Hair & Nails

Complementary alternative medicine (CAM) has been described by the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine as “health care approaches that are not typically part of conventional medical care or that may have origins outside of usual Western practice.”¹ Although this definition is broad, CAM encompasses therapies such as traditional Chinese medicine, herbal therapies, dietary supplements, and mind/body interventions. The use of CAM has grown, and according to a 2012 National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health survey, more than 30% of US adults and 12% of US children use health care approaches that are considered outside of conventional medical practice. In a survey study of US adults, at least 17.7% of respondents said they had taken a dietary supplement other than a vitamin or mineral in the last year.¹ Data from the 2007 National Health Interview Survey showed that the prevalence of adults with skin conditions using CAM was 84.5% compared to 38.3% in the general population.² In addition, 8.15 million US patients with dermatologic conditions reported using CAM over a 5-year period.³ Complementary alternative medicine has emerged as an alternative or adjunct to standard treatments, making it important for dermatologists to understand the existing literature on these therapies. Herein, we review the current evidence-based literature that exists on CAM for the treatment of atopic dermatitis (AD), psoriasis, and alopecia areata (AA).

Atopic Dermatitis

Atopic dermatitis is a chronic, pruritic, inflammatory skin condition with considerable morbidity.^4,5 The pathophysiology of AD is multifactorial and includes aspects of barrier dysfunction, IgE hypersensitivity, abnormal cell-mediated immune response, and environmental factors.⁶ Atopic dermatitis also is one of the most common inflammatory skin conditions in adults, affecting more than 7% of the US population and up to 20% of the total population in developed countries. Of those affected, 40% have moderate or severe symptoms that result in a substantial impact on quality of life.⁷ Despite advances in understanding disease pathology and treatment, a subset of patients opt to defer conventional treatments such as topical and systemic corticosteroids, antibiotics, nonsteroidal immunomodulators, and biologics. Patients may seek alternative therapies when typical treatments fail or when the perceived side effects outweigh the benefits.^5,8 The use of CAM has been well described in patients with AD; however, the existing evidence supporting its use along with its safety profile have not been thoroughly explored. Herein, we will discuss some of the most well-studied supplements for treatment of AD, including evening primrose oil (EPO), fish oil, and probiotics.⁵

Oral supplementation with polyunsaturated fatty acids commonly is reported in patients with AD.^5,8 The idea that a fatty acid deficiency could lead to atopic skin conditions has been around since 1937, when it was suggested that patients with AD had lower levels of blood unsaturated fatty acids.⁹ Conflicting evidence regarding oral fatty acid ingestion and AD disease severity has emerged.^10,11 One unsaturated fatty acid, γ-linolenic acid (GLA), has demonstrated anti-inflammatory properties and involvement in barrier repair.¹² It is converted to dihomo-GLA in the body, which acts on cyclooxygenase enzymes to produce the inflammatory mediator prostaglandin E₁. The production of GLA is mediated by the enzyme delta-6 desaturase in the metabolization of linoleic acid.¹² However, it has been reported that in a subset of patients with AD, a malfunction of delta-6 desaturase may play a role in disease progression and result in lower baseline levels of GLA.^10,12 Evening primrose oil and borage oil contain high amounts of GLA (8%–10% and 23%, respectively); thus, supplementation with these oils has been studied in AD.¹³

EPO for AD
Studies investigating EPO (Oenothera biennis) and its association with AD severity have shown mixed results. A Cochrane review reported that oral borage oil and EPO were not effective treatments for AD,¹⁴ while another larger randomized controlled trial (RCT) found no statistically significant improvement in AD symptoms.¹⁵ However, multiple smaller studies have found that clinical symptoms of AD, such as erythema, xerosis, pruritus, and total body surface area involved, did improve with oral EPO supplementation when compared to placebo, and the results were statistically significant (P=.04).^16,17 One study looked at different dosages of EPO and found that groups ingesting both 160 mg and 320 mg daily experienced reductions in eczema area and severity index score, with greater improvement noted with the higher dosage.¹⁷ Side effects associated with oral EPO include an anticoagulant effect and transient gastrointestinal tract upset.^8,14 There currently is not enough evidence or safety data to recommend this supplement to AD patients.

Although topical use of fatty acids with high concentrations of GLA, such as EPO and borage oil, have demonstrated improvement in subjective symptom severity, most studies have not reached statistical significance.^10,11 One study used a 10% EPO cream for 2 weeks compared to placebo and found statistically significant improvement in patient-reported AD symptoms (P=.045). However, this study only included 10 participants, and therefore larger studies are necessary to confirm this result.¹⁸ Some RCTs have shown that topical coconut oil, sunflower seed oil, and sandalwood album oil improve AD symptom severity, but again, large controlled trials are needed.⁵ Unfortunately, many essential oils, including EPO, can cause a secondary allergic contact dermatitis and potentially worsen AD.¹⁹

Fish Oil for AD
Fish oil is a commonly used supplement for AD due to its high content of the omega-3 fatty acids eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). Omega-3 fatty acids exert anti-inflammatory effects by displacing arachidonic acid, a proinflammatory omega-6 fatty acid thought to increase IgE, as well as helper T cell (T_H2) cytokines and prostaglandin E₂.^8,20 A 2012 Cochrane review found that, while some studies revealed mild improvement in AD symptoms with oral fish oil supplementation, these RCTs were of poor methodological quality.²¹ Multiple smaller studies have shown a decrease in pruritus, severity, and physician-rated clinical scores with fish oil use.^5,8,20,22 One study with 145 participants reported that 6 g of fish oil once daily compared to isoenergetic corn oil for 16 weeks identified no statistically significant differences between the treatment groups.²⁰ No adverse events were identified in any of the reported trials. Further studies should be conducted to assess the utility and dosing of fish oil supplements in AD patients.

Probiotics for AD
Probiotics consist of live microorganisms that enhance the microflora of the gastrointestinal tract.^8,20 They have been shown to influence food digestion and also have demonstrated potential influence on the skin-gut axis.²³ The theory that intestinal dysbiosis plays a role in AD pathogenesis has been investigated in multiple studies.^23-25 The central premise is that low-fiber and high-fat Western diets lead to fundamental changes in the gut microbiome, resulting in fewer anti-inflammatory metabolites, such as short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs).^23-25 These SCFAs are produced by microbes during the fermentation of dietary fiber and are known for their effect on epithelial barrier integrity and anti-inflammatory properties mediated through G protein–coupled receptor 43.²⁵ Multiple studies have shown that the gut microbiome in patients with AD have higher proportions of Clostridium difficile, Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus aureus and lower levels of Bifidobacterium, Bacteroidetes, and Bacteroides species compared to healthy controls.^26,27 Metagenomic analysis of fecal samples from patients with AD have shown a reduction of Faecalibacterium prausnitzii species when compared to controls, along with a decreased SCFA production, leading to the hypothesis that the gut microbiome may play a role in epithelial barrier disruption.^28,29 Systematic reviews and smaller studies have found that oral probiotic use does lead to AD symptom improvement.^8,30,31 A systematic review of 25 RCTs with 1599 participants found that supplementation with oral probiotics significantly decreased the SCORAD (SCORing Atopic Dermatitis) index in adults and children older than 1 year with AD but had no effect on infants younger than 1 year (P<.001). They also found that supplementation with diverse microbes or Lactobacillus species showed greater benefit than Bifidobacterium species alone.³⁰ Another study analyzed the effect of oral Lactobacillus fermentum (1×10⁹ CFU twice daily) in 53 children with AD vs placebo for 16 weeks. This study found a statically significant decrease in SCORAD index between oral probiotics and placebo, with 92% (n=24) of participants supplementing with probiotics having a lower SCORAD index than baseline compared to 63% (n=17) in the placebo group (P=.01).³¹ However, the use of probiotics for AD treatment has remained controversial. Two recent systematic reviews, including 39 RCTs of 2599 randomized patients, found that the use of currently available oral probiotics made little or no difference in patient-rated AD symptoms, investigator-rated AD symptoms, or quality of life.^32,33 No adverse effects were observed in the included studies. Unfortunately, the individual RCTs included were heterogeneous, and future studies with standardized probiotic supplementation should be undertaken before probiotics can be routinely recommended.

The use of topical probiotics in AD also has recently emerged. Multiple studies have shown that patients with AD have higher levels of colonization with S aureus, which is associated with T-cell dysfunction, more severe allergic skin reactions, and disruptions in barrier function.^34,35 Therefore, altering the skin microbiota through topical probiotics could theoretically reduce AD symptoms and flares. Multiple RCTs and smaller studies have shown that topical probiotics can alter the skin microbiota, improve erythema, and decrease scaling and pruritus in AD patients.^35-38 One study used a heat-treated Lactobacillus johnsonii 0.3% lotion twice daily for 3 weeks vs placebo in patients with AD with positive S aureus skin cultures. The S aureus load decreased in patients using the topical probiotic lotion, which correlated with lower SCORAD index that was statistically significant compared to placebo (P=.012).³⁶ More robust studies are needed to determine if topical probiotics should routinely be recommended in AD.

Psoriasis

Psoriasis vulgaris is a chronic inflammatory skin condition characterized by pruritic, hyperkeratotic, scaly plaques.^39,40 Keratinocyte hyperproliferation is central to psoriasis pathogenesis and is thought to be a T-cell–driven reaction to antigens or trauma in genetically predisposed individuals. Standard treatments for psoriasis currently include topical corticosteroids and anti-inflammatories, oral immunomodulatory therapy, biologic agents, and phototherapy.⁴⁰ The use of CAM is highly prevalent among patients with psoriasis, with one study reporting that 51% (n=162) of psoriatic patients interviewed had used CAM.⁴¹ The most common reasons for CAM use included dissatisfaction with current treatment, adverse side effects of standard therapy, and patient-reported attempts at “trying everything to heal disease.”⁴² Herein, we will discuss some of the most frequently used supplements for treatment of psoriatic disease.³⁹

Fish Oil for Psoriasis
One of the most common supplements used by patients with psoriasis is fish oil due to its purported anti-inflammatory qualities.^20,39 The consensus on fish oil supplementation for psoriasis is mixed.^43-45 Multiple RCTs have reported reductions in psoriasis area and severity index (PASI) scores or symptomatic improvement with variable doses of fish oil.^44,46 One RCT found that using EPA 1.8 g once daily and DHA 1.2 g once daily for 12 weeks resulted in significant improvement in pruritus, scaling, and erythema (P<.05).⁴⁴ Another study reported a significant decrease in erythema (P=.02) and total body surface area affected (P=.0001) with EPA 3.6 g once daily and DHA 2.4 g once daily supplementation compared to olive oil supplementation for 15 weeks.⁴⁶ Alternatively, multiple studies have failed to show statistically significant improvement in psoriatic symptoms with fish oil supplementation at variable doses and time frames (14–216 mg daily EPA, 9–80 mg daily DHA, from 2 weeks to 9 months).^40,47,48 Fish oil may impart anticoagulant properties and should not be started without the guidance of a physician. Currently, there are no data to make specific recommendations on the use of fish oil as an adjunct psoriatic treatment.

Curcumin for Psoriasis
Another supplement routinely utilized in patients with psoriasis is curcumin,^40,49,50 a yellow phytochemical that is a major component of the spice turmeric. Curcumin has been shown to inhibit certain proinflammatory cytokines including IL-17, IL-6, IFN-γ, and tumor necrosis factor α and has been regarded as having immune-modulating, anti-inflammatory, and antibacterial properties.^40,50 Curcumin also has been reported to suppress phosphorylase kinase, an enzyme that has increased activity in psoriatic plaques that correlates with markers of psoriatic hyperproliferation.^50,51 When applied topically, turmeric microgel 0.5% has been reported to decrease scaling, erythema, and psoriatic plaque thickness over the course of 9 weeks.⁵⁰ In a nonrandomized trial with 10 participants, researchers found that phosphorylase kinase activity levels in psoriatic skin biopsies of patients applying topical curcumin 1% were lower than placebo and topical calcipotriol applied in combination. The lower phosphorylase kinase levels correlated with level of disease severity, and topical curcumin 1% showed a superior outcome when compared to topical calcipotriol.^40,49 Although these preliminary results are interesting, there still are not enough data at this time to recommend topical curcumin as a treatment of psoriasis. No known adverse events have been reported with the use of topical curcumin to date.

Oral curcumin has poor oral bioavailability, and 40% to 90% of oral doses are excreted, making supplementation a challenge.⁴⁰ In one RCT, oral curcumin 2 g daily (using a lecithin-based delivery system to increase bioavailability) was administered in combination with topical methylprednisolone aceponate 0.1%, resulting in significant improvement in psoriatic symptoms and lower IL-22 compared to placebo and topical methylprednisolone aceponate (P<.05).⁵² Other studies also have reported decreased PASI scores with oral curcumin supplementation.^53,54 Adverse effects reported with oral curcumin included gastrointestinal tract upset and hot flashes.⁵³ Although there is early evidence that may support the use of oral curcumin supplementation for psoriasis, more data are needed before recommending this therapy.

Indigo Naturalis for Psoriasis
Topical indigo naturalis (IN) also has been reported to improve psoriasis symptoms.^39,53,55 The antipsoriatic effects are thought to occur through the active ingredient in IN (indirubin), which is responsible for inhibition of keratinocyte proliferation.⁴⁰ One study reported that topical IN 1.4% containing indirubin 0.16% with a petroleum ointment vehicle applied to psoriatic plaques over 12 weeks resulted in a significant decrease in PASI scores from 18.9 at baseline to 6.3 after IN treatment (P<.001).⁵⁶ Another study found that over 8 weeks, topical application of IN 2.83% containing indirubin 0.24% to psoriatic plaques vs petroleum jelly resulted in 56.3% (n=9) of the treatment group achieving PASI 75 compared to 0% in the placebo group (n=24).⁵⁵ One deterrent in topical IN treatment is the dark blue pigment it contains; however, no other adverse outcomes were found with topical IN treatment.⁵⁶ Larger clinical trials are necessary to further explore IN as a potential adjunct treatment in patients with mild psoriatic disease. When taken orally, IN has caused gastrointestinal tract disturbance and elevated liver enzyme levels.⁵⁷

Herbal Toxicities
It is important to consider that oral supplements including curcumin and IN are widely available over-the-counter and online without oversight by the US Food and Drug Administration.⁴⁰ Herbal supplements typically are compounded with other ingredients and have been associated with hepatotoxicity as well as drug-supplement interactions, including abnormal bleeding and clotting.⁵⁸ There exists a lack of general surveillance data, making the true burden of herbal toxicities more difficult to accurately discern. Although some supplements have been associated with anti-inflammatory qualities and disease improvement, other herbal supplements have been shown to possess immunostimulatory characteristics. Herbal supplements such as spirulina, chlorella, Aphanizomenon flos-aquae, and echinacea have been shown to upregulate inflammatory pathways in a variety of autoimmune skin conditions.⁵⁹

Probiotics for Psoriasis
Data on probiotic use in patients with psoriasis are limited.²³ A distinct pattern of dysbiosis has been identified in psoriatic patients, as there is thought to be depletion of beneficial bacteria such as Bifidobacterium, lactobacilli, and F prausnitzii and increased colonization with pathogenic organisms such as Salmonella, E coli, Heliobacter, Campylobacter, and Alcaligenes in psoriasis patients.^23,59,60 Early mouse studies have supported this hypothesis, as mice fed with Lactobacillus pentosus have developed milder forms of imiquimod-induced psoriasis compared to placebo,⁵⁵ and mice receiving probiotic supplementation have lower levels of psoriasis-related proinflammatory markers such as T_H17-associated cytokines.⁶¹ Another study in humans found that daily oral Bifidobacterium infantis supplementation for 8 weeks in psoriatic patients resulted in lower C-reactive protein and tumor necrosis factor α levels compared to placebo.⁶² Studies on the use of topical probiotics in psoriasis have been limited, and more research is needed to explore this relationship.³⁸ At this time, no specific recommendations can be made on the use of probiotics in psoriatic patients.

Alopecia Areata

Alopecia areata is nonscarring hair loss that can affect the scalp, face, or body.^63,64 The pathophysiology of AA involves the attack of the hair follicle matrix epithelium by inflammatory cells without hair follicle stem cell destruction. The precise events that precipitate these episodes are unknown, but triggers such as emotional or physical stress, vaccines, or viral infections have been reported.⁶⁵ There is no cure for AA, and current treatments such as topical minoxidil and corticosteroids (topical, intralesional, or oral) vary widely in efficacy.⁶⁴ Although Janus kinase inhibitors recently have shown promising results in the treatment of AA, the need for prolonged therapy may be frustrating to patients.⁶⁶ Severity of AA also can vary, with 30% of patients experiencing extensive hair loss.⁶⁷ The use of CAM has been widely reported in AA due to high levels of dissatisfaction with existing therapies.⁶⁸ Herein, we discuss the most studied alternative treatments used in AA

Garlic and Onion for Alopecia
One alternative treatment that has shown promising initial results is application of topical garlic and onion extracts to affected areas.^64,69,70 Both garlic and onion belong to the Allium genus and are high in sulfur and phenolic compounds.⁷⁰ They have been reported to possess bactericidal and vasodilatory activity,⁷¹ and it has been hypothesized that onion and garlic extracts may induce therapeutic effects through induction of a mild contact dermatitis.⁷⁰ One single-blinded, controlled trial using topical crude onion juice reported that 86.9% (n=20) of patients had full regrowth of hair compared to 13.3% (n=2) of patients treated with a tap water placebo at 8 weeks (P<.0001). This study also noted that patients using onion juice had a higher rate of erythema at application site; unfortunately, the study was small with only 38 patients.⁷⁰ Another double-blind RCT using garlic gel 5% with betamethasone valerate cream 0.1% compared to betamethasone valerate cream alone found that after 3 months, patients in the garlic gel group had increased terminal hairs and smaller patch sizes compared to the betamethasone valerate cream group.⁶⁹ More studies are needed to confirm these results.

Aromatherapy With Essential Oils for Alopecia
Another alternative treatment in AA that has demonstrated positive results is aromatherapy skin massage with essential oils to patches of alopecia.⁷² Although certain essential oils, such as tea tree oil, have been reported to have specific antibacterial or anti-inflammatory properties, essential oils have been reported to cause allergic contact dermatitis and should be used with caution.^73,74 For example, tea tree oil is a well-known cause of allergic contact dermatitis, and positive patch testing has ranged from 0.1% to 3.5% in studies assessing topical tea tree oil 5% application.⁷⁵ Overall, there have been nearly 80 essential oils implicated in contact dermatitis, with high-concentration products being one of the highest risk factors for an allergic contact reaction.⁷⁶ One RCT compared daily scalp massage with essential oils (rosemary, lavender, thyme, and cedarwood in a carrier oil) to daily scalp massage with a placebo carrier oil in AA patients. The results showed that at 7 months of treatment, 44% (n=19) of the aromatherapy group showed improvement compared to 15% (n=6) in the control group.⁷⁷ Another study used a similar group of essential oils (thyme, rosemary, atlas cedar, lavender, and EPO in a carrier oil) with daily scalp massage and reported similar improvement of AA symptoms compared to control; the investigators also reported irritation at application site in 1 patient.⁷⁸ There currently are not enough data to recommend aromatherapy skin massage for the treatment of AA, and this practice may cause harm to the patient by induction of allergic contact dermatitis.

There have been a few studies to suggest that the use of total glucosides of peony with compound glycyrrhizin and oral Korean red ginseng may have beneficial effects on AA treatment, but efficacy and safety data are lacking, and these therapies should not be recommended without more information.^64,79,80

Final Thoughts

Dermatologic patients frequently are opting for CAM,² and although some therapies may show promising initial results, alternative medicines also can drive adverse events.^19,30 The lack of oversight from the US Food and Drug Administration on the products leads to many unknowns for true health risks with over-the-counter CAM supplements.⁴⁰ As the use of CAM becomes increasingly common among dermatologic patients, it is important for dermatologists to understand the benefits and risks, especially for commonly treated conditions. More data is needed before CAM can be routinely recommended.

Complementary alternative medicine (CAM) has been described by the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine as “health care approaches that are not typically part of conventional medical care or that may have origins outside of usual Western practice.”¹ Although this definition is broad, CAM encompasses therapies such as traditional Chinese medicine, herbal therapies, dietary supplements, and mind/body interventions. The use of CAM has grown, and according to a 2012 National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health survey, more than 30% of US adults and 12% of US children use health care approaches that are considered outside of conventional medical practice. In a survey study of US adults, at least 17.7% of respondents said they had taken a dietary supplement other than a vitamin or mineral in the last year.¹ Data from the 2007 National Health Interview Survey showed that the prevalence of adults with skin conditions using CAM was 84.5% compared to 38.3% in the general population.² In addition, 8.15 million US patients with dermatologic conditions reported using CAM over a 5-year period.³ Complementary alternative medicine has emerged as an alternative or adjunct to standard treatments, making it important for dermatologists to understand the existing literature on these therapies. Herein, we review the current evidence-based literature that exists on CAM for the treatment of atopic dermatitis (AD), psoriasis, and alopecia areata (AA).

