User login
Too old to practice medicine?
Unlike for many other professions, there is no age limit for practicing medicine. According to international standards, airplane pilots, for example, who are responsible for the safety of many human lives, must retire by the age of 60 if they work alone, or 65 if they have a copilot. In Brazil, however, this age limit does not exist for pilots or physicians.
The only restriction on professional practice within the medical context is the mandatory retirement imposed on medical professors who teach at public (state and federal) universities, starting at the age of 75. Nevertheless, these professionals can continue practicing administrative and research-related activities. After “expulsion,” as this mandatory retirement is often called, professors who stood out or contributed to the institution and science may receive the title of professor emeritus.
In the private sector, age limits are not formally set, but the hiring of middle-aged professionals is limited.
At the Heart Institute of the University of São Paulo (Brazil) School of Medicine Clinical Hospital (InCor/HCFMUSP), one of the world’s largest teaching and research centers for cardiovascular and pulmonary diseases, several octogenarian specialists lead studies and teams. One of these is Noedir Stolf, MD, an 82-year-old cardiovascular surgeon who operates almost every day and coordinates studies on transplants, mechanical circulatory support, and aortic surgery. There is also Protásio Lemos da Luz, MD, an 82-year-old clinical cardiologist who guides research on subjects including atherosclerosis, the endothelium, microbiota, and diabetes. The protective effect of wine on atherosclerosis is one of his best-known studies.
No longer working is also not in the cards for Angelita Habr-Gama, MD, who, at 89 years old, is one of the oldest physicians in current practice. With a career spanning more than 7 decades, she is a world reference in coloproctology. She was the first woman to become a surgical resident at the HCFMUSP, where she later founded the coloproctology specialty and created the first residency program for the specialty. In April 2022, Dr. Habr-Gama joined the ranks of the 100 most influential scientists in the world, nominated by researchers at Stanford (Calif.) University, and published in PLOS Biology.
In 2020, she was sedated, intubated, and hospitalized in the intensive care unit of the Oswaldo Cruz German Hospital for 54 days because of a SARS-CoV-2 infection. After her discharge, she went back to work in less than 10 days – and added chess classes to her routine. “To get up and go to work makes me very happy. Work is my greatest hobby. No one has ever heard me complain about my life,” Dr. Habr-Gama told this news organization after having rescheduled the interview twice because of emergency surgeries.
“Doctors have a professional longevity that does not exist for other professions in which the person retires and stops practicing their profession or goes on to do something else for entertainment. Doctors can retire from one place of employment or public practice and continue practicing medicine in the office as an administrator or consultant,” Ângelo Vattimo, first secretary of the state of São Paulo Regional Board of Medicine (CREMESP), stated. The board regularly organizes a ceremony to honor professionals who have been practicing for 50 years, awarding them a certificate and engraved medal. “Many of them are around 80 years old, working and teaching. This always makes us very happy. What profession has such exceptional compliance for so long?” said Mr. Vattimo.
In the medical field, the older the age range, the smaller the number of women. According to the 2020 Medical Demographics in Brazil survey, only 2 out of 10 practicing professionals older than 70 are women.
Not everyone over 80 has Dr. Habr-Gama’s vitality, because the impact of aging is not equal. “If you look at a group of 80-year-olds, there will be much more variability than within a group of 40-year-olds,” stated Mark Katlic, MD, chief of surgery at LifeBridge Health System in the United States, who has dedicated his life to studying the subject. Dr. Katlic spoke on the subject in an interview that was published in the article “How Old Is Too Old to Work as a Doctor?” published by this news organization in April of 2022. The article discusses the evaluations of elderly physicians’ skills and competences that U.S. companies conduct. The subject has been leading to profound debate.
Dr. Katlic defends screening programs for elderly physicians, which already are in effect at the company for which he works, LifeBridge Health, and various others in the United States. “We do [screen elderly physicians at LifeBridge Health], and so do a few dozen other [U.S. institutions], but there are hundreds [of health care institutions] that do not conduct this screening,” he pointed out.
Age-related assessment faces great resistance in the United States. One physician who is against the initiative is Frank Stockdale, MD, PhD, an 86-year-old practicing oncologist affiliated with Stanford (Calif.) University Health. “It’s age discrimination ... Physicians [in the United States] receive assessments throughout their careers as part of the accreditation process – there’s no need to change that as physicians reach a certain age,” Dr. Stockdale told this news organization.
The U.S. initiative of instituting physician assessment programs for those of a certain age has even been tested in court. According to an article published in Medscape, “in New Haven, Connecticut, for instance, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) filed a suit in 2020 on behalf of the Yale New Haven Hospital staff, alleging a discriminatory late career practitioner policy.”
Also, according to the article, a similar case in Minnesota reached a settlement in 2021, providing monetary relief to staff impacted by out-of-pocket costs for the assessment, in addition to requiring that the hospital in question report to the EEOC any complaints related to age discrimination.
In Brazil, the subject is of interest to more than 34,571 physicians between 65 and 69 years of age and 34,237 physicians older than 70. In all, this population represents approximately 14.3% of the country’s active workforce, according to the 2020 Medical Demographics in Brazil survey.
The significant participation of health care professionals over age 50 in a survey conducted by this news organization to learn what physicians think about the age limit for practicing their professions is evidence that the subject is a present concern. Of a total of 1,641 participants, 57% were age 60 or older, 17% were between 50 and 59 years, and 12% were between 40 and 49 years. Among all participants, 51% were against these limitations, 17% approved of the idea for all specialties, and 32% believed the restriction was appropriate only for some specialties. Regarding the possibility of older physicians undergoing regular assessments, the opinions were divided: Thirty-one percent thought they should be assessed in all specialties. Furthermore, 31% believed that cognitive abilities should be regularly tested in all specialties, 31% thought this should take place for some specialties, and 38% were against this approach.
Professionals want to know, for example, how (and whether) advanced age can interfere with performance, what are the competences required to practice their activities, and if the criteria vary by specialty. “A psychiatrist doesn’t have to have perfect visual acuity, as required from a dermatologist, but it is important that they have good hearing, for example,” argued Clóvis Constantino, MD, former president of the São Paulo Regional Medical Board (CRM-SP) and former vice president of the Brazilian Federal Medical Board (CFM). “However, a surgeon has to stand for several hours in positions that may be uncomfortable. It’s not easy,” he told this news organization.
In the opinion of 82-year-old Henrique Klajner, MD, the oldest pediatrician in practice at the Albert Einstein Israeli Hospital in São Paulo, the physician cannot be subjected to the types of evaluations that have been applied in the United States. “Physicians should conduct constant self-evaluations to see if they have the competences and skills needed to practice their profession ... Moreover, this is not a matter of age. It is a matter of ethics,” said Dr. Klajner.
The ability to adapt to change and implement innovation is critical to professional longevity, he said. “Nowadays, when I admit patients, I no longer do hospital rounds, which requires a mobility equal to physical abuse for me. Therefore, I work with physicians who take care of my hospitalized patients.”
Dr. Klajner also feels there is a distinction between innovations learned through studies and what can be offered safely to patients. “If I have to care for a hospitalized patient with severe pneumonia, for example, since I am not up to date in this specialty, I am going to call upon a pulmonologist I trust and forgo my honorarium for this admission. But I will remain on the team, monitoring the patient’s progression,” he said.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, Dr. Klajner stopped seeing patients in person under the recommendation of his son, Sidney Klajner, MD, also a physician. The elder Dr. Klajner began exploring telemedicine, which opened a whole new world of possibilities. “I have conducted several online visits to provide educational instruction to mothers returning home post delivery, for example,” he told this news organization. The time to stop is not something that concerns Dr. Klajner. “I’m only going to stop when I have a really important reason to do so. For example, if I can no longer write or study, reading and rereading an article without being able to understand what is being said. At this time, none of that is happening.”
In the United States, as well as in Brazil, physicians rarely provide information to human resources departments on colleagues showing signs of cognitive or motor decline affecting their professional performance. “The expectation is that health care professionals will report colleagues with cognitive impairments, but that often does not happen,” Dr. Katlic said.
It is also not common for professionals to report their own deficits to their institutions. In large part, this is caused by a lack of well-defined policies for dealing with this issue. This news organization sought out several public and private hospitals in Brazil to see if there is any guidance on professional longevity: Most said that there is not. Only the A. C. Camargo Cancer Center reported, through its public relations team, that a committee is discussing the subject but that it is still in the early stages.
Brazilian specialist associations do not offer guidelines or instructions on the various aspects of professional longevity. Dr. Constantino tried to put the subject on the agenda during the years in which he was an administrator with the CFM. “We tried to open up discussions regarding truly elderly physicians, but the subject was not well received. I believe that it is precisely because there is a tradition of physicians working until they are no longer able that this is more difficult in Brazil ... No one exactly knows what to do in this respect.” Dr. Constantino is against the use of age as a criterion for quitting practice.
“Of course, this is a point that has to be considered, but I always defended the need for regular assessment of physicians, regardless of age range. And, although assessments are always welcome, in any profession, I also believe this would not be well received in Brazil.” He endorses an assessment of one’s knowledge and not of physical abilities, which are generally assessed through investigation when needed.
The absence of guidelines increases individual responsibility, as well as vulnerability. “Consciously, physicians will not put patients at risk if they do not have the competence to care for them or to perform a surgical procedure,” said Clystenes Odyr Soares Silva, MD, PhD, adjunct professor of pulmonology of the Federal University of São Paulo (Brazil) School of Medicine (UNIFESP). “Your peers will tell you if you are no longer able,” he added. The problem is that physicians rarely admit to or talk about their colleagues’ deficits, especially if they are in the spotlight because of advanced age. In this situation, the observation and opinion of family members regarding the health care professional’s competences and skills will hold more weight.
In case of health-related physical impairment, such as partial loss of hand movement, for example, “it is expected that this will set off an ethical warning in the person,” said Dr. Constantino. When this warning does not occur naturally, patients or colleagues can report the professional, and this may lead to the opening of an administrative investigation. If the report is found to be true, this investigation is used to suspend physicians who do not have the physical or mental ability to continue practicing medicine.
“If it’s something very serious, the physician’s license can be temporarily suspended while [the physician] is treated by a psychiatrist, with follow-up by the professional board. When discharged, the physician will get his or her [professional] license back and can go back to work,” Dr. Constantino explained. If an expert evaluation is needed, the physician will then be assessed by a forensic psychiatrist. One of the most in-demand forensic psychiatrists in Brazil is Guido Arturo Palomba, MD, 73 years old. “I have assessed some physicians for actions reported to see if they were normal people or not, but never for circumstances related to age,” Dr. Palomba said.
In practice, Brazilian medical entities do not have policies or programs to guide physicians who wish to grow old while they work or those who have started to notice they are not performing as they used to. “We have never lived as long; therefore, the quality of life in old age, as well as the concept of aging, are some of the most relevant questions of our time. These are subjects requiring additional discussion, broadening understanding and awareness in this regard,” observed Mr. Vattimo.
