User login
News and Views that Matter to Pediatricians
The leading independent newspaper covering news and commentary in pediatrics.
Underserved Families Share Ways to Improve Access to Pediatric Dermatologists
“Most families said that racial concordance didn’t matter that much, but they did place high value on being heard,” Dr. Kohn, of the Department of Dermatology at the University of Colorado, Aurora, told this news organization following the Society for Pediatric Dermatology annual meeting, where the study was presented during a poster session. “Being heard means that their experience was respected; that their questions and worries were anticipated, addressed, and answered; and that their feelings were acknowledged.”
As a way to understand these families’ knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs about access to pediatric dermatology care and how the hospital system and medical team could better support them, Dr. Kohn and colleagues conducted in-depth, semi-structured interviews with 32 English-speaking parents and/or guardians of children who received care at the Children’s Hospital Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus pediatric dermatology clinic. The researchers conducted and recorded the 30- to 60-minute interviews via Zoom or phone call from October 17, 2023, to January 23, 2024. Domains of interest included participant background and experiences, communication preferences, and experience accessing pediatric dermatology care. Next, Dr. Kohn and colleagues used a reflexive, team-based inductive approach to carry out a thematic analysis from the interviews.
The mean age of the 32 study participants was 38.9 years; 14 (43.75%) identified as Hispanic, 11 (34.38%) as Black, and 12 (37.50%) as American Indian/Alaska Native (response categories were not mutually exclusive). Several themes emerged from analysis of the interviews. Barriers to receiving pediatric dermatology care included distrust of the healthcare system, generational and community lack of awareness about dermatology, distance to the hospital, and household income.
“One family mentioned that they needed to save up for 3 months to be able to afford the drive, hotel, and food needed for their child to attend their pediatric dermatology visit,” Dr. Kohn said. “As we know, most pediatric dermatology visits are 10-15 minutes long, so that they needed to cut groceries for 3 months to be able to see a pediatric dermatologist for 10-15 minutes is just heart wrenching. Families also didn’t understand the large teams that we have in medicine: The medical students, residents, nurses, medical assistants, attendings, and physician extenders.”
One key facilitator to receiving pediatric dermatology care was the family’s perception that the provider shares their minoritized experience because of similarities in skin tone. “When it’s your own race, whether it’s Black, Hispanic, or you know, we feel like when it’s someone like me, they will look out for me more,” one study participant said. Other facilitators expressed by the study participants included increased representation from the family’s community at all levels of healthcare (“the more you see providers and people in a space that look like you, I think the more welcoming it will feel,” one said) and normalizing dermatology care (“letting it be known that going to the dermatologist is just like going to a regular doctor,” another said).
Dr. Kohn acknowledged certain limitations of the study, including its single-center qualitative design. “Qualitative studies are not generalizable, but they do dive into the lived experiences of a few,” she said. “There aren’t a lot of qualitative studies in derm, so even though this was a very simple study, we hope the findings will help us to support our most diverse and underserved families access the pediatric dermatology care that they need.”
The researchers reported having no relevant financial disclosures. The study was recognized as an award-winning poster at the meeting.
A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.
“Most families said that racial concordance didn’t matter that much, but they did place high value on being heard,” Dr. Kohn, of the Department of Dermatology at the University of Colorado, Aurora, told this news organization following the Society for Pediatric Dermatology annual meeting, where the study was presented during a poster session. “Being heard means that their experience was respected; that their questions and worries were anticipated, addressed, and answered; and that their feelings were acknowledged.”
As a way to understand these families’ knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs about access to pediatric dermatology care and how the hospital system and medical team could better support them, Dr. Kohn and colleagues conducted in-depth, semi-structured interviews with 32 English-speaking parents and/or guardians of children who received care at the Children’s Hospital Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus pediatric dermatology clinic. The researchers conducted and recorded the 30- to 60-minute interviews via Zoom or phone call from October 17, 2023, to January 23, 2024. Domains of interest included participant background and experiences, communication preferences, and experience accessing pediatric dermatology care. Next, Dr. Kohn and colleagues used a reflexive, team-based inductive approach to carry out a thematic analysis from the interviews.
The mean age of the 32 study participants was 38.9 years; 14 (43.75%) identified as Hispanic, 11 (34.38%) as Black, and 12 (37.50%) as American Indian/Alaska Native (response categories were not mutually exclusive). Several themes emerged from analysis of the interviews. Barriers to receiving pediatric dermatology care included distrust of the healthcare system, generational and community lack of awareness about dermatology, distance to the hospital, and household income.
“One family mentioned that they needed to save up for 3 months to be able to afford the drive, hotel, and food needed for their child to attend their pediatric dermatology visit,” Dr. Kohn said. “As we know, most pediatric dermatology visits are 10-15 minutes long, so that they needed to cut groceries for 3 months to be able to see a pediatric dermatologist for 10-15 minutes is just heart wrenching. Families also didn’t understand the large teams that we have in medicine: The medical students, residents, nurses, medical assistants, attendings, and physician extenders.”
One key facilitator to receiving pediatric dermatology care was the family’s perception that the provider shares their minoritized experience because of similarities in skin tone. “When it’s your own race, whether it’s Black, Hispanic, or you know, we feel like when it’s someone like me, they will look out for me more,” one study participant said. Other facilitators expressed by the study participants included increased representation from the family’s community at all levels of healthcare (“the more you see providers and people in a space that look like you, I think the more welcoming it will feel,” one said) and normalizing dermatology care (“letting it be known that going to the dermatologist is just like going to a regular doctor,” another said).
Dr. Kohn acknowledged certain limitations of the study, including its single-center qualitative design. “Qualitative studies are not generalizable, but they do dive into the lived experiences of a few,” she said. “There aren’t a lot of qualitative studies in derm, so even though this was a very simple study, we hope the findings will help us to support our most diverse and underserved families access the pediatric dermatology care that they need.”
The researchers reported having no relevant financial disclosures. The study was recognized as an award-winning poster at the meeting.
A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.
“Most families said that racial concordance didn’t matter that much, but they did place high value on being heard,” Dr. Kohn, of the Department of Dermatology at the University of Colorado, Aurora, told this news organization following the Society for Pediatric Dermatology annual meeting, where the study was presented during a poster session. “Being heard means that their experience was respected; that their questions and worries were anticipated, addressed, and answered; and that their feelings were acknowledged.”
As a way to understand these families’ knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs about access to pediatric dermatology care and how the hospital system and medical team could better support them, Dr. Kohn and colleagues conducted in-depth, semi-structured interviews with 32 English-speaking parents and/or guardians of children who received care at the Children’s Hospital Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus pediatric dermatology clinic. The researchers conducted and recorded the 30- to 60-minute interviews via Zoom or phone call from October 17, 2023, to January 23, 2024. Domains of interest included participant background and experiences, communication preferences, and experience accessing pediatric dermatology care. Next, Dr. Kohn and colleagues used a reflexive, team-based inductive approach to carry out a thematic analysis from the interviews.
The mean age of the 32 study participants was 38.9 years; 14 (43.75%) identified as Hispanic, 11 (34.38%) as Black, and 12 (37.50%) as American Indian/Alaska Native (response categories were not mutually exclusive). Several themes emerged from analysis of the interviews. Barriers to receiving pediatric dermatology care included distrust of the healthcare system, generational and community lack of awareness about dermatology, distance to the hospital, and household income.
“One family mentioned that they needed to save up for 3 months to be able to afford the drive, hotel, and food needed for their child to attend their pediatric dermatology visit,” Dr. Kohn said. “As we know, most pediatric dermatology visits are 10-15 minutes long, so that they needed to cut groceries for 3 months to be able to see a pediatric dermatologist for 10-15 minutes is just heart wrenching. Families also didn’t understand the large teams that we have in medicine: The medical students, residents, nurses, medical assistants, attendings, and physician extenders.”
One key facilitator to receiving pediatric dermatology care was the family’s perception that the provider shares their minoritized experience because of similarities in skin tone. “When it’s your own race, whether it’s Black, Hispanic, or you know, we feel like when it’s someone like me, they will look out for me more,” one study participant said. Other facilitators expressed by the study participants included increased representation from the family’s community at all levels of healthcare (“the more you see providers and people in a space that look like you, I think the more welcoming it will feel,” one said) and normalizing dermatology care (“letting it be known that going to the dermatologist is just like going to a regular doctor,” another said).
Dr. Kohn acknowledged certain limitations of the study, including its single-center qualitative design. “Qualitative studies are not generalizable, but they do dive into the lived experiences of a few,” she said. “There aren’t a lot of qualitative studies in derm, so even though this was a very simple study, we hope the findings will help us to support our most diverse and underserved families access the pediatric dermatology care that they need.”
The researchers reported having no relevant financial disclosures. The study was recognized as an award-winning poster at the meeting.
A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.
FROM SPD 2024
Pilot Study Finds Experimental CBD Cream Decreases UVA Skin Damage
, results from a small prospective pilot study showed.
“This study hopefully reinvigorates interest in the utilization of whether it be plant-based, human-derived, or synthetic cannabinoids in the management of dermatologic disease,” one of the study investigators, Adam Friedman, MD, professor and chair of dermatology at George Washington University, Washington, DC, told this news organization. The study was published in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.
For the prospective, single-center, pilot trial, which is believed to be the first of its kind, 19 volunteers aged 22-65 with Fitzpatrick skin types I-III applied either a nano-encapsulated CBD cream or a vehicle cream to blind spots on the skin of the buttocks twice daily for 14 days. Next, researchers applied a minimal erythema dose of UV radiation to the treated skin areas for 30 minutes. After 24 hours, they visually inspected the treated areas to clinically compare the erythema. They also performed five 4-mm punch biopsies from UVA- and non-UVA–exposed treatment sites on each buttock, as well as from an untreated control site that was at least 5 cm away from the treated left buttock.
At 24 hours, 21% of study participants showed less redness on CBD-treated skin compared with control-treated skin, while histology showed that CBD-treated skin demonstrated reduced UVA-induced epidermal hyperplasia compared with control-treated skin (a mean 11.3% change from baseline vs 28.7%, respectively; P = .01). In other findings, application of CBD cream reduced DNA damage and DNA mutations associated with UVA-induced skin aging/damage and ultimately skin cancer.
In addition, the CBD-treated skin samples had a reduction in the UVA-associated increase in the premutagenic marker 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase 1 and a reduction of two major UVA-induced mitochondrial DNA deletions associated with skin photoaging.
The research, Dr. Friedman noted, “took a village of collaborators and almost 3 years to pull together,” including collaborating with his long-standing mentor, Brian Berman, MD, PhD, professor emeritus of dermatology and dermatologic surgery at the University of Miami, Coral Gables, Florida, and a study coauthor. The study “demonstrated that purposeful delivery of CBD using an established nanoparticle platform ... can have a quantifiable impact on preventing the expected DNA damage and cellular injury one should see from UVA exposure,” said Dr. Friedman, who codeveloped the nanoparticle platform with his father, Joel M. Friedman, MD, PhD, professor of microbiology and immunology at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New York City.
“Never before has a dermatologic study on topical cannabinoids dove so deeply into the biological impact of this natural ingredient to highlight its potential, here, as a mitigation strategy for unprotected exposure to prevent the downstream sequelae of UV radiation,” Dr. Friedman said.
In the paper, he and his coauthors acknowledged certain limitations of their study, including its small sample size and the single-center design.
Dr. Friedman disclosed that he coinvented the nanoparticle technology used in the trial. Dr. Berman is a consultant at MINO Labs, which funded the study. The remaining authors had no disclosures. The study was done in collaboration with the Center for Clinical and Cosmetic Research in Aventura, Florida.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
, results from a small prospective pilot study showed.
“This study hopefully reinvigorates interest in the utilization of whether it be plant-based, human-derived, or synthetic cannabinoids in the management of dermatologic disease,” one of the study investigators, Adam Friedman, MD, professor and chair of dermatology at George Washington University, Washington, DC, told this news organization. The study was published in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.
For the prospective, single-center, pilot trial, which is believed to be the first of its kind, 19 volunteers aged 22-65 with Fitzpatrick skin types I-III applied either a nano-encapsulated CBD cream or a vehicle cream to blind spots on the skin of the buttocks twice daily for 14 days. Next, researchers applied a minimal erythema dose of UV radiation to the treated skin areas for 30 minutes. After 24 hours, they visually inspected the treated areas to clinically compare the erythema. They also performed five 4-mm punch biopsies from UVA- and non-UVA–exposed treatment sites on each buttock, as well as from an untreated control site that was at least 5 cm away from the treated left buttock.
At 24 hours, 21% of study participants showed less redness on CBD-treated skin compared with control-treated skin, while histology showed that CBD-treated skin demonstrated reduced UVA-induced epidermal hyperplasia compared with control-treated skin (a mean 11.3% change from baseline vs 28.7%, respectively; P = .01). In other findings, application of CBD cream reduced DNA damage and DNA mutations associated with UVA-induced skin aging/damage and ultimately skin cancer.
In addition, the CBD-treated skin samples had a reduction in the UVA-associated increase in the premutagenic marker 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase 1 and a reduction of two major UVA-induced mitochondrial DNA deletions associated with skin photoaging.
The research, Dr. Friedman noted, “took a village of collaborators and almost 3 years to pull together,” including collaborating with his long-standing mentor, Brian Berman, MD, PhD, professor emeritus of dermatology and dermatologic surgery at the University of Miami, Coral Gables, Florida, and a study coauthor. The study “demonstrated that purposeful delivery of CBD using an established nanoparticle platform ... can have a quantifiable impact on preventing the expected DNA damage and cellular injury one should see from UVA exposure,” said Dr. Friedman, who codeveloped the nanoparticle platform with his father, Joel M. Friedman, MD, PhD, professor of microbiology and immunology at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New York City.
“Never before has a dermatologic study on topical cannabinoids dove so deeply into the biological impact of this natural ingredient to highlight its potential, here, as a mitigation strategy for unprotected exposure to prevent the downstream sequelae of UV radiation,” Dr. Friedman said.
In the paper, he and his coauthors acknowledged certain limitations of their study, including its small sample size and the single-center design.
Dr. Friedman disclosed that he coinvented the nanoparticle technology used in the trial. Dr. Berman is a consultant at MINO Labs, which funded the study. The remaining authors had no disclosures. The study was done in collaboration with the Center for Clinical and Cosmetic Research in Aventura, Florida.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
, results from a small prospective pilot study showed.
“This study hopefully reinvigorates interest in the utilization of whether it be plant-based, human-derived, or synthetic cannabinoids in the management of dermatologic disease,” one of the study investigators, Adam Friedman, MD, professor and chair of dermatology at George Washington University, Washington, DC, told this news organization. The study was published in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.
For the prospective, single-center, pilot trial, which is believed to be the first of its kind, 19 volunteers aged 22-65 with Fitzpatrick skin types I-III applied either a nano-encapsulated CBD cream or a vehicle cream to blind spots on the skin of the buttocks twice daily for 14 days. Next, researchers applied a minimal erythema dose of UV radiation to the treated skin areas for 30 minutes. After 24 hours, they visually inspected the treated areas to clinically compare the erythema. They also performed five 4-mm punch biopsies from UVA- and non-UVA–exposed treatment sites on each buttock, as well as from an untreated control site that was at least 5 cm away from the treated left buttock.