Atopic Dermatitis

Atopic dermatitis is a chronic, pruritic, inflammatory skin condition with considerable morbidity.^4,5 The pathophysiology of AD is multifactorial and includes aspects of barrier dysfunction, IgE hypersensitivity, abnormal cell-mediated immune response, and environmental factors.⁶ Atopic dermatitis also is one of the most common inflammatory skin conditions in adults, affecting more than 7% of the US population and up to 20% of the total population in developed countries. Of those affected, 40% have moderate or severe symptoms that result in a substantial impact on quality of life.⁷ Despite advances in understanding disease pathology and treatment, a subset of patients opt to defer conventional treatments such as topical and systemic corticosteroids, antibiotics, nonsteroidal immunomodulators, and biologics. Patients may seek alternative therapies when typical treatments fail or when the perceived side effects outweigh the benefits.^5,8 The use of CAM has been well described in patients with AD; however, the existing evidence supporting its use along with its safety profile have not been thoroughly explored. Herein, we will discuss some of the most well-studied supplements for treatment of AD, including evening primrose oil (EPO), fish oil, and probiotics.⁵

Oral supplementation with polyunsaturated fatty acids commonly is reported in patients with AD.^5,8 The idea that a fatty acid deficiency could lead to atopic skin conditions has been around since 1937, when it was suggested that patients with AD had lower levels of blood unsaturated fatty acids.⁹ Conflicting evidence regarding oral fatty acid ingestion and AD disease severity has emerged.^10,11 One unsaturated fatty acid, γ-linolenic acid (GLA), has demonstrated anti-inflammatory properties and involvement in barrier repair.¹² It is converted to dihomo-GLA in the body, which acts on cyclooxygenase enzymes to produce the inflammatory mediator prostaglandin E₁. The production of GLA is mediated by the enzyme delta-6 desaturase in the metabolization of linoleic acid.¹² However, it has been reported that in a subset of patients with AD, a malfunction of delta-6 desaturase may play a role in disease progression and result in lower baseline levels of GLA.^10,12 Evening primrose oil and borage oil contain high amounts of GLA (8%–10% and 23%, respectively); thus, supplementation with these oils has been studied in AD.¹³

EPO for AD
Studies investigating EPO (Oenothera biennis) and its association with AD severity have shown mixed results. A Cochrane review reported that oral borage oil and EPO were not effective treatments for AD,¹⁴ while another larger randomized controlled trial (RCT) found no statistically significant improvement in AD symptoms.¹⁵ However, multiple smaller studies have found that clinical symptoms of AD, such as erythema, xerosis, pruritus, and total body surface area involved, did improve with oral EPO supplementation when compared to placebo, and the results were statistically significant (P=.04).^16,17 One study looked at different dosages of EPO and found that groups ingesting both 160 mg and 320 mg daily experienced reductions in eczema area and severity index score, with greater improvement noted with the higher dosage.¹⁷ Side effects associated with oral EPO include an anticoagulant effect and transient gastrointestinal tract upset.^8,14 There currently is not enough evidence or safety data to recommend this supplement to AD patients.

Although topical use of fatty acids with high concentrations of GLA, such as EPO and borage oil, have demonstrated improvement in subjective symptom severity, most studies have not reached statistical significance.^10,11 One study used a 10% EPO cream for 2 weeks compared to placebo and found statistically significant improvement in patient-reported AD symptoms (P=.045). However, this study only included 10 participants, and therefore larger studies are necessary to confirm this result.¹⁸ Some RCTs have shown that topical coconut oil, sunflower seed oil, and sandalwood album oil improve AD symptom severity, but again, large controlled trials are needed.⁵ Unfortunately, many essential oils, including EPO, can cause a secondary allergic contact dermatitis and potentially worsen AD.¹⁹

Fish Oil for AD
Fish oil is a commonly used supplement for AD due to its high content of the omega-3 fatty acids eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). Omega-3 fatty acids exert anti-inflammatory effects by displacing arachidonic acid, a proinflammatory omega-6 fatty acid thought to increase IgE, as well as helper T cell (T_H2) cytokines and prostaglandin E₂.^8,20 A 2012 Cochrane review found that, while some studies revealed mild improvement in AD symptoms with oral fish oil supplementation, these RCTs were of poor methodological quality.²¹ Multiple smaller studies have shown a decrease in pruritus, severity, and physician-rated clinical scores with fish oil use.^5,8,20,22 One study with 145 participants reported that 6 g of fish oil once daily compared to isoenergetic corn oil for 16 weeks identified no statistically significant differences between the treatment groups.²⁰ No adverse events were identified in any of the reported trials. Further studies should be conducted to assess the utility and dosing of fish oil supplements in AD patients.

Probiotics for AD
Probiotics consist of live microorganisms that enhance the microflora of the gastrointestinal tract.^8,20 They have been shown to influence food digestion and also have demonstrated potential influence on the skin-gut axis.²³ The theory that intestinal dysbiosis plays a role in AD pathogenesis has been investigated in multiple studies.^23-25 The central premise is that low-fiber and high-fat Western diets lead to fundamental changes in the gut microbiome, resulting in fewer anti-inflammatory metabolites, such as short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs).^23-25 These SCFAs are produced by microbes during the fermentation of dietary fiber and are known for their effect on epithelial barrier integrity and anti-inflammatory properties mediated through G protein–coupled receptor 43.²⁵ Multiple studies have shown that the gut microbiome in patients with AD have higher proportions of Clostridium difficile, Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus aureus and lower levels of Bifidobacterium, Bacteroidetes, and Bacteroides species compared to healthy controls.^26,27 Metagenomic analysis of fecal samples from patients with AD have shown a reduction of Faecalibacterium prausnitzii species when compared to controls, along with a decreased SCFA production, leading to the hypothesis that the gut microbiome may play a role in epithelial barrier disruption.^28,29 Systematic reviews and smaller studies have found that oral probiotic use does lead to AD symptom improvement.^8,30,31 A systematic review of 25 RCTs with 1599 participants found that supplementation with oral probiotics significantly decreased the SCORAD (SCORing Atopic Dermatitis) index in adults and children older than 1 year with AD but had no effect on infants younger than 1 year (P<.001). They also found that supplementation with diverse microbes or Lactobacillus species showed greater benefit than Bifidobacterium species alone.³⁰ Another study analyzed the effect of oral Lactobacillus fermentum (1×10⁹ CFU twice daily) in 53 children with AD vs placebo for 16 weeks. This study found a statically significant decrease in SCORAD index between oral probiotics and placebo, with 92% (n=24) of participants supplementing with probiotics having a lower SCORAD index than baseline compared to 63% (n=17) in the placebo group (P=.01).³¹ However, the use of probiotics for AD treatment has remained controversial. Two recent systematic reviews, including 39 RCTs of 2599 randomized patients, found that the use of currently available oral probiotics made little or no difference in patient-rated AD symptoms, investigator-rated AD symptoms, or quality of life.^32,33 No adverse effects were observed in the included studies. Unfortunately, the individual RCTs included were heterogeneous, and future studies with standardized probiotic supplementation should be undertaken before probiotics can be routinely recommended.

The use of topical probiotics in AD also has recently emerged. Multiple studies have shown that patients with AD have higher levels of colonization with S aureus, which is associated with T-cell dysfunction, more severe allergic skin reactions, and disruptions in barrier function.^34,35 Therefore, altering the skin microbiota through topical probiotics could theoretically reduce AD symptoms and flares. Multiple RCTs and smaller studies have shown that topical probiotics can alter the skin microbiota, improve erythema, and decrease scaling and pruritus in AD patients.^35-38 One study used a heat-treated Lactobacillus johnsonii 0.3% lotion twice daily for 3 weeks vs placebo in patients with AD with positive S aureus skin cultures. The S aureus load decreased in patients using the topical probiotic lotion, which correlated with lower SCORAD index that was statistically significant compared to placebo (P=.012).³⁶ More robust studies are needed to determine if topical probiotics should routinely be recommended in AD.

Psoriasis

Psoriasis vulgaris is a chronic inflammatory skin condition characterized by pruritic, hyperkeratotic, scaly plaques.^39,40 Keratinocyte hyperproliferation is central to psoriasis pathogenesis and is thought to be a T-cell–driven reaction to antigens or trauma in genetically predisposed individuals. Standard treatments for psoriasis currently include topical corticosteroids and anti-inflammatories, oral immunomodulatory therapy, biologic agents, and phototherapy.⁴⁰ The use of CAM is highly prevalent among patients with psoriasis, with one study reporting that 51% (n=162) of psoriatic patients interviewed had used CAM.⁴¹ The most common reasons for CAM use included dissatisfaction with current treatment, adverse side effects of standard therapy, and patient-reported attempts at “trying everything to heal disease.”⁴² Herein, we will discuss some of the most frequently used supplements for treatment of psoriatic disease.³⁹

Fish Oil for Psoriasis
One of the most common supplements used by patients with psoriasis is fish oil due to its purported anti-inflammatory qualities.^20,39 The consensus on fish oil supplementation for psoriasis is mixed.^43-45 Multiple RCTs have reported reductions in psoriasis area and severity index (PASI) scores or symptomatic improvement with variable doses of fish oil.^44,46 One RCT found that using EPA 1.8 g once daily and DHA 1.2 g once daily for 12 weeks resulted in significant improvement in pruritus, scaling, and erythema (P<.05).⁴⁴ Another study reported a significant decrease in erythema (P=.02) and total body surface area affected (P=.0001) with EPA 3.6 g once daily and DHA 2.4 g once daily supplementation compared to olive oil supplementation for 15 weeks.⁴⁶ Alternatively, multiple studies have failed to show statistically significant improvement in psoriatic symptoms with fish oil supplementation at variable doses and time frames (14–216 mg daily EPA, 9–80 mg daily DHA, from 2 weeks to 9 months).^40,47,48 Fish oil may impart anticoagulant properties and should not be started without the guidance of a physician. Currently, there are no data to make specific recommendations on the use of fish oil as an adjunct psoriatic treatment.

Curcumin for Psoriasis
Another supplement routinely utilized in patients with psoriasis is curcumin,^40,49,50 a yellow phytochemical that is a major component of the spice turmeric. Curcumin has been shown to inhibit certain proinflammatory cytokines including IL-17, IL-6, IFN-γ, and tumor necrosis factor α and has been regarded as having immune-modulating, anti-inflammatory, and antibacterial properties.^40,50 Curcumin also has been reported to suppress phosphorylase kinase, an enzyme that has increased activity in psoriatic plaques that correlates with markers of psoriatic hyperproliferation.^50,51 When applied topically, turmeric microgel 0.5% has been reported to decrease scaling, erythema, and psoriatic plaque thickness over the course of 9 weeks.⁵⁰ In a nonrandomized trial with 10 participants, researchers found that phosphorylase kinase activity levels in psoriatic skin biopsies of patients applying topical curcumin 1% were lower than placebo and topical calcipotriol applied in combination. The lower phosphorylase kinase levels correlated with level of disease severity, and topical curcumin 1% showed a superior outcome when compared to topical calcipotriol.^40,49 Although these preliminary results are interesting, there still are not enough data at this time to recommend topical curcumin as a treatment of psoriasis. No known adverse events have been reported with the use of topical curcumin to date.

Oral curcumin has poor oral bioavailability, and 40% to 90% of oral doses are excreted, making supplementation a challenge.⁴⁰ In one RCT, oral curcumin 2 g daily (using a lecithin-based delivery system to increase bioavailability) was administered in combination with topical methylprednisolone aceponate 0.1%, resulting in significant improvement in psoriatic symptoms and lower IL-22 compared to placebo and topical methylprednisolone aceponate (P<.05).⁵² Other studies also have reported decreased PASI scores with oral curcumin supplementation.^53,54 Adverse effects reported with oral curcumin included gastrointestinal tract upset and hot flashes.⁵³ Although there is early evidence that may support the use of oral curcumin supplementation for psoriasis, more data are needed before recommending this therapy.

Indigo Naturalis for Psoriasis
Topical indigo naturalis (IN) also has been reported to improve psoriasis symptoms.^39,53,55 The antipsoriatic effects are thought to occur through the active ingredient in IN (indirubin), which is responsible for inhibition of keratinocyte proliferation.⁴⁰ One study reported that topical IN 1.4% containing indirubin 0.16% with a petroleum ointment vehicle applied to psoriatic plaques over 12 weeks resulted in a significant decrease in PASI scores from 18.9 at baseline to 6.3 after IN treatment (P<.001).⁵⁶ Another study found that over 8 weeks, topical application of IN 2.83% containing indirubin 0.24% to psoriatic plaques vs petroleum jelly resulted in 56.3% (n=9) of the treatment group achieving PASI 75 compared to 0% in the placebo group (n=24).⁵⁵ One deterrent in topical IN treatment is the dark blue pigment it contains; however, no other adverse outcomes were found with topical IN treatment.⁵⁶ Larger clinical trials are necessary to further explore IN as a potential adjunct treatment in patients with mild psoriatic disease. When taken orally, IN has caused gastrointestinal tract disturbance and elevated liver enzyme levels.⁵⁷

Herbal Toxicities
It is important to consider that oral supplements including curcumin and IN are widely available over-the-counter and online without oversight by the US Food and Drug Administration.⁴⁰ Herbal supplements typically are compounded with other ingredients and have been associated with hepatotoxicity as well as drug-supplement interactions, including abnormal bleeding and clotting.⁵⁸ There exists a lack of general surveillance data, making the true burden of herbal toxicities more difficult to accurately discern. Although some supplements have been associated with anti-inflammatory qualities and disease improvement, other herbal supplements have been shown to possess immunostimulatory characteristics. Herbal supplements such as spirulina, chlorella, Aphanizomenon flos-aquae, and echinacea have been shown to upregulate inflammatory pathways in a variety of autoimmune skin conditions.⁵⁹

Probiotics for Psoriasis
Data on probiotic use in patients with psoriasis are limited.²³ A distinct pattern of dysbiosis has been identified in psoriatic patients, as there is thought to be depletion of beneficial bacteria such as Bifidobacterium, lactobacilli, and F prausnitzii and increased colonization with pathogenic organisms such as Salmonella, E coli, Heliobacter, Campylobacter, and Alcaligenes in psoriasis patients.^23,59,60 Early mouse studies have supported this hypothesis, as mice fed with Lactobacillus pentosus have developed milder forms of imiquimod-induced psoriasis compared to placebo,⁵⁵ and mice receiving probiotic supplementation have lower levels of psoriasis-related proinflammatory markers such as T_H17-associated cytokines.⁶¹ Another study in humans found that daily oral Bifidobacterium infantis supplementation for 8 weeks in psoriatic patients resulted in lower C-reactive protein and tumor necrosis factor α levels compared to placebo.⁶² Studies on the use of topical probiotics in psoriasis have been limited, and more research is needed to explore this relationship.³⁸ At this time, no specific recommendations can be made on the use of probiotics in psoriatic patients.

Alopecia Areata

Alopecia areata is nonscarring hair loss that can affect the scalp, face, or body.^63,64 The pathophysiology of AA involves the attack of the hair follicle matrix epithelium by inflammatory cells without hair follicle stem cell destruction. The precise events that precipitate these episodes are unknown, but triggers such as emotional or physical stress, vaccines, or viral infections have been reported.⁶⁵ There is no cure for AA, and current treatments such as topical minoxidil and corticosteroids (topical, intralesional, or oral) vary widely in efficacy.⁶⁴ Although Janus kinase inhibitors recently have shown promising results in the treatment of AA, the need for prolonged therapy may be frustrating to patients.⁶⁶ Severity of AA also can vary, with 30% of patients experiencing extensive hair loss.⁶⁷ The use of CAM has been widely reported in AA due to high levels of dissatisfaction with existing therapies.⁶⁸ Herein, we discuss the most studied alternative treatments used in AA

Garlic and Onion for Alopecia
One alternative treatment that has shown promising initial results is application of topical garlic and onion extracts to affected areas.^64,69,70 Both garlic and onion belong to the Allium genus and are high in sulfur and phenolic compounds.⁷⁰ They have been reported to possess bactericidal and vasodilatory activity,⁷¹ and it has been hypothesized that onion and garlic extracts may induce therapeutic effects through induction of a mild contact dermatitis.⁷⁰ One single-blinded, controlled trial using topical crude onion juice reported that 86.9% (n=20) of patients had full regrowth of hair compared to 13.3% (n=2) of patients treated with a tap water placebo at 8 weeks (P<.0001). This study also noted that patients using onion juice had a higher rate of erythema at application site; unfortunately, the study was small with only 38 patients.⁷⁰ Another double-blind RCT using garlic gel 5% with betamethasone valerate cream 0.1% compared to betamethasone valerate cream alone found that after 3 months, patients in the garlic gel group had increased terminal hairs and smaller patch sizes compared to the betamethasone valerate cream group.⁶⁹ More studies are needed to confirm these results.

Aromatherapy With Essential Oils for Alopecia
Another alternative treatment in AA that has demonstrated positive results is aromatherapy skin massage with essential oils to patches of alopecia.⁷² Although certain essential oils, such as tea tree oil, have been reported to have specific antibacterial or anti-inflammatory properties, essential oils have been reported to cause allergic contact dermatitis and should be used with caution.^73,74 For example, tea tree oil is a well-known cause of allergic contact dermatitis, and positive patch testing has ranged from 0.1% to 3.5% in studies assessing topical tea tree oil 5% application.⁷⁵ Overall, there have been nearly 80 essential oils implicated in contact dermatitis, with high-concentration products being one of the highest risk factors for an allergic contact reaction.⁷⁶ One RCT compared daily scalp massage with essential oils (rosemary, lavender, thyme, and cedarwood in a carrier oil) to daily scalp massage with a placebo carrier oil in AA patients. The results showed that at 7 months of treatment, 44% (n=19) of the aromatherapy group showed improvement compared to 15% (n=6) in the control group.⁷⁷ Another study used a similar group of essential oils (thyme, rosemary, atlas cedar, lavender, and EPO in a carrier oil) with daily scalp massage and reported similar improvement of AA symptoms compared to control; the investigators also reported irritation at application site in 1 patient.⁷⁸ There currently are not enough data to recommend aromatherapy skin massage for the treatment of AA, and this practice may cause harm to the patient by induction of allergic contact dermatitis.

There have been a few studies to suggest that the use of total glucosides of peony with compound glycyrrhizin and oral Korean red ginseng may have beneficial effects on AA treatment, but efficacy and safety data are lacking, and these therapies should not be recommended without more information.^64,79,80

Final Thoughts

Dermatologic patients frequently are opting for CAM,² and although some therapies may show promising initial results, alternative medicines also can drive adverse events.^19,30 The lack of oversight from the US Food and Drug Administration on the products leads to many unknowns for true health risks with over-the-counter CAM supplements.⁴⁰ As the use of CAM becomes increasingly common among dermatologic patients, it is important for dermatologists to understand the benefits and risks, especially for commonly treated conditions. More data is needed before CAM can be routinely recommended.

Complementary alternative medicine (CAM) has been described by the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine as “health care approaches that are not typically part of conventional medical care or that may have origins outside of usual Western practice.”¹ Although this definition is broad, CAM encompasses therapies such as traditional Chinese medicine, herbal therapies, dietary supplements, and mind/body interventions. The use of CAM has grown, and according to a 2012 National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health survey, more than 30% of US adults and 12% of US children use health care approaches that are considered outside of conventional medical practice. In a survey study of US adults, at least 17.7% of respondents said they had taken a dietary supplement other than a vitamin or mineral in the last year.¹ Data from the 2007 National Health Interview Survey showed that the prevalence of adults with skin conditions using CAM was 84.5% compared to 38.3% in the general population.² In addition, 8.15 million US patients with dermatologic conditions reported using CAM over a 5-year period.³ Complementary alternative medicine has emerged as an alternative or adjunct to standard treatments, making it important for dermatologists to understand the existing literature on these therapies. Herein, we review the current evidence-based literature that exists on CAM for the treatment of atopic dermatitis (AD), psoriasis, and alopecia areata (AA).

Atopic Dermatitis

Atopic dermatitis is a chronic, pruritic, inflammatory skin condition with considerable morbidity.^4,5 The pathophysiology of AD is multifactorial and includes aspects of barrier dysfunction, IgE hypersensitivity, abnormal cell-mediated immune response, and environmental factors.⁶ Atopic dermatitis also is one of the most common inflammatory skin conditions in adults, affecting more than 7% of the US population and up to 20% of the total population in developed countries. Of those affected, 40% have moderate or severe symptoms that result in a substantial impact on quality of life.⁷ Despite advances in understanding disease pathology and treatment, a subset of patients opt to defer conventional treatments such as topical and systemic corticosteroids, antibiotics, nonsteroidal immunomodulators, and biologics. Patients may seek alternative therapies when typical treatments fail or when the perceived side effects outweigh the benefits.^5,8 The use of CAM has been well described in patients with AD; however, the existing evidence supporting its use along with its safety profile have not been thoroughly explored. Herein, we will discuss some of the most well-studied supplements for treatment of AD, including evening primrose oil (EPO), fish oil, and probiotics.⁵

Oral supplementation with polyunsaturated fatty acids commonly is reported in patients with AD.^5,8 The idea that a fatty acid deficiency could lead to atopic skin conditions has been around since 1937, when it was suggested that patients with AD had lower levels of blood unsaturated fatty acids.⁹ Conflicting evidence regarding oral fatty acid ingestion and AD disease severity has emerged.^10,11 One unsaturated fatty acid, γ-linolenic acid (GLA), has demonstrated anti-inflammatory properties and involvement in barrier repair.¹² It is converted to dihomo-GLA in the body, which acts on cyclooxygenase enzymes to produce the inflammatory mediator prostaglandin E₁. The production of GLA is mediated by the enzyme delta-6 desaturase in the metabolization of linoleic acid.¹² However, it has been reported that in a subset of patients with AD, a malfunction of delta-6 desaturase may play a role in disease progression and result in lower baseline levels of GLA.^10,12 Evening primrose oil and borage oil contain high amounts of GLA (8%–10% and 23%, respectively); thus, supplementation with these oils has been studied in AD.¹³

EPO for AD
Studies investigating EPO (Oenothera biennis) and its association with AD severity have shown mixed results. A Cochrane review reported that oral borage oil and EPO were not effective treatments for AD,¹⁴ while another larger randomized controlled trial (RCT) found no statistically significant improvement in AD symptoms.¹⁵ However, multiple smaller studies have found that clinical symptoms of AD, such as erythema, xerosis, pruritus, and total body surface area involved, did improve with oral EPO supplementation when compared to placebo, and the results were statistically significant (P=.04).^16,17 One study looked at different dosages of EPO and found that groups ingesting both 160 mg and 320 mg daily experienced reductions in eczema area and severity index score, with greater improvement noted with the higher dosage.¹⁷ Side effects associated with oral EPO include an anticoagulant effect and transient gastrointestinal tract upset.^8,14 There currently is not enough evidence or safety data to recommend this supplement to AD patients.

Although topical use of fatty acids with high concentrations of GLA, such as EPO and borage oil, have demonstrated improvement in subjective symptom severity, most studies have not reached statistical significance.^10,11 One study used a 10% EPO cream for 2 weeks compared to placebo and found statistically significant improvement in patient-reported AD symptoms (P=.045). However, this study only included 10 participants, and therefore larger studies are necessary to confirm this result.¹⁸ Some RCTs have shown that topical coconut oil, sunflower seed oil, and sandalwood album oil improve AD symptom severity, but again, large controlled trials are needed.⁵ Unfortunately, many essential oils, including EPO, can cause a secondary allergic contact dermatitis and potentially worsen AD.¹⁹

Fish Oil for AD
Fish oil is a commonly used supplement for AD due to its high content of the omega-3 fatty acids eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). Omega-3 fatty acids exert anti-inflammatory effects by displacing arachidonic acid, a proinflammatory omega-6 fatty acid thought to increase IgE, as well as helper T cell (T_H2) cytokines and prostaglandin E₂.^8,20 A 2012 Cochrane review found that, while some studies revealed mild improvement in AD symptoms with oral fish oil supplementation, these RCTs were of poor methodological quality.²¹ Multiple smaller studies have shown a decrease in pruritus, severity, and physician-rated clinical scores with fish oil use.^5,8,20,22 One study with 145 participants reported that 6 g of fish oil once daily compared to isoenergetic corn oil for 16 weeks identified no statistically significant differences between the treatment groups.²⁰ No adverse events were identified in any of the reported trials. Further studies should be conducted to assess the utility and dosing of fish oil supplements in AD patients.