Dr. Constantino and Dr. Silva, who are completely against age-based assessments, believe that recertification of the specialist license every 5 years is the best path to confirming whether the physician is still able to practice. “A knowledge-based test every 5 years to recertify the specialist license has often been a topic of conversation. I think it’s an excellent idea. The person would provide a dossier of all they have done in terms of courses, conferences, and other activities, present it, and receive a score,” said Dr. Silva.
In practice, recertification of the specialist license is a topic of discussion that has been raised for years, and it is an idea that the Brazilian Medical Association (AMB) defends. In conjunction with the CFM, the association is studying a way to best implement this assessment. “It’s important to emphasize that this measure would not be retroactive at first. Instead, it would only be in effect for professionals licensed after the recertification requirement is established,” the AMB pointed out in a note sent to this news organization. Even so, the measure has faced significant resistance from a faction of the profession, and its enactment does not seem to be imminent.
The debate regarding professional longevity is taking place in various countries. In 2021, the American Medical Association Council on Medical Education released a report with a set of guidelines for the screening and assessment of physicians. The document is the product of a committee created in 2015 to study the subject. The AMA recommends that the assessment of elderly physicians be based on evidence and ethical, relevant, fair, equitable, transparent, verifiable, nonexhaustive principles, contemplating support and protecting against legal proceedings. In April of this year, a new AMA document highlighted the same principles.
Also in the United States, one of oldest initiatives created to support physicians in the process of recycling, the University of California San Diego Physician Assessment and Clinical Education Program (PACE), has a section focusing on the extended practice of medicine (Practicing Medicine Longer). For those wanting to learn more about discussions on this subject, there are online presentations on experiences in Quebec and Ontario with assessing aging physicians, neuropsychological perspectives on the aging medical population, and what to expect of healthy aging, among other subjects.
Created in 1996, PACE mostly provides services to physicians who need to address requirements of the state medical boards. Few physicians enroll on their own.
The first part of the program assesses knowledge and skills over approximately 2 days. In the second phase, the physician participates in a series of activities in a corresponding residency program. Depending on the results, the physician may have to go through a remedial program with varying activities to deal with performance deficiencies to clinical experiences at the residency level.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Unlike for many other professions, there is no age limit for practicing medicine. According to international standards, airplane pilots, for example, who are responsible for the safety of many human lives, must retire by the age of 60 if they work alone, or 65 if they have a copilot. In Brazil, however, this age limit does not exist for pilots or physicians.
The only restriction on professional practice within the medical context is the mandatory retirement imposed on medical professors who teach at public (state and federal) universities, starting at the age of 75. Nevertheless, these professionals can continue practicing administrative and research-related activities. After “expulsion,” as this mandatory retirement is often called, professors who stood out or contributed to the institution and science may receive the title of professor emeritus.
In the private sector, age limits are not formally set, but the hiring of middle-aged professionals is limited.
At the Heart Institute of the University of São Paulo (Brazil) School of Medicine Clinical Hospital (InCor/HCFMUSP), one of the world’s largest teaching and research centers for cardiovascular and pulmonary diseases, several octogenarian specialists lead studies and teams. One of these is Noedir Stolf, MD, an 82-year-old cardiovascular surgeon who operates almost every day and coordinates studies on transplants, mechanical circulatory support, and aortic surgery. There is also Protásio Lemos da Luz, MD, an 82-year-old clinical cardiologist who guides research on subjects including atherosclerosis, the endothelium, microbiota, and diabetes. The protective effect of wine on atherosclerosis is one of his best-known studies.
No longer working is also not in the cards for Angelita Habr-Gama, MD, who, at 89 years old, is one of the oldest physicians in current practice. With a career spanning more than 7 decades, she is a world reference in coloproctology. She was the first woman to become a surgical resident at the HCFMUSP, where she later founded the coloproctology specialty and created the first residency program for the specialty. In April 2022, Dr. Habr-Gama joined the ranks of the 100 most influential scientists in the world, nominated by researchers at Stanford (Calif.) University, and published in PLOS Biology.
In 2020, she was sedated, intubated, and hospitalized in the intensive care unit of the Oswaldo Cruz German Hospital for 54 days because of a SARS-CoV-2 infection. After her discharge, she went back to work in less than 10 days – and added chess classes to her routine. “To get up and go to work makes me very happy. Work is my greatest hobby. No one has ever heard me complain about my life,” Dr. Habr-Gama told this news organization after having rescheduled the interview twice because of emergency surgeries.
“Doctors have a professional longevity that does not exist for other professions in which the person retires and stops practicing their profession or goes on to do something else for entertainment. Doctors can retire from one place of employment or public practice and continue practicing medicine in the office as an administrator or consultant,” Ângelo Vattimo, first secretary of the state of São Paulo Regional Board of Medicine (CREMESP), stated. The board regularly organizes a ceremony to honor professionals who have been practicing for 50 years, awarding them a certificate and engraved medal. “Many of them are around 80 years old, working and teaching. This always makes us very happy. What profession has such exceptional compliance for so long?” said Mr. Vattimo.
In the medical field, the older the age range, the smaller the number of women. According to the 2020 Medical Demographics in Brazil survey, only 2 out of 10 practicing professionals older than 70 are women.
Not everyone over 80 has Dr. Habr-Gama’s vitality, because the impact of aging is not equal. “If you look at a group of 80-year-olds, there will be much more variability than within a group of 40-year-olds,” stated Mark Katlic, MD, chief of surgery at LifeBridge Health System in the United States, who has dedicated his life to studying the subject. Dr. Katlic spoke on the subject in an interview that was published in the article “How Old Is Too Old to Work as a Doctor?” published by this news organization in April of 2022. The article discusses the evaluations of elderly physicians’ skills and competences that U.S. companies conduct. The subject has been leading to profound debate.
Dr. Katlic defends screening programs for elderly physicians, which already are in effect at the company for which he works, LifeBridge Health, and various others in the United States. “We do [screen elderly physicians at LifeBridge Health], and so do a few dozen other [U.S. institutions], but there are hundreds [of health care institutions] that do not conduct this screening,” he pointed out.
Age-related assessment faces great resistance in the United States. One physician who is against the initiative is Frank Stockdale, MD, PhD, an 86-year-old practicing oncologist affiliated with Stanford (Calif.) University Health. “It’s age discrimination ... Physicians [in the United States] receive assessments throughout their careers as part of the accreditation process – there’s no need to change that as physicians reach a certain age,” Dr. Stockdale told this news organization.
The U.S. initiative of instituting physician assessment programs for those of a certain age has even been tested in court. According to an article published in Medscape, “in New Haven, Connecticut, for instance, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) filed a suit in 2020 on behalf of the Yale New Haven Hospital staff, alleging a discriminatory late career practitioner policy.”
Also, according to the article, a similar case in Minnesota reached a settlement in 2021, providing monetary relief to staff impacted by out-of-pocket costs for the assessment, in addition to requiring that the hospital in question report to the EEOC any complaints related to age discrimination.
In Brazil, the subject is of interest to more than 34,571 physicians between 65 and 69 years of age and 34,237 physicians older than 70. In all, this population represents approximately 14.3% of the country’s active workforce, according to the 2020 Medical Demographics in Brazil survey.
The significant participation of health care professionals over age 50 in a survey conducted by this news organization to learn what physicians think about the age limit for practicing their professions is evidence that the subject is a present concern. Of a total of 1,641 participants, 57% were age 60 or older, 17% were between 50 and 59 years, and 12% were between 40 and 49 years. Among all participants, 51% were against these limitations, 17% approved of the idea for all specialties, and 32% believed the restriction was appropriate only for some specialties. Regarding the possibility of older physicians undergoing regular assessments, the opinions were divided: Thirty-one percent thought they should be assessed in all specialties. Furthermore, 31% believed that cognitive abilities should be regularly tested in all specialties, 31% thought this should take place for some specialties, and 38% were against this approach.
Professionals want to know, for example, how (and whether) advanced age can interfere with performance, what are the competences required to practice their activities, and if the criteria vary by specialty. “A psychiatrist doesn’t have to have perfect visual acuity, as required from a dermatologist, but it is important that they have good hearing, for example,” argued Clóvis Constantino, MD, former president of the São Paulo Regional Medical Board (CRM-SP) and former vice president of the Brazilian Federal Medical Board (CFM). “However, a surgeon has to stand for several hours in positions that may be uncomfortable. It’s not easy,” he told this news organization.
In the opinion of 82-year-old Henrique Klajner, MD, the oldest pediatrician in practice at the Albert Einstein Israeli Hospital in São Paulo, the physician cannot be subjected to the types of evaluations that have been applied in the United States. “Physicians should conduct constant self-evaluations to see if they have the competences and skills needed to practice their profession ... Moreover, this is not a matter of age. It is a matter of ethics,” said Dr. Klajner.
The ability to adapt to change and implement innovation is critical to professional longevity, he said. “Nowadays, when I admit patients, I no longer do hospital rounds, which requires a mobility equal to physical abuse for me. Therefore, I work with physicians who take care of my hospitalized patients.”
Dr. Klajner also feels there is a distinction between innovations learned through studies and what can be offered safely to patients. “If I have to care for a hospitalized patient with severe pneumonia, for example, since I am not up to date in this specialty, I am going to call upon a pulmonologist I trust and forgo my honorarium for this admission. But I will remain on the team, monitoring the patient’s progression,” he said.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, Dr. Klajner stopped seeing patients in person under the recommendation of his son, Sidney Klajner, MD, also a physician. The elder Dr. Klajner began exploring telemedicine, which opened a whole new world of possibilities. “I have conducted several online visits to provide educational instruction to mothers returning home post delivery, for example,” he told this news organization. The time to stop is not something that concerns Dr. Klajner. “I’m only going to stop when I have a really important reason to do so. For example, if I can no longer write or study, reading and rereading an article without being able to understand what is being said. At this time, none of that is happening.”
In the United States, as well as in Brazil, physicians rarely provide information to human resources departments on colleagues showing signs of cognitive or motor decline affecting their professional performance. “The expectation is that health care professionals will report colleagues with cognitive impairments, but that often does not happen,” Dr. Katlic said.
It is also not common for professionals to report their own deficits to their institutions. In large part, this is caused by a lack of well-defined policies for dealing with this issue. This news organization sought out several public and private hospitals in Brazil to see if there is any guidance on professional longevity: Most said that there is not. Only the A. C. Camargo Cancer Center reported, through its public relations team, that a committee is discussing the subject but that it is still in the early stages.
Brazilian specialist associations do not offer guidelines or instructions on the various aspects of professional longevity. Dr. Constantino tried to put the subject on the agenda during the years in which he was an administrator with the CFM. “We tried to open up discussions regarding truly elderly physicians, but the subject was not well received. I believe that it is precisely because there is a tradition of physicians working until they are no longer able that this is more difficult in Brazil ... No one exactly knows what to do in this respect.” Dr. Constantino is against the use of age as a criterion for quitting practice.