At 24 hours, 21% of study participants showed less redness on CBD-treated skin compared with control-treated skin, while histology showed that CBD-treated skin demonstrated reduced UVA-induced epidermal hyperplasia compared with control-treated skin (a mean 11.3% change from baseline vs 28.7%, respectively; P = .01). In other findings, application of CBD cream reduced DNA damage and DNA mutations associated with UVA-induced skin aging/damage and ultimately skin cancer.
In addition, the CBD-treated skin samples had a reduction in the UVA-associated increase in the premutagenic marker 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase 1 and a reduction of two major UVA-induced mitochondrial DNA deletions associated with skin photoaging.
The research, Dr. Friedman noted, “took a village of collaborators and almost 3 years to pull together,” including collaborating with his long-standing mentor, Brian Berman, MD, PhD, professor emeritus of dermatology and dermatologic surgery at the University of Miami, Coral Gables, Florida, and a study coauthor. The study “demonstrated that purposeful delivery of CBD using an established nanoparticle platform ... can have a quantifiable impact on preventing the expected DNA damage and cellular injury one should see from UVA exposure,” said Dr. Friedman, who codeveloped the nanoparticle platform with his father, Joel M. Friedman, MD, PhD, professor of microbiology and immunology at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New York City.
“Never before has a dermatologic study on topical cannabinoids dove so deeply into the biological impact of this natural ingredient to highlight its potential, here, as a mitigation strategy for unprotected exposure to prevent the downstream sequelae of UV radiation,” Dr. Friedman said.
In the paper, he and his coauthors acknowledged certain limitations of their study, including its small sample size and the single-center design.
Dr. Friedman disclosed that he coinvented the nanoparticle technology used in the trial. Dr. Berman is a consultant at MINO Labs, which funded the study. The remaining authors had no disclosures. The study was done in collaboration with the Center for Clinical and Cosmetic Research in Aventura, Florida.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
FROM THE JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF DERMATOLOGY
A Guide to Eating Healthy While Working in Healthcare
Eat as fast as you can whenever you can.
That was the med student mindset around food, as Catherine Harmon Toomer, MD, discovered during her school years. “Without a good system in place to counter that,” she explains, “unhealthy eating can get out of control, and that’s what happened to me.”
After med school, things got worse for Dr. Toomer. By her second year in practice as a family medicine physician, she’d gained a lot of weight and had been diagnosed with type 2 diabetes and cardiomyopathy. At 36, she went into congestive heart failure and was told she likely had 5 years to live.
A moment she described as “a huge wake-up call.”
Dr. Toomer is far from alone in her struggles to balance working in medicine and eating healthfully.
internist and cofounder of ChefMD and founder of Chef Clinic.
There is also the culture of medicine, which Dr. Toomer said looks down on self-care. “Even with break times, patient needs come before our own.” So, you sit down to eat, and there’s an emergency. Your clinic closes for lunch, but the phones still ring, and patients continue to email questions. Charting is also so time-consuming that “everything else gets put on the back burner.”
Sticking to a nutritious diet in this context can feel hopeless. But it isn’t. Really. Here are some doctor-tested, real-life ways you can nourish yourself while getting it all done.
Something Is Always Better Than Nothing
Sure, you might not be able to eat a balanced lunch or dinner while at work, conceded Amy Margulies, RD, LDN, owner of The Rebellious RD. But try to focus on the bigger picture and take small steps.
First, make sure you eat something, Ms. Margulies advised. “Skipping meals can lead to overeating later and negatively impact energy levels and concentration.”
Lisa Andrews, MEd, RD, LD, owner of Sound Bites Nutrition, recalled one of her patients, a gastrointestinal surgeon with reactive hypoglycemia and fatigue. “She was experiencing energy crashes mid-afternoon,” she said. It was only after starting to eat every 4-5 hours that her patient felt better.
Of course, this is easier said than done. “When you are running from one patient to the other and trying to keep on time with your schedule, there is very little time for eating and no time at all for cooking or even heating up food,” recalled Hélène Bertrand, MD, author of Low Back Pain: 3 Steps to Relief in 2 Minutes.
But during her 55 years as a family medicine physician, Dr. Bertrand found ways to improve (if not perfect) the situation. She lunched on nuts or seeds during the day or grabbed a 95% cacao chocolate bar — higher in antioxidants and lower in sugar than a candy bar.
If you don’t have time for breakfast, try drinking a complete protein shake while driving to work, Dr. Toomer recommended. “It’s not ideal, but it’s better than nothing.” Similarly, if the only way you’ll eat a high-protein, lower-carb snack like hummus is with potato chips, go for it, she said.
Basically, don’t be type A striving for perfection. Take good enough when you can and balance the rest when you have time.
Torpedo Temptation
From free treats in the break room to always-present pizza for residents, high-fat, high-sugar, low-nutrient fare is a constant temptation. “I worked with a physician who would bring a balanced lunch to work every day, then find whatever sweet was around for his afternoon treat,” recalled Ms. Margulies.“The cookies, cakes, and donuts were starting to add up — and stopping at one wasn’t working for him.”
What did work was Ms. Margulies’ suggestion to bring a single serving of dark chocolate and fruit to savor during a longer break. “Bringing your favorite treats in appropriate portions can help you stick with your plan throughout the day,” she explained, and you’ll have an easier time resisting what’s in the break room. “When you desire a treat, tell yourself you have what you need and don’t need to indulge in the ‘free food’ just because it’s there. You have power over your choices.”
How about tricking yourself into perceiving cherry tomatoes as treats? That might be unusual, but one of Dr. La Puma’s physician patients did just that, displaying the produce in a candy dish on his office counter. Not only did this strategy help remind him to snack healthfully, it also prompted his patients to ask about eating better, he said.
Preparation Is Still Underrated
Many people find meal prepping intimidating. But it doesn’t need to be complicated. For instance, try purchasing precut veggies, cooked chicken breasts, or other healthy convenience options. You can then combine them in packable containers to prep a few meals at a time. For less busy weeks, consider cooking the protein yourself and whipping up basic sauces (like pesto and vinaigrette) to jazz up your meals.
“I worked with a resident who was gaining weight each month,” recalled Ms. Margulies. “She would skip lunch, grab a random snack, then wait until she got home to eat anything she could find.”
Encouraged by Ms. Margulies, she prepared and portioned one or two balanced dinners each week, which she’d later reheat. She also bought fresh and dried fruit and high-protein snacks, keeping single servings in her car to eat on the way home.
Similarly, Jess DeGore, RD, LDN, CDCES, CHWC, a diabetes educator and owner of Dietitian Jess Nutrition, recalled an ob.gyn. client who constantly skipped meals and relied on vending machine snacks. To combat her resulting energy crashes, she followed Ms. DeGore’s advice to prep workday lunches (like quinoa salads) over the weekend and bring fruit and nut snacks to work.
Automate as Much as You Can
If healthy is already on hand, you’ll eat healthy, said Ms. Andrews. Build up a snack stash focusing on fiber and protein. Tote a lunch bag with a cooler pack if needed. Some suggestions:
- Oatmeal packets
- Individual Greek yogurt cups or drinkable yogurts
- Protein bars
- Protein shakes
- Fresh fruit
- Fresh veggie sticks
- Nuts, dried chickpeas, or edamame
- Trail mix
- Single servings of hummus, nut butter, or guacamole
- Dried seaweed snacks
- Whole grain crackers
- Hard-boiled eggs
- String cheese
- Peanut butter sandwich
- 95% cacao chocolate bar
Try a Meal Delivery Service
Meal delivery services can be pricey, but potentially worth the expense. By bringing meals or having them sent to your office, you won’t have to find time to go to the cafeteria and stand in line, noted Janese S. Laster, MD, an internal medicine, gastroenterology, obesity medicine, and nutrition physician and founder of Gut Theory Total Digestive Care. Instead, “you’ll have something to warm up and eat while writing notes or in between patients,” she said. Plus, “you won’t have an excuse to skip meals.”
Hydration Yes, Junk Drinks No
The following can be filed in the Doctors-Know-It-But-Don’t-Always-Do-It section: “Hunger can be mistaken for thirst,” said Ms. Margulies. “Staying hydrated will help you better assess whether you’re hungry or thirsty.” Choose water over soda or energy drinks, she added, to hydrate your body without unnecessary extra sugars, sugar substitutes, calories, caffeine, or sodium — all of which can affect how you feel.
Advocate for Your Health
Convincing your institution to make changes might be difficult or even impossible, but consider asking your workplace to implement initiatives like these to boost provider nutrition, suggested Jabe Brown, BHSc (Nat), founder of Melbourne Functional Medicine:
- Establish protected break times when doctors can step away from their duties to eat
- Add more nutritious cafeteria options, like salads, whole grains, and lean proteins
- Overhaul vending machine offerings
- Offer educational workshops on nutrition
Be Tenacious About Good Eating
For Dr. Toomer, that meant taking several years off from work to improve her health. After losing more than 100 pounds, she founded TOTAL Weight Care Institute to help other healthcare professionals follow in her footsteps.
For you, the path toward a healthier diet might be gradual — grabbing a more nutritious snack, spending an extra hour per week on food shopping or prep, remembering a water bottle. Whatever it looks like, make realistic lifestyle tweaks that work for you.
Maybe even try that apple-a-day thing.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Eat as fast as you can whenever you can.
That was the med student mindset around food, as Catherine Harmon Toomer, MD, discovered during her school years. “Without a good system in place to counter that,” she explains, “unhealthy eating can get out of control, and that’s what happened to me.”
After med school, things got worse for Dr. Toomer. By her second year in practice as a family medicine physician, she’d gained a lot of weight and had been diagnosed with type 2 diabetes and cardiomyopathy. At 36, she went into congestive heart failure and was told she likely had 5 years to live.
A moment she described as “a huge wake-up call.”
Dr. Toomer is far from alone in her struggles to balance working in medicine and eating healthfully.
internist and cofounder of ChefMD and founder of Chef Clinic.
There is also the culture of medicine, which Dr. Toomer said looks down on self-care. “Even with break times, patient needs come before our own.” So, you sit down to eat, and there’s an emergency. Your clinic closes for lunch, but the phones still ring, and patients continue to email questions. Charting is also so time-consuming that “everything else gets put on the back burner.”
Sticking to a nutritious diet in this context can feel hopeless. But it isn’t. Really. Here are some doctor-tested, real-life ways you can nourish yourself while getting it all done.
Something Is Always Better Than Nothing
Sure, you might not be able to eat a balanced lunch or dinner while at work, conceded Amy Margulies, RD, LDN, owner of The Rebellious RD. But try to focus on the bigger picture and take small steps.
First, make sure you eat something, Ms. Margulies advised. “Skipping meals can lead to overeating later and negatively impact energy levels and concentration.”
Lisa Andrews, MEd, RD, LD, owner of Sound Bites Nutrition, recalled one of her patients, a gastrointestinal surgeon with reactive hypoglycemia and fatigue. “She was experiencing energy crashes mid-afternoon,” she said. It was only after starting to eat every 4-5 hours that her patient felt better.
Of course, this is easier said than done. “When you are running from one patient to the other and trying to keep on time with your schedule, there is very little time for eating and no time at all for cooking or even heating up food,” recalled Hélène Bertrand, MD, author of Low Back Pain: 3 Steps to Relief in 2 Minutes.
But during her 55 years as a family medicine physician, Dr. Bertrand found ways to improve (if not perfect) the situation. She lunched on nuts or seeds during the day or grabbed a 95% cacao chocolate bar — higher in antioxidants and lower in sugar than a candy bar.
If you don’t have time for breakfast, try drinking a complete protein shake while driving to work, Dr. Toomer recommended. “It’s not ideal, but it’s better than nothing.” Similarly, if the only way you’ll eat a high-protein, lower-carb snack like hummus is with potato chips, go for it, she said.
Basically, don’t be type A striving for perfection. Take good enough when you can and balance the rest when you have time.
Torpedo Temptation
From free treats in the break room to always-present pizza for residents, high-fat, high-sugar, low-nutrient fare is a constant temptation. “I worked with a physician who would bring a balanced lunch to work every day, then find whatever sweet was around for his afternoon treat,” recalled Ms. Margulies.“The cookies, cakes, and donuts were starting to add up — and stopping at one wasn’t working for him.”
What did work was Ms. Margulies’ suggestion to bring a single serving of dark chocolate and fruit to savor during a longer break. “Bringing your favorite treats in appropriate portions can help you stick with your plan throughout the day,” she explained, and you’ll have an easier time resisting what’s in the break room. “When you desire a treat, tell yourself you have what you need and don’t need to indulge in the ‘free food’ just because it’s there. You have power over your choices.”
How about tricking yourself into perceiving cherry tomatoes as treats? That might be unusual, but one of Dr. La Puma’s physician patients did just that, displaying the produce in a candy dish on his office counter. Not only did this strategy help remind him to snack healthfully, it also prompted his patients to ask about eating better, he said.
Preparation Is Still Underrated
Many people find meal prepping intimidating. But it doesn’t need to be complicated. For instance, try purchasing precut veggies, cooked chicken breasts, or other healthy convenience options. You can then combine them in packable containers to prep a few meals at a time. For less busy weeks, consider cooking the protein yourself and whipping up basic sauces (like pesto and vinaigrette) to jazz up your meals.
“I worked with a resident who was gaining weight each month,” recalled Ms. Margulies. “She would skip lunch, grab a random snack, then wait until she got home to eat anything she could find.”
Encouraged by Ms. Margulies, she prepared and portioned one or two balanced dinners each week, which she’d later reheat. She also bought fresh and dried fruit and high-protein snacks, keeping single servings in her car to eat on the way home.
Similarly, Jess DeGore, RD, LDN, CDCES, CHWC, a diabetes educator and owner of Dietitian Jess Nutrition, recalled an ob.gyn. client who constantly skipped meals and relied on vending machine snacks. To combat her resulting energy crashes, she followed Ms. DeGore’s advice to prep workday lunches (like quinoa salads) over the weekend and bring fruit and nut snacks to work.
Automate as Much as You Can
If healthy is already on hand, you’ll eat healthy, said Ms. Andrews. Build up a snack stash focusing on fiber and protein. Tote a lunch bag with a cooler pack if needed. Some suggestions:
- Oatmeal packets
- Individual Greek yogurt cups or drinkable yogurts
- Protein bars
- Protein shakes
- Fresh fruit
- Fresh veggie sticks
- Nuts, dried chickpeas, or edamame
- Trail mix
- Single servings of hummus, nut butter, or guacamole
- Dried seaweed snacks
- Whole grain crackers
- Hard-boiled eggs
- String cheese
- Peanut butter sandwich
- 95% cacao chocolate bar
Try a Meal Delivery Service
Meal delivery services can be pricey, but potentially worth the expense. By bringing meals or having them sent to your office, you won’t have to find time to go to the cafeteria and stand in line, noted Janese S. Laster, MD, an internal medicine, gastroenterology, obesity medicine, and nutrition physician and founder of Gut Theory Total Digestive Care. Instead, “you’ll have something to warm up and eat while writing notes or in between patients,” she said. Plus, “you won’t have an excuse to skip meals.”
