minimally invasive surgery (TAMIS) may open the door to an option that achieves the benefits of TEM while using commonly available and less expensive equipment, according to a study presented at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Dr. John Costello, general surgery resident at Georgetown University, Washington, presented a poster summarizing the findings of a systematic literature review of TEM and TAMIS studies. The experience with TAMIS is more limited since Dr. Sam Atallah of Sebring, Fla., first introduced it in 2010. The review included the only head-to-head study of the technical aspects of TAMIS and TEM to date.

“Overall the results are very similar between the two approaches,” Dr. Costello said. “In many ways there are, at least anecdotally, some benefits potentially toward the TAMIS technique aside from cost: The perioperative morbidity may be a little lower and, particularly, there seemed to be fewer early problems with continence after surgery.”

The review found similar outcomes between the two approaches: low recurrence rates for small tumors (up to 3 cm) of 4% for TAMIS and 5% for TEM, although the study found that the recurrence rate for TEM increased with larger tumors. Surgery-related deaths with TAMIS ranged from 7.4% to19% and TEM from 6% to 31% across the studies reviewed.

The challenge with the systematic review was that the population of patients who had TAMIS was fewer than 500.

Dr. Costello elucidated the reasons that rectal cancer surgery has proved so challenging to surgeons over the years. The choice of operation was either limited to transabdominal or transanal excision, but the transanal approach had limitations anatomically and was found to be oncologically inferior for early stage cancer. Even with the evolution of the TEM approach, its adoption has been slow.

Either TEM or TAMIS would be a good option for patients too frail for the radical resection that low anterior resection or abdominal perineal resection demand, and would offer an option for palliation for advanced disease, Dr. Costello said. “You could locally resect patients in a way that they go home the same day or at most stay one day in the hospital,” he said.

“The challenge with TEM is that, although the oncologic outcomes are quite good with early-stage disease, the adoption has been very poor over 3 decades mainly because it requires specialized equipment with a very large upfront cost that is limited to use in the rectum,” Dr. Costello said. He estimated the initial capital investment cost for TEM equipment at up to $60,000 on average.

The TAMIS approach, on the other hand, carries a per-procedure equipment cost of about $500 over traditional laparoscopic surgery, he said. It can utilize the single-incision laparoscopic port (SILS) for the transanal approach. TAMIS sacrifices the three-dimensional view of TEM for two-dimensional, but it does provide 360-degree visualization. The surgeon must also be facile with the laparoscopic technique. “In the past that was a big challenge, but now all trainees are very familiar with laparoscopic surgery,” Dr. Costello said.

While the paucity of data on the TAMIS approach makes it difficult to make a strong case for the procedure, the path forward is clear, Dr. Costello said.

“We feel, as do a number of authors of the most papers, that the time truly is now for an actual prospective randomized trial to compare these techniques head-to-head, because colorectal surgeons now have the skill set to be facile at both,” Dr. Costello said.

The investigators had no financial relationships to disclose.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Over the past 30 years, transanal endoscopic microsurgery (TEM) has emerged as a technique for localized rectal cancer, but the need for expensive specialized equipment put it beyond the reach of most hospitals.

Now, early results with transanal minimally invasive surgery (TAMIS) may open the door to an option that achieves the benefits of TEM while using commonly available and less expensive equipment, according to a study presented at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Dr. John Costello, general surgery resident at Georgetown University, Washington, presented a poster summarizing the findings of a systematic literature review of TEM and TAMIS studies. The experience with TAMIS is more limited since Dr. Sam Atallah of Sebring, Fla., first introduced it in 2010. The review included the only head-to-head study of the technical aspects of TAMIS and TEM to date.

“Overall the results are very similar between the two approaches,” Dr. Costello said. “In many ways there are, at least anecdotally, some benefits potentially toward the TAMIS technique aside from cost: The perioperative morbidity may be a little lower and, particularly, there seemed to be fewer early problems with continence after surgery.”

The review found similar outcomes between the two approaches: low recurrence rates for small tumors (up to 3 cm) of 4% for TAMIS and 5% for TEM, although the study found that the recurrence rate for TEM increased with larger tumors. Surgery-related deaths with TAMIS ranged from 7.4% to19% and TEM from 6% to 31% across the studies reviewed.

The challenge with the systematic review was that the population of patients who had TAMIS was fewer than 500.

Dr. Costello elucidated the reasons that rectal cancer surgery has proved so challenging to surgeons over the years. The choice of operation was either limited to transabdominal or transanal excision, but the transanal approach had limitations anatomically and was found to be oncologically inferior for early stage cancer. Even with the evolution of the TEM approach, its adoption has been slow.

Either TEM or TAMIS would be a good option for patients too frail for the radical resection that low anterior resection or abdominal perineal resection demand, and would offer an option for palliation for advanced disease, Dr. Costello said. “You could locally resect patients in a way that they go home the same day or at most stay one day in the hospital,” he said.

“The challenge with TEM is that, although the oncologic outcomes are quite good with early-stage disease, the adoption has been very poor over 3 decades mainly because it requires specialized equipment with a very large upfront cost that is limited to use in the rectum,” Dr. Costello said. He estimated the initial capital investment cost for TEM equipment at up to $60,000 on average.

The TAMIS approach, on the other hand, carries a per-procedure equipment cost of about $500 over traditional laparoscopic surgery, he said. It can utilize the single-incision laparoscopic port (SILS) for the transanal approach. TAMIS sacrifices the three-dimensional view of TEM for two-dimensional, but it does provide 360-degree visualization. The surgeon must also be facile with the laparoscopic technique. “In the past that was a big challenge, but now all trainees are very familiar with laparoscopic surgery,” Dr. Costello said.

While the paucity of data on the TAMIS approach makes it difficult to make a strong case for the procedure, the path forward is clear, Dr. Costello said.

“We feel, as do a number of authors of the most papers, that the time truly is now for an actual prospective randomized trial to compare these techniques head-to-head, because colorectal surgeons now have the skill set to be facile at both,” Dr. Costello said.

The investigators had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
TAMIS for rectal cancer holds its own vs. TEM
Display Headline
TAMIS for rectal cancer holds its own vs. TEM
Click for Credit Status
Active
Sections
Article Source

AT THE ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Key clinical point: TAMIS for removal of rectal tumors achieved equal outcomes to TEM with measurable cost savings.

Major finding: The review found similar outcomes between the two procedures and low recurrence rates for small tumors (up to 3 cm) of 4% for TAMIS and 5% for TEM.

Data source: Systematic literature review of fewer than 500 cases of TAMIS, compared with results of TEM literature.

Disclosures: The study authors reported having no financial disclosures.

Robotic colectomy takes longer, comparable results

Article Type
Changed
Wed, 01/02/2019 - 09:29
Display Headline
Robotic colectomy takes longer, comparable results

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Robotic-assisted colectomy took longer than the laparoscopic operation but didn’t result in better surgical outcomes in a large NSQIP data–based study.

As health care moves away from fee-for-service to a value-based model, the longer operative times and comparative outcomes to laparoscopic colectomy suggest that the use of robotic technologies in straightforward colon resections may not be justified at this time, investigators at Duke University concluded.

Dr. Brian Ezekian

“This is the largest analysis to date of robotic-assisted vs. laparoscopic colectomy,” Dr. Brian Ezekian, general surgery resident at Duke, reported at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress. “While the robotic approach is still in its infancy, the technology is associated with increased operative times without improved clinical outcomes, so our study suggests that the routine use of robotic surgery for colectomy may not be financially justifiable at this time.”

The study sampled the American College of Surgeons’ National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP) database for patients who had either a robotic or laparoscopic colectomy from 2012 to 2013. Among the 15,976 patients included, 498 of them (3.1%) had robotic colectomy, Dr. Ezekian said.

“The major finding of our study was that robotic-assisted colectomy was associated with roughly 30-minute longer operative times, whereas the short-term clinical outcomes were comparable between the two groups,” Dr. Ezekian said. “This held true for a subset analysis of patients undergoing segmental colectomy only.”

The analysis found no significant difference between the two approaches in rates of wound complications, urinary tract infections, cardiopulmonary or thromboembolic complications, kidney failure or insufficiency, anastomotic leaks, transfusions, unplanned readmissions, or 30-day death.

The key difference was in the operative times associated with each approach. The median time for robotic-assisted colectomy was 196 minutes vs. 166 minutes for the laparoscopic approach. The study found a similar gap for segmental resections only: 190 minutes for the robotic-assisted approach vs. 153 minutes for the laparoscopic approach.

Dr. Ezekian acknowledged that this observation might merely reflect an early experience with this novel technology. “A future direction for this research is to see if operative times for robotic-assisted surgery decrease over time once there are more years in the NSQIP database or in single-institution studies,” he said.

The authors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Sections
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Robotic-assisted colectomy took longer than the laparoscopic operation but didn’t result in better surgical outcomes in a large NSQIP data–based study.

