User login
Grandmothers, the Friendship Bench, and wisdom
Is this model a blueprint for delivering mental health care?
The 4-year-old boy and his grandmother are out for stroll around the neighborhood, walking hand in hand.
“Let’s sit on the bench and talk,” the boy says.
“Okay,” says the grandmother and they climb up onto the high bench and look out across the quiet road to a small garden beyond.
“What would you like to talk about?” his grandmother asks.
“You first,” he says.
“Okay, let’s see ... the grandmother and the grandson are out for a walk and they see a bench to sit on. They climb up and look around. They see the daffodils and the white clouds in the blue sky. The breeze is blowing gently. It is a happy day. Your turn; what would you like to talk about?”
“Nanna and Papa.”
“Do you miss Papa?”
“Yes.”
“It has been a whole year since he died.”
“A long, long time.”
“He loved you very much.”
“Yes,” the boy replies.
“Nanna must miss him very much. She must be lonely without him.”
The boy nods.
They sit on for a while, watching the occasional car and the occasional bird pass by. The boy and the grandmother are quiet and contemplative.
“Okay, let’s go,” he says and jumps down, ready to continue their walk.
The Friendship Bench
It must have been such an experience that gave Dixon Chibanda, MD, MPH, PhD, a psychiatrist from Zimbabwe, his brilliant idea. He trained grandmothers in evidence-based talk therapy and sat them on a bench in the park with his patients.1,2 He founded the Friendship Bench in 2006 in the Harare township of Mbare with 14 grandmothers. There are more than 300 grandmothers sitting on benches, listening, and providing cognitive-behavioral therapy–informed interventions because he could find no therapists in the community and he found that, with a little training, these grandmothers could provide effective culturally sensitive interventions.
Originally, the sessions were conducted in Shona, the predominant native language in Zimbabwe, but since 2017, the sessions are also in English. By 2017, the Friendship Bench had helped more than 30,000 people. The method has been empirically vetted and expanded to countries beyond, including the United States. Dr. Chibanda’s Friendship Bench serves as a blueprint for any community interested in bringing affordable, accessible, and highly effective mental health services to its residents. Dr. Chibanda said: “Imagine if we could create a global network of grandmothers in every major city in the world.”3 Participants in this study reported that the Friendship Bench had a critical role in helping them accept their HIV status, citing the grandmothers’ empathic attitude, their normalization of the reality of living with HIV, and their encouragement of young people to socialize with peers and be free of guilt. Many recipients also described enhanced health and well-being.
Why grandmothers?
Have you heard of the evolutionary importance of grandmothers? The grandmother hypothesis is an adaptationist explanation for the fact that the human female lifespan extends beyond the period of fertility. A third of the average human female life span is post menopause. Does such a long female postreproductive life span have a reason, inquired Mwenza Blell, PhD.5
Peter B. Medawar, PhD,6 and Kristen Hawkes, PhD,7 suggested that grandparents influence their own fitness by their actions toward their grandchildren. International fieldwork has revealed that the situation is less clear than their hypothesis. In industrialized countries, grandmaternal support is often financial or emotional. Two meta-analyses of largely the same group of studies investigating grandmother effects have come up with differing conclusions. Rebecca Sear, PhD, and Ruth Mace, PhD, conclude that grandmothers are “almost universally” beneficial, while acknowledging some variation in the effects of paternal grandmothers.8 Maternal grandparents appear to invest more in their grandchildren than paternal grandparents. Beverly I. Strassmann, PhD, and Wendy M. Garrard, PhD, concluded that, in patrilineal societies, survival of maternal grandparents is associated with survival of grandchildren and suggest this may represent covert matriliny.9
Examining specific time periods, maternal grandmothers may have greatest effect on survival of grandchildren at the time of weaning, a time when increased pathogenic exposure is a threat to survival. Paternal grandmothers may influence the survival of grandchildren during the early period of life (1-12 months) and to influence the condition of their daughters-in-law during pregnancy. The fact that grandmothers share one X chromosome with their sons’ daughters, none with their sons’ sons, and have a 50% chance of sharing an X chromosome with their daughters’ children is suggested to explain the patterns of survival observed in these studies than a simple maternal/paternal division.
In low- and middle-income countries, grandmothers and older women are seen as owners of traditional knowledge, and influence many decisions about childcare, help with domestic work, and emotional support and advice.10 Studies find a significant positive impact on breastfeeding when grandmothers of the infants had their own breastfeeding experience or were positively inclined toward breastfeeding, although one Chinese study found that highly educated grandmothers were associated with decreased exclusive breastfeeding.11 Despite this, most health programs target individual new mothers, without an understanding of the family and who else influences decisions.
Grandchildren and grandparents benefit from intergenerational activities with improved health and well-being of both generations. When older adults are involved in raising children, there is a significant reduction in the incidence of behavioral problems in childhood and adolescence. Grandparents improve grandchild outcomes, when measured by coresidence, caregiving, financial, and other support. The grandchild outcomes include physical health, socioemotional well-being, and cognitive development.12
Are there ‘grandparent genes?’
Flavio Schwarz, PhD, and colleagues think that variants of APOE and CD33 protect against heart disease and Alzheimer’s disease, allowing older people to live longer with better functioning hearts and brains – thus enabling transfer of wisdom from older to younger generations.13 While this logic may be a bit of a stretch, it does lead to a more interesting question: What has wisdom got to do with it?
When I ask psychiatrists what they think about wisdom, they give a variety of answers. Dilip Jeste, MD, a geriatric psychiatrist who studies successful aging, helped develop a measurable vision of wisdom.14 Wisdom is defined as a “multidimensional human trait that includes good social decision-making and pragmatic knowledge of life, prosocial attitudes and behaviors such as empathy and compassion, emotional homeostasis with a tendency to favor positive emotions, reflection and self-understanding, acknowledgment of and coping effectively with uncertainty, and decisiveness.”15 Others suggest that they include spirituality, openness to new experience, and a sense of humor.16 A scale called the San Diego Wisdom scale (SD-WISE) was created, using 524 community-dwelling adults aged 25-104 years. These subjects comprised a high proportion of White adults and individuals with a higher education, thus lacking diversity. Lack of diversity perpetuates generalizations, and like all sociocultural constructs, truth is specific to the population studied. High scores on the SD-WISE are positively correlated with good mental health, self-ratings of successful aging, mastery, resilience, happiness, and satisfaction with life.
Which brings us back to the grandmothers on the bench: Can someone please give them the SD-WISE scale and confirm several hypotheses? I would like to know whether a pragmatic knowledge of life is a recognized grandmotherly quality, suitable for the bench.
Dr. Heru is professor of psychiatry at the University of Colorado at Denver, Aurora. She is editor of “Working With Families in Medical Settings: A Multidisciplinary Guide for Psychiatrists and Other Health Professionals” (New York: Routledge, 2013). She has no conflicts of interest.
References
1. Chibanda D. Bull World Health Organ. 2018 Jun 196(6):376-7.
2. Cavanaugh R. Lancet Psychiatry. 2017 Nov. doi: 10.1016/S2215-0366(17)30420-0.
3. Nuwer R. “How a bench and a team of grandmothers can tackle depression.” BBC. 2020 May 27.
4. Ouansafi I et al. PLoS One. 2021 Apr 22;16(4):e0250074.
5. Blell M. “Grandmother hypothesis, grandmother effect, and residence patterns.” Int Encyclopedia Anthropol. John Wiley & Sons, 2018.
6. Medawar PB. An Unsolved Problem of Biology. Routledge, 1957.
7. Hawkes K et al. Proc Nat Acad Sci. 1998 Feb 395(3):1336-9.
8. Sear R and Mace R. Evol Hum Behav. 2008;29(1):1-18.
9. Strassmann B and Garrard WM. Hum Nat. 2011 Jul;22(1-2):201-22.
10. Aubel J. BMJ Glob Health. 2021;6(2). doi 10.1136/bmjgh-2020-003808.
11. Negin J et al. BMJ Pregnancy Childbirth. 2016 Apr 7. doi: 10.1186/s12884-016-0880-5.
12. Sadruddin AFA. Soc Sci Med. 2019 Aug;239(4):112476.
13. Schwarz F et al. Proc Nat Acad Sci. 2016 Jan 5;113(1):74-9.
14. Jeste DV et al. Psychol Inquiry. 2020 Jun 22;31(2):134-43.
15. Meeks TW and Jeste DV. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2009 Apr;66(4):355-65.
16. Bangen KJ et al. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2013 Dec;21(12):1254-66.
Is this model a blueprint for delivering mental health care?
Is this model a blueprint for delivering mental health care?
The 4-year-old boy and his grandmother are out for stroll around the neighborhood, walking hand in hand.
“Let’s sit on the bench and talk,” the boy says.
“Okay,” says the grandmother and they climb up onto the high bench and look out across the quiet road to a small garden beyond.
“What would you like to talk about?” his grandmother asks.
“You first,” he says.
“Okay, let’s see ... the grandmother and the grandson are out for a walk and they see a bench to sit on. They climb up and look around. They see the daffodils and the white clouds in the blue sky. The breeze is blowing gently. It is a happy day. Your turn; what would you like to talk about?”
“Nanna and Papa.”
“Do you miss Papa?”
“Yes.”
“It has been a whole year since he died.”
“A long, long time.”
“He loved you very much.”
“Yes,” the boy replies.
“Nanna must miss him very much. She must be lonely without him.”
The boy nods.
They sit on for a while, watching the occasional car and the occasional bird pass by. The boy and the grandmother are quiet and contemplative.
“Okay, let’s go,” he says and jumps down, ready to continue their walk.
The Friendship Bench
It must have been such an experience that gave Dixon Chibanda, MD, MPH, PhD, a psychiatrist from Zimbabwe, his brilliant idea. He trained grandmothers in evidence-based talk therapy and sat them on a bench in the park with his patients.1,2 He founded the Friendship Bench in 2006 in the Harare township of Mbare with 14 grandmothers. There are more than 300 grandmothers sitting on benches, listening, and providing cognitive-behavioral therapy–informed interventions because he could find no therapists in the community and he found that, with a little training, these grandmothers could provide effective culturally sensitive interventions.
Originally, the sessions were conducted in Shona, the predominant native language in Zimbabwe, but since 2017, the sessions are also in English. By 2017, the Friendship Bench had helped more than 30,000 people. The method has been empirically vetted and expanded to countries beyond, including the United States. Dr. Chibanda’s Friendship Bench serves as a blueprint for any community interested in bringing affordable, accessible, and highly effective mental health services to its residents. Dr. Chibanda said: “Imagine if we could create a global network of grandmothers in every major city in the world.”3 Participants in this study reported that the Friendship Bench had a critical role in helping them accept their HIV status, citing the grandmothers’ empathic attitude, their normalization of the reality of living with HIV, and their encouragement of young people to socialize with peers and be free of guilt. Many recipients also described enhanced health and well-being.
Why grandmothers?
Have you heard of the evolutionary importance of grandmothers? The grandmother hypothesis is an adaptationist explanation for the fact that the human female lifespan extends beyond the period of fertility. A third of the average human female life span is post menopause. Does such a long female postreproductive life span have a reason, inquired Mwenza Blell, PhD.5
Peter B. Medawar, PhD,6 and Kristen Hawkes, PhD,7 suggested that grandparents influence their own fitness by their actions toward their grandchildren. International fieldwork has revealed that the situation is less clear than their hypothesis. In industrialized countries, grandmaternal support is often financial or emotional. Two meta-analyses of largely the same group of studies investigating grandmother effects have come up with differing conclusions. Rebecca Sear, PhD, and Ruth Mace, PhD, conclude that grandmothers are “almost universally” beneficial, while acknowledging some variation in the effects of paternal grandmothers.8 Maternal grandparents appear to invest more in their grandchildren than paternal grandparents. Beverly I. Strassmann, PhD, and Wendy M. Garrard, PhD, concluded that, in patrilineal societies, survival of maternal grandparents is associated with survival of grandchildren and suggest this may represent covert matriliny.9
Examining specific time periods, maternal grandmothers may have greatest effect on survival of grandchildren at the time of weaning, a time when increased pathogenic exposure is a threat to survival. Paternal grandmothers may influence the survival of grandchildren during the early period of life (1-12 months) and to influence the condition of their daughters-in-law during pregnancy. The fact that grandmothers share one X chromosome with their sons’ daughters, none with their sons’ sons, and have a 50% chance of sharing an X chromosome with their daughters’ children is suggested to explain the patterns of survival observed in these studies than a simple maternal/paternal division.
In low- and middle-income countries, grandmothers and older women are seen as owners of traditional knowledge, and influence many decisions about childcare, help with domestic work, and emotional support and advice.10 Studies find a significant positive impact on breastfeeding when grandmothers of the infants had their own breastfeeding experience or were positively inclined toward breastfeeding, although one Chinese study found that highly educated grandmothers were associated with decreased exclusive breastfeeding.11 Despite this, most health programs target individual new mothers, without an understanding of the family and who else influences decisions.
Grandchildren and grandparents benefit from intergenerational activities with improved health and well-being of both generations. When older adults are involved in raising children, there is a significant reduction in the incidence of behavioral problems in childhood and adolescence. Grandparents improve grandchild outcomes, when measured by coresidence, caregiving, financial, and other support. The grandchild outcomes include physical health, socioemotional well-being, and cognitive development.12
Are there ‘grandparent genes?’
Flavio Schwarz, PhD, and colleagues think that variants of APOE and CD33 protect against heart disease and Alzheimer’s disease, allowing older people to live longer with better functioning hearts and brains – thus enabling transfer of wisdom from older to younger generations.13 While this logic may be a bit of a stretch, it does lead to a more interesting question: What has wisdom got to do with it?
When I ask psychiatrists what they think about wisdom, they give a variety of answers. Dilip Jeste, MD, a geriatric psychiatrist who studies successful aging, helped develop a measurable vision of wisdom.14 Wisdom is defined as a “multidimensional human trait that includes good social decision-making and pragmatic knowledge of life, prosocial attitudes and behaviors such as empathy and compassion, emotional homeostasis with a tendency to favor positive emotions, reflection and self-understanding, acknowledgment of and coping effectively with uncertainty, and decisiveness.”15 Others suggest that they include spirituality, openness to new experience, and a sense of humor.16 A scale called the San Diego Wisdom scale (SD-WISE) was created, using 524 community-dwelling adults aged 25-104 years. These subjects comprised a high proportion of White adults and individuals with a higher education, thus lacking diversity. Lack of diversity perpetuates generalizations, and like all sociocultural constructs, truth is specific to the population studied. High scores on the SD-WISE are positively correlated with good mental health, self-ratings of successful aging, mastery, resilience, happiness, and satisfaction with life.
Which brings us back to the grandmothers on the bench: Can someone please give them the SD-WISE scale and confirm several hypotheses? I would like to know whether a pragmatic knowledge of life is a recognized grandmotherly quality, suitable for the bench.
Dr. Heru is professor of psychiatry at the University of Colorado at Denver, Aurora. She is editor of “Working With Families in Medical Settings: A Multidisciplinary Guide for Psychiatrists and Other Health Professionals” (New York: Routledge, 2013). She has no conflicts of interest.