Hydration Yes, Junk Drinks No
The following can be filed in the Doctors-Know-It-But-Don’t-Always-Do-It section: “Hunger can be mistaken for thirst,” said Ms. Margulies. “Staying hydrated will help you better assess whether you’re hungry or thirsty.” Choose water over soda or energy drinks, she added, to hydrate your body without unnecessary extra sugars, sugar substitutes, calories, caffeine, or sodium — all of which can affect how you feel.
Advocate for Your Health
Convincing your institution to make changes might be difficult or even impossible, but consider asking your workplace to implement initiatives like these to boost provider nutrition, suggested Jabe Brown, BHSc (Nat), founder of Melbourne Functional Medicine:
- Establish protected break times when doctors can step away from their duties to eat
- Add more nutritious cafeteria options, like salads, whole grains, and lean proteins
- Overhaul vending machine offerings
- Offer educational workshops on nutrition
Be Tenacious About Good Eating
For Dr. Toomer, that meant taking several years off from work to improve her health. After losing more than 100 pounds, she founded TOTAL Weight Care Institute to help other healthcare professionals follow in her footsteps.
For you, the path toward a healthier diet might be gradual — grabbing a more nutritious snack, spending an extra hour per week on food shopping or prep, remembering a water bottle. Whatever it looks like, make realistic lifestyle tweaks that work for you.
Maybe even try that apple-a-day thing.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Eat as fast as you can whenever you can.
That was the med student mindset around food, as Catherine Harmon Toomer, MD, discovered during her school years. “Without a good system in place to counter that,” she explains, “unhealthy eating can get out of control, and that’s what happened to me.”
After med school, things got worse for Dr. Toomer. By her second year in practice as a family medicine physician, she’d gained a lot of weight and had been diagnosed with type 2 diabetes and cardiomyopathy. At 36, she went into congestive heart failure and was told she likely had 5 years to live.
A moment she described as “a huge wake-up call.”
Dr. Toomer is far from alone in her struggles to balance working in medicine and eating healthfully.
internist and cofounder of ChefMD and founder of Chef Clinic.
There is also the culture of medicine, which Dr. Toomer said looks down on self-care. “Even with break times, patient needs come before our own.” So, you sit down to eat, and there’s an emergency. Your clinic closes for lunch, but the phones still ring, and patients continue to email questions. Charting is also so time-consuming that “everything else gets put on the back burner.”
Sticking to a nutritious diet in this context can feel hopeless. But it isn’t. Really. Here are some doctor-tested, real-life ways you can nourish yourself while getting it all done.
Something Is Always Better Than Nothing
Sure, you might not be able to eat a balanced lunch or dinner while at work, conceded Amy Margulies, RD, LDN, owner of The Rebellious RD. But try to focus on the bigger picture and take small steps.
First, make sure you eat something, Ms. Margulies advised. “Skipping meals can lead to overeating later and negatively impact energy levels and concentration.”
Lisa Andrews, MEd, RD, LD, owner of Sound Bites Nutrition, recalled one of her patients, a gastrointestinal surgeon with reactive hypoglycemia and fatigue. “She was experiencing energy crashes mid-afternoon,” she said. It was only after starting to eat every 4-5 hours that her patient felt better.
Of course, this is easier said than done. “When you are running from one patient to the other and trying to keep on time with your schedule, there is very little time for eating and no time at all for cooking or even heating up food,” recalled Hélène Bertrand, MD, author of Low Back Pain: 3 Steps to Relief in 2 Minutes.
But during her 55 years as a family medicine physician, Dr. Bertrand found ways to improve (if not perfect) the situation. She lunched on nuts or seeds during the day or grabbed a 95% cacao chocolate bar — higher in antioxidants and lower in sugar than a candy bar.
If you don’t have time for breakfast, try drinking a complete protein shake while driving to work, Dr. Toomer recommended. “It’s not ideal, but it’s better than nothing.” Similarly, if the only way you’ll eat a high-protein, lower-carb snack like hummus is with potato chips, go for it, she said.
Basically, don’t be type A striving for perfection. Take good enough when you can and balance the rest when you have time.
Torpedo Temptation
From free treats in the break room to always-present pizza for residents, high-fat, high-sugar, low-nutrient fare is a constant temptation. “I worked with a physician who would bring a balanced lunch to work every day, then find whatever sweet was around for his afternoon treat,” recalled Ms. Margulies.“The cookies, cakes, and donuts were starting to add up — and stopping at one wasn’t working for him.”
What did work was Ms. Margulies’ suggestion to bring a single serving of dark chocolate and fruit to savor during a longer break. “Bringing your favorite treats in appropriate portions can help you stick with your plan throughout the day,” she explained, and you’ll have an easier time resisting what’s in the break room. “When you desire a treat, tell yourself you have what you need and don’t need to indulge in the ‘free food’ just because it’s there. You have power over your choices.”
How about tricking yourself into perceiving cherry tomatoes as treats? That might be unusual, but one of Dr. La Puma’s physician patients did just that, displaying the produce in a candy dish on his office counter. Not only did this strategy help remind him to snack healthfully, it also prompted his patients to ask about eating better, he said.
Preparation Is Still Underrated
Many people find meal prepping intimidating. But it doesn’t need to be complicated. For instance, try purchasing precut veggies, cooked chicken breasts, or other healthy convenience options. You can then combine them in packable containers to prep a few meals at a time. For less busy weeks, consider cooking the protein yourself and whipping up basic sauces (like pesto and vinaigrette) to jazz up your meals.
“I worked with a resident who was gaining weight each month,” recalled Ms. Margulies. “She would skip lunch, grab a random snack, then wait until she got home to eat anything she could find.”
Encouraged by Ms. Margulies, she prepared and portioned one or two balanced dinners each week, which she’d later reheat. She also bought fresh and dried fruit and high-protein snacks, keeping single servings in her car to eat on the way home.
Similarly, Jess DeGore, RD, LDN, CDCES, CHWC, a diabetes educator and owner of Dietitian Jess Nutrition, recalled an ob.gyn. client who constantly skipped meals and relied on vending machine snacks. To combat her resulting energy crashes, she followed Ms. DeGore’s advice to prep workday lunches (like quinoa salads) over the weekend and bring fruit and nut snacks to work.
Automate as Much as You Can
If healthy is already on hand, you’ll eat healthy, said Ms. Andrews. Build up a snack stash focusing on fiber and protein. Tote a lunch bag with a cooler pack if needed. Some suggestions:
- Oatmeal packets
- Individual Greek yogurt cups or drinkable yogurts
- Protein bars
- Protein shakes
- Fresh fruit
- Fresh veggie sticks
- Nuts, dried chickpeas, or edamame
- Trail mix
- Single servings of hummus, nut butter, or guacamole
- Dried seaweed snacks
- Whole grain crackers
- Hard-boiled eggs
- String cheese
- Peanut butter sandwich
- 95% cacao chocolate bar
Try a Meal Delivery Service
Meal delivery services can be pricey, but potentially worth the expense. By bringing meals or having them sent to your office, you won’t have to find time to go to the cafeteria and stand in line, noted Janese S. Laster, MD, an internal medicine, gastroenterology, obesity medicine, and nutrition physician and founder of Gut Theory Total Digestive Care. Instead, “you’ll have something to warm up and eat while writing notes or in between patients,” she said. Plus, “you won’t have an excuse to skip meals.”
Hydration Yes, Junk Drinks No
The following can be filed in the Doctors-Know-It-But-Don’t-Always-Do-It section: “Hunger can be mistaken for thirst,” said Ms. Margulies. “Staying hydrated will help you better assess whether you’re hungry or thirsty.” Choose water over soda or energy drinks, she added, to hydrate your body without unnecessary extra sugars, sugar substitutes, calories, caffeine, or sodium — all of which can affect how you feel.
Advocate for Your Health
Convincing your institution to make changes might be difficult or even impossible, but consider asking your workplace to implement initiatives like these to boost provider nutrition, suggested Jabe Brown, BHSc (Nat), founder of Melbourne Functional Medicine:
- Establish protected break times when doctors can step away from their duties to eat
- Add more nutritious cafeteria options, like salads, whole grains, and lean proteins
- Overhaul vending machine offerings
- Offer educational workshops on nutrition
Be Tenacious About Good Eating
For Dr. Toomer, that meant taking several years off from work to improve her health. After losing more than 100 pounds, she founded TOTAL Weight Care Institute to help other healthcare professionals follow in her footsteps.
For you, the path toward a healthier diet might be gradual — grabbing a more nutritious snack, spending an extra hour per week on food shopping or prep, remembering a water bottle. Whatever it looks like, make realistic lifestyle tweaks that work for you.
Maybe even try that apple-a-day thing.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Waiting for Therapy? There’s an App for That
TOPLINE:
Smartphone apps, including those using cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness techniques, showed comparable efficacy in reducing depression, anxiety, and suicidality in patients with psychiatric conditions waiting for appointments with psychiatrists or therapists.
METHODOLOGY:
- Participants were adults aged 18 years or older seeking outpatient psychiatric services from several mental and behavioral health clinics within the University of Michigan Health System.
- Eligible participants were those with either a scheduled future mental health appointment or an initial appointment completed within the past 60 days and daily access to a smartphone.
- After completing a baseline survey that gathered data on participants’ depression, anxiety, and suicidality scores, 2080 participants were randomly assigned to one of five groups:
- Enhanced personalized feedback (EPF) only (n = 690)
- SilverCloud only (SilverCloud, a mobile application designed to deliver CBT strategies; n = 345)
- SilverCloud plus EPF (n = 346)
- Headspace only (Headspace, a mobile application designed to train users in mindfulness practices; n = 349)
- Headspace plus EPF (n = 349)
TAKEAWAY:
- The mean baseline Patient Health Questionnaire-9 depression score was 12.7 (6.4% patients). Overall, depression scores significantly decreased by 2.5 points from baseline to the 6-week follow-up for all five arms, with marginal mean differences in mean change ranging from −2.1 to −2.9 (P < .001).
- The magnitude of change was not significantly different across the five arms on most measures (P = .31). Additionally, the groups did not differ in decrease of anxiety or substance use symptoms.
- The Headspace arms reported significantly greater improvements on a suicidality measure subscale than the SilverCloud arms (mean difference in mean change, 0.63; P = .004).
IN PRACTICE:
“Having this type of option, especially for people who are motivated enough to seek an appointment and wait for it, could be very valuable when providers have long wait lists,” lead author Adam Horwitz, PhD, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, said in a press release.
“These individuals want to be doing something about their mental health but don’t yet have access, so this suggests that providing them with some sort of digital option when their motivation is already high, and they are ready to do something, could begin to make a difference.”
SOURCE:
Dr. Horwitz led the study, which was published online in JAMA Network Open.
LIMITATIONS:
There may have been aspects of formal or in-person care that contributed to the improvement in symptoms across groups and diluted the ability to identify differences between applications in effects on symptom reduction.
DISCLOSURES:
This study was funded by a grant from Precision Health, the Eisenberg Family Depression Center, and the National Institute of Mental Health. Disclosures are noted in the original article.
This article was created using several editorial tools, including AI, as part of the process. Human editors reviewed this content before publication.A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
TOPLINE:
Smartphone apps, including those using cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness techniques, showed comparable efficacy in reducing depression, anxiety, and suicidality in patients with psychiatric conditions waiting for appointments with psychiatrists or therapists.
METHODOLOGY:
- Participants were adults aged 18 years or older seeking outpatient psychiatric services from several mental and behavioral health clinics within the University of Michigan Health System.
- Eligible participants were those with either a scheduled future mental health appointment or an initial appointment completed within the past 60 days and daily access to a smartphone.
- After completing a baseline survey that gathered data on participants’ depression, anxiety, and suicidality scores, 2080 participants were randomly assigned to one of five groups:
- Enhanced personalized feedback (EPF) only (n = 690)
- SilverCloud only (SilverCloud, a mobile application designed to deliver CBT strategies; n = 345)
- SilverCloud plus EPF (n = 346)
- Headspace only (Headspace, a mobile application designed to train users in mindfulness practices; n = 349)
- Headspace plus EPF (n = 349)
TAKEAWAY:
- The mean baseline Patient Health Questionnaire-9 depression score was 12.7 (6.4% patients). Overall, depression scores significantly decreased by 2.5 points from baseline to the 6-week follow-up for all five arms, with marginal mean differences in mean change ranging from −2.1 to −2.9 (P < .001).
- The magnitude of change was not significantly different across the five arms on most measures (P = .31). Additionally, the groups did not differ in decrease of anxiety or substance use symptoms.
- The Headspace arms reported significantly greater improvements on a suicidality measure subscale than the SilverCloud arms (mean difference in mean change, 0.63; P = .004).
IN PRACTICE:
“Having this type of option, especially for people who are motivated enough to seek an appointment and wait for it, could be very valuable when providers have long wait lists,” lead author Adam Horwitz, PhD, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, said in a press release.
“These individuals want to be doing something about their mental health but don’t yet have access, so this suggests that providing them with some sort of digital option when their motivation is already high, and they are ready to do something, could begin to make a difference.”
SOURCE:
Dr. Horwitz led the study, which was published online in JAMA Network Open.
LIMITATIONS:
There may have been aspects of formal or in-person care that contributed to the improvement in symptoms across groups and diluted the ability to identify differences between applications in effects on symptom reduction.
DISCLOSURES:
This study was funded by a grant from Precision Health, the Eisenberg Family Depression Center, and the National Institute of Mental Health. Disclosures are noted in the original article.
This article was created using several editorial tools, including AI, as part of the process. Human editors reviewed this content before publication.A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
TOPLINE:
Smartphone apps, including those using cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness techniques, showed comparable efficacy in reducing depression, anxiety, and suicidality in patients with psychiatric conditions waiting for appointments with psychiatrists or therapists.
METHODOLOGY:
- Participants were adults aged 18 years or older seeking outpatient psychiatric services from several mental and behavioral health clinics within the University of Michigan Health System.
- Eligible participants were those with either a scheduled future mental health appointment or an initial appointment completed within the past 60 days and daily access to a smartphone.
- After completing a baseline survey that gathered data on participants’ depression, anxiety, and suicidality scores, 2080 participants were randomly assigned to one of five groups:
- Enhanced personalized feedback (EPF) only (n = 690)
- SilverCloud only (SilverCloud, a mobile application designed to deliver CBT strategies; n = 345)
- SilverCloud plus EPF (n = 346)
- Headspace only (Headspace, a mobile application designed to train users in mindfulness practices; n = 349)
- Headspace plus EPF (n = 349)
TAKEAWAY:
- The mean baseline Patient Health Questionnaire-9 depression score was 12.7 (6.4% patients). Overall, depression scores significantly decreased by 2.5 points from baseline to the 6-week follow-up for all five arms, with marginal mean differences in mean change ranging from −2.1 to −2.9 (P < .001).
