User login
Anger in adults a red flag for childhood trauma
PARIS –
Investigators examined data on more than 2,250 individuals who were asked about trauma during childhood and a subsequent tendency toward anger or angry outbursts 4 years later.
Results showed that emotional neglect during childhood was associated with approximately a 40% increased likelihood of subsequent anger, while psychological abuse was linked to a 30% increased likelihood.
Childhood physical abuse was also significantly associated with anger in adults, with an increased risk of approximately 40%. The researchers found no link between childhood sexual abuse and adult anger.
“We can’t definitively say that the trauma causes the anger, but the link is clear,” study investigator Nienke De Bles, PhD student, department of psychiatry, Leiden (the Netherlands) University Medical Center, said in a news release.
“Being easily angered can have several consequences,” she continued. “It can make personal interactions more difficult, and it can have consequences for your mental health and well-being, but people who get angry easily also have a greater tendency to discontinue psychiatric treatment, so this anger may mean that it reduces their chances of a better life,” she added.
Ms. De Bles believes that “it should be standard practice to ask depression and anxiety sufferers about anger and past trauma, even if the patient is not exhibiting current anger.”
The findings were presented at the European Psychiatric Association 2023 Congress.
A ‘red flag’ for abuse
“Psychiatric treatments for past trauma may differ from treatments for depression, so psychiatrists need to try to understand the cause so that they can offer the correct treatment to each patient,” said Ms. De Bles.
Ms. De Bles noted that childhood trauma has many negative consequences later in life and that it is associated with a higher prevalence of adult depression and anxiety.
“There are several potential mechanisms for psychopathology in the context of childhood trauma, and emotion regulation seems to be one of the key mechanisms,” she said.
The researchers previously found that anger was highly prevalent among patients with affective disorders. It was present in 30% of those with current anxiety or depressive disorder and in 40% of those with comorbid depression and anxiety with a tendency toward anger versus 5% of healthy control persons.
Other studies have shown that anger is associated with poor treatment outcomes and dropping out of treatment.
To further investigate the link between childhood trauma and anger in adulthood, the researchers examined data on 2,271 participants in the Netherlands Study of Depression and Anxiety (NESDA).
Childhood trauma was assessed at baseline using the semistructured Childhood Trauma Interview. Anger was measured at a 4-year follow-up using the Spielberger Trait Anger Subscale, the Anger Attacks Questionnaire, and the borderline and antisocial subscales of the Personality Disorder Questionnaire 4 to identify cluster B personality traits.
Results showed that emotional neglect during childhood was significantly associated with trait anger in adulthood, at an adjusted odds ratio of 1.42 (P < .001), anger attacks (OR, 1.35; P = .004), and borderline (OR, 1.76; P < .001) and antisocial (OR, 1.88; P = .001) personality traits.
Childhood psychological abuse was also significantly associated with later trait anger (OR, 1.28; P = .002), anger attacks (OR, 1.31; P = .024), and borderline (OR, 1.77; P < .001) and antisocial (OR, 1.69; P = .011) traits.
There was also a significant association between childhood psychical abuse and trait anger in adulthood (OR, 1.37; P < .001), anger attacks (OR, 1.48; P = .004), and borderline (OR, 1.71; P < .001) and antisocial (OR, 1.98; P = .002) traits.
There was no significant association between sexual abuse experienced in childhood and later anger or personality traits.
Ms. De Bles said the findings suggest “there is indeed a relationship between childhood trauma and anger in adulthood, and this is something that might be interesting for clinicians, as anger could be a red flag for a history of childhood trauma.”
She said in an interview that anger is a “very normal human emotion” but that it has not been as widely studied as sadness and anxiety.
She suggested that future research could examine the use of trauma-based therapies for patients with a history of childhood trauma and anger.
Overlooked, neglected
Commenting on the findings, Nur Hani Zainal, PhD, department of healthcare policy, Harvard Medical School, Boston, said the findings are “very consistent with the current biopsychosocial models in psychiatry and clinical psychology.”
Dr. Zainal, who was coauthor of a recent study that showed that anger appears to mediate the relationship between childhood trauma and adult psychopathology, said the current study offers a “good, incremental contribution” to the literature.
She noted there are “good uses” for the emotion of anger, as “sometimes we need anger to set healthy boundaries for ourselves.” However, she agreed that, as an aspect of depression, anxiety, and posttraumatic stress disorder, it is often “overlooked.”
Dr. Zainal said that the findings reinforce the importance of thoroughly evaluating adult patients’ experiences during childhood.
Julian Beezhold, MD, secretary general of the EPA and a consultant psychiatrist with the Norwich (England) Medical School, University of East Anglia, commented in the release that anger is a “somewhat neglected symptom.
“The findings are in line with what we see in day-to-day clinical practice and will hopefully help increase the awareness of the importance of both anger and associated childhood trauma.”
The infrastructure for the NESDA study is funded through the Geestkracht program of the Netherlands Organization for Health Research and Development and financial contributions by participating universities and mental health care organizations. The authors disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
PARIS –
Investigators examined data on more than 2,250 individuals who were asked about trauma during childhood and a subsequent tendency toward anger or angry outbursts 4 years later.
Results showed that emotional neglect during childhood was associated with approximately a 40% increased likelihood of subsequent anger, while psychological abuse was linked to a 30% increased likelihood.
Childhood physical abuse was also significantly associated with anger in adults, with an increased risk of approximately 40%. The researchers found no link between childhood sexual abuse and adult anger.
“We can’t definitively say that the trauma causes the anger, but the link is clear,” study investigator Nienke De Bles, PhD student, department of psychiatry, Leiden (the Netherlands) University Medical Center, said in a news release.
“Being easily angered can have several consequences,” she continued. “It can make personal interactions more difficult, and it can have consequences for your mental health and well-being, but people who get angry easily also have a greater tendency to discontinue psychiatric treatment, so this anger may mean that it reduces their chances of a better life,” she added.
Ms. De Bles believes that “it should be standard practice to ask depression and anxiety sufferers about anger and past trauma, even if the patient is not exhibiting current anger.”
The findings were presented at the European Psychiatric Association 2023 Congress.
A ‘red flag’ for abuse
“Psychiatric treatments for past trauma may differ from treatments for depression, so psychiatrists need to try to understand the cause so that they can offer the correct treatment to each patient,” said Ms. De Bles.
Ms. De Bles noted that childhood trauma has many negative consequences later in life and that it is associated with a higher prevalence of adult depression and anxiety.
“There are several potential mechanisms for psychopathology in the context of childhood trauma, and emotion regulation seems to be one of the key mechanisms,” she said.
The researchers previously found that anger was highly prevalent among patients with affective disorders. It was present in 30% of those with current anxiety or depressive disorder and in 40% of those with comorbid depression and anxiety with a tendency toward anger versus 5% of healthy control persons.
Other studies have shown that anger is associated with poor treatment outcomes and dropping out of treatment.
To further investigate the link between childhood trauma and anger in adulthood, the researchers examined data on 2,271 participants in the Netherlands Study of Depression and Anxiety (NESDA).
Childhood trauma was assessed at baseline using the semistructured Childhood Trauma Interview. Anger was measured at a 4-year follow-up using the Spielberger Trait Anger Subscale, the Anger Attacks Questionnaire, and the borderline and antisocial subscales of the Personality Disorder Questionnaire 4 to identify cluster B personality traits.
Results showed that emotional neglect during childhood was significantly associated with trait anger in adulthood, at an adjusted odds ratio of 1.42 (P < .001), anger attacks (OR, 1.35; P = .004), and borderline (OR, 1.76; P < .001) and antisocial (OR, 1.88; P = .001) personality traits.