“Of course, this is a point that has to be considered, but I always defended the need for regular assessment of physicians, regardless of age range. And, although assessments are always welcome, in any profession, I also believe this would not be well received in Brazil.” He endorses an assessment of one’s knowledge and not of physical abilities, which are generally assessed through investigation when needed.
The absence of guidelines increases individual responsibility, as well as vulnerability. “Consciously, physicians will not put patients at risk if they do not have the competence to care for them or to perform a surgical procedure,” said Clystenes Odyr Soares Silva, MD, PhD, adjunct professor of pulmonology of the Federal University of São Paulo (Brazil) School of Medicine (UNIFESP). “Your peers will tell you if you are no longer able,” he added. The problem is that physicians rarely admit to or talk about their colleagues’ deficits, especially if they are in the spotlight because of advanced age. In this situation, the observation and opinion of family members regarding the health care professional’s competences and skills will hold more weight.
In case of health-related physical impairment, such as partial loss of hand movement, for example, “it is expected that this will set off an ethical warning in the person,” said Dr. Constantino. When this warning does not occur naturally, patients or colleagues can report the professional, and this may lead to the opening of an administrative investigation. If the report is found to be true, this investigation is used to suspend physicians who do not have the physical or mental ability to continue practicing medicine.
“If it’s something very serious, the physician’s license can be temporarily suspended while [the physician] is treated by a psychiatrist, with follow-up by the professional board. When discharged, the physician will get his or her [professional] license back and can go back to work,” Dr. Constantino explained. If an expert evaluation is needed, the physician will then be assessed by a forensic psychiatrist. One of the most in-demand forensic psychiatrists in Brazil is Guido Arturo Palomba, MD, 73 years old. “I have assessed some physicians for actions reported to see if they were normal people or not, but never for circumstances related to age,” Dr. Palomba said.
In practice, Brazilian medical entities do not have policies or programs to guide physicians who wish to grow old while they work or those who have started to notice they are not performing as they used to. “We have never lived as long; therefore, the quality of life in old age, as well as the concept of aging, are some of the most relevant questions of our time. These are subjects requiring additional discussion, broadening understanding and awareness in this regard,” observed Mr. Vattimo.
Dr. Constantino and Dr. Silva, who are completely against age-based assessments, believe that recertification of the specialist license every 5 years is the best path to confirming whether the physician is still able to practice. “A knowledge-based test every 5 years to recertify the specialist license has often been a topic of conversation. I think it’s an excellent idea. The person would provide a dossier of all they have done in terms of courses, conferences, and other activities, present it, and receive a score,” said Dr. Silva.
In practice, recertification of the specialist license is a topic of discussion that has been raised for years, and it is an idea that the Brazilian Medical Association (AMB) defends. In conjunction with the CFM, the association is studying a way to best implement this assessment. “It’s important to emphasize that this measure would not be retroactive at first. Instead, it would only be in effect for professionals licensed after the recertification requirement is established,” the AMB pointed out in a note sent to this news organization. Even so, the measure has faced significant resistance from a faction of the profession, and its enactment does not seem to be imminent.
The debate regarding professional longevity is taking place in various countries. In 2021, the American Medical Association Council on Medical Education released a report with a set of guidelines for the screening and assessment of physicians. The document is the product of a committee created in 2015 to study the subject. The AMA recommends that the assessment of elderly physicians be based on evidence and ethical, relevant, fair, equitable, transparent, verifiable, nonexhaustive principles, contemplating support and protecting against legal proceedings. In April of this year, a new AMA document highlighted the same principles.
Also in the United States, one of oldest initiatives created to support physicians in the process of recycling, the University of California San Diego Physician Assessment and Clinical Education Program (PACE), has a section focusing on the extended practice of medicine (Practicing Medicine Longer). For those wanting to learn more about discussions on this subject, there are online presentations on experiences in Quebec and Ontario with assessing aging physicians, neuropsychological perspectives on the aging medical population, and what to expect of healthy aging, among other subjects.
Created in 1996, PACE mostly provides services to physicians who need to address requirements of the state medical boards. Few physicians enroll on their own.
The first part of the program assesses knowledge and skills over approximately 2 days. In the second phase, the physician participates in a series of activities in a corresponding residency program. Depending on the results, the physician may have to go through a remedial program with varying activities to deal with performance deficiencies to clinical experiences at the residency level.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Unlike for many other professions, there is no age limit for practicing medicine. According to international standards, airplane pilots, for example, who are responsible for the safety of many human lives, must retire by the age of 60 if they work alone, or 65 if they have a copilot. In Brazil, however, this age limit does not exist for pilots or physicians.
The only restriction on professional practice within the medical context is the mandatory retirement imposed on medical professors who teach at public (state and federal) universities, starting at the age of 75. Nevertheless, these professionals can continue practicing administrative and research-related activities. After “expulsion,” as this mandatory retirement is often called, professors who stood out or contributed to the institution and science may receive the title of professor emeritus.
In the private sector, age limits are not formally set, but the hiring of middle-aged professionals is limited.
At the Heart Institute of the University of São Paulo (Brazil) School of Medicine Clinical Hospital (InCor/HCFMUSP), one of the world’s largest teaching and research centers for cardiovascular and pulmonary diseases, several octogenarian specialists lead studies and teams. One of these is Noedir Stolf, MD, an 82-year-old cardiovascular surgeon who operates almost every day and coordinates studies on transplants, mechanical circulatory support, and aortic surgery. There is also Protásio Lemos da Luz, MD, an 82-year-old clinical cardiologist who guides research on subjects including atherosclerosis, the endothelium, microbiota, and diabetes. The protective effect of wine on atherosclerosis is one of his best-known studies.
No longer working is also not in the cards for Angelita Habr-Gama, MD, who, at 89 years old, is one of the oldest physicians in current practice. With a career spanning more than 7 decades, she is a world reference in coloproctology. She was the first woman to become a surgical resident at the HCFMUSP, where she later founded the coloproctology specialty and created the first residency program for the specialty. In April 2022, Dr. Habr-Gama joined the ranks of the 100 most influential scientists in the world, nominated by researchers at Stanford (Calif.) University, and published in PLOS Biology.
In 2020, she was sedated, intubated, and hospitalized in the intensive care unit of the Oswaldo Cruz German Hospital for 54 days because of a SARS-CoV-2 infection. After her discharge, she went back to work in less than 10 days – and added chess classes to her routine. “To get up and go to work makes me very happy. Work is my greatest hobby. No one has ever heard me complain about my life,” Dr. Habr-Gama told this news organization after having rescheduled the interview twice because of emergency surgeries.
“Doctors have a professional longevity that does not exist for other professions in which the person retires and stops practicing their profession or goes on to do something else for entertainment. Doctors can retire from one place of employment or public practice and continue practicing medicine in the office as an administrator or consultant,” Ângelo Vattimo, first secretary of the state of São Paulo Regional Board of Medicine (CREMESP), stated. The board regularly organizes a ceremony to honor professionals who have been practicing for 50 years, awarding them a certificate and engraved medal. “Many of them are around 80 years old, working and teaching. This always makes us very happy. What profession has such exceptional compliance for so long?” said Mr. Vattimo.
In the medical field, the older the age range, the smaller the number of women. According to the 2020 Medical Demographics in Brazil survey, only 2 out of 10 practicing professionals older than 70 are women.
Not everyone over 80 has Dr. Habr-Gama’s vitality, because the impact of aging is not equal. “If you look at a group of 80-year-olds, there will be much more variability than within a group of 40-year-olds,” stated Mark Katlic, MD, chief of surgery at LifeBridge Health System in the United States, who has dedicated his life to studying the subject. Dr. Katlic spoke on the subject in an interview that was published in the article “How Old Is Too Old to Work as a Doctor?” published by this news organization in April of 2022. The article discusses the evaluations of elderly physicians’ skills and competences that U.S. companies conduct. The subject has been leading to profound debate.
Dr. Katlic defends screening programs for elderly physicians, which already are in effect at the company for which he works, LifeBridge Health, and various others in the United States. “We do [screen elderly physicians at LifeBridge Health], and so do a few dozen other [U.S. institutions], but there are hundreds [of health care institutions] that do not conduct this screening,” he pointed out.
Age-related assessment faces great resistance in the United States. One physician who is against the initiative is Frank Stockdale, MD, PhD, an 86-year-old practicing oncologist affiliated with Stanford (Calif.) University Health. “It’s age discrimination ... Physicians [in the United States] receive assessments throughout their careers as part of the accreditation process – there’s no need to change that as physicians reach a certain age,” Dr. Stockdale told this news organization.
The U.S. initiative of instituting physician assessment programs for those of a certain age has even been tested in court. According to an article published in Medscape, “in New Haven, Connecticut, for instance, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) filed a suit in 2020 on behalf of the Yale New Haven Hospital staff, alleging a discriminatory late career practitioner policy.”
Also, according to the article, a similar case in Minnesota reached a settlement in 2021, providing monetary relief to staff impacted by out-of-pocket costs for the assessment, in addition to requiring that the hospital in question report to the EEOC any complaints related to age discrimination.
In Brazil, the subject is of interest to more than 34,571 physicians between 65 and 69 years of age and 34,237 physicians older than 70. In all, this population represents approximately 14.3% of the country’s active workforce, according to the 2020 Medical Demographics in Brazil survey.
The significant participation of health care professionals over age 50 in a survey conducted by this news organization to learn what physicians think about the age limit for practicing their professions is evidence that the subject is a present concern. Of a total of 1,641 participants, 57% were age 60 or older, 17% were between 50 and 59 years, and 12% were between 40 and 49 years. Among all participants, 51% were against these limitations, 17% approved of the idea for all specialties, and 32% believed the restriction was appropriate only for some specialties. Regarding the possibility of older physicians undergoing regular assessments, the opinions were divided: Thirty-one percent thought they should be assessed in all specialties. Furthermore, 31% believed that cognitive abilities should be regularly tested in all specialties, 31% thought this should take place for some specialties, and 38% were against this approach.
Professionals want to know, for example, how (and whether) advanced age can interfere with performance, what are the competences required to practice their activities, and if the criteria vary by specialty. “A psychiatrist doesn’t have to have perfect visual acuity, as required from a dermatologist, but it is important that they have good hearing, for example,” argued Clóvis Constantino, MD, former president of the São Paulo Regional Medical Board (CRM-SP) and former vice president of the Brazilian Federal Medical Board (CFM). “However, a surgeon has to stand for several hours in positions that may be uncomfortable. It’s not easy,” he told this news organization.
In the opinion of 82-year-old Henrique Klajner, MD, the oldest pediatrician in practice at the Albert Einstein Israeli Hospital in São Paulo, the physician cannot be subjected to the types of evaluations that have been applied in the United States. “Physicians should conduct constant self-evaluations to see if they have the competences and skills needed to practice their profession ... Moreover, this is not a matter of age. It is a matter of ethics,” said Dr. Klajner.