- The magnitude of change was not significantly different across the five arms on most measures (P = .31). Additionally, the groups did not differ in decrease of anxiety or substance use symptoms.
- The Headspace arms reported significantly greater improvements on a suicidality measure subscale than the SilverCloud arms (mean difference in mean change, 0.63; P = .004).
IN PRACTICE:
“Having this type of option, especially for people who are motivated enough to seek an appointment and wait for it, could be very valuable when providers have long wait lists,” lead author Adam Horwitz, PhD, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, said in a press release.
“These individuals want to be doing something about their mental health but don’t yet have access, so this suggests that providing them with some sort of digital option when their motivation is already high, and they are ready to do something, could begin to make a difference.”
SOURCE:
Dr. Horwitz led the study, which was published online in JAMA Network Open.
LIMITATIONS:
There may have been aspects of formal or in-person care that contributed to the improvement in symptoms across groups and diluted the ability to identify differences between applications in effects on symptom reduction.
DISCLOSURES:
This study was funded by a grant from Precision Health, the Eisenberg Family Depression Center, and the National Institute of Mental Health. Disclosures are noted in the original article.
This article was created using several editorial tools, including AI, as part of the process. Human editors reviewed this content before publication.A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Introducing: A New Way to Get Teens Mental Health Care
Lauren Opladen remembers the agonizing wait all too well.
At age 17, struggling with paralyzing depression after losing her brother to suicide and her father to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, her teacher suggested she seek help.
So, she did. But she had to spend 3 days inside an emergency department at the University of Rochester Medical Center in Rochester, New York, where the Comprehensive Psychiatric Emergency Program (CPEP) provides immediate care for youth and adults experiencing psychiatric emergencies.
“We were sleeping on a couch just waiting for all these services, when that’s precious time wasted,” Ms. Opladen said.
Ms. Opladen made it through that dark period, and 5 years later, she is a registered nurse at the same hospital. Every day she walks past a new facility she wishes had existed during her troubled teenage years: An urgent care center for children and adolescents experiencing mental health crises.
Brighter Days Pediatric Mental Health Urgent Care Center, Rochester, New York, opened in July as a walk-in clinic offering rapid assessment, crisis intervention, and short-term stabilization, provides referrals to counseling or psychiatric care. Children and adolescents at immediate risk of harming themselves or others, or who need inpatient care, are sent to CPEP or another emergency department in the area.
Similar walk-in facilities linking youth to longer-term services are popping up in nearly a dozen states, including New York, Ohio, Massachusetts, and Wisconsin. The emerging model of care may offer a crucial bridge between traditional outpatient services and emergency room (ER) visits for some young people experiencing mental health crises.
“We’ve seen a significant increase in the number of children and adolescents presenting to emergency departments with mental health concerns,” said Michael A. Scharf, MD, chief of the Division of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at the University of Rochester Medical Center, who oversees operations at Brighter Days. “These urgent care centers provide a more appropriate setting for many of these cases, offering specialized care without the often overwhelming environment of an ER.”
The urgency of addressing youth behavioral health has become increasingly apparent. The most recent data from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention showed that over a 6-month period in 2020, during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic, visits to the emergency department for mental health problems spiked 24% among children aged 5-11 years and 31% among 12-17-year-olds compared with the same period in 2019. Between March 2021 and February 2022, such emergency visits rose by 22% for teen girls, while falling by 15% for boys ages 5-12 years and 9% for older boys. Most visits occur during the school year.
But staffing shortages and limited physical space are taxing the capacity of the healthcare system to screen, diagnose, and manage these patients, according to a 2023 report published in Pediatrics.
Urgent Care: A Misnomer?
Some in the mental health community said the label “urgent” in these centers’ titles is misleading. Brighter Days and similar facilities do not conduct involuntary holds, administer medication, or handle serious cases like psychotic episodes.
David Mathison, MD, senior vice president of clinic operations at PM Pediatrics, a chain of pediatric urgent care clinics in Maryland, said patients and their families may mistakenly believe the centers will address mental health problems quickly.
“It’s really not urgent behavioral health. It’s really just another access point to get behavioral health,” Dr. Mathison said. “Crises in pediatrics are so much more complex” than physical injuries or acute infections, which are the bread and butter of urgent care centers.
“An urgent care center almost implies you’re going to come in for a solution to a simple problem, and it’s going to be done relatively quickly on demand, and it’s just not what the behavioral health centers do,” he said.
Dr. Mathison, who also serves on the executive committee for the section on urgent care at the American Academy of Pediatrics, likened the centers to in-person versions of crisis center hotlines, which offer virtual counseling and talk therapy and may refer individuals to specialists who can provide clinical care over the long term.
Instead, Brighter Days and other centers provide crisis de-escalation for individuals experiencing an exacerbation of a diagnosed mental illness, such a manic episode from bipolar disorder.
“Most places aren’t just going to change their therapy without either contacting their psychiatrist or having psychiatrists on staff,” Dr. Mathison said.
Other challenges at Brighter Days and similar centers include staffing with appropriately trained mental health professionals, given the nationwide shortage of child and adolescent psychiatrists, Dr. Scharf said.
The number of child and adolescent psychiatrists per 100,000 children varies significantly across states. Nationally, the average stands at 14 psychiatrists per 100,000 children, but ranges from as low as 4 to 65, according to the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry.
For now, Dr. Scharf said, patients who visit Brighter Days are billed as if they are having a routine pediatric office visit as opposed to a pricier trip to the emergency department. And the center accepts all individuals, regardless of their insurance status.
Ms. Opladen said the urgent care center represents a significant improvement over her experience at the emergency department’s psychiatric triage.
“I saw how awful it was and just the environment,” she said. “The first thing I thought was, what do I need to do to get out of here?”
She said the pediatric mental health urgent care centers are “the complete opposite.” Like Brighter Days, these centers are designed to look more like a pediatrician’s office, with bright welcoming colors and games and toys.
“It’s separated from everything else. There’s a welcome, relaxed space,” she said. “The welcoming feel is just a whole different environment, and that’s really how it should be.”
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Lauren Opladen remembers the agonizing wait all too well.
At age 17, struggling with paralyzing depression after losing her brother to suicide and her father to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, her teacher suggested she seek help.
So, she did. But she had to spend 3 days inside an emergency department at the University of Rochester Medical Center in Rochester, New York, where the Comprehensive Psychiatric Emergency Program (CPEP) provides immediate care for youth and adults experiencing psychiatric emergencies.
“We were sleeping on a couch just waiting for all these services, when that’s precious time wasted,” Ms. Opladen said.
Ms. Opladen made it through that dark period, and 5 years later, she is a registered nurse at the same hospital. Every day she walks past a new facility she wishes had existed during her troubled teenage years: An urgent care center for children and adolescents experiencing mental health crises.
Brighter Days Pediatric Mental Health Urgent Care Center, Rochester, New York, opened in July as a walk-in clinic offering rapid assessment, crisis intervention, and short-term stabilization, provides referrals to counseling or psychiatric care. Children and adolescents at immediate risk of harming themselves or others, or who need inpatient care, are sent to CPEP or another emergency department in the area.
Similar walk-in facilities linking youth to longer-term services are popping up in nearly a dozen states, including New York, Ohio, Massachusetts, and Wisconsin. The emerging model of care may offer a crucial bridge between traditional outpatient services and emergency room (ER) visits for some young people experiencing mental health crises.
“We’ve seen a significant increase in the number of children and adolescents presenting to emergency departments with mental health concerns,” said Michael A. Scharf, MD, chief of the Division of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at the University of Rochester Medical Center, who oversees operations at Brighter Days. “These urgent care centers provide a more appropriate setting for many of these cases, offering specialized care without the often overwhelming environment of an ER.”
The urgency of addressing youth behavioral health has become increasingly apparent. The most recent data from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention showed that over a 6-month period in 2020, during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic, visits to the emergency department for mental health problems spiked 24% among children aged 5-11 years and 31% among 12-17-year-olds compared with the same period in 2019. Between March 2021 and February 2022, such emergency visits rose by 22% for teen girls, while falling by 15% for boys ages 5-12 years and 9% for older boys. Most visits occur during the school year.
But staffing shortages and limited physical space are taxing the capacity of the healthcare system to screen, diagnose, and manage these patients, according to a 2023 report published in Pediatrics.
Urgent Care: A Misnomer?
Some in the mental health community said the label “urgent” in these centers’ titles is misleading. Brighter Days and similar facilities do not conduct involuntary holds, administer medication, or handle serious cases like psychotic episodes.
David Mathison, MD, senior vice president of clinic operations at PM Pediatrics, a chain of pediatric urgent care clinics in Maryland, said patients and their families may mistakenly believe the centers will address mental health problems quickly.
“It’s really not urgent behavioral health. It’s really just another access point to get behavioral health,” Dr. Mathison said. “Crises in pediatrics are so much more complex” than physical injuries or acute infections, which are the bread and butter of urgent care centers.
“An urgent care center almost implies you’re going to come in for a solution to a simple problem, and it’s going to be done relatively quickly on demand, and it’s just not what the behavioral health centers do,” he said.
Dr. Mathison, who also serves on the executive committee for the section on urgent care at the American Academy of Pediatrics, likened the centers to in-person versions of crisis center hotlines, which offer virtual counseling and talk therapy and may refer individuals to specialists who can provide clinical care over the long term.
Instead, Brighter Days and other centers provide crisis de-escalation for individuals experiencing an exacerbation of a diagnosed mental illness, such a manic episode from bipolar disorder.
“Most places aren’t just going to change their therapy without either contacting their psychiatrist or having psychiatrists on staff,” Dr. Mathison said.
Other challenges at Brighter Days and similar centers include staffing with appropriately trained mental health professionals, given the nationwide shortage of child and adolescent psychiatrists, Dr. Scharf said.
The number of child and adolescent psychiatrists per 100,000 children varies significantly across states. Nationally, the average stands at 14 psychiatrists per 100,000 children, but ranges from as low as 4 to 65, according to the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry.
For now, Dr. Scharf said, patients who visit Brighter Days are billed as if they are having a routine pediatric office visit as opposed to a pricier trip to the emergency department. And the center accepts all individuals, regardless of their insurance status.
Ms. Opladen said the urgent care center represents a significant improvement over her experience at the emergency department’s psychiatric triage.
“I saw how awful it was and just the environment,” she said. “The first thing I thought was, what do I need to do to get out of here?”
She said the pediatric mental health urgent care centers are “the complete opposite.” Like Brighter Days, these centers are designed to look more like a pediatrician’s office, with bright welcoming colors and games and toys.
“It’s separated from everything else. There’s a welcome, relaxed space,” she said. “The welcoming feel is just a whole different environment, and that’s really how it should be.”
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Lauren Opladen remembers the agonizing wait all too well.
At age 17, struggling with paralyzing depression after losing her brother to suicide and her father to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, her teacher suggested she seek help.
So, she did. But she had to spend 3 days inside an emergency department at the University of Rochester Medical Center in Rochester, New York, where the Comprehensive Psychiatric Emergency Program (CPEP) provides immediate care for youth and adults experiencing psychiatric emergencies.
“We were sleeping on a couch just waiting for all these services, when that’s precious time wasted,” Ms. Opladen said.
Ms. Opladen made it through that dark period, and 5 years later, she is a registered nurse at the same hospital. Every day she walks past a new facility she wishes had existed during her troubled teenage years: An urgent care center for children and adolescents experiencing mental health crises.
Brighter Days Pediatric Mental Health Urgent Care Center, Rochester, New York, opened in July as a walk-in clinic offering rapid assessment, crisis intervention, and short-term stabilization, provides referrals to counseling or psychiatric care. Children and adolescents at immediate risk of harming themselves or others, or who need inpatient care, are sent to CPEP or another emergency department in the area.
Similar walk-in facilities linking youth to longer-term services are popping up in nearly a dozen states, including New York, Ohio, Massachusetts, and Wisconsin. The emerging model of care may offer a crucial bridge between traditional outpatient services and emergency room (ER) visits for some young people experiencing mental health crises.
“We’ve seen a significant increase in the number of children and adolescents presenting to emergency departments with mental health concerns,” said Michael A. Scharf, MD, chief of the Division of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at the University of Rochester Medical Center, who oversees operations at Brighter Days. “These urgent care centers provide a more appropriate setting for many of these cases, offering specialized care without the often overwhelming environment of an ER.”
The urgency of addressing youth behavioral health has become increasingly apparent. The most recent data from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention showed that over a 6-month period in 2020, during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic, visits to the emergency department for mental health problems spiked 24% among children aged 5-11 years and 31% among 12-17-year-olds compared with the same period in 2019. Between March 2021 and February 2022, such emergency visits rose by 22% for teen girls, while falling by 15% for boys ages 5-12 years and 9% for older boys. Most visits occur during the school year.
But staffing shortages and limited physical space are taxing the capacity of the healthcare system to screen, diagnose, and manage these patients, according to a 2023 report published in Pediatrics.
Urgent Care: A Misnomer?
Some in the mental health community said the label “urgent” in these centers’ titles is misleading. Brighter Days and similar facilities do not conduct involuntary holds, administer medication, or handle serious cases like psychotic episodes.
David Mathison, MD, senior vice president of clinic operations at PM Pediatrics, a chain of pediatric urgent care clinics in Maryland, said patients and their families may mistakenly believe the centers will address mental health problems quickly.
“It’s really not urgent behavioral health. It’s really just another access point to get behavioral health,” Dr. Mathison said. “Crises in pediatrics are so much more complex” than physical injuries or acute infections, which are the bread and butter of urgent care centers.
“An urgent care center almost implies you’re going to come in for a solution to a simple problem, and it’s going to be done relatively quickly on demand, and it’s just not what the behavioral health centers do,” he said.
Dr. Mathison, who also serves on the executive committee for the section on urgent care at the American Academy of Pediatrics, likened the centers to in-person versions of crisis center hotlines, which offer virtual counseling and talk therapy and may refer individuals to specialists who can provide clinical care over the long term.
Instead, Brighter Days and other centers provide crisis de-escalation for individuals experiencing an exacerbation of a diagnosed mental illness, such a manic episode from bipolar disorder.
“Most places aren’t just going to change their therapy without either contacting their psychiatrist or having psychiatrists on staff,” Dr. Mathison said.
Other challenges at Brighter Days and similar centers include staffing with appropriately trained mental health professionals, given the nationwide shortage of child and adolescent psychiatrists, Dr. Scharf said.
The number of child and adolescent psychiatrists per 100,000 children varies significantly across states. Nationally, the average stands at 14 psychiatrists per 100,000 children, but ranges from as low as 4 to 65, according to the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry.
For now, Dr. Scharf said, patients who visit Brighter Days are billed as if they are having a routine pediatric office visit as opposed to a pricier trip to the emergency department. And the center accepts all individuals, regardless of their insurance status.
Ms. Opladen said the urgent care center represents a significant improvement over her experience at the emergency department’s psychiatric triage.
“I saw how awful it was and just the environment,” she said. “The first thing I thought was, what do I need to do to get out of here?”