Probiotics for AD
Probiotics consist of live microorganisms that enhance the microflora of the gastrointestinal tract.^8,20 They have been shown to influence food digestion and also have demonstrated potential influence on the skin-gut axis.²³ The theory that intestinal dysbiosis plays a role in AD pathogenesis has been investigated in multiple studies.^23-25 The central premise is that low-fiber and high-fat Western diets lead to fundamental changes in the gut microbiome, resulting in fewer anti-inflammatory metabolites, such as short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs).^23-25 These SCFAs are produced by microbes during the fermentation of dietary fiber and are known for their effect on epithelial barrier integrity and anti-inflammatory properties mediated through G protein–coupled receptor 43.²⁵ Multiple studies have shown that the gut microbiome in patients with AD have higher proportions of Clostridium difficile, Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus aureus and lower levels of Bifidobacterium, Bacteroidetes, and Bacteroides species compared to healthy controls.^26,27 Metagenomic analysis of fecal samples from patients with AD have shown a reduction of Faecalibacterium prausnitzii species when compared to controls, along with a decreased SCFA production, leading to the hypothesis that the gut microbiome may play a role in epithelial barrier disruption.^28,29 Systematic reviews and smaller studies have found that oral probiotic use does lead to AD symptom improvement.^8,30,31 A systematic review of 25 RCTs with 1599 participants found that supplementation with oral probiotics significantly decreased the SCORAD (SCORing Atopic Dermatitis) index in adults and children older than 1 year with AD but had no effect on infants younger than 1 year (P<.001). They also found that supplementation with diverse microbes or Lactobacillus species showed greater benefit than Bifidobacterium species alone.³⁰ Another study analyzed the effect of oral Lactobacillus fermentum (1×10⁹ CFU twice daily) in 53 children with AD vs placebo for 16 weeks. This study found a statically significant decrease in SCORAD index between oral probiotics and placebo, with 92% (n=24) of participants supplementing with probiotics having a lower SCORAD index than baseline compared to 63% (n=17) in the placebo group (P=.01).³¹ However, the use of probiotics for AD treatment has remained controversial. Two recent systematic reviews, including 39 RCTs of 2599 randomized patients, found that the use of currently available oral probiotics made little or no difference in patient-rated AD symptoms, investigator-rated AD symptoms, or quality of life.^32,33 No adverse effects were observed in the included studies. Unfortunately, the individual RCTs included were heterogeneous, and future studies with standardized probiotic supplementation should be undertaken before probiotics can be routinely recommended.

The use of topical probiotics in AD also has recently emerged. Multiple studies have shown that patients with AD have higher levels of colonization with S aureus, which is associated with T-cell dysfunction, more severe allergic skin reactions, and disruptions in barrier function.^34,35 Therefore, altering the skin microbiota through topical probiotics could theoretically reduce AD symptoms and flares. Multiple RCTs and smaller studies have shown that topical probiotics can alter the skin microbiota, improve erythema, and decrease scaling and pruritus in AD patients.^35-38 One study used a heat-treated Lactobacillus johnsonii 0.3% lotion twice daily for 3 weeks vs placebo in patients with AD with positive S aureus skin cultures. The S aureus load decreased in patients using the topical probiotic lotion, which correlated with lower SCORAD index that was statistically significant compared to placebo (P=.012).³⁶ More robust studies are needed to determine if topical probiotics should routinely be recommended in AD.

Psoriasis

Psoriasis vulgaris is a chronic inflammatory skin condition characterized by pruritic, hyperkeratotic, scaly plaques.^39,40 Keratinocyte hyperproliferation is central to psoriasis pathogenesis and is thought to be a T-cell–driven reaction to antigens or trauma in genetically predisposed individuals. Standard treatments for psoriasis currently include topical corticosteroids and anti-inflammatories, oral immunomodulatory therapy, biologic agents, and phototherapy.⁴⁰ The use of CAM is highly prevalent among patients with psoriasis, with one study reporting that 51% (n=162) of psoriatic patients interviewed had used CAM.⁴¹ The most common reasons for CAM use included dissatisfaction with current treatment, adverse side effects of standard therapy, and patient-reported attempts at “trying everything to heal disease.”⁴² Herein, we will discuss some of the most frequently used supplements for treatment of psoriatic disease.³⁹

Fish Oil for Psoriasis
One of the most common supplements used by patients with psoriasis is fish oil due to its purported anti-inflammatory qualities.^20,39 The consensus on fish oil supplementation for psoriasis is mixed.^43-45 Multiple RCTs have reported reductions in psoriasis area and severity index (PASI) scores or symptomatic improvement with variable doses of fish oil.^44,46 One RCT found that using EPA 1.8 g once daily and DHA 1.2 g once daily for 12 weeks resulted in significant improvement in pruritus, scaling, and erythema (P<.05).⁴⁴ Another study reported a significant decrease in erythema (P=.02) and total body surface area affected (P=.0001) with EPA 3.6 g once daily and DHA 2.4 g once daily supplementation compared to olive oil supplementation for 15 weeks.⁴⁶ Alternatively, multiple studies have failed to show statistically significant improvement in psoriatic symptoms with fish oil supplementation at variable doses and time frames (14–216 mg daily EPA, 9–80 mg daily DHA, from 2 weeks to 9 months).^40,47,48 Fish oil may impart anticoagulant properties and should not be started without the guidance of a physician. Currently, there are no data to make specific recommendations on the use of fish oil as an adjunct psoriatic treatment.

Curcumin for Psoriasis
Another supplement routinely utilized in patients with psoriasis is curcumin,^40,49,50 a yellow phytochemical that is a major component of the spice turmeric. Curcumin has been shown to inhibit certain proinflammatory cytokines including IL-17, IL-6, IFN-γ, and tumor necrosis factor α and has been regarded as having immune-modulating, anti-inflammatory, and antibacterial properties.^40,50 Curcumin also has been reported to suppress phosphorylase kinase, an enzyme that has increased activity in psoriatic plaques that correlates with markers of psoriatic hyperproliferation.^50,51 When applied topically, turmeric microgel 0.5% has been reported to decrease scaling, erythema, and psoriatic plaque thickness over the course of 9 weeks.⁵⁰ In a nonrandomized trial with 10 participants, researchers found that phosphorylase kinase activity levels in psoriatic skin biopsies of patients applying topical curcumin 1% were lower than placebo and topical calcipotriol applied in combination. The lower phosphorylase kinase levels correlated with level of disease severity, and topical curcumin 1% showed a superior outcome when compared to topical calcipotriol.^40,49 Although these preliminary results are interesting, there still are not enough data at this time to recommend topical curcumin as a treatment of psoriasis. No known adverse events have been reported with the use of topical curcumin to date.

Oral curcumin has poor oral bioavailability, and 40% to 90% of oral doses are excreted, making supplementation a challenge.⁴⁰ In one RCT, oral curcumin 2 g daily (using a lecithin-based delivery system to increase bioavailability) was administered in combination with topical methylprednisolone aceponate 0.1%, resulting in significant improvement in psoriatic symptoms and lower IL-22 compared to placebo and topical methylprednisolone aceponate (P<.05).⁵² Other studies also have reported decreased PASI scores with oral curcumin supplementation.^53,54 Adverse effects reported with oral curcumin included gastrointestinal tract upset and hot flashes.⁵³ Although there is early evidence that may support the use of oral curcumin supplementation for psoriasis, more data are needed before recommending this therapy.

Indigo Naturalis for Psoriasis
Topical indigo naturalis (IN) also has been reported to improve psoriasis symptoms.^39,53,55 The antipsoriatic effects are thought to occur through the active ingredient in IN (indirubin), which is responsible for inhibition of keratinocyte proliferation.⁴⁰ One study reported that topical IN 1.4% containing indirubin 0.16% with a petroleum ointment vehicle applied to psoriatic plaques over 12 weeks resulted in a significant decrease in PASI scores from 18.9 at baseline to 6.3 after IN treatment (P<.001).⁵⁶ Another study found that over 8 weeks, topical application of IN 2.83% containing indirubin 0.24% to psoriatic plaques vs petroleum jelly resulted in 56.3% (n=9) of the treatment group achieving PASI 75 compared to 0% in the placebo group (n=24).⁵⁵ One deterrent in topical IN treatment is the dark blue pigment it contains; however, no other adverse outcomes were found with topical IN treatment.⁵⁶ Larger clinical trials are necessary to further explore IN as a potential adjunct treatment in patients with mild psoriatic disease. When taken orally, IN has caused gastrointestinal tract disturbance and elevated liver enzyme levels.⁵⁷

Herbal Toxicities
It is important to consider that oral supplements including curcumin and IN are widely available over-the-counter and online without oversight by the US Food and Drug Administration.⁴⁰ Herbal supplements typically are compounded with other ingredients and have been associated with hepatotoxicity as well as drug-supplement interactions, including abnormal bleeding and clotting.⁵⁸ There exists a lack of general surveillance data, making the true burden of herbal toxicities more difficult to accurately discern. Although some supplements have been associated with anti-inflammatory qualities and disease improvement, other herbal supplements have been shown to possess immunostimulatory characteristics. Herbal supplements such as spirulina, chlorella, Aphanizomenon flos-aquae, and echinacea have been shown to upregulate inflammatory pathways in a variety of autoimmune skin conditions.⁵⁹

Probiotics for Psoriasis
Data on probiotic use in patients with psoriasis are limited.²³ A distinct pattern of dysbiosis has been identified in psoriatic patients, as there is thought to be depletion of beneficial bacteria such as Bifidobacterium, lactobacilli, and F prausnitzii and increased colonization with pathogenic organisms such as Salmonella, E coli, Heliobacter, Campylobacter, and Alcaligenes in psoriasis patients.^23,59,60 Early mouse studies have supported this hypothesis, as mice fed with Lactobacillus pentosus have developed milder forms of imiquimod-induced psoriasis compared to placebo,⁵⁵ and mice receiving probiotic supplementation have lower levels of psoriasis-related proinflammatory markers such as T_H17-associated cytokines.⁶¹ Another study in humans found that daily oral Bifidobacterium infantis supplementation for 8 weeks in psoriatic patients resulted in lower C-reactive protein and tumor necrosis factor α levels compared to placebo.⁶² Studies on the use of topical probiotics in psoriasis have been limited, and more research is needed to explore this relationship.³⁸ At this time, no specific recommendations can be made on the use of probiotics in psoriatic patients.

Alopecia Areata

Alopecia areata is nonscarring hair loss that can affect the scalp, face, or body.^63,64 The pathophysiology of AA involves the attack of the hair follicle matrix epithelium by inflammatory cells without hair follicle stem cell destruction. The precise events that precipitate these episodes are unknown, but triggers such as emotional or physical stress, vaccines, or viral infections have been reported.⁶⁵ There is no cure for AA, and current treatments such as topical minoxidil and corticosteroids (topical, intralesional, or oral) vary widely in efficacy.⁶⁴ Although Janus kinase inhibitors recently have shown promising results in the treatment of AA, the need for prolonged therapy may be frustrating to patients.⁶⁶ Severity of AA also can vary, with 30% of patients experiencing extensive hair loss.⁶⁷ The use of CAM has been widely reported in AA due to high levels of dissatisfaction with existing therapies.⁶⁸ Herein, we discuss the most studied alternative treatments used in AA

Garlic and Onion for Alopecia
One alternative treatment that has shown promising initial results is application of topical garlic and onion extracts to affected areas.^64,69,70 Both garlic and onion belong to the Allium genus and are high in sulfur and phenolic compounds.⁷⁰ They have been reported to possess bactericidal and vasodilatory activity,⁷¹ and it has been hypothesized that onion and garlic extracts may induce therapeutic effects through induction of a mild contact dermatitis.⁷⁰ One single-blinded, controlled trial using topical crude onion juice reported that 86.9% (n=20) of patients had full regrowth of hair compared to 13.3% (n=2) of patients treated with a tap water placebo at 8 weeks (P<.0001). This study also noted that patients using onion juice had a higher rate of erythema at application site; unfortunately, the study was small with only 38 patients.⁷⁰ Another double-blind RCT using garlic gel 5% with betamethasone valerate cream 0.1% compared to betamethasone valerate cream alone found that after 3 months, patients in the garlic gel group had increased terminal hairs and smaller patch sizes compared to the betamethasone valerate cream group.⁶⁹ More studies are needed to confirm these results.

Aromatherapy With Essential Oils for Alopecia
Another alternative treatment in AA that has demonstrated positive results is aromatherapy skin massage with essential oils to patches of alopecia.⁷² Although certain essential oils, such as tea tree oil, have been reported to have specific antibacterial or anti-inflammatory properties, essential oils have been reported to cause allergic contact dermatitis and should be used with caution.^73,74 For example, tea tree oil is a well-known cause of allergic contact dermatitis, and positive patch testing has ranged from 0.1% to 3.5% in studies assessing topical tea tree oil 5% application.⁷⁵ Overall, there have been nearly 80 essential oils implicated in contact dermatitis, with high-concentration products being one of the highest risk factors for an allergic contact reaction.⁷⁶ One RCT compared daily scalp massage with essential oils (rosemary, lavender, thyme, and cedarwood in a carrier oil) to daily scalp massage with a placebo carrier oil in AA patients. The results showed that at 7 months of treatment, 44% (n=19) of the aromatherapy group showed improvement compared to 15% (n=6) in the control group.⁷⁷ Another study used a similar group of essential oils (thyme, rosemary, atlas cedar, lavender, and EPO in a carrier oil) with daily scalp massage and reported similar improvement of AA symptoms compared to control; the investigators also reported irritation at application site in 1 patient.⁷⁸ There currently are not enough data to recommend aromatherapy skin massage for the treatment of AA, and this practice may cause harm to the patient by induction of allergic contact dermatitis.

There have been a few studies to suggest that the use of total glucosides of peony with compound glycyrrhizin and oral Korean red ginseng may have beneficial effects on AA treatment, but efficacy and safety data are lacking, and these therapies should not be recommended without more information.^64,79,80

Final Thoughts

Dermatologic patients frequently are opting for CAM,² and although some therapies may show promising initial results, alternative medicines also can drive adverse events.^19,30 The lack of oversight from the US Food and Drug Administration on the products leads to many unknowns for true health risks with over-the-counter CAM supplements.⁴⁰ As the use of CAM becomes increasingly common among dermatologic patients, it is important for dermatologists to understand the benefits and risks, especially for commonly treated conditions. More data is needed before CAM can be routinely recommended.

Androgenetic alopecia significantly impairs patients’ overall quality of life and emotional health, but does not have a notable impact on the incidence of depression, according a systematic review and meta-analysis of 41 studies.

“Hair loss affects self-image, causes trichodynia, and plays a role in emotions and social activity, which may be associated with psychiatric problems and impaired health-related quality of life,” wrote Chun-Hsien Huang, MD, of Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Linkou, Taiwan, and colleagues. However, systematic reviews of the associations between androgenetic alopecia (AGA) and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) are lacking, they said.

In a study published in JAMA Dermatology, the researchers reviewed data from a total of 7,995 AGA patients in 41 studies. The studies included 11 tools for HRQOL assessment and 29 tools for psychological assessment. Of these, the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI) and the Hair-Specific Skindex-29 were used to assess quality of life, and the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) was used for psychological assessment in the meta-analysis.

Overall, 27 studies identified 18 factors associated with HRQOL; those with an inverse effect were higher self-rated hair loss severity, lower VAS score, and higher educational level. Of note, neither physician-rated hair loss severity nor treatment response were factors in HRQOL, the researchers said.

The pooled DLQI score across studies was 8.16, and subgroup analysis showed no differences in HRQOL between men and women or between patients from European vs. Asian countries. However, five studies showed significant differences in HRQOL between men and women when different assessment tools were used, which emphasized the need for more studies to examine the association of AGA with HRQOL by sex, the researchers said.

The meta-analysis of the Hair-Specific Skindex-29 scores showed pooled averages of 21.95 for symptom dimension, 18.52 in function dimension, and 29.22 in emotion dimension. Of these, the emotion dimension scores indicated moderate emotional impairment.

The average pooled score on the CES-D in the meta-analysis was 14.98, indicating no association between AGA and depression, the researchers said. However, “depression accounts for only a part of the emotion dimension,” they said. “Therefore, emotion dimension could be impaired even if no depressive symptoms were noted.”

The pooled DLQI scores for AGA (8.16) were higher than scores for other skin conditions including alopecia areata (6.3), contact dermatitis (7.35), and acne vulgaris (7.45), but lower than the pooled scores for vitiligo (9.11), urticaria (9.8), psoriasis (10.53), and atopic dermatitis (11.2), the researchers noted. “However, additional head-to-head studies are needed for direct comparisons of HRQOL in patients with various dermatoses,” they said.

The study findings were limited by the cross-sectional design of many of the included studies, and the limited number of assessment tools included in the analysis, the researchers noted. Other limitations were the lack of specific domain scores and the inclusion of only three studies from China, they said.

However, the results are consistent with findings from previous studies, and suggest that patients with AGA may benefit from psychological and psychosocial support, the researchers said.

Quality of life issues deserve attention

“Studies of the quality-of-life impact of various conditions are becoming more common in the medical literature,” Jamie B. MacKelfresh, MD, associate professor of dermatology, Emory University, Atlanta, said in an interview.

“Androgenetic alopecia is the most common type of hair loss in men and women,” she noted. “Hair loss can be labeled as a cosmetic concern, so it is important that providers understand the significant quality-of-life impact androgenetic alopecia has on the many people with this diagnosis,” she emphasized.

Dr. MacKelfresh, who was asked to comment on the study, said she was surprised that the subgroup analysis of the DLQI showed no significant difference between men and women. “This surprised me because a number of past studies have highlighted the relatively greater quality-of-life impact of hair loss on women compared to men,” she noted.

However, she added, “I was not surprised to see that androgenetic alopecia has a significant quality-of-life impact on many patients, and that physician objective assessments of the hair loss do not always correlate with the amount of quality-of-life impact,” said Dr. MacKelfresh. “In the patients I see, I find hair loss very often has a significant quality-of-life impact on patients, regardless of gender, and the amount of quality-of-life impact definitely does not always correlate with the objective amount of hair loss,” she noted.

A takeaway message for clinicians is to be aware that androgenetic alopecia frequently has a significant impact on patients, “particularly in the emotional dimension,” and can affect both men and women, Dr. MacKelfresh said. “Objective assessments of hair loss severity by providers may not accurately predict the degree of quality-of-life impact a patient may experience; therefore providers should include quality-of-life questions as part of their standard evaluation of patients with androgenetic alopecia,” she said. In addition to treating the hair loss, providers can help these patients by guiding them to psychological support resources, she emphasized.

More research is needed to assess the impact of androgenetic alopecia on “men, women, and the non-binary gender population,” as well as the relationship between self-esteem and hair loss, she said. “Finally, it would be helpful to understand what interventions can best help improve androgenetic alopecia patients’ quality of life,” she noted.

The study received no outside funding. The researchers had no financial conflicts to disclose. Dr. MacKelfresh had no financial conflicts to disclose.

Androgenetic alopecia significantly impairs patients’ overall quality of life and emotional health, but does not have a notable impact on the incidence of depression, according a systematic review and meta-analysis of 41 studies.

“Hair loss affects self-image, causes trichodynia, and plays a role in emotions and social activity, which may be associated with psychiatric problems and impaired health-related quality of life,” wrote Chun-Hsien Huang, MD, of Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Linkou, Taiwan, and colleagues. However, systematic reviews of the associations between androgenetic alopecia (AGA) and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) are lacking, they said.

In a study published in JAMA Dermatology, the researchers reviewed data from a total of 7,995 AGA patients in 41 studies. The studies included 11 tools for HRQOL assessment and 29 tools for psychological assessment. Of these, the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI) and the Hair-Specific Skindex-29 were used to assess quality of life, and the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) was used for psychological assessment in the meta-analysis.

Overall, 27 studies identified 18 factors associated with HRQOL; those with an inverse effect were higher self-rated hair loss severity, lower VAS score, and higher educational level. Of note, neither physician-rated hair loss severity nor treatment response were factors in HRQOL, the researchers said.

The pooled DLQI score across studies was 8.16, and subgroup analysis showed no differences in HRQOL between men and women or between patients from European vs. Asian countries. However, five studies showed significant differences in HRQOL between men and women when different assessment tools were used, which emphasized the need for more studies to examine the association of AGA with HRQOL by sex, the researchers said.

The meta-analysis of the Hair-Specific Skindex-29 scores showed pooled averages of 21.95 for symptom dimension, 18.52 in function dimension, and 29.22 in emotion dimension. Of these, the emotion dimension scores indicated moderate emotional impairment.

The average pooled score on the CES-D in the meta-analysis was 14.98, indicating no association between AGA and depression, the researchers said. However, “depression accounts for only a part of the emotion dimension,” they said. “Therefore, emotion dimension could be impaired even if no depressive symptoms were noted.”

The pooled DLQI scores for AGA (8.16) were higher than scores for other skin conditions including alopecia areata (6.3), contact dermatitis (7.35), and acne vulgaris (7.45), but lower than the pooled scores for vitiligo (9.11), urticaria (9.8), psoriasis (10.53), and atopic dermatitis (11.2), the researchers noted. “However, additional head-to-head studies are needed for direct comparisons of HRQOL in patients with various dermatoses,” they said.

The study findings were limited by the cross-sectional design of many of the included studies, and the limited number of assessment tools included in the analysis, the researchers noted. Other limitations were the lack of specific domain scores and the inclusion of only three studies from China, they said.

However, the results are consistent with findings from previous studies, and suggest that patients with AGA may benefit from psychological and psychosocial support, the researchers said.

Quality of life issues deserve attention

“Studies of the quality-of-life impact of various conditions are becoming more common in the medical literature,” Jamie B. MacKelfresh, MD, associate professor of dermatology, Emory University, Atlanta, said in an interview.