As health care moves away from fee-for-service to a value-based model, the longer operative times and comparative outcomes to laparoscopic colectomy suggest that the use of robotic technologies in straightforward colon resections may not be justified at this time, investigators at Duke University concluded.

Dr. Brian Ezekian

“This is the largest analysis to date of robotic-assisted vs. laparoscopic colectomy,” Dr. Brian Ezekian, general surgery resident at Duke, reported at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress. “While the robotic approach is still in its infancy, the technology is associated with increased operative times without improved clinical outcomes, so our study suggests that the routine use of robotic surgery for colectomy may not be financially justifiable at this time.”

The study sampled the American College of Surgeons’ National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP) database for patients who had either a robotic or laparoscopic colectomy from 2012 to 2013. Among the 15,976 patients included, 498 of them (3.1%) had robotic colectomy, Dr. Ezekian said.

“The major finding of our study was that robotic-assisted colectomy was associated with roughly 30-minute longer operative times, whereas the short-term clinical outcomes were comparable between the two groups,” Dr. Ezekian said. “This held true for a subset analysis of patients undergoing segmental colectomy only.”

The analysis found no significant difference between the two approaches in rates of wound complications, urinary tract infections, cardiopulmonary or thromboembolic complications, kidney failure or insufficiency, anastomotic leaks, transfusions, unplanned readmissions, or 30-day death.

The key difference was in the operative times associated with each approach. The median time for robotic-assisted colectomy was 196 minutes vs. 166 minutes for the laparoscopic approach. The study found a similar gap for segmental resections only: 190 minutes for the robotic-assisted approach vs. 153 minutes for the laparoscopic approach.

Dr. Ezekian acknowledged that this observation might merely reflect an early experience with this novel technology. “A future direction for this research is to see if operative times for robotic-assisted surgery decrease over time once there are more years in the NSQIP database or in single-institution studies,” he said.

The authors had no financial relationships to disclose.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Robotic-assisted colectomy took longer than the laparoscopic operation but didn’t result in better surgical outcomes in a large NSQIP data–based study.

As health care moves away from fee-for-service to a value-based model, the longer operative times and comparative outcomes to laparoscopic colectomy suggest that the use of robotic technologies in straightforward colon resections may not be justified at this time, investigators at Duke University concluded.

Dr. Brian Ezekian

“This is the largest analysis to date of robotic-assisted vs. laparoscopic colectomy,” Dr. Brian Ezekian, general surgery resident at Duke, reported at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress. “While the robotic approach is still in its infancy, the technology is associated with increased operative times without improved clinical outcomes, so our study suggests that the routine use of robotic surgery for colectomy may not be financially justifiable at this time.”

The study sampled the American College of Surgeons’ National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP) database for patients who had either a robotic or laparoscopic colectomy from 2012 to 2013. Among the 15,976 patients included, 498 of them (3.1%) had robotic colectomy, Dr. Ezekian said.

“The major finding of our study was that robotic-assisted colectomy was associated with roughly 30-minute longer operative times, whereas the short-term clinical outcomes were comparable between the two groups,” Dr. Ezekian said. “This held true for a subset analysis of patients undergoing segmental colectomy only.”

The analysis found no significant difference between the two approaches in rates of wound complications, urinary tract infections, cardiopulmonary or thromboembolic complications, kidney failure or insufficiency, anastomotic leaks, transfusions, unplanned readmissions, or 30-day death.

The key difference was in the operative times associated with each approach. The median time for robotic-assisted colectomy was 196 minutes vs. 166 minutes for the laparoscopic approach. The study found a similar gap for segmental resections only: 190 minutes for the robotic-assisted approach vs. 153 minutes for the laparoscopic approach.

Dr. Ezekian acknowledged that this observation might merely reflect an early experience with this novel technology. “A future direction for this research is to see if operative times for robotic-assisted surgery decrease over time once there are more years in the NSQIP database or in single-institution studies,” he said.

The authors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
Robotic colectomy takes longer, comparable results
Display Headline
Robotic colectomy takes longer, comparable results
Sections
Article Source

AT THE ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Key clinical point: Robotic-assisted colectomy for straightforward resections involves longer operative times than laparoscopic surgery.

Major finding: Robotic-assisted colectomy was associated with roughly 30-minute longer operative times than laparoscopic surgery with comparable short-term clinical outcomes.

Data source: Analysis of 15,976 cases of colectomy in the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program performed from 2012 to 2014.

Disclosures: The study authors reported having no financial disclosures.

Can ‘big data’ predict postop complications?

Article Type
Changed
Wed, 01/02/2019 - 09:29
Display Headline
Can ‘big data’ predict postop complications?

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. The potential of “big data” to predict surgical complications has long been expected and that potential may now in the process of becoming a reality.

As health care moves to a value-based system that penalizes surgeons and hospitals for readmissions, the inability to predict postop complications remains a problem, but investigators at University of Wisconsin have found a way to use “big data” to create a model that may help surgeons identify at-risk individuals before complications occur.

Dr. Shara Feld

Shara Feld, Ph.D., a medical student at Wisconsin, reported on the development of a Markov chain model that sequences random variables to calculate varying states over time. “A Markov model represents the patient progression through a series of health states,” Dr. Feld said at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress

“A Markov chain model combining information about prior complications and the time to occurrence after surgery can inform our likelihood of specific future complications,” she said. “Understanding these relationships among complications can improve our ability to select targeted interventions, to avoid cascades of multiple complications, counsel patients and family on prognosis, assist with care decisions, and develop quality improvement measures.”

The model draws on 3 million operations in the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP) database from 2005 to 2013. Of those, 400,000 cases involved one complication and 132,000 two or more complications, Dr. Feld said. From that, the investigators identified 21 different complications, including superficial, deep and organ surgical site infections, cardiac arrest, and pneumonia. The study accounted for complications within 30 days of the operation.

Dr. Feld pointed to one of the challenges using the existing literature on surgical risk assessment: “We know that patients can have one complication that can snowball into multiple complications, and as this snowball of complications develops, the postoperative risk in patient prognosis can change from what it was based on preoperative risk factors,” she said.

The model was best at predicting death, coma longer than a day, cardiac arrest, septic shock, renal failure, pneumonia, unplanned reintubation, ventilator use of more than 2 days, and bleeding transfusion, Dr. Feld said.

The study also found that complications most likely to cascade to a higher level were cardiac arrest, renal insufficiency or failure, stroke, intubation, septic shock, and coma, Dr. Feld said. For example, a patient who has a coma has an odds ratio greater than 1.5 of dying within 30 days of the operation while the odds ratio for death following a diagnosis of superficial surgical site infection is less than 0.5, the study found.

Evaluating population-based complication risks after surgery was difficult before the large ACS NSQIP database became available to researchers, Dr. Feld said. The model reveals the impact of specific complications, complication timing, and how combinations of multiple postoperative complications change the risk for the development of future complications..

This model has not to date looked at what type of procedure led to the complications but this line of research may be developed in the future, Dr. Feld said.

The authors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Sections
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. The potential of “big data” to predict surgical complications has long been expected and that potential may now in the process of becoming a reality.

As health care moves to a value-based system that penalizes surgeons and hospitals for readmissions, the inability to predict postop complications remains a problem, but investigators at University of Wisconsin have found a way to use “big data” to create a model that may help surgeons identify at-risk individuals before complications occur.

Dr. Shara Feld

Shara Feld, Ph.D., a medical student at Wisconsin, reported on the development of a Markov chain model that sequences random variables to calculate varying states over time. “A Markov model represents the patient progression through a series of health states,” Dr. Feld said at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress

“A Markov chain model combining information about prior complications and the time to occurrence after surgery can inform our likelihood of specific future complications,” she said. “Understanding these relationships among complications can improve our ability to select targeted interventions, to avoid cascades of multiple complications, counsel patients and family on prognosis, assist with care decisions, and develop quality improvement measures.”

The model draws on 3 million operations in the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP) database from 2005 to 2013. Of those, 400,000 cases involved one complication and 132,000 two or more complications, Dr. Feld said. From that, the investigators identified 21 different complications, including superficial, deep and organ surgical site infections, cardiac arrest, and pneumonia. The study accounted for complications within 30 days of the operation.

Dr. Feld pointed to one of the challenges using the existing literature on surgical risk assessment: “We know that patients can have one complication that can snowball into multiple complications, and as this snowball of complications develops, the postoperative risk in patient prognosis can change from what it was based on preoperative risk factors,” she said.

The model was best at predicting death, coma longer than a day, cardiac arrest, septic shock, renal failure, pneumonia, unplanned reintubation, ventilator use of more than 2 days, and bleeding transfusion, Dr. Feld said.