She said the pediatric mental health urgent care centers are “the complete opposite.” Like Brighter Days, these centers are designed to look more like a pediatrician’s office, with bright welcoming colors and games and toys.
“It’s separated from everything else. There’s a welcome, relaxed space,” she said. “The welcoming feel is just a whole different environment, and that’s really how it should be.”
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Brain Structure Differs in Youth With Conduct Disorder
Youth with conduct disorder (CD) have extensive brain structure differences, new research showed.
“We know very little about this disorder even though it can carry a high burden for families and societies,” co–lead author Yidian Gao, PhD, of the University of Birmingham, Birmingham, England, said in a press release.
“The sample included in our study is 10-20 times larger than previous studies and contains data on children from North America, Europe, and Asia. It provides the most compelling evidence to date that CD is associated with widespread structural brain differences,” he added.
The findings were published online in The Lancet Psychiatry.
An Understudied Disorder
In the largest study of its kind, researchers at the Universities of Bath and Birmingham, both in England, collaborated with research teams across Europe, North America, and Asia, as part of the Enhancing NeuroImaging Genetics through Meta-Analysis–Antisocial Behavior Working Group to learn more about one of the “least researched psychiatric disorders,” they wrote.
The investigators used MRI to examine the brain structure of 1185 children with a clinical diagnosis of CD and 1253 typically developing children from 17-21 across 15 international study cohorts.
After adjusting for total intracranial volume investigators found that youth with CD (29% women; mean age, 13.7 years) had lower total surface area and lower regional surface area in 26 of the 34 cortical regions, spanning all four lobes of the brain, compared with their typically developing counterparts (35.6% women; mean age, 13.5 years).
Youth with CD also showed greater cortical thickness in the caudal anterior cingulate cortex (P = .0001) and lower cortical thickness in the banks of the superior temporal sulcus vs those without CD (P = .0010).
In addition, the CD group also had lower volume in the thalamus (P = .0009), amygdala (P = .0014), hippocampus (P = .0031), and nucleus accumbens (P = .0052).
Most findings remained significant after adjusting for intelligence quotient, psychiatric comorbidities, and psychotropic medication use. Of note, group difference in cortical thickness, 22 of 27 differences in surface area. In addition, three of four subcortical differences remained robust after adjusting for co-occurring attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, the most frequent comorbidity.
When the investigators divided individuals with CD into two subgroups — those with high vs low levels of callous-unemotional traits — they found limited overall differences. However, those with high callous-unemotional traits had lower surface area in the superior temporal and superior frontal gyri vs those with low callous-unemotional traits and the typically developing group.
Investigators also found that individuals with childhood-onset CD had greater cortical thickness in the caudal anterior cingulate cortex compared with those with adolescent-onset CD.
Study limitations include comparison of different cohorts with differing protocols that could affect the validity of the findings. In addition, subgroup samples were small and had lower statistical power.
“Our finding of robust brain alterations in conduct disorder — similar to those in more widely recognized and widely treated disorders such as ADHD — emphasize the need for a greater focus on conduct disorder in research, treatment, and public policy,” the authors noted.
Seven study authors reported conflicts of interest with various pharmaceutical companies and other organizations.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Youth with conduct disorder (CD) have extensive brain structure differences, new research showed.
“We know very little about this disorder even though it can carry a high burden for families and societies,” co–lead author Yidian Gao, PhD, of the University of Birmingham, Birmingham, England, said in a press release.
“The sample included in our study is 10-20 times larger than previous studies and contains data on children from North America, Europe, and Asia. It provides the most compelling evidence to date that CD is associated with widespread structural brain differences,” he added.
The findings were published online in The Lancet Psychiatry.
An Understudied Disorder
In the largest study of its kind, researchers at the Universities of Bath and Birmingham, both in England, collaborated with research teams across Europe, North America, and Asia, as part of the Enhancing NeuroImaging Genetics through Meta-Analysis–Antisocial Behavior Working Group to learn more about one of the “least researched psychiatric disorders,” they wrote.
The investigators used MRI to examine the brain structure of 1185 children with a clinical diagnosis of CD and 1253 typically developing children from 17-21 across 15 international study cohorts.
After adjusting for total intracranial volume investigators found that youth with CD (29% women; mean age, 13.7 years) had lower total surface area and lower regional surface area in 26 of the 34 cortical regions, spanning all four lobes of the brain, compared with their typically developing counterparts (35.6% women; mean age, 13.5 years).
Youth with CD also showed greater cortical thickness in the caudal anterior cingulate cortex (P = .0001) and lower cortical thickness in the banks of the superior temporal sulcus vs those without CD (P = .0010).
In addition, the CD group also had lower volume in the thalamus (P = .0009), amygdala (P = .0014), hippocampus (P = .0031), and nucleus accumbens (P = .0052).
Most findings remained significant after adjusting for intelligence quotient, psychiatric comorbidities, and psychotropic medication use. Of note, group difference in cortical thickness, 22 of 27 differences in surface area. In addition, three of four subcortical differences remained robust after adjusting for co-occurring attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, the most frequent comorbidity.
When the investigators divided individuals with CD into two subgroups — those with high vs low levels of callous-unemotional traits — they found limited overall differences. However, those with high callous-unemotional traits had lower surface area in the superior temporal and superior frontal gyri vs those with low callous-unemotional traits and the typically developing group.
Investigators also found that individuals with childhood-onset CD had greater cortical thickness in the caudal anterior cingulate cortex compared with those with adolescent-onset CD.
Study limitations include comparison of different cohorts with differing protocols that could affect the validity of the findings. In addition, subgroup samples were small and had lower statistical power.
“Our finding of robust brain alterations in conduct disorder — similar to those in more widely recognized and widely treated disorders such as ADHD — emphasize the need for a greater focus on conduct disorder in research, treatment, and public policy,” the authors noted.
Seven study authors reported conflicts of interest with various pharmaceutical companies and other organizations.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Youth with conduct disorder (CD) have extensive brain structure differences, new research showed.
“We know very little about this disorder even though it can carry a high burden for families and societies,” co–lead author Yidian Gao, PhD, of the University of Birmingham, Birmingham, England, said in a press release.
“The sample included in our study is 10-20 times larger than previous studies and contains data on children from North America, Europe, and Asia. It provides the most compelling evidence to date that CD is associated with widespread structural brain differences,” he added.
The findings were published online in The Lancet Psychiatry.
An Understudied Disorder
In the largest study of its kind, researchers at the Universities of Bath and Birmingham, both in England, collaborated with research teams across Europe, North America, and Asia, as part of the Enhancing NeuroImaging Genetics through Meta-Analysis–Antisocial Behavior Working Group to learn more about one of the “least researched psychiatric disorders,” they wrote.
The investigators used MRI to examine the brain structure of 1185 children with a clinical diagnosis of CD and 1253 typically developing children from 17-21 across 15 international study cohorts.
After adjusting for total intracranial volume investigators found that youth with CD (29% women; mean age, 13.7 years) had lower total surface area and lower regional surface area in 26 of the 34 cortical regions, spanning all four lobes of the brain, compared with their typically developing counterparts (35.6% women; mean age, 13.5 years).
Youth with CD also showed greater cortical thickness in the caudal anterior cingulate cortex (P = .0001) and lower cortical thickness in the banks of the superior temporal sulcus vs those without CD (P = .0010).
In addition, the CD group also had lower volume in the thalamus (P = .0009), amygdala (P = .0014), hippocampus (P = .0031), and nucleus accumbens (P = .0052).
Most findings remained significant after adjusting for intelligence quotient, psychiatric comorbidities, and psychotropic medication use. Of note, group difference in cortical thickness, 22 of 27 differences in surface area. In addition, three of four subcortical differences remained robust after adjusting for co-occurring attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, the most frequent comorbidity.
When the investigators divided individuals with CD into two subgroups — those with high vs low levels of callous-unemotional traits — they found limited overall differences. However, those with high callous-unemotional traits had lower surface area in the superior temporal and superior frontal gyri vs those with low callous-unemotional traits and the typically developing group.
Investigators also found that individuals with childhood-onset CD had greater cortical thickness in the caudal anterior cingulate cortex compared with those with adolescent-onset CD.
Study limitations include comparison of different cohorts with differing protocols that could affect the validity of the findings. In addition, subgroup samples were small and had lower statistical power.
“Our finding of robust brain alterations in conduct disorder — similar to those in more widely recognized and widely treated disorders such as ADHD — emphasize the need for a greater focus on conduct disorder in research, treatment, and public policy,” the authors noted.
Seven study authors reported conflicts of interest with various pharmaceutical companies and other organizations.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
FROM THE LANCET PSYCHIATRY
The Rise of the Scribes
“We really aren’t taking care of records — we’re taking care of people.” — Dr. Lawrence Weed
What is the purpose of a progress note? Anyone? Yes, you there. “Insurance billing?” Yes, that’s a good one. Anyone else? “To remember what you did?” Excellent. Another? Yes, that’s right, for others to follow along in your care. These are all good reasons for a progress note to exist. But they aren’t the whole story. Let’s start at the beginning.
Charts were once a collection of paper sheets with handwritten notes. Sometimes illegible, sometimes beautiful, always efficient. A progress note back then could be just 10 characters, AK, LN2, X,X,X,X,X (with X’s marking nitrogen sprays). Then came the healthcare K-Pg event: the conversion to EMRs. Those doctors who survived evolved into computer programmers, creating blocks of text from a few keystrokes. But like toddler-sized Legos, the blocks made it impossible to build a note that is nuanced or precise. Worse yet, many notes consisting of blocks from one note added awkwardly to a new note, creating grotesque structures unrecognizable as anything that should exist in nature. Words and numbers, but no information.
Thanks to the eternity of EMR, these creations live on, hideous and useless. They waste not only the server’s energy but also our time. Few things are more maddening than scrolling to reach the bottom of another physician’s note only to find there is nothing there.
Whose fault is this? Anyone? Yes, that’s right, insurers. As there are probably no payers in this audience, let’s blame them. I agree, the crushing burden of documentation-to-get-reimbursed has forced us to create “notes” that add no value to us but add up points for us to get paid for them. CMS, payers, prior authorizations, and now even patients, it seems we are documenting for lots of people except for us. There isn’t time to satisfy all and this significant burden for every encounter is a proximate cause for doctors despair. Until now.
A fully formed, comprehensive, sometimes pretty note that satisfies all audiences. Dr. Larry Weed must be dancing in heaven. It was Dr. Weed who led us from the nicotine-stained logs of the 1950s to the powerful problem-based notes we use today, an innovation that rivals the stethoscope in its impact.
Professor Weed also predicted that computers would be important to capture and make sense of patient data, helping us make accurate diagnoses and efficient plans. Again, he was right. He would surely be advocating to take advantage of AI scribes’ marvelous ability to capture salient data and present it in the form of a problem-oriented medical record.
AI scribes will be ubiquitous soon; I’m fast and even for me they save time. They also allow, for the first time in a decade, to turn from the glow of a screen to actually face the patient – we no longer have to scribe and care simultaneously. Hallelujah. And yet, lest I disappoint you without a twist, it seems with AI scribes, like EMRs we lose a little something too.
Like self-driving cars or ChatGPT-generated letters, they remove cognitive loads. They are lovely when you have to multitask or are trying to recall a visit from hours (days) ago. Using them, you’ll feel faster, lighter, freer, happier. But what’s missing is the thinking. At the end, you have an exquisite note, but you didn’t write it. It has the salient points, but none of the mental work to create it. AI scribes subvert the valuable work of synthesis. That was the critical part of Dr. Weed’s discovery: writing problem-oriented notes helped us think better.
Writing allows for the friction that helps us process what is going on with a patient. It allows for the discovery of diagnoses and prompts plans. When I was an intern, one of my attendings would hand write notes, succinctly showing what he had observed and was thinking. He’d sketch diagrams in the chart, for example, to help illustrate how we’d work though the toxic, metabolic, and infectious etiologies of acute liver failure. Sublime.
The act of writing also helps remind us there is a person attached to these words. Like a handwritten sympathy card, it is intimate, human. Even using our EMR, I’d still often type sentences that help tell the patient’s story. “Her sister just died. Utterly devastated. I’ll forward chart to Bob (her PCP) to check in on her.” Or: “Scratch golfer wants to know why he is getting so many SCCs now. ‘Like bankruptcy, gradually then suddenly,’ I explained. I think I broke through.”
Since we’ve concluded the purpose of a note is mostly to capture data, AI scribes are a godsend. They do so with remarkable quality and efficiency. We’ll just have to remember if the diagnosis is unclear, then it might help to write the note out yourself. And even when done by the AI machine, we might add human touches now and again lest there be no art left in what we do.
“For sale. Sun hat. Never worn.”
Dr. Benabio is director of Healthcare Transformation and chief of dermatology at Kaiser Permanente San Diego. The opinions expressed in this column are his own and do not represent those of Kaiser Permanente. Dr. Benabio is @Dermdoc on X. Write to him at [email protected].
“We really aren’t taking care of records — we’re taking care of people.” — Dr. Lawrence Weed
What is the purpose of a progress note? Anyone? Yes, you there. “Insurance billing?” Yes, that’s a good one. Anyone else? “To remember what you did?” Excellent. Another? Yes, that’s right, for others to follow along in your care. These are all good reasons for a progress note to exist. But they aren’t the whole story. Let’s start at the beginning.
Charts were once a collection of paper sheets with handwritten notes. Sometimes illegible, sometimes beautiful, always efficient. A progress note back then could be just 10 characters, AK, LN2, X,X,X,X,X (with X’s marking nitrogen sprays). Then came the healthcare K-Pg event: the conversion to EMRs. Those doctors who survived evolved into computer programmers, creating blocks of text from a few keystrokes. But like toddler-sized Legos, the blocks made it impossible to build a note that is nuanced or precise. Worse yet, many notes consisting of blocks from one note added awkwardly to a new note, creating grotesque structures unrecognizable as anything that should exist in nature. Words and numbers, but no information.
Thanks to the eternity of EMR, these creations live on, hideous and useless. They waste not only the server’s energy but also our time. Few things are more maddening than scrolling to reach the bottom of another physician’s note only to find there is nothing there.
Whose fault is this? Anyone? Yes, that’s right, insurers. As there are probably no payers in this audience, let’s blame them. I agree, the crushing burden of documentation-to-get-reimbursed has forced us to create “notes” that add no value to us but add up points for us to get paid for them. CMS, payers, prior authorizations, and now even patients, it seems we are documenting for lots of people except for us. There isn’t time to satisfy all and this significant burden for every encounter is a proximate cause for doctors despair. Until now.
A fully formed, comprehensive, sometimes pretty note that satisfies all audiences. Dr. Larry Weed must be dancing in heaven. It was Dr. Weed who led us from the nicotine-stained logs of the 1950s to the powerful problem-based notes we use today, an innovation that rivals the stethoscope in its impact.
Professor Weed also predicted that computers would be important to capture and make sense of patient data, helping us make accurate diagnoses and efficient plans. Again, he was right. He would surely be advocating to take advantage of AI scribes’ marvelous ability to capture salient data and present it in the form of a problem-oriented medical record.