Childhood psychological abuse was also significantly associated with later trait anger (OR, 1.28; P = .002), anger attacks (OR, 1.31; P = .024), and borderline (OR, 1.77; P < .001) and antisocial (OR, 1.69; P = .011) traits.
There was also a significant association between childhood psychical abuse and trait anger in adulthood (OR, 1.37; P < .001), anger attacks (OR, 1.48; P = .004), and borderline (OR, 1.71; P < .001) and antisocial (OR, 1.98; P = .002) traits.
There was no significant association between sexual abuse experienced in childhood and later anger or personality traits.
Ms. De Bles said the findings suggest “there is indeed a relationship between childhood trauma and anger in adulthood, and this is something that might be interesting for clinicians, as anger could be a red flag for a history of childhood trauma.”
She said in an interview that anger is a “very normal human emotion” but that it has not been as widely studied as sadness and anxiety.
She suggested that future research could examine the use of trauma-based therapies for patients with a history of childhood trauma and anger.
Overlooked, neglected
Commenting on the findings, Nur Hani Zainal, PhD, department of healthcare policy, Harvard Medical School, Boston, said the findings are “very consistent with the current biopsychosocial models in psychiatry and clinical psychology.”
Dr. Zainal, who was coauthor of a recent study that showed that anger appears to mediate the relationship between childhood trauma and adult psychopathology, said the current study offers a “good, incremental contribution” to the literature.
She noted there are “good uses” for the emotion of anger, as “sometimes we need anger to set healthy boundaries for ourselves.” However, she agreed that, as an aspect of depression, anxiety, and posttraumatic stress disorder, it is often “overlooked.”
Dr. Zainal said that the findings reinforce the importance of thoroughly evaluating adult patients’ experiences during childhood.
Julian Beezhold, MD, secretary general of the EPA and a consultant psychiatrist with the Norwich (England) Medical School, University of East Anglia, commented in the release that anger is a “somewhat neglected symptom.
“The findings are in line with what we see in day-to-day clinical practice and will hopefully help increase the awareness of the importance of both anger and associated childhood trauma.”
The infrastructure for the NESDA study is funded through the Geestkracht program of the Netherlands Organization for Health Research and Development and financial contributions by participating universities and mental health care organizations. The authors disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
PARIS –
Investigators examined data on more than 2,250 individuals who were asked about trauma during childhood and a subsequent tendency toward anger or angry outbursts 4 years later.
Results showed that emotional neglect during childhood was associated with approximately a 40% increased likelihood of subsequent anger, while psychological abuse was linked to a 30% increased likelihood.
Childhood physical abuse was also significantly associated with anger in adults, with an increased risk of approximately 40%. The researchers found no link between childhood sexual abuse and adult anger.
“We can’t definitively say that the trauma causes the anger, but the link is clear,” study investigator Nienke De Bles, PhD student, department of psychiatry, Leiden (the Netherlands) University Medical Center, said in a news release.
“Being easily angered can have several consequences,” she continued. “It can make personal interactions more difficult, and it can have consequences for your mental health and well-being, but people who get angry easily also have a greater tendency to discontinue psychiatric treatment, so this anger may mean that it reduces their chances of a better life,” she added.
Ms. De Bles believes that “it should be standard practice to ask depression and anxiety sufferers about anger and past trauma, even if the patient is not exhibiting current anger.”
The findings were presented at the European Psychiatric Association 2023 Congress.
A ‘red flag’ for abuse
“Psychiatric treatments for past trauma may differ from treatments for depression, so psychiatrists need to try to understand the cause so that they can offer the correct treatment to each patient,” said Ms. De Bles.
Ms. De Bles noted that childhood trauma has many negative consequences later in life and that it is associated with a higher prevalence of adult depression and anxiety.
“There are several potential mechanisms for psychopathology in the context of childhood trauma, and emotion regulation seems to be one of the key mechanisms,” she said.
The researchers previously found that anger was highly prevalent among patients with affective disorders. It was present in 30% of those with current anxiety or depressive disorder and in 40% of those with comorbid depression and anxiety with a tendency toward anger versus 5% of healthy control persons.
Other studies have shown that anger is associated with poor treatment outcomes and dropping out of treatment.
To further investigate the link between childhood trauma and anger in adulthood, the researchers examined data on 2,271 participants in the Netherlands Study of Depression and Anxiety (NESDA).
Childhood trauma was assessed at baseline using the semistructured Childhood Trauma Interview. Anger was measured at a 4-year follow-up using the Spielberger Trait Anger Subscale, the Anger Attacks Questionnaire, and the borderline and antisocial subscales of the Personality Disorder Questionnaire 4 to identify cluster B personality traits.
Results showed that emotional neglect during childhood was significantly associated with trait anger in adulthood, at an adjusted odds ratio of 1.42 (P < .001), anger attacks (OR, 1.35; P = .004), and borderline (OR, 1.76; P < .001) and antisocial (OR, 1.88; P = .001) personality traits.
Childhood psychological abuse was also significantly associated with later trait anger (OR, 1.28; P = .002), anger attacks (OR, 1.31; P = .024), and borderline (OR, 1.77; P < .001) and antisocial (OR, 1.69; P = .011) traits.
There was also a significant association between childhood psychical abuse and trait anger in adulthood (OR, 1.37; P < .001), anger attacks (OR, 1.48; P = .004), and borderline (OR, 1.71; P < .001) and antisocial (OR, 1.98; P = .002) traits.
There was no significant association between sexual abuse experienced in childhood and later anger or personality traits.
Ms. De Bles said the findings suggest “there is indeed a relationship between childhood trauma and anger in adulthood, and this is something that might be interesting for clinicians, as anger could be a red flag for a history of childhood trauma.”
She said in an interview that anger is a “very normal human emotion” but that it has not been as widely studied as sadness and anxiety.
She suggested that future research could examine the use of trauma-based therapies for patients with a history of childhood trauma and anger.
Overlooked, neglected
Commenting on the findings, Nur Hani Zainal, PhD, department of healthcare policy, Harvard Medical School, Boston, said the findings are “very consistent with the current biopsychosocial models in psychiatry and clinical psychology.”
Dr. Zainal, who was coauthor of a recent study that showed that anger appears to mediate the relationship between childhood trauma and adult psychopathology, said the current study offers a “good, incremental contribution” to the literature.
She noted there are “good uses” for the emotion of anger, as “sometimes we need anger to set healthy boundaries for ourselves.” However, she agreed that, as an aspect of depression, anxiety, and posttraumatic stress disorder, it is often “overlooked.”
Dr. Zainal said that the findings reinforce the importance of thoroughly evaluating adult patients’ experiences during childhood.
Julian Beezhold, MD, secretary general of the EPA and a consultant psychiatrist with the Norwich (England) Medical School, University of East Anglia, commented in the release that anger is a “somewhat neglected symptom.
“The findings are in line with what we see in day-to-day clinical practice and will hopefully help increase the awareness of the importance of both anger and associated childhood trauma.”
The infrastructure for the NESDA study is funded through the Geestkracht program of the Netherlands Organization for Health Research and Development and financial contributions by participating universities and mental health care organizations. The authors disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
AT EPA 2023
Single-dose psilocybin promising for resistant depression
PARIS –
Known as COMP360, the synthetic agent, a proprietary, purified form of psilocybin, improved symptoms related to mood and anhedonia while leaving aspects such as appetite and weight changes unaffected, reported investigators led by Guy M. Goodwin, PhD, emeritus professor of psychiatry, University of Oxford, England, and chief medical officer, COMPASS Pathways.