The study also found that complications most likely to cascade to a higher level were cardiac arrest, renal insufficiency or failure, stroke, intubation, septic shock, and coma, Dr. Feld said. For example, a patient who has a coma has an odds ratio greater than 1.5 of dying within 30 days of the operation while the odds ratio for death following a diagnosis of superficial surgical site infection is less than 0.5, the study found.

Evaluating population-based complication risks after surgery was difficult before the large ACS NSQIP database became available to researchers, Dr. Feld said. The model reveals the impact of specific complications, complication timing, and how combinations of multiple postoperative complications change the risk for the development of future complications..

This model has not to date looked at what type of procedure led to the complications but this line of research may be developed in the future, Dr. Feld said.

The authors had no financial relationships to disclose.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. The potential of “big data” to predict surgical complications has long been expected and that potential may now in the process of becoming a reality.

As health care moves to a value-based system that penalizes surgeons and hospitals for readmissions, the inability to predict postop complications remains a problem, but investigators at University of Wisconsin have found a way to use “big data” to create a model that may help surgeons identify at-risk individuals before complications occur.

Dr. Shara Feld

Shara Feld, Ph.D., a medical student at Wisconsin, reported on the development of a Markov chain model that sequences random variables to calculate varying states over time. “A Markov model represents the patient progression through a series of health states,” Dr. Feld said at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress

“A Markov chain model combining information about prior complications and the time to occurrence after surgery can inform our likelihood of specific future complications,” she said. “Understanding these relationships among complications can improve our ability to select targeted interventions, to avoid cascades of multiple complications, counsel patients and family on prognosis, assist with care decisions, and develop quality improvement measures.”

The model draws on 3 million operations in the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP) database from 2005 to 2013. Of those, 400,000 cases involved one complication and 132,000 two or more complications, Dr. Feld said. From that, the investigators identified 21 different complications, including superficial, deep and organ surgical site infections, cardiac arrest, and pneumonia. The study accounted for complications within 30 days of the operation.

Dr. Feld pointed to one of the challenges using the existing literature on surgical risk assessment: “We know that patients can have one complication that can snowball into multiple complications, and as this snowball of complications develops, the postoperative risk in patient prognosis can change from what it was based on preoperative risk factors,” she said.

The model was best at predicting death, coma longer than a day, cardiac arrest, septic shock, renal failure, pneumonia, unplanned reintubation, ventilator use of more than 2 days, and bleeding transfusion, Dr. Feld said.

The study also found that complications most likely to cascade to a higher level were cardiac arrest, renal insufficiency or failure, stroke, intubation, septic shock, and coma, Dr. Feld said. For example, a patient who has a coma has an odds ratio greater than 1.5 of dying within 30 days of the operation while the odds ratio for death following a diagnosis of superficial surgical site infection is less than 0.5, the study found.

Evaluating population-based complication risks after surgery was difficult before the large ACS NSQIP database became available to researchers, Dr. Feld said. The model reveals the impact of specific complications, complication timing, and how combinations of multiple postoperative complications change the risk for the development of future complications..

This model has not to date looked at what type of procedure led to the complications but this line of research may be developed in the future, Dr. Feld said.

The authors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
Can ‘big data’ predict postop complications?
Display Headline
Can ‘big data’ predict postop complications?
Sections
Article Source

AT THE ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Key clinical point: A Markov chain model using data from the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program may provide a tool for predicting complications after surgery.

Major finding: The model was best at predicting death, coma longer than a day, cardiac arrest, septic shock, renal failure, pneumonia, unplanned reintubation, ventilator use of more than 2 days, and bleeding.

Data source: The model draws on 3 million operations in the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP) database from 2005 to 2013.

Disclosures: The study authors reported having no financial disclosures.

The no-operation quality assessment ‘blind spot’

Article Type
Changed
Thu, 03/28/2019 - 15:12
Display Headline
The no-operation quality assessment ‘blind spot’

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – About one-third of patients admitted to the hospital for abdominal problems like diverticulitis and small bowel obstruction get discharged without having surgery, but their outcomes are not typically included in quality assessment, leaving this group of patients in a “blind spot” of surgical quality, according to Dr. Michael Wandling.

However, researchers from Northwestern University in Chicago have analyzed data from the Nationwide (National) Inpatient Sample and determined how many cases of diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction (SBO), cholecystitis, and acute appendicitis are managed without surgery and the clinical factors that may influence that, he reported at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Richard Mark Kirkner
Dr. Michael Wandling

“Surgeons frequently will admit patients for nonoperative management of diagnoses such as diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction, cholecystitis, and perforated appendicitis,” said Dr. Wandling, a general surgery resident at Northwestern. “Yet nonoperative management does not really factor into current surgical quality assessment. In fact, nonoperative management is not frequently evaluated, and utilization rates have not even really been quantified.”

The researchers’ goal was to evaluate hospital-level variability in nonoperative management practices and identify hospital characteristics associated with high rates of nonoperative management, Dr. Wandling said.

“What we found was that smaller bed size, fewer annual discharges, being a public government-run hospital, being a nonteaching hospital, and being rural or located in the Midwest were all associated with greater use of nonoperative management,” he said.

They extracted a sample from the Nationwide (National) Inpatient Sample that analyzed admission and discharge data on 1.6 million patients admitted for one of the four studied diagnoses from 1998 to 2011. Overall, the four diagnoses accounted for more than 500,000 annual admissions, “and this rate has been increasing over time,” Dr. Wandling said. To calculate rates of nonoperative management for each diagnosis, the researchers concentrated on data from 2010 and 2011. They found the following rates of nonoperative management: 87.1% for diverticulitis, 38.1% for SBO, 11.3% for cholecystitis, and 3.7% for appendicitis. The overall rate of nonoperative management for all four diagnoses was 32.8%, Dr. Wandling said.

They also evaluated the overall rates of nonoperative management for each year from 1998 to 2011 and found they steadily increased from 25.6% to 32.8%, Dr. Wandling said. “Nonoperative management is not uncommon, with approximately 190,000 patients being admitted for nonoperative management each year, and this number has also been increasing,” he said.

Dr. Wandling acknowledged some limitations with the study because it used an administrative dataset with data collected retrospectively and because the data do not track patients after discharge, making it impossible to know if any patients managed nonoperatively were subsequently readmitted for surgery. “Current surgical quality assessment only focuses on patients who have surgery, which can be seen through public reporting programs like Hospital Compare, pay-for-performance initiatives like [Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services] valued-based purchasing, and clinical data registries,” he said. “As a result, patients who are managed nonoperatively are really left in a blind spot of surgical quality.”

Dr. Wandling said he and his coauthors are working with the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program to develop an Emergency General Surgery (EGS) Pilot to evaluate performance in operative and nonoperative care for SBO, cholecystitis, and appendicitis. Fourteen centers have so far collected more than 6 months of data as part of the EGS Pilot, he said, and additional hospitals are currently being recruited to participate.

“Ultimately the goal is to identify optimal nonoperative management strategies in general surgery so that all patients can receive high-quality surgical care, not just those who we operate on,” Dr. Wandling said.

He and his coauthors had no relevant financial disclosures.

References

Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Legacy Keywords
nonoperative management, diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction, cholecystitis, appendicitis
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – About one-third of patients admitted to the hospital for abdominal problems like diverticulitis and small bowel obstruction get discharged without having surgery, but their outcomes are not typically included in quality assessment, leaving this group of patients in a “blind spot” of surgical quality, according to Dr. Michael Wandling.

However, researchers from Northwestern University in Chicago have analyzed data from the Nationwide (National) Inpatient Sample and determined how many cases of diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction (SBO), cholecystitis, and acute appendicitis are managed without surgery and the clinical factors that may influence that, he reported at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Richard Mark Kirkner
Dr. Michael Wandling

“Surgeons frequently will admit patients for nonoperative management of diagnoses such as diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction, cholecystitis, and perforated appendicitis,” said Dr. Wandling, a general surgery resident at Northwestern. “Yet nonoperative management does not really factor into current surgical quality assessment. In fact, nonoperative management is not frequently evaluated, and utilization rates have not even really been quantified.”

The researchers’ goal was to evaluate hospital-level variability in nonoperative management practices and identify hospital characteristics associated with high rates of nonoperative management, Dr. Wandling said.

“What we found was that smaller bed size, fewer annual discharges, being a public government-run hospital, being a nonteaching hospital, and being rural or located in the Midwest were all associated with greater use of nonoperative management,” he said.

They extracted a sample from the Nationwide (National) Inpatient Sample that analyzed admission and discharge data on 1.6 million patients admitted for one of the four studied diagnoses from 1998 to 2011. Overall, the four diagnoses accounted for more than 500,000 annual admissions, “and this rate has been increasing over time,” Dr. Wandling said. To calculate rates of nonoperative management for each diagnosis, the researchers concentrated on data from 2010 and 2011. They found the following rates of nonoperative management: 87.1% for diverticulitis, 38.1% for SBO, 11.3% for cholecystitis, and 3.7% for appendicitis. The overall rate of nonoperative management for all four diagnoses was 32.8%, Dr. Wandling said.