References
1. Chibanda D. Bull World Health Organ. 2018 Jun 196(6):376-7.
2. Cavanaugh R. Lancet Psychiatry. 2017 Nov. doi: 10.1016/S2215-0366(17)30420-0.
3. Nuwer R. “How a bench and a team of grandmothers can tackle depression.” BBC. 2020 May 27.
4. Ouansafi I et al. PLoS One. 2021 Apr 22;16(4):e0250074.
5. Blell M. “Grandmother hypothesis, grandmother effect, and residence patterns.” Int Encyclopedia Anthropol. John Wiley & Sons, 2018.
6. Medawar PB. An Unsolved Problem of Biology. Routledge, 1957.
7. Hawkes K et al. Proc Nat Acad Sci. 1998 Feb 395(3):1336-9.
8. Sear R and Mace R. Evol Hum Behav. 2008;29(1):1-18.
9. Strassmann B and Garrard WM. Hum Nat. 2011 Jul;22(1-2):201-22.
10. Aubel J. BMJ Glob Health. 2021;6(2). doi 10.1136/bmjgh-2020-003808.
11. Negin J et al. BMJ Pregnancy Childbirth. 2016 Apr 7. doi: 10.1186/s12884-016-0880-5.
12. Sadruddin AFA. Soc Sci Med. 2019 Aug;239(4):112476.
13. Schwarz F et al. Proc Nat Acad Sci. 2016 Jan 5;113(1):74-9.
14. Jeste DV et al. Psychol Inquiry. 2020 Jun 22;31(2):134-43.
15. Meeks TW and Jeste DV. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2009 Apr;66(4):355-65.
16. Bangen KJ et al. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2013 Dec;21(12):1254-66.
The 4-year-old boy and his grandmother are out for stroll around the neighborhood, walking hand in hand.
“Let’s sit on the bench and talk,” the boy says.
“Okay,” says the grandmother and they climb up onto the high bench and look out across the quiet road to a small garden beyond.
“What would you like to talk about?” his grandmother asks.
“You first,” he says.
“Okay, let’s see ... the grandmother and the grandson are out for a walk and they see a bench to sit on. They climb up and look around. They see the daffodils and the white clouds in the blue sky. The breeze is blowing gently. It is a happy day. Your turn; what would you like to talk about?”
“Nanna and Papa.”
“Do you miss Papa?”
“Yes.”
“It has been a whole year since he died.”
“A long, long time.”
“He loved you very much.”
“Yes,” the boy replies.
“Nanna must miss him very much. She must be lonely without him.”
The boy nods.
They sit on for a while, watching the occasional car and the occasional bird pass by. The boy and the grandmother are quiet and contemplative.
“Okay, let’s go,” he says and jumps down, ready to continue their walk.
The Friendship Bench
It must have been such an experience that gave Dixon Chibanda, MD, MPH, PhD, a psychiatrist from Zimbabwe, his brilliant idea. He trained grandmothers in evidence-based talk therapy and sat them on a bench in the park with his patients.1,2 He founded the Friendship Bench in 2006 in the Harare township of Mbare with 14 grandmothers. There are more than 300 grandmothers sitting on benches, listening, and providing cognitive-behavioral therapy–informed interventions because he could find no therapists in the community and he found that, with a little training, these grandmothers could provide effective culturally sensitive interventions.
Originally, the sessions were conducted in Shona, the predominant native language in Zimbabwe, but since 2017, the sessions are also in English. By 2017, the Friendship Bench had helped more than 30,000 people. The method has been empirically vetted and expanded to countries beyond, including the United States. Dr. Chibanda’s Friendship Bench serves as a blueprint for any community interested in bringing affordable, accessible, and highly effective mental health services to its residents. Dr. Chibanda said: “Imagine if we could create a global network of grandmothers in every major city in the world.”3 Participants in this study reported that the Friendship Bench had a critical role in helping them accept their HIV status, citing the grandmothers’ empathic attitude, their normalization of the reality of living with HIV, and their encouragement of young people to socialize with peers and be free of guilt. Many recipients also described enhanced health and well-being.
Why grandmothers?
Have you heard of the evolutionary importance of grandmothers? The grandmother hypothesis is an adaptationist explanation for the fact that the human female lifespan extends beyond the period of fertility. A third of the average human female life span is post menopause. Does such a long female postreproductive life span have a reason, inquired Mwenza Blell, PhD.5
Peter B. Medawar, PhD,6 and Kristen Hawkes, PhD,7 suggested that grandparents influence their own fitness by their actions toward their grandchildren. International fieldwork has revealed that the situation is less clear than their hypothesis. In industrialized countries, grandmaternal support is often financial or emotional. Two meta-analyses of largely the same group of studies investigating grandmother effects have come up with differing conclusions. Rebecca Sear, PhD, and Ruth Mace, PhD, conclude that grandmothers are “almost universally” beneficial, while acknowledging some variation in the effects of paternal grandmothers.8 Maternal grandparents appear to invest more in their grandchildren than paternal grandparents. Beverly I. Strassmann, PhD, and Wendy M. Garrard, PhD, concluded that, in patrilineal societies, survival of maternal grandparents is associated with survival of grandchildren and suggest this may represent covert matriliny.9
Examining specific time periods, maternal grandmothers may have greatest effect on survival of grandchildren at the time of weaning, a time when increased pathogenic exposure is a threat to survival. Paternal grandmothers may influence the survival of grandchildren during the early period of life (1-12 months) and to influence the condition of their daughters-in-law during pregnancy. The fact that grandmothers share one X chromosome with their sons’ daughters, none with their sons’ sons, and have a 50% chance of sharing an X chromosome with their daughters’ children is suggested to explain the patterns of survival observed in these studies than a simple maternal/paternal division.
In low- and middle-income countries, grandmothers and older women are seen as owners of traditional knowledge, and influence many decisions about childcare, help with domestic work, and emotional support and advice.10 Studies find a significant positive impact on breastfeeding when grandmothers of the infants had their own breastfeeding experience or were positively inclined toward breastfeeding, although one Chinese study found that highly educated grandmothers were associated with decreased exclusive breastfeeding.11 Despite this, most health programs target individual new mothers, without an understanding of the family and who else influences decisions.
Grandchildren and grandparents benefit from intergenerational activities with improved health and well-being of both generations. When older adults are involved in raising children, there is a significant reduction in the incidence of behavioral problems in childhood and adolescence. Grandparents improve grandchild outcomes, when measured by coresidence, caregiving, financial, and other support. The grandchild outcomes include physical health, socioemotional well-being, and cognitive development.12
Are there ‘grandparent genes?’
Flavio Schwarz, PhD, and colleagues think that variants of APOE and CD33 protect against heart disease and Alzheimer’s disease, allowing older people to live longer with better functioning hearts and brains – thus enabling transfer of wisdom from older to younger generations.13 While this logic may be a bit of a stretch, it does lead to a more interesting question: What has wisdom got to do with it?
When I ask psychiatrists what they think about wisdom, they give a variety of answers. Dilip Jeste, MD, a geriatric psychiatrist who studies successful aging, helped develop a measurable vision of wisdom.14 Wisdom is defined as a “multidimensional human trait that includes good social decision-making and pragmatic knowledge of life, prosocial attitudes and behaviors such as empathy and compassion, emotional homeostasis with a tendency to favor positive emotions, reflection and self-understanding, acknowledgment of and coping effectively with uncertainty, and decisiveness.”15 Others suggest that they include spirituality, openness to new experience, and a sense of humor.16 A scale called the San Diego Wisdom scale (SD-WISE) was created, using 524 community-dwelling adults aged 25-104 years. These subjects comprised a high proportion of White adults and individuals with a higher education, thus lacking diversity. Lack of diversity perpetuates generalizations, and like all sociocultural constructs, truth is specific to the population studied. High scores on the SD-WISE are positively correlated with good mental health, self-ratings of successful aging, mastery, resilience, happiness, and satisfaction with life.
Which brings us back to the grandmothers on the bench: Can someone please give them the SD-WISE scale and confirm several hypotheses? I would like to know whether a pragmatic knowledge of life is a recognized grandmotherly quality, suitable for the bench.
Dr. Heru is professor of psychiatry at the University of Colorado at Denver, Aurora. She is editor of “Working With Families in Medical Settings: A Multidisciplinary Guide for Psychiatrists and Other Health Professionals” (New York: Routledge, 2013). She has no conflicts of interest.
References
1. Chibanda D. Bull World Health Organ. 2018 Jun 196(6):376-7.
2. Cavanaugh R. Lancet Psychiatry. 2017 Nov. doi: 10.1016/S2215-0366(17)30420-0.
3. Nuwer R. “How a bench and a team of grandmothers can tackle depression.” BBC. 2020 May 27.
4. Ouansafi I et al. PLoS One. 2021 Apr 22;16(4):e0250074.
5. Blell M. “Grandmother hypothesis, grandmother effect, and residence patterns.” Int Encyclopedia Anthropol. John Wiley & Sons, 2018.
6. Medawar PB. An Unsolved Problem of Biology. Routledge, 1957.
7. Hawkes K et al. Proc Nat Acad Sci. 1998 Feb 395(3):1336-9.
8. Sear R and Mace R. Evol Hum Behav. 2008;29(1):1-18.
9. Strassmann B and Garrard WM. Hum Nat. 2011 Jul;22(1-2):201-22.
10. Aubel J. BMJ Glob Health. 2021;6(2). doi 10.1136/bmjgh-2020-003808.
11. Negin J et al. BMJ Pregnancy Childbirth. 2016 Apr 7. doi: 10.1186/s12884-016-0880-5.
12. Sadruddin AFA. Soc Sci Med. 2019 Aug;239(4):112476.
13. Schwarz F et al. Proc Nat Acad Sci. 2016 Jan 5;113(1):74-9.
14. Jeste DV et al. Psychol Inquiry. 2020 Jun 22;31(2):134-43.
15. Meeks TW and Jeste DV. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2009 Apr;66(4):355-65.
16. Bangen KJ et al. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2013 Dec;21(12):1254-66.
Animal-assisted therapy could boost patients’ mental health
For me, vacation planning brings with it a bit of anxiety and stress – particularly as we navigate the many uncertainties around COVID-19.
Not only must my husband and I think about our own safety, we also have to make sure that our beloved dog, Samson, gets the proper care while we are away.
My husband adopted Samson, an 11-year-old mixed-breed rescue, when he was just a year old. He’s an important part of our family.
So, when booking our hotel room and flights, we also had to find someone we trust to care for Samson in our absence. Family members are not always an option, so we often rely on pet-sitting apps. We looked through profile after profile, contacted sitters, and interrogated them as if we were looking for care for a tiny human.
Eventually, we found a service that allows owners to use a mobile app that provides updates about how their pets are faring. While we were away, the sitter sent daily photos and videos of Samson that put our minds at ease.
As a registered nurse who works in an ICU, my own anxiety about leaving Samson reminded me about my patients’ reservations about leaving their pets during hospitalizations. Many of them share the same kinds of anxieties when they are separated from their beloved pets. Hospital visits are rarely planned. I have cared for patients who expressed concerns about their pets being home alone and needing to coordinate pet care. In some cases – to alleviate those patients’ anxieties – I have helped them contact friends and family members to assist with care.
Pets’ popularity grows in U.S.
According to the 2019-2020 National Pet Owners Survey, about 67% of U.S. households own a pet – which translates to about 84.9 million homes. During the height of COVID, Americans also acquired a greater number of smaller pets.1 In addition, when social restrictions increased, the demand for dog adoptions and the desire to serve as foster owners rose significantly.2 Last Chance Animal Rescue of Waldorf, Md., reportedly saw the adoption of dogs rise from 30%-40% in 2020. Another animal rescue operation, Lucky Dog, of Arlington, Va., in 2020 helped about 3,385 pets find adoption, up from about 1,800 in 2019.3 About two-thirds of all American households and roughly half of elderly individuals own pets.4
I am not surprised by those numbers. In my nursing practice, I face many stress-related factors, such as alternating day and night shifts, 12-hour shifts, strenuous physical work, and the psychological strain of attending to ill and dying patients. Interacting with Samson helps relieve that stress. The motion of petting Samson helps calm my heart rate and decreases my anxiety. In addition, Samson makes me smile – and excites almost all the people I interact with while he’s around. Of course, I’m not objective, but I view Samson’s impact on people as a symbol of the power of animal-assisted therapy (AAT).
AAT, defined as “the positive interaction between an animal and a patient within a therapeutic framework,”has proven to be an effective intervention for adults with intellectual disabilities who experience anxiety in an observational study.5 The intervention also has helped reduce cortisol levels in a study of nurses in physical medicine, internal medicine, and long-term care.6 Since most patient hospital stays are unplanned, there is a need to introduce AAT into hospital care. This would lessen anxiety in patients concerning their pets’ welfare.
We know that long-term hospital stays often cause adverse psychosocial effects on patients. Such stays can result in “hospitalization syndrome,” which is characterized by a gradual loss of cognition and orientation, an unwillingness to maintain contact with others or to engage in group therapy, and a loss of interest in their surroundings.7 The common causes for this syndrome are infection, medication, isolation, response to surgery, and dehydration. A consequence can be a permanent change in cognitive function or psychological impairment. However, my experience of practicing nursing for years has led me to discover that pets as an external stimulus can prevent the syndrome’s onset. This is because a large percentage of hospitalized patients have pets, and contact with a pet reminds them of home and the memories they share at home.
Introducing animal therapy into health care facilities could boost patients’ mental health – and ease their anxiety – by acting as a bridge between their present circumstances and the lives they have outside the establishment.
References
1. American Pet Owners Association. Will the COVID Pet Spike Last? State of the industry presentation. 2021 Mar 24.
2. Morgan L et al. Humanit Soc Sci Comm. 2020 Nov 24;7(144). doi: 10.1057/S41599-020-00649-x.
3. Hedgpeth D. So many pets have been adopted during the pandemic that shelters are running out. Washington Post. 2021 Jan 6.
4. Cherniack EP and Cherniack AR. Curr Gerontol Geriatr Res. 2014. doi: 10.1155/2014/623203.
5. Giuliani F and Jacquemettaz M. Eur J Integ Med. 2017 Sep;14;13-9.
6. Machová K et al. Int J Environ Res and Public Health. 2019 Oct;16(19):3670.
7. Machová K et al. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2012 Apr;16(8):1362.
Ms. Scott is a registered nurse specializing in critical care and also has experience in nursing leadership. She has 8 years of experience in cardiothoracic ICUs. Ms. Scott received a bachelor of science in nursing degree from Queens University of Charlotte (N.C.), and a master of business administration in health care administration from the University of North Alabama, Florence. She has no conflicts of interest.
For me, vacation planning brings with it a bit of anxiety and stress – particularly as we navigate the many uncertainties around COVID-19.
Not only must my husband and I think about our own safety, we also have to make sure that our beloved dog, Samson, gets the proper care while we are away.
My husband adopted Samson, an 11-year-old mixed-breed rescue, when he was just a year old. He’s an important part of our family.
So, when booking our hotel room and flights, we also had to find someone we trust to care for Samson in our absence. Family members are not always an option, so we often rely on pet-sitting apps. We looked through profile after profile, contacted sitters, and interrogated them as if we were looking for care for a tiny human.
Eventually, we found a service that allows owners to use a mobile app that provides updates about how their pets are faring. While we were away, the sitter sent daily photos and videos of Samson that put our minds at ease.