The ability to adapt to change and implement innovation is critical to professional longevity, he said. “Nowadays, when I admit patients, I no longer do hospital rounds, which requires a mobility equal to physical abuse for me. Therefore, I work with physicians who take care of my hospitalized patients.”
Dr. Klajner also feels there is a distinction between innovations learned through studies and what can be offered safely to patients. “If I have to care for a hospitalized patient with severe pneumonia, for example, since I am not up to date in this specialty, I am going to call upon a pulmonologist I trust and forgo my honorarium for this admission. But I will remain on the team, monitoring the patient’s progression,” he said.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, Dr. Klajner stopped seeing patients in person under the recommendation of his son, Sidney Klajner, MD, also a physician. The elder Dr. Klajner began exploring telemedicine, which opened a whole new world of possibilities. “I have conducted several online visits to provide educational instruction to mothers returning home post delivery, for example,” he told this news organization. The time to stop is not something that concerns Dr. Klajner. “I’m only going to stop when I have a really important reason to do so. For example, if I can no longer write or study, reading and rereading an article without being able to understand what is being said. At this time, none of that is happening.”
In the United States, as well as in Brazil, physicians rarely provide information to human resources departments on colleagues showing signs of cognitive or motor decline affecting their professional performance. “The expectation is that health care professionals will report colleagues with cognitive impairments, but that often does not happen,” Dr. Katlic said.
It is also not common for professionals to report their own deficits to their institutions. In large part, this is caused by a lack of well-defined policies for dealing with this issue. This news organization sought out several public and private hospitals in Brazil to see if there is any guidance on professional longevity: Most said that there is not. Only the A. C. Camargo Cancer Center reported, through its public relations team, that a committee is discussing the subject but that it is still in the early stages.
Brazilian specialist associations do not offer guidelines or instructions on the various aspects of professional longevity. Dr. Constantino tried to put the subject on the agenda during the years in which he was an administrator with the CFM. “We tried to open up discussions regarding truly elderly physicians, but the subject was not well received. I believe that it is precisely because there is a tradition of physicians working until they are no longer able that this is more difficult in Brazil ... No one exactly knows what to do in this respect.” Dr. Constantino is against the use of age as a criterion for quitting practice.
“Of course, this is a point that has to be considered, but I always defended the need for regular assessment of physicians, regardless of age range. And, although assessments are always welcome, in any profession, I also believe this would not be well received in Brazil.” He endorses an assessment of one’s knowledge and not of physical abilities, which are generally assessed through investigation when needed.
The absence of guidelines increases individual responsibility, as well as vulnerability. “Consciously, physicians will not put patients at risk if they do not have the competence to care for them or to perform a surgical procedure,” said Clystenes Odyr Soares Silva, MD, PhD, adjunct professor of pulmonology of the Federal University of São Paulo (Brazil) School of Medicine (UNIFESP). “Your peers will tell you if you are no longer able,” he added. The problem is that physicians rarely admit to or talk about their colleagues’ deficits, especially if they are in the spotlight because of advanced age. In this situation, the observation and opinion of family members regarding the health care professional’s competences and skills will hold more weight.
In case of health-related physical impairment, such as partial loss of hand movement, for example, “it is expected that this will set off an ethical warning in the person,” said Dr. Constantino. When this warning does not occur naturally, patients or colleagues can report the professional, and this may lead to the opening of an administrative investigation. If the report is found to be true, this investigation is used to suspend physicians who do not have the physical or mental ability to continue practicing medicine.
“If it’s something very serious, the physician’s license can be temporarily suspended while [the physician] is treated by a psychiatrist, with follow-up by the professional board. When discharged, the physician will get his or her [professional] license back and can go back to work,” Dr. Constantino explained. If an expert evaluation is needed, the physician will then be assessed by a forensic psychiatrist. One of the most in-demand forensic psychiatrists in Brazil is Guido Arturo Palomba, MD, 73 years old. “I have assessed some physicians for actions reported to see if they were normal people or not, but never for circumstances related to age,” Dr. Palomba said.
In practice, Brazilian medical entities do not have policies or programs to guide physicians who wish to grow old while they work or those who have started to notice they are not performing as they used to. “We have never lived as long; therefore, the quality of life in old age, as well as the concept of aging, are some of the most relevant questions of our time. These are subjects requiring additional discussion, broadening understanding and awareness in this regard,” observed Mr. Vattimo.
Dr. Constantino and Dr. Silva, who are completely against age-based assessments, believe that recertification of the specialist license every 5 years is the best path to confirming whether the physician is still able to practice. “A knowledge-based test every 5 years to recertify the specialist license has often been a topic of conversation. I think it’s an excellent idea. The person would provide a dossier of all they have done in terms of courses, conferences, and other activities, present it, and receive a score,” said Dr. Silva.
In practice, recertification of the specialist license is a topic of discussion that has been raised for years, and it is an idea that the Brazilian Medical Association (AMB) defends. In conjunction with the CFM, the association is studying a way to best implement this assessment. “It’s important to emphasize that this measure would not be retroactive at first. Instead, it would only be in effect for professionals licensed after the recertification requirement is established,” the AMB pointed out in a note sent to this news organization. Even so, the measure has faced significant resistance from a faction of the profession, and its enactment does not seem to be imminent.
The debate regarding professional longevity is taking place in various countries. In 2021, the American Medical Association Council on Medical Education released a report with a set of guidelines for the screening and assessment of physicians. The document is the product of a committee created in 2015 to study the subject. The AMA recommends that the assessment of elderly physicians be based on evidence and ethical, relevant, fair, equitable, transparent, verifiable, nonexhaustive principles, contemplating support and protecting against legal proceedings. In April of this year, a new AMA document highlighted the same principles.
Also in the United States, one of oldest initiatives created to support physicians in the process of recycling, the University of California San Diego Physician Assessment and Clinical Education Program (PACE), has a section focusing on the extended practice of medicine (Practicing Medicine Longer). For those wanting to learn more about discussions on this subject, there are online presentations on experiences in Quebec and Ontario with assessing aging physicians, neuropsychological perspectives on the aging medical population, and what to expect of healthy aging, among other subjects.
Created in 1996, PACE mostly provides services to physicians who need to address requirements of the state medical boards. Few physicians enroll on their own.
The first part of the program assesses knowledge and skills over approximately 2 days. In the second phase, the physician participates in a series of activities in a corresponding residency program. Depending on the results, the physician may have to go through a remedial program with varying activities to deal with performance deficiencies to clinical experiences at the residency level.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Which factors fuel sexual violence in health care?
At the beginning of July, Brazilians across the country were appalled when they heard that an anesthesiologist was accused of sexually abusing a woman he had been treating during cesarean delivery. The incident was recorded on video by nurses and nurse technicians who, having become suspicious of the excessive amount of sedatives given to mothers-to-be by this particular anesthesiologist, decided to film him during a procedure. To do this, they made a last-minute change, switching delivery rooms to one in which they had hidden a cell phone in a cabinet.
What the footage showed was horrifying and the assailant, Giovanni Quintella Bezerra, was arrested on the spot. He’s a 32-year-old, White, successful physician, and he’s now accused of rape. The authorities are looking into whether there are more victims, others who may have been abused by the physician. The police are investigating about 40 surgeries in which Dr. Bezerra participated. That same month saw the arrest of another physician, gynecologist Ricardo Teles Martins, who was arrested after being accused of sexually harassing and abusing several women in Hidrolândia, in the northeastern state of Ceará.
In gathering information about these incidents, this news organization interviewed four Brazilian specialists to get their insights on the issues that have been brought to light by these recent cases and the factors that play a role in these kinds of criminal acts. Claudio Cohen, MD, PhD, is a psychiatrist, bioethicist, and professor at the University of São Paulo in Brazil. Daniela Pedroso, MA, is a psychologist who has 25 years’ experience working with victims of sexual violence. Gynecologist and obstetrician Jefferson Drezett, MD, PhD, is a professor in the field of population genetics and reproductive and sexual health at the Federal University of ABC, São Paulo, and in the department of health, life cycles, and society at the University of São Paulo School of Public Health. Maria Alice Scardoelli, MD, is a psychiatrist who also serves as vice-chair of the São Paulo Regional Council of Medicine (Cremesp).
Accusations and investigations
Not all incidents of sexual violence in health care institutions are reported, and precise numbers are difficult to obtain. The fact that there are any cases at all is troubling. In 2019, journalists from The Intercept found that over a period of 6 years (2014-2019), 1,734 such attacks were recorded in nine Brazilian states. They were able to get that information from the states’ Public Security Secretariats by using the Information Access Act, a law that regulates the right to access public information.
Efforts to determine how widespread this type of sexual violence is are further complicated by the difficulties in collating the accusations filed at each state’s regional council of medicine, police stations, and public prosecutor’s office. Which investigative steps are taken depends upon where the report was filed, and only occasionally do these entities communicate with each other. According to its data, Cremesp received 78 accusations in 2019. In 2020, that number increased to 84. In 2021, it was 83; these types of attacks were the seventh most common among the investigations opened that year. In the first 6 months of 2022, there were 36 complaints. The number includes investigations opened on the basis of press reports. In such cases, enough information must be available in the press reports make it possible to initiate an evaluation and assessment of the matter. There is no information about how many accusations became the subject of professional ethics proceedings and how many were formally adjudicated.
“Each accusation received is investigated by a technical committee made up of professionals from various specialties. There really needs to be a rigorous evaluation and assessment during the investigation. We cannot be unfair: It may turn out that there was no truth to the accusation after all, and yet someone’s career may already have been destroyed,” explained Dr. Scardoelli.
After the accusation is investigated and accepted by Cremesp, there is no deadline by which the proceedings must end. They can take up to 5 years, and sometimes longer. Since March, however, a deadline for the investigation period has been in effect, after which the proceedings can commence.
“We now have 90 days to make an evaluation and assessment in the investigation phase; that time period can be extended by 3 months, starting from the date the accusation is submitted to the council. If the case is accepted, then the proceedings are opened,” Dr. Scardoelli said.
Some incidents are not reported by victims. And there are incidents that are reported only after many years have passed. This was the case with Nina Marqueti, the actress at the center of #OndeDói — “Where It Hurts” — a campaign that was launched to raise awareness about sexual violence committed by health care professionals. When she was 16, her pediatrician sexually abused her. It wasn’t until 2019, more than a decade later, that she felt able to make this accusation known publicly.
Almost immediately, the campaign received over 4,000 posts online. Most of them were people’s accounts of acts of violence committed by physicians during appointments in their offices or during treatment in a hospital. These are available on Twitter under the hashtag #ondedoi.
Inadequate sex education?