The study was presented at the European Psychiatric Association (EPA) 2023 Congress.
100 million affected
Affecting up to 100 million people globally, TRD is “not an official diagnosis,” although it is often defined as the failure to elicit a response with at least two antidepressant treatments, said Dr. Goodwin.
Compared to their counterparts with non-TRD, those with TRD experience higher relapse rates, higher rates of suicidal behavior, and more residual symptoms even when they do respond to treatment.
Previous results from the study known as P-TRD indicated that a single 25-mg dose of COMP360 significantly reduced depression scores for up to 12 weeks when given along with psychological support, although a later analysis suggested the effect subsequently dropped off.
The vast majority of the patients in the trial were naive to psychedelics, and so, Dr. Goodwin explained, they undergo a preparation phase during which they receive psychoeducation and have at least two visits with a therapist, who then stays with them during administration of the drug to offer support if they experience psychological distress.
Following the psilocybin session, participants go through a process known as integration, which involves two sessions with a therapist within 2 weeks.
“That, in our view, is essentially about safety, and about identifying problems that have arisen as a result of taking the drug,” said Dr. Goodwin.
The phase 2b trial examined changes in specific depression symptoms after psilocybin treatment in 233 patients with TRD. Participants were a mean age of 39.8 years and 59% were women. They were randomized to receive one of three doses of the drug: a 1-mg dose (n = 79), a 10-mg dose (n = 75), or a 25-mg dose (n = 79).
The primary outcome was changes in individual items on the Montgomery-Åsberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS) and 16-item Quick Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology–Self Report (QIDS-SR-16) scale.
While the effect on overall depression scores is important, said Dr. Goodwin, many of the items included in the depression assessment scales are “uninformative.”
Reduction in ‘core’ symptoms
Participants were assessed by a blinded rater at baseline, day 1, day 2, and at 1, 2, 3, 6, 9, and 12 weeks after administration of COMP360. The primary endpoint was a reduction in individual items on MADRS and scores from baseline to 3 weeks. Individual items on the QIDS-SR-16 were rated by participants at the same time points.
Investigators found the largest mean changes from baseline were on reported and apparent sadness, lassitude, inability to feel, and concentration difficulties, with “very nice and clear dose-related differences,” Dr. Goodwin said.
The results indicate that the significant benefit with the largest dose at 3 weeks versus baseline was confined to items such as inability to feel and reported and apparent sadness on the MADRS and feeling sad and general interest on the QIDS-SR-16 (Table 1).
The results suggest the effect of COMP360 is “on the core symptoms of depression,” said Dr. Goodwin.
Results were similar for individual items on the QIDS-SR-16, with the greatest changes in items including feeling sad, general interest, energy level, falling asleep, view of myself, concentration/decision-making, and feeling down.
Other scale items, such as decreased appetite, feel restless, and weight changes, showed negligible changes in response to COMP360 therapy and were described by Dr. Goodwin as “inconsequential.”
“Essentially, these items are contributing nothing but noise to the signal,” he said.
He added the results of the study need to be replicated and that plans for phase 3 trials are underway. These studies, he said, are designed to convince the Food and Drug Administration that “this is not just a recreational drug, it’s a medicine.”
Enthusiasm running ahead of the data
Commenting on the findings, Bertha K. Madras, PhD, professor of psychobiology, department of psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, who was not involved in the study, said “hallucinogens are an intriguing class of drugs and I support ongoing high-quality research in this area.”
However, she told this news organization that the “breathtaking endorsement of this drug is far ahead of scientific data.”
She cited concerns such as the “narrow demographics” of participants, their previous experience with and expectations of hallucinogens, the “potential for symptom fluidity of enrollees,” such as depression evolving into psychosis, and the “undefined role” of the therapist during a hallucinogenic session.
“Finally, I am concerned that enthusiasm for therapeutic potential has been, and will continue to be, preempted and directed towards legalization and widespread access for vulnerable populations,” Dr. Madras said.
This, she said, “is occurring at breakneck speed in the U.S., with scant resistance or skepticism from the investigators engaged in therapeutic assessment.”
The study was funded by COMPASS Pathways. Dr. Goodwin has reported relationships with COMPASS Pathways, Buckley Psytech, Boehringer Ingelheim, Clerkenwell Health, EVA Pharma, Lundbeck, Janssen Global Services, Novartis, Ocean Neurosciences, P1vital, Sage Therapeutics, Servier, Takeda, and WebMD.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
PARIS –
Known as COMP360, the synthetic agent, a proprietary, purified form of psilocybin, improved symptoms related to mood and anhedonia while leaving aspects such as appetite and weight changes unaffected, reported investigators led by Guy M. Goodwin, PhD, emeritus professor of psychiatry, University of Oxford, England, and chief medical officer, COMPASS Pathways.
The study was presented at the European Psychiatric Association (EPA) 2023 Congress.
100 million affected
Affecting up to 100 million people globally, TRD is “not an official diagnosis,” although it is often defined as the failure to elicit a response with at least two antidepressant treatments, said Dr. Goodwin.
Compared to their counterparts with non-TRD, those with TRD experience higher relapse rates, higher rates of suicidal behavior, and more residual symptoms even when they do respond to treatment.
Previous results from the study known as P-TRD indicated that a single 25-mg dose of COMP360 significantly reduced depression scores for up to 12 weeks when given along with psychological support, although a later analysis suggested the effect subsequently dropped off.
The vast majority of the patients in the trial were naive to psychedelics, and so, Dr. Goodwin explained, they undergo a preparation phase during which they receive psychoeducation and have at least two visits with a therapist, who then stays with them during administration of the drug to offer support if they experience psychological distress.
Following the psilocybin session, participants go through a process known as integration, which involves two sessions with a therapist within 2 weeks.
“That, in our view, is essentially about safety, and about identifying problems that have arisen as a result of taking the drug,” said Dr. Goodwin.
The phase 2b trial examined changes in specific depression symptoms after psilocybin treatment in 233 patients with TRD. Participants were a mean age of 39.8 years and 59% were women. They were randomized to receive one of three doses of the drug: a 1-mg dose (n = 79), a 10-mg dose (n = 75), or a 25-mg dose (n = 79).
The primary outcome was changes in individual items on the Montgomery-Åsberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS) and 16-item Quick Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology–Self Report (QIDS-SR-16) scale.
While the effect on overall depression scores is important, said Dr. Goodwin, many of the items included in the depression assessment scales are “uninformative.”
Reduction in ‘core’ symptoms
Participants were assessed by a blinded rater at baseline, day 1, day 2, and at 1, 2, 3, 6, 9, and 12 weeks after administration of COMP360. The primary endpoint was a reduction in individual items on MADRS and scores from baseline to 3 weeks. Individual items on the QIDS-SR-16 were rated by participants at the same time points.
Investigators found the largest mean changes from baseline were on reported and apparent sadness, lassitude, inability to feel, and concentration difficulties, with “very nice and clear dose-related differences,” Dr. Goodwin said.
The results indicate that the significant benefit with the largest dose at 3 weeks versus baseline was confined to items such as inability to feel and reported and apparent sadness on the MADRS and feeling sad and general interest on the QIDS-SR-16 (Table 1).
The results suggest the effect of COMP360 is “on the core symptoms of depression,” said Dr. Goodwin.
Results were similar for individual items on the QIDS-SR-16, with the greatest changes in items including feeling sad, general interest, energy level, falling asleep, view of myself, concentration/decision-making, and feeling down.