As a registered nurse who works in an ICU, my own anxiety about leaving Samson reminded me about my patients’ reservations about leaving their pets during hospitalizations. Many of them share the same kinds of anxieties when they are separated from their beloved pets. Hospital visits are rarely planned. I have cared for patients who expressed concerns about their pets being home alone and needing to coordinate pet care. In some cases – to alleviate those patients’ anxieties – I have helped them contact friends and family members to assist with care.
Pets’ popularity grows in U.S.
According to the 2019-2020 National Pet Owners Survey, about 67% of U.S. households own a pet – which translates to about 84.9 million homes. During the height of COVID, Americans also acquired a greater number of smaller pets.1 In addition, when social restrictions increased, the demand for dog adoptions and the desire to serve as foster owners rose significantly.2 Last Chance Animal Rescue of Waldorf, Md., reportedly saw the adoption of dogs rise from 30%-40% in 2020. Another animal rescue operation, Lucky Dog, of Arlington, Va., in 2020 helped about 3,385 pets find adoption, up from about 1,800 in 2019.3 About two-thirds of all American households and roughly half of elderly individuals own pets.4
I am not surprised by those numbers. In my nursing practice, I face many stress-related factors, such as alternating day and night shifts, 12-hour shifts, strenuous physical work, and the psychological strain of attending to ill and dying patients. Interacting with Samson helps relieve that stress. The motion of petting Samson helps calm my heart rate and decreases my anxiety. In addition, Samson makes me smile – and excites almost all the people I interact with while he’s around. Of course, I’m not objective, but I view Samson’s impact on people as a symbol of the power of animal-assisted therapy (AAT).
AAT, defined as “the positive interaction between an animal and a patient within a therapeutic framework,”has proven to be an effective intervention for adults with intellectual disabilities who experience anxiety in an observational study.5 The intervention also has helped reduce cortisol levels in a study of nurses in physical medicine, internal medicine, and long-term care.6 Since most patient hospital stays are unplanned, there is a need to introduce AAT into hospital care. This would lessen anxiety in patients concerning their pets’ welfare.
We know that long-term hospital stays often cause adverse psychosocial effects on patients. Such stays can result in “hospitalization syndrome,” which is characterized by a gradual loss of cognition and orientation, an unwillingness to maintain contact with others or to engage in group therapy, and a loss of interest in their surroundings.7 The common causes for this syndrome are infection, medication, isolation, response to surgery, and dehydration. A consequence can be a permanent change in cognitive function or psychological impairment. However, my experience of practicing nursing for years has led me to discover that pets as an external stimulus can prevent the syndrome’s onset. This is because a large percentage of hospitalized patients have pets, and contact with a pet reminds them of home and the memories they share at home.
Introducing animal therapy into health care facilities could boost patients’ mental health – and ease their anxiety – by acting as a bridge between their present circumstances and the lives they have outside the establishment.
References
1. American Pet Owners Association. Will the COVID Pet Spike Last? State of the industry presentation. 2021 Mar 24.
2. Morgan L et al. Humanit Soc Sci Comm. 2020 Nov 24;7(144). doi: 10.1057/S41599-020-00649-x.
3. Hedgpeth D. So many pets have been adopted during the pandemic that shelters are running out. Washington Post. 2021 Jan 6.
4. Cherniack EP and Cherniack AR. Curr Gerontol Geriatr Res. 2014. doi: 10.1155/2014/623203.
5. Giuliani F and Jacquemettaz M. Eur J Integ Med. 2017 Sep;14;13-9.
6. Machová K et al. Int J Environ Res and Public Health. 2019 Oct;16(19):3670.
7. Machová K et al. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2012 Apr;16(8):1362.
Ms. Scott is a registered nurse specializing in critical care and also has experience in nursing leadership. She has 8 years of experience in cardiothoracic ICUs. Ms. Scott received a bachelor of science in nursing degree from Queens University of Charlotte (N.C.), and a master of business administration in health care administration from the University of North Alabama, Florence. She has no conflicts of interest.
For me, vacation planning brings with it a bit of anxiety and stress – particularly as we navigate the many uncertainties around COVID-19.
Not only must my husband and I think about our own safety, we also have to make sure that our beloved dog, Samson, gets the proper care while we are away.
My husband adopted Samson, an 11-year-old mixed-breed rescue, when he was just a year old. He’s an important part of our family.
So, when booking our hotel room and flights, we also had to find someone we trust to care for Samson in our absence. Family members are not always an option, so we often rely on pet-sitting apps. We looked through profile after profile, contacted sitters, and interrogated them as if we were looking for care for a tiny human.
Eventually, we found a service that allows owners to use a mobile app that provides updates about how their pets are faring. While we were away, the sitter sent daily photos and videos of Samson that put our minds at ease.
As a registered nurse who works in an ICU, my own anxiety about leaving Samson reminded me about my patients’ reservations about leaving their pets during hospitalizations. Many of them share the same kinds of anxieties when they are separated from their beloved pets. Hospital visits are rarely planned. I have cared for patients who expressed concerns about their pets being home alone and needing to coordinate pet care. In some cases – to alleviate those patients’ anxieties – I have helped them contact friends and family members to assist with care.
Pets’ popularity grows in U.S.
According to the 2019-2020 National Pet Owners Survey, about 67% of U.S. households own a pet – which translates to about 84.9 million homes. During the height of COVID, Americans also acquired a greater number of smaller pets.1 In addition, when social restrictions increased, the demand for dog adoptions and the desire to serve as foster owners rose significantly.2 Last Chance Animal Rescue of Waldorf, Md., reportedly saw the adoption of dogs rise from 30%-40% in 2020. Another animal rescue operation, Lucky Dog, of Arlington, Va., in 2020 helped about 3,385 pets find adoption, up from about 1,800 in 2019.3 About two-thirds of all American households and roughly half of elderly individuals own pets.4
I am not surprised by those numbers. In my nursing practice, I face many stress-related factors, such as alternating day and night shifts, 12-hour shifts, strenuous physical work, and the psychological strain of attending to ill and dying patients. Interacting with Samson helps relieve that stress. The motion of petting Samson helps calm my heart rate and decreases my anxiety. In addition, Samson makes me smile – and excites almost all the people I interact with while he’s around. Of course, I’m not objective, but I view Samson’s impact on people as a symbol of the power of animal-assisted therapy (AAT).
AAT, defined as “the positive interaction between an animal and a patient within a therapeutic framework,”has proven to be an effective intervention for adults with intellectual disabilities who experience anxiety in an observational study.5 The intervention also has helped reduce cortisol levels in a study of nurses in physical medicine, internal medicine, and long-term care.6 Since most patient hospital stays are unplanned, there is a need to introduce AAT into hospital care. This would lessen anxiety in patients concerning their pets’ welfare.
We know that long-term hospital stays often cause adverse psychosocial effects on patients. Such stays can result in “hospitalization syndrome,” which is characterized by a gradual loss of cognition and orientation, an unwillingness to maintain contact with others or to engage in group therapy, and a loss of interest in their surroundings.7 The common causes for this syndrome are infection, medication, isolation, response to surgery, and dehydration. A consequence can be a permanent change in cognitive function or psychological impairment. However, my experience of practicing nursing for years has led me to discover that pets as an external stimulus can prevent the syndrome’s onset. This is because a large percentage of hospitalized patients have pets, and contact with a pet reminds them of home and the memories they share at home.
Introducing animal therapy into health care facilities could boost patients’ mental health – and ease their anxiety – by acting as a bridge between their present circumstances and the lives they have outside the establishment.
References
1. American Pet Owners Association. Will the COVID Pet Spike Last? State of the industry presentation. 2021 Mar 24.
2. Morgan L et al. Humanit Soc Sci Comm. 2020 Nov 24;7(144). doi: 10.1057/S41599-020-00649-x.
3. Hedgpeth D. So many pets have been adopted during the pandemic that shelters are running out. Washington Post. 2021 Jan 6.
4. Cherniack EP and Cherniack AR. Curr Gerontol Geriatr Res. 2014. doi: 10.1155/2014/623203.
5. Giuliani F and Jacquemettaz M. Eur J Integ Med. 2017 Sep;14;13-9.
6. Machová K et al. Int J Environ Res and Public Health. 2019 Oct;16(19):3670.
7. Machová K et al. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2012 Apr;16(8):1362.
Ms. Scott is a registered nurse specializing in critical care and also has experience in nursing leadership. She has 8 years of experience in cardiothoracic ICUs. Ms. Scott received a bachelor of science in nursing degree from Queens University of Charlotte (N.C.), and a master of business administration in health care administration from the University of North Alabama, Florence. She has no conflicts of interest.
Health anxiety common as COVID restrictions loosen
As restrictions lift and mask mandates become scarce, Americans are filling their social calendars and booking vacations. While some are rejoicing, health care professionals say others are emerging from the pandemic with more health-related fears.
COVID-19 has caused more anxiety and depression for many over the course of the pandemic. A survey from the CDC and the Census Bureau found the percentage of adults with symptoms of an anxiety or depressive disorder increased from 36.4% to 41.5% from August 2020 to February 2021.
But this phenomenon will not just disappear as COVID-19 cases decrease, said Reese Druckenmiller, a clinical social worker for the Mayo Clinic Health System.
“There are still people out there not wanting to leave home,” she said. “Some folks inherently struggle with anxiety more than others, and we know anxiety can come from different experiences and traumas.
Though there is little research on the psychological effects of pandemic outbreaks, scientists are beginning to explore this. A recent review published in the International Journal of Cognitive Therapy concluded that, based on available research and the effects of previous pandemics, COVID-19 will likely have a significant effect on people’s mental health, particularly those who already have obsessive-compulsive disorder and health anxiety, along with people on the front line of health care.
According to the authors, since the virus doesn’t have symptoms among certain populations, there’s more anxiety about becoming infected and unknowingly spreading it to vulnerable people.
Not to mention the influx of anxiety-provoking news over the past year, Ms. Druckenmiller noted.
“One thing I noticed during the pandemic: The news changed. There were still regular news stories, but at the forefront of every single newscast was the numbers, how many people have died, how many people are hospitalized,” she said.
Some of Ms. Druckenmiller’s own patients who are more health-focused saw this as an added burden – another source of anxiety.
For those still uncomfortable with an abrupt reentry into public spaces, Ms. Druckenmiller recommended taking small steps. Start leaving the house every day, she suggested, even if it’s just for a walk. It is also important to be honest with loved ones about your own comfort level.
“Our brain is very flexible and fluid, but it also doesn’t just switch on a dime,” she said. “If I’ve been told over the past year this is a horrible thing that could kill me, my brain can’t adjust that fast. We need evidence through experience.”
A version of this article first appeared on WebMD.com.
As restrictions lift and mask mandates become scarce, Americans are filling their social calendars and booking vacations. While some are rejoicing, health care professionals say others are emerging from the pandemic with more health-related fears.
COVID-19 has caused more anxiety and depression for many over the course of the pandemic. A survey from the CDC and the Census Bureau found the percentage of adults with symptoms of an anxiety or depressive disorder increased from 36.4% to 41.5% from August 2020 to February 2021.
But this phenomenon will not just disappear as COVID-19 cases decrease, said Reese Druckenmiller, a clinical social worker for the Mayo Clinic Health System.
“There are still people out there not wanting to leave home,” she said. “Some folks inherently struggle with anxiety more than others, and we know anxiety can come from different experiences and traumas.
Though there is little research on the psychological effects of pandemic outbreaks, scientists are beginning to explore this. A recent review published in the International Journal of Cognitive Therapy concluded that, based on available research and the effects of previous pandemics, COVID-19 will likely have a significant effect on people’s mental health, particularly those who already have obsessive-compulsive disorder and health anxiety, along with people on the front line of health care.
According to the authors, since the virus doesn’t have symptoms among certain populations, there’s more anxiety about becoming infected and unknowingly spreading it to vulnerable people.
Not to mention the influx of anxiety-provoking news over the past year, Ms. Druckenmiller noted.
“One thing I noticed during the pandemic: The news changed. There were still regular news stories, but at the forefront of every single newscast was the numbers, how many people have died, how many people are hospitalized,” she said.
Some of Ms. Druckenmiller’s own patients who are more health-focused saw this as an added burden – another source of anxiety.
For those still uncomfortable with an abrupt reentry into public spaces, Ms. Druckenmiller recommended taking small steps. Start leaving the house every day, she suggested, even if it’s just for a walk. It is also important to be honest with loved ones about your own comfort level.
“Our brain is very flexible and fluid, but it also doesn’t just switch on a dime,” she said. “If I’ve been told over the past year this is a horrible thing that could kill me, my brain can’t adjust that fast. We need evidence through experience.”
A version of this article first appeared on WebMD.com.
As restrictions lift and mask mandates become scarce, Americans are filling their social calendars and booking vacations. While some are rejoicing, health care professionals say others are emerging from the pandemic with more health-related fears.
COVID-19 has caused more anxiety and depression for many over the course of the pandemic. A survey from the CDC and the Census Bureau found the percentage of adults with symptoms of an anxiety or depressive disorder increased from 36.4% to 41.5% from August 2020 to February 2021.
But this phenomenon will not just disappear as COVID-19 cases decrease, said Reese Druckenmiller, a clinical social worker for the Mayo Clinic Health System.
“There are still people out there not wanting to leave home,” she said. “Some folks inherently struggle with anxiety more than others, and we know anxiety can come from different experiences and traumas.
Though there is little research on the psychological effects of pandemic outbreaks, scientists are beginning to explore this. A recent review published in the International Journal of Cognitive Therapy concluded that, based on available research and the effects of previous pandemics, COVID-19 will likely have a significant effect on people’s mental health, particularly those who already have obsessive-compulsive disorder and health anxiety, along with people on the front line of health care.
According to the authors, since the virus doesn’t have symptoms among certain populations, there’s more anxiety about becoming infected and unknowingly spreading it to vulnerable people.
Not to mention the influx of anxiety-provoking news over the past year, Ms. Druckenmiller noted.
“One thing I noticed during the pandemic: The news changed. There were still regular news stories, but at the forefront of every single newscast was the numbers, how many people have died, how many people are hospitalized,” she said.
Some of Ms. Druckenmiller’s own patients who are more health-focused saw this as an added burden – another source of anxiety.
For those still uncomfortable with an abrupt reentry into public spaces, Ms. Druckenmiller recommended taking small steps. Start leaving the house every day, she suggested, even if it’s just for a walk. It is also important to be honest with loved ones about your own comfort level.
“Our brain is very flexible and fluid, but it also doesn’t just switch on a dime,” she said. “If I’ve been told over the past year this is a horrible thing that could kill me, my brain can’t adjust that fast. We need evidence through experience.”
A version of this article first appeared on WebMD.com.
State-of-the-art psych unit designed with recovery in mind
Calming wall colors, nature-themed murals, and soft nighttime lighting are all part of a unique new state-of-the-art inpatient psychiatric unit that focuses especially on children and adolescents who have experienced significant trauma.
The 16-bed unit, which has been in the works for 3½ years and opened June 30 at the University of Maryland Medical Center (UMMC), in Baltimore, Maryland, treats youth aged 5 to 17 years. It has separate wings for younger children and for adolescents.
“We offer a really warm and welcoming environment that we think is going to promote health and healing,” the unit’s head, Sarah Edwards, DO, director of child and adolescent psychiatry at UMMC and assistant professor of psychiatry, University of Maryland School of Medicine (UMSOM), Baltimore, said in an interview.