News reports about physicians who abuse patients have a tremendous impact on the public. People are genuinely surprised when they hear the words “health care professional” and “sex attack” in the same sentence. “One of the most disturbing aspects is that health care professionals are committing these acts of violence against women who are in a vulnerable state, typically when they’re under anesthesia, they’ve fallen ill, or when the health care professional introduces an element of deception into the procedure so as to create the opportunity to abuse the patient in some way,” said Dr. Drezett.
As Dr. Cohen sees it, to perpetrate these acts of sexual violence, physicians – as well as lawyers, religious leaders, judges, politicians, police officers, and other persons in a position of trust – make use of their power to take advantage of a person’s vulnerability. “Physicians, lawyers, police officers, religious leaders, dads, bosses, husbands – the people who commit sexual abuse all have something in common,” he said. “In terms of the emotional aspect, all of them are taking advantage of both the power that their position holds in society and the asymmetrical power dynamics that exist between them and the other person.”
Indeed, anyone who knocks on a physician’s door seeking a diagnosis or treatment, anyone who knocks on a lawyer’s door seeking assistance, is putting themselves in a fragile situation. “The abuser considers the other person an object, not a human being who has rights,” said Dr. Cohen. People who fit the psychological and behavioral profile of a sexual assailant find in these “powerful” professions and in the circumstances and opportunities these professions provide a means to fulfill their desires. In medicine, however, there is yet another imbalance, one involving consent to touch a person’s body.
The age of the recently arrested anesthesiologist is something that caught Dr. Cohen’s attention. As noted in one of his many books, Bioética e Sexualidade nas Relações Profissionais [Bioethics and Sexuality in Professional Relationships], published in 1999 by the São Paulo Medical Association, age is a characteristic that repeatedly came up in his analysis of 150 sexual abuse proceedings handled by Cremesp.
“When I looked over the cases, I saw that most of the abusers were not right out of med school in their twenties – a time when sex is at the forefront of one’s life – nor were the abusers on the older end of the age spectrum. The abusers were, in fact, those who had already had several years of experience – as was the case with this 32-year-old anesthesiologist who, at a particular moment in time, breached all prohibitions and betrayed the expectations that society had of him as a physician: to care for people’s well-being and to alleviate their suffering. There was nothing that could hold him back from fulfilling his desire, not even the presence of nurses and other physicians in the operating room.” As for the findings of Dr. Cohen’s review, the majority of the 150 cases were dismissed because of lack of evidence.
To Ms. Pedroso, who has treated more than 12,000 victims of sexual harassment, it’s the questioning and intimidation that women feel in relationship to the male physician – a person who is viewed as holding knowledge about her body – that leaves them vulnerable and more subject to acts of violence, especially in more remote places. “We’re speaking, yet again, about rape culture. Not many people know what that term means, but, generally speaking, it has to do with the objectification of women’s bodies and the issue of boys growing up thinking they have the right to touch girls and women and that they will go unpunished for doing so.”
The lack of sex education and efforts to prevent sexual abuse are contributing factors for why the situation remains unchanged. “We are long overdue. We live in a country where there’s this completely mistaken belief that talking about sex education involves teaching children how to have sex, as opposed to teaching them how to protect themselves. We teach girls that they have to protect themselves from being raped, but we don’t teach boys not to rape.”
Another point highlighted by Ms. Pedroso is the fact that to carry out their actions, sexual assailants seek out-of-the-way places, places where they believe the rules can be bent and where they won’t be caught. This is what may have happened with Dr. Bezerra. During a recent press conference, the coordinator of the Health Section of the Rio de Janeiro Public Defender’s Office, Thaísa Guerreiro, stated that although the Women’s Hospital in São João do Meriti – one of the places where the assailant worked as an anesthesiologist – had adopted protocols to protect patients, it failed to enforce them. Another observation was that the health care professionals normalized violations of a woman’s right to have a companion present throughout labor and delivery, a right guaranteed by federal law. Ms. Guerreiro went on to say that the hospital’s chief of anesthesia and the state’s health coordination office did not question this, nor did they find it strange or surprising. According to witness statements, Dr. Bezerra would ask the patients’ husbands to leave the room in the middle of the procedure.
It should be clarified, Dr. Drezett mentioned, that although obstetric violence and sexual abuse overlap in places, they do not have the same root cause or definition. “There are two sets of situations that we term ‘obstetric violence.’ One involves any type of disrespectful treatment, whether comments or neglect, during pregnancy, delivery, or the postpartum period. The other refers to health care professionals’ attitudes in imposing inadequate and outdated medical procedures at the time of birth, such as keeping the woman fasting, having her pubic hair removed, and inducing labor or speeding up the delivery with oxytocin and [routine] episiotomy, among other things.”
Early education crucial
How are health care institutions dealing with this problem? “Very poorly. Sexual violence perpetrated by physicians and other health care professionals is a taboo subject that people are still afraid to talk about,” Dr. Cohen observed. “Regrettably, sexual violence happens all too often. Before, maybe we weren’t talking about it much because, from our viewpoint, health care professionals, such as physicians and nurses, weren’t likely to commit acts of violence while performing their duties,” noted Dr. Drezett.
Dr. Drezett also spoke about schools and what role they can play. “Of course, schools should discuss violence against women, especially in the field of health care. This has been done for a long time now, though it’s not in every curriculum in every medical school or nursing school, nor in every school of social work or of psychology,” said Dr. Drezett. For example, in the bioethics classes taken in the third and fourth years of the University of São Paolo’s medical degree program, Dr. Cohen asks students to reflect on the significance of being in a position where you ask a patient you’ve never met to undress so you can perform an exam, and the patient promptly and readily complies. “This is not about the physician, it’s about the power of the institution,” the professor pointed out. Sexual violence is a problem on the university campus as well. Another front in the battle has formed across various schools, where groups of students have created feminist collectives to have sexual violence and other issues related to gender-based violence added to the agenda.
Dr. Drezett said it’s very unlikely that efforts made during a degree program are going to succeed in preventing students who are prone to commit sexual violence from engaging in such behavior. “We’re talking about gender-specific lessons, where discussions about gender-based violence should be started much, much earlier – parents talking to their children, teachers talking to their pupils.” He also doesn’t believe that the molesters are dissuaded by the fact that these accusations get publicized in the media. “If they were, the Roger Abdelmassih case would have done away with the problem.”
On the other hand, Dr. Drezett suggested, publicizing these stories can help to bring very positive issues out into the open. What the Bezerra case made clear was that laws were not followed and rights were not protected. An environment was thus created in which the sexual crime could be perpetrated, with nurses coming to suspect acts of obstetric violence, such as use of sedation, which prevented the woman from having skin-to-skin contact with the newborn and from breastfeeding within the first few hours of birth – two clinical practices that are recommended the world over.
“Health care professionals who act properly, in accordance with best practices for interacting with others and performing daily duties, at all times, in public or private practice – they remove themselves from situations like those described in the Bezerra case; they don’t practice medicine in a reckless manner,” said Dr. Drezett.
Another negative aspect of all this, he said, is that the suspicion and wariness that patients feel may spread far and wide. “Among my colleagues are anesthetists and anesthesiologists with impeccable ethical and professional records. They are very upset that people are now regarding them with doubt and uncertainty. We need to make it clear that those horrifying cases are the exceptions, not the rule,” he said. There is also a need to correct the misconception that such abuse is always in some way associated with obstetrics and gynecology.
“This is not true. These incidents can happen in any doctor’s office. It all depends on the physician – whether he or she has designs on committing a criminal act,” Dr. Drezett noted. He did point out that there are few sexual molesters among health care professionals, though there are numerous cases. Yet this in no way diminishes the seriousness of the incidents. “Of course, we’re speaking again about the exceptions, but in my experience of treating victims, I’ve seen, for example, more cases where it’s been a police officer, not a physician, committing an act of sexual violence against a woman,” he stated.
The nurses and nurse technicians at São João do Meriti Hospital who reported the abuser acted very assertively. If they hadn’t gathered the evidence to back up their accusations, it’s possible that the physician wouldn’t have been caught in the act and that the case would have taken a different course – including pressure being put on them and their becoming the target of retaliation.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape Portuguese edition.
At the beginning of July, Brazilians across the country were appalled when they heard that an anesthesiologist was accused of sexually abusing a woman he had been treating during cesarean delivery. The incident was recorded on video by nurses and nurse technicians who, having become suspicious of the excessive amount of sedatives given to mothers-to-be by this particular anesthesiologist, decided to film him during a procedure. To do this, they made a last-minute change, switching delivery rooms to one in which they had hidden a cell phone in a cabinet.
What the footage showed was horrifying and the assailant, Giovanni Quintella Bezerra, was arrested on the spot. He’s a 32-year-old, White, successful physician, and he’s now accused of rape. The authorities are looking into whether there are more victims, others who may have been abused by the physician. The police are investigating about 40 surgeries in which Dr. Bezerra participated. That same month saw the arrest of another physician, gynecologist Ricardo Teles Martins, who was arrested after being accused of sexually harassing and abusing several women in Hidrolândia, in the northeastern state of Ceará.
In gathering information about these incidents, this news organization interviewed four Brazilian specialists to get their insights on the issues that have been brought to light by these recent cases and the factors that play a role in these kinds of criminal acts. Claudio Cohen, MD, PhD, is a psychiatrist, bioethicist, and professor at the University of São Paulo in Brazil. Daniela Pedroso, MA, is a psychologist who has 25 years’ experience working with victims of sexual violence. Gynecologist and obstetrician Jefferson Drezett, MD, PhD, is a professor in the field of population genetics and reproductive and sexual health at the Federal University of ABC, São Paulo, and in the department of health, life cycles, and society at the University of São Paulo School of Public Health. Maria Alice Scardoelli, MD, is a psychiatrist who also serves as vice-chair of the São Paulo Regional Council of Medicine (Cremesp).
Accusations and investigations
Not all incidents of sexual violence in health care institutions are reported, and precise numbers are difficult to obtain. The fact that there are any cases at all is troubling. In 2019, journalists from The Intercept found that over a period of 6 years (2014-2019), 1,734 such attacks were recorded in nine Brazilian states. They were able to get that information from the states’ Public Security Secretariats by using the Information Access Act, a law that regulates the right to access public information.
Efforts to determine how widespread this type of sexual violence is are further complicated by the difficulties in collating the accusations filed at each state’s regional council of medicine, police stations, and public prosecutor’s office. Which investigative steps are taken depends upon where the report was filed, and only occasionally do these entities communicate with each other. According to its data, Cremesp received 78 accusations in 2019. In 2020, that number increased to 84. In 2021, it was 83; these types of attacks were the seventh most common among the investigations opened that year. In the first 6 months of 2022, there were 36 complaints. The number includes investigations opened on the basis of press reports. In such cases, enough information must be available in the press reports make it possible to initiate an evaluation and assessment of the matter. There is no information about how many accusations became the subject of professional ethics proceedings and how many were formally adjudicated.