Other scale items, such as decreased appetite, feel restless, and weight changes, showed negligible changes in response to COMP360 therapy and were described by Dr. Goodwin as “inconsequential.”
“Essentially, these items are contributing nothing but noise to the signal,” he said.
He added the results of the study need to be replicated and that plans for phase 3 trials are underway. These studies, he said, are designed to convince the Food and Drug Administration that “this is not just a recreational drug, it’s a medicine.”
Enthusiasm running ahead of the data
Commenting on the findings, Bertha K. Madras, PhD, professor of psychobiology, department of psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, who was not involved in the study, said “hallucinogens are an intriguing class of drugs and I support ongoing high-quality research in this area.”
However, she told this news organization that the “breathtaking endorsement of this drug is far ahead of scientific data.”
She cited concerns such as the “narrow demographics” of participants, their previous experience with and expectations of hallucinogens, the “potential for symptom fluidity of enrollees,” such as depression evolving into psychosis, and the “undefined role” of the therapist during a hallucinogenic session.
“Finally, I am concerned that enthusiasm for therapeutic potential has been, and will continue to be, preempted and directed towards legalization and widespread access for vulnerable populations,” Dr. Madras said.
This, she said, “is occurring at breakneck speed in the U.S., with scant resistance or skepticism from the investigators engaged in therapeutic assessment.”
The study was funded by COMPASS Pathways. Dr. Goodwin has reported relationships with COMPASS Pathways, Buckley Psytech, Boehringer Ingelheim, Clerkenwell Health, EVA Pharma, Lundbeck, Janssen Global Services, Novartis, Ocean Neurosciences, P1vital, Sage Therapeutics, Servier, Takeda, and WebMD.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
PARIS –
Known as COMP360, the synthetic agent, a proprietary, purified form of psilocybin, improved symptoms related to mood and anhedonia while leaving aspects such as appetite and weight changes unaffected, reported investigators led by Guy M. Goodwin, PhD, emeritus professor of psychiatry, University of Oxford, England, and chief medical officer, COMPASS Pathways.
The study was presented at the European Psychiatric Association (EPA) 2023 Congress.
100 million affected
Affecting up to 100 million people globally, TRD is “not an official diagnosis,” although it is often defined as the failure to elicit a response with at least two antidepressant treatments, said Dr. Goodwin.
Compared to their counterparts with non-TRD, those with TRD experience higher relapse rates, higher rates of suicidal behavior, and more residual symptoms even when they do respond to treatment.
Previous results from the study known as P-TRD indicated that a single 25-mg dose of COMP360 significantly reduced depression scores for up to 12 weeks when given along with psychological support, although a later analysis suggested the effect subsequently dropped off.
The vast majority of the patients in the trial were naive to psychedelics, and so, Dr. Goodwin explained, they undergo a preparation phase during which they receive psychoeducation and have at least two visits with a therapist, who then stays with them during administration of the drug to offer support if they experience psychological distress.
Following the psilocybin session, participants go through a process known as integration, which involves two sessions with a therapist within 2 weeks.
“That, in our view, is essentially about safety, and about identifying problems that have arisen as a result of taking the drug,” said Dr. Goodwin.
The phase 2b trial examined changes in specific depression symptoms after psilocybin treatment in 233 patients with TRD. Participants were a mean age of 39.8 years and 59% were women. They were randomized to receive one of three doses of the drug: a 1-mg dose (n = 79), a 10-mg dose (n = 75), or a 25-mg dose (n = 79).
The primary outcome was changes in individual items on the Montgomery-Åsberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS) and 16-item Quick Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology–Self Report (QIDS-SR-16) scale.
While the effect on overall depression scores is important, said Dr. Goodwin, many of the items included in the depression assessment scales are “uninformative.”
Reduction in ‘core’ symptoms
Participants were assessed by a blinded rater at baseline, day 1, day 2, and at 1, 2, 3, 6, 9, and 12 weeks after administration of COMP360. The primary endpoint was a reduction in individual items on MADRS and scores from baseline to 3 weeks. Individual items on the QIDS-SR-16 were rated by participants at the same time points.
Investigators found the largest mean changes from baseline were on reported and apparent sadness, lassitude, inability to feel, and concentration difficulties, with “very nice and clear dose-related differences,” Dr. Goodwin said.
The results indicate that the significant benefit with the largest dose at 3 weeks versus baseline was confined to items such as inability to feel and reported and apparent sadness on the MADRS and feeling sad and general interest on the QIDS-SR-16 (Table 1).
The results suggest the effect of COMP360 is “on the core symptoms of depression,” said Dr. Goodwin.
Results were similar for individual items on the QIDS-SR-16, with the greatest changes in items including feeling sad, general interest, energy level, falling asleep, view of myself, concentration/decision-making, and feeling down.
Other scale items, such as decreased appetite, feel restless, and weight changes, showed negligible changes in response to COMP360 therapy and were described by Dr. Goodwin as “inconsequential.”
“Essentially, these items are contributing nothing but noise to the signal,” he said.
He added the results of the study need to be replicated and that plans for phase 3 trials are underway. These studies, he said, are designed to convince the Food and Drug Administration that “this is not just a recreational drug, it’s a medicine.”
Enthusiasm running ahead of the data
Commenting on the findings, Bertha K. Madras, PhD, professor of psychobiology, department of psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, who was not involved in the study, said “hallucinogens are an intriguing class of drugs and I support ongoing high-quality research in this area.”
However, she told this news organization that the “breathtaking endorsement of this drug is far ahead of scientific data.”
She cited concerns such as the “narrow demographics” of participants, their previous experience with and expectations of hallucinogens, the “potential for symptom fluidity of enrollees,” such as depression evolving into psychosis, and the “undefined role” of the therapist during a hallucinogenic session.
“Finally, I am concerned that enthusiasm for therapeutic potential has been, and will continue to be, preempted and directed towards legalization and widespread access for vulnerable populations,” Dr. Madras said.
This, she said, “is occurring at breakneck speed in the U.S., with scant resistance or skepticism from the investigators engaged in therapeutic assessment.”
The study was funded by COMPASS Pathways. Dr. Goodwin has reported relationships with COMPASS Pathways, Buckley Psytech, Boehringer Ingelheim, Clerkenwell Health, EVA Pharma, Lundbeck, Janssen Global Services, Novartis, Ocean Neurosciences, P1vital, Sage Therapeutics, Servier, Takeda, and WebMD.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
AT EPA 2023
Music at bedtime may aid depression-related insomnia
PARIS –
The Music to Improve Sleep Quality in Adults With Depression and Insomnia (MUSTAFI) trial randomly assigned more than 110 outpatients with depression to either a music intervention or a waiting list. Sleep quality and quality of life significantly improved after listening to music for half an hour at bedtime for 4 weeks.
“This is a low-cost, safe intervention that has no side effects and may easily be implemented in psychiatry” along with existing treatments, lead researcher Helle Nystrup Lund, PhD, unit for depression, Aalborg (Denmark) University Hospital, said in an interview.
The findings were presented at the European Psychiatric Association 2023 Congress, and recently published in the Nordic Journal of Psychiatry.
Difficult to resolve
The researchers noted that insomnia is common in patients with depression and is “difficult to resolve.”
They noted that, while music is commonly used as a sleep aid and a growing evidence base suggests it has positive effects, there have been few investigations into the effectiveness of music for patients with depression-related insomnia.
To fill this research gap, 112 outpatients with depression and comorbid insomnia who were receiving care at a single center were randomly assigned to either an intervention group or a wait list control group.