Previous research shows that 1 in 4 children experience some kind of maltreatment, whether physical, sexual, or emotional, and that 1 in 5 develop a diagnosable mental health disorder.
, Dr. Edwards noted. Recent data show that the rate of suicidal ideation among youth has increased significantly during the COVID-19 crisis.
“Urban children have unfortunately suffered a lot of what we call traumatic stress, so they might be victims of physical or sexual abuse but also face layers of stressful situations – for example, living in unsafe neighborhoods and attending schools that might not be so welcoming and safe,” said Dr. Edwards.
Safety first
Typical conditions treated at the new unit will include depression, anxiety, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, psychotic spectrum, as well as trauma disorders.
Some of these young patients have been through the foster care system and show signs of trauma and poor attachment, Dr. Edwards noted. As a result, they may have difficulty regulating their thoughts and emotions and at times exhibit dangerous behavior.
The new unit is designed both architecturally and clinically to deliver “trauma-informed” care. This type of approach “recognizes the pervasive nature of trauma” and promotes settings that facilitate recovery, Dr. Edwards added.
The idea is to treat individuals “in a way that doesn’t re-traumatize them or make their condition worse,” she added.
Safety is of the utmost importance in the unit, Jill RachBeisel, MD, chief of psychiatry at UMMC and professor and chair in the department of psychiatry at UMSOM, said in an interview.
“Health care workers must recognize and respond to the effects of trauma – and one very important way is to provide care in settings that emphasize physical and emotional safety, which helps instill a sense of control and empowerment,” Dr. RachBeisel said.
Providing youth with options is an important way to provide that sense of control, Dr. Edwards added. For example, residents can choose their own music in their bedroom, such as sounds of nature, running water, or birds chirping. They can also draw or write personal notes on a large whiteboard in their unit.
Circadian-rhythm lighting
Other unique elements of the new unit include walls painted soothing shades and murals of natural scenery, created by a local artist.
These murals perfectly capture “the kind of overall spirit of what we were trying to induce,” said Dr. Edwards.
A part of the unit dubbed the “front porch” has a large mural depicting “a landscape of beautiful trees and water and animals,” she noted. Kids can gather here to relax or just hang out.
The lighting at the unit mirrors circadian rhythms. It’s brighter during the day to promote wakefulness and participation in activities and gradually dims toward the evening hours to help induce restful nighttime sleep.
Safe and empowering and adopt productive behaviors and coping skills, Dr. Edwards noted.
The staff for the interprofessional unit includes psychiatrists, psychologists, psychiatric nurses, occupational therapists, and others trained in pediatric care.
Advice for other centers
“Our new unit is designed to provide the highest standard in mental health care and incorporates a high-tech approach to create a calming, soothing, and engaging setting,” said Dr. RachBeisel.
School-transition specialists help connect discharged patients and their families to vital services and peer support. These services represent “an essential component of the continuum of care” for youth experiencing mental distress, she added.
Other organizations considering establishing a similar type of psychiatric unit should consult all stakeholders.
“We had staff, no matter what their role, be part of every step of this process, including helping with the design, picking out furniture they thought would make the most sense, and helping choose the artwork,” she said.
It is also important to incorporate feedback from youth themselves, Dr. Edwards added.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Calming wall colors, nature-themed murals, and soft nighttime lighting are all part of a unique new state-of-the-art inpatient psychiatric unit that focuses especially on children and adolescents who have experienced significant trauma.
The 16-bed unit, which has been in the works for 3½ years and opened June 30 at the University of Maryland Medical Center (UMMC), in Baltimore, Maryland, treats youth aged 5 to 17 years. It has separate wings for younger children and for adolescents.
“We offer a really warm and welcoming environment that we think is going to promote health and healing,” the unit’s head, Sarah Edwards, DO, director of child and adolescent psychiatry at UMMC and assistant professor of psychiatry, University of Maryland School of Medicine (UMSOM), Baltimore, said in an interview.
Previous research shows that 1 in 4 children experience some kind of maltreatment, whether physical, sexual, or emotional, and that 1 in 5 develop a diagnosable mental health disorder.
, Dr. Edwards noted. Recent data show that the rate of suicidal ideation among youth has increased significantly during the COVID-19 crisis.
“Urban children have unfortunately suffered a lot of what we call traumatic stress, so they might be victims of physical or sexual abuse but also face layers of stressful situations – for example, living in unsafe neighborhoods and attending schools that might not be so welcoming and safe,” said Dr. Edwards.
Safety first
Typical conditions treated at the new unit will include depression, anxiety, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, psychotic spectrum, as well as trauma disorders.
Some of these young patients have been through the foster care system and show signs of trauma and poor attachment, Dr. Edwards noted. As a result, they may have difficulty regulating their thoughts and emotions and at times exhibit dangerous behavior.
The new unit is designed both architecturally and clinically to deliver “trauma-informed” care. This type of approach “recognizes the pervasive nature of trauma” and promotes settings that facilitate recovery, Dr. Edwards added.
The idea is to treat individuals “in a way that doesn’t re-traumatize them or make their condition worse,” she added.
Safety is of the utmost importance in the unit, Jill RachBeisel, MD, chief of psychiatry at UMMC and professor and chair in the department of psychiatry at UMSOM, said in an interview.
“Health care workers must recognize and respond to the effects of trauma – and one very important way is to provide care in settings that emphasize physical and emotional safety, which helps instill a sense of control and empowerment,” Dr. RachBeisel said.
Providing youth with options is an important way to provide that sense of control, Dr. Edwards added. For example, residents can choose their own music in their bedroom, such as sounds of nature, running water, or birds chirping. They can also draw or write personal notes on a large whiteboard in their unit.
Circadian-rhythm lighting
Other unique elements of the new unit include walls painted soothing shades and murals of natural scenery, created by a local artist.
These murals perfectly capture “the kind of overall spirit of what we were trying to induce,” said Dr. Edwards.
A part of the unit dubbed the “front porch” has a large mural depicting “a landscape of beautiful trees and water and animals,” she noted. Kids can gather here to relax or just hang out.
The lighting at the unit mirrors circadian rhythms. It’s brighter during the day to promote wakefulness and participation in activities and gradually dims toward the evening hours to help induce restful nighttime sleep.
Safe and empowering and adopt productive behaviors and coping skills, Dr. Edwards noted.
The staff for the interprofessional unit includes psychiatrists, psychologists, psychiatric nurses, occupational therapists, and others trained in pediatric care.
Advice for other centers
“Our new unit is designed to provide the highest standard in mental health care and incorporates a high-tech approach to create a calming, soothing, and engaging setting,” said Dr. RachBeisel.
School-transition specialists help connect discharged patients and their families to vital services and peer support. These services represent “an essential component of the continuum of care” for youth experiencing mental distress, she added.
Other organizations considering establishing a similar type of psychiatric unit should consult all stakeholders.
“We had staff, no matter what their role, be part of every step of this process, including helping with the design, picking out furniture they thought would make the most sense, and helping choose the artwork,” she said.
It is also important to incorporate feedback from youth themselves, Dr. Edwards added.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Calming wall colors, nature-themed murals, and soft nighttime lighting are all part of a unique new state-of-the-art inpatient psychiatric unit that focuses especially on children and adolescents who have experienced significant trauma.
The 16-bed unit, which has been in the works for 3½ years and opened June 30 at the University of Maryland Medical Center (UMMC), in Baltimore, Maryland, treats youth aged 5 to 17 years. It has separate wings for younger children and for adolescents.
“We offer a really warm and welcoming environment that we think is going to promote health and healing,” the unit’s head, Sarah Edwards, DO, director of child and adolescent psychiatry at UMMC and assistant professor of psychiatry, University of Maryland School of Medicine (UMSOM), Baltimore, said in an interview.
Previous research shows that 1 in 4 children experience some kind of maltreatment, whether physical, sexual, or emotional, and that 1 in 5 develop a diagnosable mental health disorder.
, Dr. Edwards noted. Recent data show that the rate of suicidal ideation among youth has increased significantly during the COVID-19 crisis.
“Urban children have unfortunately suffered a lot of what we call traumatic stress, so they might be victims of physical or sexual abuse but also face layers of stressful situations – for example, living in unsafe neighborhoods and attending schools that might not be so welcoming and safe,” said Dr. Edwards.
Safety first
Typical conditions treated at the new unit will include depression, anxiety, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, psychotic spectrum, as well as trauma disorders.
Some of these young patients have been through the foster care system and show signs of trauma and poor attachment, Dr. Edwards noted. As a result, they may have difficulty regulating their thoughts and emotions and at times exhibit dangerous behavior.
The new unit is designed both architecturally and clinically to deliver “trauma-informed” care. This type of approach “recognizes the pervasive nature of trauma” and promotes settings that facilitate recovery, Dr. Edwards added.
The idea is to treat individuals “in a way that doesn’t re-traumatize them or make their condition worse,” she added.
Safety is of the utmost importance in the unit, Jill RachBeisel, MD, chief of psychiatry at UMMC and professor and chair in the department of psychiatry at UMSOM, said in an interview.
“Health care workers must recognize and respond to the effects of trauma – and one very important way is to provide care in settings that emphasize physical and emotional safety, which helps instill a sense of control and empowerment,” Dr. RachBeisel said.
Providing youth with options is an important way to provide that sense of control, Dr. Edwards added. For example, residents can choose their own music in their bedroom, such as sounds of nature, running water, or birds chirping. They can also draw or write personal notes on a large whiteboard in their unit.
Circadian-rhythm lighting
Other unique elements of the new unit include walls painted soothing shades and murals of natural scenery, created by a local artist.
These murals perfectly capture “the kind of overall spirit of what we were trying to induce,” said Dr. Edwards.
A part of the unit dubbed the “front porch” has a large mural depicting “a landscape of beautiful trees and water and animals,” she noted. Kids can gather here to relax or just hang out.
The lighting at the unit mirrors circadian rhythms. It’s brighter during the day to promote wakefulness and participation in activities and gradually dims toward the evening hours to help induce restful nighttime sleep.
Safe and empowering and adopt productive behaviors and coping skills, Dr. Edwards noted.
The staff for the interprofessional unit includes psychiatrists, psychologists, psychiatric nurses, occupational therapists, and others trained in pediatric care.
Advice for other centers
“Our new unit is designed to provide the highest standard in mental health care and incorporates a high-tech approach to create a calming, soothing, and engaging setting,” said Dr. RachBeisel.
School-transition specialists help connect discharged patients and their families to vital services and peer support. These services represent “an essential component of the continuum of care” for youth experiencing mental distress, she added.
Other organizations considering establishing a similar type of psychiatric unit should consult all stakeholders.
“We had staff, no matter what their role, be part of every step of this process, including helping with the design, picking out furniture they thought would make the most sense, and helping choose the artwork,” she said.
It is also important to incorporate feedback from youth themselves, Dr. Edwards added.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
COVID-19: Guiding vaccinated patients through to the ‘new normal’
As COVID-related restrictions are lifting and the streets, restaurants, and events are filling back up, we must encourage our patients to take inventory. It is time to help them create posttraumatic growth.
As we help them navigate this part of the pandemic, encourage them to ask what they learned over the last year and how they plan to integrate what they’ve been through to successfully create the “new normal.”
The Biden administration had set a goal of getting at least one shot to 70% of American adults by July 4, and that goal will not be reached. That shortfall, combined with the increase of the highly transmissible Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2 means that we and our patients must not let our guards completely down. At the same time, we can encourage our vaccinated patients to get back to their prepandemic lives – to the extent that they feel comfortable doing so.
Ultimately, this is about respecting physical and emotional boundaries. How do we greet vaccinated people now? Is it okay to shake hands, hug, or kiss to greet a friend or family member – or should we continue to elbow bump – or perhaps wave? Should we confront family members who have opted not to get vaccinated for reasons not related to health? Is it safe to visit with older relatives who are vaccinated? What about children under 12 who are not?
Those who were on the front lines of the pandemic faced unfathomable pain and suffering – and mental and physical exhaustion. And we know that the nightmare is not over. Several areas of the country with large numbers of unvaccinated people could face “very dense outbreaks,” in large part because of the Delta variant.
As we sort through the remaining challenges, I urge us all to reflect. We have been in this together and will emerge together. We know that the closer we were to the trauma, the longer recovery will take.
Ask patients to consider what is most important to resume and what can still wait. Some are eager to jump back into the deep end of the pool; others prefer to continue to wait cautiously. Families need to be on the same page as they assess risks and opportunities going forward, because household spread continues to be at the highest risk. Remind patients that the health of one of us affects the health of all of us.
Urge patients to take time to explore the following questions as they process the pandemic. We can also ask ourselves these same questions and share them with colleagues who are also rebuilding.
- Did you prioritize your family more? How can you continue to spend quality time them as other opportunities emerge?
- Did you have to withdraw from friends/coworkers and family members because of the pandemic? If so, how can you reincorporate them in our lives?
- Did you send more time caring for yourself with exercise and meditation? Can those new habits remain in place as life presents more options? How can you continue to make time for self-care while adding back other responsibilities?
- Did you eat better or worse in quarantine? Can you maintain the positive habits you developed as you venture back to restaurants, parties, and gatherings?
- What habits did you break that you are now better off without?
- What new habits or hobbies did you create that you want to continue?
- What hobbies should you resume that you missed during the last year?
- What new coping skills have you gained?
- Has your alcohol consumption declined or increased during the pandemic?
- Did you neglect/decide to forgo your medical and dental care? How quickly can you safely resume that care?
- How did your value system shift this year?
- Did the people you feel closest to change?
- How can you use this trauma to appreciate life more?
Life might get very busy this summer, so encourage patients to find time to answer these questions. Journaling can be a great way to think through all that we have experienced. Our brains will need to change again to adapt. Many of us have felt sad or anxious for a quite a while, and we want to move toward more positive feelings of safety, happiness, optimism, and joy. This will take effort. After all, we have lost more than 600,000 people to COVID, and much of the world is still in the middle of the pandemic. But this will get much easier as the threat of COVID-19 continues to recede. We must now work toward creating better times ahead.
Dr. Ritvo has almost 30 years’ experience in psychiatry and is currently practicing telemedicine. She is the author of “Bekindr – The Transformative Power of Kindness” (Hellertown, Pa.: Momosa Publishing, 2018). She has no conflicts of interest.
As COVID-related restrictions are lifting and the streets, restaurants, and events are filling back up, we must encourage our patients to take inventory. It is time to help them create posttraumatic growth.
As we help them navigate this part of the pandemic, encourage them to ask what they learned over the last year and how they plan to integrate what they’ve been through to successfully create the “new normal.”
The Biden administration had set a goal of getting at least one shot to 70% of American adults by July 4, and that goal will not be reached. That shortfall, combined with the increase of the highly transmissible Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2 means that we and our patients must not let our guards completely down. At the same time, we can encourage our vaccinated patients to get back to their prepandemic lives – to the extent that they feel comfortable doing so.
Ultimately, this is about respecting physical and emotional boundaries. How do we greet vaccinated people now? Is it okay to shake hands, hug, or kiss to greet a friend or family member – or should we continue to elbow bump – or perhaps wave? Should we confront family members who have opted not to get vaccinated for reasons not related to health? Is it safe to visit with older relatives who are vaccinated? What about children under 12 who are not?