They also evaluated the overall rates of nonoperative management for each year from 1998 to 2011 and found they steadily increased from 25.6% to 32.8%, Dr. Wandling said. “Nonoperative management is not uncommon, with approximately 190,000 patients being admitted for nonoperative management each year, and this number has also been increasing,” he said.

Dr. Wandling acknowledged some limitations with the study because it used an administrative dataset with data collected retrospectively and because the data do not track patients after discharge, making it impossible to know if any patients managed nonoperatively were subsequently readmitted for surgery. “Current surgical quality assessment only focuses on patients who have surgery, which can be seen through public reporting programs like Hospital Compare, pay-for-performance initiatives like [Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services] valued-based purchasing, and clinical data registries,” he said. “As a result, patients who are managed nonoperatively are really left in a blind spot of surgical quality.”

Dr. Wandling said he and his coauthors are working with the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program to develop an Emergency General Surgery (EGS) Pilot to evaluate performance in operative and nonoperative care for SBO, cholecystitis, and appendicitis. Fourteen centers have so far collected more than 6 months of data as part of the EGS Pilot, he said, and additional hospitals are currently being recruited to participate.

“Ultimately the goal is to identify optimal nonoperative management strategies in general surgery so that all patients can receive high-quality surgical care, not just those who we operate on,” Dr. Wandling said.

He and his coauthors had no relevant financial disclosures.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – About one-third of patients admitted to the hospital for abdominal problems like diverticulitis and small bowel obstruction get discharged without having surgery, but their outcomes are not typically included in quality assessment, leaving this group of patients in a “blind spot” of surgical quality, according to Dr. Michael Wandling.

However, researchers from Northwestern University in Chicago have analyzed data from the Nationwide (National) Inpatient Sample and determined how many cases of diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction (SBO), cholecystitis, and acute appendicitis are managed without surgery and the clinical factors that may influence that, he reported at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Richard Mark Kirkner
Dr. Michael Wandling

“Surgeons frequently will admit patients for nonoperative management of diagnoses such as diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction, cholecystitis, and perforated appendicitis,” said Dr. Wandling, a general surgery resident at Northwestern. “Yet nonoperative management does not really factor into current surgical quality assessment. In fact, nonoperative management is not frequently evaluated, and utilization rates have not even really been quantified.”

The researchers’ goal was to evaluate hospital-level variability in nonoperative management practices and identify hospital characteristics associated with high rates of nonoperative management, Dr. Wandling said.

“What we found was that smaller bed size, fewer annual discharges, being a public government-run hospital, being a nonteaching hospital, and being rural or located in the Midwest were all associated with greater use of nonoperative management,” he said.

They extracted a sample from the Nationwide (National) Inpatient Sample that analyzed admission and discharge data on 1.6 million patients admitted for one of the four studied diagnoses from 1998 to 2011. Overall, the four diagnoses accounted for more than 500,000 annual admissions, “and this rate has been increasing over time,” Dr. Wandling said. To calculate rates of nonoperative management for each diagnosis, the researchers concentrated on data from 2010 and 2011. They found the following rates of nonoperative management: 87.1% for diverticulitis, 38.1% for SBO, 11.3% for cholecystitis, and 3.7% for appendicitis. The overall rate of nonoperative management for all four diagnoses was 32.8%, Dr. Wandling said.

They also evaluated the overall rates of nonoperative management for each year from 1998 to 2011 and found they steadily increased from 25.6% to 32.8%, Dr. Wandling said. “Nonoperative management is not uncommon, with approximately 190,000 patients being admitted for nonoperative management each year, and this number has also been increasing,” he said.

Dr. Wandling acknowledged some limitations with the study because it used an administrative dataset with data collected retrospectively and because the data do not track patients after discharge, making it impossible to know if any patients managed nonoperatively were subsequently readmitted for surgery. “Current surgical quality assessment only focuses on patients who have surgery, which can be seen through public reporting programs like Hospital Compare, pay-for-performance initiatives like [Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services] valued-based purchasing, and clinical data registries,” he said. “As a result, patients who are managed nonoperatively are really left in a blind spot of surgical quality.”

Dr. Wandling said he and his coauthors are working with the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program to develop an Emergency General Surgery (EGS) Pilot to evaluate performance in operative and nonoperative care for SBO, cholecystitis, and appendicitis. Fourteen centers have so far collected more than 6 months of data as part of the EGS Pilot, he said, and additional hospitals are currently being recruited to participate.

“Ultimately the goal is to identify optimal nonoperative management strategies in general surgery so that all patients can receive high-quality surgical care, not just those who we operate on,” Dr. Wandling said.

He and his coauthors had no relevant financial disclosures.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
The no-operation quality assessment ‘blind spot’
Display Headline
The no-operation quality assessment ‘blind spot’
Legacy Keywords
nonoperative management, diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction, cholecystitis, appendicitis
Legacy Keywords
nonoperative management, diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction, cholecystitis, appendicitis
Article Source

AT THE ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Key clinical point: Quality assessment of surgical outcomes does not account for cases that are managed medically without an operation; this study evaluated nonoperative management for four common diagnoses of abdominal pain.

Major finding: The overall rate of nonoperative management for diverticulitis, small bowel obstruction, cholecystitis, and appendicitis was 32.8% with rates increasing steadily over the 13-year study period.

Data source: An analysis of a sampling of 1.6 million admissions from the Nationwide (National) Inpatient Sample from 1998 to 2011, with concentration on data from 2010 and 2011.

Disclosures: The study authors reported having no relevant financial disclosures.

Study measures post-thyroidectomy voice changes

Article Type
Changed
Wed, 01/02/2019 - 09:29
Display Headline
Study measures post-thyroidectomy voice changes

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Voice quality changes after thyroid surgery are detectable by using both subjective and objective measures, according to investigators at Monash University in Melbourne, Australia.

After thyroid surgery, up to 80% of patients with functional recurrent laryngeal nerves (RLNs) have reported voice changes, so the investigators set out to evaluate the extent of those voice changes and how the extent of the operation and RLN edema may affect them.

Dr. James Lee

“It has been confirmed that thyroid procedures do alter the voice without necessarily causing a measurable recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy,” said lead investigator Dr. James Lee, “and the change of voice is correlated to the extent of surgery and the amount of nerve swelling.” The findings were presented at the Association of Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

The study evaluated 62 patients who had total and partial thyroidectomy surgery between 2010 and 2011 at the Monash University Endocrine Surgery Unit. To subjectively measure voice quality after surgery, the researchers used the Voice Disorder Index (VDI), which measures voice quality on a 0-40 scale from best to worst. After surgery, the mean VDI score in this group showed a 5.2 plus or minus 1.2–point deterioration from 4.2 to 9.4 (P less than .001). For objective evaluation, the researchers used the Dysphonia Severity Index (DSI), which scores voice quality on a scale of –5 to 5 from worst to best. After surgery, the mean DSI score showed a 1.1 plus or minus 0.2–point deterioration from 3.9 to 2.8 (P less than .001). Two speech pathologists conducted the voice assessments.

“Subjective scoring of both hemithyroidectomy and total thyroidectomy reported worse voice postoperatively,” Dr. Lee said. “However, when you take a close look at the numbers, those undergoing total thyroidectomy reported a higher measure of deterioration in their voice.”

Patients who had either partial and total thyroidectomy reported significant subjective deterioration of their voice with mean VDI change from 5.4 to 7.9 (P = 0.02) and 3.5 to 10.6 (P less than .001), respectively. However, on objective evaluation, only the total thyroidectomy patients showed significant voice deterioration, with a mean DSI change from 4 to 2.5 (P less than .001).

Dr. Lee noted that study outcomes between partial and total thyroidectomy patients diverged in another respect: the impact RLN swelling had on voice deterioration. To evaluate RLN swelling, the researchers measured the diameter of the nerve with Vernier calipers before and after the lobectomy during each operation. RLN diameter increased 0.58 plus or minus 0.05 mm on average (P less than .001). In patients who had partial thyroidectomy, the greater the RLN swelling, the worse the subjective score (P = .03). This was not the case in the total thyroidectomy patients where involvement of two nerves complicates the interaction, he said.

During follow-up, the investigators came upon a revelatory finding. “With median 8-month follow-up, the self-reported, VDI scores had returned to baseline levels,” Dr. Lee said. “Interestingly, not only did the objective DSI scores show a return to baseline levels, but it exceeded the baseline levels, meaning the voice had scored better after surgery than before.” However, he noted only 13 patients completed the follow-up.