Participants in the intervention group listened to music for a minimum of 30 minutes at bedtime for 4 weeks. The music was delivered via the MusicStar app, which is available as a free download from the Apple and Android (Google Play) app stores. The app was developed by Dr. Lund and Lars Rye Bertelsen, a PhD student and music therapist at Aalborg University Hospital.
The app is designed as a multicolored star, with each arm of the star linking to a playlist lasting between 30 minutes and 1 hour. Each color of the star indicates a different tempo of music.
Blue playlists, Dr. Lund explained, offer the quietest music, green is more lively, and red is the most dynamic. Gray playlists linked to project-related soundtracks, such as summer rain.
Dr. Lund said organizing the playlists by stimuli and color code, instead of genre, allows users to regulate their level of arousal and makes the music choice intuitive and easy.
She said that the genres of music include New Age, folk, pop, classical, and film soundtracks, “but no hard rock.”
“There’s actually a quite large selection of music available, because studies show that individual choice is important, as are personal preferences,” she said, adding that the endless choices offered by streaming services can cause confusion.
“So we made curated playlists and designed them with well-known pieces, but also with newly composed music not associated with anything,” Dr. Lund said.
Participants were assessed using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale, and two World Health Organization well-being questionnaires (WHO-5, WHOQOL-BREF), as well as actigraphy.
Results showed that, at 4 weeks, participants in the intervention group experienced significant improvements in sleep quality in comparison with control persons. The effect size for the PSQI was –2.1, and for quality of life on the WHO-5, the effect size was 8.4.
A subanalysis revealed that the length of nocturnal sleep in the intervention group increased by an average of 18 minutes during the study from a baseline of approximately 5 hours per night, said Dr. Lund.
However, there were no changes in actigraphy measurements and no significant improvements in HAMD-17 scores.
Dr. Lund said that, on the basis of these positive findings, music intervention as a sleep aid is now offered at Aalborg University Hospital to patients with depression-related insomnia.
Clinically meaningful?
Commenting on the findings, Gerald J. Haeffel, PhD, department of psychology, University of Notre Dame, South Bend, Ind., said that overall, the study showed there was a change in sleep-quality and quality of life scores of “about 10% in each.”
“This, on the surface, would seem to be a meaningful change,” although it is less clear whether it is “clinically meaningful.” Perhaps it is, “but it would be nice to have more information.”
It would be useful, he said, to “show the means for each group pre- to postintervention, along with standard deviations,” he added.
Dr. Haeffel added that on the basis of current results, it isn’t possible to determine whether individuals’ control over music choice is important.
“We have no idea if ‘choice’ or length of playlist had any causal role in the results. One would need to run a study with the same playlist, but in one group people have to listen to whatever song comes on versus another condition in which they get to choose a song off the same list,” he said.
He noted that his group conducted a study in which highly popular music that was chosen by individual participants was found to have a positive effect. Even so, he said, “we could not determine if it was ‘choice’ or ‘popularity’ that caused the positive effects of music.”
In addition, he said, the reason music has a positive effect on insomnia remains unclear.
“It is not because it helped with depression, and it’s not because it’s actually changing objective sleep parameters. It could be that it improves mood right before bed or helps distract people right before bed. At the same time, it could also just be a placebo effect,” said Dr. Haeffel.
In addition, he said, it’s important to note that the music intervention had no comparator, so “maybe just doing something different or getting to talk with researchers created the effect and has nothing to do with music.”
Overall, he believes that there are “not enough data” to use the sleep intervention that was employed in the current study “as primary intervention, but future work could show its usefulness as a supplement.”
Dr. Lund and Mr. Bertelsen reported ownership and sales of the MusicStar app. Dr. Haeffel reported no relevant financial relationships.
PARIS –
The Music to Improve Sleep Quality in Adults With Depression and Insomnia (MUSTAFI) trial randomly assigned more than 110 outpatients with depression to either a music intervention or a waiting list. Sleep quality and quality of life significantly improved after listening to music for half an hour at bedtime for 4 weeks.
“This is a low-cost, safe intervention that has no side effects and may easily be implemented in psychiatry” along with existing treatments, lead researcher Helle Nystrup Lund, PhD, unit for depression, Aalborg (Denmark) University Hospital, said in an interview.
The findings were presented at the European Psychiatric Association 2023 Congress, and recently published in the Nordic Journal of Psychiatry.
Difficult to resolve
The researchers noted that insomnia is common in patients with depression and is “difficult to resolve.”
They noted that, while music is commonly used as a sleep aid and a growing evidence base suggests it has positive effects, there have been few investigations into the effectiveness of music for patients with depression-related insomnia.
To fill this research gap, 112 outpatients with depression and comorbid insomnia who were receiving care at a single center were randomly assigned to either an intervention group or a wait list control group.
Participants in the intervention group listened to music for a minimum of 30 minutes at bedtime for 4 weeks. The music was delivered via the MusicStar app, which is available as a free download from the Apple and Android (Google Play) app stores. The app was developed by Dr. Lund and Lars Rye Bertelsen, a PhD student and music therapist at Aalborg University Hospital.
The app is designed as a multicolored star, with each arm of the star linking to a playlist lasting between 30 minutes and 1 hour. Each color of the star indicates a different tempo of music.
Blue playlists, Dr. Lund explained, offer the quietest music, green is more lively, and red is the most dynamic. Gray playlists linked to project-related soundtracks, such as summer rain.
Dr. Lund said organizing the playlists by stimuli and color code, instead of genre, allows users to regulate their level of arousal and makes the music choice intuitive and easy.
She said that the genres of music include New Age, folk, pop, classical, and film soundtracks, “but no hard rock.”
“There’s actually a quite large selection of music available, because studies show that individual choice is important, as are personal preferences,” she said, adding that the endless choices offered by streaming services can cause confusion.
“So we made curated playlists and designed them with well-known pieces, but also with newly composed music not associated with anything,” Dr. Lund said.
Participants were assessed using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale, and two World Health Organization well-being questionnaires (WHO-5, WHOQOL-BREF), as well as actigraphy.
Results showed that, at 4 weeks, participants in the intervention group experienced significant improvements in sleep quality in comparison with control persons. The effect size for the PSQI was –2.1, and for quality of life on the WHO-5, the effect size was 8.4.
A subanalysis revealed that the length of nocturnal sleep in the intervention group increased by an average of 18 minutes during the study from a baseline of approximately 5 hours per night, said Dr. Lund.
However, there were no changes in actigraphy measurements and no significant improvements in HAMD-17 scores.
Dr. Lund said that, on the basis of these positive findings, music intervention as a sleep aid is now offered at Aalborg University Hospital to patients with depression-related insomnia.
Clinically meaningful?
Commenting on the findings, Gerald J. Haeffel, PhD, department of psychology, University of Notre Dame, South Bend, Ind., said that overall, the study showed there was a change in sleep-quality and quality of life scores of “about 10% in each.”
“This, on the surface, would seem to be a meaningful change,” although it is less clear whether it is “clinically meaningful.” Perhaps it is, “but it would be nice to have more information.”
It would be useful, he said, to “show the means for each group pre- to postintervention, along with standard deviations,” he added.
Dr. Haeffel added that on the basis of current results, it isn’t possible to determine whether individuals’ control over music choice is important.
“We have no idea if ‘choice’ or length of playlist had any causal role in the results. One would need to run a study with the same playlist, but in one group people have to listen to whatever song comes on versus another condition in which they get to choose a song off the same list,” he said.