AI scribes will be ubiquitous soon; I’m fast and even for me they save time. They also allow, for the first time in a decade, to turn from the glow of a screen to actually face the patient – we no longer have to scribe and care simultaneously. Hallelujah. And yet, lest I disappoint you without a twist, it seems with AI scribes, like EMRs we lose a little something too.
Like self-driving cars or ChatGPT-generated letters, they remove cognitive loads. They are lovely when you have to multitask or are trying to recall a visit from hours (days) ago. Using them, you’ll feel faster, lighter, freer, happier. But what’s missing is the thinking. At the end, you have an exquisite note, but you didn’t write it. It has the salient points, but none of the mental work to create it. AI scribes subvert the valuable work of synthesis. That was the critical part of Dr. Weed’s discovery: writing problem-oriented notes helped us think better.
Writing allows for the friction that helps us process what is going on with a patient. It allows for the discovery of diagnoses and prompts plans. When I was an intern, one of my attendings would hand write notes, succinctly showing what he had observed and was thinking. He’d sketch diagrams in the chart, for example, to help illustrate how we’d work though the toxic, metabolic, and infectious etiologies of acute liver failure. Sublime.
The act of writing also helps remind us there is a person attached to these words. Like a handwritten sympathy card, it is intimate, human. Even using our EMR, I’d still often type sentences that help tell the patient’s story. “Her sister just died. Utterly devastated. I’ll forward chart to Bob (her PCP) to check in on her.” Or: “Scratch golfer wants to know why he is getting so many SCCs now. ‘Like bankruptcy, gradually then suddenly,’ I explained. I think I broke through.”
Since we’ve concluded the purpose of a note is mostly to capture data, AI scribes are a godsend. They do so with remarkable quality and efficiency. We’ll just have to remember if the diagnosis is unclear, then it might help to write the note out yourself. And even when done by the AI machine, we might add human touches now and again lest there be no art left in what we do.
“For sale. Sun hat. Never worn.”
Dr. Benabio is director of Healthcare Transformation and chief of dermatology at Kaiser Permanente San Diego. The opinions expressed in this column are his own and do not represent those of Kaiser Permanente. Dr. Benabio is @Dermdoc on X. Write to him at [email protected].
“We really aren’t taking care of records — we’re taking care of people.” — Dr. Lawrence Weed
What is the purpose of a progress note? Anyone? Yes, you there. “Insurance billing?” Yes, that’s a good one. Anyone else? “To remember what you did?” Excellent. Another? Yes, that’s right, for others to follow along in your care. These are all good reasons for a progress note to exist. But they aren’t the whole story. Let’s start at the beginning.
Charts were once a collection of paper sheets with handwritten notes. Sometimes illegible, sometimes beautiful, always efficient. A progress note back then could be just 10 characters, AK, LN2, X,X,X,X,X (with X’s marking nitrogen sprays). Then came the healthcare K-Pg event: the conversion to EMRs. Those doctors who survived evolved into computer programmers, creating blocks of text from a few keystrokes. But like toddler-sized Legos, the blocks made it impossible to build a note that is nuanced or precise. Worse yet, many notes consisting of blocks from one note added awkwardly to a new note, creating grotesque structures unrecognizable as anything that should exist in nature. Words and numbers, but no information.
Thanks to the eternity of EMR, these creations live on, hideous and useless. They waste not only the server’s energy but also our time. Few things are more maddening than scrolling to reach the bottom of another physician’s note only to find there is nothing there.
Whose fault is this? Anyone? Yes, that’s right, insurers. As there are probably no payers in this audience, let’s blame them. I agree, the crushing burden of documentation-to-get-reimbursed has forced us to create “notes” that add no value to us but add up points for us to get paid for them. CMS, payers, prior authorizations, and now even patients, it seems we are documenting for lots of people except for us. There isn’t time to satisfy all and this significant burden for every encounter is a proximate cause for doctors despair. Until now.
A fully formed, comprehensive, sometimes pretty note that satisfies all audiences. Dr. Larry Weed must be dancing in heaven. It was Dr. Weed who led us from the nicotine-stained logs of the 1950s to the powerful problem-based notes we use today, an innovation that rivals the stethoscope in its impact.
Professor Weed also predicted that computers would be important to capture and make sense of patient data, helping us make accurate diagnoses and efficient plans. Again, he was right. He would surely be advocating to take advantage of AI scribes’ marvelous ability to capture salient data and present it in the form of a problem-oriented medical record.
AI scribes will be ubiquitous soon; I’m fast and even for me they save time. They also allow, for the first time in a decade, to turn from the glow of a screen to actually face the patient – we no longer have to scribe and care simultaneously. Hallelujah. And yet, lest I disappoint you without a twist, it seems with AI scribes, like EMRs we lose a little something too.
Like self-driving cars or ChatGPT-generated letters, they remove cognitive loads. They are lovely when you have to multitask or are trying to recall a visit from hours (days) ago. Using them, you’ll feel faster, lighter, freer, happier. But what’s missing is the thinking. At the end, you have an exquisite note, but you didn’t write it. It has the salient points, but none of the mental work to create it. AI scribes subvert the valuable work of synthesis. That was the critical part of Dr. Weed’s discovery: writing problem-oriented notes helped us think better.
Writing allows for the friction that helps us process what is going on with a patient. It allows for the discovery of diagnoses and prompts plans. When I was an intern, one of my attendings would hand write notes, succinctly showing what he had observed and was thinking. He’d sketch diagrams in the chart, for example, to help illustrate how we’d work though the toxic, metabolic, and infectious etiologies of acute liver failure. Sublime.
The act of writing also helps remind us there is a person attached to these words. Like a handwritten sympathy card, it is intimate, human. Even using our EMR, I’d still often type sentences that help tell the patient’s story. “Her sister just died. Utterly devastated. I’ll forward chart to Bob (her PCP) to check in on her.” Or: “Scratch golfer wants to know why he is getting so many SCCs now. ‘Like bankruptcy, gradually then suddenly,’ I explained. I think I broke through.”
Since we’ve concluded the purpose of a note is mostly to capture data, AI scribes are a godsend. They do so with remarkable quality and efficiency. We’ll just have to remember if the diagnosis is unclear, then it might help to write the note out yourself. And even when done by the AI machine, we might add human touches now and again lest there be no art left in what we do.
“For sale. Sun hat. Never worn.”
Dr. Benabio is director of Healthcare Transformation and chief of dermatology at Kaiser Permanente San Diego. The opinions expressed in this column are his own and do not represent those of Kaiser Permanente. Dr. Benabio is @Dermdoc on X. Write to him at [email protected].
Emergency Contraception Recommended for Teens on Isotretinoin
TORONTO —
That was one of the main messages from Andrea L. Zaenglein, MD, professor of dermatology and pediatrics, Penn State University, Hershey, who discussed hormonal therapies for pediatric acne at the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology.
Many doctors are reluctant to prescribe EC, which refers to contraceptive methods used to prevent unintended pregnancy after unprotected sexual intercourse or contraceptive failure, whether that’s from discomfort with EC or lack of training, Dr. Zaenglein said in an interview.
Isotretinoin, a retinoid marketed as Accutane and other brand names, is an effective treatment for acne but carries serious teratogenicity risks; the iPLEDGE Risk Evaluation and Mitigation Strategy is designed to manage this risk and minimize fetal exposure. Yet from 2011 to 2017, 210-310 pregnancies per year were reported to the Food and Drug Administration, according to a 2019 study.
There is a knowledge gap regarding EC among dermatologists who prescribe isotretinoin, which “is perpetuated by the iPLEDGE program because it is inadequate in guiding clinicians or educating patients about the use of EC,” Dr. Zaenglein and colleagues wrote in a recently published viewpoint on EC prescribing in patients on isotretinoin.
Types of EC include oral levonorgestrel (plan B), available over the counter; oral ulipristal acetate (ella), which requires a prescription; and the copper/hormonal intrauterine device.
Not all teens taking isotretinoin can be trusted to be sexually abstinent. Dr. Zaenglein cited research showing 39% of female high school students have had sexual relations. “In my opinion, these patients should have emergency contraception prescribed to them as a backup,” she said.
Dr. Zaenglein believes there’s a fair amount of “misunderstanding” about EC, with many people thinking it’s an abortion pill. “It’s a totally different medicine. This is contraception; if you’re pregnant, it’s not going to affect your fetus.”
Outgoing SPD President Sheilagh Maguiness, MD, professor of dermatology and pediatrics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, agreed that Dr. Zaenglein raised an important issue. “She has identified a practice gap and a knowledge gap that we need to address,” she said in an interview.
When discussing contraception with female patients taking isotretinoin, assume they’re sexually active or could be, Dr. Zaenglein told meeting attendees. Be explicit about the risks to the fetus and consider their past compliance.
Complex Disorder
During her presentation, Dr. Zaenglein described acne as a “very complex, multifactorial inflammatory disorder” of the skin. It involves four steps: Increased sebum production, hyperkeratinization, Cutibacterium acnes, and inflammation. External factors such as diet, genes, and the environment play a role.
“But at the heart of all of it is androgens; if you didn’t have androgens, you wouldn’t have acne.” That’s why some acne treatments block androgen receptors.
Clinicians are increasingly using one such therapy, spironolactone, to treat acne in female adolescents. Dr. Zaenglein referred to a Mayo Clinic study of 80 patients (mean age, 19 years), who had moderate to severe acne treated with a mean dose of 100 mg/day, that found 80% had improvement with a favorable side effect profile. This included nearly 23% who had a complete response (90% or more) and 36% who had a partial response (more than 50%); 20% had no response.
However, response rates are higher in adults, said Dr. Zaenglein, noting that spironolactone works “much better” in adult women.
Side effects of spironolactone can include menstrual disturbances, breast enlargement and tenderness, and premenstrual syndrome–like symptoms.
Dermatologists should also consider combined oral contraceptives (COCs) in their adolescent patients with acne. These have an estrogen component as well as a progestin component.
They have proven effectiveness for acne in adolescents, yet a US survey of 170 dermatology residents found only 60% felt comfortable prescribing them to healthy adolescents. The survey also found only 62% of respondents felt adequately trained on the efficacy of COCs, and 42% felt adequately trained on their safety.
Contraindications for COCs include thrombosis, migraine with aura, lupus, seizures, and hypertension. Complex valvular heart disease and liver tumors also need to be ruled out, said Dr. Zaenglein. One of the “newer concerns” with COCs is depression. “There’s biological plausibility because, obviously, hormones impact the brain.”
Preventing Drug Interactions
Before prescribing hormonal therapy, clinicians should carry out an acne assessment, aimed in part at preventing drug interactions. “The one we mostly have to watch out for is rifampin,” an antibiotic that could interact with COCs, said Dr. Zaenglein.
The herbal supplement St John’s Wort can reduce the efficacy of COCs. “You also want to make sure that they’re not on any medicines that will increase potassium, such as ACE inhibitors,” said Dr. Zaenglein. But tetracyclines, ampicillin, or metronidazole are usually “all okay” when combined with COCs.
It’s important to get baseline blood pressure levels and to check these along with weight on a regular basis, she added.
Always Consider PCOS
Before starting hormonal therapy, she advises dermatologists to “always consider” polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), a condition that’s “probably much underdiagnosed.” Acne is common in adolescents with PCOS. She suggests using a PCOS checklist, a reminder to ask about irregular periods, hirsutism, signs of insulin resistance such as increased body mass index, a history of premature adrenarche, and a family history of PCOS, said Dr. Zaenglein, noting that a person with a sibling who has PCOS has about a 40% chance of developing the condition.
“We play an important role in getting kids diagnosed at an early age so that we can make interventions because the impact of the metabolic syndrome can have lifelong effects on their cardiovascular system, as well as infertility.”
Dr. Zaenglein is a member of the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) Acne Guidelines work group, the immediate past president of the American Acne and Rosacea Society, a member of the AAD iPLEDGE work group, co–editor in chief of Pediatric Dermatology, an advisory board member of Ortho Dermatologics, and a consultant for Church & Dwight. Dr. Maguiness had no relevant conflicts of interest.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
TORONTO —
That was one of the main messages from Andrea L. Zaenglein, MD, professor of dermatology and pediatrics, Penn State University, Hershey, who discussed hormonal therapies for pediatric acne at the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology.
Many doctors are reluctant to prescribe EC, which refers to contraceptive methods used to prevent unintended pregnancy after unprotected sexual intercourse or contraceptive failure, whether that’s from discomfort with EC or lack of training, Dr. Zaenglein said in an interview.
Isotretinoin, a retinoid marketed as Accutane and other brand names, is an effective treatment for acne but carries serious teratogenicity risks; the iPLEDGE Risk Evaluation and Mitigation Strategy is designed to manage this risk and minimize fetal exposure. Yet from 2011 to 2017, 210-310 pregnancies per year were reported to the Food and Drug Administration, according to a 2019 study.
There is a knowledge gap regarding EC among dermatologists who prescribe isotretinoin, which “is perpetuated by the iPLEDGE program because it is inadequate in guiding clinicians or educating patients about the use of EC,” Dr. Zaenglein and colleagues wrote in a recently published viewpoint on EC prescribing in patients on isotretinoin.
Types of EC include oral levonorgestrel (plan B), available over the counter; oral ulipristal acetate (ella), which requires a prescription; and the copper/hormonal intrauterine device.
Not all teens taking isotretinoin can be trusted to be sexually abstinent. Dr. Zaenglein cited research showing 39% of female high school students have had sexual relations. “In my opinion, these patients should have emergency contraception prescribed to them as a backup,” she said.
Dr. Zaenglein believes there’s a fair amount of “misunderstanding” about EC, with many people thinking it’s an abortion pill. “It’s a totally different medicine. This is contraception; if you’re pregnant, it’s not going to affect your fetus.”
Outgoing SPD President Sheilagh Maguiness, MD, professor of dermatology and pediatrics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, agreed that Dr. Zaenglein raised an important issue. “She has identified a practice gap and a knowledge gap that we need to address,” she said in an interview.
When discussing contraception with female patients taking isotretinoin, assume they’re sexually active or could be, Dr. Zaenglein told meeting attendees. Be explicit about the risks to the fetus and consider their past compliance.
Complex Disorder
During her presentation, Dr. Zaenglein described acne as a “very complex, multifactorial inflammatory disorder” of the skin. It involves four steps: Increased sebum production, hyperkeratinization, Cutibacterium acnes, and inflammation. External factors such as diet, genes, and the environment play a role.
“But at the heart of all of it is androgens; if you didn’t have androgens, you wouldn’t have acne.” That’s why some acne treatments block androgen receptors.
Clinicians are increasingly using one such therapy, spironolactone, to treat acne in female adolescents. Dr. Zaenglein referred to a Mayo Clinic study of 80 patients (mean age, 19 years), who had moderate to severe acne treated with a mean dose of 100 mg/day, that found 80% had improvement with a favorable side effect profile. This included nearly 23% who had a complete response (90% or more) and 36% who had a partial response (more than 50%); 20% had no response.
However, response rates are higher in adults, said Dr. Zaenglein, noting that spironolactone works “much better” in adult women.