“Voice change post-thyroidectomy without recurrent laryngeal nerve injury is a complex phenomenon and is likely multifactorial, and we only looked at two of those factors: the extent of surgery and the gradient of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury with nerve edema as a surrogate,” Dr. Lee said. Future studies should evaluate other factors, including the role of the external branch of the superior laryngeal nerve and patient factors such as diabetes or smoking, he said.

Dr. Lee and his coauthors had no disclosures.

References

Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Voice quality changes after thyroid surgery are detectable by using both subjective and objective measures, according to investigators at Monash University in Melbourne, Australia.

After thyroid surgery, up to 80% of patients with functional recurrent laryngeal nerves (RLNs) have reported voice changes, so the investigators set out to evaluate the extent of those voice changes and how the extent of the operation and RLN edema may affect them.

Dr. James Lee

“It has been confirmed that thyroid procedures do alter the voice without necessarily causing a measurable recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy,” said lead investigator Dr. James Lee, “and the change of voice is correlated to the extent of surgery and the amount of nerve swelling.” The findings were presented at the Association of Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

The study evaluated 62 patients who had total and partial thyroidectomy surgery between 2010 and 2011 at the Monash University Endocrine Surgery Unit. To subjectively measure voice quality after surgery, the researchers used the Voice Disorder Index (VDI), which measures voice quality on a 0-40 scale from best to worst. After surgery, the mean VDI score in this group showed a 5.2 plus or minus 1.2–point deterioration from 4.2 to 9.4 (P less than .001). For objective evaluation, the researchers used the Dysphonia Severity Index (DSI), which scores voice quality on a scale of –5 to 5 from worst to best. After surgery, the mean DSI score showed a 1.1 plus or minus 0.2–point deterioration from 3.9 to 2.8 (P less than .001). Two speech pathologists conducted the voice assessments.

“Subjective scoring of both hemithyroidectomy and total thyroidectomy reported worse voice postoperatively,” Dr. Lee said. “However, when you take a close look at the numbers, those undergoing total thyroidectomy reported a higher measure of deterioration in their voice.”

Patients who had either partial and total thyroidectomy reported significant subjective deterioration of their voice with mean VDI change from 5.4 to 7.9 (P = 0.02) and 3.5 to 10.6 (P less than .001), respectively. However, on objective evaluation, only the total thyroidectomy patients showed significant voice deterioration, with a mean DSI change from 4 to 2.5 (P less than .001).

Dr. Lee noted that study outcomes between partial and total thyroidectomy patients diverged in another respect: the impact RLN swelling had on voice deterioration. To evaluate RLN swelling, the researchers measured the diameter of the nerve with Vernier calipers before and after the lobectomy during each operation. RLN diameter increased 0.58 plus or minus 0.05 mm on average (P less than .001). In patients who had partial thyroidectomy, the greater the RLN swelling, the worse the subjective score (P = .03). This was not the case in the total thyroidectomy patients where involvement of two nerves complicates the interaction, he said.

During follow-up, the investigators came upon a revelatory finding. “With median 8-month follow-up, the self-reported, VDI scores had returned to baseline levels,” Dr. Lee said. “Interestingly, not only did the objective DSI scores show a return to baseline levels, but it exceeded the baseline levels, meaning the voice had scored better after surgery than before.” However, he noted only 13 patients completed the follow-up.

“Voice change post-thyroidectomy without recurrent laryngeal nerve injury is a complex phenomenon and is likely multifactorial, and we only looked at two of those factors: the extent of surgery and the gradient of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury with nerve edema as a surrogate,” Dr. Lee said. Future studies should evaluate other factors, including the role of the external branch of the superior laryngeal nerve and patient factors such as diabetes or smoking, he said.

Dr. Lee and his coauthors had no disclosures.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Voice quality changes after thyroid surgery are detectable by using both subjective and objective measures, according to investigators at Monash University in Melbourne, Australia.

After thyroid surgery, up to 80% of patients with functional recurrent laryngeal nerves (RLNs) have reported voice changes, so the investigators set out to evaluate the extent of those voice changes and how the extent of the operation and RLN edema may affect them.

Dr. James Lee

“It has been confirmed that thyroid procedures do alter the voice without necessarily causing a measurable recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy,” said lead investigator Dr. James Lee, “and the change of voice is correlated to the extent of surgery and the amount of nerve swelling.” The findings were presented at the Association of Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

The study evaluated 62 patients who had total and partial thyroidectomy surgery between 2010 and 2011 at the Monash University Endocrine Surgery Unit. To subjectively measure voice quality after surgery, the researchers used the Voice Disorder Index (VDI), which measures voice quality on a 0-40 scale from best to worst. After surgery, the mean VDI score in this group showed a 5.2 plus or minus 1.2–point deterioration from 4.2 to 9.4 (P less than .001). For objective evaluation, the researchers used the Dysphonia Severity Index (DSI), which scores voice quality on a scale of –5 to 5 from worst to best. After surgery, the mean DSI score showed a 1.1 plus or minus 0.2–point deterioration from 3.9 to 2.8 (P less than .001). Two speech pathologists conducted the voice assessments.

“Subjective scoring of both hemithyroidectomy and total thyroidectomy reported worse voice postoperatively,” Dr. Lee said. “However, when you take a close look at the numbers, those undergoing total thyroidectomy reported a higher measure of deterioration in their voice.”

Patients who had either partial and total thyroidectomy reported significant subjective deterioration of their voice with mean VDI change from 5.4 to 7.9 (P = 0.02) and 3.5 to 10.6 (P less than .001), respectively. However, on objective evaluation, only the total thyroidectomy patients showed significant voice deterioration, with a mean DSI change from 4 to 2.5 (P less than .001).

Dr. Lee noted that study outcomes between partial and total thyroidectomy patients diverged in another respect: the impact RLN swelling had on voice deterioration. To evaluate RLN swelling, the researchers measured the diameter of the nerve with Vernier calipers before and after the lobectomy during each operation. RLN diameter increased 0.58 plus or minus 0.05 mm on average (P less than .001). In patients who had partial thyroidectomy, the greater the RLN swelling, the worse the subjective score (P = .03). This was not the case in the total thyroidectomy patients where involvement of two nerves complicates the interaction, he said.

During follow-up, the investigators came upon a revelatory finding. “With median 8-month follow-up, the self-reported, VDI scores had returned to baseline levels,” Dr. Lee said. “Interestingly, not only did the objective DSI scores show a return to baseline levels, but it exceeded the baseline levels, meaning the voice had scored better after surgery than before.” However, he noted only 13 patients completed the follow-up.

“Voice change post-thyroidectomy without recurrent laryngeal nerve injury is a complex phenomenon and is likely multifactorial, and we only looked at two of those factors: the extent of surgery and the gradient of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury with nerve edema as a surrogate,” Dr. Lee said. Future studies should evaluate other factors, including the role of the external branch of the superior laryngeal nerve and patient factors such as diabetes or smoking, he said.

Dr. Lee and his coauthors had no disclosures.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
Study measures post-thyroidectomy voice changes
Display Headline
Study measures post-thyroidectomy voice changes
Article Source

AT THE ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Key clinical point: Voice changes after thyroid surgery directly correlate to the amount of swelling of the recurrent laryngeal nerves as well as the duration and intensity of the operation.

Major finding: Mean subjective voice scores declined from 4.2 to 9.4 on the Voice Disorder Index and mean objective voice scores declined from 3.9 to 2.8 on the Dysphonia Severity Index after thyroidectomy.

Data source: Sixty-two patients undergoing total and hemithyroidectomy were prospectively recruited from the Monash University Endocrine Surgery Unit between 2010 and 2011.

Disclosures: The study authors reported having no financial disclosures.

Prepared surgery patients less likely to boomerang

Article Type
Changed
Thu, 03/28/2019 - 15:12
Display Headline
Prepared surgery patients less likely to boomerang

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Patients who report receiving and using materials to help them prepare for surgery and its aftermath are less likely to be readmitted, according to results of a large surgical patient survey.

Readmissions after surgery have become anathema to doctors and hospitals as government and commercial payers ratchet up penalties, but a study presented at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress has found that giving patients written instructions, handouts, and videos and directing them to multimedia and online sources can reduce the risk of readmission after surgery by about two-thirds.

Dr. Luke Martin, a general surgery resident at the University of Utah, Salt Lake City, presented results from a nationwide online survey of 1,917 people who either had surgery in the past year or were relatives or caregivers of someone who did.

“We found a direct relationship between the quantity of resources used and the patient-reported feelings of preparedness,” Dr. Martin said. “We found that feeling unprepared or using no resources was associated with an increased 30-day risk of readmission.”

The study analyzed respondents’ feelings of preparedness before surgery and after surgery but before discharge. Those who felt prepared before surgery had a 30-day readmission rate of 8% vs. 23% for those who did not feel prepared. Rates were similar for those who felt prepared after surgery and those who felt unprepared: 9% vs. 23%. The overall readmission rate of 10% “is in line with expected results,” Dr. Martin said. “Using any resource was associated with a 10% rate of readmission, whereas using no resources was associated with a 31% rate of 30-day readmission,” Dr. Martin said.