He noted that his group conducted a study in which highly popular music that was chosen by individual participants was found to have a positive effect. Even so, he said, “we could not determine if it was ‘choice’ or ‘popularity’ that caused the positive effects of music.”
In addition, he said, the reason music has a positive effect on insomnia remains unclear.
“It is not because it helped with depression, and it’s not because it’s actually changing objective sleep parameters. It could be that it improves mood right before bed or helps distract people right before bed. At the same time, it could also just be a placebo effect,” said Dr. Haeffel.
In addition, he said, it’s important to note that the music intervention had no comparator, so “maybe just doing something different or getting to talk with researchers created the effect and has nothing to do with music.”
Overall, he believes that there are “not enough data” to use the sleep intervention that was employed in the current study “as primary intervention, but future work could show its usefulness as a supplement.”
Dr. Lund and Mr. Bertelsen reported ownership and sales of the MusicStar app. Dr. Haeffel reported no relevant financial relationships.
PARIS –
The Music to Improve Sleep Quality in Adults With Depression and Insomnia (MUSTAFI) trial randomly assigned more than 110 outpatients with depression to either a music intervention or a waiting list. Sleep quality and quality of life significantly improved after listening to music for half an hour at bedtime for 4 weeks.
“This is a low-cost, safe intervention that has no side effects and may easily be implemented in psychiatry” along with existing treatments, lead researcher Helle Nystrup Lund, PhD, unit for depression, Aalborg (Denmark) University Hospital, said in an interview.
The findings were presented at the European Psychiatric Association 2023 Congress, and recently published in the Nordic Journal of Psychiatry.
Difficult to resolve
The researchers noted that insomnia is common in patients with depression and is “difficult to resolve.”
They noted that, while music is commonly used as a sleep aid and a growing evidence base suggests it has positive effects, there have been few investigations into the effectiveness of music for patients with depression-related insomnia.
To fill this research gap, 112 outpatients with depression and comorbid insomnia who were receiving care at a single center were randomly assigned to either an intervention group or a wait list control group.
Participants in the intervention group listened to music for a minimum of 30 minutes at bedtime for 4 weeks. The music was delivered via the MusicStar app, which is available as a free download from the Apple and Android (Google Play) app stores. The app was developed by Dr. Lund and Lars Rye Bertelsen, a PhD student and music therapist at Aalborg University Hospital.
The app is designed as a multicolored star, with each arm of the star linking to a playlist lasting between 30 minutes and 1 hour. Each color of the star indicates a different tempo of music.
Blue playlists, Dr. Lund explained, offer the quietest music, green is more lively, and red is the most dynamic. Gray playlists linked to project-related soundtracks, such as summer rain.
Dr. Lund said organizing the playlists by stimuli and color code, instead of genre, allows users to regulate their level of arousal and makes the music choice intuitive and easy.
She said that the genres of music include New Age, folk, pop, classical, and film soundtracks, “but no hard rock.”
“There’s actually a quite large selection of music available, because studies show that individual choice is important, as are personal preferences,” she said, adding that the endless choices offered by streaming services can cause confusion.
“So we made curated playlists and designed them with well-known pieces, but also with newly composed music not associated with anything,” Dr. Lund said.
Participants were assessed using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale, and two World Health Organization well-being questionnaires (WHO-5, WHOQOL-BREF), as well as actigraphy.
Results showed that, at 4 weeks, participants in the intervention group experienced significant improvements in sleep quality in comparison with control persons. The effect size for the PSQI was –2.1, and for quality of life on the WHO-5, the effect size was 8.4.
A subanalysis revealed that the length of nocturnal sleep in the intervention group increased by an average of 18 minutes during the study from a baseline of approximately 5 hours per night, said Dr. Lund.
However, there were no changes in actigraphy measurements and no significant improvements in HAMD-17 scores.
Dr. Lund said that, on the basis of these positive findings, music intervention as a sleep aid is now offered at Aalborg University Hospital to patients with depression-related insomnia.
Clinically meaningful?
Commenting on the findings, Gerald J. Haeffel, PhD, department of psychology, University of Notre Dame, South Bend, Ind., said that overall, the study showed there was a change in sleep-quality and quality of life scores of “about 10% in each.”
“This, on the surface, would seem to be a meaningful change,” although it is less clear whether it is “clinically meaningful.” Perhaps it is, “but it would be nice to have more information.”
It would be useful, he said, to “show the means for each group pre- to postintervention, along with standard deviations,” he added.
Dr. Haeffel added that on the basis of current results, it isn’t possible to determine whether individuals’ control over music choice is important.
“We have no idea if ‘choice’ or length of playlist had any causal role in the results. One would need to run a study with the same playlist, but in one group people have to listen to whatever song comes on versus another condition in which they get to choose a song off the same list,” he said.
He noted that his group conducted a study in which highly popular music that was chosen by individual participants was found to have a positive effect. Even so, he said, “we could not determine if it was ‘choice’ or ‘popularity’ that caused the positive effects of music.”
In addition, he said, the reason music has a positive effect on insomnia remains unclear.
“It is not because it helped with depression, and it’s not because it’s actually changing objective sleep parameters. It could be that it improves mood right before bed or helps distract people right before bed. At the same time, it could also just be a placebo effect,” said Dr. Haeffel.
In addition, he said, it’s important to note that the music intervention had no comparator, so “maybe just doing something different or getting to talk with researchers created the effect and has nothing to do with music.”
Overall, he believes that there are “not enough data” to use the sleep intervention that was employed in the current study “as primary intervention, but future work could show its usefulness as a supplement.”
Dr. Lund and Mr. Bertelsen reported ownership and sales of the MusicStar app. Dr. Haeffel reported no relevant financial relationships.
AT EPA 2023
Impact of child abuse differs by gender
PARIS – , new research shows.
Investigators found childhood emotional and sexual abuse had a greater effect on women than men, whereas men were more adversely affected by emotional and physical neglect.
“Our findings indicate that exposure to childhood maltreatment increases the risk of having psychiatric symptoms in both men and women,” lead researcher Thanavadee Prachason, PhD, department of psychiatry and neuropsychology, Maastricht (the Netherlands) University Medical Center, said in a press release.
“Exposure to emotionally or sexually abusive experiences during childhood increases the risk of a variety of psychiatric symptoms, particularly in women. In contrast, a history of emotional or physical neglect in childhood increases the risk of having psychiatric symptoms more in men,” Dr. Prachason added.
The findings were presented at the European Psychiatric Association 2023 Congress.
A leading mental illness risk factor
Study presenter Laura Fusar-Poli, MD, PhD, from the department of brain and behavioral sciences, University of Pavia (Italy), said that the differential impact of trauma subtypes in men and women indicate that both gender and the type of childhood adversity experienced need to be taken into account in future studies.
Dr. Fusar-Poli began by highlighting that 13%-36% of individuals have experienced some kind of childhood trauma, with 30% exposed to at least two types of trauma.
Trauma has been identified as a risk factor for a range of mental health problems.
“It is estimated that, worldwide, around one third of all psychiatric disorders are related to childhood trauma,” senior researcher Sinan Gül
Consequently, “childhood trauma is a leading preventable risk factor for mental illness,” he added.
Previous research suggests the subtype of trauma has an impact on subsequent biological changes and clinical outcomes, and that there are gender differences in the effects of childhood trauma.
To investigate, the researchers examined data from TwinssCan, a Belgian cohort of twins and siblings aged 15-35 years without a diagnosis of pervasive mental disorders.