Those who were on the front lines of the pandemic faced unfathomable pain and suffering – and mental and physical exhaustion. And we know that the nightmare is not over. Several areas of the country with large numbers of unvaccinated people could face “very dense outbreaks,” in large part because of the Delta variant.
As we sort through the remaining challenges, I urge us all to reflect. We have been in this together and will emerge together. We know that the closer we were to the trauma, the longer recovery will take.
Ask patients to consider what is most important to resume and what can still wait. Some are eager to jump back into the deep end of the pool; others prefer to continue to wait cautiously. Families need to be on the same page as they assess risks and opportunities going forward, because household spread continues to be at the highest risk. Remind patients that the health of one of us affects the health of all of us.
Urge patients to take time to explore the following questions as they process the pandemic. We can also ask ourselves these same questions and share them with colleagues who are also rebuilding.
- Did you prioritize your family more? How can you continue to spend quality time them as other opportunities emerge?
- Did you have to withdraw from friends/coworkers and family members because of the pandemic? If so, how can you reincorporate them in our lives?
- Did you send more time caring for yourself with exercise and meditation? Can those new habits remain in place as life presents more options? How can you continue to make time for self-care while adding back other responsibilities?
- Did you eat better or worse in quarantine? Can you maintain the positive habits you developed as you venture back to restaurants, parties, and gatherings?
- What habits did you break that you are now better off without?
- What new habits or hobbies did you create that you want to continue?
- What hobbies should you resume that you missed during the last year?
- What new coping skills have you gained?
- Has your alcohol consumption declined or increased during the pandemic?
- Did you neglect/decide to forgo your medical and dental care? How quickly can you safely resume that care?
- How did your value system shift this year?
- Did the people you feel closest to change?
- How can you use this trauma to appreciate life more?
Life might get very busy this summer, so encourage patients to find time to answer these questions. Journaling can be a great way to think through all that we have experienced. Our brains will need to change again to adapt. Many of us have felt sad or anxious for a quite a while, and we want to move toward more positive feelings of safety, happiness, optimism, and joy. This will take effort. After all, we have lost more than 600,000 people to COVID, and much of the world is still in the middle of the pandemic. But this will get much easier as the threat of COVID-19 continues to recede. We must now work toward creating better times ahead.
Dr. Ritvo has almost 30 years’ experience in psychiatry and is currently practicing telemedicine. She is the author of “Bekindr – The Transformative Power of Kindness” (Hellertown, Pa.: Momosa Publishing, 2018). She has no conflicts of interest.
As COVID-related restrictions are lifting and the streets, restaurants, and events are filling back up, we must encourage our patients to take inventory. It is time to help them create posttraumatic growth.
As we help them navigate this part of the pandemic, encourage them to ask what they learned over the last year and how they plan to integrate what they’ve been through to successfully create the “new normal.”
The Biden administration had set a goal of getting at least one shot to 70% of American adults by July 4, and that goal will not be reached. That shortfall, combined with the increase of the highly transmissible Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2 means that we and our patients must not let our guards completely down. At the same time, we can encourage our vaccinated patients to get back to their prepandemic lives – to the extent that they feel comfortable doing so.
Ultimately, this is about respecting physical and emotional boundaries. How do we greet vaccinated people now? Is it okay to shake hands, hug, or kiss to greet a friend or family member – or should we continue to elbow bump – or perhaps wave? Should we confront family members who have opted not to get vaccinated for reasons not related to health? Is it safe to visit with older relatives who are vaccinated? What about children under 12 who are not?
Those who were on the front lines of the pandemic faced unfathomable pain and suffering – and mental and physical exhaustion. And we know that the nightmare is not over. Several areas of the country with large numbers of unvaccinated people could face “very dense outbreaks,” in large part because of the Delta variant.
As we sort through the remaining challenges, I urge us all to reflect. We have been in this together and will emerge together. We know that the closer we were to the trauma, the longer recovery will take.
Ask patients to consider what is most important to resume and what can still wait. Some are eager to jump back into the deep end of the pool; others prefer to continue to wait cautiously. Families need to be on the same page as they assess risks and opportunities going forward, because household spread continues to be at the highest risk. Remind patients that the health of one of us affects the health of all of us.
Urge patients to take time to explore the following questions as they process the pandemic. We can also ask ourselves these same questions and share them with colleagues who are also rebuilding.
- Did you prioritize your family more? How can you continue to spend quality time them as other opportunities emerge?
- Did you have to withdraw from friends/coworkers and family members because of the pandemic? If so, how can you reincorporate them in our lives?
- Did you send more time caring for yourself with exercise and meditation? Can those new habits remain in place as life presents more options? How can you continue to make time for self-care while adding back other responsibilities?
- Did you eat better or worse in quarantine? Can you maintain the positive habits you developed as you venture back to restaurants, parties, and gatherings?
- What habits did you break that you are now better off without?
- What new habits or hobbies did you create that you want to continue?
- What hobbies should you resume that you missed during the last year?
- What new coping skills have you gained?
- Has your alcohol consumption declined or increased during the pandemic?
- Did you neglect/decide to forgo your medical and dental care? How quickly can you safely resume that care?
- How did your value system shift this year?
- Did the people you feel closest to change?
- How can you use this trauma to appreciate life more?
Life might get very busy this summer, so encourage patients to find time to answer these questions. Journaling can be a great way to think through all that we have experienced. Our brains will need to change again to adapt. Many of us have felt sad or anxious for a quite a while, and we want to move toward more positive feelings of safety, happiness, optimism, and joy. This will take effort. After all, we have lost more than 600,000 people to COVID, and much of the world is still in the middle of the pandemic. But this will get much easier as the threat of COVID-19 continues to recede. We must now work toward creating better times ahead.
Dr. Ritvo has almost 30 years’ experience in psychiatry and is currently practicing telemedicine. She is the author of “Bekindr – The Transformative Power of Kindness” (Hellertown, Pa.: Momosa Publishing, 2018). She has no conflicts of interest.
‘Treat youth with gender dysphoria as individuals’
Young people with gender dysphoria should be considered as individuals rather than fall into an age-defined bracket when assessing their understanding to consent to hormone treatment, according to the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust, as it awaits the verdict of its recent appeal in London against a High Court ruling.
The High Court ruling, made in December 2020 as reported by this news organization, stated that adolescents with gender dysphoria were unlikely to fully understand the consequences of hormone treatment for gender reassignment and was the result of a case brought by 24-year-old Keira Bell, who transitioned from female to male at the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS), starting at the age of 16, but later “detransitioned.”
Along with changes made to rules around prescribing puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to minors with gender dysphoria in countries such as Finland and Sweden, the English ruling signals a more cautious approach to any medical treatment for such children, as detailed in a feature published in April.
However, during the appeal, The Trust argued once more that puberty blockers give children time to “consider options” about their bodies and that the decision (the December ruling) was inconsistent with the law that “entitles children under the age of 16 to make decisions for themselves after being assessed as competent to do so by their doctor.”
Alongside other organizations, the United States–based Endocrine Society submitted written evidence in support of the Tavistock. “The High Court’s decision, if it is allowed to stand, would set a harmful precedent preventing physicians from providing transgender and gender diverse youth with high-quality medical care,” it noted in a statement.
Defending the High Court’s ruling, the lawyer for Ms. Bell said its conclusion was that puberty blockers for gender dysphoria are an “experimental” treatment with a very limited evidence base.
“The judgment of the [High Court] is entirely correct, and there is no proper basis for overturning it,” he asserted.
The 2-day appeal hearing ended on June 24, and a ruling will be made at a later date.
Do children understand the consequences of hormone treatment?
One central aspect of the overall case is the fact that Ms. Bell regrets her decision to transition at age 16, saying she only received three counseling sessions prior to endocrinology referral. And she consequently had a mastectomy at age 20, which she also bitterly regrets.
So a key concern is whether young people fully understand the consequences of taking puberty blockers and therapies that may follow, including cross-sex hormones.
Witness for the appeal Gary Butler, MD, consultant in pediatric and adolescent endocrinology at University College Hospital, London, where children are referred to from GIDS for hormone treatment, said the number of children who go on to cross-sex hormones from puberty blockers is “over 80%.”
But the actual number of children who are referred to endocrinology services (where puberty blockers are initiated) from GIDS is low, at approximately 16%, according to 2019-2020 data, said a GIDS spokesperson.
“Once at the endocrinology service, young people either participate in a group education session, or if under 15 years, an individualized session between the clinician and the patient and family members,” she added. The Trust also maintained that initiation of cross-sex hormones “is separate from the prescription of puberty blockers.”
Since the December ruling, The Trust has put in place multidisciplinary clinical reviews (MDCR) of cases, and in July, NHS England will start implementing an independent multidisciplinary professional review (MDPR) to check that the GIDS has followed due process with each case.
Slow the process down, give appropriate psychotherapy
Stella O’Malley is a psychotherapist who works with transitioners and detransitioners and is a founding member of the International Association of Therapists for Desisters and Detransitioners (IATDD).
Whatever the outcome of the appeal process, Ms. O’Malley said she would like to see the Tavistock slow down and take a broader approach to counseling children before referral to endocrinology services.
In discussing therapy prior to transition, Ms. O’Malley stated that her clients often say they did not explore their inner motivations or other possible reasons for their distress, and the therapy was focused more on when they transition, rather than being sure it was something they wanted to do.
“We need to learn from the mistakes made with people like Keira Bell. , especially when [children are] ... young and especially when they’re traumatized,” Ms. O’Malley said.
“Had they received a more conventional therapy, they might have thought about their decision from different perspectives and in the process acquired more self-awareness, which would have been more beneficial.”
“The ‘affirmative’ approach to gender therapy is too narrow; we need to look at the whole individual. Therapy in other areas would never disregard other, nongender issues such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or anxiety [which often co-exist with gender dysphoria] – issues bleed into each other,” Ms. O’Malley pointed out. “We need a more exploratory approach.”
“I’d also like to see other therapists all over the [U.K.] who are perfectly qualified and capable of working with gender actually start working with gender issues,” she said, noting that such an approach might also help reduce the long waiting list at the Tavistock.
The latter had been overwhelmed, and this led to a speeding up of the assessment process, which led to a number of professionals resigning from the service in recent years, saying children were being “fast-tracked” to medical transition.
Fertility and sexual function are complex issues for kids
Also asked to comment was Claire Graham, from Genspect, a group that describes itself as a voice for parents of gender-questioning kids.
She told this news organization that “parents are rightly concerned about their children’s ability to consent to treatments that may lead to infertility and issues surrounding sexual function.” She added that other countries in Europe were changing their approach. “Look to Sweden and Finland, who have both rowed back on puberty blockers and no longer recommend them.”
Ms. Graham, who has worked with children with differences in sexual development, added that it was very difficult for children and young people to understand the life-long implications of decisions made at an early age.
“How can children understand what it is to live with impaired sexual functioning if they have never had sex? Likewise, fertility is a complex issue. Most people do not want to become parents as teenagers, but we understand that this will often change as they grow,” said Ms. Graham.
“Many parents worry that their child is not being considered in the whole [and] that their child’s ability to consent to medical interventions for gender dysphoria is impacted by comorbidities, such as a diagnosis of autism or a history of mental health issues. These children are particularly vulnerable.”
“At Genspect, we hope that the decision from the ... court is upheld,” Ms. Graham concluded.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Young people with gender dysphoria should be considered as individuals rather than fall into an age-defined bracket when assessing their understanding to consent to hormone treatment, according to the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust, as it awaits the verdict of its recent appeal in London against a High Court ruling.
The High Court ruling, made in December 2020 as reported by this news organization, stated that adolescents with gender dysphoria were unlikely to fully understand the consequences of hormone treatment for gender reassignment and was the result of a case brought by 24-year-old Keira Bell, who transitioned from female to male at the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS), starting at the age of 16, but later “detransitioned.”
Along with changes made to rules around prescribing puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to minors with gender dysphoria in countries such as Finland and Sweden, the English ruling signals a more cautious approach to any medical treatment for such children, as detailed in a feature published in April.
However, during the appeal, The Trust argued once more that puberty blockers give children time to “consider options” about their bodies and that the decision (the December ruling) was inconsistent with the law that “entitles children under the age of 16 to make decisions for themselves after being assessed as competent to do so by their doctor.”
Alongside other organizations, the United States–based Endocrine Society submitted written evidence in support of the Tavistock. “The High Court’s decision, if it is allowed to stand, would set a harmful precedent preventing physicians from providing transgender and gender diverse youth with high-quality medical care,” it noted in a statement.
Defending the High Court’s ruling, the lawyer for Ms. Bell said its conclusion was that puberty blockers for gender dysphoria are an “experimental” treatment with a very limited evidence base.
“The judgment of the [High Court] is entirely correct, and there is no proper basis for overturning it,” he asserted.
The 2-day appeal hearing ended on June 24, and a ruling will be made at a later date.
Do children understand the consequences of hormone treatment?
One central aspect of the overall case is the fact that Ms. Bell regrets her decision to transition at age 16, saying she only received three counseling sessions prior to endocrinology referral. And she consequently had a mastectomy at age 20, which she also bitterly regrets.
So a key concern is whether young people fully understand the consequences of taking puberty blockers and therapies that may follow, including cross-sex hormones.
Witness for the appeal Gary Butler, MD, consultant in pediatric and adolescent endocrinology at University College Hospital, London, where children are referred to from GIDS for hormone treatment, said the number of children who go on to cross-sex hormones from puberty blockers is “over 80%.”
But the actual number of children who are referred to endocrinology services (where puberty blockers are initiated) from GIDS is low, at approximately 16%, according to 2019-2020 data, said a GIDS spokesperson.
“Once at the endocrinology service, young people either participate in a group education session, or if under 15 years, an individualized session between the clinician and the patient and family members,” she added. The Trust also maintained that initiation of cross-sex hormones “is separate from the prescription of puberty blockers.”
Since the December ruling, The Trust has put in place multidisciplinary clinical reviews (MDCR) of cases, and in July, NHS England will start implementing an independent multidisciplinary professional review (MDPR) to check that the GIDS has followed due process with each case.
Slow the process down, give appropriate psychotherapy
Stella O’Malley is a psychotherapist who works with transitioners and detransitioners and is a founding member of the International Association of Therapists for Desisters and Detransitioners (IATDD).
Whatever the outcome of the appeal process, Ms. O’Malley said she would like to see the Tavistock slow down and take a broader approach to counseling children before referral to endocrinology services.
In discussing therapy prior to transition, Ms. O’Malley stated that her clients often say they did not explore their inner motivations or other possible reasons for their distress, and the therapy was focused more on when they transition, rather than being sure it was something they wanted to do.
“We need to learn from the mistakes made with people like Keira Bell. , especially when [children are] ... young and especially when they’re traumatized,” Ms. O’Malley said.
“Had they received a more conventional therapy, they might have thought about their decision from different perspectives and in the process acquired more self-awareness, which would have been more beneficial.”
“The ‘affirmative’ approach to gender therapy is too narrow; we need to look at the whole individual. Therapy in other areas would never disregard other, nongender issues such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or anxiety [which often co-exist with gender dysphoria] – issues bleed into each other,” Ms. O’Malley pointed out. “We need a more exploratory approach.”