Side effects of spironolactone can include menstrual disturbances, breast enlargement and tenderness, and premenstrual syndrome–like symptoms.
Dermatologists should also consider combined oral contraceptives (COCs) in their adolescent patients with acne. These have an estrogen component as well as a progestin component.
They have proven effectiveness for acne in adolescents, yet a US survey of 170 dermatology residents found only 60% felt comfortable prescribing them to healthy adolescents. The survey also found only 62% of respondents felt adequately trained on the efficacy of COCs, and 42% felt adequately trained on their safety.
Contraindications for COCs include thrombosis, migraine with aura, lupus, seizures, and hypertension. Complex valvular heart disease and liver tumors also need to be ruled out, said Dr. Zaenglein. One of the “newer concerns” with COCs is depression. “There’s biological plausibility because, obviously, hormones impact the brain.”
Preventing Drug Interactions
Before prescribing hormonal therapy, clinicians should carry out an acne assessment, aimed in part at preventing drug interactions. “The one we mostly have to watch out for is rifampin,” an antibiotic that could interact with COCs, said Dr. Zaenglein.
The herbal supplement St John’s Wort can reduce the efficacy of COCs. “You also want to make sure that they’re not on any medicines that will increase potassium, such as ACE inhibitors,” said Dr. Zaenglein. But tetracyclines, ampicillin, or metronidazole are usually “all okay” when combined with COCs.
It’s important to get baseline blood pressure levels and to check these along with weight on a regular basis, she added.
Always Consider PCOS
Before starting hormonal therapy, she advises dermatologists to “always consider” polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), a condition that’s “probably much underdiagnosed.” Acne is common in adolescents with PCOS. She suggests using a PCOS checklist, a reminder to ask about irregular periods, hirsutism, signs of insulin resistance such as increased body mass index, a history of premature adrenarche, and a family history of PCOS, said Dr. Zaenglein, noting that a person with a sibling who has PCOS has about a 40% chance of developing the condition.
“We play an important role in getting kids diagnosed at an early age so that we can make interventions because the impact of the metabolic syndrome can have lifelong effects on their cardiovascular system, as well as infertility.”
Dr. Zaenglein is a member of the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) Acne Guidelines work group, the immediate past president of the American Acne and Rosacea Society, a member of the AAD iPLEDGE work group, co–editor in chief of Pediatric Dermatology, an advisory board member of Ortho Dermatologics, and a consultant for Church & Dwight. Dr. Maguiness had no relevant conflicts of interest.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
TORONTO —
That was one of the main messages from Andrea L. Zaenglein, MD, professor of dermatology and pediatrics, Penn State University, Hershey, who discussed hormonal therapies for pediatric acne at the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology.
Many doctors are reluctant to prescribe EC, which refers to contraceptive methods used to prevent unintended pregnancy after unprotected sexual intercourse or contraceptive failure, whether that’s from discomfort with EC or lack of training, Dr. Zaenglein said in an interview.
Isotretinoin, a retinoid marketed as Accutane and other brand names, is an effective treatment for acne but carries serious teratogenicity risks; the iPLEDGE Risk Evaluation and Mitigation Strategy is designed to manage this risk and minimize fetal exposure. Yet from 2011 to 2017, 210-310 pregnancies per year were reported to the Food and Drug Administration, according to a 2019 study.
There is a knowledge gap regarding EC among dermatologists who prescribe isotretinoin, which “is perpetuated by the iPLEDGE program because it is inadequate in guiding clinicians or educating patients about the use of EC,” Dr. Zaenglein and colleagues wrote in a recently published viewpoint on EC prescribing in patients on isotretinoin.
Types of EC include oral levonorgestrel (plan B), available over the counter; oral ulipristal acetate (ella), which requires a prescription; and the copper/hormonal intrauterine device.
Not all teens taking isotretinoin can be trusted to be sexually abstinent. Dr. Zaenglein cited research showing 39% of female high school students have had sexual relations. “In my opinion, these patients should have emergency contraception prescribed to them as a backup,” she said.
Dr. Zaenglein believes there’s a fair amount of “misunderstanding” about EC, with many people thinking it’s an abortion pill. “It’s a totally different medicine. This is contraception; if you’re pregnant, it’s not going to affect your fetus.”
Outgoing SPD President Sheilagh Maguiness, MD, professor of dermatology and pediatrics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, agreed that Dr. Zaenglein raised an important issue. “She has identified a practice gap and a knowledge gap that we need to address,” she said in an interview.
When discussing contraception with female patients taking isotretinoin, assume they’re sexually active or could be, Dr. Zaenglein told meeting attendees. Be explicit about the risks to the fetus and consider their past compliance.
Complex Disorder
During her presentation, Dr. Zaenglein described acne as a “very complex, multifactorial inflammatory disorder” of the skin. It involves four steps: Increased sebum production, hyperkeratinization, Cutibacterium acnes, and inflammation. External factors such as diet, genes, and the environment play a role.
“But at the heart of all of it is androgens; if you didn’t have androgens, you wouldn’t have acne.” That’s why some acne treatments block androgen receptors.
Clinicians are increasingly using one such therapy, spironolactone, to treat acne in female adolescents. Dr. Zaenglein referred to a Mayo Clinic study of 80 patients (mean age, 19 years), who had moderate to severe acne treated with a mean dose of 100 mg/day, that found 80% had improvement with a favorable side effect profile. This included nearly 23% who had a complete response (90% or more) and 36% who had a partial response (more than 50%); 20% had no response.
However, response rates are higher in adults, said Dr. Zaenglein, noting that spironolactone works “much better” in adult women.
Side effects of spironolactone can include menstrual disturbances, breast enlargement and tenderness, and premenstrual syndrome–like symptoms.
Dermatologists should also consider combined oral contraceptives (COCs) in their adolescent patients with acne. These have an estrogen component as well as a progestin component.
They have proven effectiveness for acne in adolescents, yet a US survey of 170 dermatology residents found only 60% felt comfortable prescribing them to healthy adolescents. The survey also found only 62% of respondents felt adequately trained on the efficacy of COCs, and 42% felt adequately trained on their safety.
Contraindications for COCs include thrombosis, migraine with aura, lupus, seizures, and hypertension. Complex valvular heart disease and liver tumors also need to be ruled out, said Dr. Zaenglein. One of the “newer concerns” with COCs is depression. “There’s biological plausibility because, obviously, hormones impact the brain.”
Preventing Drug Interactions
Before prescribing hormonal therapy, clinicians should carry out an acne assessment, aimed in part at preventing drug interactions. “The one we mostly have to watch out for is rifampin,” an antibiotic that could interact with COCs, said Dr. Zaenglein.
The herbal supplement St John’s Wort can reduce the efficacy of COCs. “You also want to make sure that they’re not on any medicines that will increase potassium, such as ACE inhibitors,” said Dr. Zaenglein. But tetracyclines, ampicillin, or metronidazole are usually “all okay” when combined with COCs.
It’s important to get baseline blood pressure levels and to check these along with weight on a regular basis, she added.
Always Consider PCOS
Before starting hormonal therapy, she advises dermatologists to “always consider” polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), a condition that’s “probably much underdiagnosed.” Acne is common in adolescents with PCOS. She suggests using a PCOS checklist, a reminder to ask about irregular periods, hirsutism, signs of insulin resistance such as increased body mass index, a history of premature adrenarche, and a family history of PCOS, said Dr. Zaenglein, noting that a person with a sibling who has PCOS has about a 40% chance of developing the condition.
“We play an important role in getting kids diagnosed at an early age so that we can make interventions because the impact of the metabolic syndrome can have lifelong effects on their cardiovascular system, as well as infertility.”
Dr. Zaenglein is a member of the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) Acne Guidelines work group, the immediate past president of the American Acne and Rosacea Society, a member of the AAD iPLEDGE work group, co–editor in chief of Pediatric Dermatology, an advisory board member of Ortho Dermatologics, and a consultant for Church & Dwight. Dr. Maguiness had no relevant conflicts of interest.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
FROM SPD 2024
Several Skin Conditions More Likely in Children With Obesity
TORONTO — results of new research show.
The retrospective cohort study found markedly higher rates of skin infections, atopic dermatitis (AD), and acanthosis nigricans among children with overweight, compared with children with average weight.
“Many conditions associated with obesity are strong predictors of cardiovascular mortality as these children age, so doctors can play a key role in advocating for weight loss strategies in this population,” lead study author Samantha Epstein, third-year medical student at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, said in an interview. The findings were presented at the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology.
Previous research has linked obesity, a chronic inflammatory condition, to psoriasis, AD, hidradenitis suppurativa (HS), acne vulgaris, infections, and rosacea in adults. However, there’s scant research exploring the connection between obesity and cutaneous conditions in children.
According to the Cleveland Clinic, childhood obesity is defined as a body mass index, which is weight in kg divided by the square of height in m2, at or above the 95th percentile for age and sex in children aged 2 years or older.
For the study, Ms. Epstein and coauthor Sonal D. Shah, MD, associate professor, Department of Dermatology, Case Western Reserve University, and a board-certified pediatric dermatologist accessed a large national research database and used diagnostic codes to identify over 1 million children (mean age, 8.5 years). Most (about 44%) were White; about one-quarter were Black. The groups were propensity matched, so there were about equal numbers of youngsters with and without obesity and of boys and girls.
They collected data on AD, HS, rosacea, psoriasis, and acanthosis nigricans (a thickened purplish discoloration typically found in body folds around the armpits, groin, and neck). They also gathered information on comorbidities.
Acanthosis nigricans, which is linked to metabolic syndrome, type 2 diabetes, and insulin resistance , was more prevalent among children with obesity (20,885 cases in the with-obesity group and 336 in the without-obesity group, for a relative risk [RR] of 62.16 and an odds ratio [OR] of 64.38).
Skin and subcutaneous tissue infections were also more common among those with obesity (14,795 cases) vs 4720 cases among those without obesity (RR, 3.14; OR, 3.2). As for AD, there were 11,892 cases in the with-obesity group and 2983 in the without-obesity group (RR, 3.99; OR, 4.06). There were 1166 cases of psoriasis among those with obesity and 408 among those without obesity (RR, 2.86; OR, 2.88).
HS (587 cases in the with-obesity group and 70 in the without-obesity group; RR, 8.39; OR, 8.39) and rosacea (351 in the with-obesity group and 138 in the without-obesity group; RR, 2.54; OR, 2.55) were the least common skin conditions.
Higher Comorbidity Rates
Compared with their average-weight counterparts, the children with obesity had higher rates of comorbidities, including type 2 diabetes. Ms. Epstein noted that children with diabetes and obesity had increased risks for every skin condition except for infections of the skin and subcutaneous tissue when compared with children without obesity.
Such infections were the most common skin conditions among children without obesity. “This was expected just due to the fact that children are outside, they’re playing in the grass and the dirt, and they get infected,” said Ms. Epstein. Still, these infections were three times more common in youngsters with obesity.
Although acanthosis nigricans is “highly correlated” with type 2 diabetes, “not as many children as we would expect in this population have developed type 2 diabetes,” said Ms. Epstein. This might make some sense, though, because these children are still quite young. “When dermatologists recognize this skin condition, they can advocate for weight loss management to try to prevent it.”
Other conditions seen more often in the overweight children with overweight included: hypertension, hyperlipidemia, obstructive sleep apnea, polycystic ovarian syndrome, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, major depressive disorder, depressive episodes, and anxiety (all P < .001).
Commenting on the results, Sonia Havele, MD, a pediatrician and dermatology resident at Children’s Mercy Hospital, Kansas City, Missouri, said in an interview that the study reflects trends that she and her colleagues see in clinic: There are more common skin conditions in their patients with obesity.
She agreed that it offers an opening for education. “The results of this study highlight the opportunity we have as pediatric dermatologists to provide additional counseling on obesity and offer referrals to our colleagues in endocrinology, gastroenterology, and nutrition if needed.”
No conflicts of interest were reported.
TORONTO — results of new research show.
The retrospective cohort study found markedly higher rates of skin infections, atopic dermatitis (AD), and acanthosis nigricans among children with overweight, compared with children with average weight.
“Many conditions associated with obesity are strong predictors of cardiovascular mortality as these children age, so doctors can play a key role in advocating for weight loss strategies in this population,” lead study author Samantha Epstein, third-year medical student at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, said in an interview. The findings were presented at the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology.
Previous research has linked obesity, a chronic inflammatory condition, to psoriasis, AD, hidradenitis suppurativa (HS), acne vulgaris, infections, and rosacea in adults. However, there’s scant research exploring the connection between obesity and cutaneous conditions in children.
According to the Cleveland Clinic, childhood obesity is defined as a body mass index, which is weight in kg divided by the square of height in m2, at or above the 95th percentile for age and sex in children aged 2 years or older.
For the study, Ms. Epstein and coauthor Sonal D. Shah, MD, associate professor, Department of Dermatology, Case Western Reserve University, and a board-certified pediatric dermatologist accessed a large national research database and used diagnostic codes to identify over 1 million children (mean age, 8.5 years). Most (about 44%) were White; about one-quarter were Black. The groups were propensity matched, so there were about equal numbers of youngsters with and without obesity and of boys and girls.
They collected data on AD, HS, rosacea, psoriasis, and acanthosis nigricans (a thickened purplish discoloration typically found in body folds around the armpits, groin, and neck). They also gathered information on comorbidities.
Acanthosis nigricans, which is linked to metabolic syndrome, type 2 diabetes, and insulin resistance , was more prevalent among children with obesity (20,885 cases in the with-obesity group and 336 in the without-obesity group, for a relative risk [RR] of 62.16 and an odds ratio [OR] of 64.38).
Skin and subcutaneous tissue infections were also more common among those with obesity (14,795 cases) vs 4720 cases among those without obesity (RR, 3.14; OR, 3.2). As for AD, there were 11,892 cases in the with-obesity group and 2983 in the without-obesity group (RR, 3.99; OR, 4.06). There were 1166 cases of psoriasis among those with obesity and 408 among those without obesity (RR, 2.86; OR, 2.88).
HS (587 cases in the with-obesity group and 70 in the without-obesity group; RR, 8.39; OR, 8.39) and rosacea (351 in the with-obesity group and 138 in the without-obesity group; RR, 2.54; OR, 2.55) were the least common skin conditions.
Higher Comorbidity Rates
Compared with their average-weight counterparts, the children with obesity had higher rates of comorbidities, including type 2 diabetes. Ms. Epstein noted that children with diabetes and obesity had increased risks for every skin condition except for infections of the skin and subcutaneous tissue when compared with children without obesity.
Such infections were the most common skin conditions among children without obesity. “This was expected just due to the fact that children are outside, they’re playing in the grass and the dirt, and they get infected,” said Ms. Epstein. Still, these infections were three times more common in youngsters with obesity.
Although acanthosis nigricans is “highly correlated” with type 2 diabetes, “not as many children as we would expect in this population have developed type 2 diabetes,” said Ms. Epstein. This might make some sense, though, because these children are still quite young. “When dermatologists recognize this skin condition, they can advocate for weight loss management to try to prevent it.”