“Androgenetic alopecia is the most common type of hair loss in men and women,” she noted. “Hair loss can be labeled as a cosmetic concern, so it is important that providers understand the significant quality-of-life impact androgenetic alopecia has on the many people with this diagnosis,” she emphasized.

Dr. MacKelfresh, who was asked to comment on the study, said she was surprised that the subgroup analysis of the DLQI showed no significant difference between men and women. “This surprised me because a number of past studies have highlighted the relatively greater quality-of-life impact of hair loss on women compared to men,” she noted.

However, she added, “I was not surprised to see that androgenetic alopecia has a significant quality-of-life impact on many patients, and that physician objective assessments of the hair loss do not always correlate with the amount of quality-of-life impact,” said Dr. MacKelfresh. “In the patients I see, I find hair loss very often has a significant quality-of-life impact on patients, regardless of gender, and the amount of quality-of-life impact definitely does not always correlate with the objective amount of hair loss,” she noted.

A takeaway message for clinicians is to be aware that androgenetic alopecia frequently has a significant impact on patients, “particularly in the emotional dimension,” and can affect both men and women, Dr. MacKelfresh said. “Objective assessments of hair loss severity by providers may not accurately predict the degree of quality-of-life impact a patient may experience; therefore providers should include quality-of-life questions as part of their standard evaluation of patients with androgenetic alopecia,” she said. In addition to treating the hair loss, providers can help these patients by guiding them to psychological support resources, she emphasized.

More research is needed to assess the impact of androgenetic alopecia on “men, women, and the non-binary gender population,” as well as the relationship between self-esteem and hair loss, she said. “Finally, it would be helpful to understand what interventions can best help improve androgenetic alopecia patients’ quality of life,” she noted.

The study received no outside funding. The researchers had no financial conflicts to disclose. Dr. MacKelfresh had no financial conflicts to disclose.

Androgenetic alopecia significantly impairs patients’ overall quality of life and emotional health, but does not have a notable impact on the incidence of depression, according a systematic review and meta-analysis of 41 studies.

“Hair loss affects self-image, causes trichodynia, and plays a role in emotions and social activity, which may be associated with psychiatric problems and impaired health-related quality of life,” wrote Chun-Hsien Huang, MD, of Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Linkou, Taiwan, and colleagues. However, systematic reviews of the associations between androgenetic alopecia (AGA) and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) are lacking, they said.

In a study published in JAMA Dermatology, the researchers reviewed data from a total of 7,995 AGA patients in 41 studies. The studies included 11 tools for HRQOL assessment and 29 tools for psychological assessment. Of these, the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI) and the Hair-Specific Skindex-29 were used to assess quality of life, and the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) was used for psychological assessment in the meta-analysis.

Overall, 27 studies identified 18 factors associated with HRQOL; those with an inverse effect were higher self-rated hair loss severity, lower VAS score, and higher educational level. Of note, neither physician-rated hair loss severity nor treatment response were factors in HRQOL, the researchers said.

The pooled DLQI score across studies was 8.16, and subgroup analysis showed no differences in HRQOL between men and women or between patients from European vs. Asian countries. However, five studies showed significant differences in HRQOL between men and women when different assessment tools were used, which emphasized the need for more studies to examine the association of AGA with HRQOL by sex, the researchers said.

The meta-analysis of the Hair-Specific Skindex-29 scores showed pooled averages of 21.95 for symptom dimension, 18.52 in function dimension, and 29.22 in emotion dimension. Of these, the emotion dimension scores indicated moderate emotional impairment.

The average pooled score on the CES-D in the meta-analysis was 14.98, indicating no association between AGA and depression, the researchers said. However, “depression accounts for only a part of the emotion dimension,” they said. “Therefore, emotion dimension could be impaired even if no depressive symptoms were noted.”

The pooled DLQI scores for AGA (8.16) were higher than scores for other skin conditions including alopecia areata (6.3), contact dermatitis (7.35), and acne vulgaris (7.45), but lower than the pooled scores for vitiligo (9.11), urticaria (9.8), psoriasis (10.53), and atopic dermatitis (11.2), the researchers noted. “However, additional head-to-head studies are needed for direct comparisons of HRQOL in patients with various dermatoses,” they said.

The study findings were limited by the cross-sectional design of many of the included studies, and the limited number of assessment tools included in the analysis, the researchers noted. Other limitations were the lack of specific domain scores and the inclusion of only three studies from China, they said.

However, the results are consistent with findings from previous studies, and suggest that patients with AGA may benefit from psychological and psychosocial support, the researchers said.

Quality of life issues deserve attention

“Studies of the quality-of-life impact of various conditions are becoming more common in the medical literature,” Jamie B. MacKelfresh, MD, associate professor of dermatology, Emory University, Atlanta, said in an interview.

“Androgenetic alopecia is the most common type of hair loss in men and women,” she noted. “Hair loss can be labeled as a cosmetic concern, so it is important that providers understand the significant quality-of-life impact androgenetic alopecia has on the many people with this diagnosis,” she emphasized.

Dr. MacKelfresh, who was asked to comment on the study, said she was surprised that the subgroup analysis of the DLQI showed no significant difference between men and women. “This surprised me because a number of past studies have highlighted the relatively greater quality-of-life impact of hair loss on women compared to men,” she noted.

However, she added, “I was not surprised to see that androgenetic alopecia has a significant quality-of-life impact on many patients, and that physician objective assessments of the hair loss do not always correlate with the amount of quality-of-life impact,” said Dr. MacKelfresh. “In the patients I see, I find hair loss very often has a significant quality-of-life impact on patients, regardless of gender, and the amount of quality-of-life impact definitely does not always correlate with the objective amount of hair loss,” she noted.

A takeaway message for clinicians is to be aware that androgenetic alopecia frequently has a significant impact on patients, “particularly in the emotional dimension,” and can affect both men and women, Dr. MacKelfresh said. “Objective assessments of hair loss severity by providers may not accurately predict the degree of quality-of-life impact a patient may experience; therefore providers should include quality-of-life questions as part of their standard evaluation of patients with androgenetic alopecia,” she said. In addition to treating the hair loss, providers can help these patients by guiding them to psychological support resources, she emphasized.

More research is needed to assess the impact of androgenetic alopecia on “men, women, and the non-binary gender population,” as well as the relationship between self-esteem and hair loss, she said. “Finally, it would be helpful to understand what interventions can best help improve androgenetic alopecia patients’ quality of life,” she noted.

The study received no outside funding. The researchers had no financial conflicts to disclose. Dr. MacKelfresh had no financial conflicts to disclose.

The correlation between stress and graying of hair has long been hypothesized, but has been difficult to prove. In addition, reversal of hair graying has been thought of as a temporary phenomenon as hair pigment goes through its natural progression of senescence.

Noel Hendrickson/Getty Images

However, the recent publication that is a collaboration between the department of psychiatry at Columbia University, New York; and the departments of dermatology at the University College Dublin, University of Miami, and the University of Manchester (England); and the Monasterium Laboratory in Münster, Germany, demonstrates a quantitative mapping of human hair graying – and its reversal – in relation to stress.

In the study, hair color of single strands of hair from seven healthy females and seven healthy males, whose mean age was 35 years (range, 9-65 years), were analyzed. In addition to hair pigment analysis, study subjects documented the stress they were experiencing each week in diaries. Using either high resolution image scanners, electron microscopy, and/or hair shaft proteomics, the investigators were able to evaluate loss of pigment within fragments small enough to have grown over one hour.

When changes in hair color were noted, variations in up to 300 proteins were documented, including an up-regulation of the fatty acid synthesis and metabolism machinery in graying. Recent studies also corroborate that fatty acid synthesis by fatty acid synthase and “transport by CPT1A ... are sufficient drivers of cell senescence, and that fatty acid metabolism regulates melanocyte aging biology” the authors wrote.

Molecularly, the investigators found that gray hairs up-regulate proteins associated with energy metabolism, mitochondria, and antioxidant defenses. The graying correlated with stress was also reversible, “at least temporarily,” based on their retrospective analysis and analysis over the 2.5-year recruitment period, the investigators wrote. Specifically, they found that graying hair “may be acutely triggered by stressful life experiences, the removal of which can trigger reversal.” From the data, they also developed a mathematical model to predict what might happen to human hair over time.

Through this study, proof-of-concept evidence is provided indicating that biobehavioral factors are linked to human hair graying dynamics. Future analysis with larger sample sizes and incorporating neuroendocrine markers may further support these correlations. This is an interesting study that elucidates the mechanisms responsible for how stress and other life exposures manifest in human biology, and, if we as human beings effectively manage that stress, how it may both reverse the negative impact and outcomes affecting our body and health.

The study was supported by the Wharton Fund and grants from the National Institutes of Health.

Dr. Wesley and Dr. Lily Talakoub are cocontributors to this column. Dr. Wesley practices dermatology in Beverly Hills, Calif. Dr. Talakoub is in private practice in McLean, Va. This month’s column is by Dr. Wesley. Write to them at [email protected]. They have no relevant disclosures.

The correlation between stress and graying of hair has long been hypothesized, but has been difficult to prove. In addition, reversal of hair graying has been thought of as a temporary phenomenon as hair pigment goes through its natural progression of senescence.

Noel Hendrickson/Getty Images

However, the recent publication that is a collaboration between the department of psychiatry at Columbia University, New York; and the departments of dermatology at the University College Dublin, University of Miami, and the University of Manchester (England); and the Monasterium Laboratory in Münster, Germany, demonstrates a quantitative mapping of human hair graying – and its reversal – in relation to stress.

In the study, hair color of single strands of hair from seven healthy females and seven healthy males, whose mean age was 35 years (range, 9-65 years), were analyzed. In addition to hair pigment analysis, study subjects documented the stress they were experiencing each week in diaries. Using either high resolution image scanners, electron microscopy, and/or hair shaft proteomics, the investigators were able to evaluate loss of pigment within fragments small enough to have grown over one hour.

When changes in hair color were noted, variations in up to 300 proteins were documented, including an up-regulation of the fatty acid synthesis and metabolism machinery in graying. Recent studies also corroborate that fatty acid synthesis by fatty acid synthase and “transport by CPT1A ... are sufficient drivers of cell senescence, and that fatty acid metabolism regulates melanocyte aging biology” the authors wrote.

Molecularly, the investigators found that gray hairs up-regulate proteins associated with energy metabolism, mitochondria, and antioxidant defenses. The graying correlated with stress was also reversible, “at least temporarily,” based on their retrospective analysis and analysis over the 2.5-year recruitment period, the investigators wrote. Specifically, they found that graying hair “may be acutely triggered by stressful life experiences, the removal of which can trigger reversal.” From the data, they also developed a mathematical model to predict what might happen to human hair over time.

Through this study, proof-of-concept evidence is provided indicating that biobehavioral factors are linked to human hair graying dynamics. Future analysis with larger sample sizes and incorporating neuroendocrine markers may further support these correlations. This is an interesting study that elucidates the mechanisms responsible for how stress and other life exposures manifest in human biology, and, if we as human beings effectively manage that stress, how it may both reverse the negative impact and outcomes affecting our body and health.

The study was supported by the Wharton Fund and grants from the National Institutes of Health.

Dr. Wesley and Dr. Lily Talakoub are cocontributors to this column. Dr. Wesley practices dermatology in Beverly Hills, Calif. Dr. Talakoub is in private practice in McLean, Va. This month’s column is by Dr. Wesley. Write to them at [email protected]. They have no relevant disclosures.

The correlation between stress and graying of hair has long been hypothesized, but has been difficult to prove. In addition, reversal of hair graying has been thought of as a temporary phenomenon as hair pigment goes through its natural progression of senescence.

Noel Hendrickson/Getty Images

However, the recent publication that is a collaboration between the department of psychiatry at Columbia University, New York; and the departments of dermatology at the University College Dublin, University of Miami, and the University of Manchester (England); and the Monasterium Laboratory in Münster, Germany, demonstrates a quantitative mapping of human hair graying – and its reversal – in relation to stress.

In the study, hair color of single strands of hair from seven healthy females and seven healthy males, whose mean age was 35 years (range, 9-65 years), were analyzed. In addition to hair pigment analysis, study subjects documented the stress they were experiencing each week in diaries. Using either high resolution image scanners, electron microscopy, and/or hair shaft proteomics, the investigators were able to evaluate loss of pigment within fragments small enough to have grown over one hour.

When changes in hair color were noted, variations in up to 300 proteins were documented, including an up-regulation of the fatty acid synthesis and metabolism machinery in graying. Recent studies also corroborate that fatty acid synthesis by fatty acid synthase and “transport by CPT1A ... are sufficient drivers of cell senescence, and that fatty acid metabolism regulates melanocyte aging biology” the authors wrote.

Molecularly, the investigators found that gray hairs up-regulate proteins associated with energy metabolism, mitochondria, and antioxidant defenses. The graying correlated with stress was also reversible, “at least temporarily,” based on their retrospective analysis and analysis over the 2.5-year recruitment period, the investigators wrote. Specifically, they found that graying hair “may be acutely triggered by stressful life experiences, the removal of which can trigger reversal.” From the data, they also developed a mathematical model to predict what might happen to human hair over time.

Through this study, proof-of-concept evidence is provided indicating that biobehavioral factors are linked to human hair graying dynamics. Future analysis with larger sample sizes and incorporating neuroendocrine markers may further support these correlations. This is an interesting study that elucidates the mechanisms responsible for how stress and other life exposures manifest in human biology, and, if we as human beings effectively manage that stress, how it may both reverse the negative impact and outcomes affecting our body and health.

The study was supported by the Wharton Fund and grants from the National Institutes of Health.

Dr. Wesley and Dr. Lily Talakoub are cocontributors to this column. Dr. Wesley practices dermatology in Beverly Hills, Calif. Dr. Talakoub is in private practice in McLean, Va. This month’s column is by Dr. Wesley. Write to them at [email protected]. They have no relevant disclosures.

Traction alopecia (TA)--one of the most common types of hair loss in Black women (although not exclusive to Black women)--is reversible when early corrective measures are taken; if chronic tension continues, however, permanent scarring alopecia ensues. Dermatologists can prevent worsening of this distressing hair loss. Due to a dearth of training among dermatologists in conditions occurring in patients with tightly coiled hair, it is imperative to add practical methods to the body of dermatology literature, with the goal of enhancing cultural humility.  

Hairstyling among Black women often is a lengthy process and often results in relationship bonding with the hair care giver, in turn imparting hair care traditions to the next generation. Therefore, a well-received discussion about TA prevention not only has an impact on the patient but potentially on a multigenerational family of women and friends. We present a memory aid for discussing TA, with a focus on cultural humility and patient-centered communication. 

Factors contributing to the risk of TA are hairstyles and hair care practices commonly used in Black individuals, including braids, locs, weaves, wigs, and chemical straightening.¹ These styles often are worn to increase hair manageability or as a creative expression of beauty. 

Discussing TA can be distressing for physicians and patients, especially in the setting of hair texture discordance. In a study that surveyed Black patients' perception of their dermatologic care both in and outside of a skin of color clinic, 71% of respondents (12/17) said that they prefer a race-concordant dermatologist. Some respondents reported that non-skin of color clinic dermatologists examined their hair with the end of a pencil or not at all; patients interpreted these interactions as disrespectful and racially insensitive.² Another study found that only 30.2% (19/63) of dermatology chief residents and 12.2% (5/41) of program directors reported a specific rotation during which residents gained experience treating skin of color patients.³ 

Due to a paucity of training in diagnosing and treating patients with tightly coiled hair who experience hair loss, some physicians might feel uncomfortable caring for patients who have tightly coiled hair. Although many Black patients prefer to see a race-concordant dermatologist because of their perceived cultural competence and shared experience, there is a paucity of Black dermatologists to see all patients who have tightly coiled hair.⁴ Therefore, all dermatologists should become skilled and comfortable discussing and treating TA in patients with all hair types. 

METHOD FOR COUNSELING 

The following scenarios are a guide to begin closing the competency gap in counseling about TA, using a "compliment, discuss, and suggest" method.  

Scenario 1 
A Black woman presents with a concern of "thinning edges" (a popular term on social media for TA). A hair-discordant dermatologist tells her, first, that she has TA caused by wearing tight hairstyles and, second, that the treatment is to stop wearing tight braids and weaves and to discontinue chemical relaxers. The dermatologist then leaves the room.  

The Patient's Perspective
It is not uncommon for the patient to have feelings of frustration about how they will style their hair, especially if they are unfamiliar with caring for their hair in its natural state.⁵ Also, they might have feelings of dismay that the loving childhood hair care giver, often their mother or grandmother, unintentionally harmed them with a tight style. They also might feel betrayed by their hairstylist, who might not have encouraged them to see a dermatologist, or who continued to oblige their request for a high-risk hairstyle. The patient might feel uncomfortable communicating the dermatologist's new recommendations to their hair care team, who also are part of her emotional support system. The patient also might think that the hair-discordant dermatologist has no idea what they "go through" with their hair.  

"Compliment, Discuss, and Suggest" Counseling
Traction alopecia is caused by tight hairstyles that often hurt when they are put in as tight braids, weaves, and ponytails.⁶ Risk increases if tight styles are applied to chemically straightened hair.¹ Braids, sew-in weaves, and wigs with adhesive sometimes are referred to as protective styles. However, these styles can still lead to TA due to excessive tension.  

• Compliment: "Your hair looks great. I know that you get many compliments."  
• Discuss: "However, some of the styles might be increasing your risk for hair loss. Our goal is to preserve as many of your follicles as possible."  
• Suggest: "Let's start by loosening the hairstyle if it is painful when being applied. Pain means inflammation, which can lead to scarring of hair follicles and worsening of hair loss." 

Using pronouns such as we, us, and our is intentional. Doing so signals that the dermatologist is a partner with the patient in the treatment of TA. Starting with a simple initial recommendation gives the patient time to process the common thoughts highlighted in The Patient's Perspective section.⁶  

Scenario 2 
A Black child (we'll call her "Janet") is accompanied by her mother for follow-up of mild atopic dermatitis on the body and scalp. When the dermatologist examines the patient's scalp, they note that she has the fringe sign--retained short hairs along the frontal hairline--that is consistent with TA. Janet's hair is adorned with 2 tight ponytails in the front with colorful decorative balls on ponytail ties, barrettes, and 6 cornrow braids in the back with plastic beads on the ends. The dermatologist counsels about the atopic dermatitis and leaves the room.  

"Compliment, Discuss, and Suggest" Counseling
The use of tight decorative balls on ponytail ties and numerous plastic beads increases the amount of tension and weight on the hair, which may lead to a higher risk for developing traction alopecia.⁶ It is quite common for children of African descent to wear hair adornments. Proper counseling regarding their use and possible implications is essential. 

1. Compliment: "You're doing a great job controlling the atopic dermatitis, which can cause Janet's scalp to be dry. Also, her hair is beautiful--it looks like you spent a lot of time on her hair. And Janet, I like the color of your barrettes." 
2. Discuss: "Mom, I just noticed that a few areas look tight. Let's look together." (The dermatologist points out areas where the scalp is tented upward due to traction, follicular pustules or papules, or the frontal fringe sign.) "I'm on a mission to #savetheedges because we want Janet to grow up with full edges." (Again, loss of "edges" refers to TA.) 
3. Suggest: "When you do Janet's hair, it's OK if every hair is not in place. In fact, making styles look and feel 1 or 2 weeks old will lessen tension on the scalp. Remove Janet's hair ties to release tension when she is at home and while she's sleeping, if possible. Every minute that the hair is loose really does help."⁶  

The Parent's Perspective

All parents take pride in their children. In some Black communities, mothers are judged by how well they manage and style their children's hair. Some people might even suggest that parents of children with nonstyled, tightly coiled hair are not fit parents. Anthropologist Sylvia Boone, PhD, found that among the Mende tribe in Sierra Leone, "unkempt, 'neglected,' or 'messy' hair implied that a woman either had loose morals or was insane."⁷ 

Braids are commonly worn by people of African heritage for a variety of reasons, including ease of manageability, to decrease daily hairstyling time, and as an expression of creativity. Intricate neat hairstyles, despite the risk of pain and TA, are perceived as a sign that the child is cared for and loved.⁶  

FINAL THOUGHTS 

Patient-centered communication is associated with the patient trusting the physician, which is especially important in race-discordant physician-patient relationships. A study found that patient-physician race discordance led to shorter visits, a lower rating of patient affect, and less shared decision-making.⁸ Moreover, in a study of primary care clinicians, implicit bias was found to affect communication patterns and social interactions, impacting patient outcomes. Downstream effects of racial bias resulted in less speaking, smiling, and social comments when interacting with Black patients.⁹  

These findings highlight the need to address interpersonal barriers to effective communication in race-discordant patient-physician dyads. A history of segregated neighborhoods and schools might contribute to structural barriers, resulting in lack of familiarity with cultural norms outside one's culture, which might globally perpetuate poor communication and patient outcomes.  

The "compliment, discuss, and suggest" method might lead to more positive physician-patient encounters by having the dermatologist focus on empathetically understanding the patient's perspective.¹⁰ Effective communication, understanding cultural hair care practices, and a thorough scalp examination are paramount for patients with tightly coiled hair.¹¹ Early intervention in TA is crucial and involves partnering with patients and parents to amend high-risk hairstyling routines with cultural humility. 

Traction alopecia (TA)--one of the most common types of hair loss in Black women (although not exclusive to Black women)--is reversible when early corrective measures are taken; if chronic tension continues, however, permanent scarring alopecia ensues. Dermatologists can prevent worsening of this distressing hair loss. Due to a dearth of training among dermatologists in conditions occurring in patients with tightly coiled hair, it is imperative to add practical methods to the body of dermatology literature, with the goal of enhancing cultural humility.  

Hairstyling among Black women often is a lengthy process and often results in relationship bonding with the hair care giver, in turn imparting hair care traditions to the next generation. Therefore, a well-received discussion about TA prevention not only has an impact on the patient but potentially on a multigenerational family of women and friends. We present a memory aid for discussing TA, with a focus on cultural humility and patient-centered communication. 

Factors contributing to the risk of TA are hairstyles and hair care practices commonly used in Black individuals, including braids, locs, weaves, wigs, and chemical straightening.¹ These styles often are worn to increase hair manageability or as a creative expression of beauty. 