“The bottom line is that health information resources have not been well studied in surgical patients, and no matter what types of resources we provide patients, sometimes they go out and find their own health information resources and supplements,” Dr. Martin said.

Overall, 64% of respondents said they felt very prepared before and after surgery and before leaving the hospital; 8% felt very unprepared before their operations, and 4% felt that way before leaving the hospital.

Patients who felt prepared were most likely to report being given multiple health information resources before surgery (97% vs. 79%, P less than .001) and before leaving the hospital (91% vs. 85%, P = .02). Resources included face-to-face meetings, written instructions, Internet sites, videos, and smartphone applications.

Patients who reported receiving one or more resources before surgery had rates of feeling prepared exceeding 90%. Those who said they had received three or more resources had almost universal rates of feeling prepared. On the other hand, only about 60% of patients who claimed they did not receive resources before their operations felt prepared.

The researchers also looked at whether survey respondents reported that they actually utilized the resources they were given before their operations or if they sought out resources on their own.

“We found that the very commonly provided written instructions are used by patients less than half the time, 41%, vs. a 90% rate of having them provided,” Dr. Martin said. The converse was true of utilization of Internet resources; only 17% of respondents said they were provided with Internet resources, but 45% said they utilized them.

“We should as providers ensure access to more resources because patients who use more resources or are provided with more resources feel more prepared to transition after surgical procedures, and perhaps we should personalize resources to patients’ preferences, learning styles, and levels of health literacy so that we can ensure they feel prepared to transition before and after their surgical procedure,” Dr. Martin said.

 During the discussion, Dr. Dawn Elfenbein of the University of California, Irvine, cautioned against using quantity of information as the only measure. “We give our patients written instructions and websites, and they say they actually don’t use the information because we give them too much and it needs to be better organized,” she said. ”Sometimes accessibility is part of the issue, and quality is also important.”

Dr. Matthew Corriere of Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, N.C., had another take on patient preparation for surgery. “I think those patients who do not have Internet access are a real goldmine for readmission,” he said.

Dr. Martin and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Legacy Keywords
preparation, surgery, boomerang
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Patients who report receiving and using materials to help them prepare for surgery and its aftermath are less likely to be readmitted, according to results of a large surgical patient survey.

Readmissions after surgery have become anathema to doctors and hospitals as government and commercial payers ratchet up penalties, but a study presented at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress has found that giving patients written instructions, handouts, and videos and directing them to multimedia and online sources can reduce the risk of readmission after surgery by about two-thirds.

Dr. Luke Martin, a general surgery resident at the University of Utah, Salt Lake City, presented results from a nationwide online survey of 1,917 people who either had surgery in the past year or were relatives or caregivers of someone who did.

“We found a direct relationship between the quantity of resources used and the patient-reported feelings of preparedness,” Dr. Martin said. “We found that feeling unprepared or using no resources was associated with an increased 30-day risk of readmission.”

The study analyzed respondents’ feelings of preparedness before surgery and after surgery but before discharge. Those who felt prepared before surgery had a 30-day readmission rate of 8% vs. 23% for those who did not feel prepared. Rates were similar for those who felt prepared after surgery and those who felt unprepared: 9% vs. 23%. The overall readmission rate of 10% “is in line with expected results,” Dr. Martin said. “Using any resource was associated with a 10% rate of readmission, whereas using no resources was associated with a 31% rate of 30-day readmission,” Dr. Martin said.

“The bottom line is that health information resources have not been well studied in surgical patients, and no matter what types of resources we provide patients, sometimes they go out and find their own health information resources and supplements,” Dr. Martin said.

Overall, 64% of respondents said they felt very prepared before and after surgery and before leaving the hospital; 8% felt very unprepared before their operations, and 4% felt that way before leaving the hospital.

Patients who felt prepared were most likely to report being given multiple health information resources before surgery (97% vs. 79%, P less than .001) and before leaving the hospital (91% vs. 85%, P = .02). Resources included face-to-face meetings, written instructions, Internet sites, videos, and smartphone applications.

Patients who reported receiving one or more resources before surgery had rates of feeling prepared exceeding 90%. Those who said they had received three or more resources had almost universal rates of feeling prepared. On the other hand, only about 60% of patients who claimed they did not receive resources before their operations felt prepared.

The researchers also looked at whether survey respondents reported that they actually utilized the resources they were given before their operations or if they sought out resources on their own.

“We found that the very commonly provided written instructions are used by patients less than half the time, 41%, vs. a 90% rate of having them provided,” Dr. Martin said. The converse was true of utilization of Internet resources; only 17% of respondents said they were provided with Internet resources, but 45% said they utilized them.

“We should as providers ensure access to more resources because patients who use more resources or are provided with more resources feel more prepared to transition after surgical procedures, and perhaps we should personalize resources to patients’ preferences, learning styles, and levels of health literacy so that we can ensure they feel prepared to transition before and after their surgical procedure,” Dr. Martin said.

 During the discussion, Dr. Dawn Elfenbein of the University of California, Irvine, cautioned against using quantity of information as the only measure. “We give our patients written instructions and websites, and they say they actually don’t use the information because we give them too much and it needs to be better organized,” she said. ”Sometimes accessibility is part of the issue, and quality is also important.”

Dr. Matthew Corriere of Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, N.C., had another take on patient preparation for surgery. “I think those patients who do not have Internet access are a real goldmine for readmission,” he said.

Dr. Martin and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Patients who report receiving and using materials to help them prepare for surgery and its aftermath are less likely to be readmitted, according to results of a large surgical patient survey.

Readmissions after surgery have become anathema to doctors and hospitals as government and commercial payers ratchet up penalties, but a study presented at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress has found that giving patients written instructions, handouts, and videos and directing them to multimedia and online sources can reduce the risk of readmission after surgery by about two-thirds.

Dr. Luke Martin, a general surgery resident at the University of Utah, Salt Lake City, presented results from a nationwide online survey of 1,917 people who either had surgery in the past year or were relatives or caregivers of someone who did.

“We found a direct relationship between the quantity of resources used and the patient-reported feelings of preparedness,” Dr. Martin said. “We found that feeling unprepared or using no resources was associated with an increased 30-day risk of readmission.”

The study analyzed respondents’ feelings of preparedness before surgery and after surgery but before discharge. Those who felt prepared before surgery had a 30-day readmission rate of 8% vs. 23% for those who did not feel prepared. Rates were similar for those who felt prepared after surgery and those who felt unprepared: 9% vs. 23%. The overall readmission rate of 10% “is in line with expected results,” Dr. Martin said. “Using any resource was associated with a 10% rate of readmission, whereas using no resources was associated with a 31% rate of 30-day readmission,” Dr. Martin said.

“The bottom line is that health information resources have not been well studied in surgical patients, and no matter what types of resources we provide patients, sometimes they go out and find their own health information resources and supplements,” Dr. Martin said.

Overall, 64% of respondents said they felt very prepared before and after surgery and before leaving the hospital; 8% felt very unprepared before their operations, and 4% felt that way before leaving the hospital.

Patients who felt prepared were most likely to report being given multiple health information resources before surgery (97% vs. 79%, P less than .001) and before leaving the hospital (91% vs. 85%, P = .02). Resources included face-to-face meetings, written instructions, Internet sites, videos, and smartphone applications.

Patients who reported receiving one or more resources before surgery had rates of feeling prepared exceeding 90%. Those who said they had received three or more resources had almost universal rates of feeling prepared. On the other hand, only about 60% of patients who claimed they did not receive resources before their operations felt prepared.

The researchers also looked at whether survey respondents reported that they actually utilized the resources they were given before their operations or if they sought out resources on their own.

“We found that the very commonly provided written instructions are used by patients less than half the time, 41%, vs. a 90% rate of having them provided,” Dr. Martin said. The converse was true of utilization of Internet resources; only 17% of respondents said they were provided with Internet resources, but 45% said they utilized them.

“We should as providers ensure access to more resources because patients who use more resources or are provided with more resources feel more prepared to transition after surgical procedures, and perhaps we should personalize resources to patients’ preferences, learning styles, and levels of health literacy so that we can ensure they feel prepared to transition before and after their surgical procedure,” Dr. Martin said.

 During the discussion, Dr. Dawn Elfenbein of the University of California, Irvine, cautioned against using quantity of information as the only measure. “We give our patients written instructions and websites, and they say they actually don’t use the information because we give them too much and it needs to be better organized,” she said. ”Sometimes accessibility is part of the issue, and quality is also important.”

Dr. Matthew Corriere of Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, N.C., had another take on patient preparation for surgery. “I think those patients who do not have Internet access are a real goldmine for readmission,” he said.