The study included 477 females and 314 males who had completed the Childhood Trauma Questionnaire–Short Form (CTQ) and the Symptom Checklist-90 SR (SCL-90) to determine exposure to childhood adversity and levels of psychopathology, respectively.
Results showed that total CTQ scores were significantly associated with total SCL-90 scores in both men and women, as well as with each of the nine symptom domains of the SCL-90 (P < .001 for all assessments). These included psychoticism, paranoid ideation, anxiety, depression, somatization, obsessive-compulsive, interpersonal sensitivity, hostility, and phobic anxiety.
There were no significant differences in the associations with total CTQ scores between men and women.
However, when the researchers examined trauma subtypes and psychopathology, clear gender differences emerged.
Investigators found a significant association between emotional abuse on the CTQ and total SCL-90 scores in both men (P < .023) and women (P < .001), but that the association was significantly stronger in women (P = .043).
Sexual abuse was significantly associated with total SCL-90 scores in women (P < .001), while emotional neglect and physical neglect were significantly associated with psychopathology scores in men (P = .026 and P < .001, respectively).
“Physical neglect may include experiences of not having enough to eat, wearing dirty clothes, not being taken care of, and not getting taken to the doctor when the person was growing up,” said Dr. Prachason.
“Emotional neglect may include childhood experiences like not feeling loved or important, and not feeling close to the family.”
In women, emotional abuse was significantly associated with all nine symptom domains of the SCL-90, while sexual abuse was associated with seven: psychoticism, paranoid ideation, anxiety, depression, somatization, obsessive-compulsive, and hostility.
Physical neglect, in men, was significantly associated with eight of the symptom domains (all but somatization), but emotional neglect was linked only to depression, Dr. Fusar-Poli reported.
“This study showed a very important consequence of childhood trauma, and not only in people with mental disorders. I would like to underline that this is a general population, composed of adolescents and young adults, which is the age in which the majority of mental disorders starts, Dr. Fusar-Poli said in an interview.
She emphasized that psychotic disorders are only a part of the “broad range” of conditions that may be related to childhood trauma, which “can have an impact on sub-threshold symptoms that can affect functioning and quality of life in the general population.”
Addressing the differential findings in men and women, Dr. Gül
However, he said, this is “something that we really need understand,” as there is likely an underlying mechanism, “and not only a biological mechanism but probably a societal one.”
Dr. Gül
Compromised cognitive, emotional function
Commenting on the findings for this news organization, Elaine F. Walker, PhD, professor of psychology and neuroscience at Emory University in Atlanta, said stress exposure in general, including childhood trauma, “has transdiagnostic effects on vulnerability to mental disorders.”
“The effects are primarily mediated by the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, which triggers the release of cortisol. When persistently elevated, this can result in neurobiological processes that have adverse effects on brain structure and circuitry which, in turn, compromises cognitive and emotional functioning,” said Dr. Walker, who was not associated with the study.
She noted that, “while it is possible that there are sex differences in biological sensitivity to certain subtypes of childhood trauma, it may also be the case that sex differences in the likelihood of exposure to trauma subtypes is actually the key factor.”
“At the present time, there are not specific treatment protocols aimed at addressing childhood trauma subtypes, but most experienced therapists will incorporate information about the individual’s trauma history in their treatment,” Dr. Walker added.
Also commenting on the research, Philip Gorwood, MD, PhD, head of the Clinique des Maladies Mentales et de l’Encéphale at Centre Hospitalier Sainte Anne in Paris, said the results are “important … as childhood trauma has been clearly recognized as a major risk factor for the vast majority of psychiatric disorders, but with poor knowledge of gender specificities.”
“Understanding which aspects of trauma are more damaging according to gender will facilitate research on the resilience process. Many intervention strategies will indeed benefit from a more personalized approach,” he said in a statement. Dr. Gorwood was not involved with this study.
The study authors, Dr. Gorwood, and Dr. Walker report no relevant financial relationships.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
PARIS – , new research shows.
Investigators found childhood emotional and sexual abuse had a greater effect on women than men, whereas men were more adversely affected by emotional and physical neglect.
“Our findings indicate that exposure to childhood maltreatment increases the risk of having psychiatric symptoms in both men and women,” lead researcher Thanavadee Prachason, PhD, department of psychiatry and neuropsychology, Maastricht (the Netherlands) University Medical Center, said in a press release.
“Exposure to emotionally or sexually abusive experiences during childhood increases the risk of a variety of psychiatric symptoms, particularly in women. In contrast, a history of emotional or physical neglect in childhood increases the risk of having psychiatric symptoms more in men,” Dr. Prachason added.
The findings were presented at the European Psychiatric Association 2023 Congress.
A leading mental illness risk factor
Study presenter Laura Fusar-Poli, MD, PhD, from the department of brain and behavioral sciences, University of Pavia (Italy), said that the differential impact of trauma subtypes in men and women indicate that both gender and the type of childhood adversity experienced need to be taken into account in future studies.
Dr. Fusar-Poli began by highlighting that 13%-36% of individuals have experienced some kind of childhood trauma, with 30% exposed to at least two types of trauma.
Trauma has been identified as a risk factor for a range of mental health problems.
“It is estimated that, worldwide, around one third of all psychiatric disorders are related to childhood trauma,” senior researcher Sinan Gül
Consequently, “childhood trauma is a leading preventable risk factor for mental illness,” he added.
Previous research suggests the subtype of trauma has an impact on subsequent biological changes and clinical outcomes, and that there are gender differences in the effects of childhood trauma.
To investigate, the researchers examined data from TwinssCan, a Belgian cohort of twins and siblings aged 15-35 years without a diagnosis of pervasive mental disorders.
The study included 477 females and 314 males who had completed the Childhood Trauma Questionnaire–Short Form (CTQ) and the Symptom Checklist-90 SR (SCL-90) to determine exposure to childhood adversity and levels of psychopathology, respectively.
Results showed that total CTQ scores were significantly associated with total SCL-90 scores in both men and women, as well as with each of the nine symptom domains of the SCL-90 (P < .001 for all assessments). These included psychoticism, paranoid ideation, anxiety, depression, somatization, obsessive-compulsive, interpersonal sensitivity, hostility, and phobic anxiety.
There were no significant differences in the associations with total CTQ scores between men and women.
However, when the researchers examined trauma subtypes and psychopathology, clear gender differences emerged.
Investigators found a significant association between emotional abuse on the CTQ and total SCL-90 scores in both men (P < .023) and women (P < .001), but that the association was significantly stronger in women (P = .043).
Sexual abuse was significantly associated with total SCL-90 scores in women (P < .001), while emotional neglect and physical neglect were significantly associated with psychopathology scores in men (P = .026 and P < .001, respectively).
“Physical neglect may include experiences of not having enough to eat, wearing dirty clothes, not being taken care of, and not getting taken to the doctor when the person was growing up,” said Dr. Prachason.
“Emotional neglect may include childhood experiences like not feeling loved or important, and not feeling close to the family.”
In women, emotional abuse was significantly associated with all nine symptom domains of the SCL-90, while sexual abuse was associated with seven: psychoticism, paranoid ideation, anxiety, depression, somatization, obsessive-compulsive, and hostility.
Physical neglect, in men, was significantly associated with eight of the symptom domains (all but somatization), but emotional neglect was linked only to depression, Dr. Fusar-Poli reported.
“This study showed a very important consequence of childhood trauma, and not only in people with mental disorders. I would like to underline that this is a general population, composed of adolescents and young adults, which is the age in which the majority of mental disorders starts, Dr. Fusar-Poli said in an interview.