Discussing TA can be distressing for physicians and patients, especially in the setting of hair texture discordance. In a study that surveyed Black patients' perception of their dermatologic care both in and outside of a skin of color clinic, 71% of respondents (12/17) said that they prefer a race-concordant dermatologist. Some respondents reported that non-skin of color clinic dermatologists examined their hair with the end of a pencil or not at all; patients interpreted these interactions as disrespectful and racially insensitive.² Another study found that only 30.2% (19/63) of dermatology chief residents and 12.2% (5/41) of program directors reported a specific rotation during which residents gained experience treating skin of color patients.³ 

Due to a paucity of training in diagnosing and treating patients with tightly coiled hair who experience hair loss, some physicians might feel uncomfortable caring for patients who have tightly coiled hair. Although many Black patients prefer to see a race-concordant dermatologist because of their perceived cultural competence and shared experience, there is a paucity of Black dermatologists to see all patients who have tightly coiled hair.⁴ Therefore, all dermatologists should become skilled and comfortable discussing and treating TA in patients with all hair types. 

METHOD FOR COUNSELING 

The following scenarios are a guide to begin closing the competency gap in counseling about TA, using a "compliment, discuss, and suggest" method.  

Scenario 1 
A Black woman presents with a concern of "thinning edges" (a popular term on social media for TA). A hair-discordant dermatologist tells her, first, that she has TA caused by wearing tight hairstyles and, second, that the treatment is to stop wearing tight braids and weaves and to discontinue chemical relaxers. The dermatologist then leaves the room.  

The Patient's Perspective
It is not uncommon for the patient to have feelings of frustration about how they will style their hair, especially if they are unfamiliar with caring for their hair in its natural state.⁵ Also, they might have feelings of dismay that the loving childhood hair care giver, often their mother or grandmother, unintentionally harmed them with a tight style. They also might feel betrayed by their hairstylist, who might not have encouraged them to see a dermatologist, or who continued to oblige their request for a high-risk hairstyle. The patient might feel uncomfortable communicating the dermatologist's new recommendations to their hair care team, who also are part of her emotional support system. The patient also might think that the hair-discordant dermatologist has no idea what they "go through" with their hair.  

"Compliment, Discuss, and Suggest" Counseling
Traction alopecia is caused by tight hairstyles that often hurt when they are put in as tight braids, weaves, and ponytails.⁶ Risk increases if tight styles are applied to chemically straightened hair.¹ Braids, sew-in weaves, and wigs with adhesive sometimes are referred to as protective styles. However, these styles can still lead to TA due to excessive tension.  

• Compliment: "Your hair looks great. I know that you get many compliments."  
• Discuss: "However, some of the styles might be increasing your risk for hair loss. Our goal is to preserve as many of your follicles as possible."  
• Suggest: "Let's start by loosening the hairstyle if it is painful when being applied. Pain means inflammation, which can lead to scarring of hair follicles and worsening of hair loss." 

Using pronouns such as we, us, and our is intentional. Doing so signals that the dermatologist is a partner with the patient in the treatment of TA. Starting with a simple initial recommendation gives the patient time to process the common thoughts highlighted in The Patient's Perspective section.⁶  

Scenario 2 
A Black child (we'll call her "Janet") is accompanied by her mother for follow-up of mild atopic dermatitis on the body and scalp. When the dermatologist examines the patient's scalp, they note that she has the fringe sign--retained short hairs along the frontal hairline--that is consistent with TA. Janet's hair is adorned with 2 tight ponytails in the front with colorful decorative balls on ponytail ties, barrettes, and 6 cornrow braids in the back with plastic beads on the ends. The dermatologist counsels about the atopic dermatitis and leaves the room.  

"Compliment, Discuss, and Suggest" Counseling
The use of tight decorative balls on ponytail ties and numerous plastic beads increases the amount of tension and weight on the hair, which may lead to a higher risk for developing traction alopecia.⁶ It is quite common for children of African descent to wear hair adornments. Proper counseling regarding their use and possible implications is essential. 

1. Compliment: "You're doing a great job controlling the atopic dermatitis, which can cause Janet's scalp to be dry. Also, her hair is beautiful--it looks like you spent a lot of time on her hair. And Janet, I like the color of your barrettes." 
2. Discuss: "Mom, I just noticed that a few areas look tight. Let's look together." (The dermatologist points out areas where the scalp is tented upward due to traction, follicular pustules or papules, or the frontal fringe sign.) "I'm on a mission to #savetheedges because we want Janet to grow up with full edges." (Again, loss of "edges" refers to TA.) 
3. Suggest: "When you do Janet's hair, it's OK if every hair is not in place. In fact, making styles look and feel 1 or 2 weeks old will lessen tension on the scalp. Remove Janet's hair ties to release tension when she is at home and while she's sleeping, if possible. Every minute that the hair is loose really does help."⁶  

The Parent's Perspective

All parents take pride in their children. In some Black communities, mothers are judged by how well they manage and style their children's hair. Some people might even suggest that parents of children with nonstyled, tightly coiled hair are not fit parents. Anthropologist Sylvia Boone, PhD, found that among the Mende tribe in Sierra Leone, "unkempt, 'neglected,' or 'messy' hair implied that a woman either had loose morals or was insane."⁷ 

Braids are commonly worn by people of African heritage for a variety of reasons, including ease of manageability, to decrease daily hairstyling time, and as an expression of creativity. Intricate neat hairstyles, despite the risk of pain and TA, are perceived as a sign that the child is cared for and loved.⁶  

FINAL THOUGHTS 

Patient-centered communication is associated with the patient trusting the physician, which is especially important in race-discordant physician-patient relationships. A study found that patient-physician race discordance led to shorter visits, a lower rating of patient affect, and less shared decision-making.⁸ Moreover, in a study of primary care clinicians, implicit bias was found to affect communication patterns and social interactions, impacting patient outcomes. Downstream effects of racial bias resulted in less speaking, smiling, and social comments when interacting with Black patients.⁹  

These findings highlight the need to address interpersonal barriers to effective communication in race-discordant patient-physician dyads. A history of segregated neighborhoods and schools might contribute to structural barriers, resulting in lack of familiarity with cultural norms outside one's culture, which might globally perpetuate poor communication and patient outcomes.  

The "compliment, discuss, and suggest" method might lead to more positive physician-patient encounters by having the dermatologist focus on empathetically understanding the patient's perspective.¹⁰ Effective communication, understanding cultural hair care practices, and a thorough scalp examination are paramount for patients with tightly coiled hair.¹¹ Early intervention in TA is crucial and involves partnering with patients and parents to amend high-risk hairstyling routines with cultural humility. 

Traction alopecia (TA)--one of the most common types of hair loss in Black women (although not exclusive to Black women)--is reversible when early corrective measures are taken; if chronic tension continues, however, permanent scarring alopecia ensues. Dermatologists can prevent worsening of this distressing hair loss. Due to a dearth of training among dermatologists in conditions occurring in patients with tightly coiled hair, it is imperative to add practical methods to the body of dermatology literature, with the goal of enhancing cultural humility.  

Hairstyling among Black women often is a lengthy process and often results in relationship bonding with the hair care giver, in turn imparting hair care traditions to the next generation. Therefore, a well-received discussion about TA prevention not only has an impact on the patient but potentially on a multigenerational family of women and friends. We present a memory aid for discussing TA, with a focus on cultural humility and patient-centered communication. 

Factors contributing to the risk of TA are hairstyles and hair care practices commonly used in Black individuals, including braids, locs, weaves, wigs, and chemical straightening.¹ These styles often are worn to increase hair manageability or as a creative expression of beauty. 

Discussing TA can be distressing for physicians and patients, especially in the setting of hair texture discordance. In a study that surveyed Black patients' perception of their dermatologic care both in and outside of a skin of color clinic, 71% of respondents (12/17) said that they prefer a race-concordant dermatologist. Some respondents reported that non-skin of color clinic dermatologists examined their hair with the end of a pencil or not at all; patients interpreted these interactions as disrespectful and racially insensitive.² Another study found that only 30.2% (19/63) of dermatology chief residents and 12.2% (5/41) of program directors reported a specific rotation during which residents gained experience treating skin of color patients.³ 

Due to a paucity of training in diagnosing and treating patients with tightly coiled hair who experience hair loss, some physicians might feel uncomfortable caring for patients who have tightly coiled hair. Although many Black patients prefer to see a race-concordant dermatologist because of their perceived cultural competence and shared experience, there is a paucity of Black dermatologists to see all patients who have tightly coiled hair.⁴ Therefore, all dermatologists should become skilled and comfortable discussing and treating TA in patients with all hair types. 

METHOD FOR COUNSELING 

The following scenarios are a guide to begin closing the competency gap in counseling about TA, using a "compliment, discuss, and suggest" method.  

Scenario 1 
A Black woman presents with a concern of "thinning edges" (a popular term on social media for TA). A hair-discordant dermatologist tells her, first, that she has TA caused by wearing tight hairstyles and, second, that the treatment is to stop wearing tight braids and weaves and to discontinue chemical relaxers. The dermatologist then leaves the room.  

The Patient's Perspective
It is not uncommon for the patient to have feelings of frustration about how they will style their hair, especially if they are unfamiliar with caring for their hair in its natural state.⁵ Also, they might have feelings of dismay that the loving childhood hair care giver, often their mother or grandmother, unintentionally harmed them with a tight style. They also might feel betrayed by their hairstylist, who might not have encouraged them to see a dermatologist, or who continued to oblige their request for a high-risk hairstyle. The patient might feel uncomfortable communicating the dermatologist's new recommendations to their hair care team, who also are part of her emotional support system. The patient also might think that the hair-discordant dermatologist has no idea what they "go through" with their hair.  

"Compliment, Discuss, and Suggest" Counseling
Traction alopecia is caused by tight hairstyles that often hurt when they are put in as tight braids, weaves, and ponytails.⁶ Risk increases if tight styles are applied to chemically straightened hair.¹ Braids, sew-in weaves, and wigs with adhesive sometimes are referred to as protective styles. However, these styles can still lead to TA due to excessive tension.  

• Compliment: "Your hair looks great. I know that you get many compliments."  
• Discuss: "However, some of the styles might be increasing your risk for hair loss. Our goal is to preserve as many of your follicles as possible."  
• Suggest: "Let's start by loosening the hairstyle if it is painful when being applied. Pain means inflammation, which can lead to scarring of hair follicles and worsening of hair loss." 

Using pronouns such as we, us, and our is intentional. Doing so signals that the dermatologist is a partner with the patient in the treatment of TA. Starting with a simple initial recommendation gives the patient time to process the common thoughts highlighted in The Patient's Perspective section.⁶  

Scenario 2 
A Black child (we'll call her "Janet") is accompanied by her mother for follow-up of mild atopic dermatitis on the body and scalp. When the dermatologist examines the patient's scalp, they note that she has the fringe sign--retained short hairs along the frontal hairline--that is consistent with TA. Janet's hair is adorned with 2 tight ponytails in the front with colorful decorative balls on ponytail ties, barrettes, and 6 cornrow braids in the back with plastic beads on the ends. The dermatologist counsels about the atopic dermatitis and leaves the room.  

"Compliment, Discuss, and Suggest" Counseling
The use of tight decorative balls on ponytail ties and numerous plastic beads increases the amount of tension and weight on the hair, which may lead to a higher risk for developing traction alopecia.⁶ It is quite common for children of African descent to wear hair adornments. Proper counseling regarding their use and possible implications is essential. 

1. Compliment: "You're doing a great job controlling the atopic dermatitis, which can cause Janet's scalp to be dry. Also, her hair is beautiful--it looks like you spent a lot of time on her hair. And Janet, I like the color of your barrettes." 
2. Discuss: "Mom, I just noticed that a few areas look tight. Let's look together." (The dermatologist points out areas where the scalp is tented upward due to traction, follicular pustules or papules, or the frontal fringe sign.) "I'm on a mission to #savetheedges because we want Janet to grow up with full edges." (Again, loss of "edges" refers to TA.) 
3. Suggest: "When you do Janet's hair, it's OK if every hair is not in place. In fact, making styles look and feel 1 or 2 weeks old will lessen tension on the scalp. Remove Janet's hair ties to release tension when she is at home and while she's sleeping, if possible. Every minute that the hair is loose really does help."⁶  

The Parent's Perspective

All parents take pride in their children. In some Black communities, mothers are judged by how well they manage and style their children's hair. Some people might even suggest that parents of children with nonstyled, tightly coiled hair are not fit parents. Anthropologist Sylvia Boone, PhD, found that among the Mende tribe in Sierra Leone, "unkempt, 'neglected,' or 'messy' hair implied that a woman either had loose morals or was insane."⁷ 

Braids are commonly worn by people of African heritage for a variety of reasons, including ease of manageability, to decrease daily hairstyling time, and as an expression of creativity. Intricate neat hairstyles, despite the risk of pain and TA, are perceived as a sign that the child is cared for and loved.⁶  

FINAL THOUGHTS 

Patient-centered communication is associated with the patient trusting the physician, which is especially important in race-discordant physician-patient relationships. A study found that patient-physician race discordance led to shorter visits, a lower rating of patient affect, and less shared decision-making.⁸ Moreover, in a study of primary care clinicians, implicit bias was found to affect communication patterns and social interactions, impacting patient outcomes. Downstream effects of racial bias resulted in less speaking, smiling, and social comments when interacting with Black patients.⁹  

These findings highlight the need to address interpersonal barriers to effective communication in race-discordant patient-physician dyads. A history of segregated neighborhoods and schools might contribute to structural barriers, resulting in lack of familiarity with cultural norms outside one's culture, which might globally perpetuate poor communication and patient outcomes.  

The "compliment, discuss, and suggest" method might lead to more positive physician-patient encounters by having the dermatologist focus on empathetically understanding the patient's perspective.¹⁰ Effective communication, understanding cultural hair care practices, and a thorough scalp examination are paramount for patients with tightly coiled hair.¹¹ Early intervention in TA is crucial and involves partnering with patients and parents to amend high-risk hairstyling routines with cultural humility. 

The prevalence of pediatric alopecia areata (AA) in the United States has increased twofold over the past decade and it disproportionately affects females and Hispanic children, according to results from the largest study to date on the topic.

“Alopecia areata is a relatively common cause of nonscarring hair loss in children,” Paige McKenzie said during the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology. “The only two epidemiologic studies that have been performed in children have been based on registry or survey data which is inherently at risk for bias,” she added, referring to studies published in 2017 and 2018. “Additionally, epidemiologic descriptions of alopecia areata in adults are limited and overall estimates have varied from 0.2% to 2%. Current understanding is also largely based on population studies in Olmsted County, Minnesota, an area with mostly White racial demographics, so it’s not representative of the U.S. population as a whole.”

To identify the incidence and prevalence of pediatric AA over time, and across age, race/ethnicity, and sex, Ms. McKenzie and colleagues conducted a retrospective cohort study from 2009 to 2020 using PEDSnet, a network of seven U.S. pediatric health institutions with a database of more than 6.5 million children. “PEDSnet is unique because it uses a common data model to standardize EHR data across different health systems and uses SNOMED [Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine]–Clinical Terms to identify specific patient populations,” said Ms. McKenzie, who was a clinical research fellow in the section of dermatology at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia during the 2020-2021 academic year.

She and her coauthors limited their analysis to children younger than age 18 who were assigned a SNOMED code for AA during at least one dermatology physician visit or at least two nondermatology physician visits. They also identified an incidence cohort that was a subset of the study cohort who had at least 12 months of follow-up. “To determine the accuracy of AA patient identification, we also reviewed 100 cases at random from one institution with a threshold of greater than 95% accuracy,” said Ms. McKenzie, who is now a fourth-year medical student at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas.

Of 5,409,919 children included in the study, 5,801 had AA, for an overall prevalence of 0.11%. The prevalence doubled from 0.04% in 2009 to 0.08% in 2019. “It fell in 2020, which we believe is a result of the COVID-19 pandemic’s effects on health care utilization,” she said. AA prevalence peaked at 9 years of age and was higher among females, compared with males (0.12% vs. 0.09%, respectively). The prevalence was highest among Hispanic children (0.23%), followed by Asian children (0.17%), Black children (0.12%), and White children (0.08%).

The incidence cohort consisted of 2,896,241 children. Of these, 2,398 had AA between 2009-2020, for an overall incidence of 13.6 cases per 100,000 patient-years. The incidence rate of AA by age was normally distributed and peaked at 6 years of age. Rates were 22.8% higher in female patients than in male patients. In addition, incidence rates were highest among Hispanics (31.5/100,000 person-years), followed by Asians (23.1/100,000 person-years), Blacks (17.0/100,000 person-years), and Whites (8.8/100,000).

Logistic regression analysis showed general agreement with the unadjusted incidence data. Males were less likely to be diagnosed with AA, compared with females (adjusted odds ratio, 0.80; P < .001). Analysis across race/ethnicity revealed significantly increased rates among children from minority backgrounds when compared with white children. Hispanic children had the greatest risk of developing AA (aOR, 3.07), followed by Asian children (aOR, 2.02), and Black children (aOR, 1.73) (P < .001 for all associations). Patients with atopic dermatitis, thyroid disease, psoriasis, vitiligo, and trisomy 21 prior to AA diagnosis all had a significantly higher risk of developing AA, compared with those without those diagnoses.

“This is the largest description of pediatric AA to date,” Ms. McKenzie said. “The prevalence has increased steadily, with a twofold increase over the last 10 years, which mirrors other autoimmune disorders. Children who identify as Hispanic, Asian, and Black have significantly higher incidence rates of alopecia areata compared to those who identify as White.”

Moving forward, she added, “efforts should focus on increasing education and awareness of AA in diverse communities and in community pediatricians so that patients can be diagnosed correctly early on. We can also use this data to ensure that representative populations are included in clinical trials for patients with AA.”

Asked to comment on the results Maria Hordinsky, MD, professor and chair of the department of dermatology at the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, said that the study “is a great contribution to our understanding of the epidemiology of pediatric alopecia areata and also highlights how common alopecia areata is in children.” In an interview, she said that it would be interesting to see if this is a worldwide phenomenon or unique to the United States.

Lawrence J. Green, MD, clinical professor of dermatology at George Washington University, Washington, who was asked to comment on the study, characterized the work as being “very informative. Looking at a large cohort of pediatric patients with alopecia areata diagnosed by a dermatologist or two or more nondermatologists, the authors found a higher incidence and prevalence in nonwhite children here in the United States. I am worried in fact, the true incidence could be even higher than noted in the searched database because nonwhite children can often come from underserved and undercared for areas.”

The other authors were Christopher B. Forrest, MD, PhD, Mitchell Maltenfort, PhD, and Leslie Castelo-Soccio, MD, PhD, of Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia. Dr. Castelo-Soccio is a consultant for Pfizer; the other authors reported having no financial disclosures. Dr. Hordinsky disclosed receiving grant support for clinical research work on hair diseases from Pfizer, Eli Lilly, Concert Pharmaceuticals, and Target Derm and grant support from the National Alopecia Areata Foundation; and is on an advisory panel for Cassiopea. Dr. Green disclosed that he is a speaker, consultant, or investigator for numerous pharmaceutical companies.

*This story was updated on 7/19/21.

[email protected]

The prevalence of pediatric alopecia areata (AA) in the United States has increased twofold over the past decade and it disproportionately affects females and Hispanic children, according to results from the largest study to date on the topic.

“Alopecia areata is a relatively common cause of nonscarring hair loss in children,” Paige McKenzie said during the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology. “The only two epidemiologic studies that have been performed in children have been based on registry or survey data which is inherently at risk for bias,” she added, referring to studies published in 2017 and 2018. “Additionally, epidemiologic descriptions of alopecia areata in adults are limited and overall estimates have varied from 0.2% to 2%. Current understanding is also largely based on population studies in Olmsted County, Minnesota, an area with mostly White racial demographics, so it’s not representative of the U.S. population as a whole.”

To identify the incidence and prevalence of pediatric AA over time, and across age, race/ethnicity, and sex, Ms. McKenzie and colleagues conducted a retrospective cohort study from 2009 to 2020 using PEDSnet, a network of seven U.S. pediatric health institutions with a database of more than 6.5 million children. “PEDSnet is unique because it uses a common data model to standardize EHR data across different health systems and uses SNOMED [Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine]–Clinical Terms to identify specific patient populations,” said Ms. McKenzie, who was a clinical research fellow in the section of dermatology at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia during the 2020-2021 academic year.

She and her coauthors limited their analysis to children younger than age 18 who were assigned a SNOMED code for AA during at least one dermatology physician visit or at least two nondermatology physician visits. They also identified an incidence cohort that was a subset of the study cohort who had at least 12 months of follow-up. “To determine the accuracy of AA patient identification, we also reviewed 100 cases at random from one institution with a threshold of greater than 95% accuracy,” said Ms. McKenzie, who is now a fourth-year medical student at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas.

Of 5,409,919 children included in the study, 5,801 had AA, for an overall prevalence of 0.11%. The prevalence doubled from 0.04% in 2009 to 0.08% in 2019. “It fell in 2020, which we believe is a result of the COVID-19 pandemic’s effects on health care utilization,” she said. AA prevalence peaked at 9 years of age and was higher among females, compared with males (0.12% vs. 0.09%, respectively). The prevalence was highest among Hispanic children (0.23%), followed by Asian children (0.17%), Black children (0.12%), and White children (0.08%).

The incidence cohort consisted of 2,896,241 children. Of these, 2,398 had AA between 2009-2020, for an overall incidence of 13.6 cases per 100,000 patient-years. The incidence rate of AA by age was normally distributed and peaked at 6 years of age. Rates were 22.8% higher in female patients than in male patients. In addition, incidence rates were highest among Hispanics (31.5/100,000 person-years), followed by Asians (23.1/100,000 person-years), Blacks (17.0/100,000 person-years), and Whites (8.8/100,000).

Logistic regression analysis showed general agreement with the unadjusted incidence data. Males were less likely to be diagnosed with AA, compared with females (adjusted odds ratio, 0.80; P < .001). Analysis across race/ethnicity revealed significantly increased rates among children from minority backgrounds when compared with white children. Hispanic children had the greatest risk of developing AA (aOR, 3.07), followed by Asian children (aOR, 2.02), and Black children (aOR, 1.73) (P < .001 for all associations). Patients with atopic dermatitis, thyroid disease, psoriasis, vitiligo, and trisomy 21 prior to AA diagnosis all had a significantly higher risk of developing AA, compared with those without those diagnoses.

“This is the largest description of pediatric AA to date,” Ms. McKenzie said. “The prevalence has increased steadily, with a twofold increase over the last 10 years, which mirrors other autoimmune disorders. Children who identify as Hispanic, Asian, and Black have significantly higher incidence rates of alopecia areata compared to those who identify as White.”