Other conditions seen more often in the overweight children with overweight included: hypertension, hyperlipidemia, obstructive sleep apnea, polycystic ovarian syndrome, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, major depressive disorder, depressive episodes, and anxiety (all P < .001).
Commenting on the results, Sonia Havele, MD, a pediatrician and dermatology resident at Children’s Mercy Hospital, Kansas City, Missouri, said in an interview that the study reflects trends that she and her colleagues see in clinic: There are more common skin conditions in their patients with obesity.
She agreed that it offers an opening for education. “The results of this study highlight the opportunity we have as pediatric dermatologists to provide additional counseling on obesity and offer referrals to our colleagues in endocrinology, gastroenterology, and nutrition if needed.”
No conflicts of interest were reported.
TORONTO — results of new research show.
The retrospective cohort study found markedly higher rates of skin infections, atopic dermatitis (AD), and acanthosis nigricans among children with overweight, compared with children with average weight.
“Many conditions associated with obesity are strong predictors of cardiovascular mortality as these children age, so doctors can play a key role in advocating for weight loss strategies in this population,” lead study author Samantha Epstein, third-year medical student at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, said in an interview. The findings were presented at the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology.
Previous research has linked obesity, a chronic inflammatory condition, to psoriasis, AD, hidradenitis suppurativa (HS), acne vulgaris, infections, and rosacea in adults. However, there’s scant research exploring the connection between obesity and cutaneous conditions in children.
According to the Cleveland Clinic, childhood obesity is defined as a body mass index, which is weight in kg divided by the square of height in m2, at or above the 95th percentile for age and sex in children aged 2 years or older.
For the study, Ms. Epstein and coauthor Sonal D. Shah, MD, associate professor, Department of Dermatology, Case Western Reserve University, and a board-certified pediatric dermatologist accessed a large national research database and used diagnostic codes to identify over 1 million children (mean age, 8.5 years). Most (about 44%) were White; about one-quarter were Black. The groups were propensity matched, so there were about equal numbers of youngsters with and without obesity and of boys and girls.
They collected data on AD, HS, rosacea, psoriasis, and acanthosis nigricans (a thickened purplish discoloration typically found in body folds around the armpits, groin, and neck). They also gathered information on comorbidities.
Acanthosis nigricans, which is linked to metabolic syndrome, type 2 diabetes, and insulin resistance , was more prevalent among children with obesity (20,885 cases in the with-obesity group and 336 in the without-obesity group, for a relative risk [RR] of 62.16 and an odds ratio [OR] of 64.38).
Skin and subcutaneous tissue infections were also more common among those with obesity (14,795 cases) vs 4720 cases among those without obesity (RR, 3.14; OR, 3.2). As for AD, there were 11,892 cases in the with-obesity group and 2983 in the without-obesity group (RR, 3.99; OR, 4.06). There were 1166 cases of psoriasis among those with obesity and 408 among those without obesity (RR, 2.86; OR, 2.88).
HS (587 cases in the with-obesity group and 70 in the without-obesity group; RR, 8.39; OR, 8.39) and rosacea (351 in the with-obesity group and 138 in the without-obesity group; RR, 2.54; OR, 2.55) were the least common skin conditions.
Higher Comorbidity Rates
Compared with their average-weight counterparts, the children with obesity had higher rates of comorbidities, including type 2 diabetes. Ms. Epstein noted that children with diabetes and obesity had increased risks for every skin condition except for infections of the skin and subcutaneous tissue when compared with children without obesity.
Such infections were the most common skin conditions among children without obesity. “This was expected just due to the fact that children are outside, they’re playing in the grass and the dirt, and they get infected,” said Ms. Epstein. Still, these infections were three times more common in youngsters with obesity.
Although acanthosis nigricans is “highly correlated” with type 2 diabetes, “not as many children as we would expect in this population have developed type 2 diabetes,” said Ms. Epstein. This might make some sense, though, because these children are still quite young. “When dermatologists recognize this skin condition, they can advocate for weight loss management to try to prevent it.”
Other conditions seen more often in the overweight children with overweight included: hypertension, hyperlipidemia, obstructive sleep apnea, polycystic ovarian syndrome, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, major depressive disorder, depressive episodes, and anxiety (all P < .001).
Commenting on the results, Sonia Havele, MD, a pediatrician and dermatology resident at Children’s Mercy Hospital, Kansas City, Missouri, said in an interview that the study reflects trends that she and her colleagues see in clinic: There are more common skin conditions in their patients with obesity.
She agreed that it offers an opening for education. “The results of this study highlight the opportunity we have as pediatric dermatologists to provide additional counseling on obesity and offer referrals to our colleagues in endocrinology, gastroenterology, and nutrition if needed.”
No conflicts of interest were reported.
FROM SPD 2024
Topical Ruxolitinib: Analysis Finds Repigmentation Rates in Adolescents with Vitiligo
data showed.
“We consider repigmenting vitiligo a two-step process, where the overactive immune system needs to be calmed down and then the melanocytes need to repopulate to the white areas,” one of the study investigators, David Rosmarin, MD, chair of the Department of Dermatology at Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, said in an interview in advance of the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology, where the study results were presented during a poster session. “In younger patients, it may be that the melanocytes are more rapidly repigmenting the patches, which is why we see this effect.”
Ruxolitinib, 1.5% cream (Opzelura) is a Janus kinase inhibitor approved for the treatment of nonsegmental vitiligo in patients 12 years of age and older. Dr. Rosmarin and colleagues sought to evaluate differences in rates of complete or near-complete repigmentation and repigmentation by body region between adolescents 12-17 years of age and adults 18 years of age and older who applied ruxolitinib cream twice daily. The researchers evaluated patients who were initially randomized to ruxolitinib cream, 1.5% in the pivotal TRuE-V1 and TRuE-V2 studies and applied it for up to 104 weeks. Complete facial improvement was defined as 100% improvement on the Facial Vitiligo Area Scoring Index (F-VASI 100) from baseline, and near-total improvement was categorized as a ≥ 75% or ≥ 90% improvement from baseline on the Total body VASI (T-VASI). Responses for each of six body regions, excluding the face, were assessed by the proportion of patients who achieved at least a 50% improvement from baseline on the T-VASI.
Compared with adults, a greater proportion of adolescents achieved F-VASI 100 at week 24 (5.7% [3/53] vs 2.9% [10/341], respectively), but there were no differences between the two groups at week 52 (8.0% [4/50] vs 8.0% [24/300]). Response rates were greater among adolescents vs adults for T-VASI 75 at weeks 24 (13.2% [7/53] vs 5.6% [19/341]) and 52 (22.0% [11/50] vs 20.3% [61/300]), as well as T-VASI 90 at weeks 24 (3.8% [2/53] vs 0.3% [1/341]) and 52 (12.0% [6/50] vs 4.0% [12/300]).
The researchers observed that VASI 50 responses by body region were generally similar between adolescents and adults, but a greater proportion of adolescents achieved a VASI 50 in lower extremities (67.3% [33/49] vs 51.8% [118/228]) and feet (37.5% [12/32] vs 27.9% [51/183]) at week 52.
“Adolescents repigmented more rapidly than adults, so that at 24 weeks, more teens had complete facial repigmentation and T-VASI 75 and T-VASI 90 results,” Dr. Rosmarin said. “With continued use of ruxolitinib cream, both more adults and adolescents achieved greater repigmentation.” He acknowledged certain limitations of the study, including the fact that it was only vehicle controlled up through 24 weeks and that, after week 52, there were fewer patients who completed the long-term extension.
“The take-home message is that ruxolitinib cream can effectively and safely help many patients repigment, including adolescents,” he said.
The study was funded by topical ruxolitinib manufacturer Incyte. Dr. Rosmarin disclosed that he has consulted, spoken for, or conducted trials for AbbVie, Abcuro, Almirall, AltruBio, Amgen, Arena, Astria, Boehringer Ingelheim, Bristol Meyers Squibb, Celgene, Concert, CSL Behring, Dermavant Sciences, Dermira, Galderma, Incyte, Janssen, Kyowa Kirin, Lilly, Merck, Nektar, Novartis, Pfizer, RAPT, Regeneron, Recludix Pharma, Revolo Biotherapeutics, Sanofi, Sun Pharmaceuticals, UCB, Viela Bio, and Zura.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
data showed.
“We consider repigmenting vitiligo a two-step process, where the overactive immune system needs to be calmed down and then the melanocytes need to repopulate to the white areas,” one of the study investigators, David Rosmarin, MD, chair of the Department of Dermatology at Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, said in an interview in advance of the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology, where the study results were presented during a poster session. “In younger patients, it may be that the melanocytes are more rapidly repigmenting the patches, which is why we see this effect.”
Ruxolitinib, 1.5% cream (Opzelura) is a Janus kinase inhibitor approved for the treatment of nonsegmental vitiligo in patients 12 years of age and older. Dr. Rosmarin and colleagues sought to evaluate differences in rates of complete or near-complete repigmentation and repigmentation by body region between adolescents 12-17 years of age and adults 18 years of age and older who applied ruxolitinib cream twice daily. The researchers evaluated patients who were initially randomized to ruxolitinib cream, 1.5% in the pivotal TRuE-V1 and TRuE-V2 studies and applied it for up to 104 weeks. Complete facial improvement was defined as 100% improvement on the Facial Vitiligo Area Scoring Index (F-VASI 100) from baseline, and near-total improvement was categorized as a ≥ 75% or ≥ 90% improvement from baseline on the Total body VASI (T-VASI). Responses for each of six body regions, excluding the face, were assessed by the proportion of patients who achieved at least a 50% improvement from baseline on the T-VASI.
Compared with adults, a greater proportion of adolescents achieved F-VASI 100 at week 24 (5.7% [3/53] vs 2.9% [10/341], respectively), but there were no differences between the two groups at week 52 (8.0% [4/50] vs 8.0% [24/300]). Response rates were greater among adolescents vs adults for T-VASI 75 at weeks 24 (13.2% [7/53] vs 5.6% [19/341]) and 52 (22.0% [11/50] vs 20.3% [61/300]), as well as T-VASI 90 at weeks 24 (3.8% [2/53] vs 0.3% [1/341]) and 52 (12.0% [6/50] vs 4.0% [12/300]).
The researchers observed that VASI 50 responses by body region were generally similar between adolescents and adults, but a greater proportion of adolescents achieved a VASI 50 in lower extremities (67.3% [33/49] vs 51.8% [118/228]) and feet (37.5% [12/32] vs 27.9% [51/183]) at week 52.
“Adolescents repigmented more rapidly than adults, so that at 24 weeks, more teens had complete facial repigmentation and T-VASI 75 and T-VASI 90 results,” Dr. Rosmarin said. “With continued use of ruxolitinib cream, both more adults and adolescents achieved greater repigmentation.” He acknowledged certain limitations of the study, including the fact that it was only vehicle controlled up through 24 weeks and that, after week 52, there were fewer patients who completed the long-term extension.
“The take-home message is that ruxolitinib cream can effectively and safely help many patients repigment, including adolescents,” he said.
The study was funded by topical ruxolitinib manufacturer Incyte. Dr. Rosmarin disclosed that he has consulted, spoken for, or conducted trials for AbbVie, Abcuro, Almirall, AltruBio, Amgen, Arena, Astria, Boehringer Ingelheim, Bristol Meyers Squibb, Celgene, Concert, CSL Behring, Dermavant Sciences, Dermira, Galderma, Incyte, Janssen, Kyowa Kirin, Lilly, Merck, Nektar, Novartis, Pfizer, RAPT, Regeneron, Recludix Pharma, Revolo Biotherapeutics, Sanofi, Sun Pharmaceuticals, UCB, Viela Bio, and Zura.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
data showed.
“We consider repigmenting vitiligo a two-step process, where the overactive immune system needs to be calmed down and then the melanocytes need to repopulate to the white areas,” one of the study investigators, David Rosmarin, MD, chair of the Department of Dermatology at Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, said in an interview in advance of the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology, where the study results were presented during a poster session. “In younger patients, it may be that the melanocytes are more rapidly repigmenting the patches, which is why we see this effect.”
Ruxolitinib, 1.5% cream (Opzelura) is a Janus kinase inhibitor approved for the treatment of nonsegmental vitiligo in patients 12 years of age and older. Dr. Rosmarin and colleagues sought to evaluate differences in rates of complete or near-complete repigmentation and repigmentation by body region between adolescents 12-17 years of age and adults 18 years of age and older who applied ruxolitinib cream twice daily. The researchers evaluated patients who were initially randomized to ruxolitinib cream, 1.5% in the pivotal TRuE-V1 and TRuE-V2 studies and applied it for up to 104 weeks. Complete facial improvement was defined as 100% improvement on the Facial Vitiligo Area Scoring Index (F-VASI 100) from baseline, and near-total improvement was categorized as a ≥ 75% or ≥ 90% improvement from baseline on the Total body VASI (T-VASI). Responses for each of six body regions, excluding the face, were assessed by the proportion of patients who achieved at least a 50% improvement from baseline on the T-VASI.
Compared with adults, a greater proportion of adolescents achieved F-VASI 100 at week 24 (5.7% [3/53] vs 2.9% [10/341], respectively), but there were no differences between the two groups at week 52 (8.0% [4/50] vs 8.0% [24/300]). Response rates were greater among adolescents vs adults for T-VASI 75 at weeks 24 (13.2% [7/53] vs 5.6% [19/341]) and 52 (22.0% [11/50] vs 20.3% [61/300]), as well as T-VASI 90 at weeks 24 (3.8% [2/53] vs 0.3% [1/341]) and 52 (12.0% [6/50] vs 4.0% [12/300]).
The researchers observed that VASI 50 responses by body region were generally similar between adolescents and adults, but a greater proportion of adolescents achieved a VASI 50 in lower extremities (67.3% [33/49] vs 51.8% [118/228]) and feet (37.5% [12/32] vs 27.9% [51/183]) at week 52.
“Adolescents repigmented more rapidly than adults, so that at 24 weeks, more teens had complete facial repigmentation and T-VASI 75 and T-VASI 90 results,” Dr. Rosmarin said. “With continued use of ruxolitinib cream, both more adults and adolescents achieved greater repigmentation.” He acknowledged certain limitations of the study, including the fact that it was only vehicle controlled up through 24 weeks and that, after week 52, there were fewer patients who completed the long-term extension.
“The take-home message is that ruxolitinib cream can effectively and safely help many patients repigment, including adolescents,” he said.
The study was funded by topical ruxolitinib manufacturer Incyte. Dr. Rosmarin disclosed that he has consulted, spoken for, or conducted trials for AbbVie, Abcuro, Almirall, AltruBio, Amgen, Arena, Astria, Boehringer Ingelheim, Bristol Meyers Squibb, Celgene, Concert, CSL Behring, Dermavant Sciences, Dermira, Galderma, Incyte, Janssen, Kyowa Kirin, Lilly, Merck, Nektar, Novartis, Pfizer, RAPT, Regeneron, Recludix Pharma, Revolo Biotherapeutics, Sanofi, Sun Pharmaceuticals, UCB, Viela Bio, and Zura.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
FROM SPD 2024