“Each accusation received is investigated by a technical committee made up of professionals from various specialties. There really needs to be a rigorous evaluation and assessment during the investigation. We cannot be unfair: It may turn out that there was no truth to the accusation after all, and yet someone’s career may already have been destroyed,” explained Dr. Scardoelli.
After the accusation is investigated and accepted by Cremesp, there is no deadline by which the proceedings must end. They can take up to 5 years, and sometimes longer. Since March, however, a deadline for the investigation period has been in effect, after which the proceedings can commence.
“We now have 90 days to make an evaluation and assessment in the investigation phase; that time period can be extended by 3 months, starting from the date the accusation is submitted to the council. If the case is accepted, then the proceedings are opened,” Dr. Scardoelli said.
Some incidents are not reported by victims. And there are incidents that are reported only after many years have passed. This was the case with Nina Marqueti, the actress at the center of #OndeDói — “Where It Hurts” — a campaign that was launched to raise awareness about sexual violence committed by health care professionals. When she was 16, her pediatrician sexually abused her. It wasn’t until 2019, more than a decade later, that she felt able to make this accusation known publicly.
Almost immediately, the campaign received over 4,000 posts online. Most of them were people’s accounts of acts of violence committed by physicians during appointments in their offices or during treatment in a hospital. These are available on Twitter under the hashtag #ondedoi.
Inadequate sex education?
News reports about physicians who abuse patients have a tremendous impact on the public. People are genuinely surprised when they hear the words “health care professional” and “sex attack” in the same sentence. “One of the most disturbing aspects is that health care professionals are committing these acts of violence against women who are in a vulnerable state, typically when they’re under anesthesia, they’ve fallen ill, or when the health care professional introduces an element of deception into the procedure so as to create the opportunity to abuse the patient in some way,” said Dr. Drezett.
As Dr. Cohen sees it, to perpetrate these acts of sexual violence, physicians – as well as lawyers, religious leaders, judges, politicians, police officers, and other persons in a position of trust – make use of their power to take advantage of a person’s vulnerability. “Physicians, lawyers, police officers, religious leaders, dads, bosses, husbands – the people who commit sexual abuse all have something in common,” he said. “In terms of the emotional aspect, all of them are taking advantage of both the power that their position holds in society and the asymmetrical power dynamics that exist between them and the other person.”
Indeed, anyone who knocks on a physician’s door seeking a diagnosis or treatment, anyone who knocks on a lawyer’s door seeking assistance, is putting themselves in a fragile situation. “The abuser considers the other person an object, not a human being who has rights,” said Dr. Cohen. People who fit the psychological and behavioral profile of a sexual assailant find in these “powerful” professions and in the circumstances and opportunities these professions provide a means to fulfill their desires. In medicine, however, there is yet another imbalance, one involving consent to touch a person’s body.
The age of the recently arrested anesthesiologist is something that caught Dr. Cohen’s attention. As noted in one of his many books, Bioética e Sexualidade nas Relações Profissionais [Bioethics and Sexuality in Professional Relationships], published in 1999 by the São Paulo Medical Association, age is a characteristic that repeatedly came up in his analysis of 150 sexual abuse proceedings handled by Cremesp.
“When I looked over the cases, I saw that most of the abusers were not right out of med school in their twenties – a time when sex is at the forefront of one’s life – nor were the abusers on the older end of the age spectrum. The abusers were, in fact, those who had already had several years of experience – as was the case with this 32-year-old anesthesiologist who, at a particular moment in time, breached all prohibitions and betrayed the expectations that society had of him as a physician: to care for people’s well-being and to alleviate their suffering. There was nothing that could hold him back from fulfilling his desire, not even the presence of nurses and other physicians in the operating room.” As for the findings of Dr. Cohen’s review, the majority of the 150 cases were dismissed because of lack of evidence.
To Ms. Pedroso, who has treated more than 12,000 victims of sexual harassment, it’s the questioning and intimidation that women feel in relationship to the male physician – a person who is viewed as holding knowledge about her body – that leaves them vulnerable and more subject to acts of violence, especially in more remote places. “We’re speaking, yet again, about rape culture. Not many people know what that term means, but, generally speaking, it has to do with the objectification of women’s bodies and the issue of boys growing up thinking they have the right to touch girls and women and that they will go unpunished for doing so.”
The lack of sex education and efforts to prevent sexual abuse are contributing factors for why the situation remains unchanged. “We are long overdue. We live in a country where there’s this completely mistaken belief that talking about sex education involves teaching children how to have sex, as opposed to teaching them how to protect themselves. We teach girls that they have to protect themselves from being raped, but we don’t teach boys not to rape.”
Another point highlighted by Ms. Pedroso is the fact that to carry out their actions, sexual assailants seek out-of-the-way places, places where they believe the rules can be bent and where they won’t be caught. This is what may have happened with Dr. Bezerra. During a recent press conference, the coordinator of the Health Section of the Rio de Janeiro Public Defender’s Office, Thaísa Guerreiro, stated that although the Women’s Hospital in São João do Meriti – one of the places where the assailant worked as an anesthesiologist – had adopted protocols to protect patients, it failed to enforce them. Another observation was that the health care professionals normalized violations of a woman’s right to have a companion present throughout labor and delivery, a right guaranteed by federal law. Ms. Guerreiro went on to say that the hospital’s chief of anesthesia and the state’s health coordination office did not question this, nor did they find it strange or surprising. According to witness statements, Dr. Bezerra would ask the patients’ husbands to leave the room in the middle of the procedure.
It should be clarified, Dr. Drezett mentioned, that although obstetric violence and sexual abuse overlap in places, they do not have the same root cause or definition. “There are two sets of situations that we term ‘obstetric violence.’ One involves any type of disrespectful treatment, whether comments or neglect, during pregnancy, delivery, or the postpartum period. The other refers to health care professionals’ attitudes in imposing inadequate and outdated medical procedures at the time of birth, such as keeping the woman fasting, having her pubic hair removed, and inducing labor or speeding up the delivery with oxytocin and [routine] episiotomy, among other things.”
Early education crucial
How are health care institutions dealing with this problem? “Very poorly. Sexual violence perpetrated by physicians and other health care professionals is a taboo subject that people are still afraid to talk about,” Dr. Cohen observed. “Regrettably, sexual violence happens all too often. Before, maybe we weren’t talking about it much because, from our viewpoint, health care professionals, such as physicians and nurses, weren’t likely to commit acts of violence while performing their duties,” noted Dr. Drezett.
Dr. Drezett also spoke about schools and what role they can play. “Of course, schools should discuss violence against women, especially in the field of health care. This has been done for a long time now, though it’s not in every curriculum in every medical school or nursing school, nor in every school of social work or of psychology,” said Dr. Drezett. For example, in the bioethics classes taken in the third and fourth years of the University of São Paolo’s medical degree program, Dr. Cohen asks students to reflect on the significance of being in a position where you ask a patient you’ve never met to undress so you can perform an exam, and the patient promptly and readily complies. “This is not about the physician, it’s about the power of the institution,” the professor pointed out. Sexual violence is a problem on the university campus as well. Another front in the battle has formed across various schools, where groups of students have created feminist collectives to have sexual violence and other issues related to gender-based violence added to the agenda.
Dr. Drezett said it’s very unlikely that efforts made during a degree program are going to succeed in preventing students who are prone to commit sexual violence from engaging in such behavior. “We’re talking about gender-specific lessons, where discussions about gender-based violence should be started much, much earlier – parents talking to their children, teachers talking to their pupils.” He also doesn’t believe that the molesters are dissuaded by the fact that these accusations get publicized in the media. “If they were, the Roger Abdelmassih case would have done away with the problem.”
On the other hand, Dr. Drezett suggested, publicizing these stories can help to bring very positive issues out into the open. What the Bezerra case made clear was that laws were not followed and rights were not protected. An environment was thus created in which the sexual crime could be perpetrated, with nurses coming to suspect acts of obstetric violence, such as use of sedation, which prevented the woman from having skin-to-skin contact with the newborn and from breastfeeding within the first few hours of birth – two clinical practices that are recommended the world over.
“Health care professionals who act properly, in accordance with best practices for interacting with others and performing daily duties, at all times, in public or private practice – they remove themselves from situations like those described in the Bezerra case; they don’t practice medicine in a reckless manner,” said Dr. Drezett.
Another negative aspect of all this, he said, is that the suspicion and wariness that patients feel may spread far and wide. “Among my colleagues are anesthetists and anesthesiologists with impeccable ethical and professional records. They are very upset that people are now regarding them with doubt and uncertainty. We need to make it clear that those horrifying cases are the exceptions, not the rule,” he said. There is also a need to correct the misconception that such abuse is always in some way associated with obstetrics and gynecology.
“This is not true. These incidents can happen in any doctor’s office. It all depends on the physician – whether he or she has designs on committing a criminal act,” Dr. Drezett noted. He did point out that there are few sexual molesters among health care professionals, though there are numerous cases. Yet this in no way diminishes the seriousness of the incidents. “Of course, we’re speaking again about the exceptions, but in my experience of treating victims, I’ve seen, for example, more cases where it’s been a police officer, not a physician, committing an act of sexual violence against a woman,” he stated.
The nurses and nurse technicians at São João do Meriti Hospital who reported the abuser acted very assertively. If they hadn’t gathered the evidence to back up their accusations, it’s possible that the physician wouldn’t have been caught in the act and that the case would have taken a different course – including pressure being put on them and their becoming the target of retaliation.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape Portuguese edition.
At the beginning of July, Brazilians across the country were appalled when they heard that an anesthesiologist was accused of sexually abusing a woman he had been treating during cesarean delivery. The incident was recorded on video by nurses and nurse technicians who, having become suspicious of the excessive amount of sedatives given to mothers-to-be by this particular anesthesiologist, decided to film him during a procedure. To do this, they made a last-minute change, switching delivery rooms to one in which they had hidden a cell phone in a cabinet.
What the footage showed was horrifying and the assailant, Giovanni Quintella Bezerra, was arrested on the spot. He’s a 32-year-old, White, successful physician, and he’s now accused of rape. The authorities are looking into whether there are more victims, others who may have been abused by the physician. The police are investigating about 40 surgeries in which Dr. Bezerra participated. That same month saw the arrest of another physician, gynecologist Ricardo Teles Martins, who was arrested after being accused of sexually harassing and abusing several women in Hidrolândia, in the northeastern state of Ceará.
In gathering information about these incidents, this news organization interviewed four Brazilian specialists to get their insights on the issues that have been brought to light by these recent cases and the factors that play a role in these kinds of criminal acts. Claudio Cohen, MD, PhD, is a psychiatrist, bioethicist, and professor at the University of São Paulo in Brazil. Daniela Pedroso, MA, is a psychologist who has 25 years’ experience working with victims of sexual violence. Gynecologist and obstetrician Jefferson Drezett, MD, PhD, is a professor in the field of population genetics and reproductive and sexual health at the Federal University of ABC, São Paulo, and in the department of health, life cycles, and society at the University of São Paulo School of Public Health. Maria Alice Scardoelli, MD, is a psychiatrist who also serves as vice-chair of the São Paulo Regional Council of Medicine (Cremesp).