Moving forward, she added, “efforts should focus on increasing education and awareness of AA in diverse communities and in community pediatricians so that patients can be diagnosed correctly early on. We can also use this data to ensure that representative populations are included in clinical trials for patients with AA.”

Asked to comment on the results Maria Hordinsky, MD, professor and chair of the department of dermatology at the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, said that the study “is a great contribution to our understanding of the epidemiology of pediatric alopecia areata and also highlights how common alopecia areata is in children.” In an interview, she said that it would be interesting to see if this is a worldwide phenomenon or unique to the United States.

Lawrence J. Green, MD, clinical professor of dermatology at George Washington University, Washington, who was asked to comment on the study, characterized the work as being “very informative. Looking at a large cohort of pediatric patients with alopecia areata diagnosed by a dermatologist or two or more nondermatologists, the authors found a higher incidence and prevalence in nonwhite children here in the United States. I am worried in fact, the true incidence could be even higher than noted in the searched database because nonwhite children can often come from underserved and undercared for areas.”

The other authors were Christopher B. Forrest, MD, PhD, Mitchell Maltenfort, PhD, and Leslie Castelo-Soccio, MD, PhD, of Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia. Dr. Castelo-Soccio is a consultant for Pfizer; the other authors reported having no financial disclosures. Dr. Hordinsky disclosed receiving grant support for clinical research work on hair diseases from Pfizer, Eli Lilly, Concert Pharmaceuticals, and Target Derm and grant support from the National Alopecia Areata Foundation; and is on an advisory panel for Cassiopea. Dr. Green disclosed that he is a speaker, consultant, or investigator for numerous pharmaceutical companies.

*This story was updated on 7/19/21.

[email protected]

The prevalence of pediatric alopecia areata (AA) in the United States has increased twofold over the past decade and it disproportionately affects females and Hispanic children, according to results from the largest study to date on the topic.

“Alopecia areata is a relatively common cause of nonscarring hair loss in children,” Paige McKenzie said during the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology. “The only two epidemiologic studies that have been performed in children have been based on registry or survey data which is inherently at risk for bias,” she added, referring to studies published in 2017 and 2018. “Additionally, epidemiologic descriptions of alopecia areata in adults are limited and overall estimates have varied from 0.2% to 2%. Current understanding is also largely based on population studies in Olmsted County, Minnesota, an area with mostly White racial demographics, so it’s not representative of the U.S. population as a whole.”

To identify the incidence and prevalence of pediatric AA over time, and across age, race/ethnicity, and sex, Ms. McKenzie and colleagues conducted a retrospective cohort study from 2009 to 2020 using PEDSnet, a network of seven U.S. pediatric health institutions with a database of more than 6.5 million children. “PEDSnet is unique because it uses a common data model to standardize EHR data across different health systems and uses SNOMED [Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine]–Clinical Terms to identify specific patient populations,” said Ms. McKenzie, who was a clinical research fellow in the section of dermatology at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia during the 2020-2021 academic year.

She and her coauthors limited their analysis to children younger than age 18 who were assigned a SNOMED code for AA during at least one dermatology physician visit or at least two nondermatology physician visits. They also identified an incidence cohort that was a subset of the study cohort who had at least 12 months of follow-up. “To determine the accuracy of AA patient identification, we also reviewed 100 cases at random from one institution with a threshold of greater than 95% accuracy,” said Ms. McKenzie, who is now a fourth-year medical student at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas.

Of 5,409,919 children included in the study, 5,801 had AA, for an overall prevalence of 0.11%. The prevalence doubled from 0.04% in 2009 to 0.08% in 2019. “It fell in 2020, which we believe is a result of the COVID-19 pandemic’s effects on health care utilization,” she said. AA prevalence peaked at 9 years of age and was higher among females, compared with males (0.12% vs. 0.09%, respectively). The prevalence was highest among Hispanic children (0.23%), followed by Asian children (0.17%), Black children (0.12%), and White children (0.08%).

The incidence cohort consisted of 2,896,241 children. Of these, 2,398 had AA between 2009-2020, for an overall incidence of 13.6 cases per 100,000 patient-years. The incidence rate of AA by age was normally distributed and peaked at 6 years of age. Rates were 22.8% higher in female patients than in male patients. In addition, incidence rates were highest among Hispanics (31.5/100,000 person-years), followed by Asians (23.1/100,000 person-years), Blacks (17.0/100,000 person-years), and Whites (8.8/100,000).

Logistic regression analysis showed general agreement with the unadjusted incidence data. Males were less likely to be diagnosed with AA, compared with females (adjusted odds ratio, 0.80; P < .001). Analysis across race/ethnicity revealed significantly increased rates among children from minority backgrounds when compared with white children. Hispanic children had the greatest risk of developing AA (aOR, 3.07), followed by Asian children (aOR, 2.02), and Black children (aOR, 1.73) (P < .001 for all associations). Patients with atopic dermatitis, thyroid disease, psoriasis, vitiligo, and trisomy 21 prior to AA diagnosis all had a significantly higher risk of developing AA, compared with those without those diagnoses.

“This is the largest description of pediatric AA to date,” Ms. McKenzie said. “The prevalence has increased steadily, with a twofold increase over the last 10 years, which mirrors other autoimmune disorders. Children who identify as Hispanic, Asian, and Black have significantly higher incidence rates of alopecia areata compared to those who identify as White.”

Moving forward, she added, “efforts should focus on increasing education and awareness of AA in diverse communities and in community pediatricians so that patients can be diagnosed correctly early on. We can also use this data to ensure that representative populations are included in clinical trials for patients with AA.”

Asked to comment on the results Maria Hordinsky, MD, professor and chair of the department of dermatology at the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, said that the study “is a great contribution to our understanding of the epidemiology of pediatric alopecia areata and also highlights how common alopecia areata is in children.” In an interview, she said that it would be interesting to see if this is a worldwide phenomenon or unique to the United States.

Lawrence J. Green, MD, clinical professor of dermatology at George Washington University, Washington, who was asked to comment on the study, characterized the work as being “very informative. Looking at a large cohort of pediatric patients with alopecia areata diagnosed by a dermatologist or two or more nondermatologists, the authors found a higher incidence and prevalence in nonwhite children here in the United States. I am worried in fact, the true incidence could be even higher than noted in the searched database because nonwhite children can often come from underserved and undercared for areas.”

The other authors were Christopher B. Forrest, MD, PhD, Mitchell Maltenfort, PhD, and Leslie Castelo-Soccio, MD, PhD, of Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia. Dr. Castelo-Soccio is a consultant for Pfizer; the other authors reported having no financial disclosures. Dr. Hordinsky disclosed receiving grant support for clinical research work on hair diseases from Pfizer, Eli Lilly, Concert Pharmaceuticals, and Target Derm and grant support from the National Alopecia Areata Foundation; and is on an advisory panel for Cassiopea. Dr. Green disclosed that he is a speaker, consultant, or investigator for numerous pharmaceutical companies.

*This story was updated on 7/19/21.

[email protected]

Practice Gap

Perioperative anxiety is common in patients undergoing nail surgery. Patients might worry about seeing blood; about the procedure itself, including nail avulsion; and about associated pain and disfigurement. Nail surgery causes a high level of anxiety that correlates positively with postoperative pain¹ and overall patient dissatisfaction. Furthermore, surgery-related anxiety is a predictor of increased postoperative analgesic use² and delayed recovery.³

Therefore, implementing strategies that reduce perioperative anxiety may help minimize postoperative pain. Squeezing a stress ball, hand-holding, virtual reality, and music are tools that have been studied to reduce anxiety in the context of Mohs micrographic surgery; these strategies have not been studied for nail surgery.

The Technique

Using a sleep mask is a practical solution to reduce patient anxiety during nail surgery. A minority of patients will choose to watch their surgical procedure; most become unnerved observing their nail surgery. Using a sleep mask diverts visual attention from the surgical field without physically interfering with the nail surgeon. Utilizing a sleep mask is cost-effective, with disposable sleep masks available online for less than $0.30 each. Patients can bring their own mask, or a mask can be offered prior to surgery.

If desired, patients are instructed to wear the sleep mask during the entirety of the procedure, starting from anesthetic infiltration until wound closure and dressing application. Any adjustments can be made with the patient’s free hand. The sleep mask can be offered to patients of all ages undergoing nail surgery under local anesthesia, except babies and young children, who require general anesthesia.

Practical Implications

Distraction is an important strategy to reduce anxiety and pain in patients undergoing surgical procedures. In an observational study of 3087 surgical patients, 36% reported that self-distraction was the most helpful strategy for coping with preoperative anxiety.⁴ In a randomized, open-label clinical trial of 72 patients undergoing peripheral venous catheterization, asking the patients simple questions during the procedure was more effective than local anesthesia in reducing the perception of pain.⁵

It is crucial to implement strategies to reduce anxiety in patients undergoing nail surgery. Using a sleep mask impedes direct visualization of the surgical field, thus distracting the patient’s sight and attention from the procedure. Furthermore, this technique is safe and cost-effective.

Controlled clinical trials are necessary to assess the efficacy of this method in reducing nail surgery–related anxiety in comparison to other techniques.

Practice Gap

Perioperative anxiety is common in patients undergoing nail surgery. Patients might worry about seeing blood; about the procedure itself, including nail avulsion; and about associated pain and disfigurement. Nail surgery causes a high level of anxiety that correlates positively with postoperative pain¹ and overall patient dissatisfaction. Furthermore, surgery-related anxiety is a predictor of increased postoperative analgesic use² and delayed recovery.³

Therefore, implementing strategies that reduce perioperative anxiety may help minimize postoperative pain. Squeezing a stress ball, hand-holding, virtual reality, and music are tools that have been studied to reduce anxiety in the context of Mohs micrographic surgery; these strategies have not been studied for nail surgery.

The Technique

Using a sleep mask is a practical solution to reduce patient anxiety during nail surgery. A minority of patients will choose to watch their surgical procedure; most become unnerved observing their nail surgery. Using a sleep mask diverts visual attention from the surgical field without physically interfering with the nail surgeon. Utilizing a sleep mask is cost-effective, with disposable sleep masks available online for less than $0.30 each. Patients can bring their own mask, or a mask can be offered prior to surgery.

If desired, patients are instructed to wear the sleep mask during the entirety of the procedure, starting from anesthetic infiltration until wound closure and dressing application. Any adjustments can be made with the patient’s free hand. The sleep mask can be offered to patients of all ages undergoing nail surgery under local anesthesia, except babies and young children, who require general anesthesia.

Practical Implications

Distraction is an important strategy to reduce anxiety and pain in patients undergoing surgical procedures. In an observational study of 3087 surgical patients, 36% reported that self-distraction was the most helpful strategy for coping with preoperative anxiety.⁴ In a randomized, open-label clinical trial of 72 patients undergoing peripheral venous catheterization, asking the patients simple questions during the procedure was more effective than local anesthesia in reducing the perception of pain.⁵

It is crucial to implement strategies to reduce anxiety in patients undergoing nail surgery. Using a sleep mask impedes direct visualization of the surgical field, thus distracting the patient’s sight and attention from the procedure. Furthermore, this technique is safe and cost-effective.

Controlled clinical trials are necessary to assess the efficacy of this method in reducing nail surgery–related anxiety in comparison to other techniques.

Practice Gap

Perioperative anxiety is common in patients undergoing nail surgery. Patients might worry about seeing blood; about the procedure itself, including nail avulsion; and about associated pain and disfigurement. Nail surgery causes a high level of anxiety that correlates positively with postoperative pain¹ and overall patient dissatisfaction. Furthermore, surgery-related anxiety is a predictor of increased postoperative analgesic use² and delayed recovery.³

Therefore, implementing strategies that reduce perioperative anxiety may help minimize postoperative pain. Squeezing a stress ball, hand-holding, virtual reality, and music are tools that have been studied to reduce anxiety in the context of Mohs micrographic surgery; these strategies have not been studied for nail surgery.

The Technique

Using a sleep mask is a practical solution to reduce patient anxiety during nail surgery. A minority of patients will choose to watch their surgical procedure; most become unnerved observing their nail surgery. Using a sleep mask diverts visual attention from the surgical field without physically interfering with the nail surgeon. Utilizing a sleep mask is cost-effective, with disposable sleep masks available online for less than $0.30 each. Patients can bring their own mask, or a mask can be offered prior to surgery.

If desired, patients are instructed to wear the sleep mask during the entirety of the procedure, starting from anesthetic infiltration until wound closure and dressing application. Any adjustments can be made with the patient’s free hand. The sleep mask can be offered to patients of all ages undergoing nail surgery under local anesthesia, except babies and young children, who require general anesthesia.

Practical Implications

Distraction is an important strategy to reduce anxiety and pain in patients undergoing surgical procedures. In an observational study of 3087 surgical patients, 36% reported that self-distraction was the most helpful strategy for coping with preoperative anxiety.⁴ In a randomized, open-label clinical trial of 72 patients undergoing peripheral venous catheterization, asking the patients simple questions during the procedure was more effective than local anesthesia in reducing the perception of pain.⁵

It is crucial to implement strategies to reduce anxiety in patients undergoing nail surgery. Using a sleep mask impedes direct visualization of the surgical field, thus distracting the patient’s sight and attention from the procedure. Furthermore, this technique is safe and cost-effective.

Controlled clinical trials are necessary to assess the efficacy of this method in reducing nail surgery–related anxiety in comparison to other techniques.

Congenital onychodysplasia of the index finger (COIF), or Iso-Kikuchi syndrome, is a rare disorder characterized by malformation of one or both nails of the index fingers. The various anomalies described are anonychia, micronychia, polyonychia, malalignment, or hemi-onychogryphosis. It may be associated with abnormalities of the underlying phalangeal bone, the most masked being bifurcation of the terminal phalange.¹ Initially thought to be nonhereditary and nonfamilial,² it is now known that COIF can be inherited in an autosomal-dominant fashion.³ Millman and Strier³ described a family of 9 patients with COIF. It rarely is described outside of Japan. Padmavathy et al⁴ described a case in an Indian patient with COIF that was associated with the absence of a ring finger in addition to anomalies of the metacarpal bones.

Congenital onychodysplasia of the index finger has a broad spectrum regarding its etiology and clinical features.⁵ The pathogenesis of COIF still is poorly understood. Deficient circulation in digital arteries is thought to be a putative mechanism for developing a deformed nail. The nail is affected on the radial side of the index finger, likely because of the smaller caliber of the artery on that side.⁵ Hereditary as well as nonhereditary sporadic cases have been reported. In addition to the various fingernail anomalies, skeletal abnormalities also have been reported. Baran and Stroud⁶ have reported deformed lunulae as a manifestation of COIF.

The Diagnosis: Congenital Onychodysplasia of the Index Finger

The differential diagnosis of COIF includes hidrotic ectodermal dysplasia, nail-patella syndrome, Poland syndrome, and DOOR syndrome. Hidrotic ectodermal dysplasia exhibits onychodystrophy, generalized hypotrichosis, palmoplantar keratoderma, and dental anomalies.⁷ Nail-patella syndrome presents with hypoplasia of the fingernails and toenails, triangular nail lunulae, absent or hypoplastic patellae, and elbow and iliac horn dysplasia. Poland syndrome is distinguished from COIF by the congenital absence of the pectoralis major muscle on the ipsilateral side of the involved digits. The DOOR syndrome tetrad is comprised of deafness, onychodystrophy, osteodystrophy, and mental retardation.⁸ Unlike these conditions, COIF does not involve systems other than the nails and phalanges.

Treatment of this condition is mainly conservative, as patients typically do not have symptoms.⁹ Surgical interventions can be considered for cosmetic concerns. Knowledge of this congenital entity and its clinical findings is essential to prevent unnecessary procedures and workup.

Congenital onychodysplasia of the index finger (COIF), or Iso-Kikuchi syndrome, is a rare disorder characterized by malformation of one or both nails of the index fingers. The various anomalies described are anonychia, micronychia, polyonychia, malalignment, or hemi-onychogryphosis. It may be associated with abnormalities of the underlying phalangeal bone, the most masked being bifurcation of the terminal phalange.¹ Initially thought to be nonhereditary and nonfamilial,² it is now known that COIF can be inherited in an autosomal-dominant fashion.³ Millman and Strier³ described a family of 9 patients with COIF. It rarely is described outside of Japan. Padmavathy et al⁴ described a case in an Indian patient with COIF that was associated with the absence of a ring finger in addition to anomalies of the metacarpal bones.

Congenital onychodysplasia of the index finger has a broad spectrum regarding its etiology and clinical features.⁵ The pathogenesis of COIF still is poorly understood. Deficient circulation in digital arteries is thought to be a putative mechanism for developing a deformed nail. The nail is affected on the radial side of the index finger, likely because of the smaller caliber of the artery on that side.⁵ Hereditary as well as nonhereditary sporadic cases have been reported. In addition to the various fingernail anomalies, skeletal abnormalities also have been reported. Baran and Stroud⁶ have reported deformed lunulae as a manifestation of COIF.

The Diagnosis: Congenital Onychodysplasia of the Index Finger

The differential diagnosis of COIF includes hidrotic ectodermal dysplasia, nail-patella syndrome, Poland syndrome, and DOOR syndrome. Hidrotic ectodermal dysplasia exhibits onychodystrophy, generalized hypotrichosis, palmoplantar keratoderma, and dental anomalies.⁷ Nail-patella syndrome presents with hypoplasia of the fingernails and toenails, triangular nail lunulae, absent or hypoplastic patellae, and elbow and iliac horn dysplasia. Poland syndrome is distinguished from COIF by the congenital absence of the pectoralis major muscle on the ipsilateral side of the involved digits. The DOOR syndrome tetrad is comprised of deafness, onychodystrophy, osteodystrophy, and mental retardation.⁸ Unlike these conditions, COIF does not involve systems other than the nails and phalanges.

Treatment of this condition is mainly conservative, as patients typically do not have symptoms.⁹ Surgical interventions can be considered for cosmetic concerns. Knowledge of this congenital entity and its clinical findings is essential to prevent unnecessary procedures and workup.

Congenital onychodysplasia of the index finger (COIF), or Iso-Kikuchi syndrome, is a rare disorder characterized by malformation of one or both nails of the index fingers. The various anomalies described are anonychia, micronychia, polyonychia, malalignment, or hemi-onychogryphosis. It may be associated with abnormalities of the underlying phalangeal bone, the most masked being bifurcation of the terminal phalange.¹ Initially thought to be nonhereditary and nonfamilial,² it is now known that COIF can be inherited in an autosomal-dominant fashion.³ Millman and Strier³ described a family of 9 patients with COIF. It rarely is described outside of Japan. Padmavathy et al⁴ described a case in an Indian patient with COIF that was associated with the absence of a ring finger in addition to anomalies of the metacarpal bones.

Congenital onychodysplasia of the index finger has a broad spectrum regarding its etiology and clinical features.⁵ The pathogenesis of COIF still is poorly understood. Deficient circulation in digital arteries is thought to be a putative mechanism for developing a deformed nail. The nail is affected on the radial side of the index finger, likely because of the smaller caliber of the artery on that side.⁵ Hereditary as well as nonhereditary sporadic cases have been reported. In addition to the various fingernail anomalies, skeletal abnormalities also have been reported. Baran and Stroud⁶ have reported deformed lunulae as a manifestation of COIF.

The Diagnosis: Congenital Onychodysplasia of the Index Finger

The differential diagnosis of COIF includes hidrotic ectodermal dysplasia, nail-patella syndrome, Poland syndrome, and DOOR syndrome. Hidrotic ectodermal dysplasia exhibits onychodystrophy, generalized hypotrichosis, palmoplantar keratoderma, and dental anomalies.⁷ Nail-patella syndrome presents with hypoplasia of the fingernails and toenails, triangular nail lunulae, absent or hypoplastic patellae, and elbow and iliac horn dysplasia. Poland syndrome is distinguished from COIF by the congenital absence of the pectoralis major muscle on the ipsilateral side of the involved digits. The DOOR syndrome tetrad is comprised of deafness, onychodystrophy, osteodystrophy, and mental retardation.⁸ Unlike these conditions, COIF does not involve systems other than the nails and phalanges.

Treatment of this condition is mainly conservative, as patients typically do not have symptoms.⁹ Surgical interventions can be considered for cosmetic concerns. Knowledge of this congenital entity and its clinical findings is essential to prevent unnecessary procedures and workup.

Professional appearance of servicemembers has been a long-standing custom in the US Military. Specific standards are determined by each branch. Initially, men dominated the military.^1,2 As the number of women as well as racial diversity increased in the military, modifications to grooming standards were slow to change and resulted in female hair standards requiring a uniform tight and sleek style or short haircut. Clinicians can be attuned to these occupational standards and their implications on the diagnosis and management of common diseases of the hair and scalp.

History of Hairstyle Standards for Female Servicemembers

For half a century, female servicemembers had limited hairstyle choices. They were not authorized to have hair shorter than one-quarter inch in length. They could choose either short hair worn down or long hair with neatly secured loose ends in the form of a bun or a tucked braid—both of which could not extend past the bottom edge of the uniform collar.^3-5 Female navy sailors and air force airmen with long hair were only allowed to wear ponytails during physical training; however, army soldiers previously were limited to wearing a bun.^3,6,7 Cornrows and microbraids were authorized in the mid-1990s for the US Air Force, but policy stated that locs were prohibited due to their “unkempt” and “matted” nature. Furthermore, the size of hair bulk in the air force was restricted to no more than 3 inches and could not obstruct wear of the uniform cap.⁵ Based on these regulations, female servicemembers with longer hair had to utilize tight hairstyles that caused prolonged traction and pressure along the scalp, which contributed to headaches, a sore scalp, and alopecia over time. Normalization of these symptoms led to underreporting, as women lived with the consequences or turned to shorter hairstyles.

In the last decade alone, female servicemembers have witnessed the greatest number of changes in authorized hairstyles despite being part of the military for more than 50 years (Figure 1).^1-11 In 2014, the language used in the air force instructions to describe locs was revised to remove ethnically offensive terms.^4,5 This same year, the army allowed female soldiers to wear ponytails during physical training, a privilege that had been authorized by other services years prior.^3,6,7 By the end of 2018, locs were authorized by all services, and female sailors could wear a ponytail in all navy uniforms as long as it did not extend 3 inches below the collar.^3,4,6-8 In 2018, the air force increased authorized hair bulk up to 3.5 inches from the previous mandate of 3 inches and approved female buzz cuts^6,9; in 2020, it allowed hair bulk up to 4 inches. As of 2021, female airmen can wear a ponytail and/or braid(s) as long as it starts below the crown of the head and the length does not extend below a horizontal line running between the top of each sleeve inseam at the underarm (Figures 2–4).⁶ In an ongoing effort to be more inclusive of hair density differences, female airmen will be authorized to wear a ponytail not exceeding a maximum width bulk of 1 ft starting June 25, 2021, so long as they can comply with the above regulations.¹¹ The army now allows ponytails and braids across all uniforms, as long they do not extend past the bottom of the shoulder blades. This change came just months after authorizing the wearing of ponytails tucked under the uniform blouse with tactical headgear.¹⁰ These changes allow for a variety of hairstyles for members to practice while avoiding the physical consequences that develop from repetitive traction and pressure along the same areas of the hair and scalp.