“I’d also like to see other therapists all over the [U.K.] who are perfectly qualified and capable of working with gender actually start working with gender issues,” she said, noting that such an approach might also help reduce the long waiting list at the Tavistock.
The latter had been overwhelmed, and this led to a speeding up of the assessment process, which led to a number of professionals resigning from the service in recent years, saying children were being “fast-tracked” to medical transition.
Fertility and sexual function are complex issues for kids
Also asked to comment was Claire Graham, from Genspect, a group that describes itself as a voice for parents of gender-questioning kids.
She told this news organization that “parents are rightly concerned about their children’s ability to consent to treatments that may lead to infertility and issues surrounding sexual function.” She added that other countries in Europe were changing their approach. “Look to Sweden and Finland, who have both rowed back on puberty blockers and no longer recommend them.”
Ms. Graham, who has worked with children with differences in sexual development, added that it was very difficult for children and young people to understand the life-long implications of decisions made at an early age.
“How can children understand what it is to live with impaired sexual functioning if they have never had sex? Likewise, fertility is a complex issue. Most people do not want to become parents as teenagers, but we understand that this will often change as they grow,” said Ms. Graham.
“Many parents worry that their child is not being considered in the whole [and] that their child’s ability to consent to medical interventions for gender dysphoria is impacted by comorbidities, such as a diagnosis of autism or a history of mental health issues. These children are particularly vulnerable.”
“At Genspect, we hope that the decision from the ... court is upheld,” Ms. Graham concluded.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Young people with gender dysphoria should be considered as individuals rather than fall into an age-defined bracket when assessing their understanding to consent to hormone treatment, according to the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust, as it awaits the verdict of its recent appeal in London against a High Court ruling.
The High Court ruling, made in December 2020 as reported by this news organization, stated that adolescents with gender dysphoria were unlikely to fully understand the consequences of hormone treatment for gender reassignment and was the result of a case brought by 24-year-old Keira Bell, who transitioned from female to male at the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS), starting at the age of 16, but later “detransitioned.”
Along with changes made to rules around prescribing puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to minors with gender dysphoria in countries such as Finland and Sweden, the English ruling signals a more cautious approach to any medical treatment for such children, as detailed in a feature published in April.
However, during the appeal, The Trust argued once more that puberty blockers give children time to “consider options” about their bodies and that the decision (the December ruling) was inconsistent with the law that “entitles children under the age of 16 to make decisions for themselves after being assessed as competent to do so by their doctor.”
Alongside other organizations, the United States–based Endocrine Society submitted written evidence in support of the Tavistock. “The High Court’s decision, if it is allowed to stand, would set a harmful precedent preventing physicians from providing transgender and gender diverse youth with high-quality medical care,” it noted in a statement.
Defending the High Court’s ruling, the lawyer for Ms. Bell said its conclusion was that puberty blockers for gender dysphoria are an “experimental” treatment with a very limited evidence base.
“The judgment of the [High Court] is entirely correct, and there is no proper basis for overturning it,” he asserted.
The 2-day appeal hearing ended on June 24, and a ruling will be made at a later date.
Do children understand the consequences of hormone treatment?
One central aspect of the overall case is the fact that Ms. Bell regrets her decision to transition at age 16, saying she only received three counseling sessions prior to endocrinology referral. And she consequently had a mastectomy at age 20, which she also bitterly regrets.
So a key concern is whether young people fully understand the consequences of taking puberty blockers and therapies that may follow, including cross-sex hormones.
Witness for the appeal Gary Butler, MD, consultant in pediatric and adolescent endocrinology at University College Hospital, London, where children are referred to from GIDS for hormone treatment, said the number of children who go on to cross-sex hormones from puberty blockers is “over 80%.”
But the actual number of children who are referred to endocrinology services (where puberty blockers are initiated) from GIDS is low, at approximately 16%, according to 2019-2020 data, said a GIDS spokesperson.
“Once at the endocrinology service, young people either participate in a group education session, or if under 15 years, an individualized session between the clinician and the patient and family members,” she added. The Trust also maintained that initiation of cross-sex hormones “is separate from the prescription of puberty blockers.”
Since the December ruling, The Trust has put in place multidisciplinary clinical reviews (MDCR) of cases, and in July, NHS England will start implementing an independent multidisciplinary professional review (MDPR) to check that the GIDS has followed due process with each case.
Slow the process down, give appropriate psychotherapy
Stella O’Malley is a psychotherapist who works with transitioners and detransitioners and is a founding member of the International Association of Therapists for Desisters and Detransitioners (IATDD).
Whatever the outcome of the appeal process, Ms. O’Malley said she would like to see the Tavistock slow down and take a broader approach to counseling children before referral to endocrinology services.
In discussing therapy prior to transition, Ms. O’Malley stated that her clients often say they did not explore their inner motivations or other possible reasons for their distress, and the therapy was focused more on when they transition, rather than being sure it was something they wanted to do.
“We need to learn from the mistakes made with people like Keira Bell. , especially when [children are] ... young and especially when they’re traumatized,” Ms. O’Malley said.
“Had they received a more conventional therapy, they might have thought about their decision from different perspectives and in the process acquired more self-awareness, which would have been more beneficial.”
“The ‘affirmative’ approach to gender therapy is too narrow; we need to look at the whole individual. Therapy in other areas would never disregard other, nongender issues such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or anxiety [which often co-exist with gender dysphoria] – issues bleed into each other,” Ms. O’Malley pointed out. “We need a more exploratory approach.”
“I’d also like to see other therapists all over the [U.K.] who are perfectly qualified and capable of working with gender actually start working with gender issues,” she said, noting that such an approach might also help reduce the long waiting list at the Tavistock.
The latter had been overwhelmed, and this led to a speeding up of the assessment process, which led to a number of professionals resigning from the service in recent years, saying children were being “fast-tracked” to medical transition.
Fertility and sexual function are complex issues for kids
Also asked to comment was Claire Graham, from Genspect, a group that describes itself as a voice for parents of gender-questioning kids.
She told this news organization that “parents are rightly concerned about their children’s ability to consent to treatments that may lead to infertility and issues surrounding sexual function.” She added that other countries in Europe were changing their approach. “Look to Sweden and Finland, who have both rowed back on puberty blockers and no longer recommend them.”
Ms. Graham, who has worked with children with differences in sexual development, added that it was very difficult for children and young people to understand the life-long implications of decisions made at an early age.
“How can children understand what it is to live with impaired sexual functioning if they have never had sex? Likewise, fertility is a complex issue. Most people do not want to become parents as teenagers, but we understand that this will often change as they grow,” said Ms. Graham.
“Many parents worry that their child is not being considered in the whole [and] that their child’s ability to consent to medical interventions for gender dysphoria is impacted by comorbidities, such as a diagnosis of autism or a history of mental health issues. These children are particularly vulnerable.”
“At Genspect, we hope that the decision from the ... court is upheld,” Ms. Graham concluded.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Depression remains common among dystonia patients
About one-third of individuals with adult-onset idiopathic dystonia experience major depression or dysthymia, data from a meta-analysis of 54 studies show.
Adult-onset idiopathic dystonia (AOID) is the third-most common movement disorder after essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease, and data show that depression and anxiety are the largest contributors to reduced quality of life in these patients, wrote Alex Medina Escobar, MD, of the University of Calgary (Alta.), and colleagues. However, “the pathogenic mechanisms of depression and anxiety in AOID remain unclear” and might involve a combination of biologic factors, as well as social stigma.
In the meta-analysis, published in Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, the researchers examined the point prevalence of supraclinical threshold depressive symptoms/depressive disorders in AOID using 54 studies. The resulting study population included 12,635 patients: 6,977 with cervical dystonia, 732 with cranial dystonia, 4,504 with mixed forms, 303 with laryngeal dystonia, and 119 with upper-limb dystonia. The studies were published between 1988 and 2020, and included patients from 21 countries in 52 single-center studies and 2 multicenter studies.
Overall, the pooled prevalence of either supraclinical threshold depressive symptoms or depressive disorders was 31.5% for cervical dystonia, 29.2 % for cranial dystonia, and 33.6 % for clinical samples with mixed forms of AOID.
Among patients with cervical dystonia, major depressive disorder was more prevalent than dysthymia, but among patients with cranial dystonia, dysthymia was more prevalent. Among patients with mixed forms, the prevalence of major depressive disorder was higher than dysthymia. Heterogeneity varied among the studies but was higher in studies that used rating scales.
Treatment of patients with AOID does not take into account the impact of depression on quality of life, Dr. Escobar and colleagues reported.
“ Such model appears to be inefficient to guarantee resources to address these comorbidities within secondary or tertiary care, or through shared care pathways engaging both primary and hospital-based care.” They also said the use of antidepressants and cognitive-behavioral therapy as a way to target negative body concept or social stigma among these patients are “underexplored and underutilized.”
The study findings were limited by several factors, including the inclusion only of studies published in English. In addition, most of the studies were conducted at movement disorders clinics, which may have yielded a patient population with more severe AOID. Further limitations included the inability to perform subgroup analysis based on demographic and clinical factors, and the insufficient number of studies for meta-analysis of laryngeal and hand dystonia, Dr. Escobar and colleagues added.
However, the results represent the first pooled estimate of depression prevalence in AOID and confirm a high prevalence across different clinical forms, the researchers said. The heterogeneity across studies highlights the need for standardized screening for depression and improved diagnosis of mood disorders in AOID.
“The meta-analytic estimates provided here will be highly useful for the planning of future mechanistic and interventional studies, as well as for the redefinition of current models of care,” they concluded.
The study received no outside funding. Dr. Escobar and colleagues had no disclosures.
About one-third of individuals with adult-onset idiopathic dystonia experience major depression or dysthymia, data from a meta-analysis of 54 studies show.
Adult-onset idiopathic dystonia (AOID) is the third-most common movement disorder after essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease, and data show that depression and anxiety are the largest contributors to reduced quality of life in these patients, wrote Alex Medina Escobar, MD, of the University of Calgary (Alta.), and colleagues. However, “the pathogenic mechanisms of depression and anxiety in AOID remain unclear” and might involve a combination of biologic factors, as well as social stigma.
In the meta-analysis, published in Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, the researchers examined the point prevalence of supraclinical threshold depressive symptoms/depressive disorders in AOID using 54 studies. The resulting study population included 12,635 patients: 6,977 with cervical dystonia, 732 with cranial dystonia, 4,504 with mixed forms, 303 with laryngeal dystonia, and 119 with upper-limb dystonia. The studies were published between 1988 and 2020, and included patients from 21 countries in 52 single-center studies and 2 multicenter studies.
Overall, the pooled prevalence of either supraclinical threshold depressive symptoms or depressive disorders was 31.5% for cervical dystonia, 29.2 % for cranial dystonia, and 33.6 % for clinical samples with mixed forms of AOID.
Among patients with cervical dystonia, major depressive disorder was more prevalent than dysthymia, but among patients with cranial dystonia, dysthymia was more prevalent. Among patients with mixed forms, the prevalence of major depressive disorder was higher than dysthymia. Heterogeneity varied among the studies but was higher in studies that used rating scales.
Treatment of patients with AOID does not take into account the impact of depression on quality of life, Dr. Escobar and colleagues reported.
“ Such model appears to be inefficient to guarantee resources to address these comorbidities within secondary or tertiary care, or through shared care pathways engaging both primary and hospital-based care.” They also said the use of antidepressants and cognitive-behavioral therapy as a way to target negative body concept or social stigma among these patients are “underexplored and underutilized.”
The study findings were limited by several factors, including the inclusion only of studies published in English. In addition, most of the studies were conducted at movement disorders clinics, which may have yielded a patient population with more severe AOID. Further limitations included the inability to perform subgroup analysis based on demographic and clinical factors, and the insufficient number of studies for meta-analysis of laryngeal and hand dystonia, Dr. Escobar and colleagues added.
However, the results represent the first pooled estimate of depression prevalence in AOID and confirm a high prevalence across different clinical forms, the researchers said. The heterogeneity across studies highlights the need for standardized screening for depression and improved diagnosis of mood disorders in AOID.
“The meta-analytic estimates provided here will be highly useful for the planning of future mechanistic and interventional studies, as well as for the redefinition of current models of care,” they concluded.
The study received no outside funding. Dr. Escobar and colleagues had no disclosures.
About one-third of individuals with adult-onset idiopathic dystonia experience major depression or dysthymia, data from a meta-analysis of 54 studies show.
Adult-onset idiopathic dystonia (AOID) is the third-most common movement disorder after essential tremor and Parkinson’s disease, and data show that depression and anxiety are the largest contributors to reduced quality of life in these patients, wrote Alex Medina Escobar, MD, of the University of Calgary (Alta.), and colleagues. However, “the pathogenic mechanisms of depression and anxiety in AOID remain unclear” and might involve a combination of biologic factors, as well as social stigma.
In the meta-analysis, published in Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, the researchers examined the point prevalence of supraclinical threshold depressive symptoms/depressive disorders in AOID using 54 studies. The resulting study population included 12,635 patients: 6,977 with cervical dystonia, 732 with cranial dystonia, 4,504 with mixed forms, 303 with laryngeal dystonia, and 119 with upper-limb dystonia. The studies were published between 1988 and 2020, and included patients from 21 countries in 52 single-center studies and 2 multicenter studies.
Overall, the pooled prevalence of either supraclinical threshold depressive symptoms or depressive disorders was 31.5% for cervical dystonia, 29.2 % for cranial dystonia, and 33.6 % for clinical samples with mixed forms of AOID.
Among patients with cervical dystonia, major depressive disorder was more prevalent than dysthymia, but among patients with cranial dystonia, dysthymia was more prevalent. Among patients with mixed forms, the prevalence of major depressive disorder was higher than dysthymia. Heterogeneity varied among the studies but was higher in studies that used rating scales.
Treatment of patients with AOID does not take into account the impact of depression on quality of life, Dr. Escobar and colleagues reported.
“ Such model appears to be inefficient to guarantee resources to address these comorbidities within secondary or tertiary care, or through shared care pathways engaging both primary and hospital-based care.” They also said the use of antidepressants and cognitive-behavioral therapy as a way to target negative body concept or social stigma among these patients are “underexplored and underutilized.”
The study findings were limited by several factors, including the inclusion only of studies published in English. In addition, most of the studies were conducted at movement disorders clinics, which may have yielded a patient population with more severe AOID. Further limitations included the inability to perform subgroup analysis based on demographic and clinical factors, and the insufficient number of studies for meta-analysis of laryngeal and hand dystonia, Dr. Escobar and colleagues added.
However, the results represent the first pooled estimate of depression prevalence in AOID and confirm a high prevalence across different clinical forms, the researchers said. The heterogeneity across studies highlights the need for standardized screening for depression and improved diagnosis of mood disorders in AOID.
“The meta-analytic estimates provided here will be highly useful for the planning of future mechanistic and interventional studies, as well as for the redefinition of current models of care,” they concluded.
The study received no outside funding. Dr. Escobar and colleagues had no disclosures.
FROM NEUROSCIENCE AND BIOBEHAVIORAL REVIEWS
Insomnia in children tied to mood and anxiety disorders in adulthood
, new research indicates. However, insomnia symptoms in childhood that remit in the transition to adolescence do not confer increased risk of mood or anxiety disorders later on, the study found.