Accusations and investigations
Not all incidents of sexual violence in health care institutions are reported, and precise numbers are difficult to obtain. The fact that there are any cases at all is troubling. In 2019, journalists from The Intercept found that over a period of 6 years (2014-2019), 1,734 such attacks were recorded in nine Brazilian states. They were able to get that information from the states’ Public Security Secretariats by using the Information Access Act, a law that regulates the right to access public information.
Efforts to determine how widespread this type of sexual violence is are further complicated by the difficulties in collating the accusations filed at each state’s regional council of medicine, police stations, and public prosecutor’s office. Which investigative steps are taken depends upon where the report was filed, and only occasionally do these entities communicate with each other. According to its data, Cremesp received 78 accusations in 2019. In 2020, that number increased to 84. In 2021, it was 83; these types of attacks were the seventh most common among the investigations opened that year. In the first 6 months of 2022, there were 36 complaints. The number includes investigations opened on the basis of press reports. In such cases, enough information must be available in the press reports make it possible to initiate an evaluation and assessment of the matter. There is no information about how many accusations became the subject of professional ethics proceedings and how many were formally adjudicated.
“Each accusation received is investigated by a technical committee made up of professionals from various specialties. There really needs to be a rigorous evaluation and assessment during the investigation. We cannot be unfair: It may turn out that there was no truth to the accusation after all, and yet someone’s career may already have been destroyed,” explained Dr. Scardoelli.
After the accusation is investigated and accepted by Cremesp, there is no deadline by which the proceedings must end. They can take up to 5 years, and sometimes longer. Since March, however, a deadline for the investigation period has been in effect, after which the proceedings can commence.
“We now have 90 days to make an evaluation and assessment in the investigation phase; that time period can be extended by 3 months, starting from the date the accusation is submitted to the council. If the case is accepted, then the proceedings are opened,” Dr. Scardoelli said.
Some incidents are not reported by victims. And there are incidents that are reported only after many years have passed. This was the case with Nina Marqueti, the actress at the center of #OndeDói — “Where It Hurts” — a campaign that was launched to raise awareness about sexual violence committed by health care professionals. When she was 16, her pediatrician sexually abused her. It wasn’t until 2019, more than a decade later, that she felt able to make this accusation known publicly.
Almost immediately, the campaign received over 4,000 posts online. Most of them were people’s accounts of acts of violence committed by physicians during appointments in their offices or during treatment in a hospital. These are available on Twitter under the hashtag #ondedoi.
Inadequate sex education?
News reports about physicians who abuse patients have a tremendous impact on the public. People are genuinely surprised when they hear the words “health care professional” and “sex attack” in the same sentence. “One of the most disturbing aspects is that health care professionals are committing these acts of violence against women who are in a vulnerable state, typically when they’re under anesthesia, they’ve fallen ill, or when the health care professional introduces an element of deception into the procedure so as to create the opportunity to abuse the patient in some way,” said Dr. Drezett.
As Dr. Cohen sees it, to perpetrate these acts of sexual violence, physicians – as well as lawyers, religious leaders, judges, politicians, police officers, and other persons in a position of trust – make use of their power to take advantage of a person’s vulnerability. “Physicians, lawyers, police officers, religious leaders, dads, bosses, husbands – the people who commit sexual abuse all have something in common,” he said. “In terms of the emotional aspect, all of them are taking advantage of both the power that their position holds in society and the asymmetrical power dynamics that exist between them and the other person.”
Indeed, anyone who knocks on a physician’s door seeking a diagnosis or treatment, anyone who knocks on a lawyer’s door seeking assistance, is putting themselves in a fragile situation. “The abuser considers the other person an object, not a human being who has rights,” said Dr. Cohen. People who fit the psychological and behavioral profile of a sexual assailant find in these “powerful” professions and in the circumstances and opportunities these professions provide a means to fulfill their desires. In medicine, however, there is yet another imbalance, one involving consent to touch a person’s body.
The age of the recently arrested anesthesiologist is something that caught Dr. Cohen’s attention. As noted in one of his many books, Bioética e Sexualidade nas Relações Profissionais [Bioethics and Sexuality in Professional Relationships], published in 1999 by the São Paulo Medical Association, age is a characteristic that repeatedly came up in his analysis of 150 sexual abuse proceedings handled by Cremesp.
“When I looked over the cases, I saw that most of the abusers were not right out of med school in their twenties – a time when sex is at the forefront of one’s life – nor were the abusers on the older end of the age spectrum. The abusers were, in fact, those who had already had several years of experience – as was the case with this 32-year-old anesthesiologist who, at a particular moment in time, breached all prohibitions and betrayed the expectations that society had of him as a physician: to care for people’s well-being and to alleviate their suffering. There was nothing that could hold him back from fulfilling his desire, not even the presence of nurses and other physicians in the operating room.” As for the findings of Dr. Cohen’s review, the majority of the 150 cases were dismissed because of lack of evidence.
To Ms. Pedroso, who has treated more than 12,000 victims of sexual harassment, it’s the questioning and intimidation that women feel in relationship to the male physician – a person who is viewed as holding knowledge about her body – that leaves them vulnerable and more subject to acts of violence, especially in more remote places. “We’re speaking, yet again, about rape culture. Not many people know what that term means, but, generally speaking, it has to do with the objectification of women’s bodies and the issue of boys growing up thinking they have the right to touch girls and women and that they will go unpunished for doing so.”
The lack of sex education and efforts to prevent sexual abuse are contributing factors for why the situation remains unchanged. “We are long overdue. We live in a country where there’s this completely mistaken belief that talking about sex education involves teaching children how to have sex, as opposed to teaching them how to protect themselves. We teach girls that they have to protect themselves from being raped, but we don’t teach boys not to rape.”
Another point highlighted by Ms. Pedroso is the fact that to carry out their actions, sexual assailants seek out-of-the-way places, places where they believe the rules can be bent and where they won’t be caught. This is what may have happened with Dr. Bezerra. During a recent press conference, the coordinator of the Health Section of the Rio de Janeiro Public Defender’s Office, Thaísa Guerreiro, stated that although the Women’s Hospital in São João do Meriti – one of the places where the assailant worked as an anesthesiologist – had adopted protocols to protect patients, it failed to enforce them. Another observation was that the health care professionals normalized violations of a woman’s right to have a companion present throughout labor and delivery, a right guaranteed by federal law. Ms. Guerreiro went on to say that the hospital’s chief of anesthesia and the state’s health coordination office did not question this, nor did they find it strange or surprising. According to witness statements, Dr. Bezerra would ask the patients’ husbands to leave the room in the middle of the procedure.
It should be clarified, Dr. Drezett mentioned, that although obstetric violence and sexual abuse overlap in places, they do not have the same root cause or definition. “There are two sets of situations that we term ‘obstetric violence.’ One involves any type of disrespectful treatment, whether comments or neglect, during pregnancy, delivery, or the postpartum period. The other refers to health care professionals’ attitudes in imposing inadequate and outdated medical procedures at the time of birth, such as keeping the woman fasting, having her pubic hair removed, and inducing labor or speeding up the delivery with oxytocin and [routine] episiotomy, among other things.”
Early education crucial
How are health care institutions dealing with this problem? “Very poorly. Sexual violence perpetrated by physicians and other health care professionals is a taboo subject that people are still afraid to talk about,” Dr. Cohen observed. “Regrettably, sexual violence happens all too often. Before, maybe we weren’t talking about it much because, from our viewpoint, health care professionals, such as physicians and nurses, weren’t likely to commit acts of violence while performing their duties,” noted Dr. Drezett.
Dr. Drezett also spoke about schools and what role they can play. “Of course, schools should discuss violence against women, especially in the field of health care. This has been done for a long time now, though it’s not in every curriculum in every medical school or nursing school, nor in every school of social work or of psychology,” said Dr. Drezett. For example, in the bioethics classes taken in the third and fourth years of the University of São Paolo’s medical degree program, Dr. Cohen asks students to reflect on the significance of being in a position where you ask a patient you’ve never met to undress so you can perform an exam, and the patient promptly and readily complies. “This is not about the physician, it’s about the power of the institution,” the professor pointed out. Sexual violence is a problem on the university campus as well. Another front in the battle has formed across various schools, where groups of students have created feminist collectives to have sexual violence and other issues related to gender-based violence added to the agenda.
Dr. Drezett said it’s very unlikely that efforts made during a degree program are going to succeed in preventing students who are prone to commit sexual violence from engaging in such behavior. “We’re talking about gender-specific lessons, where discussions about gender-based violence should be started much, much earlier – parents talking to their children, teachers talking to their pupils.” He also doesn’t believe that the molesters are dissuaded by the fact that these accusations get publicized in the media. “If they were, the Roger Abdelmassih case would have done away with the problem.”
On the other hand, Dr. Drezett suggested, publicizing these stories can help to bring very positive issues out into the open. What the Bezerra case made clear was that laws were not followed and rights were not protected. An environment was thus created in which the sexual crime could be perpetrated, with nurses coming to suspect acts of obstetric violence, such as use of sedation, which prevented the woman from having skin-to-skin contact with the newborn and from breastfeeding within the first few hours of birth – two clinical practices that are recommended the world over.
“Health care professionals who act properly, in accordance with best practices for interacting with others and performing daily duties, at all times, in public or private practice – they remove themselves from situations like those described in the Bezerra case; they don’t practice medicine in a reckless manner,” said Dr. Drezett.
Another negative aspect of all this, he said, is that the suspicion and wariness that patients feel may spread far and wide. “Among my colleagues are anesthetists and anesthesiologists with impeccable ethical and professional records. They are very upset that people are now regarding them with doubt and uncertainty. We need to make it clear that those horrifying cases are the exceptions, not the rule,” he said. There is also a need to correct the misconception that such abuse is always in some way associated with obstetrics and gynecology.
“This is not true. These incidents can happen in any doctor’s office. It all depends on the physician – whether he or she has designs on committing a criminal act,” Dr. Drezett noted. He did point out that there are few sexual molesters among health care professionals, though there are numerous cases. Yet this in no way diminishes the seriousness of the incidents. “Of course, we’re speaking again about the exceptions, but in my experience of treating victims, I’ve seen, for example, more cases where it’s been a police officer, not a physician, committing an act of sexual violence against a woman,” he stated.
The nurses and nurse technicians at São João do Meriti Hospital who reported the abuser acted very assertively. If they hadn’t gathered the evidence to back up their accusations, it’s possible that the physician wouldn’t have been caught in the act and that the case would have taken a different course – including pressure being put on them and their becoming the target of retaliation.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape Portuguese edition.