Dr. Martin and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
Prepared surgery patients less likely to boomerang
Display Headline
Prepared surgery patients less likely to boomerang
Legacy Keywords
preparation, surgery, boomerang
Legacy Keywords
preparation, surgery, boomerang
Article Source

AT THE ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Key clinical point: The amount and quality of information patients report receiving before an operation and discharge are correlated to how likely patients are to be readmitted after surgery.

Major finding: Patients who felt prepared before surgery had a 30-day readmission rate of 8% vs. 23% for those who did not feel prepared.

Data source: A nationwide online survey of 1,917 people who either had surgery in the past year or were relatives or caregivers of someone who did.

Disclosures: The study authors reported having no relevant financial disclosures.

Stanford program takes aim at resident burnout

Article Type
Changed
Thu, 03/28/2019 - 15:12
Display Headline
Stanford program takes aim at resident burnout

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – When an admired surgical resident from Stanford (Calif.) University took his own life during his fellowship within 4 months of completing his residency, it sent a wake-up call to the residency program directors that burnout of surgical and medical residents was real and that something had to be done about it.

So Stanford launched a programmed approach to address resident burnout that includes group counseling, retreats, and even a fully stocked refrigerator accessible 24 hours a day, and found that after 3 years residents reported feeling more “in balance” than they did before the program started, said Dr. Claudia Mueller, a pediatric surgeon at Stanford, who presented a poster on the program at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Dr. Claudia Mueller

The surgery department at Stanford has charted the progress of the program to address burnout among surgical residents. The effort started with the creation of a committee at the behest of Dr. Ralph Greco, former Stanford residency program director and study coauthor. “This group was intentionally resident driven so that we could figure out how best to look at four concepts of wellness – psychological, physical, social, and professional – from the resident perspective, because all four areas are necessary,” Dr. Mueller said.

Components of the program include outside group activities, group sessions on a 4- to 6-week schedule with a psychologist who is also available for individual sessions, and wellness visits to doctors.

To evaluate the program, the study authors had the surgical residents complete two different surveys, the Life Balance survey and the Causes of Stress survey, at separate times during 2013-2015. In the first assessment, only 5 of 25 residents surveyed achieved scores indicating their lives were in balance. “We knew that something was off,” Dr. Mueller said.

First-year residents were more likely to report feeling in balance than were more senior colleagues, Dr. Mueller said. “After about 3 years, we looked at how residents were doing in terms of balance, and what we found is that there have been some improvements, although not as many as we would like,” she said. “Junior residents in particular seemed to have shown some improvements in their overall balance.”

The concept is reproducible at other institutions, Dr. Mueller said. Dr. Ellen Morrow, a former Stanford resident, has started a similar program at the University of Utah, and other residency managers have approached Stanford for advice. Dr. Mueller said she believes that one key to the program is the involvement of residents. “It has to be what the residents want, not what we think they want,” she said.

“Our program came out of a very tragic event,” Dr. Mueller said. “We’re trying obviously not only to prevent a tragedy like that from happening again, but to also improve the lives of residents overall. The burnout is everywhere.”

Dr. Mueller said she had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Legacy Keywords
resident, burnout, program
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – When an admired surgical resident from Stanford (Calif.) University took his own life during his fellowship within 4 months of completing his residency, it sent a wake-up call to the residency program directors that burnout of surgical and medical residents was real and that something had to be done about it.

So Stanford launched a programmed approach to address resident burnout that includes group counseling, retreats, and even a fully stocked refrigerator accessible 24 hours a day, and found that after 3 years residents reported feeling more “in balance” than they did before the program started, said Dr. Claudia Mueller, a pediatric surgeon at Stanford, who presented a poster on the program at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Dr. Claudia Mueller

The surgery department at Stanford has charted the progress of the program to address burnout among surgical residents. The effort started with the creation of a committee at the behest of Dr. Ralph Greco, former Stanford residency program director and study coauthor. “This group was intentionally resident driven so that we could figure out how best to look at four concepts of wellness – psychological, physical, social, and professional – from the resident perspective, because all four areas are necessary,” Dr. Mueller said.

Components of the program include outside group activities, group sessions on a 4- to 6-week schedule with a psychologist who is also available for individual sessions, and wellness visits to doctors.

To evaluate the program, the study authors had the surgical residents complete two different surveys, the Life Balance survey and the Causes of Stress survey, at separate times during 2013-2015. In the first assessment, only 5 of 25 residents surveyed achieved scores indicating their lives were in balance. “We knew that something was off,” Dr. Mueller said.

First-year residents were more likely to report feeling in balance than were more senior colleagues, Dr. Mueller said. “After about 3 years, we looked at how residents were doing in terms of balance, and what we found is that there have been some improvements, although not as many as we would like,” she said. “Junior residents in particular seemed to have shown some improvements in their overall balance.”

The concept is reproducible at other institutions, Dr. Mueller said. Dr. Ellen Morrow, a former Stanford resident, has started a similar program at the University of Utah, and other residency managers have approached Stanford for advice. Dr. Mueller said she believes that one key to the program is the involvement of residents. “It has to be what the residents want, not what we think they want,” she said.

“Our program came out of a very tragic event,” Dr. Mueller said. “We’re trying obviously not only to prevent a tragedy like that from happening again, but to also improve the lives of residents overall. The burnout is everywhere.”

Dr. Mueller said she had no financial relationships to disclose.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – When an admired surgical resident from Stanford (Calif.) University took his own life during his fellowship within 4 months of completing his residency, it sent a wake-up call to the residency program directors that burnout of surgical and medical residents was real and that something had to be done about it.

So Stanford launched a programmed approach to address resident burnout that includes group counseling, retreats, and even a fully stocked refrigerator accessible 24 hours a day, and found that after 3 years residents reported feeling more “in balance” than they did before the program started, said Dr. Claudia Mueller, a pediatric surgeon at Stanford, who presented a poster on the program at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress.

Dr. Claudia Mueller

The surgery department at Stanford has charted the progress of the program to address burnout among surgical residents. The effort started with the creation of a committee at the behest of Dr. Ralph Greco, former Stanford residency program director and study coauthor. “This group was intentionally resident driven so that we could figure out how best to look at four concepts of wellness – psychological, physical, social, and professional – from the resident perspective, because all four areas are necessary,” Dr. Mueller said.

Components of the program include outside group activities, group sessions on a 4- to 6-week schedule with a psychologist who is also available for individual sessions, and wellness visits to doctors.

To evaluate the program, the study authors had the surgical residents complete two different surveys, the Life Balance survey and the Causes of Stress survey, at separate times during 2013-2015. In the first assessment, only 5 of 25 residents surveyed achieved scores indicating their lives were in balance. “We knew that something was off,” Dr. Mueller said.

First-year residents were more likely to report feeling in balance than were more senior colleagues, Dr. Mueller said. “After about 3 years, we looked at how residents were doing in terms of balance, and what we found is that there have been some improvements, although not as many as we would like,” she said. “Junior residents in particular seemed to have shown some improvements in their overall balance.”

The concept is reproducible at other institutions, Dr. Mueller said. Dr. Ellen Morrow, a former Stanford resident, has started a similar program at the University of Utah, and other residency managers have approached Stanford for advice. Dr. Mueller said she believes that one key to the program is the involvement of residents. “It has to be what the residents want, not what we think they want,” she said.

“Our program came out of a very tragic event,” Dr. Mueller said. “We’re trying obviously not only to prevent a tragedy like that from happening again, but to also improve the lives of residents overall. The burnout is everywhere.”

Dr. Mueller said she had no financial relationships to disclose.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
Stanford program takes aim at resident burnout
Display Headline
Stanford program takes aim at resident burnout
Legacy Keywords
resident, burnout, program
Legacy Keywords
resident, burnout, program
Article Source

AT THE ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Emergency hernia surgery risk predicted by access, age, and race

Article Type
Changed
Thu, 03/28/2019 - 15:12
Display Headline
Emergency hernia surgery risk predicted by access, age, and race

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Age and access to medical care may be key drivers of emergency surgery for ventral hernia repair, a large retrospective study has found.

Patients who do not have health insurance, are advanced in age, are black or Hispanic, or have unrelated health problems are at significantly higher risk than other patients with hernias of having emergency surgery for ventral hernia repair, facing a higher risk of death, a higher cost, and a longer hospital stay, Dr. Lindsey Wolf said at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress. “This study demonstrates persistent disparities in access to elective surgery care that must be understood and mitigated,” she said. “The strongest predictor was being uninsured. The self-pay group had an odds ratio of 3.5 for undergoing emergency surgery, compared with those who were primarily insured.”