“As insomnia symptoms may precipitate or maintain internalizing disorders, our findings further reinforce the need for early sleep interventions to prevent future mental health disorders,” said lead investigator Julio Fernandez-Mendoza, PhD, associate professor at Penn State University, Hershey.
He presented his research at Virtual SLEEP 2021, the 35th annual meeting of the Associated Professional Sleep Societies.
Results ‘very clear’
The findings are based on data from the Penn State Child Cohort, a longitudinal, population-based sample of 700 children with a median age of 9 years, including 421 who were followed up 8 years later as adolescents (median age, 16 years) and 502 who were followed up 15 years later as young adults (median age, 24 years).
The data are “very clear that the risk of having internalizing disorders in young adulthood associated with having persistent insomnia symptoms, since childhood through adolescence into young adulthood,” Dr. Fernandez-Mendoza said in his presentation.
A persistent developmental trajectory was associated with a threefold increased risk of adult internalizing disorder (hazard ratio, 3.19).
The risk of having an internalizing disorder in young adulthood associated with newly developing (incident) insomnia symptoms is about twofold higher (HR, 1.94), whereas the risk associated with the waxing and waning pattern of insomnia is 1.5-fold (HR, 1.53) higher and only marginally significant, he reported.
An equally important finding, said Dr. Fernandez-Mendoza, is that those who had remitted insomnia symptoms in the transition to adolescence and throughout young adulthood were not at increased risk of having an internalizing disorder in young adulthood.
“Insomnia symptoms in a persistent manner associated with long-term adverse mental health outcomes, but remission of those insomnia symptoms associated with a good prognosis,” he said.
It’s also important to note, he said, that about 40% of children do not outgrow their insomnia symptoms in the transition to adolescence and are at risk of developing mental health disorders later on during early adulthood.
Reached for comment, Nitun Verma, MD, a spokesperson for the American Academy of Sleep Medicine, said: “There is a connection with mood and anxiety disorders with sleep, especially insomnia. This is a good reminder that reviewing someone’s sleep habits should always be a part of assessing someone’s mental health.”
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
, new research indicates. However, insomnia symptoms in childhood that remit in the transition to adolescence do not confer increased risk of mood or anxiety disorders later on, the study found.
“As insomnia symptoms may precipitate or maintain internalizing disorders, our findings further reinforce the need for early sleep interventions to prevent future mental health disorders,” said lead investigator Julio Fernandez-Mendoza, PhD, associate professor at Penn State University, Hershey.
He presented his research at Virtual SLEEP 2021, the 35th annual meeting of the Associated Professional Sleep Societies.
Results ‘very clear’
The findings are based on data from the Penn State Child Cohort, a longitudinal, population-based sample of 700 children with a median age of 9 years, including 421 who were followed up 8 years later as adolescents (median age, 16 years) and 502 who were followed up 15 years later as young adults (median age, 24 years).
The data are “very clear that the risk of having internalizing disorders in young adulthood associated with having persistent insomnia symptoms, since childhood through adolescence into young adulthood,” Dr. Fernandez-Mendoza said in his presentation.
A persistent developmental trajectory was associated with a threefold increased risk of adult internalizing disorder (hazard ratio, 3.19).
The risk of having an internalizing disorder in young adulthood associated with newly developing (incident) insomnia symptoms is about twofold higher (HR, 1.94), whereas the risk associated with the waxing and waning pattern of insomnia is 1.5-fold (HR, 1.53) higher and only marginally significant, he reported.
An equally important finding, said Dr. Fernandez-Mendoza, is that those who had remitted insomnia symptoms in the transition to adolescence and throughout young adulthood were not at increased risk of having an internalizing disorder in young adulthood.
“Insomnia symptoms in a persistent manner associated with long-term adverse mental health outcomes, but remission of those insomnia symptoms associated with a good prognosis,” he said.
It’s also important to note, he said, that about 40% of children do not outgrow their insomnia symptoms in the transition to adolescence and are at risk of developing mental health disorders later on during early adulthood.
Reached for comment, Nitun Verma, MD, a spokesperson for the American Academy of Sleep Medicine, said: “There is a connection with mood and anxiety disorders with sleep, especially insomnia. This is a good reminder that reviewing someone’s sleep habits should always be a part of assessing someone’s mental health.”
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
, new research indicates. However, insomnia symptoms in childhood that remit in the transition to adolescence do not confer increased risk of mood or anxiety disorders later on, the study found.
“As insomnia symptoms may precipitate or maintain internalizing disorders, our findings further reinforce the need for early sleep interventions to prevent future mental health disorders,” said lead investigator Julio Fernandez-Mendoza, PhD, associate professor at Penn State University, Hershey.
He presented his research at Virtual SLEEP 2021, the 35th annual meeting of the Associated Professional Sleep Societies.
Results ‘very clear’
The findings are based on data from the Penn State Child Cohort, a longitudinal, population-based sample of 700 children with a median age of 9 years, including 421 who were followed up 8 years later as adolescents (median age, 16 years) and 502 who were followed up 15 years later as young adults (median age, 24 years).
The data are “very clear that the risk of having internalizing disorders in young adulthood associated with having persistent insomnia symptoms, since childhood through adolescence into young adulthood,” Dr. Fernandez-Mendoza said in his presentation.
A persistent developmental trajectory was associated with a threefold increased risk of adult internalizing disorder (hazard ratio, 3.19).
The risk of having an internalizing disorder in young adulthood associated with newly developing (incident) insomnia symptoms is about twofold higher (HR, 1.94), whereas the risk associated with the waxing and waning pattern of insomnia is 1.5-fold (HR, 1.53) higher and only marginally significant, he reported.
An equally important finding, said Dr. Fernandez-Mendoza, is that those who had remitted insomnia symptoms in the transition to adolescence and throughout young adulthood were not at increased risk of having an internalizing disorder in young adulthood.
“Insomnia symptoms in a persistent manner associated with long-term adverse mental health outcomes, but remission of those insomnia symptoms associated with a good prognosis,” he said.
It’s also important to note, he said, that about 40% of children do not outgrow their insomnia symptoms in the transition to adolescence and are at risk of developing mental health disorders later on during early adulthood.
Reached for comment, Nitun Verma, MD, a spokesperson for the American Academy of Sleep Medicine, said: “There is a connection with mood and anxiety disorders with sleep, especially insomnia. This is a good reminder that reviewing someone’s sleep habits should always be a part of assessing someone’s mental health.”
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.
Neurodegeneration complicates psychiatric care for Parkinson’s patients
Managing depression and anxiety in Parkinson’s disease should start with a review of medications and involve multidisciplinary care, according to a recent summary of evidence.
“Depression and anxiety have a complex relationship with the disease and while the exact mechanism for this association is unknown, both disturbances occur with increased prevalence across the disease course and when present earlier in life, increase the risk of PD by about twofold,” wrote Gregory M. Pontone, MD, of Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, and colleagues.
Randomized trials to guide treatment of anxiety and depression in patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD) are limited, the researchers noted. However, data from a longitudinal study showed that PD patients whose depression remitted spontaneously or responded to treatment were able to attain a level of function similar to that of never-depressed PD patients, Dr. Pontone and colleagues said.
The researchers offered a pair of treatment algorithms to help guide clinicians in managing depression and anxiety in PD. However, a caveat to keep in mind is that “the benefit of antidepressant medications, used for depression or anxiety, can be confounded when motor symptoms are not optimally treated,” the researchers emphasized.
For depression, the researchers advised starting with some lab work; “at a minimum we suggest checking a complete blood count, metabolic panel, TSH, B12, and folate,” they noted. They recommended an antidepressant, cognitive-behavioral therapy, or both, as a first-line treatment, such as monotherapy with selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors or selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. They advised titrating the chosen monotherapy to a minimum effective dose over a 2- to 3-week period to assess response.
“We recommend continuing antidepressant therapy for at least 1 year based on literature in non-PD populations and anecdotal clinical experience. At 1 year, if not in remission, consider continuing treatment or augmenting to improve response,” the researchers said.
, and they recommended using anxiety rating scales to diagnose anxiety in PD. “Given the high prevalence of atypical anxiety syndromes in PD and their potential association with both motor and nonmotor symptoms of the disease, working with the neurologist to achieve optimal control of PD is an essential first step to alleviating anxiety,” they emphasized.
The researchers also advised addressing comorbidities, including cardiovascular disease, chronic pain, diabetes, gastrointestinal issues, hyperthyroidism, and lung disease, all of which can be associated with anxiety. Once comorbidities are addressed, they advised caution given the lack of evidence for efficacy of both pharmacologic and nonpharmacologic anxiety treatments for PD patients. However, first-tier treatment for anxiety could include monotherapy with serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors or selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, they said.
PD patients with depression and anxiety also may benefit from nonpharmacologic interventions, including exercise, mindfulness, relaxation therapy, and cognitive behavioral therapy the researchers said.
Although the algorithm may not differ significantly from current treatment protocols, it highlights aspects unique to PD patients, the researchers said. In particular, the algorithm shows “that interventions used for motor symptoms, for example, dopamine agonists, may be especially potent for mood in the PD population and that augmentation strategies, such as antipsychotics and lithium, may not be well tolerated given their outsized risk of adverse events in PD,” they said.
“While an article of this kind cannot hope to address the gap in knowledge on comparative efficacy between interventions, it can guide readers on the best strategies for implementation and risk mitigation in PD – essentially focusing more on effectiveness,” they concluded.
The study received no outside funding. Dr. Pontone disclosed serving as a consultant for Acadia Pharmaceuticals and Concert Pharmaceuticals.
Managing depression and anxiety in Parkinson’s disease should start with a review of medications and involve multidisciplinary care, according to a recent summary of evidence.
“Depression and anxiety have a complex relationship with the disease and while the exact mechanism for this association is unknown, both disturbances occur with increased prevalence across the disease course and when present earlier in life, increase the risk of PD by about twofold,” wrote Gregory M. Pontone, MD, of Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, and colleagues.
Randomized trials to guide treatment of anxiety and depression in patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD) are limited, the researchers noted. However, data from a longitudinal study showed that PD patients whose depression remitted spontaneously or responded to treatment were able to attain a level of function similar to that of never-depressed PD patients, Dr. Pontone and colleagues said.
The researchers offered a pair of treatment algorithms to help guide clinicians in managing depression and anxiety in PD. However, a caveat to keep in mind is that “the benefit of antidepressant medications, used for depression or anxiety, can be confounded when motor symptoms are not optimally treated,” the researchers emphasized.
For depression, the researchers advised starting with some lab work; “at a minimum we suggest checking a complete blood count, metabolic panel, TSH, B12, and folate,” they noted. They recommended an antidepressant, cognitive-behavioral therapy, or both, as a first-line treatment, such as monotherapy with selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors or selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. They advised titrating the chosen monotherapy to a minimum effective dose over a 2- to 3-week period to assess response.
“We recommend continuing antidepressant therapy for at least 1 year based on literature in non-PD populations and anecdotal clinical experience. At 1 year, if not in remission, consider continuing treatment or augmenting to improve response,” the researchers said.
, and they recommended using anxiety rating scales to diagnose anxiety in PD. “Given the high prevalence of atypical anxiety syndromes in PD and their potential association with both motor and nonmotor symptoms of the disease, working with the neurologist to achieve optimal control of PD is an essential first step to alleviating anxiety,” they emphasized.
The researchers also advised addressing comorbidities, including cardiovascular disease, chronic pain, diabetes, gastrointestinal issues, hyperthyroidism, and lung disease, all of which can be associated with anxiety. Once comorbidities are addressed, they advised caution given the lack of evidence for efficacy of both pharmacologic and nonpharmacologic anxiety treatments for PD patients. However, first-tier treatment for anxiety could include monotherapy with serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors or selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, they said.
PD patients with depression and anxiety also may benefit from nonpharmacologic interventions, including exercise, mindfulness, relaxation therapy, and cognitive behavioral therapy the researchers said.
Although the algorithm may not differ significantly from current treatment protocols, it highlights aspects unique to PD patients, the researchers said. In particular, the algorithm shows “that interventions used for motor symptoms, for example, dopamine agonists, may be especially potent for mood in the PD population and that augmentation strategies, such as antipsychotics and lithium, may not be well tolerated given their outsized risk of adverse events in PD,” they said.
“While an article of this kind cannot hope to address the gap in knowledge on comparative efficacy between interventions, it can guide readers on the best strategies for implementation and risk mitigation in PD – essentially focusing more on effectiveness,” they concluded.
The study received no outside funding. Dr. Pontone disclosed serving as a consultant for Acadia Pharmaceuticals and Concert Pharmaceuticals.
Managing depression and anxiety in Parkinson’s disease should start with a review of medications and involve multidisciplinary care, according to a recent summary of evidence.
“Depression and anxiety have a complex relationship with the disease and while the exact mechanism for this association is unknown, both disturbances occur with increased prevalence across the disease course and when present earlier in life, increase the risk of PD by about twofold,” wrote Gregory M. Pontone, MD, of Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, and colleagues.
Randomized trials to guide treatment of anxiety and depression in patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD) are limited, the researchers noted. However, data from a longitudinal study showed that PD patients whose depression remitted spontaneously or responded to treatment were able to attain a level of function similar to that of never-depressed PD patients, Dr. Pontone and colleagues said.
The researchers offered a pair of treatment algorithms to help guide clinicians in managing depression and anxiety in PD. However, a caveat to keep in mind is that “the benefit of antidepressant medications, used for depression or anxiety, can be confounded when motor symptoms are not optimally treated,” the researchers emphasized.
For depression, the researchers advised starting with some lab work; “at a minimum we suggest checking a complete blood count, metabolic panel, TSH, B12, and folate,” they noted. They recommended an antidepressant, cognitive-behavioral therapy, or both, as a first-line treatment, such as monotherapy with selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors or selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. They advised titrating the chosen monotherapy to a minimum effective dose over a 2- to 3-week period to assess response.
“We recommend continuing antidepressant therapy for at least 1 year based on literature in non-PD populations and anecdotal clinical experience. At 1 year, if not in remission, consider continuing treatment or augmenting to improve response,” the researchers said.
, and they recommended using anxiety rating scales to diagnose anxiety in PD. “Given the high prevalence of atypical anxiety syndromes in PD and their potential association with both motor and nonmotor symptoms of the disease, working with the neurologist to achieve optimal control of PD is an essential first step to alleviating anxiety,” they emphasized.
The researchers also advised addressing comorbidities, including cardiovascular disease, chronic pain, diabetes, gastrointestinal issues, hyperthyroidism, and lung disease, all of which can be associated with anxiety. Once comorbidities are addressed, they advised caution given the lack of evidence for efficacy of both pharmacologic and nonpharmacologic anxiety treatments for PD patients. However, first-tier treatment for anxiety could include monotherapy with serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors or selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, they said.
PD patients with depression and anxiety also may benefit from nonpharmacologic interventions, including exercise, mindfulness, relaxation therapy, and cognitive behavioral therapy the researchers said.
Although the algorithm may not differ significantly from current treatment protocols, it highlights aspects unique to PD patients, the researchers said. In particular, the algorithm shows “that interventions used for motor symptoms, for example, dopamine agonists, may be especially potent for mood in the PD population and that augmentation strategies, such as antipsychotics and lithium, may not be well tolerated given their outsized risk of adverse events in PD,” they said.