Mortality 12 times higher in children with congenital Zika
About 80% of people infected with Zika virus show no symptoms, and that’s particularly problematic during pregnancy. The infection can cause birth defects and is the origin of numerous cases of microcephaly and other neurologic impairments.
The large amount of Aedes aegypti mosquitoes in Brazilian cities, in addition to social and political problems, facilitated the spread of Zika to the point that the country recorded its highest number of congenital Zika syndrome notifications from 2015 to 2018. Since then, researchers have investigated the extent of the problem.
One of the most compelling findings about the dramatic legacy of Zika in Brazil was published Feb. 24 in The New England Journal of Medicine: After tracking 11,481,215 children born alive in Brazil up to 36 months of age between the years 2015 and 2018, the researchers found that the mortality rate was about 12 times higher among children with congenital Zika syndrome in comparison to children without the syndrome. The study is the first to follow children with congenital Zika syndrome for 3 years and to report mortality in this group.
“This difference persisted throughout the first 3 years of life,” Enny S. Paixão, PhD, of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, and Fiocruz-Bahia’s Instituto Gonçalo Moniz, in Brazil, said in an interview.
At the end of the study period, the mortality rate was 52.6 deaths (95% confidence interval, 47.6-58.0) per 1,000 person-years among children with congenital Zika syndrome and 5.6 deaths (95% CI, 5.6-5.7) per 1,000 person-years among those without the syndrome. The mortality rate ratio among children with congenital Zika syndrome, compared with those without it, was 11.3 (95% CI, 10.2-12.4). Data analysis also showed that the 3,308 children with the syndrome were born to mothers who were younger and had fewer years of study when compared to the mothers of their 11,477,907 counterparts without the syndrome.
“If the children survived the first month of life, they had a greater chance of surviving during childhood, because the mortality rates drop,” said Dr. Paixão. “In children with congenital Zika syndrome, this rate also drops, but slowly. The more we stratified by period – neonatal, post neonatal, and the period from the first to the third year of life – the more we saw the relative risk increase. After the first year of life, children with the syndrome were almost 22 times more likely to die compared to children without it. It was hard to believe the data.” Dr. Paixão added that the mortality observed in this study is comparable with the findings of previous studies.
In addition to the large sample size – more than 11 million children – another unique aspect of the work was the comparison with healthy live births. “Previous studies didn’t have this comparison group,” Dr. said Paixão.
Perhaps the major challenge of the study, Dr. Paixão explained, was the fragmentation of the data. “In Brazil we have high-quality data systems, but they are not interconnected. We have a database with all live births, another with mortality records, and another with all children with congenital Zika syndrome. The first big challenge was putting all this information together.”
The solution found by the researchers was to use data linkage – bringing information about the same person from different data banks to create a richer dataset. Basically, they linked the data from the live births registry with the deaths that occurred in the studied age group plus around 18,000 children with congenital Zika syndrome. This was done, said Dr. Paixão, by choosing some identifying variables (such as mother’s name, address, and age) and using an algorithm that evaluates the probability that the “N” in one database is the same person in another database.
“This is expensive, complex, [and] involves super-powerful computers and a lot of researchers,” she said.
The impressive mortality data for children with congenital Zika syndrome obtained by the group of researchers made it inevitable to think about how the country should address this terrible legacy.
“The first and most important recommendation is that the country needs to invest in primary care, so that women don’t get Zika during pregnancy and children aren’t at risk of getting the syndrome,” said Dr. Paixão.
As for the affected population, she highlighted the need to deepen the understanding of the syndrome’s natural history to improve survival and quality of life of affected children and their families. One possibility that was recently discussed by the group of researchers is to carry out a study on the causes of hospitalization of children with the syndrome to develop appropriate protocols and procedures that reduce admissions and death in this population.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
About 80% of people infected with Zika virus show no symptoms, and that’s particularly problematic during pregnancy. The infection can cause birth defects and is the origin of numerous cases of microcephaly and other neurologic impairments.
The large amount of Aedes aegypti mosquitoes in Brazilian cities, in addition to social and political problems, facilitated the spread of Zika to the point that the country recorded its highest number of congenital Zika syndrome notifications from 2015 to 2018. Since then, researchers have investigated the extent of the problem.
One of the most compelling findings about the dramatic legacy of Zika in Brazil was published Feb. 24 in The New England Journal of Medicine: After tracking 11,481,215 children born alive in Brazil up to 36 months of age between the years 2015 and 2018, the researchers found that the mortality rate was about 12 times higher among children with congenital Zika syndrome in comparison to children without the syndrome. The study is the first to follow children with congenital Zika syndrome for 3 years and to report mortality in this group.
“This difference persisted throughout the first 3 years of life,” Enny S. Paixão, PhD, of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, and Fiocruz-Bahia’s Instituto Gonçalo Moniz, in Brazil, said in an interview.
At the end of the study period, the mortality rate was 52.6 deaths (95% confidence interval, 47.6-58.0) per 1,000 person-years among children with congenital Zika syndrome and 5.6 deaths (95% CI, 5.6-5.7) per 1,000 person-years among those without the syndrome. The mortality rate ratio among children with congenital Zika syndrome, compared with those without it, was 11.3 (95% CI, 10.2-12.4). Data analysis also showed that the 3,308 children with the syndrome were born to mothers who were younger and had fewer years of study when compared to the mothers of their 11,477,907 counterparts without the syndrome.
“If the children survived the first month of life, they had a greater chance of surviving during childhood, because the mortality rates drop,” said Dr. Paixão. “In children with congenital Zika syndrome, this rate also drops, but slowly. The more we stratified by period – neonatal, post neonatal, and the period from the first to the third year of life – the more we saw the relative risk increase. After the first year of life, children with the syndrome were almost 22 times more likely to die compared to children without it. It was hard to believe the data.” Dr. Paixão added that the mortality observed in this study is comparable with the findings of previous studies.
In addition to the large sample size – more than 11 million children – another unique aspect of the work was the comparison with healthy live births. “Previous studies didn’t have this comparison group,” Dr. said Paixão.
Perhaps the major challenge of the study, Dr. Paixão explained, was the fragmentation of the data. “In Brazil we have high-quality data systems, but they are not interconnected. We have a database with all live births, another with mortality records, and another with all children with congenital Zika syndrome. The first big challenge was putting all this information together.”
The solution found by the researchers was to use data linkage – bringing information about the same person from different data banks to create a richer dataset. Basically, they linked the data from the live births registry with the deaths that occurred in the studied age group plus around 18,000 children with congenital Zika syndrome. This was done, said Dr. Paixão, by choosing some identifying variables (such as mother’s name, address, and age) and using an algorithm that evaluates the probability that the “N” in one database is the same person in another database.
“This is expensive, complex, [and] involves super-powerful computers and a lot of researchers,” she said.
The impressive mortality data for children with congenital Zika syndrome obtained by the group of researchers made it inevitable to think about how the country should address this terrible legacy.
“The first and most important recommendation is that the country needs to invest in primary care, so that women don’t get Zika during pregnancy and children aren’t at risk of getting the syndrome,” said Dr. Paixão.
As for the affected population, she highlighted the need to deepen the understanding of the syndrome’s natural history to improve survival and quality of life of affected children and their families. One possibility that was recently discussed by the group of researchers is to carry out a study on the causes of hospitalization of children with the syndrome to develop appropriate protocols and procedures that reduce admissions and death in this population.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
About 80% of people infected with Zika virus show no symptoms, and that’s particularly problematic during pregnancy. The infection can cause birth defects and is the origin of numerous cases of microcephaly and other neurologic impairments.
The large amount of Aedes aegypti mosquitoes in Brazilian cities, in addition to social and political problems, facilitated the spread of Zika to the point that the country recorded its highest number of congenital Zika syndrome notifications from 2015 to 2018. Since then, researchers have investigated the extent of the problem.
One of the most compelling findings about the dramatic legacy of Zika in Brazil was published Feb. 24 in The New England Journal of Medicine: After tracking 11,481,215 children born alive in Brazil up to 36 months of age between the years 2015 and 2018, the researchers found that the mortality rate was about 12 times higher among children with congenital Zika syndrome in comparison to children without the syndrome. The study is the first to follow children with congenital Zika syndrome for 3 years and to report mortality in this group.
“This difference persisted throughout the first 3 years of life,” Enny S. Paixão, PhD, of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, and Fiocruz-Bahia’s Instituto Gonçalo Moniz, in Brazil, said in an interview.
At the end of the study period, the mortality rate was 52.6 deaths (95% confidence interval, 47.6-58.0) per 1,000 person-years among children with congenital Zika syndrome and 5.6 deaths (95% CI, 5.6-5.7) per 1,000 person-years among those without the syndrome. The mortality rate ratio among children with congenital Zika syndrome, compared with those without it, was 11.3 (95% CI, 10.2-12.4). Data analysis also showed that the 3,308 children with the syndrome were born to mothers who were younger and had fewer years of study when compared to the mothers of their 11,477,907 counterparts without the syndrome.
“If the children survived the first month of life, they had a greater chance of surviving during childhood, because the mortality rates drop,” said Dr. Paixão. “In children with congenital Zika syndrome, this rate also drops, but slowly. The more we stratified by period – neonatal, post neonatal, and the period from the first to the third year of life – the more we saw the relative risk increase. After the first year of life, children with the syndrome were almost 22 times more likely to die compared to children without it. It was hard to believe the data.” Dr. Paixão added that the mortality observed in this study is comparable with the findings of previous studies.
In addition to the large sample size – more than 11 million children – another unique aspect of the work was the comparison with healthy live births. “Previous studies didn’t have this comparison group,” Dr. said Paixão.
Perhaps the major challenge of the study, Dr. Paixão explained, was the fragmentation of the data. “In Brazil we have high-quality data systems, but they are not interconnected. We have a database with all live births, another with mortality records, and another with all children with congenital Zika syndrome. The first big challenge was putting all this information together.”
The solution found by the researchers was to use data linkage – bringing information about the same person from different data banks to create a richer dataset. Basically, they linked the data from the live births registry with the deaths that occurred in the studied age group plus around 18,000 children with congenital Zika syndrome. This was done, said Dr. Paixão, by choosing some identifying variables (such as mother’s name, address, and age) and using an algorithm that evaluates the probability that the “N” in one database is the same person in another database.
“This is expensive, complex, [and] involves super-powerful computers and a lot of researchers,” she said.
The impressive mortality data for children with congenital Zika syndrome obtained by the group of researchers made it inevitable to think about how the country should address this terrible legacy.
“The first and most important recommendation is that the country needs to invest in primary care, so that women don’t get Zika during pregnancy and children aren’t at risk of getting the syndrome,” said Dr. Paixão.
As for the affected population, she highlighted the need to deepen the understanding of the syndrome’s natural history to improve survival and quality of life of affected children and their families. One possibility that was recently discussed by the group of researchers is to carry out a study on the causes of hospitalization of children with the syndrome to develop appropriate protocols and procedures that reduce admissions and death in this population.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.