Common Hair Disorders in Female Servicemembers

Herein, we discuss 3 of the most common hair and scalp disorders linked to grooming practices utilized by women to meet prior military regulations: trichorrhexis nodosa (TN), extracranial headaches, and traction alopecia (TA). It is essential that health care providers are able to promptly recognize these conditions, understand their risk factors, and be familiar with first-line treatment options. With these new standards, the hope is that the incidence of the following conditions decreases, thus improving servicemembers’ medical readiness and overall quality of life.

Trichorrhexis Nodosa
Acquired TN is a defect in the hair shaft that causes the hair to break easily secondary to chemical, thermal, or mechanical trauma. This can include but is not limited to chemical relaxers, blow-dryers, excessive brushing or styling, flat irons, and tightly packed hairstyles. The condition is characterized by a thickened hair diameter and splitting at the tip. Clinically, it may present as brittle, lusterless, broken hair with split ends, as well as a positive tug test.¹⁴ Management includes gentle hair care and avoidance of harsh hair care practices and treatments.

Extracranial Headaches
Headaches are a common concern among military servicemembers¹⁵ and generally are classified as primary or secondary. A less commonly discussed primary headache disorder includes external-pressure headaches, which result from either sustained compression or traction of the soft tissues of the scalp, usually from wearing headbands, helmets, or tight hairstyles.¹⁶ Additional at-risk groups include those who chronically wear surgical scrub caps or flight caps, especially if clipped or pinned to the hair. In our 38 years of combined military clinical experience, we can attest that these types of headaches are common among female servicemembers. The diagnostic criteria for an external-pressure headache, commonly referred to by patients as a “ponytail headache,” includes at least 2 headache episodes triggered within 1 hour of sustained traction on the scalp, maximal at the site of traction and resolving within 1 hour after relieving the traction.¹⁶ Management includes removal of the pressure-causing source, usually a tight ponytail or bun.

Traction Alopecia
Traction alopecia is hair loss caused by repetitive or prolonged tension on the hair secondary to tight hairstyles. It can be clinically classified into 2 types: marginal and nonmarginal patchy alopecia (Figure 5).^13,17,18 Traction alopecia most commonly is found in individuals with ethnic hair, predominantly Black women. Hairstyles with the highest risk for causing TA include tight buns, ponytails, cornrows, weaves, and locs—all of which are utilized by female servicemembers to maintain a professional appearance and adhere to grooming regulations.^13,18 Other groups at risk include athletes (eg, ballerinas, gymnasts) and those with chronic headwear use (eg, turbans, helmets, nurse caps, wigs).¹⁸ Early TA typically presents with perifollicular erythema followed by follicular-based papules or pustules.^13,18 Marginal TA classically includes frontotemporal hair loss or thinning with or without a fringe sign.^17,18 Nonmarginal TA includes patchy alopecia most commonly involving the parietal or occipital scalp, seen with chignons, buns, ponytails, or the use of clips, extensions, or bobby pins.¹⁸ The first line in management is avoidance of traction-causing hairstyles or headgear. Medical therapy may be warranted and consists of a single agent or combination regimen to include oral or topical antibiotics, topical or intralesional steroids, and topical minoxidil.^13,18

Final Thoughts

Military hair-grooming standards have evolved over time. Recent changes show that the US Department of Defense is seriously evaluating policies that may be inherently exclusive. Prior grooming standards resulted in the widespread use of tight hairstyles and harsh hair treatments among female servicemembers with long hair. These practices resulted in TN, extracranial headaches, and TA, among other hair and scalp disorders. These occupational-related hair conditions impact female servicemembers’ mental and physical well-being and thus impact military readiness. Physicians should recognize that these conditions can be related to occupational grooming standards that may impact hair care practices.

The challenge that remains is a lack of standardized documentation for hair and scalp symptoms in the medical record. Due to a paucity in reporting and documentation, limited objective data exist to guide future recommendations for military grooming standards. Another obstacle is the lack of knowledge of hair diseases among primary care providers and patients, especially due to the underrepresentation of ethnic hair in medical textbooks.¹⁹ As a result, women frequently accept their hair symptoms as normal and either suffer through them, cut their hair short, or wear wigs before considering a visit to the doctor. Furthermore, hair-grooming standards can expose racial disparities, which are the driving force behind the current policy changes. Clinicians can strive to ask about hair and scalp symptoms and document the following in relation to hair and scalp disorders: occupational grooming requirements; skin and hair type; location, number, and size of scalp lesion(s); onset; duration; current and prior hair care practices; history of treatment; and clinical course accompanied with photographic documentation. Ultimately, improved awareness in patients, collaboration between physicians, and consistent clinical documentation can help create positive change and continued improvement in hair-grooming standards within the military. Improved reporting and documentation will facilitate further study into the effectiveness of the updated hair-grooming standards in female servicemembers.

Professional appearance of servicemembers has been a long-standing custom in the US Military. Specific standards are determined by each branch. Initially, men dominated the military.^1,2 As the number of women as well as racial diversity increased in the military, modifications to grooming standards were slow to change and resulted in female hair standards requiring a uniform tight and sleek style or short haircut. Clinicians can be attuned to these occupational standards and their implications on the diagnosis and management of common diseases of the hair and scalp.

History of Hairstyle Standards for Female Servicemembers

For half a century, female servicemembers had limited hairstyle choices. They were not authorized to have hair shorter than one-quarter inch in length. They could choose either short hair worn down or long hair with neatly secured loose ends in the form of a bun or a tucked braid—both of which could not extend past the bottom edge of the uniform collar.^3-5 Female navy sailors and air force airmen with long hair were only allowed to wear ponytails during physical training; however, army soldiers previously were limited to wearing a bun.^3,6,7 Cornrows and microbraids were authorized in the mid-1990s for the US Air Force, but policy stated that locs were prohibited due to their “unkempt” and “matted” nature. Furthermore, the size of hair bulk in the air force was restricted to no more than 3 inches and could not obstruct wear of the uniform cap.⁵ Based on these regulations, female servicemembers with longer hair had to utilize tight hairstyles that caused prolonged traction and pressure along the scalp, which contributed to headaches, a sore scalp, and alopecia over time. Normalization of these symptoms led to underreporting, as women lived with the consequences or turned to shorter hairstyles.

In the last decade alone, female servicemembers have witnessed the greatest number of changes in authorized hairstyles despite being part of the military for more than 50 years (Figure 1).^1-11 In 2014, the language used in the air force instructions to describe locs was revised to remove ethnically offensive terms.^4,5 This same year, the army allowed female soldiers to wear ponytails during physical training, a privilege that had been authorized by other services years prior.^3,6,7 By the end of 2018, locs were authorized by all services, and female sailors could wear a ponytail in all navy uniforms as long as it did not extend 3 inches below the collar.^3,4,6-8 In 2018, the air force increased authorized hair bulk up to 3.5 inches from the previous mandate of 3 inches and approved female buzz cuts^6,9; in 2020, it allowed hair bulk up to 4 inches. As of 2021, female airmen can wear a ponytail and/or braid(s) as long as it starts below the crown of the head and the length does not extend below a horizontal line running between the top of each sleeve inseam at the underarm (Figures 2–4).⁶ In an ongoing effort to be more inclusive of hair density differences, female airmen will be authorized to wear a ponytail not exceeding a maximum width bulk of 1 ft starting June 25, 2021, so long as they can comply with the above regulations.¹¹ The army now allows ponytails and braids across all uniforms, as long they do not extend past the bottom of the shoulder blades. This change came just months after authorizing the wearing of ponytails tucked under the uniform blouse with tactical headgear.¹⁰ These changes allow for a variety of hairstyles for members to practice while avoiding the physical consequences that develop from repetitive traction and pressure along the same areas of the hair and scalp.

Common Hair Disorders in Female Servicemembers

Herein, we discuss 3 of the most common hair and scalp disorders linked to grooming practices utilized by women to meet prior military regulations: trichorrhexis nodosa (TN), extracranial headaches, and traction alopecia (TA). It is essential that health care providers are able to promptly recognize these conditions, understand their risk factors, and be familiar with first-line treatment options. With these new standards, the hope is that the incidence of the following conditions decreases, thus improving servicemembers’ medical readiness and overall quality of life.

Trichorrhexis Nodosa
Acquired TN is a defect in the hair shaft that causes the hair to break easily secondary to chemical, thermal, or mechanical trauma. This can include but is not limited to chemical relaxers, blow-dryers, excessive brushing or styling, flat irons, and tightly packed hairstyles. The condition is characterized by a thickened hair diameter and splitting at the tip. Clinically, it may present as brittle, lusterless, broken hair with split ends, as well as a positive tug test.¹⁴ Management includes gentle hair care and avoidance of harsh hair care practices and treatments.

Extracranial Headaches
Headaches are a common concern among military servicemembers¹⁵ and generally are classified as primary or secondary. A less commonly discussed primary headache disorder includes external-pressure headaches, which result from either sustained compression or traction of the soft tissues of the scalp, usually from wearing headbands, helmets, or tight hairstyles.¹⁶ Additional at-risk groups include those who chronically wear surgical scrub caps or flight caps, especially if clipped or pinned to the hair. In our 38 years of combined military clinical experience, we can attest that these types of headaches are common among female servicemembers. The diagnostic criteria for an external-pressure headache, commonly referred to by patients as a “ponytail headache,” includes at least 2 headache episodes triggered within 1 hour of sustained traction on the scalp, maximal at the site of traction and resolving within 1 hour after relieving the traction.¹⁶ Management includes removal of the pressure-causing source, usually a tight ponytail or bun.

Traction Alopecia
Traction alopecia is hair loss caused by repetitive or prolonged tension on the hair secondary to tight hairstyles. It can be clinically classified into 2 types: marginal and nonmarginal patchy alopecia (Figure 5).^13,17,18 Traction alopecia most commonly is found in individuals with ethnic hair, predominantly Black women. Hairstyles with the highest risk for causing TA include tight buns, ponytails, cornrows, weaves, and locs—all of which are utilized by female servicemembers to maintain a professional appearance and adhere to grooming regulations.^13,18 Other groups at risk include athletes (eg, ballerinas, gymnasts) and those with chronic headwear use (eg, turbans, helmets, nurse caps, wigs).¹⁸ Early TA typically presents with perifollicular erythema followed by follicular-based papules or pustules.^13,18 Marginal TA classically includes frontotemporal hair loss or thinning with or without a fringe sign.^17,18 Nonmarginal TA includes patchy alopecia most commonly involving the parietal or occipital scalp, seen with chignons, buns, ponytails, or the use of clips, extensions, or bobby pins.¹⁸ The first line in management is avoidance of traction-causing hairstyles or headgear. Medical therapy may be warranted and consists of a single agent or combination regimen to include oral or topical antibiotics, topical or intralesional steroids, and topical minoxidil.^13,18

Final Thoughts

Military hair-grooming standards have evolved over time. Recent changes show that the US Department of Defense is seriously evaluating policies that may be inherently exclusive. Prior grooming standards resulted in the widespread use of tight hairstyles and harsh hair treatments among female servicemembers with long hair. These practices resulted in TN, extracranial headaches, and TA, among other hair and scalp disorders. These occupational-related hair conditions impact female servicemembers’ mental and physical well-being and thus impact military readiness. Physicians should recognize that these conditions can be related to occupational grooming standards that may impact hair care practices.

The challenge that remains is a lack of standardized documentation for hair and scalp symptoms in the medical record. Due to a paucity in reporting and documentation, limited objective data exist to guide future recommendations for military grooming standards. Another obstacle is the lack of knowledge of hair diseases among primary care providers and patients, especially due to the underrepresentation of ethnic hair in medical textbooks.¹⁹ As a result, women frequently accept their hair symptoms as normal and either suffer through them, cut their hair short, or wear wigs before considering a visit to the doctor. Furthermore, hair-grooming standards can expose racial disparities, which are the driving force behind the current policy changes. Clinicians can strive to ask about hair and scalp symptoms and document the following in relation to hair and scalp disorders: occupational grooming requirements; skin and hair type; location, number, and size of scalp lesion(s); onset; duration; current and prior hair care practices; history of treatment; and clinical course accompanied with photographic documentation. Ultimately, improved awareness in patients, collaboration between physicians, and consistent clinical documentation can help create positive change and continued improvement in hair-grooming standards within the military. Improved reporting and documentation will facilitate further study into the effectiveness of the updated hair-grooming standards in female servicemembers.

Professional appearance of servicemembers has been a long-standing custom in the US Military. Specific standards are determined by each branch. Initially, men dominated the military.^1,2 As the number of women as well as racial diversity increased in the military, modifications to grooming standards were slow to change and resulted in female hair standards requiring a uniform tight and sleek style or short haircut. Clinicians can be attuned to these occupational standards and their implications on the diagnosis and management of common diseases of the hair and scalp.

History of Hairstyle Standards for Female Servicemembers

For half a century, female servicemembers had limited hairstyle choices. They were not authorized to have hair shorter than one-quarter inch in length. They could choose either short hair worn down or long hair with neatly secured loose ends in the form of a bun or a tucked braid—both of which could not extend past the bottom edge of the uniform collar.^3-5 Female navy sailors and air force airmen with long hair were only allowed to wear ponytails during physical training; however, army soldiers previously were limited to wearing a bun.^3,6,7 Cornrows and microbraids were authorized in the mid-1990s for the US Air Force, but policy stated that locs were prohibited due to their “unkempt” and “matted” nature. Furthermore, the size of hair bulk in the air force was restricted to no more than 3 inches and could not obstruct wear of the uniform cap.⁵ Based on these regulations, female servicemembers with longer hair had to utilize tight hairstyles that caused prolonged traction and pressure along the scalp, which contributed to headaches, a sore scalp, and alopecia over time. Normalization of these symptoms led to underreporting, as women lived with the consequences or turned to shorter hairstyles.

In the last decade alone, female servicemembers have witnessed the greatest number of changes in authorized hairstyles despite being part of the military for more than 50 years (Figure 1).^1-11 In 2014, the language used in the air force instructions to describe locs was revised to remove ethnically offensive terms.^4,5 This same year, the army allowed female soldiers to wear ponytails during physical training, a privilege that had been authorized by other services years prior.^3,6,7 By the end of 2018, locs were authorized by all services, and female sailors could wear a ponytail in all navy uniforms as long as it did not extend 3 inches below the collar.^3,4,6-8 In 2018, the air force increased authorized hair bulk up to 3.5 inches from the previous mandate of 3 inches and approved female buzz cuts^6,9; in 2020, it allowed hair bulk up to 4 inches. As of 2021, female airmen can wear a ponytail and/or braid(s) as long as it starts below the crown of the head and the length does not extend below a horizontal line running between the top of each sleeve inseam at the underarm (Figures 2–4).⁶ In an ongoing effort to be more inclusive of hair density differences, female airmen will be authorized to wear a ponytail not exceeding a maximum width bulk of 1 ft starting June 25, 2021, so long as they can comply with the above regulations.¹¹ The army now allows ponytails and braids across all uniforms, as long they do not extend past the bottom of the shoulder blades. This change came just months after authorizing the wearing of ponytails tucked under the uniform blouse with tactical headgear.¹⁰ These changes allow for a variety of hairstyles for members to practice while avoiding the physical consequences that develop from repetitive traction and pressure along the same areas of the hair and scalp.

Common Hair Disorders in Female Servicemembers

Herein, we discuss 3 of the most common hair and scalp disorders linked to grooming practices utilized by women to meet prior military regulations: trichorrhexis nodosa (TN), extracranial headaches, and traction alopecia (TA). It is essential that health care providers are able to promptly recognize these conditions, understand their risk factors, and be familiar with first-line treatment options. With these new standards, the hope is that the incidence of the following conditions decreases, thus improving servicemembers’ medical readiness and overall quality of life.

Trichorrhexis Nodosa
Acquired TN is a defect in the hair shaft that causes the hair to break easily secondary to chemical, thermal, or mechanical trauma. This can include but is not limited to chemical relaxers, blow-dryers, excessive brushing or styling, flat irons, and tightly packed hairstyles. The condition is characterized by a thickened hair diameter and splitting at the tip. Clinically, it may present as brittle, lusterless, broken hair with split ends, as well as a positive tug test.¹⁴ Management includes gentle hair care and avoidance of harsh hair care practices and treatments.

Extracranial Headaches
Headaches are a common concern among military servicemembers¹⁵ and generally are classified as primary or secondary. A less commonly discussed primary headache disorder includes external-pressure headaches, which result from either sustained compression or traction of the soft tissues of the scalp, usually from wearing headbands, helmets, or tight hairstyles.¹⁶ Additional at-risk groups include those who chronically wear surgical scrub caps or flight caps, especially if clipped or pinned to the hair. In our 38 years of combined military clinical experience, we can attest that these types of headaches are common among female servicemembers. The diagnostic criteria for an external-pressure headache, commonly referred to by patients as a “ponytail headache,” includes at least 2 headache episodes triggered within 1 hour of sustained traction on the scalp, maximal at the site of traction and resolving within 1 hour after relieving the traction.¹⁶ Management includes removal of the pressure-causing source, usually a tight ponytail or bun.

Traction Alopecia
Traction alopecia is hair loss caused by repetitive or prolonged tension on the hair secondary to tight hairstyles. It can be clinically classified into 2 types: marginal and nonmarginal patchy alopecia (Figure 5).^13,17,18 Traction alopecia most commonly is found in individuals with ethnic hair, predominantly Black women. Hairstyles with the highest risk for causing TA include tight buns, ponytails, cornrows, weaves, and locs—all of which are utilized by female servicemembers to maintain a professional appearance and adhere to grooming regulations.^13,18 Other groups at risk include athletes (eg, ballerinas, gymnasts) and those with chronic headwear use (eg, turbans, helmets, nurse caps, wigs).¹⁸ Early TA typically presents with perifollicular erythema followed by follicular-based papules or pustules.^13,18 Marginal TA classically includes frontotemporal hair loss or thinning with or without a fringe sign.^17,18 Nonmarginal TA includes patchy alopecia most commonly involving the parietal or occipital scalp, seen with chignons, buns, ponytails, or the use of clips, extensions, or bobby pins.¹⁸ The first line in management is avoidance of traction-causing hairstyles or headgear. Medical therapy may be warranted and consists of a single agent or combination regimen to include oral or topical antibiotics, topical or intralesional steroids, and topical minoxidil.^13,18

Final Thoughts

Military hair-grooming standards have evolved over time. Recent changes show that the US Department of Defense is seriously evaluating policies that may be inherently exclusive. Prior grooming standards resulted in the widespread use of tight hairstyles and harsh hair treatments among female servicemembers with long hair. These practices resulted in TN, extracranial headaches, and TA, among other hair and scalp disorders. These occupational-related hair conditions impact female servicemembers’ mental and physical well-being and thus impact military readiness. Physicians should recognize that these conditions can be related to occupational grooming standards that may impact hair care practices.

The challenge that remains is a lack of standardized documentation for hair and scalp symptoms in the medical record. Due to a paucity in reporting and documentation, limited objective data exist to guide future recommendations for military grooming standards. Another obstacle is the lack of knowledge of hair diseases among primary care providers and patients, especially due to the underrepresentation of ethnic hair in medical textbooks.¹⁹ As a result, women frequently accept their hair symptoms as normal and either suffer through them, cut their hair short, or wear wigs before considering a visit to the doctor. Furthermore, hair-grooming standards can expose racial disparities, which are the driving force behind the current policy changes. Clinicians can strive to ask about hair and scalp symptoms and document the following in relation to hair and scalp disorders: occupational grooming requirements; skin and hair type; location, number, and size of scalp lesion(s); onset; duration; current and prior hair care practices; history of treatment; and clinical course accompanied with photographic documentation. Ultimately, improved awareness in patients, collaboration between physicians, and consistent clinical documentation can help create positive change and continued improvement in hair-grooming standards within the military. Improved reporting and documentation will facilitate further study into the effectiveness of the updated hair-grooming standards in female servicemembers.

Goodbye stress, goodbye gray hair

Last year was a doozy, so it wouldn’t be too surprising if we all had a few new gray strands in our hair. But what if we told you that you don’t need to start dying them or plucking them out? What if they could magically go back to the way they were? Well, it may be possible, sans magic and sans stress.

Investigators recently discovered that the age-old belief that stress will permanently turn your hair gray may not be true after all. There’s a strong possibility that it could turn back to its original color once the stressful agent is eliminated.

“Understanding the mechanisms that allow ‘old’ gray hairs to return to their ‘young’ pigmented states could yield new clues about the malleability of human aging in general and how it is influenced by stress,” said senior author Martin Picard, PhD, of Columbia University, New York.

NomeVisualizzato/Pixabay

One small step for squid

Space does a number on the human body. Forget the obvious like going for a walk outside without a spacesuit, or even the well-known risks like the degradation of bone in microgravity; there are numerous smaller but still important changes to the body during spaceflight, like the disruption of the symbiotic relationship between gut bacteria and the human body. This causes the immune system to lose the ability to recognize threats, and illnesses spread more easily.

Naturally, if astronauts are going to undertake years-long journeys to Mars and beyond, a thorough understanding of this disturbance is necessary, and that’s why NASA has sent a bunch of squid to the International Space Station.

When it comes to animal studies, squid aren’t the usual culprits, but there’s a reason NASA chose calamari over the alternatives: The Hawaiian bobtail squid has a symbiotic relationship with bacteria that regulate their bioluminescence in much the same way that we have a symbiotic relationship with our gut bacteria, but the squid is a much simpler animal. If the bioluminescence-regulating bacteria are disturbed during their time in space, it will be much easier to figure out what’s going wrong.

PxHere

Less plastic, more vanilla

Have you been racked by guilt over the number of plastic water bottles you use? What about the amount of ice cream you eat? Well, this one’s for you.