“While an article of this kind cannot hope to address the gap in knowledge on comparative efficacy between interventions, it can guide readers on the best strategies for implementation and risk mitigation in PD – essentially focusing more on effectiveness,” they concluded.
The study received no outside funding. Dr. Pontone disclosed serving as a consultant for Acadia Pharmaceuticals and Concert Pharmaceuticals.
FROM THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF GERIATRIC PSYCHIATRY
Incorporating self-care, wellness into routines can prevent doctors’ burnout
Gradually, we are emerging from the chaos, isolation, and anxiety of COVID-19. As the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention adjusts its recommendations and vaccinations become more widely available, our communities are beginning to return to normalcy. We are encouraged to put aside our masks if vaccinated and rejoin society, to venture out with less hesitancy and anxiety. As family and friends reunite, memories of confusion, frustration, and fear are beginning to fade to black. Despite the prevailing belief that we should move on, look forward, and remember the past to safeguard our future, remnants of the pandemic remain.
Unvaccinated individuals, notably children under the age of 12, are quite significant in number. The use of telehealth is now standard practice.
For several years, we were warned about the looming “mental health crisis.” The past year has demonstrated that a crisis no longer looms – it has arrived. Our patients can reveal the vulnerability COVID-19 has wrought – from the devastation of lives lost, supply shortages, loss of employment and financial stability – to a lack of access to computers and thereby, the risk of educational decline. Those factors, coupled with isolation and uncertainty about the future, have led to an influx of individuals with anxiety, depression, and other mood disorders seeking mental health treatment.
Doctors, others suffering
As result of a medical culture guided by the sacred oath to which care, compassion, and dedication held as true in ancient Greece as it does today, the focus centers on those around us – while signs of our own weariness are waved away as “a bad day.” Even though several support groups are readily available to offer a listening ear and mental health physicians who focus on the treatment of health care professionals are becoming more ubiquitous, the vestiges of past doctrine remain.
In this modern age of medical training, there is often as much sacrifice as there is attainment of knowledge. This philosophy is so ingrained that throughout training and practice one may come across colleagues experiencing an abundance of guilt when leave is needed for personal reasons. We are quick to recommend such steps for our patients, family, and friends, but hesitant to consider such for ourselves. Yet, of all the lessons this past year has wrought, the importance of mental health and self-care cannot be overstated. This raises the question:
It is vital to accept our humanity as something not to repair, treat, or overcome but to understand. There is strength and power in vulnerability. If we do not perceive and validate this process within ourselves, how can we do so for others? In other words, the oxygen mask must be placed on us first before we can place it on anyone else – patients or otherwise.
Chiefly and above all else, the importance of identifying individual signs of stress is essential. Where do you hold tension? Are you prone to GI distress or headaches when taxed? Do you tend toward irritability, apathy, or exhaustion?
Once this is determined, it is important to assess your stress on a numerical scale, such as those used for pain. Are you a 5 or an 8? Finally, are there identifiable triggers or reliable alleviators? Is there a time of day or day of the week that is most difficult to manage? Can you anticipate potential stressors? Understanding your triggers, listening to your body, and practicing the language of self is the first step toward wellness.
Following introspection and observation, the next step is inventory. Take stock of your reserves. What replenishes? What depletes? What brings joy? What brings dread? Are there certain activities that mitigate stress? If so, how much time do they entail? Identify your number on a scale and associate that number with specific strategies or techniques. Remember that decompression for a 6 might be excessive for a 4. Furthermore, what is the duration of these feelings? Chronic stressors may incur gradual change verses sudden impact if acute. Through identifying personal signs, devising and using a scale, as well as escalating or de-escalating factors, individuals become more in tune with their bodies and therefore, more likely to intervene before burnout takes hold.
With this process well integrated, one can now consider stylized approaches for stress management. For example, those inclined toward mindfulness practices may find yoga, meditation, and relaxation exercises beneficial. Others may thrive on positive affirmations, gratitude, and thankfulness. While some might find relief in physical activity, be it strenuous or casual, the creative arts might appeal to those who find joy in painting, writing, or doing crafts. In addition, baking, reading, dancing, and/or listening to music might help lift stress.
Along with those discoveries, or in some cases, rediscoveries, basic needs such as dietary habits and nutrition, hydration, and sleep are vital toward emotional regulation, physiological homeostasis, and stress modulation. Remember HALT: Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired, Too hot, Too cold, Sad or Stressed. Those strategies are meant to guide self-care and highlight the importance of allowing time for self-awareness. Imagine yourself as if you are meeting a new patient. Establish rapport, identify symptoms, and explore options for treatment. When we give time to ourselves, we can give time more freely to others. With this in mind, try following the 5-minute wellness check that I formulated:
1. How am I feeling? What am I feeling?
2. Assess HALTS.
3. Identify the number on your scale.
4. Methods of quick de-escalation:
- Designate and schedule personal time.
- Write down daily goals.
- Repeat positive affirmations or write down words of gratitude.
- Use deep breathing exercises.
- Stretch or take a brief walk.
- Engage in mindfulness practices, such as meditation.
Once we develop a habit of monitoring, assessing, and practicing self-care, the process becomes more efficient and effective. Think of the way a seasoned attending can manage workflow with ease, compared with an intern. Recognizing signs and using these strategies routinely can become a quick daily measure of well-being.
Dr. Thomas is a board-certified adult psychiatrist with interests in chronic illness, women’s behavioral health, and minority mental health. She currently practices in North Kingstown and East Providence, R.I. Dr. Thomas has no conflicts of interest.
Gradually, we are emerging from the chaos, isolation, and anxiety of COVID-19. As the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention adjusts its recommendations and vaccinations become more widely available, our communities are beginning to return to normalcy. We are encouraged to put aside our masks if vaccinated and rejoin society, to venture out with less hesitancy and anxiety. As family and friends reunite, memories of confusion, frustration, and fear are beginning to fade to black. Despite the prevailing belief that we should move on, look forward, and remember the past to safeguard our future, remnants of the pandemic remain.
Unvaccinated individuals, notably children under the age of 12, are quite significant in number. The use of telehealth is now standard practice.
For several years, we were warned about the looming “mental health crisis.” The past year has demonstrated that a crisis no longer looms – it has arrived. Our patients can reveal the vulnerability COVID-19 has wrought – from the devastation of lives lost, supply shortages, loss of employment and financial stability – to a lack of access to computers and thereby, the risk of educational decline. Those factors, coupled with isolation and uncertainty about the future, have led to an influx of individuals with anxiety, depression, and other mood disorders seeking mental health treatment.
Doctors, others suffering
As result of a medical culture guided by the sacred oath to which care, compassion, and dedication held as true in ancient Greece as it does today, the focus centers on those around us – while signs of our own weariness are waved away as “a bad day.” Even though several support groups are readily available to offer a listening ear and mental health physicians who focus on the treatment of health care professionals are becoming more ubiquitous, the vestiges of past doctrine remain.
In this modern age of medical training, there is often as much sacrifice as there is attainment of knowledge. This philosophy is so ingrained that throughout training and practice one may come across colleagues experiencing an abundance of guilt when leave is needed for personal reasons. We are quick to recommend such steps for our patients, family, and friends, but hesitant to consider such for ourselves. Yet, of all the lessons this past year has wrought, the importance of mental health and self-care cannot be overstated. This raises the question:
It is vital to accept our humanity as something not to repair, treat, or overcome but to understand. There is strength and power in vulnerability. If we do not perceive and validate this process within ourselves, how can we do so for others? In other words, the oxygen mask must be placed on us first before we can place it on anyone else – patients or otherwise.
Chiefly and above all else, the importance of identifying individual signs of stress is essential. Where do you hold tension? Are you prone to GI distress or headaches when taxed? Do you tend toward irritability, apathy, or exhaustion?
Once this is determined, it is important to assess your stress on a numerical scale, such as those used for pain. Are you a 5 or an 8? Finally, are there identifiable triggers or reliable alleviators? Is there a time of day or day of the week that is most difficult to manage? Can you anticipate potential stressors? Understanding your triggers, listening to your body, and practicing the language of self is the first step toward wellness.
Following introspection and observation, the next step is inventory. Take stock of your reserves. What replenishes? What depletes? What brings joy? What brings dread? Are there certain activities that mitigate stress? If so, how much time do they entail? Identify your number on a scale and associate that number with specific strategies or techniques. Remember that decompression for a 6 might be excessive for a 4. Furthermore, what is the duration of these feelings? Chronic stressors may incur gradual change verses sudden impact if acute. Through identifying personal signs, devising and using a scale, as well as escalating or de-escalating factors, individuals become more in tune with their bodies and therefore, more likely to intervene before burnout takes hold.
With this process well integrated, one can now consider stylized approaches for stress management. For example, those inclined toward mindfulness practices may find yoga, meditation, and relaxation exercises beneficial. Others may thrive on positive affirmations, gratitude, and thankfulness. While some might find relief in physical activity, be it strenuous or casual, the creative arts might appeal to those who find joy in painting, writing, or doing crafts. In addition, baking, reading, dancing, and/or listening to music might help lift stress.
Along with those discoveries, or in some cases, rediscoveries, basic needs such as dietary habits and nutrition, hydration, and sleep are vital toward emotional regulation, physiological homeostasis, and stress modulation. Remember HALT: Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired, Too hot, Too cold, Sad or Stressed. Those strategies are meant to guide self-care and highlight the importance of allowing time for self-awareness. Imagine yourself as if you are meeting a new patient. Establish rapport, identify symptoms, and explore options for treatment. When we give time to ourselves, we can give time more freely to others. With this in mind, try following the 5-minute wellness check that I formulated:
1. How am I feeling? What am I feeling?
2. Assess HALTS.
3. Identify the number on your scale.
4. Methods of quick de-escalation:
- Designate and schedule personal time.
- Write down daily goals.
- Repeat positive affirmations or write down words of gratitude.
- Use deep breathing exercises.
- Stretch or take a brief walk.
- Engage in mindfulness practices, such as meditation.
Once we develop a habit of monitoring, assessing, and practicing self-care, the process becomes more efficient and effective. Think of the way a seasoned attending can manage workflow with ease, compared with an intern. Recognizing signs and using these strategies routinely can become a quick daily measure of well-being.
Dr. Thomas is a board-certified adult psychiatrist with interests in chronic illness, women’s behavioral health, and minority mental health. She currently practices in North Kingstown and East Providence, R.I. Dr. Thomas has no conflicts of interest.
Gradually, we are emerging from the chaos, isolation, and anxiety of COVID-19. As the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention adjusts its recommendations and vaccinations become more widely available, our communities are beginning to return to normalcy. We are encouraged to put aside our masks if vaccinated and rejoin society, to venture out with less hesitancy and anxiety. As family and friends reunite, memories of confusion, frustration, and fear are beginning to fade to black. Despite the prevailing belief that we should move on, look forward, and remember the past to safeguard our future, remnants of the pandemic remain.
Unvaccinated individuals, notably children under the age of 12, are quite significant in number. The use of telehealth is now standard practice.
For several years, we were warned about the looming “mental health crisis.” The past year has demonstrated that a crisis no longer looms – it has arrived. Our patients can reveal the vulnerability COVID-19 has wrought – from the devastation of lives lost, supply shortages, loss of employment and financial stability – to a lack of access to computers and thereby, the risk of educational decline. Those factors, coupled with isolation and uncertainty about the future, have led to an influx of individuals with anxiety, depression, and other mood disorders seeking mental health treatment.
Doctors, others suffering
As result of a medical culture guided by the sacred oath to which care, compassion, and dedication held as true in ancient Greece as it does today, the focus centers on those around us – while signs of our own weariness are waved away as “a bad day.” Even though several support groups are readily available to offer a listening ear and mental health physicians who focus on the treatment of health care professionals are becoming more ubiquitous, the vestiges of past doctrine remain.
In this modern age of medical training, there is often as much sacrifice as there is attainment of knowledge. This philosophy is so ingrained that throughout training and practice one may come across colleagues experiencing an abundance of guilt when leave is needed for personal reasons. We are quick to recommend such steps for our patients, family, and friends, but hesitant to consider such for ourselves. Yet, of all the lessons this past year has wrought, the importance of mental health and self-care cannot be overstated. This raises the question:
It is vital to accept our humanity as something not to repair, treat, or overcome but to understand. There is strength and power in vulnerability. If we do not perceive and validate this process within ourselves, how can we do so for others? In other words, the oxygen mask must be placed on us first before we can place it on anyone else – patients or otherwise.
Chiefly and above all else, the importance of identifying individual signs of stress is essential. Where do you hold tension? Are you prone to GI distress or headaches when taxed? Do you tend toward irritability, apathy, or exhaustion?
Once this is determined, it is important to assess your stress on a numerical scale, such as those used for pain. Are you a 5 or an 8? Finally, are there identifiable triggers or reliable alleviators? Is there a time of day or day of the week that is most difficult to manage? Can you anticipate potential stressors? Understanding your triggers, listening to your body, and practicing the language of self is the first step toward wellness.
Following introspection and observation, the next step is inventory. Take stock of your reserves. What replenishes? What depletes? What brings joy? What brings dread? Are there certain activities that mitigate stress? If so, how much time do they entail? Identify your number on a scale and associate that number with specific strategies or techniques. Remember that decompression for a 6 might be excessive for a 4. Furthermore, what is the duration of these feelings? Chronic stressors may incur gradual change verses sudden impact if acute. Through identifying personal signs, devising and using a scale, as well as escalating or de-escalating factors, individuals become more in tune with their bodies and therefore, more likely to intervene before burnout takes hold.
With this process well integrated, one can now consider stylized approaches for stress management. For example, those inclined toward mindfulness practices may find yoga, meditation, and relaxation exercises beneficial. Others may thrive on positive affirmations, gratitude, and thankfulness. While some might find relief in physical activity, be it strenuous or casual, the creative arts might appeal to those who find joy in painting, writing, or doing crafts. In addition, baking, reading, dancing, and/or listening to music might help lift stress.
Along with those discoveries, or in some cases, rediscoveries, basic needs such as dietary habits and nutrition, hydration, and sleep are vital toward emotional regulation, physiological homeostasis, and stress modulation. Remember HALT: Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired, Too hot, Too cold, Sad or Stressed. Those strategies are meant to guide self-care and highlight the importance of allowing time for self-awareness. Imagine yourself as if you are meeting a new patient. Establish rapport, identify symptoms, and explore options for treatment. When we give time to ourselves, we can give time more freely to others. With this in mind, try following the 5-minute wellness check that I formulated:
1. How am I feeling? What am I feeling?
2. Assess HALTS.
3. Identify the number on your scale.
4. Methods of quick de-escalation:
- Designate and schedule personal time.
- Write down daily goals.
- Repeat positive affirmations or write down words of gratitude.
- Use deep breathing exercises.
- Stretch or take a brief walk.
- Engage in mindfulness practices, such as meditation.
Once we develop a habit of monitoring, assessing, and practicing self-care, the process becomes more efficient and effective. Think of the way a seasoned attending can manage workflow with ease, compared with an intern. Recognizing signs and using these strategies routinely can become a quick daily measure of well-being.
Dr. Thomas is a board-certified adult psychiatrist with interests in chronic illness, women’s behavioral health, and minority mental health. She currently practices in North Kingstown and East Providence, R.I. Dr. Thomas has no conflicts of interest.