She emphasized that psychotic disorders are only a part of the “broad range” of conditions that may be related to childhood trauma, which “can have an impact on sub-threshold symptoms that can affect functioning and quality of life in the general population.”
Addressing the differential findings in men and women, Dr. Gül
However, he said, this is “something that we really need understand,” as there is likely an underlying mechanism, “and not only a biological mechanism but probably a societal one.”
Dr. Gül
Compromised cognitive, emotional function
Commenting on the findings for this news organization, Elaine F. Walker, PhD, professor of psychology and neuroscience at Emory University in Atlanta, said stress exposure in general, including childhood trauma, “has transdiagnostic effects on vulnerability to mental disorders.”
“The effects are primarily mediated by the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, which triggers the release of cortisol. When persistently elevated, this can result in neurobiological processes that have adverse effects on brain structure and circuitry which, in turn, compromises cognitive and emotional functioning,” said Dr. Walker, who was not associated with the study.
She noted that, “while it is possible that there are sex differences in biological sensitivity to certain subtypes of childhood trauma, it may also be the case that sex differences in the likelihood of exposure to trauma subtypes is actually the key factor.”
“At the present time, there are not specific treatment protocols aimed at addressing childhood trauma subtypes, but most experienced therapists will incorporate information about the individual’s trauma history in their treatment,” Dr. Walker added.
Also commenting on the research, Philip Gorwood, MD, PhD, head of the Clinique des Maladies Mentales et de l’Encéphale at Centre Hospitalier Sainte Anne in Paris, said the results are “important … as childhood trauma has been clearly recognized as a major risk factor for the vast majority of psychiatric disorders, but with poor knowledge of gender specificities.”
“Understanding which aspects of trauma are more damaging according to gender will facilitate research on the resilience process. Many intervention strategies will indeed benefit from a more personalized approach,” he said in a statement. Dr. Gorwood was not involved with this study.
The study authors, Dr. Gorwood, and Dr. Walker report no relevant financial relationships.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
PARIS – , new research shows.
Investigators found childhood emotional and sexual abuse had a greater effect on women than men, whereas men were more adversely affected by emotional and physical neglect.
“Our findings indicate that exposure to childhood maltreatment increases the risk of having psychiatric symptoms in both men and women,” lead researcher Thanavadee Prachason, PhD, department of psychiatry and neuropsychology, Maastricht (the Netherlands) University Medical Center, said in a press release.
“Exposure to emotionally or sexually abusive experiences during childhood increases the risk of a variety of psychiatric symptoms, particularly in women. In contrast, a history of emotional or physical neglect in childhood increases the risk of having psychiatric symptoms more in men,” Dr. Prachason added.
The findings were presented at the European Psychiatric Association 2023 Congress.
A leading mental illness risk factor
Study presenter Laura Fusar-Poli, MD, PhD, from the department of brain and behavioral sciences, University of Pavia (Italy), said that the differential impact of trauma subtypes in men and women indicate that both gender and the type of childhood adversity experienced need to be taken into account in future studies.
Dr. Fusar-Poli began by highlighting that 13%-36% of individuals have experienced some kind of childhood trauma, with 30% exposed to at least two types of trauma.
Trauma has been identified as a risk factor for a range of mental health problems.
“It is estimated that, worldwide, around one third of all psychiatric disorders are related to childhood trauma,” senior researcher Sinan Gül
Consequently, “childhood trauma is a leading preventable risk factor for mental illness,” he added.
Previous research suggests the subtype of trauma has an impact on subsequent biological changes and clinical outcomes, and that there are gender differences in the effects of childhood trauma.
To investigate, the researchers examined data from TwinssCan, a Belgian cohort of twins and siblings aged 15-35 years without a diagnosis of pervasive mental disorders.
The study included 477 females and 314 males who had completed the Childhood Trauma Questionnaire–Short Form (CTQ) and the Symptom Checklist-90 SR (SCL-90) to determine exposure to childhood adversity and levels of psychopathology, respectively.
Results showed that total CTQ scores were significantly associated with total SCL-90 scores in both men and women, as well as with each of the nine symptom domains of the SCL-90 (P < .001 for all assessments). These included psychoticism, paranoid ideation, anxiety, depression, somatization, obsessive-compulsive, interpersonal sensitivity, hostility, and phobic anxiety.
There were no significant differences in the associations with total CTQ scores between men and women.
However, when the researchers examined trauma subtypes and psychopathology, clear gender differences emerged.
Investigators found a significant association between emotional abuse on the CTQ and total SCL-90 scores in both men (P < .023) and women (P < .001), but that the association was significantly stronger in women (P = .043).
Sexual abuse was significantly associated with total SCL-90 scores in women (P < .001), while emotional neglect and physical neglect were significantly associated with psychopathology scores in men (P = .026 and P < .001, respectively).
“Physical neglect may include experiences of not having enough to eat, wearing dirty clothes, not being taken care of, and not getting taken to the doctor when the person was growing up,” said Dr. Prachason.
“Emotional neglect may include childhood experiences like not feeling loved or important, and not feeling close to the family.”
In women, emotional abuse was significantly associated with all nine symptom domains of the SCL-90, while sexual abuse was associated with seven: psychoticism, paranoid ideation, anxiety, depression, somatization, obsessive-compulsive, and hostility.
Physical neglect, in men, was significantly associated with eight of the symptom domains (all but somatization), but emotional neglect was linked only to depression, Dr. Fusar-Poli reported.
“This study showed a very important consequence of childhood trauma, and not only in people with mental disorders. I would like to underline that this is a general population, composed of adolescents and young adults, which is the age in which the majority of mental disorders starts, Dr. Fusar-Poli said in an interview.
She emphasized that psychotic disorders are only a part of the “broad range” of conditions that may be related to childhood trauma, which “can have an impact on sub-threshold symptoms that can affect functioning and quality of life in the general population.”
Addressing the differential findings in men and women, Dr. Gül
However, he said, this is “something that we really need understand,” as there is likely an underlying mechanism, “and not only a biological mechanism but probably a societal one.”
Dr. Gül
Compromised cognitive, emotional function
Commenting on the findings for this news organization, Elaine F. Walker, PhD, professor of psychology and neuroscience at Emory University in Atlanta, said stress exposure in general, including childhood trauma, “has transdiagnostic effects on vulnerability to mental disorders.”
“The effects are primarily mediated by the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, which triggers the release of cortisol. When persistently elevated, this can result in neurobiological processes that have adverse effects on brain structure and circuitry which, in turn, compromises cognitive and emotional functioning,” said Dr. Walker, who was not associated with the study.
She noted that, “while it is possible that there are sex differences in biological sensitivity to certain subtypes of childhood trauma, it may also be the case that sex differences in the likelihood of exposure to trauma subtypes is actually the key factor.”
“At the present time, there are not specific treatment protocols aimed at addressing childhood trauma subtypes, but most experienced therapists will incorporate information about the individual’s trauma history in their treatment,” Dr. Walker added.
Also commenting on the research, Philip Gorwood, MD, PhD, head of the Clinique des Maladies Mentales et de l’Encéphale at Centre Hospitalier Sainte Anne in Paris, said the results are “important … as childhood trauma has been clearly recognized as a major risk factor for the vast majority of psychiatric disorders, but with poor knowledge of gender specificities.”
“Understanding which aspects of trauma are more damaging according to gender will facilitate research on the resilience process. Many intervention strategies will indeed benefit from a more personalized approach,” he said in a statement. Dr. Gorwood was not involved with this study.
The study authors, Dr. Gorwood, and Dr. Walker report no relevant financial relationships.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
AT EPA 2023