Plastic isn’t the first thing you think about when you open up a pint of vanilla ice cream and catch the sweet, spicy vanilla scent, or when you smell those fresh vanilla scones coming out of the oven at the coffee shop, but a new study shows that the flavor of vanilla can come from water bottles.

Here’s the deal. A compound called vanillin is responsible for the scent of vanilla, and it can come naturally from the bean or it can be made synthetically. Believe it or not, 85% of vanillin is made synthetically from fossil fuels!

We’ve definitely grown accustomed to our favorite vanilla scents, foods, and cosmetics. In 2018, the global demand for vanillin was about 40,800 tons and is expected to grow to 65,000 tons by 2025, which far exceeds the supply of natural vanilla.

So what can we do? Well, we can use genetically engineered bacteria to turn plastic water bottles into vanillin, according to a study published in the journal Green Chemistry.

tezzstock/Thinkstock

No withdrawals from this bank

Into each life, some milestones must fall: High school graduation, birth of a child, first house, 50th wedding anniversary, COVID-19. One LOTME staffer got really excited – way too excited, actually – when his Nissan Sentra reached 300,000 miles.

Well, there are milestones, and then there are milestones. “1,000 Reasons for Hope” is a report celebrating the first 1,000 brains donated to the VA-BU-CLF Brain Bank. For those of you keeping score at home, that would be the Department of Veterans Affairs, Boston University, and the Concussion Legacy Foundation.

The Brain Bank, created in 2008 to study concussions and chronic traumatic encephalopathy, is the brainchild – yes, we went there – of Chris Nowinski, PhD, a former professional wrestler, and Ann McKee, MD, an expert on neurogenerative disease. “Our discoveries have already inspired changes to sports that will prevent many future cases of CTE in the next generation of athletes,” Dr. Nowinski, the CEO of CLF, said in a written statement.

Jana Blaková/Thinkstock

Goodbye stress, goodbye gray hair

Last year was a doozy, so it wouldn’t be too surprising if we all had a few new gray strands in our hair. But what if we told you that you don’t need to start dying them or plucking them out? What if they could magically go back to the way they were? Well, it may be possible, sans magic and sans stress.

Investigators recently discovered that the age-old belief that stress will permanently turn your hair gray may not be true after all. There’s a strong possibility that it could turn back to its original color once the stressful agent is eliminated.

“Understanding the mechanisms that allow ‘old’ gray hairs to return to their ‘young’ pigmented states could yield new clues about the malleability of human aging in general and how it is influenced by stress,” said senior author Martin Picard, PhD, of Columbia University, New York.

NomeVisualizzato/Pixabay

One small step for squid

Space does a number on the human body. Forget the obvious like going for a walk outside without a spacesuit, or even the well-known risks like the degradation of bone in microgravity; there are numerous smaller but still important changes to the body during spaceflight, like the disruption of the symbiotic relationship between gut bacteria and the human body. This causes the immune system to lose the ability to recognize threats, and illnesses spread more easily.

Naturally, if astronauts are going to undertake years-long journeys to Mars and beyond, a thorough understanding of this disturbance is necessary, and that’s why NASA has sent a bunch of squid to the International Space Station.

When it comes to animal studies, squid aren’t the usual culprits, but there’s a reason NASA chose calamari over the alternatives: The Hawaiian bobtail squid has a symbiotic relationship with bacteria that regulate their bioluminescence in much the same way that we have a symbiotic relationship with our gut bacteria, but the squid is a much simpler animal. If the bioluminescence-regulating bacteria are disturbed during their time in space, it will be much easier to figure out what’s going wrong.

PxHere

Less plastic, more vanilla

Have you been racked by guilt over the number of plastic water bottles you use? What about the amount of ice cream you eat? Well, this one’s for you.

Plastic isn’t the first thing you think about when you open up a pint of vanilla ice cream and catch the sweet, spicy vanilla scent, or when you smell those fresh vanilla scones coming out of the oven at the coffee shop, but a new study shows that the flavor of vanilla can come from water bottles.

Here’s the deal. A compound called vanillin is responsible for the scent of vanilla, and it can come naturally from the bean or it can be made synthetically. Believe it or not, 85% of vanillin is made synthetically from fossil fuels!

We’ve definitely grown accustomed to our favorite vanilla scents, foods, and cosmetics. In 2018, the global demand for vanillin was about 40,800 tons and is expected to grow to 65,000 tons by 2025, which far exceeds the supply of natural vanilla.

So what can we do? Well, we can use genetically engineered bacteria to turn plastic water bottles into vanillin, according to a study published in the journal Green Chemistry.

tezzstock/Thinkstock

No withdrawals from this bank

Into each life, some milestones must fall: High school graduation, birth of a child, first house, 50th wedding anniversary, COVID-19. One LOTME staffer got really excited – way too excited, actually – when his Nissan Sentra reached 300,000 miles.

Well, there are milestones, and then there are milestones. “1,000 Reasons for Hope” is a report celebrating the first 1,000 brains donated to the VA-BU-CLF Brain Bank. For those of you keeping score at home, that would be the Department of Veterans Affairs, Boston University, and the Concussion Legacy Foundation.

The Brain Bank, created in 2008 to study concussions and chronic traumatic encephalopathy, is the brainchild – yes, we went there – of Chris Nowinski, PhD, a former professional wrestler, and Ann McKee, MD, an expert on neurogenerative disease. “Our discoveries have already inspired changes to sports that will prevent many future cases of CTE in the next generation of athletes,” Dr. Nowinski, the CEO of CLF, said in a written statement.

Jana Blaková/Thinkstock

Goodbye stress, goodbye gray hair

Last year was a doozy, so it wouldn’t be too surprising if we all had a few new gray strands in our hair. But what if we told you that you don’t need to start dying them or plucking them out? What if they could magically go back to the way they were? Well, it may be possible, sans magic and sans stress.

Investigators recently discovered that the age-old belief that stress will permanently turn your hair gray may not be true after all. There’s a strong possibility that it could turn back to its original color once the stressful agent is eliminated.

“Understanding the mechanisms that allow ‘old’ gray hairs to return to their ‘young’ pigmented states could yield new clues about the malleability of human aging in general and how it is influenced by stress,” said senior author Martin Picard, PhD, of Columbia University, New York.

NomeVisualizzato/Pixabay

One small step for squid

Space does a number on the human body. Forget the obvious like going for a walk outside without a spacesuit, or even the well-known risks like the degradation of bone in microgravity; there are numerous smaller but still important changes to the body during spaceflight, like the disruption of the symbiotic relationship between gut bacteria and the human body. This causes the immune system to lose the ability to recognize threats, and illnesses spread more easily.

Naturally, if astronauts are going to undertake years-long journeys to Mars and beyond, a thorough understanding of this disturbance is necessary, and that’s why NASA has sent a bunch of squid to the International Space Station.

When it comes to animal studies, squid aren’t the usual culprits, but there’s a reason NASA chose calamari over the alternatives: The Hawaiian bobtail squid has a symbiotic relationship with bacteria that regulate their bioluminescence in much the same way that we have a symbiotic relationship with our gut bacteria, but the squid is a much simpler animal. If the bioluminescence-regulating bacteria are disturbed during their time in space, it will be much easier to figure out what’s going wrong.

PxHere

Less plastic, more vanilla

Have you been racked by guilt over the number of plastic water bottles you use? What about the amount of ice cream you eat? Well, this one’s for you.

Plastic isn’t the first thing you think about when you open up a pint of vanilla ice cream and catch the sweet, spicy vanilla scent, or when you smell those fresh vanilla scones coming out of the oven at the coffee shop, but a new study shows that the flavor of vanilla can come from water bottles.

Here’s the deal. A compound called vanillin is responsible for the scent of vanilla, and it can come naturally from the bean or it can be made synthetically. Believe it or not, 85% of vanillin is made synthetically from fossil fuels!

We’ve definitely grown accustomed to our favorite vanilla scents, foods, and cosmetics. In 2018, the global demand for vanillin was about 40,800 tons and is expected to grow to 65,000 tons by 2025, which far exceeds the supply of natural vanilla.

So what can we do? Well, we can use genetically engineered bacteria to turn plastic water bottles into vanillin, according to a study published in the journal Green Chemistry.

tezzstock/Thinkstock

No withdrawals from this bank

Into each life, some milestones must fall: High school graduation, birth of a child, first house, 50th wedding anniversary, COVID-19. One LOTME staffer got really excited – way too excited, actually – when his Nissan Sentra reached 300,000 miles.

Well, there are milestones, and then there are milestones. “1,000 Reasons for Hope” is a report celebrating the first 1,000 brains donated to the VA-BU-CLF Brain Bank. For those of you keeping score at home, that would be the Department of Veterans Affairs, Boston University, and the Concussion Legacy Foundation.

The Brain Bank, created in 2008 to study concussions and chronic traumatic encephalopathy, is the brainchild – yes, we went there – of Chris Nowinski, PhD, a former professional wrestler, and Ann McKee, MD, an expert on neurogenerative disease. “Our discoveries have already inspired changes to sports that will prevent many future cases of CTE in the next generation of athletes,” Dr. Nowinski, the CEO of CLF, said in a written statement.

Jana Blaková/Thinkstock

To the Editor:

Argyria is a rare disease caused by chronic exposure to products with high silver content (eg, oral ingestion, inhalation, percutaneous absorption). With time, the blood levels of silver surpass the body’s renal and hepatic excretory capacities that lead to silver granules being deposited in the skin and internal organs, including the liver, spleen, adrenal glands, and bone marrow.¹ The cutaneous deposition results in a blue or blue-gray pigmentation of the skin, mucous membranes, and nails. Intervals of exposure that span from 8 months to 5 years prior to symptom onset have been described in the literature.² The discoloration that results often is permanent, with no established way of effectively removing silver deposits from the tissue.³

A 22-year-old autistic man, who was completely dependent on his mother’s care, presented to the emergency department with a primary concern of abdominal pain. The mother reported that he was indicating abdominal pain by motioning to his stomach for the last 5 days. The mother also reported he did not have a bowel movement during this time, and she noticed his hands were shaking. Prior to presentation, the mother had given him 2 enemas and had him on a 3-day strict liquid fast consisting of water, lemon juice, cayenne pepper, honey, and orange juice. Notably, the mother had a strong history of using naturopathic remedies for treatment of her son’s ailments.

On admission, the patient was stable. There was a 2-point decrease in the patient’s body mass index over the last month. Initial serum electrolytes were highly abnormal with a serum sodium level of 124 mEq/L (reference range, 135–145 mEq/L), blood urea nitrogen of 3 mg/dL (reference range, 7–20 mg/dL), creatinine of 0.77 mg/dL (reference range, 0.74–1.35 mg/dL), and lactic acid of 2.1 mEq/L (reference range, 0.5–1 mEq/L). Serum osmolality was 272 mOsm/kg (reference range, 275–295 mOsm/kg). Urine osmolality was 114 mOsm/kg (reference range, 500–850 mOsm/kg) with a low-normal urine sodium level of 41 mmol/24 hr (reference range, 40–220 mmol/24 hr). Abnormalities were felt to be secondary to malnutrition from the strict liquid diet (blood urea nitrogen and creatinine ratio of 3:1 suggestive of notable protein calorie malnutrition). The patient was given 1 L of normal saline in the emergency department, with further fluids held so as not to increase serum sodium level too rapidly. A regular diet was started.

Physical examination revealed dry mucosal membranes but otherwise was unremarkable. Active bowel sounds were noted, as well as a soft, nontender, and nondistended abdomen; however, when examining the patient’s hands for reported shaking, a distinct abnormality of the nails was noticed. The patient had slate blue discoloration of the lunula, along with hyperpigmented violaceous discoloration of the proximal nail bed on all 10 fingernails (Figure 1). No abnormalities were seen on the toenails. The mother had a distinct bluish gray discoloration of the face as well as similar nail findings (Figure 2), strongly suggestive of colloidal silver use. An urgent serum silver level was ordered on the patient as well as a heavy metal panel. The mother was found applying numerous “natural remedies” to the patient’s skin while in the hospital, including a liquid spray and lotion, both in unmarked bottles. At that time, the mother was informed that no external supplements should be applied to her son. The serum silver level was elevated substantially at 94.3 ng/mL (reference range, <1.0 ng/mL). When the mother was confronted, she initially denied use of silver but later admitted to notable silver content in the cream she was applying to her son’s skin. The mother reported that she read online that colloidal silver had been historically used to cure numerous ailments and she was ordering products from an online company. She was counseled on the dangers of both topical application and ingestion of silver, and all supplements were removed from the home.

Initial differential diagnoses for altered nail pigmentation include drug-induced causes, systemic diseases, cyanosis, and exposure to metals.⁷ The most commonly indicated medications resulting in blue nail pigment changes include antimalarials, minocycline, zidovudine, and phenothiazine. Systemic diseases that may cause blue nail color change include Wilson disease, hemochromatosis, Addison disease, methemoglobinemia, and alkaptonuria.⁷ Metals include gold, mercury, arsenic, bismuth, lead, and silver.⁴ After a thorough review of the patient’s medications and lack of support for any underlying disease process, contact with metals, particularly silver, was ranked highly on our differential list. In support of this theory, the mother’s bluish gray facial skin led to high clinical suspicion that she was ingesting colloidal silver and also was exposing her son to silver.

Treatment of argyria is challenging but first and foremost involves discontinuation of the source of chronic silver exposure. Unfortunately, the discoloration of generalized argyria often is permanent. Sunscreen can be used to help prevent any further darkening of pigment. The pigment in localized argyria has been reported to slowly fade with time, and there also have been reports of successful treatment using a low-fluence Q-switched 1064-nm Nd:YAG laser.⁸

To the Editor:

Argyria is a rare disease caused by chronic exposure to products with high silver content (eg, oral ingestion, inhalation, percutaneous absorption). With time, the blood levels of silver surpass the body’s renal and hepatic excretory capacities that lead to silver granules being deposited in the skin and internal organs, including the liver, spleen, adrenal glands, and bone marrow.¹ The cutaneous deposition results in a blue or blue-gray pigmentation of the skin, mucous membranes, and nails. Intervals of exposure that span from 8 months to 5 years prior to symptom onset have been described in the literature.² The discoloration that results often is permanent, with no established way of effectively removing silver deposits from the tissue.³

A 22-year-old autistic man, who was completely dependent on his mother’s care, presented to the emergency department with a primary concern of abdominal pain. The mother reported that he was indicating abdominal pain by motioning to his stomach for the last 5 days. The mother also reported he did not have a bowel movement during this time, and she noticed his hands were shaking. Prior to presentation, the mother had given him 2 enemas and had him on a 3-day strict liquid fast consisting of water, lemon juice, cayenne pepper, honey, and orange juice. Notably, the mother had a strong history of using naturopathic remedies for treatment of her son’s ailments.

On admission, the patient was stable. There was a 2-point decrease in the patient’s body mass index over the last month. Initial serum electrolytes were highly abnormal with a serum sodium level of 124 mEq/L (reference range, 135–145 mEq/L), blood urea nitrogen of 3 mg/dL (reference range, 7–20 mg/dL), creatinine of 0.77 mg/dL (reference range, 0.74–1.35 mg/dL), and lactic acid of 2.1 mEq/L (reference range, 0.5–1 mEq/L). Serum osmolality was 272 mOsm/kg (reference range, 275–295 mOsm/kg). Urine osmolality was 114 mOsm/kg (reference range, 500–850 mOsm/kg) with a low-normal urine sodium level of 41 mmol/24 hr (reference range, 40–220 mmol/24 hr). Abnormalities were felt to be secondary to malnutrition from the strict liquid diet (blood urea nitrogen and creatinine ratio of 3:1 suggestive of notable protein calorie malnutrition). The patient was given 1 L of normal saline in the emergency department, with further fluids held so as not to increase serum sodium level too rapidly. A regular diet was started.

Physical examination revealed dry mucosal membranes but otherwise was unremarkable. Active bowel sounds were noted, as well as a soft, nontender, and nondistended abdomen; however, when examining the patient’s hands for reported shaking, a distinct abnormality of the nails was noticed. The patient had slate blue discoloration of the lunula, along with hyperpigmented violaceous discoloration of the proximal nail bed on all 10 fingernails (Figure 1). No abnormalities were seen on the toenails. The mother had a distinct bluish gray discoloration of the face as well as similar nail findings (Figure 2), strongly suggestive of colloidal silver use. An urgent serum silver level was ordered on the patient as well as a heavy metal panel. The mother was found applying numerous “natural remedies” to the patient’s skin while in the hospital, including a liquid spray and lotion, both in unmarked bottles. At that time, the mother was informed that no external supplements should be applied to her son. The serum silver level was elevated substantially at 94.3 ng/mL (reference range, <1.0 ng/mL). When the mother was confronted, she initially denied use of silver but later admitted to notable silver content in the cream she was applying to her son’s skin. The mother reported that she read online that colloidal silver had been historically used to cure numerous ailments and she was ordering products from an online company. She was counseled on the dangers of both topical application and ingestion of silver, and all supplements were removed from the home.

Initial differential diagnoses for altered nail pigmentation include drug-induced causes, systemic diseases, cyanosis, and exposure to metals.⁷ The most commonly indicated medications resulting in blue nail pigment changes include antimalarials, minocycline, zidovudine, and phenothiazine. Systemic diseases that may cause blue nail color change include Wilson disease, hemochromatosis, Addison disease, methemoglobinemia, and alkaptonuria.⁷ Metals include gold, mercury, arsenic, bismuth, lead, and silver.⁴ After a thorough review of the patient’s medications and lack of support for any underlying disease process, contact with metals, particularly silver, was ranked highly on our differential list. In support of this theory, the mother’s bluish gray facial skin led to high clinical suspicion that she was ingesting colloidal silver and also was exposing her son to silver.

Treatment of argyria is challenging but first and foremost involves discontinuation of the source of chronic silver exposure. Unfortunately, the discoloration of generalized argyria often is permanent. Sunscreen can be used to help prevent any further darkening of pigment. The pigment in localized argyria has been reported to slowly fade with time, and there also have been reports of successful treatment using a low-fluence Q-switched 1064-nm Nd:YAG laser.⁸

To the Editor:

Argyria is a rare disease caused by chronic exposure to products with high silver content (eg, oral ingestion, inhalation, percutaneous absorption). With time, the blood levels of silver surpass the body’s renal and hepatic excretory capacities that lead to silver granules being deposited in the skin and internal organs, including the liver, spleen, adrenal glands, and bone marrow.¹ The cutaneous deposition results in a blue or blue-gray pigmentation of the skin, mucous membranes, and nails. Intervals of exposure that span from 8 months to 5 years prior to symptom onset have been described in the literature.² The discoloration that results often is permanent, with no established way of effectively removing silver deposits from the tissue.³

A 22-year-old autistic man, who was completely dependent on his mother’s care, presented to the emergency department with a primary concern of abdominal pain. The mother reported that he was indicating abdominal pain by motioning to his stomach for the last 5 days. The mother also reported he did not have a bowel movement during this time, and she noticed his hands were shaking. Prior to presentation, the mother had given him 2 enemas and had him on a 3-day strict liquid fast consisting of water, lemon juice, cayenne pepper, honey, and orange juice. Notably, the mother had a strong history of using naturopathic remedies for treatment of her son’s ailments.

On admission, the patient was stable. There was a 2-point decrease in the patient’s body mass index over the last month. Initial serum electrolytes were highly abnormal with a serum sodium level of 124 mEq/L (reference range, 135–145 mEq/L), blood urea nitrogen of 3 mg/dL (reference range, 7–20 mg/dL), creatinine of 0.77 mg/dL (reference range, 0.74–1.35 mg/dL), and lactic acid of 2.1 mEq/L (reference range, 0.5–1 mEq/L). Serum osmolality was 272 mOsm/kg (reference range, 275–295 mOsm/kg). Urine osmolality was 114 mOsm/kg (reference range, 500–850 mOsm/kg) with a low-normal urine sodium level of 41 mmol/24 hr (reference range, 40–220 mmol/24 hr). Abnormalities were felt to be secondary to malnutrition from the strict liquid diet (blood urea nitrogen and creatinine ratio of 3:1 suggestive of notable protein calorie malnutrition). The patient was given 1 L of normal saline in the emergency department, with further fluids held so as not to increase serum sodium level too rapidly. A regular diet was started.

Physical examination revealed dry mucosal membranes but otherwise was unremarkable. Active bowel sounds were noted, as well as a soft, nontender, and nondistended abdomen; however, when examining the patient’s hands for reported shaking, a distinct abnormality of the nails was noticed. The patient had slate blue discoloration of the lunula, along with hyperpigmented violaceous discoloration of the proximal nail bed on all 10 fingernails (Figure 1). No abnormalities were seen on the toenails. The mother had a distinct bluish gray discoloration of the face as well as similar nail findings (Figure 2), strongly suggestive of colloidal silver use. An urgent serum silver level was ordered on the patient as well as a heavy metal panel. The mother was found applying numerous “natural remedies” to the patient’s skin while in the hospital, including a liquid spray and lotion, both in unmarked bottles. At that time, the mother was informed that no external supplements should be applied to her son. The serum silver level was elevated substantially at 94.3 ng/mL (reference range, <1.0 ng/mL). When the mother was confronted, she initially denied use of silver but later admitted to notable silver content in the cream she was applying to her son’s skin. The mother reported that she read online that colloidal silver had been historically used to cure numerous ailments and she was ordering products from an online company. She was counseled on the dangers of both topical application and ingestion of silver, and all supplements were removed from the home.

Initial differential diagnoses for altered nail pigmentation include drug-induced causes, systemic diseases, cyanosis, and exposure to metals.⁷ The most commonly indicated medications resulting in blue nail pigment changes include antimalarials, minocycline, zidovudine, and phenothiazine. Systemic diseases that may cause blue nail color change include Wilson disease, hemochromatosis, Addison disease, methemoglobinemia, and alkaptonuria.⁷ Metals include gold, mercury, arsenic, bismuth, lead, and silver.⁴ After a thorough review of the patient’s medications and lack of support for any underlying disease process, contact with metals, particularly silver, was ranked highly on our differential list. In support of this theory, the mother’s bluish gray facial skin led to high clinical suspicion that she was ingesting colloidal silver and also was exposing her son to silver.

Treatment of argyria is challenging but first and foremost involves discontinuation of the source of chronic silver exposure. Unfortunately, the discoloration of generalized argyria often is permanent. Sunscreen can be used to help prevent any further darkening of pigment. The pigment in localized argyria has been reported to slowly fade with time, and there also have been reports of successful treatment using a low-fluence Q-switched 1064-nm Nd:YAG laser.⁸