Richard Mark Kirkner
Dr. Lindsey Wolf

The goal of the study was to identify patient and hospital factors associated with emergency ventral hernia surgery in the U.S. population, said Dr. Wolf of Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston. “Prior studies that have been done on predictors of emergency repair are from universally insured populations,” she said. One was a national cohort study in Denmark, and another involved the Veterans Affairs population, she said. “Both of these identified several demographic and clinical risk factors for emergency hernia repair,” she said.

The current Brigham and Women’s study involved a retrospective cross-sectional data analysis of approximately 453,000 elective and emergency ventral hernia repairs performed from 2003 to 2011 in the Nationwide Inpatient Sample. Any cases that involved a trauma diagnosis were excluded. Forty percent of the cases in the sample were emergency admissions.

When considering the effect of age, the investigators found that the aged 65-75 group had the lowest risk of emergency hernia surgery of all age groups with an odds ratio of 0.77, compared with those under 45 years. Those aged 85 and older, however, had the highest risk of all age groups with an odds ratio of 2.23. “The proportion of the cohort undergoing emergency surgery really increases drastically with age after 75 years,” Dr. Wolf said.

Other factors that had an impact on emergency hernia repair were Medicaid coverage (OR, 1.29, compared with private insurance), black race (OR, 1.64, compared with white race), Hispanic ethnicity (OR, 1.44, compared with non-Hispanic white race/ethnicity), and comorbidities, ranging from 1.13 for one comorbidity to 1.68 for three or more, compared with none.

The study also elucidated a few consequences of emergency ventral hernia repair: 2.58 times higher odds of death, a 15% greater cost per hospital stay, and 26% longer hospital stays.

“Looking forward there are both patient and provider areas to target,” Dr. Wolf said. “For patients, interventions must be designed to populations that may have poor access to elective surgical services.” She acknowledged that race was a strong predictor, “but race is a social construct that may be a proxy to many barriers to access and care.”

The study findings may also help inform surgeons on when to operate on ventral hernias. “In the absence of any clinical guidelines for when a hernia should be repaired, our results with regard to age and multiple comorbidities may assist surgeons in risk stratifying patients when considering [whether] to perform an elective repair,” she said.

Dr. Wolf and her coauthors had no relevant financial conflicts to disclose.

References

Meeting/Event
Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Legacy Keywords
emergency, hernia, surgery, access
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Meeting/Event
Meeting/Event

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Age and access to medical care may be key drivers of emergency surgery for ventral hernia repair, a large retrospective study has found.

Patients who do not have health insurance, are advanced in age, are black or Hispanic, or have unrelated health problems are at significantly higher risk than other patients with hernias of having emergency surgery for ventral hernia repair, facing a higher risk of death, a higher cost, and a longer hospital stay, Dr. Lindsey Wolf said at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress. “This study demonstrates persistent disparities in access to elective surgery care that must be understood and mitigated,” she said. “The strongest predictor was being uninsured. The self-pay group had an odds ratio of 3.5 for undergoing emergency surgery, compared with those who were primarily insured.”

Richard Mark Kirkner
Dr. Lindsey Wolf

The goal of the study was to identify patient and hospital factors associated with emergency ventral hernia surgery in the U.S. population, said Dr. Wolf of Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston. “Prior studies that have been done on predictors of emergency repair are from universally insured populations,” she said. One was a national cohort study in Denmark, and another involved the Veterans Affairs population, she said. “Both of these identified several demographic and clinical risk factors for emergency hernia repair,” she said.

The current Brigham and Women’s study involved a retrospective cross-sectional data analysis of approximately 453,000 elective and emergency ventral hernia repairs performed from 2003 to 2011 in the Nationwide Inpatient Sample. Any cases that involved a trauma diagnosis were excluded. Forty percent of the cases in the sample were emergency admissions.

When considering the effect of age, the investigators found that the aged 65-75 group had the lowest risk of emergency hernia surgery of all age groups with an odds ratio of 0.77, compared with those under 45 years. Those aged 85 and older, however, had the highest risk of all age groups with an odds ratio of 2.23. “The proportion of the cohort undergoing emergency surgery really increases drastically with age after 75 years,” Dr. Wolf said.

Other factors that had an impact on emergency hernia repair were Medicaid coverage (OR, 1.29, compared with private insurance), black race (OR, 1.64, compared with white race), Hispanic ethnicity (OR, 1.44, compared with non-Hispanic white race/ethnicity), and comorbidities, ranging from 1.13 for one comorbidity to 1.68 for three or more, compared with none.

The study also elucidated a few consequences of emergency ventral hernia repair: 2.58 times higher odds of death, a 15% greater cost per hospital stay, and 26% longer hospital stays.

“Looking forward there are both patient and provider areas to target,” Dr. Wolf said. “For patients, interventions must be designed to populations that may have poor access to elective surgical services.” She acknowledged that race was a strong predictor, “but race is a social construct that may be a proxy to many barriers to access and care.”

The study findings may also help inform surgeons on when to operate on ventral hernias. “In the absence of any clinical guidelines for when a hernia should be repaired, our results with regard to age and multiple comorbidities may assist surgeons in risk stratifying patients when considering [whether] to perform an elective repair,” she said.

Dr. Wolf and her coauthors had no relevant financial conflicts to disclose.

JACKSONVILLE, FLA. – Age and access to medical care may be key drivers of emergency surgery for ventral hernia repair, a large retrospective study has found.

Patients who do not have health insurance, are advanced in age, are black or Hispanic, or have unrelated health problems are at significantly higher risk than other patients with hernias of having emergency surgery for ventral hernia repair, facing a higher risk of death, a higher cost, and a longer hospital stay, Dr. Lindsey Wolf said at the Association for Academic Surgery/Society of University Surgeons Academic Surgical Congress. “This study demonstrates persistent disparities in access to elective surgery care that must be understood and mitigated,” she said. “The strongest predictor was being uninsured. The self-pay group had an odds ratio of 3.5 for undergoing emergency surgery, compared with those who were primarily insured.”

Richard Mark Kirkner
Dr. Lindsey Wolf

The goal of the study was to identify patient and hospital factors associated with emergency ventral hernia surgery in the U.S. population, said Dr. Wolf of Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston. “Prior studies that have been done on predictors of emergency repair are from universally insured populations,” she said. One was a national cohort study in Denmark, and another involved the Veterans Affairs population, she said. “Both of these identified several demographic and clinical risk factors for emergency hernia repair,” she said.

The current Brigham and Women’s study involved a retrospective cross-sectional data analysis of approximately 453,000 elective and emergency ventral hernia repairs performed from 2003 to 2011 in the Nationwide Inpatient Sample. Any cases that involved a trauma diagnosis were excluded. Forty percent of the cases in the sample were emergency admissions.

When considering the effect of age, the investigators found that the aged 65-75 group had the lowest risk of emergency hernia surgery of all age groups with an odds ratio of 0.77, compared with those under 45 years. Those aged 85 and older, however, had the highest risk of all age groups with an odds ratio of 2.23. “The proportion of the cohort undergoing emergency surgery really increases drastically with age after 75 years,” Dr. Wolf said.

Other factors that had an impact on emergency hernia repair were Medicaid coverage (OR, 1.29, compared with private insurance), black race (OR, 1.64, compared with white race), Hispanic ethnicity (OR, 1.44, compared with non-Hispanic white race/ethnicity), and comorbidities, ranging from 1.13 for one comorbidity to 1.68 for three or more, compared with none.

The study also elucidated a few consequences of emergency ventral hernia repair: 2.58 times higher odds of death, a 15% greater cost per hospital stay, and 26% longer hospital stays.

“Looking forward there are both patient and provider areas to target,” Dr. Wolf said. “For patients, interventions must be designed to populations that may have poor access to elective surgical services.” She acknowledged that race was a strong predictor, “but race is a social construct that may be a proxy to many barriers to access and care.”

The study findings may also help inform surgeons on when to operate on ventral hernias. “In the absence of any clinical guidelines for when a hernia should be repaired, our results with regard to age and multiple comorbidities may assist surgeons in risk stratifying patients when considering [whether] to perform an elective repair,” she said.

Dr. Wolf and her coauthors had no relevant financial conflicts to disclose.

References

References

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
Emergency hernia surgery risk predicted by access, age, and race
Display Headline
Emergency hernia surgery risk predicted by access, age, and race
Legacy Keywords
emergency, hernia, surgery, access
Legacy Keywords
emergency, hernia, surgery, access
Article Source

AT THE ACADEMIC SURGICAL CONGRESS

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Key clinical point: Disparities among patients more likely to get emergency rather than elective ventral hernia repair include race, insurance status, and advanced age.

Major finding: Among demographic groups with a significantly higher likelihood of undergoing emergency ventral hernia repair were blacks (odds ratio, 1.64), Hispanics (OR, 1.44), and people over age 85 (OR, 2.23).

Data source: Nationwide Inpatient Sample of 453,000 adults who had inpatient ventral hernia repair from 2003 to 2011.

Disclosures: The study authors reported having no relevant financial disclosures.